Welcome! You have accidentally reached the blog of a heteroclite follower of Jesus: dave wainscott. I'm
"pushing toward the unobvious" as I post thinkings/linkings
re: Scripture, church and culture. Hot topics include: temple tantrums, time travel, sexuality/spirituality, U2kklesia, role of the pastor, God-haunted music/art..and subversive videos like these.
You’ve heard this: “The
word ekklesia is a Greek word for the church that literally means,
“called out ones””. Technically, this isn’t true. While combining the
two root words (“called out from”) does indeed create something like
“called out ones”, the truth is, the word ekklesia is never used that
way in the New Testament or its contemporaries. In fact, ekklesia was
used to refer to a group of philosophers, mathematicians, or any other
kind of assembly in the Greco-Roman world. So unless we’re supposing
that actors and gladiators were called to a holy lifestyle by assembling
together, we can’t create a relationship between holiness and ekklesia
necessarily. While it’s true that the church is composed of “called out”
ones – that’s not the particular point of this word. It just means
“assembly” or “gathering.” Nick McDonald
--
See also Craig Keener:
Another example of this problem occurs when interpreters speak of the Church as the “called-out ones” based on the Greek word for church,ekklesia. We are, to be sure, “called-out,” but we know that for other reasons, not because we can determine that from ekklesia. Some divideekklesia into ek, meaning “out of,” and kaleo, which means “call.” Butekklesia had already been used by Greeks for centuries to mean an “assembly” or “gathering”; Jewish people who knew Greek spoke of the congregation of Israel in the wilderness as God’s ekklesia. So the New Testament does not make up a new word to call Christians the “called-out-ones”; rather, it uses a standard term for an assembly, and probably the first Christians thought especially of God’s own assembly in the Old Testament, his people. LINK
So what does Jesus promise Peter? He will be the foundation on which Christ will build his “church.” Here is the first use of ekklesia in the Gospels. It occurs only three times, all in Matthew, and the other two references are both in 18:17. Many hold that Jesus did not conceive of establishing a church and that these verses are later Matthean insertions. But the nature of Jesus’ instruction to his community of followers certainly implied their continued existence in some form, even if there is little of an “institution” yet in view. Moreover, the word ekklesia in Hellenistic Greek often simply meant an assembly… The popular view that the church is somehow to separate itself from society, based on the derivation of ekklesia from ekkaleo (to call out) affords a classic example of what linguists call the etymological fallacy. Words often develop meanings over time that differ from their roots. They only sense in which the wordchurch in New Testament times means those who are called out is that believers routinely gather together by leaving their separate places of residence or work. (p 252-53) (italics in original -Craig Blomberg, HT, Alan Knox
Greek word ekklesia. When we hear the word church, one of the following images usually pops into our heads: a building with a steeple on it; a Sunday morning service; a denomination; a pastor; a pulpit; pews; a worship team (or choir); and a sermon. Or we think of all the Christians in the entire world
.
Like ‘nice’ and ‘pagan,’ the word ekklesia has morphed since the first century. Back then, it did not mean “called out ones” as is sometimes taught. Consistently, the word meant a local community of people who assemble together regularly.
The word was used for the Greek assembly whereby those in the community were “called forth” from their private lives to meet (assemble) in the town forum to make decisions for their city. Consequently, the word also carries the flavor of every-member participation in decision-making. According to the New Testament, the church of Jesus Christ is not a place where one buries the dead and marries the living. It’s a community of people who gather together and who possess a shared life in Christ. As such, the ekklesia is visible, touchable, locatable, and tangible. You can visit it. You can observe it. And you can live in it.” -Frank Viola, “From Eternity to Here”, pp. 280-281
Peter Woit's working conclusion about string theory is hugely helpful to church/culture shift. No surprise, as God has been speaking to us in ekklesia about ekklesia, from the parellel and dovetail discipline of physics (see
The whole modern-postmodern pregnant parenthesis wer are in is basically the same story as the relativity>quantum; Newtonian>postNewtonian morph.
The conclusion is basically that string theory is inevitably partly right (that is if it exists)... but, as in his title, "not even wrong."
