Showing posts sorted by relevance for query mcneal. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query mcneal. Sort by date Show all posts

Saturday, July 01, 2006

Collapse of Church Culture: McNeal


Reggie McNeal
from " The Present Future,":



The collapse of the church culture.
a) Wrong question: How do we do church better?
b) Tough question: How do we reconvert from “churchianity” to Christianity?

The shift from church growth to kingdom growth.
a) Wrong question: How do we grow this church?
b) Tough question: How do we transform our community?

A new reformation: Releasing God’s people.
a) Wrong question: How do we turn members into ministers?
b) Tough question: How do we turn members into missionaries?

The return to spiritual formation.
a) Wrong question: How do we develop church members?
b) Tough question: How do we develop followers of Jesus?

The shift from planning to preparation.
a) Wrong question: How do we plan for the future?
b) Tough question: How do we prepare for the future?

The rise of apostolic leadership.
a) Wrong question: How do we develop leaders for church work?
b) Tough question: How do we develop leaders for the Christian movement?
===
The Collapse of the Church Culture
By Reggie McNeal

We are entering a new epoch of human history called the postmodern age. The postmodern world will demand a new church expression, just as did the rise of the modern world.

The modern world assaulted God, shoving him further and further into the corner with its determination to drain all the mystery out of life and the universe. Everything that could be explained scientifically further diminished the realm of the spiritual.

Having retreated into a diminishing corner for several hundreds of years, the North American church culture unfortunately now reflects the materialism and secularism of the modern era. Not only do we not need God to explain the universe, we don't need God to operate the church. Many operate like giant machines, with church leaders serving as mechanics. God doesn't have to show up to get done what's being done. The culture does not want the powerless God of the modern church.

We need to take courage. Though secularism and nihilism have taken their best shot to kill God, they have lost. The postmodern world, governed by quantum physics and it's emphasis on relationships, is God's end run round the modern world. A quantum world stands ready to accept divine design and divine interaction. God himself is stirring the pot. If we can pay attention we will eventually discover that not only will we not lose God in this emerging postmodern world, we will find him again!

Although the next church's shape is not yet obvious, the forces that will give it shape are. They are futures that are already present. The first of these present futures is shocking and dramatic, because it declares that much of what we call church is not going to survive.

Wrong Question: How Do We Do Church Better?
Faced with diminishing returns on investment of money, time, and energy, church leaders have spent much of the last five decades trying to figure out how to do church better. Emphases have come and gone in rapid succession. Church and lay renewal has given way to church growth, which has given way to church health. The results beg the question.

An entire industry has been spawned to help churches do whatever it is they decide to do. Consultants, parachurch ministries, denominational headquarters, and publishing houses prod and push the church toward whatever the current fad is. A spate of program fixes have consistently over promised and under delivered. The suggestions are plentiful: offer small groups, contemporize your worship, market your services, focus on the customer service, create a spiritual experience, become seeker-friendly, create a high-expectation member culture, purify the church from bad doctrine, return the church to the basics. After decades of this kind of environment no wonder church leaders are a little skeptical about the "next thing" and why many feel that just about the time they catch up they fall further behind. But the mailings keep coming, the seminars keep filling up, and the conference notebooks keep stacking up on the shelves.

All of this activity anesthetizes the pain of loss. It offers a way to stay busy and preoccupied with methodological pursuits while not facing the hard truth: none of this seems to be making much of a difference. Church activity is a poor substitute for genuine spiritual vitality.

Wrong Response
Many congregations and church leaders, faced with collapse of the church culture, have responded by adopting a refuge mentality. Those with a refuge mentality view the world outside the church as the enemy. Their answer is to live inside the bubble of a Christian subculture complete with its own entertainment industry. Evangelism in this worldview is about churching the unchurched, not connecting people to Jesus. It focuses on cleaning people up, changing their behavior so Christians, (translation: church people), can be more comfortable around them.

The point is, all the effort to fix the church misses the point. You can build the perfect church-and they still won't come. People are not looking for a great church. They do not wake up every day wondering what church they can make successful. The age in which institutional religion holds appeal is passing away-and in a hurry.

Church leaders seem unable to grasp this simple implication of the new world-people outside the church think church is for church people, not for them. We may have saturated the market of people who want to be part of the church culture, who want church the way we do it in North America.

Tough Question: How do we Deconvert from Churchianity to Christianity?
North American Christians think in terms of its institutional expression, the church, as opposed to thinking about Christianity in terms of a movement. Deconversion will require a disentangling, an intentional self-differentiation from church in order to gain perspective, a willingness to abandon church club member mentality for the sake of following Jesus.

