There are so many reasons to love this "CBS Sunday Morning" video.
It's a feature about an amazing couple (he's a farmer; she's a PhD) who run what likely is the largest bookstore in the country;
an estimated million books,
with no ads and no sign ...
in eleven buildings, of which the main one is a converted cow manure shed...
...all in an incredibly unprime location in the middle of...
well, you must watch it:
Thanks to Brother Maynard/
As a bonus, here's another episode of CBS Sunday morning, this time covering the Porn Awards...the host Bill Geist even met Craig Gross of XXXChurch, giving away "Jesus Loves Porn Stars" Bibles..here
Welcome! You have accidentally reached the blog of a heteroclite follower of Jesus: dave wainscott. I'm "pushing toward the unobvious" as I post thinkings/linkings re: Scripture, church and culture. Hot topics include: temple tantrums, time travel, sexuality/spirituality, U2kklesia, role of the pastor, God-haunted music/art..and subversive videos like these.
Pages
Search Me:
Friday, May 16, 2008
"What is the Bible trying to do to us?"
From the University Presbyterian Church (Fresno), pastored by someone you need to know:
website
website
Dr. Chris Erdman, our Senior Pastor says: Today, it seems to me that "what is the Bible trying to do to us?" is not the first question we bring to the Bible (if we come to it at all). There are signs that this is changing among us at UPC, if the way our elders are now reading the Bible in their ministry teams is any indication. But by and large, the American church is asking different questions. I identify these questions according to three major varieties:
Questions of the refrigerator variety: is there something here that I can consume and feel satisfied?
Questions of the pharmacy variety: is there something here I can take that will make me feel better?
Questions of the life-preserver variety: is there something here that I can use to pull myself out of this mess I'm in?
Now, these on the surface one can hardly argue with these questions. They come from very real needs we all have. But at UPC we recognize how different these questions are from the single question we place at the top of the list: "What is the Bible trying to do to us?" We recognize that the typical questions put "I" as the subject who acts on the Bible as the "object" and that that gets things all wrong theologically. Instead, when we ask, "what is the Bible trying to do to us?" we are putting God and we are putting ourselves in the right order. The Bible acts on us just as God acts on us. The Bible seeks to form us just as God formed us from the soil of the earth.
-Link, click the "spirituality" tab
Thursday, May 15, 2008
Not (Just) About Dogs...and hangovers
If you don't know The Frames, you are long overdue. Check this out, with links to Pastor Steve Stockman's interview with singer Glen Hansard.
The disarmingly innocent story that Hansard pastorally tells about the D-Fer the Dog, at least the way he tells it on the phenomenal live CD, (see a different version in the video at top here) always gets me...
...Not because I am a cheesy sentimentalist, but because the segue from that stand-up comedy story intro into the delightfully devastating song is holy juxtaposition, non-sequitur sequitur that shouldn't work, but works..
This is much like how Bono self-effacingly (in this video)diffuses...and thus spotlights.. the serious-grief in
the "gospel song," "In a Little While." This song was never "just about a hangover....before it became gospel song." And
The Frames song in discussion was never about a dog.
The Frames song "What Happens When the Heart Just Stops," can be...well, hearstopping.
And grief-healing kickstarting.
Which means it starts your heart while you sing about it stopping.
That is naked gospel.
Connect it to holy grieving, lament, and
Here's another version of the Frames song without spoken intro):
Also calls to mind how Roger Waters ("Praying with Pink Floyd"), in a priestly-pastoral mode, allowed his audience/congregation to cathartically enter into holy grief and ownership of their human weakkness..or something like that, Check it out:
"Are there any paranoids out there tonight? Anyone who worries about anything? Are they any weak people out there tonight?...This is for you...."
Even though the "Clap! Enjoy yourselves is perhaps sarcastic, and in context of the CD from which the song comes, nihilistic ("annihilating nihilism and cultural masturbation" ...
What a call to worship/reality/grief/God.
And the opening hymn it is the invocation for is "Run Like Hell".
Watch it:
Heartstopping.
The disarmingly innocent story that Hansard pastorally tells about the D-Fer the Dog, at least the way he tells it on the phenomenal live CD, (see a different version in the video at top here) always gets me...
...Not because I am a cheesy sentimentalist, but because the segue from that stand-up comedy story intro into the delightfully devastating song is holy juxtaposition, non-sequitur sequitur that shouldn't work, but works..
