Showing posts sorted by relevance for query assayas. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query assayas. Sort by date Show all posts

Monday, November 15, 2010

lust need not incarnate, but Love must inevitably do so, and "find form"


"Between the horses of love and lust we are trampled underfoot"
-U2's "So Cruel" via 2 Kings 9:33 (The death of Jezebel)
--------------------

Assayas: But you’re the singer and front man in a band, and it’s not just any band. I’m sure you’ve been tempted. Don’t you ever feel that no matter what you have decided [about fidelity to your wife], love needs to be incarnated? ...Think of groupies.

Bono: We never fostered that environment. If you mean groupie in the sense that I know it, which is sexual favors traded for proximity with the band.... Taking advantage of a fan, sexual bullying is to be avoided, but the music is sexual.... Sometimes ...the erotic love [we sing about] can turn into something much higher, and bigger notions of love, and God, and family. It seems to segue very easily from me between those.

Assayas: ...I’m surprised at how easily religion comes up in your answers, whatever the question is. How come you’re always quoting from the Bible? Was it because it was taught at school? Or because your father or mother wanted you to read it?
Bono:
Let me try to explain something... which I hope will make sense of the whole conversation. .I remember coming back from a very long tour.. On Christmas Eve I went to St. Patrick's Cathedral..It had dawned on me before, but it really sank in: the Christmas story. The idea that God, if there is a force of Love and Logic in the universe, that it would seek to explain itself is amazing enough. That it would seek to explain itself and describe itself by becoming a child born in straw poverty. a child, I just thought: "Wow!" Just the poetry. Unknowable love, unknowable power, describes itself as the most vulnerable. There it was. I was sitting there, and .tears came down my face, and I saw the genius of this, utter genius of picking a particular point in time and deciding to turn on this. Because that's exactly what we were talking about earlier: love needs to find form, intimacy needs to be whispered. To me, it makes sense. It's actually logical. It's pure logic. Essence has to manifest itself. It's inevitable. Love has to become an action or something concrete. It would have to happen.  There must be an incarnation. Love must be made flesh.
-Bono: in Conversation with Michka Assayas, pp. 119-120, 124-125



    --
    RELATED:
    =SEX LEADS TO ELEVATION

    All right, let’s get to the elevation of "Elevation, " because as you will recall, it’s the only path up to Vertigo (I promise we’ll get there!) . To my amazement and delight, I stumbled upon a stunningly insightful commentary on U2’s song (and therefore prayer about, and theology of) "Elevation." I guess I shouldn’t have been surprised, as theological analysis of U2 is all over the world and web. (Even as scholarly papers at the business meetings of the "I guess they’re not so square and stodgy after all" Evangelical Theological Society…Baptist PhD’s contemplating the theological catalog of Bono!) . But this particular piece grasped and grappled so well with what U2 are (in Bono’s phrase) "on about" in "Elevation, " and in general, I cannot anymore hear or pray the song without this review at hand. It has rocked my world, theology and prayer life. I had always intuitively felt the song was about, indeed was, prayer. But to definitively second that motion it took these words, which should be read slowly, and with "Elevation" playing softly (!) in the background:


    ...For the chasid, prayer is not something one recites, it is rather an exercise that one performs, or an
    experience that one enters into.... There is no room for inhibition...singing and dancing are essential means by which ...he expresses his emotional cleaving to God….but
    that desire for God has to be so overwhelming that any extraneous thoughts are excluded…If distractions are erotic in nature…and (one) faces up to the predominance of the sexual urge at both conscious and subconscious levels, and
    its capacity to intrude even during prayer...then he has learned to take measures…Chasidism dealt with this by introducing the doctrine of the "elevation of strange
    thoughts." This...technique not of sublimation, but of thought conversion, whereby the beauty or desirability of the woman is latched upon and used not as a sexual but rather as a mental and spiritual stimulus.... taught to "elevate" these thoughts by substituting the beauty of God for the
    physical beauty that is currently bewitching us. (The pray-er) has learned to immediately contrast the pale reflection of beauty that humans are endowed with, on the one hand, and the supreme Divine source of authentic and enduring beauty,
    on the other…
    link



    "This is not sublimation; This is elevation
    .
    ' Wow! Surely anyone who re-reads the lyrics to "Elevation," (or ventures and voyeurs a watching as Bono sings/prays/dances/incarnates it on concert DVD)
    , will surely fall at the feet and conclusions of the reviewer, admitting that he astoundingly accurate. And I (seminary grad!) didn’t even know until I found this review that "elevation" was the official name for an ancient and established style and form of prayer. Surely this is exactly what Bono is fundamentally "on about" in this song; even in wider life and mission. Just for starters, lets interlace the lyrics to the song "Elevation" itself, and the review thereof:

    Prayer is not something (Bono) just recites...it is an
    experience he enters into. There is no room for inhibition; singing and dancing are essential means by which he expresses his emotional cleaving to God….but
    such ardor/desire for God has to be so overwhelming("You make me feel like I could fly") that any extraneous thoughts are excluded…If distractions are erotic in nature…and (Bono) faces up to the predominance of the sexual urge ("I’ve lost
    all self-contol")at both conscious and subconscious("Digging up my soul/Going
    down/Excavation") levels, and its capacity to intrude even during prayer( "Tell me something true/I believe in You"")...then he has learned to take measures…by
    introducing the ancient doctrine of the "elevation of strange thoughts." This is a Chasidic not of sublimation, but of thought conversion,whereby the beauty or desirability of the woman(the corner of your lips/the
    orbit of your hips")is latched upon and used not as a sexual but rather as a mental ("I need you to elevate my mind") and spiritual("you elevate my soul") stimulus. We are taught to "elevate" these thoughts by substituting the beauty
    of God for the physical beauty that is currently bewitching us. (Bono) has learned to immediately contrast the pale reflection of beauty that humans are endowed with, on the one hand, and the supreme Divine source of authentic and
    enduring beauty, on the other. This is not sublimation, but
    elevation.