In North America the invitation to become a Christian has become largely an invitation to convert to the church. The assumption is that anyone serious about being a Christian will order their lives around the church, shift their life and work rhythms around the church schedule, channel their charitable giving through the church, and serve in some church ministry; in other words, serve the church and become a fervent marketer to bring others in to the church to do the same.

Many church leaders confuse the downward statistics on church participation with a loss of spiritual interest in Americans. That's because these leaders can't think of Christianity outside of institutional terms. The truth is, although intrigue with institutional religion is down, interest in spirituality is up. Many have observed that there is a spiritual awakening occurring in America. However, it is not informed by the Christian theology, and it's not happening in the church.
People may be turned off to the church, but they are not turned off to Jesus. Jesus is popular. He still makes the cover of Time and Newsweek every year. Church people sometimes get excited by this, but fail to understand that people in the nonchurch culture don't associate Jesus with the church.

The pursuit of the wrong question will continue to turn the wheel of the church industry, but it will do little to expand the kingdom of God. The need of the North American church is not a methodological fix. It is much more profound. The church needs a mission fix.

The North American church is suffering from severe mission amnesia. It has forgotten why it exists. The church was created to be the people of God to join him in his redemptive mission in the world. The church was never intended to exist for itself. It was and is the chosen instrument of God to expand his kingdom. The church is the bride of Christ. Its union with him is designed for reproduction, the growth of the kingdom. Jesus does not teach his disciples to pray, "Thy Church come". The kingdom is the destination. In its institutional preoccupation the church has abandoned its real identity and reason for existence.

God did not give up on his mission in the Old Testament when Israel refused to partner with him. God is a reckless lover. He decided to go on the mission himself. We do not need to be mistaken about this: if the church refuses its missional assignment, God will do it another way. The church has, and he is. God is pulling end runs around the institutional North American church to get to people in the streets. God is still inviting us to join him on mission, but it is the invitation to be part of a movement, not a religious club.

The Beginning of a Movement
When Jesus came on the scene he entered a world very similar to our own in terms of its spiritual landscape. The collapse of institutional religion in the first century was accompanied by an upsurge in personal spiritual search for God and salvation. Jesus tapped into this widespread sentiment of disillusionment with religion but hunger for God with his teaching about the kingdom of God and how people could become a part of it. His emphasis was on universal accessibility as opposed to the exclusivity of the Pharisees. His teaching was a radical departure from the legalistic behavioral approach of Judaism. He taught and practiced grace in terms of how God deals with people. At the same time he elevated standards for personal behavior by looking past mere externals to internal heart motivations. He preached that God was for people, not against them.

The movement Jesus initiated had power because it had at its core a personal life-transforming experience. People undergoing this conversion could not keep quiet about it. They had discovered meaning for their life and wanted other people to experience the same thing. This is the dynamic of genuine Christianity. This is what turned the world upside down at the beginning of the Christian era. The time is ripe again for recapturing this initial appeal of the gospel.

The current spiritual awakening in North America lacks Christian content and file systems. This is the scary part of it. Left to their own imagination people will devise all sorts of crazy stuff about God, from New Age crystals to self-enlightenment. But this is also the opportunity of the current spiritual landscape. People are open to revealed truth of God if they can get it. Unfortunately, the North American church has lost its influence at this critical juncture. It has lost its influence because it has lost its identity. It has lost its identity because it has lost is mission.

The correct response, then, to the collapse of the church culture is not to try to become better at doing church. The need is not for a methodological fix. The need is for a missional fix.

The appropriate response to the emerging world is a rebooting of the mission, a radical obedience to an ancient command, a loss of self rather than self preoccupation, concern about service and sacrifice rather than concern about style.

The collapse of the church culture is God's gracious invitation to the church to rediscover itself. It will do this by dying to itself and coming alive to God's mission.

-Reggie McNeal

(See this also)

Wednesday, February 08, 2006

The Evil of Steering Cats: L. Sweet and R. McNeal

image
"It could be you're spending too much time planning and not enough time preparing. The planning mode leads to dissonance. The modulation mode leads to consonance....

There is no evidence that 'planning' leads to a brighter tomorrow. Never has. Never will. Ask any gardener...

Modulation means replacing 'plans' with metaphors and songlines of preparedness. Modulation means replacing a philosophy of 'results:' (production, sales, cash flow, net profit, membership gains...) with a philosophy of 'resonance' where power and success reside not in rank or position but in relation and being..

