Showing posts sorted by relevance for query doug pagitt. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query doug pagitt. Sort by date Show all posts

Wednesday, October 03, 2007

Hang Up and Drive, Jerk!!


This is what many drivers see daily , accompamied at times by
a rude gesture that amounts to "half the peace sign."

Problems is, most drivers who see this sign or bumper stickers
are not guilty parties.



Doug Pagitt, contrasting "speeching" with "preaching":

"Speaching" is a violation of what we know about building relationships. Speaching isn't the normal way to talk or listen, and it isn't the normal way to build trust or community. It is,in fact, best suited for promoting a generic message for a generic audience. I was recently driving behind a car with a bumper sticker that said, "Hang Up and Drive".. it struck me that far more people who aren't using cellphones while driving will see that sticker every day than those who are on the phone...I found myself saying I"'m not even on the phone.. Why a re you giving me instructions that have nothing to do with my situation" ..When the content of the sermon is created in the isolated setting of the pastor's mind and study and is delivered to whoever happens to show up that Sunday, it has all the impact of that bumper sticker..
-Doug Pagitt, Preaching Reimagined, pp. 82-83

Amen.

and reminds me to let Earl Creps remind me to only prepare sermons in a "secular"place...in the presence of "the sought." Otherwise, all they will likely hear if they do show up is:




I gave that kind of speaching up for Lent and for good.

I hope.

Thursday, May 13, 2010

Thursday, January 15, 2009

simulacra-kklesia (part 11): Doug Paggitt, two Trinities, & my encounter with St. Paul Newman on the road to Emmaus

At Ashram, The Really Real Rev. St. John McFarland
(who stars in his own music video here) showed us this "really real...really" video of Michael Jackson's facial morph over the years, as a call to really pray for the man:



The I haven't had any tuckings or liftings.

But I





am tempted to dab some permanent marker over the (four) grey hairs on my goatee.

If the Bible has wonderful and commendable things to say about them,
why can't I just let them be?

I want to paint them black.

Because I fear death;
or better yet, being old.

Because I like you to think I am younger than I am;
not older than I like to think I look.

I want you to (virtually) like me.

I forget to remember that you'll like me better if I'm real.
That I might even look younger if I quit putting on the simulacrap.

In college, I wrote a satirical essay on machismo, which got picked up by an independent newspaper; I'll see if I can find it..
It featured a guy who taped on fake chest hair.

I don't do that.

But I virtually do.



Besides, if I cut the goatee altogether, I won't look like other hip emerging church types
(assuming they don't glue theirs on).

Like Doug Paggitt.
I need to hang with him, like Matt Cleaver did:

I have read plenty of blogs and magazine articles about Solomon’s Porch and their lead pastor (not sure what his real title is) Doug Pagitt. I thought this would be a cool opportunity to see in real life all that I had been reading and hearing about, and it was honestly pretty much what I expected: quite anticlimactic and ordinary. And I mean that truly in the best way possible.
Obviously when I say ordinary I don’t mean mainstream. When you walk into the Great Room (think sanctuary) and see it filled with tons of couches all arranged pointing towards a couple of stools sitting in the middle of the room you realize that the environment is anything but typical church fare.
When I say that the Sunday Gathering is ordinary and anticlimactic I mean that the community and leadership embrace a super-flat ecclesiology. Lines between staff and laity seem blurred, and there is no such thing as a celebrity...

.. You’ll see what I mean in a second.
So, here’s the play-by-play. There are about 12 or so of us from the seminary who decide to go to Solomon’s Porch, and of course we don’t want to be late, so we arrive obscenely early. We walk into the Great Room and walk right past Doug Pagitt, who is sitting on a couch chatting with someone. We all sit down together in a little corner, and are pretty much the only ones in the room besides those who are preparing for some part in the gathering. Yeah, we don’t stand out at all.
Doug finishes his conversation and comes over to us and introduces himself, “Hi, I’m Doug.” I think to myself, Wow, he is really big. He acts like your typical guy and does the whole small talk thing, asking us what brings us there, where we’re from, yada yada yada...

If you ever get a chance to go to Solomon’s Porch, it’s obviously worth your time if you are familiar with the emerging church, if for no other reason that to realize that the heavens do not open when Doug sits on his stool. It’s amazing how anticlimactic innovation appears. Maybe the everyday and the extraordinary are anything but.
Maybe there’s hope for your church after all.
link



Actually, the heavens DO open
precisely when the heavens DON'T open
when the preacher does his or her thing.
That is precisely the point and paradox.
The Lord Be With You...Even When He’s Not"

Kerry Soper, in his chapter (p. 59) in "U2 and Philosophy," notes of "Even Better Than the Real Thing" that "the song concludes that the lover, rather than fleeting, hyper-real images, is the real thing--or even better than the real thing."

Being the real thing is even better than the real thing.
If there is such a thing.

That's not just blowing smoke;
it's taking Baudrilllard, Bono and the Bible at their (supra-)logical extreme.




I had intuitively felt there was a connection between simulacra and wanderlust.
(painted brilliantly in Johnny Cash/U2's "The Wanderer," and the entire "Zooropa" CD)
Mark Sayers helped me catch the connection . It's easy to see how the simulacra of our culture causes us to desire to be something we're not; but there is also the inevitable extension:
wanting to be somewhere we're not.

This is a cousin of the elusive idolatry of place,
and what Howard Snyder calls the church's edifice complex.
We are more concerned with real estate than our real estate.



