Showing posts sorted by relevance for query u2 sound. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query u2 sound. Sort by date Show all posts

Sunday, September 20, 2009

The (Sound) Sound of God at the Speed of (Amazing) Grace



What IS the sound of grace anyway?

I am slow.

It was not until U2 recently started introducing their centerpiece anthem, "Where the Streets Have No Name" with a snippet of "Amazing Grace"
("Amazing grace/How sweet the sound/That saved a wretch like me...")
in concert that it
hit me:

1)Of course! "Sound" is a hallmark theme of their most recent CD
("Let me on the sound," "We are people borne of sound," "I found grace within a sound," etc.
I have written on this here, as have others.

The "sound" to me is
:

  • the musical, mystical sound Bono has often mentioned: "looking for a sound to drown out the world."
  • a reference to string theory ("The universe is at base, sound/music" -Len Sweet), and thus:
  • a cry to be let into God's sound/voice/strings at its very creation, core, and chaotic creativity. (See "The Divine Voice," an amazing theology of sound, and Sweet's seminal "Summoned to Lead"). Perhaps we can only hear/see God's voice/sound when we pray/act in holy synesthesia...some amazing biblical precedence there.
  • link


All salvation, if sound, is salvation by sound.
And only sound, at the end of the day, is the sign of a relationship with God:

"Connecting knowledge to sight fools us into thinking that knowing is a private event, since you do not have to be seen in order to see. The very image of illumination conjures a quiet moment that takes place in one's solitude, since light moves without making a sound. The privacy of sight is reinforced by the fact that you can see from a distance. Indeed, the further you can see (the further from the object you are), the more impressive is your act of knowledge.

Hearing, by contrast, establishes a more intimate relationship between source and perception. On a very basic level, this is true simply because we must be fairly close to the source of the sound we are trying to hear. Even with amplification, as all theater professionals know, we understand what someone is saying better when we can see them speak. More scientifically put, sound waves travel slower and weaken more quickly than light waves. It is that physical limitation that makes hearing a more relational form of knowledge.
-Stephen Webb, "The Sound of God: Supersonic Theology and the Future of Public Speaking"

Do the math:

"We walk by faith, not by sight." (2 Cor 5:17):
It's "not by sight," so the "certainty of what we see" is moot (and "mute").

Better to trust and intuit from what/who we HEAR...in the sound:

"Faith comes by hearing...":

Somehow Bono has intuited that, just knows it, has not just heard of it, but heard it.
He is epistemelogically grounded and doctrinally sound.

Shofar, so good..

2)BUT...Why did the hymn writer (uh, John Newton, not Bono this time) choose the surprising, non-sequitur definition of grace as...of all things.. a "sound"? St. Tim may talk about me "pushing toward the unobvious," but if you asked 1oo theology students to define grace with a fill-in-the-blank, a total of less than zero would answer
"sound." Even though it may be the definitive right answer.

How unobvious is Newton's answer? Everyone knows grace is (yawn) "undeserved and unmerited favor."

But Newton has been telling us all along it's about sound? IS sound?


One would think John Newton had been influenced by Bono's theologizing on "No Line on the Horizon" in 1748.

U2 has been quoting or referencing sections of "Amazing Grace" since...well, the first single of their first album:and singing snippets of the hymn itself in concert for
almost as long. Bono has called it nothing less than his all time favorite song.

But finally it is fully at home in the setlist, as the whole trajectory and "order of worship" revolves around sound itself.
---

To my amazement, the first two results (here and here)of a quick googling of the "Amazing Grace" lyrics coupled with "sound of grace" landed me on articles about the U2 record!

But who has researced what Newton chose the striking sound metaphor
(or the opposite of metaphor, whatever that is...one dictionary suggests that it is "anthropomorphism,"
"The ascription to the Deity of human forms or modes and of human feelings or moods, respectively...
A term used in its widest sense to signify the tendency of man to conceive the activities of the external world as the counterpart of his own.")?

Anyone know the story?

What did Newton hear that convinced him that grace was a Sound that saved him?

I have only found one guesstimate:

The opening words of the song are interesting; I do wonder what Christians make of them: "Amazing grace; how sweet the sound ..." Why sound, and not feeling or experience?

.. It would seem from Newton's careful, clever lyrics that his experience, too, was triggered by a sound -- likely that of the ship's bell or foghorn.
-Tom Armstrong



In the meantime, one should read (or better yet, listen to) two of the books I have already namechecked:



Which brings us full circle to the coupling of "Amazing Grace"/Where the Streets Have No Name."

The latter is usually interpreted (albeit too simplistically, but not inaccurately...see this) as "about heaven."
And therefore about sound.

Huh?

It's Webb who traces a tradition...all the way back through Augustine, and implicity yet intrinsically in Scripture itself...that the fundamental "sense" of heaven is indeed sound.

And since ultinately "Where the Streets" (see this) is about not (just), but heaven invading earth in the here and now..

Such is also the theme of the entire "No Line" CD..
and accompanying tour
(
"In this innovative sacred space setting for a live music event, U2 turn out to be channeling thhe Son, the sound, and Williams/Owens mixing a Lumière that lets us in the sound in a new way.")

No wonder they were considering "sound spotlights" for this tour.

How else would one incarnate the sound of grace, and let is into said sound?

Sounds good.

Sounds like grace.

Thy Sound come.
Thy Grace be done.
On the streets of earth
As it already is in heaven.

"...all great music gives us a sonic foretaste of heaven by translating salvation into a musical key. All imagination is born out of the desire for eternity, but as much as the imagination transforms our desires, so will heaven transform our imagination. Heaven will not be contrary to what we imagine of it, but it will exceed our imagination to an inconceivable degree. In heaven, the divine voice will no longer be carried along by vibrations of air but instead will travel at the speed of grace, and it will sound amazingly sweet."
-Stephen Webb, "The Sound of God: Supersonic Theology and the Future of Public Speaking"


Oh how we need on earth before we go to heaven, an eschatological inbreaking of imagination, jumpstart on justice, and the Shematic hearing of God's heavenly Voiceprints.