This is much like how Bono self-effacingly (in this video)diffuses...and thus spotlights.. the serious-grief in
the "gospel song," "In a Little While." This song was never "just about a hangover....before it became gospel song." And
The Frames song in discussion was never about a dog.
The Frames song "What Happens When the Heart Just Stops," can be...well, hearstopping.
And grief-healing kickstarting.
Which means it starts your heart while you sing about it stopping.
That is naked gospel.
Connect it to holy grieving, lament, and
Here's another version of the Frames song without spoken intro):
Also calls to mind how Roger Waters ("Praying with Pink Floyd"), in a priestly-pastoral mode, allowed his audience/congregation to cathartically enter into holy grief and ownership of their human weakkness..or something like that, Check it out:
"Are there any paranoids out there tonight? Anyone who worries about anything? Are they any weak people out there tonight?...This is for you...."
Even though the "Clap! Enjoy yourselves is perhaps sarcastic, and in context of the CD from which the song comes, nihilistic ("annihilating nihilism and cultural masturbation" ...
What a call to worship/reality/grief/God.
And the opening hymn it is the invocation for is "Run Like Hell".
Watch it:
Heartstopping.
Artist or Billboard Painter

The line :
"he said he was an artist...
but he really painted billboards"
to me always captured the whole dilemma of the gospel and culture:
- We may we are new wineskin/emerging/freelance, but aren't we really just creating ads?
- Isn't "art for sale" an oxymoron?
- Do we, by default, preach/teach/heal like we have something to sell? Isn't it often sex?
- etc etc
The line is from an obscure and haunting B-Side song from Joshua Tree-era U2,
"Walk to the Water." It was likely never finished; and what the lyrics are about is your guess...
but that one line to me is a wake-up/shake-up call when I meet the young women in the 22nd pews and thrift stores.
There is no compromise in literally doing both for a living, like Mark DeRaud (podcast here),
but if it happens to us pastor types, we are "two-souled" commercial televangelistas.
We have sold our soul (both, actually) for a bowl of Jacob's oatmeal; and traded our art for empire and industry. That's "sublimation, not elevation," as Bono and the Chasidic rabbis would say.
Next thing I'll want is my name on the sign, parking space.
The usual remedy when we get caught with our priorites and panst down is just do the same stupid thing....only louder. The very next line in the song:
He said he was an artist
But he really painted billboards
In large capital letters
Large capital letters
!
and then:
He was telling jokes
Nobody else would listen to him
(If that isn't me...and many preachers....)_
But why is it that "secular" sources like Fast Company publish articles to help us; like an article, "Sex vs. Ethics": (see also Bottled Water: It’s All About the Sex Appeal and How Companies Have Sex):
"If you want to sell something, Charney says, appeal to people's self-interest."(Fast Company, June 2008)
That's seeker-sensitive. It's selling sex and self.
The catch is we are all in a sense selling art. Beth Maynard mentions, in passing, "U2 have been producing art for over 25 years". So have I.
Eugene Peterson, in the context of an interview about U2, offers, "This is what art does, it gets beneath or within essential aspects of our lives."
Eugene Peterson, in the context of an interview about U2, offers, "This is what art does, it gets beneath or within essential aspects of our lives."
But how do we sell it; knowing that simultaneously, "we've got to give it away."
Paul McGuinness, U2
manager, comments about the secret to art being keeping ones sexuality and politics in creative tension. (Great quote, bet Beth can find it...It was on the "Soundbytes" section of atu2.com)
manager, comments about the secret to art being keeping ones sexuality and politics in creative tension. (Great quote, bet Beth can find it...It was on the "Soundbytes" section of atu2.com)
The artist/billboard line also reminds me of a parallel juxtapostion in the obscure backwoods U2 repertoire:
"I wanted to meet God,
but you sold me religion."
(Hear/watch it/read about it...and weep.... here).
Religion sells (ask Tim Keller and Len Hjalmarson).
It has to sell.
I have no idea what to think about this "end-times" preacher!!??:
I have no idea what to think about this "end-times" preacher!!??:
And don't get me started on "Christian
billboards." (though I like this one). Neal Peart was right, again: It all "echoes with the sound of salesmen," not the one thing pastors need:
billboards." (though I like this one). Neal Peart was right, again: It all "echoes with the sound of salesmen," not the one thing pastors need:
silence.
SO..
after two minutes of silence...