Sayer's book about hyperreality is called "The Trouble with Paris."
I am sure he enjoys the fact that most assume the title refers (just) to Paris Hilton.
But she is not mentioned in the book.
The title refers to a nameless young lady the author met, who seemed was consumed (due to simulacra of media) with moving to Paris, France:


"All she had to do was travel and find new friends and a new job to experience life as it was meant to be--exciting, stimulating and meaningful.

Six months later I received an email from this girl. She was now in Ireland. Paris was not all she had expected.".
(22)


No place ever can be.

Television, film, movies, church..they all lie; they cannot not.

Especially if church services are televised.

"It's very nearly impossible to tell the truth in television..If I write a novel, signed by my name, I am saying these are my thoughts...and the response of the reader is according. If you set up a camera and take a film, that is not considered anyone's views, that is reality"
-Muggeridge, "Christ in the Media, p. 60


In addressing antitodes to simulacra, Sayers suggests

" we are estranged from the concept of wisdom"(174).

He goes on (175) to offer that
"The medieval spiritual writer Theresa of Avila had a powerful metaphor to describe the effects of choosing sin over wisdom" :

her famous journey through the interior castle.

The catch is this was not a mere metaphor in Teresa's part,
it was a vision, an experience, encounter..

a real reality.

Like visions are.
Like vision is.




"I have a dream; I have a vision..television!!,"
Mac Phisto once preached.

No, not that vision.

The real vision.

Teresa was not just a "medieval spiritual writer,"
she was a mystic visionary who was after something/Someone better than the real.

Sayers also almost suggests that an ancient Christian doctrine, rightly envisioned,
is key to subverting simulacra:

Trinity.

In a a helpful section,
"The Hyperreal Christian Trinity,"
he offers this chart of our counterfeit trinity:



He doesn't explicitly address how a theology of the trinity should and could inform and form almost everything we do, say and pray as church.

So get next to some pioneers who do:
Len,

Moltmann,

Frank Viola,

The Shack,

and inevitably,


Bono.

Here's Len:

"is it possible to articulate an enduring missional theology apart from the Trinity?
And the answer to that I believe is"no."
-comments on Tony Jones post, Is the Trinity optional?


Call it/them what you will,
but can we dare to believe there is something so inherently relational
that all of life is really relational and intrinsically

trinitarian?

Three-Personed?

Trinity might even be our only model for church..
.(and computers, by the way).

If...if....
we finally embrace our full humanity.

Like the Second Member of the Trinity did.

Like I do, when I don't black out my gray goatee hairs.

We do indeed bear the image of the Trinity in and through the assumption of our humanity in Christ. The imago trinitatis is always and only the imago Christi.
-link, Inhabitatio Dei

Via our humanity.
Our real rugged, authentic and actual, bathroom-going and glorious human-ness.

Do we have any role models on this quest to just be human?

Many of those mentioned (Doug Paggitt, Bono)
and many not mentioned above(Bruce Cockburn, Mike Yaconelli)
are consistently themselves,
insistently human.

But one final helper.
One who died not long ago,
but bridged Hollywood simulacra and real humanity..


No, I don't mean the equally deserving Johnny Cash,who, like U2 in Zoo TV, brilliantly subverted simulacra on a medium prone to simulacra:




I'm talking someone of whom it was said:

"closest thing we've had in a movie star to a saint—and probably he'd say that was the dumbest thing he'd ever heard, which as far as I'm concerned is more proof."

Paul Newman.

?

I once went shopping with Paul Newman.

!!

Actually, we were both shopping at a rural outdoor fruit stand/shopping plaza in Connecticut.

There was not a bodyguard in sight.
Just Paul Newman, a real live human being,
about to cross my path
No one else around.

I said hi.
He smiled graciously and said, 'hi."

We walked our separate ways.

His famous blue eyes were haunting.

Of course, they may not have been real; he certainly had enough money to simulacra them up.

But he was, on that road, the real thing.

A delightful memoir from "CBS This Morning":



Paul Newman has died, damn it. He was the closest thing we've had in a movie star to a saint—and probably he'd say that was the dumbest thing he'd ever heard, which as far as I'm concerned is more proof. I'm not just talking about the hundreds of millions he earned for charity with his Newman's Own products, or his persistent but judicious political activism. As an artist, he was self-deprecating, often deeply self-critical; he never assumed we'd love him because he was, you know, Paul Newman. When directors built him pedestals, he worked to earn his place on them. Early in his career, he studied the Method, but he never went in for the fumbly-mumbly self-plumbing that became its hallmark. He always threw his attention onto the other actors—which might be why, opposite him, so many became stars and won awards. Everyone looked brighter in his light.
The light came from those blue eyes, of course—but it wasn't just their color that was hypnotizing. Two of his most vivid performances were in black and white: the self-loathing pool-hall drifter in The Hustler, and the mean-drunk, oversexed sleazeball rancher in Hud (probably his sexiest, most magnetic turn—but who can choose?). Newman didn't use those eyes promiscuously, as jeepers-creepers peepers. He hooded them, slit them, closed them tightly in pain. When open, they were sky blue with a milky haze. You could get lost in them; you could also see that he was sometimes lost behind them. Trim, smooth, chiseled, pretty, Newman was physically our most wide-open movie star, yet on one level he was also our most unfathomable...
...Newman was ambivalent about his prettiness, but he didn't make a show of fighting it: He never slapped on a fake nose or did a Quasimodo turn. (His voice—gruff and increasingly gravelly—balanced out his looks somewhat.) He was good in wounded Adonis parts (as in Cat on a Hot Tin Roof), but he was better with a shot of self-satire.