From the back cover (emphasis mine):
Peter Woit shows that what many physicists call "superstring theory" is not a theory at all, but an unrealized hope that a theory exists. In his view, superstring theory has departed the realm of testable hypothesis and now resembles something like speculation, even theology--it makes no predictions, even wrong ones.
I also love the New Scientist review of the book from (emphasis mine):
"A call to arms for physicists to pursue multiple paths in search of truth, not funding."
If we only realized that Emergent/emerging, emergissional, or whatever we are and tend to trust in is not the Final Answer; the coveted Theory of Everything (see Mike's rude toejam here)... ...at least in its perfect form). It may not even be a theory yet..if ever. They/We may not even be predicting predictions.
Yet we intuit we are partly right in this wineskin; as any means of mixing/mashing small and large worlds/groups/networks is a Kingdom thing. Just as Sexy String Theory as currently defined seems to be the best model we have for making sense of small/micro (quantum) and large/macro ), so the creative forms and norms many are testing these days (cell and celebration; house church and city church, etc) are good places to be.
the set of units sometimes revered to 'God-given' units, or 'natural' units...(which) are chosen to take advantage of basic features of special relativity and quantum mechanics, getting rid as much as possible constraints..(5-6)
All I want to do is take holy and wholly advantage of all things "naturally" or literally "God-given." Eschewing a reductionist version of Hegelian synthesis; or an old school mainline line of skubala ("The millenium/heaven-on earth has arrived, and we have created it."). We might even have enough to work from if all we have is Jesus...and a sur-theoretical/pre-theorectical predilection for praxis and liminality.
If only we really did pursue multiple paths in search of truth, not funding. Mammon (and his twin Aphrodite) may be the only false god we ultimately wrestle with. Hmm, money and sex. Isn't that prostitution? Ask Eugene Peterson sometime about pastors "whoring after other gods."
As Bill Murray and Steve Martin once asked, "What the heck is that?" ..or something like that, see vintage video below:
.
We must keep asking that about "church" I love showing this "Council of Elrond" scene from "Lord of the Rings" to illustrate how tough it can be to describe ekklesia/church. What is it? It's a mission....quest....thing.":
I also love how Donald Kraybill talks about "collectivity""
"The Kingdom of God is a collectivity--anetwork of persons....more than a series ofindividualized email connectionslinkingt he King to each subject...[It] infuses theweb of relationships, binding King and citizens togeter" --Kraybill (p, 19 emphases mine) see more context here
Peter Rollins, especially in "The Idolatry of Godm" settles on "collective" as the term of choice for talking about the church "thing."
I love our local ekklesi-thing.. But what the heck is it? We have called it "third day" from the beginning, and it;s a great name (see this), but why don't we nickname ourselves (dba) as some combo of the above: "The Ekkollective [ekklesia +collective...and as a bonus, it sounds like "eclectic"] Mission/Quest/Thing."
How about just "Thing"?
(we already know who Thing One and Thing Two are...see this)
On Pasha Siberia posts on "Jesus' original intention" in using the word "ekklesia" in Matthew:
.. in conclusion,Jesus was interested in establishing his Kingdom on earth, a new order.
To do this he wanted to see Local Council Assemblies of believers be
his representatives through out the earth. He always intended to remain
the King in charge of all of these assemblies, never to have an
intermediate person in charge. These Local Assemblies are of course
places of worship, but if they never consider how to transform the world
around them, then they are not fulfilling their purpose. Therefore the
Council part of the definition needs to be worked out in practical
Christian love.
I have argued strongly against the word church before. Again, I am not
even suggesting a replacement. It is equally possible for us to behave
as the representatives of King Jesus in local gatherings without having
to put a label on anything. Often when we start to use labels, we begin
to shape them into our own human religion and depart from Jesus'
original intention. Let's be about doing Jesus' Kingdom.
LINK,Pasha Siberia
Dave: You wrote: "The word 'church' is not used in Bible for a building or a Sunday gathering. So to emphasize this, we try not to say 'at church,' for example, because we are the church. "
Do not take this wrong... I am trying to learn all that is possible. You used the above sentence. I am trying to learn why... Yes I know each person is the ultimate church or should be. Yet to have a regular spot such as a "temple" or "building" seems to have been what is being said in the Scriptures below:
1)Yes I understand in the below that Peter IS the rock... but what did Peter do and build? Matthew 16:18 18 And I tell you that you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church, and the gates of Hades will not overcome it. Matthew 18:15-17 "If your brother sins against you, go and show him his fault, just between the two of you. If he listens to you, you have won your brother over. 16 But if he will not listen, take one or two others along, so that 'every matter may be established by the testimony of two or three witnesses.' 17 If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church; and if he refuses to listen even to the church, treat him as you would a pagan or a tax collector.