    Because it so convincing, I hope Bono read the review I quoted, and I’m guessing he may well have. Not because I found it in Rolling Stone, or another obvious publication that Mr. Vox has been known to frequent, but because it’s in a classic book called "Blessed are You: A Comprehensive Guide to Jewish Prayer," by Rabbi Jeffrey Cohen, copyright 1993. That’s right, a commentary on U2’s "Elevation" written long before the song. (And of course, "elevation" as the name of a prayer-vehicle has been around for centuries). No, I didn’t truly trick you; though I did..
    continued



    ------------------
    BTW, that interview with Bono is amazing.,  Waych him get all CS Lewis-esque:

    in Bono: In Conversation with Michka Assayas


    Bono: My understanding of the Scriptures has been made simple by the person of Christ. Christ teaches that God is love. What does that mean? What it means for me: a study of the life of Christ. Love here describes itself as a child born in straw poverty, the most vulnerable situation of all, without honor. I don't let my religious world get too complicated. I just kind of go: Well, I think I know what God is. God is love, and as much as I respond [sighs] in allowing myself to be transformed by that love and acting in that love, that's my religion. Where things get complicated for me, is when I try to live this love. Now that's not so easy.
    Assayas: What about the God of the Old Testament? He wasn't so "peace and love"?
    Bono: There's nothing hippie about my picture of Christ. The Gospels paint a picture of a very demanding, sometimes divisive love, but love it is. I accept the Old Testament as more of an action movie: blood, car chases, evacuations, a lot of special effects, seas dividing, mass murder, adultery. The children of God are running amok, wayward. Maybe that's why they're so relatable. But the way we would see it, those of us who are trying to figure out our Christian conundrum, is that the God of the Old Testament is like the journey from stern father to friend. When you're a child, you need clear directions and some strict rules. But with Christ, we have access in a one-to-one relationship, for, as in the Old Testament, it was more one of worship and awe, a vertical relationship. The New Testament, on the other hand, we look across at a Jesus who looks familiar, horizontal. The combination is what makes the Cross.
    '
    Assayas: Speaking of bloody action movies, we were talking about South and Central America last time. The Jesuit priests arrived there with the gospel in one hand and a rifle in the other.
    Bono: I know, I know. Religion can be the enemy of God. It's often what happens when God, like Elvis, has left the building. [laughs] A list of instructions where there was once conviction; dogma where once people just did it; a congregation led by a man where once they were led by the Holy Spirit. Discipline replacing discipleship. Why are you chuckling?
    Assayas: I was wondering if you said all of that to the Pope the day you met him.
    Bono: Let's not get too hard on the Holy Roman Church here. The Church has its problems, but the older I get, the more comfort I find there. The physical experience of being in a crowd of largely humble people, heads bowed, murmuring prayers, stories told in stained-glass windows
    Assayas: So you won't be critical.
    Bono: No, I can be critical, especially on the topic of contraception. But when I meet someone like Sister Benedicta and see her work with AIDS orphans in Addis Ababa, or Sister Ann doing the same in Malawi, or Father Jack Fenukan and his group Concern all over Africa, when I meet priests and nuns tending to the sick and the poor and giving up much easier lives to do so, I surrender a little easier.
    Assayas: But you met the man himself. Was it a great experience?
    Bono: [W]e all knew why we were there. The Pontiff was about to make an important statement about the inhumanity and injustice of poor countries spending so much of their national income paying back old loans to rich countries. Serious business. He was fighting hard against his Parkinson's. It was clearly an act of will for him to be there. I was oddly moved by his humility, and then by the incredible speech he made, even if it was in whispers. During the preamble, he seemed to be staring at me. I wondered. Was it the fact that I was wearing my blue fly-shades? So I took them off in case I was causing some offense. When I was introduced to him, he was still staring at them. He kept looking at them in my hand, so I offered them to him as a gift in return for the rosary he had just given me.
    Assayas: Didn't he put them on?
    Bono: Not only did he put them on, he smiled the wickedest grin you could ever imagine. He was a comedian. His sense of humor was completely intact. Flashbulbs popped, and I thought: "Wow! The Drop the Debt campaign will have the Pope in my glasses on the front page of every newspaper."
    Assayas: I don't remember seeing that photograph anywhere, though.
    Bono: Nor did we. It seems his courtiers did not have the same sense of humor. Fair enough. I guess they could see the T-shirts.
    Later in the conversation:
    Assayas: I think I am beginning to understand religion because I have started acting and thinking like a father. What do you make of that?
    Bono: Yes, I think that's normal. It's a mind-blowing concept that the God who created the universe might be looking for company, a real relationship with people, but the thing that keeps me on my knees is the difference between Grace and Karma.
    Assayas: I haven't heard you talk about that.
    Bono: I really believe we've moved out of the realm of Karma into one of Grace.
    Assayas: Well, that doesn't make it clearer for me.
    Bono: You see, at the center of all religions is the idea of Karma. You know, what you put out comes back to you: an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth, or in physics; in physical laws every action is met by an equal or an opposite one. It's clear to me that Karma is at the very heart of the universe. I'm absolutely sure of it. And yet, along comes this idea called Grace to upend all that "as you reap, so you will sow" stuff. Grace defies reason and logic. Love interrupts, if you like, the consequences of your actions, which in my case is very good news indeed, because I've done a lot of stupid stuff.
    Assayas: I'd be interested to hear that.
    Bono: That's between me and God. But I'd be in big trouble if Karma was going to finally be my judge. I'd be in deep s---. It doesn't excuse my mistakes, but I'm holding out for Grace. I'm holding out that Jesus took my sins onto the Cross, because I know who I am, and I hope I don't have to depend on my own religiosity.
    Assayas: The Son of God who takes away the sins of the world. I wish I could believe in that.
    Bono: But I love the idea of the Sacrificial Lamb. I love the idea that God says: Look, you cretins, there are certain results to the way we are, to selfishness, and there's a mortality as part of your very sinful nature, and, let's face it, you're not living a very good life, are you? There are consequences to actions. The point of the death of Christ is that Christ took on the sins of the world, so that what we put out did not come back to us, and that our sinful nature does not reap the obvious death. That's the point. It should keep us humbled . It's not our own good works that get us through the gates of heaven.
    Assayas: That's a great idea, no denying it. Such great hope is wonderful, even though it's close to lunacy, in my view. Christ has his rank among the world's great thinkers. But Son of God, isn't that farfetched?
    Bono: No, it's not farfetched to me. Look, the secular response to the Christ story always goes like this: he was a great prophet, obviously a very interesting guy, had a lot to say along the lines of other great prophets, be they Elijah, Muhammad, Buddha, or Confucius. But actually Christ doesn't allow you that. He doesn't let you off that hook. Christ says: No. I'm not saying I'm a teacher, don't call me teacher. I'm not saying I'm a prophet. I'm saying: "I'm the Messiah." I'm saying: "I am God incarnate." And people say: No, no, please, just be a prophet. A prophet, we can take. You're a bit eccentric. We've had John the Baptist eating locusts and wild honey, we can handle that. But don't mention the "M" word! Because, you know, we're gonna have to crucify you. And he goes: No, no. I know you're expecting me to come back with an army, and set you free from these creeps, but actually I am the Messiah. At this point, everyone starts staring at their shoes, and says: Oh, my God, he's gonna keep saying this. So what you're left with is: either Christ was who He said He was the Messiah or a complete nutcase. I mean, we're talking nutcase on the level of Charles Manson. This man was like some of the people we've been talking about earlier. This man was strapping himself to a bomb, and had "King of the Jews" on his head, and, as they were putting him up on the Cross, was going: OK, martyrdom, here we go. Bring on the pain! I can take it. I'm not joking here. The idea that the entire course of civilization for over half of the globe could have its fate changed and turned upside-down by a nutcase, for me, that's farfetched
    Bono later says it all comes down to how we regard Jesus:
    Bono: If only we could be a bit more like Him, the world would be transformed. When I look at the Cross of Christ, what I see up there is all my s--- and everybody else's. So I ask myself a question a lot of people have asked: Who is this man? And was He wo He said He was, or was He just a religious nut? And there it is, and that's the question. And no one can talk you into it or out of it.