...Great actors and great artists don't have to be role models in life to inspire you with their work. But when they are, they give a special kind of joy. The character of his life is everywhere in his work, in its lack of self-centeredness, in the way it radiated out. In sad days and sunny ones, Paul Newman bathed the world in blue.
Paul Newman's Light





Joan Collins:
I remember once at a party, we played a rather morbid game where we all suggested our own epitaphs.
Beer in hand as always, Paul quipped: 'Here lies Paul Newman, who died a failure because his eyes turned brown.'

link

Monday, July 05, 2010

I need to go to bars more often

Note: i had a post up here, which quoted Adam Walker Cleaveland and Doug Pagitt.
But I decided to delete it until Doug's book comes out (really look forward to it), as I just saw this post from Doug (even though it's uncertain whether the post is a joke or not)

Tuesday, October 07, 2008

"Salvation on the Small Screen": 24 hours of Christian TV/crack

2015 update: Years after this post, I am linking to it for some students, who I assigned to watch a half-hour of Christian TV, and post about their experience in the comments, noting what is the view of Jesus/church /Kingdom being communicated.


He stroked his goatee pensively, and offered:

"Hmmm...well, it's kind of like being on crack."

(note: if you'd rather watch than read this story, click the video below)

He wasn't trying to offend (he did); he was simply responding to the question,

"What do you think of the Gaithers?"

I'll never forget the look on the Gaither fan's face. She assumed he meant something like it was a downer, or a "bad trip."



But what the  goateed-man  meant was:

"That whole culture..the Gaithers and other TBN type music and studio sets..it's just so foreign to me that the only analogy I have for entering such a parallel universe is being on crack."

The TBN experience can indeed be addicting ...in the sense of intriguing.

And some of it can be downright sickening.

(Someone..you'll guess who in a minute,,,,once said,"I reject wholesale the gospel of prosperity, primarily on the grounds that I'm pretty sure it makes Jesus throw up a little but every time he thinks of it").

Some of the memories my wife and I have of catching fleeting glimpses of TBN and other Christian TV include crack-like moments like Tammy Fae Bakker interviewing an armless woman...and asking her how she puts on her makeup; and Robert Tilton (who makes a delightful appearance in this classic Steve Taylor song, "Cash Cow") spouting out "Someone is called to give a million dollars to this ministry;don't think about it, don't pray about it...just call in!"...followed by a long outburst of tongues to confirm the word.

I have a hard time with many of these shows; but I have to dare to believe God is using some (all?) of them, even if the personalities are crazy, sick, fake..

...or  just on crack.

So I was thrilled to hear that my favorite sarcastic Lutheran (who is more tattooed than our guitar player St. Guinness) had been asked to write a book ("Salvation on the Small Screen? 24 Hours of Christian Television"by Nadia Bolz-Weber) about the experience of watching 24 hours of Christian television (in the company of some wonderful hand-picked friends)..TBN, to be exact.

I must have prayed for her the moment I heard she had the job. (:

Buy the book already...here's the link.

Some of my favorite writers and thinkers have blurbed the book in a helpful way; and if you are any kind of regular around these parts, their words alone will sell you the book....read Mike Morell, Doug Pagitt, Craig Detweiler and Becky Garrison's back cover comments, then come on back...





Since we are mostly on the same page around here,  rather than offer an extended review or commentary, I will mostly quote some of the author's  zingers and theological insights.....Often they are the same thing! (Which makes her very much like Jesus...).

As hilarious as the book is (it exceeded even my high expectations here), I found it not only appropriately respectful (some will disagree...maybe even the author!),  but hugely helpful in many "serious" ways...

...largely because of the "crack factor." One of Nadia's friends, as they watched "Breakthrough with Rod Parsley, commented:


"I don't even know if I live in the same universe as this guy."


First of all, on the whole theme of "Kind of like being on crack/another planet" being a learning point, as is any cross-cultural immersion:








"My full immersion into the world of TBN and a Christianity that can
seem it's from another planet entirely, rather than strengthening my confidence
in the sufficiency of my own tradition, has actually weakened it. I see the
holes.


I hope this shift continues for me because it feels like for so very
long the sects and denominations within the church (including my own) have spent so much energy defending their theological, doctrinal and liturgical
purity that they have been unable to see what it is we actually have to
offer one another..


..(Though for the record, I still think Paula White is a nut
job)."



(p.104)




Nadia is razor-sharp and spot-on in calling out and countering Paula White's outrageousness in a hilarious section reminiscent of Chris Seay's taking on of Rev. Bucco (see "Pastor sends Sodomites to island; gets stoned"):

"Two can play at this game,my prooftexting sister."(p.14)

But note the prooftexter is a sister.
Who is my neighbor, anyway?

"I, too live in a lavish lifestyle funded by the giving of the faithful, and this realization is discomforting. It is undoubtedly the plank in my own eye" (p.67)

It is her humility and wit that grant her authority to note out loud and in public things any of us have noted privately:

"though I'm no medical expert...(John Hagee) may possibly be bloated on his own hate(p.35)"

"Rod Parsley's voice is undeniably 'Southern TV preacher,' but it sounds so deeply affected that it's like he's actually making fun of himself."(39)

"(items for sale) the likes of which Liberace would find gaudy" (99)

"(One preacher's) particular level of clean-cuteness makes Pat Boone look like Sid Vicious"
(p. 107).