Here is the song:
the line is at 0:50ff in this video (which is not an official U2video, but lets me post the song)
"We are .. artists... I wish we were comedians. We would probably have more effect…Anyway, for all this: imagination!..To tell our stories, to paint pictures…Because we have fallen asleep in the comfort of our freedom. "
-Bono
"Every artist is a cannibal....."
-The Fly
They don't know what you're doing
Babe, it must be art ..
They want you to be Jesus
They'll go down on one knee
But they'll want their money back
If you're alive at thirty-three
And you're turning tricks
With your crucifix
You're a star "
-U2
Labels:
art,
Beth Maynard,
elevation,
Mark DeRaud,
role of the pastor,
U2 1980s
Tony Jones: Emergent Ethos and Vibe
Here's a clip of Tony Jones on "Think," addressing (of course) What is emergent?
Apparently some are upset (of course) that Jones suggests that "Emergence is not so much a doctrinal position as it is a vibe or an ethos....scaffolding." And the emphasis is allowing all to participate, wikistyle. The catch, he says, is the church corporate (definition 1: as in group/Body ) or corporate (definition 2: as in company/hierarchy)?
I guess that is doctrinal: Do we believe that Jesus has a body on earth?
Us.
But shouldn't they be thrilled that this current shift is "only" about structure, form, style, ethos.
It's an experiment in vibe, as The Violet Burning once did musically.
Hey, as wishywashy as "vibe" might sound, that's all we have to work with in the universe, according to string theory..
"In rediscovering the gospel of salvation by faith and grace alone, Luther started to reform the Church through a reformation of theology. In the 18th century through movements like the Moravians there was a recovery of a new intimacy with God, which led to a reformation of spirituality, the Second Reformation. Now God is touching the wineskins themselves, initiating a Third Reformation, a reformation of structure.' Wolfgang Simson
Gee, next thing you'll tell me is the critics don't get/like Trucker Frank, either.
Oops, that seems to be the case...here.
I had better quit, I am using too much "them" (vs. "us") language..(:
The Need to Measure/Oppress
Are these two short clips related?
Len Hjalmarson on the Gospel, the Center and Certainty..."about certainty and salvation, and our need to measure and 'know' where someone is at in contrast to faith and pilgrimage."
(also see set theory):
Tim Keller at a Veritas Forum, on "Religion is a Problem in the World", including the three steps from faith to oppressing others who are unlike you (uh, also see set theory):
Len Hjalmarson on the Gospel, the Center and Certainty..."about certainty and salvation, and our need to measure and 'know' where someone is at in contrast to faith and pilgrimage."
(also see set theory):
Tim Keller at a Veritas Forum, on "Religion is a Problem in the World", including the three steps from faith to oppressing others who are unlike you (uh, also see set theory):
Wednesday, May 14, 2008
The Sex of String Theory & 3 Questions for her...

Dialogue at the 1998 gathering of Pastors Promise Keepers Atlanta...largest gathering of pastors in one place in history:
Rev. Kevin ("Topless Beach Bum"..story told in " God, beach and breasts" ) Clancey:
"Is this the Fourth Great Awakening, or just a bunch of pastors getting together?"
Me: "Yes."
As we move even more into this current, and unsettling churchwide Reformation/Reorientation/Awakening;
it is obvious we have lots to learn from the current and unsettling Reformation/Reorientation/Awakening
in physics.
Same thing; mas o menos.
The attraction of string theory (the scientific theory, not the band) is that it offers a practical paradigm for a potential "Theory of Everything," something that even a literal Einstein glimpsed, but could not reach in his lifetime.
Rev. Kevin ("Topless Beach Bum"..story told in " God, beach and breasts" ) Clancey:
"Is this the Fourth Great Awakening, or just a bunch of pastors getting together?"
Me: "Yes."
As we move even more into this current, and unsettling churchwide Reformation/Reorientation/Awakening;
it is obvious we have lots to learn from the current and unsettling Reformation/Reorientation/Awakening
in physics.
Same thing; mas o menos.
The attraction of string theory (the scientific theory, not the band) is that it offers a practical paradigm for a potential "Theory of Everything," something that even a literal Einstein glimpsed, but could not reach in his lifetime.
Maybe Brian Greene and
gang are Joshua to Einstein's Moses.
Hmmm, "subtle is the Lord," indeed.