    Thursday, February 01, 2007

    Self-Disclosure with Sunglasses On

    This has long been a popular photo; reminding us that only 10-20% of an iceberg is visible above water.
    Of course, I great reminder about transparency, self-disclosure and the "Splagnhizomai glasses' (to switch the metaphor.




    Sunday was amazing.. I will post on it later...Basically, the "sermon" preached by one became the "habitat" (someone...Ron Martoia? offered "habitat" as a name for the new "sermon")experienced by all. We split into seven groups with various projects.
    But the point here was the groups were formed by the ice breaking game where somone has a sign on their back that they can't read..it has the name of a person or character (Jesus, Moses, Lois Lane, SpongeBob). The person must roam around the room and by merely asking 'yes or no' questions (Am I a TV character? Male or female?) of folks, discern who they are.
    Paul Tournier ("Nothing makes us so lonely as our secrets') suggests that we cannot know who we are except through the lens of...even asking questions of one another...and of God. "Known as we are known."
    Note to self: explore intereelationships of Johari window/Myers-Briggs related to self-disclosure (as individuals and as community...Mark Artist speaks of "the interior like of a community'). I assume Len (fellow Myers-Briggs INFP) or Dream Factory Tom will beat me to the topic, but that's good.. I need to learn. And I know Moltmann is helpful on God's self-disclosure... Of course, in the meantime there is inevitably the Bono connection:

    Bono: (Our manager Paul McGuinness) would sit me down and say, “You have what it takes. You must have more confidence in yourself and continue to dig deeper. And I don’t be upset or surprised when you pull something out of the depth that’s uncomfortable.”

    Assayas: So you discovered things that, on first glance, you’d rather have kept hidden? What were those?

    Bono: The gauche nature of awe, of worship, the wonderment at the world around you. Coolness might help in your negotiation with your world, maybe, but it is impossible to meet God with sunglasses on. It is impossible to meet God without abandon, without exposing yourself, being raw. That’s the connection with great music and art, and that’s the other reason you wanted to join a band: you wanted to do the cool thing. Trying to capture religious experiences on tape wasn’t what you had in mind when you signed up for the job.

    Assayas: What about your own sunglasses, then? Do you wear them the same way a taxi driver would turn off his front light, so as to signal to God that this rock star is too full of himself and not to hire at the moment?

    Bono: Yeah, my insincerity… I have learnt the importance of not being earnest at all times. You don’t know what’s going on behind those glasses, but God, I can assure you, does.
    (Assayas, 53-54...read more)


    Thursday, February 16, 2012

    I am moody and I have a nice butt

    "Any preacher who doesn’t think he’s a fraud is – a fraud."
    ------

    Assayas: What about your own sunglasses, then? Do you wear them the same way a taxi driver would turn off his front light, so as to signal to God that this rock star is too full of himself and not to hire at the moment?

    Bono: Yeah, my insincerity… I have learnt the importance of not being earnest at all times. You don’t know what’s going on behind those glasses, but God, I can assure you, does.
    (Assayas, 53-54...read more)
    -----------------
    We have a tremendous capacity for self-deception.