It's we who walk in grace and are grace, that are and incarnate the "grace...and sound greater than... and beyond the noise" (Sammy Rodriguez's phrase ):

"What does the sound of grace sound like ? ...Jesus is the Resurrected Songwriter of the new song..We go beyond the music, beyond the noise, beyond the volume..

Grace has a sound..YOU are the sound of grace."
-Rodriguez, "Are You a Third Day Christian?" , pp 108; 117








Tuesday, January 20, 2009

new U2 song: The Sound of Watchman Nee's Girly Boots From the Future

Of course, many want to know what I think about the new single by

The answer, as always, has to be a combination of

1)I love it (I mean, it's U2. There's only one song of theirs I really don't do)
2)I don't know yet (I am just now beginning to appreciate the first single from the last album in a new way!!)

Some thoughts so far on "Get On Your Boots," before debuting (for a few of you) the audio and lyrics at the bottom of the page:

1)Glad for the new vibe..and/or old vibe.
The many comparisons to "Actungopapop" (90s U2),
as well as Dylan's "Subterrannean Homesick Blues," Elvis Costello's "Pump It Up"
and (unfortunately) an old song many are claiming it was lifted from.
.
are all partly true..

but so are (partly) the comparisons to Talking Heads, Toby Mac (first thing my son said at the "Let me in the sound" outro) and ...(gulp)Brittney Spears..


2)Lyrically, it feels like..
among other things, as always..

prayer or pray-able
(which the last section spells out).

Maybe it's a prayer that we would be open to how God is wanting to use any who desire to be used...

particularly prophetic women....

in this next season of the world/wineskin/economy/emergence to move us beyond culture wars, gender wars and literal wars ("wars between nations)."


On the women leading the way, I amen it
(see "Banning Women/Missional Chicks");
I think the whole song might even be midrash on Bono's speech to the Women's Conference :

...but I do lament that "sexy boots" can sound, well, sexist. I think however, the sexiness is related to Bono's frequent comments about the unsexiness of justice issues and social action...
I guess if one issues a call to war against war ("Sunday Bloody Sunday" as a violent/militant anthem to peace/pacifism, etc etc), the best image/imagery to invoke must be subversive, too:

war boots aren't usually sexy.
On the boots, this post I did was a spoof, but I can't help but wonder of Bono was tracking with the Isaiah 9:6 use of boots.

I am intrigued by the seguing/splicing (Beth is hilarious here: "It's the JEDP theory of U2!")
onto the end of it the whole "Let me in the sound/God, I'm going down/drown" psalm of supplication.

onto the end the whole "Let me in the sound/God, I'm going down/drown" psalm of supplication.
Matt McGee has called attention to the drowning man motif throughout the U2 canon; Beth picks it up here:


I had never seen that article on drowning imagery by Matt, and it's quite interesting. It also brought the line "lookin' for a sound that's gonna drown out the world" to the forefront of my mind -- there's another abstract "sound" like the one in the GOYB chant, and "drown" is right there both times. Whatever that means.

I have a theory, as I think you know, that the title "Drowning Man" is a Watchman Nee reference drawn from a memorable use of drowning as a spiritual image in his "The Normal Christian Life." Would be interesting to see how Matt would factor that one in to his article.
Beth



I have to wonder how many U2 songs are still wrestling with his mom ,
Jesus, Shalom, and Watchman Nee.
Maybe as many as all.
The "sound" to me is:

  • the musical sound Bono has often mentioned "looking for a sound to drown out the world."
  • a reference to string theory ("The universe is at base, sound/music" (Len Sweet), and thus:
  • a cry to be let into God's sound/voice/strings at its very creation, core, and chaotic creativity. (see "The Divine Voice,"an amazing theology of sound, and Sweet's seminal "Summoned to Lead"). Perhaps we can only hear/see God's voice/sound when we pray/act in holy synesthesia...some amazing biblical precedence there.
This "sound" prayer may well be the answer to Switchfoot's complaint that in our day and age, "Nothing is Sound."

Satan loves to drop bomb and soundscares here,
but they can't scare godly men and sound women.

In the sound of God's sound,
even in the deep waters of a sound (as in "Long Island Sound") one is drowning in,
everything is sound.

Let me in, too.

By the way that "women of the future" seem to get God's sound/revelation.
of course,
such women are fundamentally FROM the future
(see emotional music from a creative future,
and
THE KINGDOM’S RETROACTIVE RETROFUTURE: SEND ME MORE ARROWS

and recall Bono's African prophecy (the only I time I find where Bono specifically claimed to be prophesying) about/from the future:

I'm an artist not a politician. But I prophesy that what was once impossible is possible. I prophesy that I will probably drink one too many red wines this evening. I'm sure, maybe, some people might dance on the tables.

'I prophesy that a day is coming when there will be no HIV.

'I prophesy that this jewel of a kingdom is soon to become a giant.

'Colin Powell once said that the greatest weapon of mass destruction is a virus called HIV. But no WMD could break the spirit I feel in this room. God is in the house, I feel.'