To get a sense of string theory via Brian Greene, you can "watch" his book" The Elegant Universe") on YouTube?PBS here;
or for a hilarious quickie,
see his hilarious quick interview with Stephen Colbert here below.
String theory is also cool enough to
gang are Joshua to Einstein's Moses.Hmmm, "subtle is the Lord," indeed.
To get a sense of string theory via Brian Greene, you can "watch" his book" The Elegant Universe") on YouTube?PBS here;
or for a hilarious quickie,
see his hilarious quick interview with Stephen Colbert here below.
String theory is also cool enough to
have "her" own MySpace (become her friend, or she may vaporize you into a black hole) website. And whether it's (she's) right or not, it may be "not even wrong."
As Karl Marx once said, and as Jesus...independently of Marx (: .... seemed to tell me,
"Nothing is more practical than theory, (and nothing is more theoretical than practice)."
"Nothing is more practical than theory, (and nothing is more theoretical than practice)."
But you may know the apparent dilemma; as summarized by Greene:
For many years, physicists found that the central obstacle to realizing a unified theory was the fundamental conflict between the two major breakthroughs of twentieth-century physics: general relativity and quantum mechanics. Although these two frameworks are typically applied in vastly different realms-general relativity to big things like stars and galaxies, quantum mechanics to small things like molecules and atoms-each theory claims to be universal, to work in all realms.However, as mentioned above, when the theories are used in conjunction, their combined equations produce nonsensical answers....Calculations...simply show that the combined equations...have gone haywire."
-Brian Greene, "The Fabric of the Cosmos," p. 16
I am guessing I am not the first to ask (but can't hurt to ask) if that apparent haywire is actually "OK"; or to be expected....or not truly haywire. What of the "nonsense" answers actually and ultimately make sense, or are super-sensible/suprasensible/surrational? If there are indeed multiple dimensions, might there not also be parallel ways/means of doing math, so that these "nonsense" equations only "tilt" the pinball game because of the way we are looking at them?
What if the "fundamental conflict" is not fundamental/foundational at all, but only relative..in a quantum kinda way, of course (:
Studies in synesthesia and nueroscience suggest much that appears fundamentally non-sensical
makes more sense than common sense.
A reading of "The Divine Voice,"an amazing theological acoustemology, might even suggest that the primacy of sound would connect with superstring theory (summarized by Len Sweet as "the universe at base is music" ...or sound. See Sweet's seminal "Summoned to Lead"). We need to interpret data through sound sense..pun intended..more that common sense...
or "math as usual" sense.
Comic relief:
Q.Did you hear the one about the constipated mathematician?
A. Yeah, he worked it out with a pencil.
or "math as usual" sense.
Comic relief:
Q.Did you hear the one about the constipated mathematician?
A. Yeah, he worked it out with a pencil.
Second question...in light of the following thoughts by Greene...and just replace "third revolution" with "third reformation," small/quantum" with "small Kingdom gatherings" and "large/general relativity" with "large Kingdom gatherings", "independent" with "apostolic networks", etc:
If I were to hazard a guess on future developments, I'd imagine that the background-independent techniques developed by the loop quantum gravity community will be adapted to stringtheory, paving the way for a string formulation that is background independent. And that's the spark, I suspect, that will ignite a third superstring revolution in which, I'm optimistic, many of the remaining deep mysteries will be solved....I believe that such a (union)...between general relativity and quantum mechanics would yield a gratifying resolution..."
-Greene, 491
...Why in the world (universe?) don't we appropriate the findings of physics even more? In any number of areas imagined above...and also including time travel (a basic definition of The Kingdom in Hebrews 6:1-4..see "THE KINGDOM’S RETROACTIVE RETROFUTURE: SEND ME MORE ARROWS")
Thank God for Kester, Len H., Len S. and tribesters. But the tribe must increase! And embrace Margaret Wheatley and Bono the physicist...
...and Bono's friend Christopher Nolan!
Why in the...heck/hell/quantum dimensions...did the non Christian physicist have to write the book "The Physics of Christianity"?!
THAT's emerging, baby.
Third question:
If you have been brave or bored enough to read this far, aren't you ready for a bad string theory joke (click here)..or the video, "Can String Theory Detect God?" ..one person's attempt to put (Scriptural) chapter and verse to string theory):
"If my thesis is correct...Christianity will become a branch of physics."
-Frank Tipler
Labels:
margaret wheatley,
sexuality,
sound theory,
string theory,
time travel
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