And how could you not note the strikingly high percentage of Old Testament references, and almost nonexistent mentions of the name of Jesus (!) ..except as a "talisman"..in the 24 hours so meticulously journaled and recorded? That call-in prayer lines were sometimes not available?

How is  that"The 700 Club" ends in the same way as "Romper Room"? (that section alone is worth the price of the book).


All pastors of churches larger than 100 people or 22 pews (recognize the reference?) have (hopefully) struggled with the false intimacy of knowing their flock, and vice versa. I have written on that here. ..But watch this:







"What disturbs me about this so-called love between Joyce Meyer and her TV
viewers is this is not pastoral care. You can become a
ministry partner and give Joyce Meyer your entire measley pension, and
she's still not showing up with a casserole when your mother dies."
(28)








Any readers here will likely agree that it's not about title and status... but one still has to ask
about all these folk introduced a "Dr." on TBN.....with honorary doctorates from Oral Roberts University, or less.

"I find myself getting a tad indignant about people taking the title 'pastor' much less 'bishop' with all the consideration and credentialing one might use choosing a chat room screen name." (12)

And that it's not about simply saying the Name. But why did it take 60 Minutes and a Sarcastic Lutheran to add things up?:

"If reference to Christ, even in passing, is the standard for calling something Christian, than I'm not certain someone the likes of Joel Osteen or Paula White or John Hagee would qualify."(82)

"So why is the art of Thomas Kincaid...in so many evangelical homes? Is it simply due to the fact that he signs his paintings with John 3:16? If so, you have to give it to him, because regardless of how aesthetically questionable it may be, there is an implied righteousness to a Thomas Kincaid painting, and that righteousness is highly marketable.

"I'm fairly certain that the descriptor 'Christian' when applied to music and TV shows is not an indicator of theological content but instead points to what is absent:profanity, homosexuals, liberals, uncertainty--basically anything that would challenge a particular worldview."


I have often said (just kidding, but I will now) that God loves us so much as the church that he has given us four categories of people and things to unconditionally learn from, and glean God-insights from:







profanity,





homosexuals,





"liberals,"





uncertainty.








At one point, a Christian celebrity "sits on a garish sofa talking about how Jesus is better than nightclubs, which is, of course, a false dichotomy. I believe in Jesus and nightclubs,or even Jesus in nightclubs, but that's another story" (133)

The unfortunate fact that that indeed is "another story" altogether for Christian television...and evangelicalism in general...is a big story indeed.

If you can't amen that, you are on the wrong blog....and you won't like the book, either.





So buy it already.



Finally, I must say Bolz-Weber's passing insights about simulacra (12, 56), which at first glance appear as easy jokes....are incredibly helpful. This is territory that Ian Robertson picks up regarding U2's intentionally ironic and subversive (ahhhh,big difference) use of this method (Chapter 6 in "U2 and Philosophy").

But the catch is TBN is not Zoo Tv.

Or is it?


"Do these folks really believe what they are saying?..If (not), then the question becomes: Is that sort of fragmentation of the self possible to maintain? Can we really project a false self for so long
without psychically necessitating an accommodation in the form of assimilation? Wouldn't one, in order to survive, have to start believing it?

Therefore, I think they believe it because they don't believe it and the only way to maintain not believing it is to believe it.

Simple enough."

(p.135)








Indeed.





Simply profound as well.





Funny!





And scary..





What's on T.V?

Who's on crack?
--
2015 update: Years after this post, I am linking to it for some students, who I assigned to watch a half-hour of Christian TV, and post about their experience in the comments, noting what is the view of Jesus/church/Kingdom  being communicated.

Sunday, May 27, 2007

Way Too Much Fun...Click Away

just the latest posts on "Shift Happens"(www.3dff.com/php):





Wednesday, January 12, 2011

We don't see things as they are..

"We don't see things as they are,
 we see things as we are."
 -Anaïs Nin
(quoted in Doug Pagitt's wonderful "Church in the Inventive Age," p. 73


When I first saw the quote, I thought it said, 'we see things as we were."  That will preach, too.


More Nin quotes:

  • "Life shrinks or expands in proportion to one's courage."
  • "Love never dies a natural death. It dies because we don't know how to replenish its source. It dies of blindness and errors and betrayals. It dies of illness and wounds; it dies of weariness, of withering, of tarnishing."
  • "We don't see things as they are, we see them as we are."
  • "If what Proust says is true, that happiness is the absence of fever, then I will never know happiness. For I am possessed by a fever for knowledge, experience, and creation."
  • "For me, the adventures of the mind, each inflection of thought, each movement, nuance, growth, discovery, is a source of exhilaration."
  • "It takes courage to push yourself to places that you have never been before, to test your limits, to break through barriers. And the day came when the risk it took to remain tight inside the bud was more painful than the risk it took to blossom."
  • "How wrong is it for a woman to expect man to build the world she wants, rather than set out to create it herself."
  • "Creation which cannot express itself becomes madness."
  • "Shame is the lie someone told you about yourself."
  • "We don't have a language for the senses. Feelings are images, sensations are like musical sounds."
  • "The body is an instrument which only gives off music when it is used as a body. Always an orchestra, and just as music traverses walls, so sensuality traverses the body and reaches up to ecstasy."
  • "Something is always born of excess: great art was born of great terror, great loneliness, great inhibitions, instabilities, and it always balances them."
  • "The role of a writer is not to say what we all can say, but what we are unable to say."
  • "The possession of knowledge does not kill the sense of wonder and mystery. There is always more mystery"

Saturday, August 01, 2009

Of course it opens a door to heresy...do it anyway!