 What organism plans its life? What person can plan his or her future? Can you plan your love? Life is false to formula.. In our world, planning is worse than a mistake-it's an evil.. Ever try to steer a cat or a puppy? No one steers a living thing, it moves forward one step at a time. No living enterprise moves forward by 'planning'.. When you come to a pothole, you don't need a strategic plan to get by. You improvise. After a brief pause, you ad lib your zig zags until you regain your bearings." :-Leonard Sweet , Summoned to Lead 76-77

"New Reality Number Five is the shift from planning to preparation.. Much of what has ultimate effect on the church happens outside it  and its control...

Typical approaches to the future involve prediction and planning. This works OK in a world that expriences significant continuity. It doesn't work in the current environment. Planning tends to be incremenmtal, pushing what we currently are doing into a world that we imagine will be the same as today. Incrementalism as an anticipatory strategy is dead.. The Bible sounds a recurring theme : God wants his people to pray and prepare for his intervention ...It is God who declares 'I know the plans I have for you ', in Jer 29.11. He does not say 'I am waiting for you to develop plans I can bless.' I am not against planning. I am just suggesting..the North American church has settled for (its imaginations, plans and dreams)..

 The future belongs to those who prepare for it, not plan for it. If the North American church is going to make the leap off the sigmoid curve and avoid the sure death guaranteed by incrementalism, it will have to shift its beginning point from present to future. -Reggie McNeal, The Present Future, 92ff

Saturday, September 01, 2007

The Meaning of History at St. Arbuck's..in 3 Easy Strands


Maybe the beloved biblical maxim about a strand of three cords not being easily broken is not just for marriages anymore.

And maybe it will work in my favor here.

All (!) I want to do in the next few (!) minutes is string together three strands; and note how they interrelate/intercalate, dovetail/Dovetail and form/inform each other:


  • 1.) The emerging consensus of missiology preceding ecclesiology
  • 2.) Quantum loops and the emergence of spacetime and gravity
  • 3.) The epistemological emergence of consciousness/soul

All right, for the three of you still reading(:.........

At least the common word "emergence" has tied all three together. But isn't it obvious (or is
Tim correct in his analysis of me: "you always push toward the unobvious") that all three phenomena are versions of (strand-ed together by) the same meta-phenomenon (that being: the meaning of history)?

Okay, for the two of you still reading...

This morning at St. Arbuck's I asked the ever prophetic subversive punster Keltic Ken (from Klovis) the question that everyone at every table of every St. Arbuck's is asking, if they really admit it:

"What is the meaning of history?"

He said (correct me, Ken) something like "God working out his purposes, and revealing himself, through sinful humanity."

I immediately congratulated him on his intuitive transcendence of a hyper-Hegelian overemphasis on "God/Geist AS history."

But if history/culture is indeed the chief "secular" venue in which is God is attempting to sovereignly self-disclose, Ken is (as usual) onto something huge.

And since we are blessed to live "at such a (postmodern/emerging/shift) time as this" IN history (David Dark: "this weird moment in history)":

"God must have a lot of confidence in you to put you on the planet at just this time. It was his sovereign decision to insert you onto planet earth during a time of huge transition. It takes incredible faith to lead during hinge points of history. " -Reggie McNeal,"The Present Future"

And to offer a surprising..but accurate...twist on the usual semantic domain of faith/confidence, try this quote from Graham Cooke:

"When the old wineskin is dying, the new wineskin is created by people who are not afraid to be vulnerable. "

Or this from ecologist Buhro:

"When the forms of an old culture are dying, the new culture is created by a few people who are not afraid to be insecure"



Thus...we need...counterintuitively...some profound and holy insecurity/vulnerability to our faith-life in these amazing days to see all that could come to pass, actually materialize. Because Bono is right: "History is more malleable than you think."

If Ken is right about the meaning of history is , and Bono is correct about
the mallebility of history..

...then maybe we shouldn't be afraid to (assuming Cooke and Buhro are spot-on) tie my three strands together, and see what emerges and converges.

The three strands, then, laid out:

-----------------------------------------------

1)Missiology precedes eccelesiology

Len asked a million dollar question ,"Do you think missiology precedes ecclesiology, or it is the other way round?" and then collected answers by some seminal thinkers and bloggers. These answers are all worth weighing, and are posted here:




Brother Maynard teases that this question is an "evil little trick"...as it may well be a"both/and" paradox (Alan Hirsch: "Dualistic expressions of faith always result in practical polytheism" or Heidegger : “It makes a difference where one enters the circle”);

it may well be a "the two are essentially the same" (a la the classic quote by Emil Bruner, "The Church exists by mission, as fire exists by burning");

but ultimately...against everything we've been taught in Sunday School and seminary (Brian Dodd: "Healthy churches tend to have non seminary trained leaders...')... it may best be a "yes, missiology precedes."