Acts 5:11-12 1 Great fear seized the whole church and all who heard about these events. 12 The apostles performed many miraculous signs and wonders among the people. And all the believers used to meet together in Solomon's Colonnade. The outer courts were enclosed by magnificent colonnades. Along the east side of the outer court ran what was called Solomon's Colonnade; it was here that Jesus was seen walking during the Feast of the Dedication (Hanukkah) and teaching the multitudes.
Joel 2:17 17 "Let the priests, who minister before the LORD, weep between the temple porch and the altar. 2)Question::" Was the 'temple, porch, altar' expressly denied by Jesus.. forbidden by Him?
One last thought. "Church" by it's pure definition means: [Old English cir(i)ce , from a prehistoric Germanic word that is also the ancestor of German Kirche; ultimately from Greek kuriakon doma “house of the lord,” from kurios “lord”].
A scoffer's reply to some of your statements (about not saying "in church") might be: "Funny, Jesus used that term (church) several times while on planet earth...I thought He liked it."
Dave, just hit me over the head and point me in the right direction. -(Name not included)
======================= ANSWER I certainly love you too much to hit you over the head. Actually, I would love it if all disciples had a 'head" like yours to ask just the right, intelligent and necessary questions. You have done so, and I certainly take no offense, only offer thanksgiving that we have a chance to explore these deep things together. Here we go. I could hope every Christian was as deep a thinker and as profound a wrestler after truth! I do stand by my quote in your first paragraph, though I do recognize that I tend to make blanket statements for shock value sometimes, but that is only intended to "shock" us into how radical are the ways of Jesus, and how radically we have misunderstood terms like 'church." I had no intent of implying there was anything wrong with gathering publicly with other believers in a place. But, no, in light of your comment in the second paragraph, it is NOT what the Scriptures you cite are suggesting, that "to have a regular spot such as a "temple" or "building" seems to have been what is being said in the Scriptures below." To have such a place and space is not in and of itself a problem (though we can sure trust too much in a "sacred spot"), but every text you quoted actually are the among the choicest texts to evidence the opposite case: that "church" is never defined in Scripture as "place," but always "people." Let's dive into the Matthew text, with your quote and question to help frame us.
You said:
Matthew 16:18: And I tell you that you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church..."). Yes I understand in the below that Peter IS the rock... but what did Peter do and build?
Short answer: He built people. But notice, his temptation, like ours, was to build a literal building when he didn't need to. Remember on the Mount of Transfiguration, he said, "Lord, this is such a great place to be. Let's build a building to worship here...in fact, let's build three." (Mark 9:5) In the very next verse, though, it is revealed that Peter only proposed this "building program" out of fear and an (in Howard Snyder's clever coinage) "edifice complex." I know the Catholic tradition that Peter probably built some literally buildings later in his life, after becoming pope. Even if it is true that he eventually did so, it cannot be what Jesus was speaking about in this passage. First of all, since "church" is never a building in the Bible, he didn't mean any literal building. And secondly, Jesus said HE would do the actual building. But back to the top: Peter, like his Lord, built people..built them up. In predicting that He Himself would build His church, Christ didn't mean literally building anything, since he obviously never built a building, and no serious Bible scholar would even imply that He did. He meant building "spiritually" His believing people. The word "church" Jesus is quoted as using is the Greek "ekklesia" which means literally "called-out ones (people)" and has nothing to do with a literal building or place . No one in their wildest imagination who knew Greek would ever associate the word with a building. This brings up of course, your quoting the Old English, German word for church, translating "house of the Lord". To use