If penguins are "open source," when will we sheep catch up?


Every so often, one hears the concern that churches with more open-source, participatory sermons
open themselves up to heresy.

Of course they do.

But they also open themselves up to what God is saying through the ministers.

I love University Chrsitian Fellowship; especially their classic tongue(s)-in cheek "order of worship (see "Virgin Sacrifices...That's "postmodern" worship!"):

We like to share the wealth. Seeing as most of our ministers with bible school training got it via mail order, we don't feel that hearing from God is something only one of them can do. Everyone in our church could potentially be sitting on a great sermon, so we like to let everyone get a chance to speak. So we have a five minute slot. Occasionally we get some weird discourse on helicopters and UFO's, but 99.9% of the time or more it is a good message.
link

Doug Pagitt, in "Preaching Reimagined," comments on this at least three times:
  • There are those who assume that if more people are allowed to share...then there's a greater risk of the church losing truth. But the history of heresy shows it's most often the abuse of power--not an openness of power--that creates envirins ripe with heresy. The church is at greater risk of losing its message when we limit those who can tell thes story versus when we invite the community to know and refine it. (43)
  • When I've talked with other pastors about progressional preaching, their concerns are almost always about heresy..They're concerned all hell--literally--will beak loose. I understand this concern. As pastors we spend years in theological training...(so) we won't toss out crazy ideas about God to the masses...But I've found this concern to be unfounded. Far from pulling us in the direction of heresy, including collective conversation in our sermon time has in many, many instances led to greater understanding....and actually prevents the heretical thinking so easily found in individuated expressions of faith. When people set their ideas on the table, thoss who might lean towards heresy or idiocy are quickly called out by the group (53-54)
  • We may not agree with the conclusions people draw, but we're better when we're moved to additional ways of seeing the world (137)
And Tony Jones, who attends the church pastored by Paggit, comments that 99 percent of churches don't let just anyone talk...



“..but because anyone, including Trucker Frank, can speak freely in this emergent church, my seminary-trained eyes were opened to find a truth in the Bible that had previously eluded me.” -Tony Jones, The New Christians, p.92
That truth emerged in a discussion of Matthew 18's "treat the unrepentant brother like a tax collector or sinner.":
"And how did Jesus treat tax collectors and pagans?" Frank asked aloud, pausing, "as of for a punchline he'd been waiting all his life to deliver,"....., "He welcomed them!""

More on Trucker Frank here; he can interrupt my sermons anytime..

Monday, April 12, 2010

official list of heretics...add your name!

I am honored to appear on Rev. Steve's blog, listed with other heretics and "false teachers" (Brian McLaren, Len Hjalmarson, and Bono).

But Lew Graff of Revolution has done the Body quite the service: he has helpfully compiled a list of people and organizations considered heretic/heretical:

....After seeing many of the names on the list, I went ahead and added my own name to the list just to be on the safe side. We'll see if I lose any sleep over it. Feel free to submit your own name if you'd like me to add you to the list. The sites are Lighthouse Trails and Apprising Ministries, but I like to call them Load of Crap 1 and Load of Crap 2.
-Lew Graff, link

  • Alpha Course
  • Rick Warren
  • Awana
  • Bruce Wilkinson
  • Youth Specialties
  • Brennan Manning
  • Rob Bell
  • The Pope
  • Catholicism
  • Brian Mclaren
  • Dan Kimball
  • Tony Jones
  • Erwin McManus
  • Mark Driscoll
  • Zondervan
  • Doug Pagitt
  • Bill Hybels
  • Moody Bible Institute
  • Eugene Peterson
  • Bob Coy
  • David Crowder
  • Billy Graham
  • Mennonites
  • Beth Moore
  • Max Lucado
  • Donald Miller
  • Tony Campolo
  • Campus Crusade
  • Michael W. Smith
  • Newsboys
  • Jeremy Camp
  • Delirious
  • Phil Keagy
  • Rich Mullins
  • Baylor University
  • J.K. Rowling
  • Tim Lahaye
  • Chuck Swindoll
  • David Jeremiah
  • Kay Arthur
  • World Vision
  • Leonard Sweet
  • Phillip Yancey
  • Josh McDowell
  • Luis Palua
  • Greg Laurie
  • NavPress
  • Intervarsity
  • Christianity Today
  • Relevant Magazine
  • Lutherans
  • Episcopalians
  • American Baptists
  • Presbyterians
  • Methodists
  • Women of Faith
  • Oprah Winfrey
  • Emerging Church Movement
  • Emergent Church Village
  • Joel Osteen
  • T.D. Jakes
  • Ed Young Jr.
  • Southern Baptist Convention
  • Lifeway Stores
  • Mother Theresa
  • Quakers
  • TBN
  • Bono of U2
  • N.T. Wright
  • “Christ-Followers”
  • Rick Mckinley
  • Craig Groeschel
  • Andy Stanley
  • Mark Beeson
  • Lew Graff

Friday, May 25, 2007

Preaching Texts That May or May Not Be "About Preaching"


One of the joys of my life is facilitating classes for Ministry Skills Institute (an outreach of Grace Covenant)
and other groups.

I enjoy the MSI classes as pastors, missionaries and all interested folk come out for regional events that are seminary level, but decidedy practical and impartational.

As usual, my teaching can be (to mix metaphors) "out of the box and without a paddle." They call me (lovingly, I think) the faculty "Wildman"..