As I have said (I doubt it's original with me), "The church doesn't have a mission, the mission has a church."

Or as Len has..better..said: "It is not the Church of God that has a mission in the world — it is the God of mission who has a Church in the world."


By the way, since you asked(:... my longwinded answer to Len's question is here (and there Steve Porter lovingly challenges me, which makes me think(: I may even be right)..and if you want the short wind of my article, concludes:


So, again, If I had to pick an answer, it would be yes..missiology tends to precede and produce ecclesiology; philosophically, epistemologically, and practically speaking. I find quantum physics hugely helpful here; especially 'reverse causality," which accords with what Ladd has well emphasized about the Kingdom entering this age "from" the future; time working 'backwards," etc. This will be fleshed out (incarcarnated) in smaller, organic, networked and non-hierarchical (all lessons from physics again; the universe is such) ways and means...

...Meaning that counterintuitively to our modern mindset, doing can precede being; missiology can even (creatively) create ecclesiology.


I asked a friend today the question at hand. She immediately answered, "Missiology, of course. God told Moses he was being sent; before God even told Moses what his (God's) name was."


Holy smoke, she's right!

Bono nails it again (in a sermon he has preached around the world); "God may be with us in our mansions on the hill...I hope so....but God is with the poor. And God is with us, if we are with the poor."

We find our ecclesiology as we find and follow our missiological tug.


In the process, we might even find God.


Or as Hirsch would have it:
Christology>Missiology>Ecclesiology

(And check out Cultural Savage's addendum)

And as Mike Todd would unpack that:

Our Christology leads to missiology which leads to ecclesiology..In other words, who Jesus is gives us our mission, and our mission prescribes what church should be. How many of us in the west have that exactly backwards? We need to reboot, as Al calls it. We need to return to our primary source documents--the Gospels--and figure out who this Jesus was. Or, as we put it in our faith community:
We need to get to know Jesus again for the first time -link


Note: Andrew Jones and Radical Congruency have also asked the question(answering it similarly) and assembled answers..


2.) Quantum loops and the emergence of spacetime and gravity
..
Some of the debate in quantum physics revolves around whether the curvature of spacetime creates gravity, or the other way around. Like the question in #1, this could well be construed as a both/and... chicken-egg ...Or, just as missiology can assume precedence, there may be something a priori (in a spacetime way)about space-time...as in the common consensus:"gravity arises out of the curvature of spacetime".






3.) The epistemological emergence of consciousness/soul
I love the Hofsadter title "I am Strange Loop'. Because I am, amen? Check out his cheeky interview about the book here, and consider his thesis that Consciousness/"soul" arises out of a series of self-refrerential loops" By the way, literally a Pulitzer-Prize winning thesis.


And then weigh in with a quote Roger Penrose (no slouch either...co-winner with Stephen Hawking of the Wolf Prize for Physics" that floored me, (or to switch the metaphor back, stranded my #2 and #3 cords together):



"I have argued strongly against the view (of computational functionalism) in which it is merely computational activity that gives rise to conscious mentality), and I have indeed suggested that consciousness actually depends on (emerges from) the missing gravitational OR theory." -The Road to Reality : A Complete Guide to the Laws of the Universe , p. 1033)


Threw me for a loop (pun intended...as it is technically "loop quantum gravity" that is under discussion)..

Consciousness emerges from a self-referential loop; eh, Hofsatdter?...And (maybe this is the same thing) perchance it (also?) emerges from spacetime-based gravity.

All that to say God knew what he was doing when he embedded himself in history/culture/physics.

---------------
There you go; I have only begun exporing this three-standed triad. And I am aware that it is in the liminal spaces/thin places/holy Venning where they overlap that a lot is to be learned.



If we are about our Godbusiness of being missional then God will back us up (I love one of E Stanley Jones's keynotes: When you think Kingdomly and missionally, "You are no longer working against the grain of the universe; you are working with it.") to the tune of space and time "suddenly" and sovereignly working in our favor, and...as a free bonus, our loopy souls and consciousness will get bigger.

Ain't that the veritable meaning of history?

I am serious.
And if you seriously want to hear more about time and space working for us as Kingdom partners, check this out.