an English and German definition for a word that the Bible defines in Greek can be very misleading. The idea of "house" is nowhere in the definition of the biblical word for "church". The European and American church has truly and tragically tripped up using definitions from their own languages, even though we all know the Bible was written in Koine Greek. Your cited definition also quotes a Greek word "kuriokon doma", "house of the Lord". True, that is in fact Greek, and that is a fair way to translate it, but the point is that word is NOT in any instance the word used for "church" in the Bible. It is always "ekklesia", which again can only mean "called out people." "Where is a house that You can build for me? There is none, says the Lord." (Note this Scripture is actually an OLD Testament one, Isaiah 66:1..amazing!) Wolfgang Simson is profoundly articulate and prophetically accurate (It's nice to be able to quote someone who says what you are trying to say, only says it BETTER) when he issues the following clamant call:
"From the time of the New Testament, there is no such thing as 'a house of God.' At the cost of his life, Stephen reminded us: God does not live in temples made with human hands. The church is the people of God. " Source: page xvii of "Houses That Change the World", also found here on this website on the "Risky Reading" page..clickhere
And note 1 Cor 3:9: "You, God's people, are God's building." Of course the church (=people) is called to gather in Solomon's colonnade, in homes(see, for example, Colossians 4:14: "the church that meets at her house"), and in other gatherings; but, on a very important technicality, that place is not "church." That is the church (that is, called-out people) gathering as the church. as in 1 Cor. 14:23 "when the whole church comes together." As you know, most New Testament letters are addressed to "the church in Ephesus" or "the church in Corinth," or whatever city is involved. Paul obviously didn't write letters to buildings. So Matthew 18:17,"Tell it to the church," obviously means tell it to the church (Christians) when they are gathered as the church (not when they are "in church."). You said,
"Peter IS the rock."
Well, we need to park there a minute, and closely examine that assumption. Bear with me. Peter the rock? Maybe that's what Jesus meant. But not necessarily. Jesus did not say, as He could have, "Peter, you are the rock." He said instead, "You are Peter, and on this rock, I will build my church." When Jesus spoke here, he was using a pun and play on words: "Peter" in the biblical language is "Petros", the word for "small rock or pebble." The word he used for "Rock" is almost identical ("petra"0, but this definition is decidedly different; it's the term for a large rock. So He says, "You are a little rock, and on this big Rock I will build my church." He did not say, "on you, Peter(Petros)," because He used the other word for rock(petra). It is not dogmatically clear what Jesus was referring to when he said "on this rock". Here are the main options/interpretation:
1)by 'on this rock', He meant Peter (this is the Catholic position: that thereby Peter is the first pope). 2)by "on this rock" he meant the confession of faith that Peter just proclaimed ("You are the Christ".(verse16)...so that the "rock" to build the church on is the rock-solid confession that" Jesus is the Christ." 3)a combination of 1 and 2 4) when He said "this Rock" , He meant Himself and maybe literally pointed to Himself. In other words, "I tell you, Peter, that you are a small rock. But on this Big Rock (Me, Jesus), I will build.." 5) a completely different interpretation, which I'll work on explaining later (just don't want to get too far off the main point at hand).
Working against interpretation #1 is the fact that no individual..Peter or any individual is the rock/cornerstone. only Jesus(1 Pet 2:4-8 and Eph 2:20). "What did Peter do and build?", you ask. Note, Jesus said that HE (Jesus) not Peter or anyone else would build the church. But Peter was a leader..who, along with other leaders, allowed Jesus through them to build up His people, the church. In the New Testament,. the "temple" is now us:
1 Cor 3:16: "You are God's temple" .
2 Cor 6:16: "We are now the temple of the living God."
Eph 2:21: "The church people rise up to be God's temple."
Acts 17:24: "I, God, no longer dwell in temples made and built by human hands."