I think students for my next preaching class (It will eventually be called "Preaching in the New World", "The Event Formerly Known as Preaching" or something cheesy like that) will have the fun of picking a number from the list below, and then using the suggested pair of books for their research paper. Some pairs may be obvious: they dovetail, they contadict, they balance

each other theologically or lengrth-wise...Some pairs are unobvious and that's OK..it's holy randomnity...

...which is why I might allow "mix and match."

I am aware that I really wanted more authors of "color" (not mine, that is: ghostwhite) and/or international representation. Any suggestions would be appreciated.

----------------



1)"Countdown to Sunday: A Daily Guide for Those Who Dare to Preach" by Chris Erdman
and
"Re-Imagining Preaching" by Doug Pagitt




2)Haddon Robinson's "Expository Preaching"
and
Ralph Lewis's "Inductive Preaching"

3)"A Serrated Edge: A Brief Defense of Biblical Satire and Trinitarian Skylarking "
by Douglas Wilson
and
and
"Permission Granted to Do Church Differently in the 21st Century"
by
Graham Cooke and Gary Goodell




5)" A Conversation With Jesus" by Stephen Seamands
and
"Get Up Up Off Your Knees: Preaching the U2 Catalog" ed. by Raewynne J. Whiteley and
Beth Maynard


6)"Teaching a Stone to Talk: Expeditions and Encounters"
by
Annie Dillard
and
"Kingdom, Grace, Judgment: Paradox, Outrage, and Vindication in the Parables of Jesus" by Robert Farrar Capon

7)"Ministry in the Image of God: The Trinitarian Shape of Christian Service"
by
Stephen Seamands
and
"If You Want to Write" by Brenda Ueland/"On Writing: A Memoir of the Craft" by Stephen King

9)
The Shaping of Things to Come: Innovation and Mission for the 21 Century Church by Michael Frost and Alan Hirsch
and
"One Step Closer: Why U2 Matters to Those Seeking God" by Christian Scharen

10)"The Hidden Power of Electronic Culture: How Media Shapes Faith, the Gospel, and Church" by
Shane Hipps
and
and
"Plan B: Further Thoughts on Faith" , Anne Lamott

12)"Prophetic Imagination"
by Walter Bruggeman
and
"Rock Gets Religion" by Terry Mattingly

13)"Houses That Change The World" by
Wolfgang Simson
and "The Tipping Point" by Malcolm Gladwell








Saturday, March 31, 2007

Emergent Manifesto of Hope

Doug Pagitt and Tony Jones

"it's more than couches...it's how we view the world"


http://www.anemergentmanifestoofhope.com/

Tuesday, March 07, 2006

Inspiration of Scripture: Images over words


After I posted my sarcastic "First Church of Binitarian Biblioaters", I found that Len has helpfully cataloged some excerpts from Brian McLaren and Doug Pagitt
that will provoke us to further clarify the role of Scripture in these amazing days..

I will post some excerpts below to get started.


But first, confession.

I need to have compassion on folks who think we (whoever "we" are) are wimping out on Scripture...I can understand that accusation. I likely would have made it about myself ten years ago. (As Bono said after speaking at the Prayer Breakfast, "The me of ten years ago can't imagine that I am here now.")

Yet, if we are read correctly, we actually esteem and value the Scripture more than ever.

And the "me" that's "here now" is even more hungry for the Word; not less...as a result of what to some is mere semantisizing; but in actuality is a "super-sizing"
(and cirumcision) of the heart..

Years ago, (at a respected "Bible-believing" scholar's suggestion), I stared using the term "accurate" to qualify Scripture..
partly because it seemed a better microcosm; and partly to avoid the unnecessary missiles and missives of the "inerrant vs. infallible" wars that were raging in my evangelical circles at the time.

But perhaps what we need is not just a better word, but a bigger picture.

I heard a pastor at a wedding make sure he got in the "proper" view of Scripture, especilaly for the backsliders he was told were present. With each adjective his voice, volume and velocity (and hair!) raised: "Any Christian marriage must be based on the inspired, INFALLIBLE, INERRANT Word of God!"

Funny that those three qualifiers of bibical authority, from first to last, have been used in that order on the spectrum ("inspired" often meaning a very generic"liberal" inpsiration, like Shakespeare is inspired; "Infallible" being the moderate evangelical term of choice--meaning "without error", then "inerrant" cranks up the stakes, as the term implies "so without error that it's not even capable of erring." This of course being the litmus test term for conservative conservatives" or fundamentalists.

Of course we can use all three of these words about the Word, and still not live it out. (ironic: I heard that the very scholar who suggested the word "accurate" fell into an extra-marital affair and was defrocked.)

Or get the point: the picture.

E. Stanley Jones rightly discerns the "dividing line" between Christianity and other religions:

"But in them, the word became word, a set of teachings, a morality, a religious framework. Only within Christianity does the word become flesh. It's the word that became flesh, that offers human hope for mankind."


Jones was obviously speaking about the other "Word": Jesus. But Scripture also calls another entity "the Word": itself.

Fascinating that both Jesus and Scripture are called the word. And that Jesus is also called "The Image" of God (Colossians 1:15). Question: Why isn't Scripture explicitly called in Scripture that which it in a sense must be: the Image of God??

Or the "photo album" of God.

Somehow, the Word (Scripture) must also "become flesh."

Which inevitably means it must incarnate image.

Perhaps the portal to this enfleshing; this "imaging" of Scripture...is the primacy of image over word in our current culture; and to grasp that such is not "evil postmodernism" and enemny, but an embedded-in-culture God-watermark that can work in our favor:

In "The Rise of Image and the Fall of the Word," Mitchell Stevens proffers that we are living in a “communications transformation as fundamental as the introduction of writing 3,500 years ago.” Thus, the mileu of the future will increasingly be hallmarked by "the communication of meaning through moving images."