Because THAT is the meaning of history! I learned it at St. Arbuck's! (And maybe from a good book called..uh, "The Meaning of History".)

Would the one of you still reading (likely Ken or Len)...pick up here?....

after I give Reggie McNeal the last word so far:

The current spiritual awakening in North America lacks Christian content and file systems. This is the scary part of it. Left to their own imagination people will devise all sorts of crazy stuff about God, from New Age crystals to self-enlightenment. But this is also the opportunity of the current spiritual landscape. People are open to revealed truth of God if they can get it. Unfortunately, the North American church has lost its influence at this critical juncture. It has lost its influence because it has lost its identity. It has lost its identity because it has lost is mission.

The correct response, then, to the collapse of the church culture is not to try to become better at doing church. The need is not for a methodological fix. The need is for a missional fix.

The appropriate response to the emerging world is a rebooting of the mission, a radical obedience to an ancient command, a loss of self rather than self preoccupation, concern about service and sacrifice rather than concern about style.

The collapse of the church culture is God's gracious invitation to the church to rediscover itself. It will do this by dying to itself and coming alive to God's mission.link

Tuesday, July 01, 2008

of course orgasm is partly prayer


"For many, sexuality is simply what happens between two people involving physical pleasure. But that's only a small percentage of what sexuality is. Our sexuality is all the ways we strive to reconnect with our world, with each other, and with God." (Rob Bell, "Sex God," p. 42)

"The Reformation sometimes looks like a case of baby and bathwater. In neglecting the sensual for the explicable we damage our ability to model the Otherness of God.

...To a medieval person the church building gave unparalleled sensual pleasure as an analogy and actual foretaste of heaven. Maybe church was even better than sex, given how little people washed back then. And chocolate hadn't been invented."

-Stephen Shields

Okay, first of all, "Don't hear what I'm not saying," as St. Reggie McNeal taught me to say...

BUT>>
Of course,
the Da Vinci Code is inevitably partly right:

Orgasm
is
inevitably
a
form of prayer
.


Or a precursor to prayer/call to prayer/means of prayer/avoidance of prayer (and thus prayer).

Maybe all orgasm is prayer;
but not all prayer is orgasm.

Ask someone who would intuitively know--a rabbi:

Prayer is not something the believer just recites...it is an
experience he enters into. There is no room for inhibition; singing and dancing
are essential means by which he expresses his emotional cleaving to God….but
such ardor/desire for God has to be so overwhelming that any extraneous thoughts
are excluded…If distractions are erotic in nature…and he faces up to the
predominance of the sexual urge at both conscious and subconscious levels, and
its capacity to intrude even during prayer...then he has learned to take
measures…by introducing the (ancient) doctrine of the "elevation of strange
thoughts." This is a Chasidic Jewish technique not of sublimation, but of
thought conversion, whereby the beauty or desirability of the woman is latched
upon and used not as a sexual but rather as a mental and spiritual stimulus. We
are taught to "elevate" these thoughts by substituting the beauty of God for the
physical beauty that is currently bewitching us. The pray-er has learned to
immediately contrast the pale reflection of beauty that humans are endowed with,
on the one hand, and the supreme Divine source of authentic and enduring beauty,
on the other…This is not sublimation; This is elevation
.
"Blessed are You: A Comprehensive Guide to Jewish Prayer," by Rabbi Jeffrey Cohen
link:
Elevation Church:Jesus Loves Righteous People


Ask another rabbi:


'Celibacy was utterly rejected by biblical and rabbinic teaching. Those who refused to marry and bear children were regarded not only as having violated the first mitzvah of procreation, but also as if they had shed blood and diminished the image of God from the world, since man is created in his image. And according to the rabbis, they even caused the divine presence to depart from tthe Jewish people. The rabbis taught, 'No man without a wife, neither a woman without a husband, nor both of them without God (Genesis Rabbah 8:9 and Babylonian Talmud, Yev. 62b,63a)...An unmarried high priest was not even allowed to officiate in the temple on the Day of Atonement. Sexuality was seen as a potentially positive drive in rabbinic thought; for without those desires, 'no man wold build a house, marry a wife or have children.' (Gen Rab. 9:7)
-"Rabbi Yechiel Eckstein"
How Firm a Foundation," p.137


Ask someone who is a poet AND scholar (that tribe must increase!)-Eugene Peterson:


Because of the common origin of our creation and redemption, an examination of our sex life leads to an examination of our prayer life and vice versa.
link