The Lord couldn't be more clear. Yes, the early believer still sometimes went to the temple, while it was still standing (Acts 3:1), but if we had asked any one of them what they meant by the word "church," it would not even cross any of their minds to mention a building. There is no such thing as a "church building" built until hundreds of years from this gospel. Regarding your question #2: "Was the temple, porch, altar" (quoted from Joel) expressly denied by Jesus...?. Again, an excellent and vital question. I think in a sense the simple, but too simplistic, answer is "yes, " but a more correct and nuanced answer is that He totally transformed the definition, tenor and application of these terms in the current New Covenant. He Himself has literally and spiritually fulfilled these Scriptures. So their Old Testament pattern being seen as normative for today is quite expressly "denied", though you have noticed I have chosen other more positive terms. This passage from Joel is obviously an Old Testament command regarding patterns of worship. So yes, it has been quite clearly superceded. That's precisely what the New Testament book of Hebrews is about. It speaks so often of the "new and better way"! We now have a "better hope" (7:19), a "better covenant (7:22), "better promises: (8:6), "better sacrifices than the old ones" (9:23), a 'better word" (12:24). Now, in the New Testament, we (after and under High and Ultimate Priest, Jesus) are the priests, (Rev 1:6, Rev 5:10 spell this out), and we no longer need a literal, physical porch and altar to approach God. (Note, I am not saying there is anything inherently wrong with a place where believers meet for worship; of course not. But there is something inherently and tragically wrong in thinking we need a place to reach and worship God). Hebrews 9:11-14 proclaims boldly that now that Christ has made His sacrifice "once and for all," The temple way of doing worship is abolished forever. "Jesus 'SETS ASIDE' the old way of doing worship to establish and inaugurate the new way" (Heb 9:9). I capitalized "set aside" to dovetail with your question about "expressly forbidding." It sounds like He did indeed in essence forbid it; if No One less than Jesus has "set something aside," I don't want to "go there". King James is stronger than the NIV I have quoted: "He TAKES AWAY the first system." Living Bible: "He CANCELS the first system." Revised Standard: "He ABOLISHES the old system.." Strong, and strongly needed words. "The law is only a shadow of the good things that have come. not the realities themselves, " according to Hebrews 10:1. Such is "the old way of worship which can never forgive sins." So yes, Jesus did forbid the "temple, porch, altar" way of worship because in God's own words, it is not even "reality."!! There is no longer in the Old Testament, literal sense, a place between the porch and altar. Remember when the curtain in the literal temple was torn in two when Jesus died? That meant the temple system of worship, of needing a human priest to mediate was over forever. And to revert or backslide into that system as our ultimate means and trust would be what the Bible expressly calls throughout the book of Hebrews a "danger," "peril." I m not saying, you (the one who asked this fine question) are doing that; just clarifying why the implications of a correct answer are so terribly significant.
Finally, an answer to your scoffer: "
"Funny, Jesus used that term ( church) several times while on planet earth...I thought he liked it."
Well, scoffer, contrary to popular opinion. even the opinions of many non-scoffers...Jesus did not, by a long shot, use the term "church" several times. He only used it. shock..TWICE during His entire earthly ministry (Both passages were discussed above: Matt. 16:18 and 18:17, and both clearly show that He never meant a "place" but "people"). Slim pickings! However, we know beyond a shadow of a doubt that he liked (and loved) the word "church". because the church is His people! "Christ loved the church, and gave Himself completely for the church." (Ephesians 5:25). Hope this helps. Blessings again for your keen question. It enabled me to focus my own thinking. And I still refuse to hit you over the head! (:
The most tremendously deep Christian still has a terrifying capacity for self-deception, I have often said.
Len's helpful post(Hohstadt on “our Greek soul” ) hijaked me into me to rethinking/feeling/tooling how subtly dualism, gnosticm and hellenism are temptations; ironically/especially when we are attempting to intentionally dismantle them! We sometimes (re)create new dualisms, gnosticisms , and hellenisms in the process.
I got a kick out of St. Steve cleverly/winkingly commenting that he is the biggest Hellenistic thinker in the world."...which of course is a Hellenistic statement... Len quotes Thomas: "Our ancient Greek legacy is totally incompatible with the ancient Hebrews." A Greek-phrased thesis to advocate non-Greek thinking!
..Oh, no a loop!
Hofstadter offers brilliant work on how consciousness/"soul" emerges: through a series of self-referential feedback loops (kinda like the Edge on guitar!!!); a fascinating phenomenon that great music, art and math ("Godel, Escher , Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid.") can is some sense exhibit (thus, Hofstadter's delightful phrase for such manifestations : they are "big-souled."