Hmmm, "meaning through moving images." Besides the obvious (movies, etc), this can also imply a new (old) view of Scripture.

Consider:

Because we have by today so deeply interiorized writing, made it so much a part of ourselves, as Plato's age had not yet made it fully a part of itself, we find it difficult to consider writing to be a technology as we commonly assume printing and the computer to be. Yet writing (and especially alphabetic writing) is a technology, calling for the use of tools and other equipment: styli or brushes or pens, carefully prepared surfaces such as paper, animal skins, strips of wood, as well as inks or paints, and much more. … Writing is in a way the most drastic of the three technologies. It initiated what print and computers only continue, the reduction of dynamic sound to quiescent space, the separation of the word from the living present, where alone spoken words can exist.
-Walter Ong, "Orality and Literacy: The Technologizing of the Word.


And file this:

...the invention of the printing press was akin to the invention of todays internet. Except in the reformation most people still could not read. This gave the preachers a practical authoirity over the dissemination of the word as they could read and they controlled the technology of the printing press.
The post-modern conundrum, often expressed as there not being a reverence for absolute truths needs to be refined in light of this technology. Its not that we do not have a belief in absolutes, it is that in the leveling of access in the technology almost all voices can speek with authority and get their word out resonably well. How then does one discern what is an absolute truth and what is somebody's well constructed paradigm?
But this belies our own initial prejudice formed by our westrern ideology, in that we have taken the Word, or Truth, whom God revealed as a person, and abstracted him into men's words Propositonal or absolute truths) to be known through men's words. The rise of preaching may well be understood as a triumph over the intended role of the Holy Spirit as the revealer of Christ to us.
(Mark Deraud, in posted comments on the 6th post down on this page
).

Of course, we preacher types seem to enjoy filling in for the Holy Spirit. And one of the most subtle yet sinister ways we do it, is calling in the Holy Bible to substitute/pinch-hit for the Holy Spirit....thinking that coaching maneuver will win the game...or argument.

But arguing died with modernism. And manipulating should have died in our baptismal waters.

Yes, we pastors...sometimes accidentally; sometimes intentionally..actually make too much of the Bible.


!


Jesus was inistent: "You search and quote the Scriptures because you think in them you have eternal life; but that's found not in a book--no matter how inspired it is-- but in me. The whole point of the Scriptrures are to floodlight me." (John 5:39).


We are to be a Christ-centered, not Bible-centered, tribe.

What is about to follow must not be seen as a judgement on the congregations involved; but merely a hope that we live more Christ-centered way than our lives (and website mottos) often suggest.



Googling is a helpful (but fallible!) tool for catching a pulse on the world/church..a quick search shows "Bible-centered" calls up 95,400 listings; while <"a href="http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=%22christ-centered%22&btnG=Search">"Christ-centered" yields 1,720,000
results. That's the right direction. Also good news is that
"Holy_Spirit-centered" yielded only 170 results, several of which were statements critcal of such a phrase.

I love J.I. Packer's image of the Spirit in relation to Jesus, traced in
"Keep In Step with the Spirit":

The Spirit's 'floodlight' ministry. Have you ever looked at a properly floodlit building, perhaps a castle or a cathedral? If the lights are correctly placed they illuminate the building and don't dazzle the watcher, who should hardly be conscious of them. The secret of good lighting is that you so not see the lights but what they are lighting up. In a similar way the Holy Spirit has a special role in drawing attention to Jesus, without drawing attention to himself (Jn. 16.14) 'The Spirit's message to us is never "look at me; listen to me; come to me; get to know me," but always, "Look at him and see his glory; listen to him, and hear his word; go to him, and have life; get to know him, and taste his gift of joy and peace."



A more heady theological concept for this is ontological subrdination, which is not exactlt what happens among members of the Trinty. Better yet, as
Moltmann and others coin it, the "economic trinity", affords us seeing the
mutual submision of husband and wife as parabolic for mutualal submission/ flooodlighting of members of the Godhead by other members.

Some futher resources? i was delighted to learn of

N. T. Wright's "The Last Word : Beyond the Bible Wars to a New Understanding of the Authority of Scriptture". .

One review
is helpful here:

Wright observes that most churches make strong statements about the centrality of scripture and its authority in the mission, life, discipline and doctrine of the community. However, there is no agreement on what this might mean or how it might be practiced. He describes how both evangelicals and liberals misread scripture, and he tries to restore the Bible to its rightful role as a guide for the church.

Wright believes we are asking some of the questions regarding authority in the wrong way. “How can what is mostly a narrative text be ‘authoritative’?” (xi) Authority, for Wright, belongs to God alone, and is now embodied in Jesus Christ. So, the question becomes, “What might it mean to think that the authority of Jesus is somehow exercised through the Bible?”

The authority of scripture must be understood as part of a larger divine authority.


And the "larger divine authority"? Musn't it begin with, if not end with The Holy Spirit, who is, by Christ's own admisson "the Source of All Truth".

Michael J. Chrisstensen summarizes C. S. Lewis's view of Scripture below. It will be shocking to any evangelical-trained types, adn I myself may not even buy all of it. But I think the last line is crucial to consider.