.. 'The future is here. Didn't you feel it?'
link

That prophecy may well be what "Boots" is all about fulfilling.
On to the song (official lyrics and audio here):

The future needs a big kiss
Winds blows with a twist
Never seen a moon like this
Can you see it too
Night is falling everywhere
Rockets at the fun fair
Satan loves a bomb scare
But he won’t scare you
Hey, sexy boots
Get on your boots, yeah
You free me from the dark dream
Candy floss, ice cream
All our kids are screaming
But the ghosts aren’t real
Here’s where we gotta be
Love and community
Laughter is eternity
If joy is real
You don’t know how beautiful
You don’t know how beautiful you are
You don’t know and you don’t get it, do you
No, you don't know how beautiful
You don't know
You don’t know how beautiful you are
That’s someone’s stuff they’re blowing up
We’re into growing up
Women of the future
Hold the big revelations
I got a submarine
You got gasoline
I don’t want to talk about
Wars between nations
Not right now
Hey sexy boots, yeah
No, no, no
Get on your boots, yeah
Not right now
Bossy boots
You don’t know how beautiful
You don’t know how beautiful you are
You don’t know and you don’t get it, do you
No, you don't know how beautiful
You don't know
You don’t know how beautiful you are
Sexy boots
I don’t want to talk about
The wars between the nations
Sexy boots, yeah
Let me in the sound
Let me in the sound
Let me in the sound, sound
Let me in the sound, sound
Let me in the sound
Let me in the sound
Let me in the sound, now
God, I’m going down
I don’t wanna drown now
Meet me in the sound
Let me in the sound
Let me in the sound
Let me in the sound, sound
Let me in the sound, sound
Meet me in the sound
Get on your boots
Get on your boots
Get on your boots
Yeah hey hey
Get on your boots
Yeah hey hey
Get on your boots
Yeah hey hey
Get on your boots
Yeah hey hey

Tuesday, March 17, 2009

U2's "No Line": 4 motifs-part 4: walk by sound, not by faith



Bookmark and Share
"The heavenly motions are nothing but a continous song for several voices (perceived by the intellect, not the ear), a music which, through discordant tensions, sincopes an cadenzas as it were (as men employ them in imitation of those natural discords) progresses towards certain pre-designed quasi six-voiced clasuras, and then sets landmarks in the immeasurable flow of time."
-Johannes Kepler, "Harmnice Mundi," 1619

"particles defy time and space..so does music"
-Joseph Ege
"Time is irrelevant, its not linear."
"Let me in the sound, God.."
-U2, "No Line on the Horizon" 2009

The many references to sound on this album have been noticed, here is a great summary from St. Beth:


As has been pointed out already, it seems clear to me that "the sound" is one central metaphor. We have three "let me in the sound" requests, as well as "I found grace inside a/the sound" and "people born of sound," all of which have an essentialist, palpable ring (especially if you want to argue for a vague John 3 echo in the last one.) Along with these, there are more evocations of sound per se as granting some kind of mysterious access to the ultimate: "hear the universe," "roar on the other side of silence," and "the rhythm of my soul... that yearns to be released from control." And don't forget this album's ineffable soundscapes themselves, such as the one that begins "Unknown Caller." Because of all that, I am more inclined to understand "sound" in NLOTH as pointing to mystical communion with God now, rather than as looking forward to songs sung by others in heaven.

While we also get several specific mentions of people themselves vocalizing ("Sing your heart out," "I was born to sing for you," "listen for me, I'll be shouting") it's the sense of sound as sacred essence that intrigues me here, as if Pop's "looking for a sound that's gonna drown out the world" quest has been fulfilled in a sound-baptism by immersion on NLOTH...
-U2Sermons



Many, including my badself, have connected the dots to Sound Theory/String Theory/God.

"The universe at base," Sweet suggests, "is sound."


"particles defy time and space..so does music"
-Joseph Eger, "Einstein's Violin: A Conductor's Notes on Music, Physics and Social Change,"
p. 39, 214.




This is not just cute Bono-isms, and clever ideas...it is the stuff Nobel Prizes are made of:

"The music of the spheres," is an amazing line from a classic hymn, but also sound physics.
Dazzle yourself with Nobel-Prize winner Frank Wilczek's "Longing for the Harmonies: Themes and Vibrations From Modern Physics. Soundtrack it to U2.

Please.

But I want to pick up a line in "Moment of Surrender" that may not be obviously connected to the sound motif.

It's about sight and seeing.
So it must connect synesthesiastically.

How obvious is that.



"We walk by faith, not by sight."

Does that mean we walk by blind faith?
Well, yes.

But robbed of sight, we can call upon an even more fundemantal and "sound" sense:

sound; hearing.

Pure synesthesia to walk by sound.

And watch...I mean, listen, to what Jason Stellman picks up here:

Following Scripture, Reformed theology has always placed great emphasis on the ear over the eye. The gospel is called by Paul "the word of faith," a message that produces belief "by hearing the Word of Christ." The opposite of faith, of course, is not doubt but sight. A person is most faithless, therefore, not when disbelief is mingled with his belief, but when he demands to see, to experience, to feel the truth before he'll believe it. "We walk by faith," says Paul, "and not by sight."


Go ahead and roll your eyes, but I maintain that Bono understands this.

...his theme is prevalent on their new release, No Line on the Horizon, as well. In the song "Moment of Surrender" Bono sings:

At the moment of surrender,
I folded to my knees;
I did not notice the passers-by,
And they did not notice me.

At the moment of surrender,
Of vision over visibility,
I did not notice the passers-by,
And they did not notice me.
True surrender, in other words, can only happen with "visibility" is relinquished.
-Jason Stellman



Bono has discussed the "vision over visibility" line:

"Moment" includes a phrase that's close to sacred for Bono: "vision over visibility". ...Bono: "It's like Martin Luther King's speech - the moment when you see the place, but you can't see yet how to get there."
-Rolling Stone
This is another angle on
"By faith, Abraham left home, completely clueless about where he was going'
. Heb 11.8"


We have "no compass; no map," but "uncertainty can be a guiding light" (As Bono sang in Zooropa). The catch is this holy uncertainty of the faithwalk is caught by pleading with God, the Source of all Sound, to be let into the sound. The Sound of the Spheres, the Sound of Music, the sound we were borne of.

The one who has ears to hear, let them hear.

Or at least read another Pulitzer Prize-winner, Douglas Hofstadter's classic,
"Godel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid."

At bare minimum, hear a soundbyte from it
and souncheck and soundtrack it to U2.