In a recent Scientific American two leading neuroscientists debate "How Does Consciousness Happen? I am sorry they didn't ask theological epistemologists like PubProphet Rharbert, so we'll have to settle for Christof Koch and Susan Greenfield, who preface the article with:
How brain processes translate to consciousness is one of the greatest un-solved questions in science. Although the scientific method can delineate events immediately after the big bang and uncover the biochemical nuts and bolts of the brain, it has utterly failed to satisfactorily explain how subjective experience is created.
As neuroscientists, both of us have made it our life’s goal to try to solve this puzzle (and we disagree).
You technical geniuses can interpret the opposing answers the good docs give....But could it be that one arrived at a Greek answer from a Hebrew perspective, and the other reached a Hebrew answer from their Hebraic assumptions?
Either way (both ways), soul happens.
Greenfield suggests that any strong sensory stimulus (such as an alarm clock or bright light) will induce consciousness. The more extensive and organic the person's network of neurons, the more likely they will be awakened. How God (The ultimate strong external stimulus) must delight in "waking/shaking us up," summoning our soul to arise. I only hope my nueron/ekklesia-basileis network is extensive,organic, and receptive. Only then does the net work. Bach, through his prophetic Godawareness realized something super/supernatural was transpiring through some of his canons:
I can't let a Bach Cantata as beautiful as it is) have a bigger soul than me. It's inanimate(or is ts?)! I long for a holy, jealous, zealous "soul envy."
I crave spiritual, soulical mentors:the creations/emergences/soul-happenings Godel, Escher, Bach..
and of course Celtic artists who can move in liminal/sacred/thin places,
...and Loopy Bono: "The goal is soul!"....see the escatic glossolalic, bigsouled outburst at the end of this classic clip where he quotes this, from 1:00 to the end":
These are all
an alarm clock to the soul..
After all, What does it profit me to gain the whole world and lose my loop?"
It just came out of the Kinks via singer/lyricist Ray Davies..
..and all most people know is the staccatoriff that may have singlehandedly launched punk rock only twelve years ahead of its time; "You Really Got Me."
Ahead of
their time, indeed. Even as I type, Radiohead's "Airbag" is playing in the next room; its riff, lyric and persona feel very Kinkish. (Both these bands at their best have delivered what Bono keeps threatening U2 will: "punk rock from Venus" with social commentary. And you can dance to it. Kinky!)
"I've realized how difficult it is to be on your own after being in a group for so long," says Davies, who led the Kinks for thirty-two years. "I want to feel I'm in a band, but I'm not. That's the biggest problem I've had in recent years."
Rolling Stone follows up that quote with:
This is quite a statement, given what Davies went through in 2004, when he was shot by a mugger in New Orleans. The injuries were much worse than reported at the time, and Davies still hasn't fully recovered.
especially as channeled into the need/sehnsucht/cry for
community/communitas/group/ekklesia ("I don't much want to tour, except for the community of Kinks fans. They meet each other at my gigs, which hasn't happened for a long time. That's ic;">the only reason I would want to tour: the community.")
can feel and be far worse a pain than any physical pain we can imagine.
Such stuff bullets your blue sky, and sends you into psalms and hell-on-earth;
and turns your heart and hunger toward connection and collaboration:
is often far " a="" suffering="" than="" any="" physical="" pain="" we="" could="" imagine="" or="">
"Getting shot is easy compared to creating an identity for yourself as a solo artist," Davies says, picking at his baked avocado, which is oozing grease and smelling bad. He's speaking like a depressed person. Minimal volume. Minimal affect. "I don't want to treat musicians like hired help. I encourage a collaborative spirit.."
And on the ride from the restaurant to his home, he laments:
"There aren't any proper pubs in England anymore. They're all gastro-pubs. If you want a decent pint, you have to go to Ireland. The pubs, the churches — all dying institutions."
Uh, yeah.
"Another reason I wanted to move to New Orleans was to escape Tony Blair," says Davies. "I'm a socialist, and Labor is not socialist anymore. The working man is still downtrodden and unheard. And now they're vanishing. Blair came in and it became uncool to be working class. Everybody aspired to be something a little bit better. Nothing wrong with wanting to better yourself, but when you forget your origins — that's bad. That's why I don't fit into this culture anymore. I take the side of the underdog." Davies sips his tea and thinks.
"I don't justify the guy who shot me," he resumes. "But I kind of understood. Maybe he didn't have such a great life. I don't know."