    As part of  a class on Ministry and Leadership I was subbing for, the assigned topic was the book "The Dark Side of Christian Leadership."  We had some great discussion about how our  individual "dark side" ("Darth  Side" vs. Anakin side)  issues affect our life and ministry.   The students had completed the survey in the book, so they each knew which category they "were":



    It's hard, because the categories sound so hard  ("hardening of the categories")and clinical, and everyone comes out with a  default dark-sounding dark side "orientation"(not a clinical diagnosis!).  A power-point of the book, summarizing the categories is HERE:
    • The Compulsive Leader
    • The Narcissistic Leader
    • The Paranoid Leader
    • The Codependent Leader
    • The Passive-Aggressive Leader

       
     I came out "narcissistic,"  (Steve will love that!) Must be true, considering stories like this about me.
    I am proud of my humility.
               And proud of that pride.
                               Proud of my low-self esteem, etc.

    So here are my results (you can take the survey at this link here,,..dare you!) in all their gory glory:



    Then  we spent a few minutes orienting the students to the "Johari Window"...

     ..highlighting the fact that we  may not know how obviously our dark side is showing, or even know what it is...but others do:

    The Johari window is a technique created by Joseph Luft and Harry Ingham in 1955[1] in the United States, used to help people better understand their mental instability. It is used primarily in self-help groups and corporate settings as a heuristic exercise.
    When performing the exercise, subjects are given a list of 56 adjectives and pick five or six that they feel describe their own personality. Peers of the subject are then given the same list, and each pick five or six adjectives that describe the subject. These adjectives are then mapped onto a grid.[2]
    ..

    Quadrants:

    Open: Adjectives that are selected by both the participant and his or her peers are placed into the Open quadrant. This quadrant represents traits of the subjects that both they and their peers are aware of.

    Hidden: Adjectives selected only by subjects, but not by any of their peers, are placed into the Hidden quadrant, representing information about them their peers are unaware of. It is then up to the subject to disclose this information or not.

    Blind Spot: Adjectives that are not selected by subjects but only by their peers are placed into the Blind Spot quadrant. These represent information that the subject is not aware of, but others are, and they can decide whether and how to inform the individual about these "blind spots".


    Unknown: Adjectives that were not selected by either subjects or their peers remain in the Unknown quadrant, representing the participant's behaviors or motives that were not recognized by anyone participating. This may be because they do not apply or because there is collective ignorance of the existence of these traits.  Wiki



    It's so true that we can't really know ourselves until we are known by another (Tournier)

    All this carries profound insights for epistemology, psychology....and especially leadership/dark side issues.

    So as last-minute lark, (why be normal?), which I was hoping would be a lively teaching moment, I asked for volunteers to take  a clipboard around  campus, and ask anyone on campus  (student, faculty, staff) who knew of me to list 5-6 adjectives that described me...anonymously, of course.

    I knew there might be surprises; stuff I didn't want to hear.
    Which was the point of the teaching point.

    Here's what they came back with, and I post this for the big LOL at the last answer:



    The students also told me someone who didn't know me answered the question anyway: That answer was properly ironic and partly true:  they said I was "narcissistic"   (Anyone sending students out to ask people what they thought about him was obviously narcissistic!)    (:

    Then I had another group of volunteers phone some people who knew me well..like Dallas Elder and Nancy Boyd..I knew she would be honest!!), etc.  They were asked the same question, and promised they could be honest, as who said what would not be revealed when the answers were revealed to the class.

    I was glad to get some positive feedback.
    The narcissist in me was thrilled.

    One person, though, said:

    "Moody."

    Moody?

    I don't think I'm moody!

    That makes me moody, by the way...

    I needed to hear that.

    I even asked my wife later, and she basically said, "Well, you may have  lots of issues, but being moody isn't one of them."

    That felt better.
    But dang it, I must be.
    There are things about me that I don't see, my wife may overlook....but are me.



    And I really needed to hear that.
    Which is precisely the point of the teaching point..


    Anyway...I better quit blogging on this; as I'm getting moody.

    But as for whoever it was that said I had a "nice butt"..

    I think the actual quote was transcribed wrongly.
                               The person probably said,  "He's nice, but..."

    ---

    Related posts:

     

    Tuesday, June 14, 2011

    Bono: "Don't lose your faith in this holy clown/idiot"

    It has been fascinating to follow the changes in the prophetic prayer rap Bono has been adding to live versions  of "Moment of Surrender" in the last couple years.   But I was pretty sure I heard a new and intriguing twist the other night in Oakland.  Frustrated that I didn't think to record it, and that the full version wasn't on YouTube yet....I was thrilled that St. Seth (who was there with us), pointed out a recording...that proves I heard right.

    Some history, and then the recording..

    The first (?) version  appeared out of nowhere on Saturday Night Live (NBC has taken it offline),
    and  wasn't incorporated into concerts for awhile,
    but by the time of the Rose Bowl concerts, captured in the DVD here below (see 5:40ff), it showed up, and showed up emotionally (see comments at "Moment of....Prayer Rap").


    It usually goes something like this:

    Life is short…it’s the longest thing you’ll ever do
    The worst, the curse was that your dreams come true
    God is a mirror in which each man sees himself
    Hell is a place where you don’t need any help
    When I first met you, your face was like snow
    Wherever you went, I wanted to go
    Your face, your grace, your can of mace
    Your case as you put it down
    8:17 on the ground
    Your faith in a clown
    Don’t leave me now, Lord, in this song
    Don’t leave me now
    Alone in this song 

    One of the hot debates was " Was he saying 'clown," 'crowd,' crown,"??.... I usually opted for "clown";
    hoping he was drawing (again) from the "holy fool" tradition and referring to Jesus and/or himself as the clown..