Ask the author of the incredible "On Borrowed Words", Ilian Stavans, who recalls losing his virginity in a Mexican brothel:

"I felt warm and cold at once, and mostly bestial, but truly alive and mystical." (54)



Ask someone who has holy gall--Pete ("Imagine if being a Christian were about life?") Gall:

"Look, if this whole deal with God is at all real, it has to do better than drone on in hypothetical and scholastic debates. It has to apply to premarital nudity, dreams of personal glory, colossal lapses in judgment, family dysfunctions, battles with addiction, and frustration with fools. It must have something to say about tenacity, idolatry, heroes, love, sunsets, demons, prayer, miracles, worms, rivers and hard-won orgasm. Tell me about that stuff. Admit that you’ve somehow come to believe that the sin of the world can hold a candle to the wretchedness of your own heart. Take on questions that are bigger than your answers. Fight to let pain serve its purpose. Let grace shine through if it’s so real and so great and so worth living for. Show me a Jesus who gives a shit about the world I inhabit, and I’ll keep reading."
link

Doesn't this mean "Global Orgasm For Peace Day" is largely whacky but also partly right?

Don't ask John McArthur.
Sign up for this seminar instead. (:

This also means The Edge..as a "Zen Presbyterian" ..is partly right:



..which is partly what is bandmate meant on that same night about "God walking through the [bed]room."

Monday, July 25, 2011

we're not in PurposeDriven anymore, Toto...

I love University Christian Fellowship in one of my former hometowns, Syracuse, NY.
If you've never read their "order of worship," you are missing a real treat: hilarious and profound. It's here.
I dare you NOT to love them after you've read that!

And check out their Directional Document for 2011, which came out of their Strategic Planning Retreat.  Suffice to say while many churches come out of visioning retreats with ten year plans, programs laid out, and million dollar budgets....life in "biotic" churches is a bit more organic and messy.  It's a PDF, here.

Related:

The Evil of Steering Cats: L. Sweet and R. McNeal

Wednesday, June 11, 2008

St Reggie and Shredding Agendas



One of the 569 reasons I love St. Reggie. I have done this with church staff.
It is revolutionary. Cures staff/staph infections. A good and God thing. Might get you fired. So do it anyway!:

“Reggie McNeal led this session. He related that while working with a church staff, he gave them the following:

Assignment: Leave staff meeting and find a Starbucks, mall or park bench and simply pray, “God, help me to see what you see.”

They came back and shredded the church agenda. It changed the church because it changed the staff. They realized that what God was concerned about was not what they had been concerned about."

link

Monday, January 12, 2009

"It's A.D. 30 All Over Again"

"It's A.D. 30 All Over Again"
by Reggie McNeal:

Tuesday, October 02, 2007

Idolatry of Form, Worship of Norm: Ignorance, Fear & St. Dogbert Wisdom

image link
I never planned to be an idolater when I grew up.
And I never became one full-blown until I became a pastor.
Full and explicit confession; I like form too much.
By default we tend to focus on …and thus inevitably worship …forms instead of norms.
Without (literally) divine intervention we wind up unintentionally at (if not autobahnning our way on purpose) our destination:
idolatry of form.
Not our destiny:
the norm, normal and normative Great Commissional lifequest.
“It’s good for us to be here, Lord.”
Uh, oh. Sounds good and spiritual. After all, it is technically a prayer.
And often it would be an appropriate response.
But in this case, it is death.
The well-meaning (?) saint who uttered it was well off the mark.
In fact, he only said it out of his personal ignorance; and the corporate systemic fear of the group/church he was hanging with.
(That's a fascinating assessment of why he misspoke. So hold on to it for a few minutes; it may indeed be the only reason believers ever misspeak and land off the mark,;and thus an incredibly handy hermeneutic for self-diagnosis).
Personal ignorance.
Corporate fear.
At least that’s the twofold interpretation of Peter’s “It’s good for us to be here, Lord.” quote/prayer/idolatry of form in Mark 9:6:
"He said this because he (as an individual) did not know what to say; and because they (as a group) were so frightened."
But Jesus seems to show up on Mounts of Transfiguration only to commission-kick us into the demon-infested valleys.
For the next verse (14) and vista after the mountaintop experience was just that.
Pete and the diciples were to apply what they had seen and heard on the glorious mountaintop in the "real world" marketplace. To backtrack and look back would be not only "idolatry of the form" but "to shrink back into destruction" (Hebrews 10:26).