Tha author finds nothing less than an "eternal braid" or "strange loop" in Bach's music,
which is both linear and nonlinear, as well as suggests that "time is irrelevant":


"Bach wrote in the margin of his 'Canon por Tonos,'
'As the modulation (sound) rises, so may the King's glory.'
To emphasize this canon's potentially infinite aspect, I like to call this 'The Ever-Rising Canon.'
..And perhaps to experience that sense of wonder and awe is more satisfying than having an answer...at least for awhile."
-p.10, 548



Tuesday, March 10, 2009

U2's "No Line": 5 meta motifs (and a sign from God)-part 1




"But I don't want to say "hello,"
YOU are supposed to take the initiative, and greet me first!
That's why I'm here."

That's what I said to myself today at the
drive-through today, upon seeing this sign:



I understand the reasoning; for some reason (not enough video camera coverage?),
the workers at this fine restaurant are not omniscient, and may not take the initiative to speak first.

But they are supposed to!

I just googled to see if this is a common phenomenon,
and found the post "Perspective From a Long John Silver's Drive-Thru Cashier":


My experience working at Long John Silver's was a marvelous year. I actually learned a lot about fast food....sake, read and learn what not to do or say to cashiers.... Another thing that is considered one of the rude things at drive-thru is to act like no one has waited on you. For example: "Thank you for choosing Long John Silvers, how may I help you?" Then the customer might just ignore you or say "give me a minute". That's alright, but when ready to order never say, "Hello?" or "Anybody there?". The cashier will most usually not like you after that. Elderly people are sometimes excused for hearing problems. The most annoying thing that has happened to me is when customers knock on the window, and more than once is really bad...
link
Yeah, not only is it wrong, but rude for me to yell "hello" to the magic box.
"I am ready to order," I said.

A minute later, the voice boomed,
"Are you ready to order?"

They never heard my initiative, anyway!


What does all that have to do with the new U2 CD?
If you grant the cheap analogy, as much as everything:

One could make the case that the whole message of "No Line on the Horizon" is:
the Kingdom has come to earth, but not yet fully so yet....
therefore, even though we can expect glorious experiences of God breaking through,
it won't always feel like God's voice is taking the initiative...
even though it does.
If only we could more consistently tune into it. "Let me in the sound, God."

I would like to look at the trajectory and narrative arc of the lyrics...and significantly, the images and music, the sound through these theological grids;

-the sound of God
-divine initiative
-spiritual stillness
-the nonlinear nature of life and spirituality
-now and not yetness


These motifs need to be plotted ("plotting some plot," as the cop in "No Line" schemes) on a Venn diagram, they of necessity overlap and are ocasionally synonymous.

Of course, a Venn diagram, by definition, subverts linearity, as the lines overlap.

And well follow up on my drive-through illustration under point 2 (I just can't be linear).

1)THE SOUND OF GOD:

Even before the album was released, I was guessing from the single ("Get On Your Boots")
and it's "let me in the sound" prayer of persisteverance that this would be a permeating theme:


The "sound" to me is:

  • the musical, mystical sound Bono has often mentioned: "looking for a sound to drown out the world."
  • a reference to string theory ("The universe is at base, sound/music" -Len Sweet), and thus:
  • a cry to be let into God's sound/voice/strings at its very creation, core, and chaotic creativity. (See "The Divine Voice," an amazing theology of sound, and Sweet's seminal "Summoned to Lead"). Perhaps we can only hear/see God's voice/sound when we pray/act in holy synesthesia...some amazing biblical precedence there.
  • link
It turned out to be! Not only does the "let me in the sound" invocation show up three times ("Fez,"), we also hear that Bono (or his character in "Breathe") has "found grace inside a/the sound" (Beth brilliantly suggest the "a/the"), and hear that we are indeed "people born of sound." THAT is excellent string theory!

“Acoustemology..an exploration of sonic sensibilities, specifically of ways in which sound is central to making sense, to knowing, to experiential truth. "
-
Feld


"It's time church leaders developed a philosophy of soundness, even a sound spirituality..

..One doesn't see a vison, one sees a vision."

-Leonard Sweet, "Summoned to Lead"

That last line is loaded, and introduces us to an interpetretive key to the album...and to life:

Jesus had holy synesthesia and wants to infect us with it!

For several years now, U2 have been rumored to feature on tour
breakthrough holosonic technology--"sound spotlights."

We in the church have often been more concerned with sound doctrine and sound mind
(good and godly things), but at the expense of a sound theology of sound.

-"Let me in the theoacoustic/holosonic Sound, God




And how we even forget to remember to pray the prayer to be let into such sound..

And this leads...in fairly linear fashion, amazingly, to theme #2:

2)DIVINE INITIATIVE:




"I was born to sing for You/I didn't have a choice but to lift You up"
("Magnificent").
How "Calvinist" is that?
Maybe Bono was predestined to have free will"
Or maybe Wesley was right:
"Freedom of the will? Ha! Free only to do evil."

Isaiah (chapter 6) heard the sound/voice of God: "Who will go for me?"
The unsolicited (unless God always shows up, and sounds off, when Uzziahs die, and we turn contemplative in the temple) "auditory vision."
The Holy Sound spoke first.
As per the norm.
The Holy Sound sounded as if he were willing for anyone listening to be the chosen responder.
As per the norm and form of divine initiative.

Samuel (I Sam 3) heard the Sound/Voice three times.
The unsolicited (unless sleeping in the church, as young Sam was doing, was invitation enough to God's voice) call came at night.
The Holy Sound took clear initiative in the beckoning.
He always does.
The Holy Sound even risked being misheard as the voice of the only human/very human priest/pastor (Eli).
He always does.

John on Patmos (Rev 1) , with a wild case of "holy synesthesia"
turns to "see the voice" of Jesus.
How does one see a voice?
He must have at some point taken the initiative to seek God's initiative.
He was a Calviminian.
As is God.
That is sound theology.


The "Unknown Caller" places an unsolicited (unless being a desperate person is itself an invitation for Someone to speak) call to the character in the song of the same name.
There was "no signal at all,"
or was there?