    "Holy fool" backstory:
    Bono: (Paul McGuinness) would sit me down and say, “You have what it takes. You must have more confidence in yourself and continue to dig deeper. And I don’t be upset or surprised when you pull something out of the depth that’s uncomfortable.”
    Assayas: So you discovered things that, on first glance, you’d rather have kept hidden? What were those?
    Bono: The gauche nature of awe, of worship, the wonderment at the world around you. Coolness might help in your negotiation with your world, maybe, but it is impossible to meet God with sunglasses on. It is impossible to meet God without abandon, without exposing yourself, being raw. That’s the connection with great music and art, and that’s the other reason you wanted to join a band: you wanted to do the cool thing. Trying to capture religious experiences on tape wasn’t what ypu had in mind when you signed up for the job.
    Assayas: What about your own sunglasses, then? Do you wear them the same way a taxi driver would turn off his front light, so as to signal to God that this rock star is too full of himself and not to hire at the moment?
    Bono: Yeah, my insincerity… I have learnt the importance of not being earnest at all times. You don’t know what’s going on behind those glasses, but God, I can assure you, does. (53-54)


    Sans glasses, still wearing wisdom, and more irony than one might think. It’s just been properly retooled and “dreamed up again” for a new millennium. He’s still a:


    “Holy Fool,” which is a wonderful tradition of the Eastern Church who periodically pops up here in the West. In the Russian tradition, some of the saints would do almost anything to avoid being perceived as saints. One of them kept offering to wrestle bears so people would think him a nut and not praise him as a saint. In the West, St. Philip Neri acted goofy, partly because he enjoyed being a goof and partly to throw people off the scent of his sanctity and keep them from gushing over him. When offered a cardinal's hat, he proceeded to play football with it. Currently, we saw something of the Holy Fool in Forrest Gump a few years ago. All such fools have one thing in common: they know they are not wise. Similarly, those who are convinced of their innate wisdom are invariably great ninnies. It's far better to be a fool for Christ than to be a fool on one's own. Today, thank God for the folly that is his wisdom.

    1 Corinthians 3:18: Let no one deceive himself. If any one among you thinks that he is wise in this age, let him become a fool that he may become wise.
    -Mark Shea, Daily Cathloc Exchange Devotional, Aopril 1, 2005

    He’s still a holy fool, just more stripped down and streamlined. Far more subtle, no devil mask. But how is is that, on this current tour, he can dedicate “Running to Stand Still” to the troops in Iraq with a straight poker face, let alone without a McPhisto/devil mask to make the irony obvious? Does no one get it? Has anyone booed? No, they applaud what they perceive as patriotism (and they are partly right) and miss and misunderstand the subtle point (War is an exercise in death; in futility, and in standing still). Applaud is what they should do……but for another reason altogether: the singer has just brilliantly and understatedly (!) pulled off a holy fool moment. And dismantled death even. Even if not many “get it.”
    -link



    A couple years ago, Towers commented on my blog:


    I would venture an as yet unspoken theory that Bono is in fact saying "8:17 on the ground - your faith in a clown" as a reference to 1.) the approximate start time of the concert..? 2.) the clown as himself. Picture - it's 8:17, the crowd is on the crowd, ready for 'Space Oddity' and lift off with 'King of your Love' and the drum roll of 'Breathe.' Everyone's enthralled. In keeping with the themes explored in 'Stand Up Comedy' (sadly unplayed as yet) perhaps Bono is here having a go at the idea that people place faith in rock stars who, despite pomp and circumstance, are essentially clowns.  -see comments here,  Towers,  
    I agree that it is likely 8:17 (and not A-17 as many think), as originally every song on "No Line" included a time reference...and Towers' guess is as good as any in context.

    So..

    what i thought I heard in person the other night  was  that "Don't put your faith in a clown"   had become "Don't lose your faith in this clown" (Either way, Bono would be meaning himself, unless he pointed upwards, which I didn't see.
    Here is the audio, check out 7:58..it's pretty clear:


    LATER NOTE: FINALLY FOUND A FULL CONCERT VIDEO VERSION.  HERE IT IS, pick up the video at 5:45 mark: (Note: I make the case that you can often tell when Bono's about to move into a prophetic section...you can watch his hand start to shake or swirl...LOL, I guess he's been to Toronto.  see below and especially "Without You" at Slane here):

    I realize he could be praying that GOD would not lose his faith in "this clown"=Bono.
    He sure assumes a posture of prayer as soon as he finishes saying it the last time.
    --
    Considering what happened next...which was amazing:

    ..definitely one of the highlights, check out what happened at the very end as the band meets Wojtek,  This whole thing felt prophetic as I watched it, as if the guest was sent to bring a blessing to the band and to the U.S with his visit...and gift to Bono.  Of course, it is yet another refreshing example of how U2 honors fans......and a reminder that Beth is right: Bono does not bring only girls up on stage:



                 - link: "Wojtek flew twenty hours...without an airplane")

    ...suffice to say I haven't lost my faith in either clown.
    When Bono was 'foolish' enough to let Wojtek up on stage, it was holy foolishness.
    When someone holds up a sign that says "Bono: I flew 20 hours to be on stage with U2,"
    and Bono is humble and holy enough to let it happen..

    ..wow, once some folks travelled  eight hours to meet me..That was holy and humbling enough.

    Story:

    We were minding our own business, teaching for a small group at our church by the brothel (see both here) in  Huancayo, Peru...when these men  (video below) showed up unannounced.

    No one knew them, so Ken greeted them and found they has somehow heard from the grapevine that we (some special gringos) were in Huancayo; they had travelled for eight hours on mountain roads, on the chance that we might be able to pray/commission them for their ministry: they run an intercession/outreach center  from the poorest apartment complex in the country.

    Sometimes when North Americans teach in Latin America or Africa, the locals think we are especially anointed, or will blow on them/knock 'em down like the televangelists on TBN.  This was different.  They just felt like we had something for them.


    -Link: "you travelled eight hours to meet US!?"

    Count me a holy fool.

    I even wore a clown suit once..maybe I'll buy it back..story and photos here..

    Oh...

    if the "holy fool" language trips you up, would it trip you up more to use the phrase "idiot"?:



    I would love to browse the books by Bono's bedside.
    We have long known he has read
    Eugene Peterson (some see direct Peterson inspirations in this album),
    Brennan Manning (great story)
    Phillip Yancey (great story) ../


    We have just confirmed a long suspicion he has read John of the Cross!