Scripture, to Lewis, is:

“human literature, divinely inspired and authoritative, but not verbally inspired or without error... He viewed some parts as 'more Inspired' than others. “The kind of truth we demand of Scripture, Lewis remarks in conclusion to this letter, ‘was, in my opinion, never even envisaged by the ancients.’” (11, 19)


Anyway,to the quotes promised at the top of the hour, with thanks to Len:


Excerpt from "A New Kind of Christian" by Brian McLaren: He replied, "The Bible never speaks of itself this way. You're the pastor; you should know-there are only two places I know of where the New Testament speaks of foundations-no three. In one case, the church is the foundation of the truth, and in the second, Jesus is the foundation of the church, and then there's a third, when Jesus told Peter he was the foundation. But unless I'm mistaken, the Bible never calls itself the foundation."

Well, you've got me there," I said.

He looked at me, perturbed, and said, "I'm not trying to 'get you,' man! Just a minute." Then, with no explanation of where he was going, he adjusted his faded red baseball cap and stepped off the path and in a second vanished into the forest undergrowth. I walked over to the edge of the path and strained my eyes to try to see him. A minute passed. Then two. I could hear the snap of breaking twigs moving toward the river but still couldn't see him. What was going on? I called his name once, twice, three times. No answer.

After the fourth time I called his name, he called mine: "Dan, over here, come here!"

I'm a bit nervous about poison ivy and snakes, but I gingerly pushed through the bushes toward his voice. When I saw him, my first thought was that he was relieving himself. He was standing perfectly erect, with his back toward me. Then he turned and motioned me to come closer. When I came up beside him, he pulled a branch aside to reveal a perfect web made by a huge yellow and black spider. "That's exactly what I was looking for, a common garden spider, Argiope aurantia," he said, always the science teacher. "But in spite of the "common" in their name, they aren't all that common. Beautiful, isn't she?" That wasn't the word that had leapt to my mind. "Let me ask you a question, Daniel. Where is the foundation for the home of this spider?" I replied, "Well, I guess it doesn't exactly have one. But it does have anchor points-like where the web attaches to that leaf and that branch and that branch there.

"OK," Neo said, "I think you can see where I'm going. What if faith isn't best compared to a building, but rather to a spiderweb? Instead of one foundation, it has several anchor points. Those points might be spiritual experiences, exemplary people and institutions whom one has come to trust, that sort of thing."

"But where does the Bible fit in?" I asked.
"Well," Neo replied, "it could be seen as one of the anchor points. Or perhaps every passage in the Bible that has affected your life could be seen as an anchor point. Or perhaps the Bible isn't only in the anchor points. Perhaps it is part of every thread of the web."

I wasn't satisfied. "But I think you're stretching things, Neo. I mean, why just pick a spiderweb as your model for faith? That seems kind of arbitrary, doesn't it?"

"No more than a building with a foundation, really. When you think about it, a spiderweb has some real advantages over a building It's flexible. It can be repaired when it is damaged. It functions as both a home and a tool for catching food. But if you don t like spiderwebs let's use a different model altogether. Let's take the earth. What's the foundation of the earth? What keeps the earth stable?"

"Well, it's not that simple," I said. "The earth seems to get its stability from a combination of things-its own momentum, the gravity of the sun; maybe even the moon and other planets play some role, I'm not sure."

"What if faith were more like the earth than a building? What if faith could never be stable in the way God intends it to be if it didn't have forward momentum and if that momentum weren't in the field of the gravity of God himself? And if you don't like that metaphor, think of a bird in flight or a bicycle or a ship on the sea. In each case, there's movement in relation to some larger forces and realities. Stability comes through an interplay of those factors. Stability is not always as simple as a static building sitting on a solid foundation. John Wesley-he was an Anglican, you know-understood this very well: he talked about the church deriving its stability from a dynamic interplay of four forces-what were they? Scripture, tradition, reason, and . . . what was the fourth? Oh yes, spiritual experience. Maybe," - and here he backed away from the spiderweb, knelt down again, and drew his line on the ground - "maybe both liberals and conservatives are working from a static model of authority and both need to be called to a higher point of view to see that our situation is much more dynamic, much more predicamental, moving up here instead of down in the dust."

Finally Neo stopped and said, "Maybe neither the liberals nor the conservatives take the bible seriously enough."

I almost laughed, "That's a good one."

"No, I'm serious," he said. One thing that both liberals and conservatives have in common is that they read the bible in...

Read it allhere




In the following chapter McLaren talks about Scripture, opening with the story of a friend who shared his disappointment that Brian had abandoned his high regard for the Bible. A shocked and hurt McLaren later received an apology. Standing where I stand today, I understand that story very well. I too believe that my regard for Scripture is perhaps higher than it has ever been, but it is very much different from the regard I had ten years ago when I was uncomfortable with, but still using, extra-biblical terms like "inerrant, infallible, objective, absolute, and literal." McLaren writes,

"Perhaps the best way to use Scripture is not to concentrate on it at all but rather to focus on our pursuit of mission. Then we will need Scripture to do what it was intended to do. This is exactly where Paul goes in his letter to Timothy..

"When Scripture talks about itself, it doesn't use the language we use... Hardly anyone realizes why these words are important. Hardly anyone knows the stories of Sir Isaac Newton, Rene Descartes, the Enlightenment, David Hume and Foundationalism-- which provide the context in which these words are so important. Hardly anyone notices the irony of resorting to the authority of extrabiblical words and concepts to justify one's belief in the Bible's ultimate authority.

Oddly, I've never heard of a denomination or church that asked people to affirm a doctrinal statement like this: The purpose of Scripture is to equip God's people for good works."

Read it all
here