It should go without saying that the "3:33" time reference in the song is a reference to what Bono calls "God's phone number":

"Call unto me, and I will tell you great and magnificent things that you do not know"
-Jeremiah 3:33

Divine initiative. Even though it appears that we make the first call,
it's really a call back.
All calls are.
All "calls from home" are.

One should dovetail in here tme mind-bending, and time-bending
Isaih 65:24: "Before you call, I have already answered"

Wow, is that divine initiative, or not?.
It also suggests that "time is irrelevant; it's not linear."
But that's another album lyric.
And topic #4 (I'm ahead of myself).
But suffice to say the Kingdom of God by definition
IS time travel.
See "Time Travel: Sabbath Novels, Clockless Monasteries,Toyota Corollas and the Gospel of the Kingdom"




God is longing to meet us in the sound, but we miss out wait for him by sight.
And we never see the voice that speaks:
"Shush now...Rise up...Shout for joy...Restart...You're free to go"

I am making the assumption here, and throughout the album, the group singing/chanting (or other than U2 voices)
sections signify that the speaker is God. This helps immensely, in interpreting, for example, "Return the call from home" in "Cedars of Lebanon."

The call home /Home is always a return call.
Home has always called first.
Divine initiative initiates.
The Sound can do no other.
Of course, many will pick up the biblical reference in the title of "Cedars of Lebanon":

The voice (sound) of the LORD is over the waters;
the God of glory thunders,
the LORD thunders over the mighty waters.
The voice (sound) of the LORD is powerful;
the voice of the LORD is magnificent.
The voice (sound) of the LORD breaks the cedars;
the LORD breaks in pieces the cedars of Lebanon.

-Psalm 29: 3-5


That Soundstorm is radical divine initiative.
The Sound of Yahweh is like that.
Breaks cedars, breaks wills.
Not necessarily against our will, but sometimes without it.
Whic is precisely why "this shitty world sometimes produces a rose"
Even in Lebanon.

Even when someone/Someone knocks on your door...an unsolicted solictor...with the promise to reveal "three things that'll keep you alive." ("Breathe").

Why would I "let a complete stranger(like that) into my home?"

Unless...

3)SABBATH STILLNESS:


"Sound confronts us with interiority, Craig Matson suggests,"To hear is to relinquish our place as sovereign spectators and managers in the world and to position ourselves in medias res as morally obligated and mortally vulnerable hearers of the word."

Bono free-associates his thoughts on the album:
"Lifeforce, joy, innovation, emotional honesty, analogue not digital, home-made not pro-tooled, unique sonic landscape... Soul music for the frenzied, rock music for the still."


How does one "teach me to surrenferbe still"
How do the frenzied get to "shush now"?

By sabbath.

Which is also time travel.
Time is that irrelevant.
The Sabbath is made for
time travel,
not time travel for the sabbath.

But unless we

"Hear (God)/Cease to speak/That (God) may speak,"
we cannot "Hush now."

Such is the corporate, corporal voicesound/soundprint of God in "Unknown Caller"
Which is also paraphrase of Psalm 46:10.

But what of Caller-God's advice to "Escape gravity"?
Simple (!) and sound physics again.
The relationship between space/time curvature and gravity is well known.
But why let all the physicists have all the fun.
Maybe
Christianity as a branch of physics,
after all.

It's only as we get out of our zone/realm/earthly kingdom that we hear/see the cedar-smashing sound of God's future voice now. In such times, for all practical purposes, there IS no line (linear or otherwise)
on the horizon.

"The minute I think of Christ and myself as separate,"Luther preached, "I am sunk."

Sunk: "God, I'm going down/I don't wanna drown/Let me in the sound Sound"

Kierkegaard tells a parable:

"A man thought prayer was talking to God.
Then he prayed.
And he discovered prayer was God talking to him."


Even if the "grace inside the sound"of the voice is;

"shush now."

Time to time-travel and sabbath-travel via Kingdom-listening prayer:

Judaism is a religion of time aiming at the sanctification of time. Unlike the space-minded man to whom time is unvaried, iterative, homogeneous, to whom all hours are alike, quality-less, empty shells, the Bible senses the diversified character of time. There are no two hours alike. Every hour is unique and the only one given at the moment, exclusive and endlessly precious.
Judaism teaches us to be attached to holiness in time, to be attached to sacred events, to learn how to consecrate sanctuaries that emerge from the magnificent stream of a year. The Sabbaths are our great cathedrals; and our Holy of Holies is a shrine that neither the Romans nor the Germans were able to burn; a shrine that even apostasy cannot easily obliterate: the Day of Atonement. According to the ancient rabbis, it is not the observance of the Day of Atonement, but the Day itself, the "essence of the Day," which, with man's repentance, atones for the sins of man.
Jewish ritual may be characterized as the art of significant forms in time, as architecture of time. Most of its observances--the Sabbath, the New Moon, the festivals, the Sabbatical and the Jubilee year--depend on a certain hour of the day or season of the year. It is, for example, the evening, morning, or afternoon that brings with it the call to prayer. The main themes of faith lie in the realm of time. We remember the day of the exodus from Egypt, the day when Israel stood at Sinai; and our Messianic hope is the expectation of a day, of the end of days....


The meaning of the Sabbath is to celebrate time rather than space. Six days a week we live under the tyranny of things of space; on the Sabbath we try to become attuned to holiness in time. It is a day on which we are called upon to share in what is eternal in time, to turn from the results of creation to the mystery of creation, from the world of creation to the creation of the world.
-Rabbi Abraham Heschel.
"Shabbat as a Sanctuary in Time:The Sabbaths are our great cathedrals, the Jewish equivalent of sacred architecture."

-for the story of the photo, see: "raging chutzpah, sabbath elevators, bibliolatry and missionality"
It has been suggested that the first notes keyboard flourish and then the achingly beautiful Crazy Horse meets Gilmour guitar solo that conclude "Unknown Caller" intentionally echo the hymn"How Wonderful, How Marvelous (My Savior's Love For Me)."