    Why would he not be referencing Dostoyevsky's "The Idiot" in "Crazy Tonight"s use of ":idiot" language?
    The title character is not only a Christ-figure, but his development was influenced by the "holy fool" tradition (which Bono directly utilized in the 9os).  -full story

    Thursday, November 13, 2008

    Rev. Clayton on "what you believe,what's truthful, what's relevant to your life "

    In the stretching times the economy is currently junctured in..
    in the fearful hope and hopeful fear we are juxtaposed in..

    it would seem prime time for the liminal landscape that only the church can call the culture into.

    Zoo TV/Zooropa
    was certainly designed to speak to its times (1990s),
    yet there is something prophetic and proleptic about how it speaks into the season we are now in.

    In a rare interview montage from this era, Adam Clayton's insight (7:43ff) is helpful:

    "I think Europe is much more geared up for the future, in a way, than America was before this election. I think Europe is generally looking forward to the turn of the century (and) a little bit more cynical about the grip of the media upon it. So I think..these two ideas of the turn of the century, and the media as such and what you believe and what's truthful and what's relevant to your life and how much of it's under your own control... are
    issues that are going to be valid in Europe over the next ten years.


    I think the unification of Europe is going to present as many problems as it solves..people are aware of that...so I think what we're going be be trying to do is touch on those issues, and not necessarily preach to anyone, but certainly in our own way, within in the context of the ZOO TV (Zooropa) Tour is perhaps have our own particular unity..the 'United Colors of Zooropa' or whatever.
    I think it will be a ray of sunshine in a very bleak year"


    So many things stand out! Among them, if only the church could microcosmically and counterculturally...and "without necessarily preaching"... model Kingdom community, colors and alternate reality. "Church within the church"
    is nothing new..but it's time to try it!

    It likely will take a touch of postmodern and postexilic simulacra and a taste of the orthodox "holy fool" (see bottom of this page) approach....in a way that is sensitive to the '00s...maybe in the more subdued irony that U2 has captured recently.
    No horns.

    Maybe one.

    St Tim Neufeld has caught the relevance of 90s U2 for our times.
    "As usual, U2 was ten years ahead of their time."
    ...As always when you enter the present by the back door/trap door of the future.

    (one should not that Larry Burkett wrote "The Coming Economic Earthquake" in
    the early 1990s, and he died with people saying he was a false prophet)


    But within "our own tour" (Steve Taylor's language, as well: "tourism can serve as a redemptive framework for postmodern mission, in which people are `tourists' on spiritual journeys and the church operates as `tour guide,' stimulating forward movement and nourishing the quest." (p.83, "The Out of Bounds Church?") , and "in our own way"..
    let "our own particular unity" shine.


    About the "ray of sunshine in a very bleak year."

    Clayton smiles, as he is well aware of the irony; the album and tour they were crafting as he spoke (Zooropa) was their bleakest ever..but what better technique/techbleak than to embody and incarnate such hopelessness ("Wake Up Dead Man").
    No redemption without incarnation.


    That comment also connected me to the classic and controversial "The Bright Side of Life"
    from Monty Python's "Life of Brian."
    If you think that was pure heresy, you haven't heard Jesus sing the song/;lament/dirge that the Biblle itself tells us was "Doe of the Morning"..

    He sang it on a cross.



    How else does one subvert and hijack dread, except via a ridiculous but redemptive whistling in the dark..

    which is always the times we're in.

    Some times even more so.
    That's even better than the realer thing.
    --

    A few years ago, I wrote about dismantling death:

    BY BECOMING A HOLY FOOL, REMIXED FOR THE NEW MILLENIUM



    All this emphasis on the critical nature of prophetic weeping and lamenting . reminds that deep imside, no matter how numbed-over; no matter how deathed-down we are all crying. Or at least crying to cry. We intuitively know that tears are not only healing but prophetic. But we hide behind a mask, and only cry the tears of a clown.”

    In the 9O’s Bono often wore a mask. For dismantling death and consumerism in that neo-nihilistic era, that was the proper costume. But the 00’s are a time to “pray naked.”

    Bono: (Paul McGuinness) would sit me down and say, “You have what it takes. You must have more confidence in yourself and continue to dig deeper. And I don’t be upset or surprised when you pull something out of the depth that’s uncomfortable.”
    Assayas: So you discovered things that, on first glance, you’d rather have kept hidden? What were those?
    Bono: The gauche nature of awe, of worship, the wonderment at the world around you. Coolness might help in your negotiation with your world, maybe, but it is impossible to meet God with sunglasses on. It is impossible to meet God without abandon, without exposing yourself, being raw. That’s the connection with great music and art, and that’s the other reason you wanted to join a band: you wanted to do the cool thing. Trying to capture religious experiences on tape wasn’t what ypu had in mind when you signed up for the job.
    Assayas: What about your own sunglasses, then? Do you wear them the same way a taxi driver would turn off his front light, so as to signal to God that this rock star is too full of himself and not to hire at the moment?
    Bono: Yeah, my insincerity… I have learnt the importance of not being earnest at all times. You don’t know what’s going on behind those glasses, but God, I can assure you, does. (53-54)


    Sans glasses, still wearing wisdom, and more irony than one might think. It’s just been properly retooled and “dreamed up again” for a new millennium. He’s still a


    “Holy Fool,” which is a wonderful tradition of the Eastern Church who periodically pops up here in the West. In the Russian tradition, some of the saints would do almost anything to avoid being perceived as saints. One of them kept offering to wrestle bears so people would think him a nut and not praise him as a saint. In the West, St. Philip Neri acted goofy, partly because he enjoyed being a goof and partly to throw people off the scent of his sanctity and keep them from gushing over him. When offered a cardinal's hat, he proceeded to play football with it. Currently, we saw something of the Holy Fool in Forrest Gump a few years ago. All such fools have one thing in common: they know they are not wise. Similarly, those who are convinced of their innate wisdom are invariably great ninnies. It's far better to be a fool for Christ than to be a fool on one's own. Today, thank God for the folly that is his wisdom.