That itself summarizes one of my seminary life-lessons reading Frank Lake.
Maybe Davies is prepping to be a pastor in is second career; wounded healer indeed...
"Universal, they've culled the tunes, they've cut out this, and kept that, and I've inherited all this bullshit. So it's the illusion that you can get by without a 9-to-5 job. Most of my time was taken up dealing with corporate people, the bullshit people. And I've had to deal with bullshit for most of my career. Does Bob Dylan have to deal with the same thing? I talk to more lawyers than I do musicians. The reason I don't give up is that I want to be an annoyance to the bean counters for the rest of my life."
And he's already leading the kind of organic, relationship-based, weeklong pastor seminars...uh, excuse me, musician seminars...that our church network does:
A tall middle-aged man in a fat winter jacket shyly approaches Davies at the table. He appears to be a fan, then Davies has a moment of recognition, and they talk warmly for a few minutes, shaking hands when the man departs. "He was one of my songwriting students," says Davies. "I do a songwriting seminar — it's residential, and it lasts a week. I was trying to arrange the exchange of schools between New Orleans and London before I got shot. I was trying to expand it just to get kids writing and feeling good about themselves. Like this guy I just talked to. He's not a student, just someone who took a different route than I did. He's done the day job, he's getting near the end of his career. He's always wanted to be a songwriter, and he decides, 'I'm going to do it.' So he takes the course; he can express something he wants to say, and he feels great at the end of the week. It keeps something in him alive, because the guitar does mean freedom. Everyone deserves that space to dream of freedom...
Then the clincher, that seems to capture Davies' own dilemma and Godstruggle:
... but it gets harder and harder to earn that dream time."
But when the young female employee of Uncle Harry's leaned back in the couch-chair uncomfortably next to me and cascaded her hair to within inches of my arm..
(don't worry, this is NOT a photo I took of her, but a pic I googled up for this post so you can imagine the scene with me!)
a few thoughts hit me.
One, "what's up with this...she is breaking so many rules about personal-private space."
Or was she?
I was at Uncle Harry's... local bagelry/coffee shop; waiting on Keltic Ken from our ekklesia-thing. So I sat down in the corner in one of two overstuffed chairs around a small round table; obviously a table for two.
I set my water bottle and a book on the table stategically in front of the other chair; and noted there was also a newspaper on the chair.
It was obvious to me I was saving the seat.
But not to Charity (not her real name).
To my surprise, without even acknowledging me (I was reading...of course), she simply moved the newspaper and sprawled out to relax a bit.
I didn't bother to tell her the seat was saved;
..But in a few minutes I was almost wondering if I was.
I had been praying about opportunities to talk to people in the marketplace and coffee shops; truly wanting to meet and accept people where they are...
..but not often taking the initiative to actually do it.
I simply prayed and wondered what was up.
When I told this story to our Thursday afternoon group, a sister was convinced the young lady was flirting with me.
I don't believe it..and besides, I am old guy!
Another sister in her twenties agreed with me...a bit too readily(:
But she got the point that Creps has made well about the younger/postmodern natives:
They have completely different culture and worldview about private/public space.
Especially regarding cell phones, which is what she pulled out next..
And left a message with her name, number, and personal details about her life for the voicemail she got.
I felt a little embarrassed.
She did not.
I do not even know that she knew I was there..
..even though her hair was now almost in my face, and I felt like a stalker.
I was praying that if I was called to say something to her before this was all over:
"Hi, The Lord told me your name is _____, and your phone number is ______, and...."
(:
More likely something inocuous and pre-evangelistic like:
"How do you enjoy working here?"
or
"You pagan dork, can't you tell I am saving that seat? Besides, I now know your phone number and will crank-call you!"
(:
But I also
realized that she was taking a break from work in her workspace instead of the back room. That, too, is typical of the new generations..especially if they work in a Third Place. We would have never done that at Sambo's back in the day; huge separation of work and break.
She even called out help to customers who were looking for cups while she was on the cell phone talking about..
Anyway..
the vignette was a reminder to me that I really was called to bless and minister in this type of setting, not just blog about it.
I might have said something to her, but just then my bud came in, and she got up to get back to work..
And i am back to work, knowing I must press on in "planting my bench outside the box," living missiomally, making myself missionally available with a ready compassion to real people and real places..