I wouldn't be surprised.

It's the sound of music; it's the Aslan-ic "roar on the other side of silence."
("Breathe)

ON TO
4)the nonlinear nature of life and spirituality
5)now and not yetness

NEXT POST TO BE CONTINUED


Friday, March 20, 2009

U2's "No Line" part 5: a sound epistemology of faith in God, not in certainty

“It is not the place but the Presence that upholds you; This is your only certainty.”
-Erwin McManus


REM's Michael Stipe, who in this delightful video clip, finds music
--his own and U2's--
  • "epiphanal,"
  • a way out of "stasis"
  • and catalyzer of a quest to "keep learning...and not know everything" (his words in this clip) ,

seems to intuitively trust and know what it's like to be
be "borne of sound," "find grace within a sound," and to pray "let me in the sound"
(all Bono's words from "No Line" CD lyrics);

Of course, this is still the same message as the vintage:
"You know I believe it, but I still haven't found what I'm looking for."

It is wonderful to watch Stipe and Chef Mario Batali, with hands raised as to The Magnificent
as they enjoy a stageside view of U2 in the full worship flight section (3:10) of "Beautiful Day."

Stipe's zeal to "keep learning...and not know everything" rings resonant with Ty Tabor(of King's X)' s spoof of certainty:

All plans and knowledge and the reason for the war
Every mark and movement in the crack upon the floor
One day, any day, the time before the dawn
All knowledge brought before scattered on the lawn
I know everything

(spoken):
So, weak and tired and looking for the key?
Well look no further, you've just run into me!
We'll walk beyond that door, we'll love and dance and sing
Last time I looked around, I knew everything
I know everything
-link


And, to the point, also one of the undercurrents of "No Line":

  • "But while I´m getting over certainty/Stop helping God across the road like a little old lady." ("Stand Up Comedy")
  • " Two souls too smart to be in the realm of certainty" ("Moment of Surrender")


Why have we (especially the 'we' still emerging from modernity/fundaconservaagelicalism)
crafted such an idol as "certainty"?

Don't we grasp, like St. David Dark's new book title:
"The Sacredness of Questioning Everything?"




?

"If you were to die tonight, are you absolutely certain you would go to heaven?"

Is it possible to have complete faith in Jesus, in salvation by grace through faith, and answer with the one word that is everyone's answer if they were ever honest:

"No."

Uh, I know that's not the expected answer.

And maybe it's too extreme and subversive..

But doesn't something within you relate to TonyJones' classic quote to Rev. Fundaconservagelical below:


And doesn't something within every evangelical want to agree with Jeff Keuss:
{the album suggests that] liberty is found in faith in God rather than in a certainty about God..
From Bono’s call to “get over certainty” in “Stand Up Comedy” to the acknowledgment in “Moment of Surrender” that we are “too smart to be / In the realm of certainty,” the role that faith should play is clearly contrasted to the modernist (and ultimately failing) search after certainty. In this reminder, which frames much of the album, the fact that we find our fulfillment as human beings in a relationship of faith rather than intractable certainty means that we find our hope not in our limited selves, but in the God who created us...
As Bono continues the verse, he decries choosing knowledge and will power over faith when he sings, “While I’m getting over certainty / Stop helping God across the road like a little old lady.” This double challenge—(1) dropping the search for certainty in favor of faith amid the intelligent design debates and (2) allowing God to, well, be God—becomes the liberating truth for the protagonist of the song.
-link






Anne Lammott nails it: "The opposite of faith is not doubt, but certainty.' This actually unleashes our epistemology to be more of what evangelicals have always claimed they are about: relational (there is a reason the KJV translated "Adam knew Eve"), as well as what we have feared it was all about: risky.

John Wimber even advocated spelling faith "R I S K."

But also it's time to consider approaching epistemology (and faith) as sound-activated, sound-sourced, sound-tracked, and as
connecting our head to our heart and life via a sound theology/experience of sound.

Do the math:

"We walk by faith, not by sight." (2 Cor 5:17):
It's "not by sight," so the "certainty of what we see" is moot (and "mute").

Better to trust and intuit from what/who we HEAR...in the sound:

"Faith comes by hearing...":

It is far too reductionist to equate this with preaching, as some Reformed folks suggest.
It's much deeper, wider; and more nonlinear and quantum than that.
It's not only that we are born/borne of sound, but that we "walk by faith, which is blind, but operates and activates by sound."

We walk by sound, not by sight; and never by certainty.

The Scripture does not/cannot say, "Do you not know; have you not seen?"
Instead, the formula is far more sound:
"Do you not know; have you not heard.."

"Know" and "hear" are here placed in a Hebrew poetic parallelism, suggesting they are largely synonymous.

!!

"I turned to see the voice of Jesus," John wrote of his Patmos experience (Rev. 1:13).
"I will watch to see what the Lord will say, Habakkuk (2:1-3) journals.

I noted from Bono's recent interviews that the "vision over visibility".. line has long been part of his lexicon and life: "It's like Martin Luther King's speech - the moment when you see the place, but you can't see yet how to get there."


But I was recently reminded that the phrase traces as far back as his "Introduction to the Psalms,
where in another parallelism, equates/translates "vision over visibility" as "instinct over intellect":

Explaining belief has always been difficult. How do you explain a love and logic at the heart of the universe when the world is so out of kilter with this? Has free will got us crucified? And what about the dodgy characters who inhabit the tome known as the Bible, who hear the voice of God? Explaining faith is impossible: vision over visibility; instinct over intellect. A songwriter plays a chord with the faith that he will hear the next one in his head.

"Faith that he will hear..."

Faith hears.

It's all about sound.

And instinct over intellect.

Epistemologically, this is certainly not about certainty.