    1 Corinthians 3:18: Let no one deceive himself. If any one among you thinks that he is wise in this age, let him become a fool that he may become wise.
    -Mark Shea, Daily Cathloc Exchange Devotional, Aopril 1, 2005


    He’s still a holy fool, just more stripped down and streamlined. Far more subtle, no devil mask. But how is is that, on this current tour, he can dedicate “Running to Stand Still” to the troops in Iraq with a straight poker face, let alone without a McPhisto/devil mask to make the irony obvious? Does no on get it? Has anyone booed? No, they applaud what they perceive as patriotism (and they are partly right) and miss and misunderstand the subtle point (War is an exercise in death; in futility, and in standing still). Applaud is what they should do……but for another reason altogether: the singer has just brilliantly and understatedly (!) pulled off a holy fool moment. And dismantled death even. Even if not many “get it.”
    -link

    ---------
    ------------


    Richard Inchausti:

    The point that many moderns fail to grasp about Christian thinkers is that they have very little interest in changing the world. They seek merely to see things clearly in the light of God's hidden logic. And if by so doing they expose the narcissism of their contemporaries, the false agendas of their leaders, the didactic pornography of their artists and entertainers-well, that is all to the good. But unlike their more utilitarian peers, they desire to live in the truth even more than they desire to be effective in the world. ...Evil manifests itself in absence of perception, and in the negation of Being more than it does in the presence of stupidity, violence or even hatred. It is more often than not a species of folly-a commitment to "virtues" that are not really virtues...It wears a suit or a uniform, waves a flag and has credentials. That is why the primary moral task from a Christian perspective is first to perceive evil. And this requires that one see what isn't there and through things that are. This is possible only for someone who is suspicious of virtre and believes in a greater reality than his own. What the Christian mysteries require from us is not that we construct a better world, but that we love and serve the one we are given. As one Parisian graffiti artist wrote in 1968:: "the intellectuals have hitherto only changed the world, the point is to understand it." This is a decidedly contemplative observation, one that confirms Blake's suspicions of the new aesceticism and Kierkegaards' view that even if someone were to speak the Word of God directly today, no one in the modern world would hear it, simply because there is too much noise and distraction. The function of the modern apostle, therefore, is to create the silent contemplative places where individuals can
    experience truth for themselves.
    -Subversive Orthodoxy: Outlaws, Revolutionaries and Other Christians in Disguise. pp187-189

    Friday, October 24, 2008

    Bono and Jim Kerr on preaching

    I love Matt's answer to my question "What can the church learn from U2; even though/especially because in humility he felt unqualified to answer
    (read his answer here; then buy his book).

    And Chris has delightfully drawn out from Bono's interview with Assayas (buy the book) hugely helpful lessons about "what the preacher can learn from U2/Bono"
    (buy the book);

    And of course we have an amazing resource for "preaching the U2 catalog" (buy the book).



    But I was thrilled to find in this 1983 joint interview of Bono and Jim Kerr of the Simple Minds (another group that has breathed on my preaching for decades now) that Bono himself speaks a timely word for us preacher types twenty five years, and a whole new world later..especially related to church shift.
    Just replace a few words ("flowered shirts" for "leather pants" etc.):

    "Satin pants have been replaced by leather pants, but it's the same old tripe [?] that they're giving the audience:

    'Here WE are, and there YOU {condesending point of finger} are;

    now you look at us, and we're going to give you what you need..

    and that's wrong."

    Or:

    "a lot of rock and roll looks to the past...while myself and Jim, our music looks to the future...

    It's a whole new generation; a whole new blood. And for too long, there was a tourniquet applied to the music which wasn't allowing the new blood through..but it burst the dams.."


    Off with the dam(n) tourniquets.
    Is this stuff eerily relevant to our day, or not?
    Right down to the opening comments about gay weddings (:
    ..followed by the phenomenon of fainting at concerts (Wesley,Cane Ridge, Brownsville..."slaying in the Spirit"?)..
    ...and the "monster which can become a dinosaur" of communicating to large crowds.

    Monday, January 13, 2014

    Bono and chess

    "The reason I like the game chess is because each move has countless repercussions, but you're in charge of them. And it's your ability to see into the future and the effects of the decisions you've made that makes you either a good or not a good chess player. It's not luck.” ― Bono, Bono: In Conversation with Michka Assayas

    See:
    --

    Bono: Chess, do you play chess?
    Dylan: Yeah, I play chess. Are you a chess player?
    Bono: I am a chess player.
    Dylan: I'm not that good actually.
    Bono: I'll challenge you to a game of chess.
    Dylan: I don't have it right now actually, I just don't have one on me, but the next time you see me!
    Bono: Oh, you can get these little ones you know, that you can carry around.
    Dylan: Yeah, I take them on tour all the time, but nobody in the band will play me.
    Bono: Really?
    Dylan: Yeah, they say it's an ego trip. They say I want to win, I don't want to win, I just like to play.


    Thursday, July 31, 2008

    Two Naked Pastors

    If I could only learn to pray naked (St. Mike blazed the way, see story halfway down here, along with fully clothed video of the song by that name), preach naked, be naked.

    It's all I have got to offer.

    In the league of Chris Erdman on what we can learn about preaching from U2
    (this lesson, and a classic "trialogue" with Bono and Assayas that wound up in Chris' book);

    now consider Naked Pastor's post on recently "ordained" minister (!) Alanis Morissette:


    Alanis Morissette & Improv Preaching

    Posted in art, thought by nakedpastor on the June 19th, 2008

    image.jpegLisa turned me on to an article Saturday in Saint John’s Telegraph Journal called “Alanis, raw”… about a Canadian musician and artist, Alanis Morissette. I love her music anyway and have always been intrigued by her. Her latest album, Flavors of Entanglement, is just incredible. Pick it up.