Even if "all I do" is pray.. (and talk to strange people at Jack in the Box)
Last night in Romans class, we noted that Romans 12:1 ( "Offer your bodies...this is your service of worship") is the only time the phrase "worship service" shows up in the Bible.
What is a 'worship service' there?
Wherever you take your human body! Wherever: to a church building, to the bathroom, to Wal-Mart, to the bar. "Church buildings are sacred..." Mark Driscoll quips, adding a pregnant pause, "...like everything else."
"'Ekklesia' comes from the word 'ek' (out of) and klesis (a calling, kaleo means to call)...Note the church is not the enklesia-those called in..called away from the world to huddle together in a survivalist mode....By its very definition, the church does most of its work outside the four walls of the building and scattered throughout the world..
The church does not have to be physically together to be in session."
It is common in the Messianic Jewish community to not call themselves...or even claim that they are..."Christian," even though they believe wholeheartedly in Jesus as Messiah and Lord. Often, the reason presented is that to many Jews, "Gentile" connotes "Gentile" (or is Greek term, when the Hebrew is preferred).
However, one thing that causes me angst is the premise that while Messianic Jews and Gentile Christians are part of the one ekklesia,
still, there is assumption that they inhabit different socio-religious
spaces, and Messianic Jews are not actually “Christians.” The
impression I get is that Messianic Judaism is presenting itself not
simply as an ethnic church group or as a Christian denomination, it is
touted as a separate species of Christ-believer, one more entrenched in
its Jewish heritage and distinguishable from the Gentile Christians. To
be honest – and Joel might push back on this – I think Galatians rules
out precisely this kind of vision of believers in Jesus. First, when
Paul says that in Christ there is “neither Jew nor Gentile,” he is
creating a shared meta-identity where it is union with Christ that is
determinative for our relationship with God and to each other, with the
result that all walls between these groups are utterly broken down. What
is more, Paul particularly wants to avoid any kind of ecclesiology that
results in someone insisting on foreskins sit on the left and
no-foreskins sit on the right. I think Paul knew of both mixed and
parallel groups of Jewish/Gentile Christ-believers, but not two species
of believers. Second, despite the aversion to using the word
“Christian,” I cannot help but note that Christianoi was originally used for mixed Jewish and Gentile groups in both Antioch (Acts 11:21) and in Asia Minor (1 Pet 5:13). Christianoi means “client or adherent of Christ.”
Note: the excerpt above is from a review of Introduction to Messianic Judaism ,a collection of essays from Jewish and Gentile writers (including genius gentile Craig Keener) See Scot McKnight's review of the book here #1, #2)
"U2: Seeking An Ecclesiology" by Tripp Hudgins for Sojourners-excerpt:
...What I want you to see is this post from
the New Yorker. Do we truly have a "Church of U2" and is it in the
cloud as well as the arenas around the globe? Can they send their sonic
tracts anywhere they want? With 33 million downloads, is this a form of evangelism or is it simply "offering something beautiful?"It
is so wed with making money to support the mammoth (and fading) music
industry, that it's hard to know where the market begins and the
ekklesia ends.
Of course, trying to disentangle those two is always a right mess. Ask Henry VIII. It ain' easy.
The
story of U2 might be this: having begun as a band that was uncertain
about the idea of pursuing a life of faith through music, they have
resolved that uncertainty. Their thin ecclesiology has become thick. Today,
they are their own faith community; they even have a philanthropic arm,
which has improved the lives of millions of people. They know they made
the right choice, and they seem happy. Possibly, their growing comfort
is bad for their art. But how long could they have kept singing the same
song of yearning and doubt? “I waited patiently for the Lord,” Bono
sings, in the band’s version of Psalm 40. “He inclined and heard my
cry.”
Yeah. There
it is. And the connection to the new album? Here: "It expresses a
particular combination of faith and disquiet, exaltation and
desperation, that is too spiritual for rock but too strange for
church—classic U2."
Right. There.
There
is our "authenticity." There is the new ecclesiology that we see
emerging. It is not an institution in the brick and mortar sense. No, it
is an aesthetic. It is "authenticity' that is too spiritual for rock (the pure market) but too strange for church (sorry, Pope Francis).