If that's the case, we don't know anything unless we refuse and defuse intellect and sight as we know it, and trust our blinks, The Sound... and synesthesia;

indeed, could it be that we live by, incarnate, and at heart are sound:

By framing the human condition musically (“We are people borne of sound”) rather than imminently (winners of “the DNA lottery”), and by embodying hope, faith, and love rather than purveying some objective doctrine that merely affirms those traits, U2 is calling humanity to a comedic revolution par excellence. As music, we embrace a kenotic release from the fixation of self and are freed from isolation and estrangement. As song, we see ourselves as imminent and transcendent, neither bound to this world nor the world that is yet to come. The protagonist in “Get on Your Boots” kicks at the door of the music (“Let me in the sound”), and this refrain is repeated as a sample in the musical prelude for “FEZ—Being Born,” but as the album begins to close, “Breathe” reminds us that this “sound,” this liminal mystical union with that which never fades and is sustained on the voices of generations, is what we are to the very core. We are beautiful, we are sound, and ultimately, we are loved.
-Jeff Keuss, link
When my brother and I were in college, for a leadership class, he had to navigate a whole day
around campus blindfolded. The intent was empathy for the blind, realizing reliance on others, and...well, "getting over certainty" because he literally needed help crossing the road.
I helped him like a little old lady.

I remember attempting to help him drink the juice during a chapel communion, and our attempt to hold back our laughter as he accidentally slurped a bit. The memory of that sound, and the remembrance of my irreverent (? I wasn't even a Christian yet) quip, "tastes good, huh?," ..but mostly my recall of the poorly suppressed laughter moves me to this day.
Bruce had to rely on sound and others.

So do I.
So do you.
So do U2.

That is a certain statement of faith.

Kierkegaard often gets the last word around here:


Thus everything is assumed to be in order with regard to the Holy Scriptures--what then? has the person who did not believe come a single stop closer to faith? No, not a single step. Faith does not result from straightforward scholarly deliberation, nor does it come directly; on the contrary, in this objectivity one loses that infinite, personal, impassioned interestedness, which is the condition of faith, the ubique et nusquam [everywhere and nowhere] in which faith can come into existence.
Has the person who did believe gained anything with regard to the power and strength of faith? No, not in the least; in this prolix knowledge, in this certainty that lurks at faith's door and craves for it, he is rather in such a precarious position that much effort, much fear and trembling will indeed be needed lest he fall into temptation and confuse knowledge with faith. Where as up to now faith has had a beneficial taskmaster in uncertainty, it would have its worst enemy in this certainty. This is, if passion is taken away, faith no longer exists, and certainty and passion do not hitch up as a team.

-Soren Kierkegaard,
Concluding Unscientific Postscript to Philosophical Fragments
lifted from Tommy's blog

--





* U2's "No Line": 5 meta motifs (and a sign from God)-part 1:
http://davewainscott.blogspot.com/2009/03/u2s-no-line-4-motifs-part-1_10.html




o U2's "No Line": 5 meta motifs, part 2: non linear and no yet:
http://davewainscott.blogspot.com/2009/03/u2s-no-line-5-meta-motifs-part-2.html




+ U2's "No Line": 5 motifs-part 3: she spoke in tongues in my ear:
http://davewainscott.blogspot.com/2009/03/u2s-no-line-4-motifs-part-3-she-spoke.html



# U2's "No Line": 5 motifs-part 4: walk by sound, not by faith:
http://davewainscott.blogspot.com/2009/03/u2s-no-line-4-motifs-part-4-walk-by.html

Monday, February 16, 2009

let me in the theoacoustic/holosonic Sound, God


“Acoustemology..an exploration of sonic sensibilities, specifically of ways in which sound is central to making sense, to knowing, to experiential truth. "
-
Feld


"It's time church leaders developed a philosophy of soundness, even a sound spirituality.
-Leonard Sweet, "Summoned to Lead"


It might have been just my U2intuitiveness,
but as you can tell by my post when the first single of the upcoming album came out
it felt like the "let me in the sound" outro/prayer in that songs was somehow more than a spliced tag-on at the end of one song (2:28ff in the clip). It felt like the lyric (and the sound) was something larger; perhaps a metanarrative/motif/midrash for the whole CD/tour/season.

And now we hear (literally here, play the third song) that the "let me in the sound" lyric is looped into another song ("Fez-Being Born") or two, and may well be the name of the upcoming tour (the tour itself is rumored to feature breakthrough holosonic technology--"sound spotlights," if you will--that well, let listeners into the sound).

And now we read that the song "Breathe" includes the line
"I found grace inside a sound."



"'Let me in the sound'" is a repeated lyrical motif .. The theme of the album is surrender." - Neil McCormick

How does sound connect to surrender?
"Sound confronts us with interiority, Craig Matson suggests,"To hear is to relinquish our place as sovereign spectators and managers in the world and to position ourselves in medias res as morally obligated and mortally vulnerable hearers of the word."
-Craig Matson

For a student of acoustemology/theo-acoustics, theology of sound, this is engaging stuff.
Of course, the core premise of string theory is that life/God are at core, sound. That sound is somehow the most fundamental sense is suggested by scientists worldwide.
I just finished teaching a leadership class centerpieced around Leonard Sweet's amazing sonogram/book,
"Summoned the Lead"{Chapters one and two online here}.

I often return to Stephen H. Webb's loaded "The Divine Voice: Christian Proclamation and the Theology of Sound."

But my life is soundtracked by U2.

We in the church have often been more concerned with sound doctrine and sound mind (good and godly things), but at the expense of a sound theology of sound.

God is longing to meet us in the sound, but we miss out wait for him by sight.



In the song "Unknown Caller," (of which McCormick offers,
"Words and music dovetail in surprising ways that send the senses spinning."),
the lyrics include:

"Escape yourself/and gravity/Hear Me/ cease to speak/ that I may speak/Hush now."




Bono free-associates his thoughts on the album:

"Lifeforce, joy, innovation, emotional honesty, analogue not digital, home-made not pro-tooled, unique sonic landscape...
Soul music for the frenzied, rock music for the still."