Not to mention missing the fun and form of ministry that awaits any that "tear the curtain down and bring the Altar to the ground." (lyric to the 77s classic bombblast: "What was in That Letter?")
God is on the move, out task is to move with the movement.
But I'd rather stay "in church" (a "place" Jesus never commanded us to go), and "build three shrines: one for Jesus, one for Elijah..."
Death.

More often than not, Jesus is subversively moving us into the valley to give away life; to heal demonized kids;
to be missional in the marketplace and not (just on) the Mountain.
But wait, is there no place to just be "in worship?"..as the Scripture says to “Be still and Know that I am the Lord."?

Of course....but in that contract and context of that Quietist comamnd is the activist second half of that same sentence (Isaiah 46:10)...“so that My Name will be evangelized in all the earth."
The only reason God takes us to mountains of glory is to "glorify" the valley.
The real glory, which we seem to want, is not "in the church," but in the world:
"The whole earth (not 'church') is full of his glory."
We can take the mountain and prayer closet with us, you know. They are portable.
Monastic and missional go well together; indeed they are the rhythm we must listen for and live out. "Our monastery is our backpacks," a nu-monastic nun once told me.

But we prefer (not surprisingly) our personal ignorance. We defer to (surprisingly) our coroprate fear. It's familiar, comfortable...and besides we might get to see Jesus light up again!
Context is everything.
If Jesus does light up, its only becausde he and we are the light of the world.
He never claimed to be the light of the church.
"Joy to the church, the Lord has come...."
?
In fact, only worship is missional.
Or conversely, as John Piper suggests, “Mission exists because worship doesn’t.”
So back to the norm (being greatly-commissional); there’s a reason it's designed to be...well, normative.
But Form (wanting "worship" "church" or "revival" to look or last a certain way more than we want to follow Jesus into ministry in the valley), when it becomes normative and (literally) "formative" actually prevents us from worshipping the Capital N "Norm" (God).…
Hey I hear the heresy hunters already “He’s starting a cult; actually suggesting we worship a god named Norm!"

Personal ignorance.
Corporate fear.
This inevitable entanglement of personal and corporate issues is a microsm for the wisdom of great individual people or churches meshed with the wisdom of the connection to the Wider Body. Microcosm needs macrocosm and macrocosm bleeds microscosm.
Both Steve Taylors speak articulately and artfully to the dilemma. The singer/songwriter/producer S.T. has lyrically lamented about the "Meltdown at Madame Toussaud's' and that "This Disco Used to Be a Cute Cathedral."
"Yet when churches opt for oneness with the universal church, then the majority voice wins. Nothing can change. Unique identities are at risk of being lost. Rarely do innovations or minority reports float to the surface.
This is a problem in the emerging church. A Dilbert cartoon says it well. Dogburt recommends 'forming a separate group to pursue disruptions.' This suggests that separation is needed for innovation to occur...the dream of Dogburt is immense: 'a glorious place, fully funded, amazing ambience, brilliant people, free from democracy!'..
..The emerging church meets in a number of ways..(but)...it's time to get missionary"
-Steve Taylor, "The Out of Bounds Church," pp. 7-8, 10)
We can and must wrestle with loaded and leaded questions about individual vs. group.
Though there is a great book about "The Wisdom of Crowds," there is another equally prophetic book about the evil of Groupthink. Basically, there is great wisdom in a group..IF that group is the Body. If it's not, it's a "committee of buzzards." (the actual official term for a group of buzzards....whuch immediately exegetes the phrase "church committee").
Committees are buzzards...they steal, kill and destroy. They worship Form. But the Glorious Group called the Body is more like a buunch of rhinos, and should be the norm:
Rhinos moving together at full speed are known as a crash. Even when they’re just hanging around enjoying the watershed, they’re called a crash because of their potential. You’ve got to love that. I think that’s what we’re supposed to be. That’s what happens when we become barbarians and shake free of domestication and civility. The church becomes a crash. We become an unstoppable force. We don’t have to pretend we know the future. Who cares that we can see only thirty feet ahead? Whatever’s at thirty-one feet needs to care that we’re coming and better get out of the way.

We need to move together as God’s people, a barbarian tribe, and become the human version of the rhino crash. The future is uncertain, but we need to move toward it with confidence. There’s a future to be created, a humanity to be liberated. We need to stop wasting our time and stop being afraid of what we cannot see and do not know. We need to move forward full force because of what we do know.
(Erwin McManus)
Community crashes us into mission. Mountains are missional. Form leads to Norm.
Yet as the church, we are obviosuly still afraid (personally) and ignorant (corprately) to even enter the real world.
But the joke's on us; we have already entered it…when we were born. Being born again did not at all yank us out of it.
“In the world, but not of it...but not out of it yet either," as Leonard Sweet translates.
Personal ignorance and corporate fear attempt to keep us holed up in the hotel and holy huddle. Jesus loves us so much he prefers we live in hell.
At least hell on earth.
So his will (and mountain) be done on earth/hell as it is in mountain/heaven.
It is tough to untwist the Greek grammar of Mark's spin on Peter's problem. Was it a twofold problem (personal ignorance AND corporate fear)? Is it personal ignorance LEADING TO corporate fear? Or corporate fear leading to personal ignorance.
The only truly biblical answer is yes.
We need to bomb both chicken and egg without worrying about which came first.
It's all a vicous circle/cycle and feedback loop.

Peter should have simply declared himself sick of the spin cycle and jumped off;
landing square on the street; in the real world; marketplaced.
A pastor friend of mine lives in a city where he feels the "official" citywide pastors prayer meeting has become ingrown "good old boys club"; even evidencing telltale signs of the dreaded disease of koinonitis.
Now how could anyone complain that pastor from across the city actually get together and pray? That in itelf is thrilling (as I know, it happens in our city, thank God!).
But that in itself is Form and Death.
The Good Samritan was recruited because the clergyman was late to the pastors prayer meeting. God, as Bono has suggested, will use anyone who raises their hand to volunteer.
“Thank you; God, that this prayer meeting shows the city that we are unified" is apparently a commom prayer at the meeting. Sounds good and spiritual. And often would be the good news. But my friend fears it is...
...Personal ignorance and corporate fear.
For this reason, my friend is about to suggest the group "de-mountain" and "de-form" the meeting by moving it down the street to a coffee shop in a needy neighborhood.
He is afraid that suggestion will cost him his spot on the board.
But since he tells me another common prayer at the meeting is "Dear God, send revival to our city; and start with our pulpits and sermons, and take it to the streets"..
..and since, with all due respect, that order is exactly backwards..
I am afraid I would vote with him for the new form.
The alterntive is to be still and know that the old form is god.

Wolfgang Simson is usually right:
"Our only problem is doing the new in the power of the old.”
Leonard Sweet is usually right on:

"It could be for the first time in history, God is more active in the world than the church."

I ams o proud of our sister church in Oakdale, California.

They were brave enough to shut down an old form that had become formless: The longstanding (Six years...doesn't that make it an annual event till Jesus returns?) men's retreat.

I am sure some church members though the glory had departed.

Actually they are correct:

The glory has departed, just as it is supposed to. We are not meant to live on the mountain and retreat. We are called to live first and foremost in the one place scripture promises teh glory cloud is thickest: The whole earth.

That makes it an advance toward the Norm; not a retreat to the form.

As Reggie McNeal (and I) often have to say:

"Don't hear what i'm not saying."


I am not saying cancel all "worship events" in "sacred buildings."

I am not saying all men's retreats should self-destruct.

Actually, I am close to saying both. But the real point at this point is:

The norm and form of church in the era we live in should be far more much more missional, "worldly" and marketplaced.

And I've been to the top.

For one, to the top of the Andes. For one of the most glorious mountaintop (to the tune of 17,000 feet) prayer meetings I ever experienced (Read all about it here).
I've been to the Brownsville Revival, the Toronto Blessing.
Thank God those two "movements' have wisely morphed, downsized and caught new and missional forms.
The only alternative is to build three monuments and let the world go to hell.
I have lived in Wilmore, home of the famous 1970 Asbury Revival.
In Wilmore, some well-meaning folks pray...to this day:
"Lord, do it again, just like you did in 1970!"
It'll be great of he does; yet I believe I can actually promise he won't.
Form (wineskins...see this)..need constant renewing.
I've been to Azusa Street.

There's nothing there but a marker.
And that’s not a bad thing.
It’s in the street..
"When the forms of an old wineskin are dying, " Graham Cooke often says, "the new forms are created by those who are not afraid to be insecure."
Give me the holy insecurity of being dropped into the demon-possessed valley and challenge to do greater works than Jesus ever did. That trumps the "glory" of maintaining (beyond its expiration date) the glory of any mountaintop appearance of Jesus.
But I say this out of personal ignorance and corporate fear.
So I need a few more minutes on the mountain before I move out into mission.
But I won't succumb to that satanic temptation.
Jesus is waiting to meet me in the "new" form and norm.
"...so the disciple descended the Mount of Transfiguration...and immediately found...a demonized child"