Only the still hear/see/are let fully into the Sound of the sonic landscape.

"Let me in the sound sound
God I'm going down
..Meet me in the sound"

Thursday, July 23, 2026

U2's Theological Imagination: A Guide For Pilgrims on the Way"


In this case, the title alone-- "U2's Theological Imagination: A Guide For Pilgrims  on the Way"-- would have sold me on buying the book.



But that the author is Steven Harmon?  That clinched the deal.  Harmon, Professor of Historical Theology at Gardner-Webb School  of Divinity is (see p. 9 for "U2 as Theologians)an articulate theologian and deep fan  of U2.

He definitely has some ground beneath his feet, and the authority to write this book.

As you can see, it  sits on the honored top of my stack and stash of books this month...




"My own academic discipline of systematic or constructive  theology helps me discern in U2's music the theological framework of Christian doctrinal convictions about God, creation, the human condition, redemption  and the goals of God's community-making work in a world that longs for reconciliation." (pp. 3-4)

Suffice to say this is not a pop-culture , superficial .. let alone "tacky and vouyeristic" ...mass-market title on U2 and their faith.

Having said that..

I didn't  expect  to see my name on the first page (:

There, in the acknowledgements (p.ix), he expresses indebtedness to "rewarding conversations  about  the theological implications of U2's music ...[with]  Scot Calhoun, Cathleen Falsani, Derek  Hogan, John Inscore Essick, Beth Maynard, Will McDonald, Mark Medley. Tim Neufeld, Angela Pancella, Kenneth Tanner, Dave Wainscott and Andrew William Smith."

Well, as you can see by the mentions of several of those names on my blog, and on my Facebook, that is would be  dynamic cohort to hang  with for a few days! Next U2 Conference, hopefully! ...

.. As long as Megan Click is also there! Her wonderful review of U2's "Easter Lilly' blew me away, and I will brag on her and that in my next post.

Harmon's  book is of course an indispensable addition to the library of theologically-minded U2 fans, and I will commend the Amazon preview and reviews to you at this link, and simply  highlight here  two vital talking points...both related to The Edge...  from the first two  chapters  alone.



1) Edge's eschatological guitar

My brother and I, who first saw U2 in concert on the convert on War tour, (see my review "I am still living off this concert" , and see this  to check how electric it was ), and we  have often talked about  "The Holy Spirit on guitar!"  when listening  to The Edge's "swirling epiphanies," There are others who seemingly pray through their guitar, but no one emotes it like Edge,

 Harmon's discussion of a  more specific branch of theology, eschatology,  illuminates how Edge is a theologically-informed guitarrist/pray-er:


".. ['Gloria'] exemplifies what I've come to regard as theologically significant about The Edge's very tone: the amp pushed just to the edge of breakup without going fully over into distortion, expressing an urgent stretching forth toward something not quite reached, contrasting with those ethereal chiming harmonics that break in from somewhere transcendent. Both come together in this next song, The first verse voices frustration at efforts to sing, and stand up, and speak up that don't quite succeed, accompanied by a riff that's the rock guitar equivalent of a Baroque keyboard fugue, played with that yearning overdriven tone. Then comes the inbreaking of those transcendent chiming harmonics...(p.5)

-------------------

"The word that comes to mind when I try to come up with language for the sound of a U2 song is  yearning ..the music itself evokes yearning."(p. 6)

----------------------------

"The reign of God is at hand and people have the opportunity to participate in it in the here and now, but it is not yet fully realized ar cannot become so without the participation of people in the rein of God. This tension is the key theological concept for understanding the spiritual significance of the whole of U2's music.

"...n the formative years of the band, U2 even found a way l express this tension through the distinctive instrumental sound they created. U2 remythologized the open-fifth power chord that eschews both major and minor thirds as a way of musically maintaining the eschatological tension between the now and the not yet...

..I. say that U2 "remythologized" the open-fifth power chord because, as one of my guitar-playing theology students noted when I mentioned this to him, the power chord commonplace in guitar-based rock music is by definition a root note, its fifth, and the octave of the root. But The Edge's rationale for utilizing this chord structure is theologically, in particular eschatologically, significant. When the neither-major-nor-minor fifths were combined with The Edge's frequent playing of ethereal-sounding chiming harmonics , his distinctive use of the delay effect not as an atmospheric effect= with trailing echoes but as a compositional technique to create notes that are not directly played but are integral to the music, and clean guitar tone overdriven to the edge of breakup without turning fully into distortion evoking urgency, the result was the yearning sound of the already/not-yet tension of Christian eschatology translated into the idiom of post-punk rock music."  (pp 22-23)


-----------------------------------------------------------

-2)Edge's   Pádraig Ó Tuama and Methodist connections

"I've been reading a lot about the early period of Methodism...and George Whitfield who was..the first evangelist to take his sermons out doors," said the Edge to Pádraig Ó Tuama

Wait..what?

Double take..

How had I ever missed that Edge had been interviewed by  Pádraig Ó Tuama?
And that in the process, he expressed great interest in early Methodist DNA? (see"Wesleyan Vile-tality: Reclaiming the Heart of Methodist Identity")


Two of my favorite topics.

Methodism is my heritage and tribe, and that Edge ( "the "Zen Presbyterian") had been reading about it--- let alone " a lot"--- made my day...a lot.



And of course no surprise that fellow Irishmen  and fellow theologians O'Tuama and Edge (see p. 9 for "U2 as Theologians) got together and got  along.


I have been using a song (below)  of O. Tuama's  in teaching and seminars for years, a shocking (to evangelical sensitivities, anyway) song of lament (complete with F word ) for years.


I often wondered if O'Tuama knew U2.

I learned all this from Harmon's magnificent book (p.10). 

-----------------------------------

All that to say, as a pilgrim on my way, I highly  commend and recommend..

nay, require..this book,

Suffice to say I am thankful for the theological imagination of pilgrim Steven Harmon himself.








  
here



\