    What intrigues me about her is how she writes her songs and records her albums. I heard years ago that she doesn’t write any lyrics until she’s actually in the studio with the record button on. It’s all spontaneous and impromptu, giving her songs a real and immediate quality:

    Typically I go in the studio and whatever I’m contemplating that day will wind up being a song. I don’t come in with lyrics… I just go in and let it happen… I don’t change anything once we’re done. I put all my energy – and this also shows up in other areas of my life – my energy goes into being ready… With songwriting I spend a lot of time living life, accruing all these experiences, journaling, and then by the time I get to the studio, I’m teeming with the drive to write.

    Sigsworth (who’s worked with Imogen Heap of Frou Frou), worked with Alanis in the studio and says:

    So many of my ideas about songwriting have been changed by working with her, because she works so fast as a writer and gets the raw statement of the song so precisely so quickly… She seems to just centre on that focal point, the crisis issue at the heart of the song, and she gets it immediately… There were songs where I would listen and be almost in tears and think, ‘Where did this come from? There was nothing here this morning.’

    Alanis’ approach to the creative art of songwriting and singing has encouraged me over the years in my approach to the sermon or preaching event. If you’ve been following my blog, you can read a post I wrote last April called Preaching Improv that talks about this. I remember when I first started pastoring churches and preaching I followed the recommended formula of one hour’s preparation for each minute of preaching (which, in the Presbyterian Church, was precisely 20 minutes. Do the math.). Over the years I found this increasingly clinical, artificial, impersonal and therefore frustrating. I began to approach teaching less as presenting a carefully formulated bottle of water to giving living water (if there was any) from the well that I had hopefully nourished in my personal life. My preaching became impromptu. Seldom any notes. Often plenty of nerves. But usually always engagement between everyone in the room. This doesn’t mean that there isn’t any study, writing, contemplation or decision. In fact, the opposite is true. When I used to prepare sermons, it was necessary for me to isolate (insulate?) myself from people and life. Now, I feel more fully engaged with people and with life, documenting my discoveries, revelations and conclusions in concrete experiences, journals, blogs, art, songs and occasional teaching moments.

    -Naked Pastor, link



    Some of that reminded me of "How can I be a spokemen when all I've got to say is 'Help!'"

    Naked Pastor's post is even better than the brilliant Naked Alanis music video/song/psalm/prayer:

    What's really naked and vulnerable in this song is Alanis' soul.
    I want to be like that.
    Or not.

    Guess you'll have to settle for a "naked picture of Dave Wainscott"..

    "Thank U"
    by (Rev.) Alanis Morisette

    how bout getting off these antibiotics
    how bout stopping eating when I'm full up
    how bout them transparent dangling carrots
    how bout that ever elusive kudo

    thank you india
    thank you terror
    thank you disillusionment
    thank you frailty
    thank you consequence
    thank you thank you silence

    how bout me not blaming you for everything
    how bout me enjoying the moment for once
    how bout how good it feels to finally forgive you
    how bout grieving
    it all one at a time

    thank you india
    thank you terror
    thank you disillusionment
    thank you frailty
    thank you consequence
    thank you thank you silence

    the moment I let go of it was the moment
    I got more than I could handle
    the moment I jumped off of it
    was the moment I touched down

    how bout no longer being masochistic
    how bout remembering your divinity
    how bout unabashedly bawling your eyes out
    how bout not equating death with stopping

    thank you india
    thank you providence
    thank you disillusionment
    thank you nothingness
    thank you clarity
    thank you thank you silence


    Wow.

    Of course a spoof of the video was inevitable; see it here,
    but the new line there, "wash me," is prayer as well..




    Don't forget:

    Sunday, October 06, 2013

    "train wreck" or quantum evangelism? Pope's interview with atheist

    The pope's second big interview  (see excerpt here, and RNS response here) is intriguing for several reasons.

    One, it's with a skeptic.  That should be be considered when reading quotes out of context.  The pope is more pastor than evangelist.  At times, though, it reminds. of Bono's famous C.S. Lewis-esque  interview with   Assayas , in that it is quite aplogetic/persuasive..but in a humble, relational way. One writer complains that the pope's line " Proselytism is solemn nonsense, it makes no sense. We need to get to know each other, listen to each other and improve our knowledge of the world around us.”  But the pope didn't say "evangelism," he said " Proselytism'!

    The complaints against what has been called  by that same  Protestant a "theological train wreck"  (article here)  of the pope's comments  might be tempered with the "quantum" view of the pope that  John Raines has proffered.

    Friday, April 25, 2008

    Gimme the Bird, Bono



    I couldn't get this document to paste in very well here: no links, lotsa errors. Sorry!

    Welcome to rough draft of Part 3 (parts 1,2,4 at www.davestuff.blogspot.com)of a theological roundtable (table guests range this time from the classic theologian Woody Allen to genius professor Wolfhart Pannenberg ...by way of Don Quixote and an M.D. or two..and of course(!) Aristotle (hint: NOT a punk band from Toledo)… around the explosive “Bomb” U2 dropped in 2004. In this episode, we find the chief lyricist of the band is a Slinky Bird; and thus a master of prophetic-priestly metaphor. And we note that the “arc from fear to faith” is not only one you can feel; but is congruent with ancient theological... and recent neurological ...evidence for the primacy of feeling. Which keeps us from accidentally joining the First Church of Binitarian Bibliolaters. Thus U2 proves once again...via flamenco and carnival... that we can embrace all variety of psalm-songs; especially the laments that heal. Especially the ones with forbidden and colorful four letter "F-word" (not the F-word you think, I bet!)... And you can dance to them!..or at least kneel!









    ===============================





    ONLY THE BIRD CAN GET US OUT OF THE BOX

    There are the mud-flowers of dialect
    And the immortelles of perfect pitch
    And that moment when the bird sings very close
    To the music of what happens.


    Bono is the bomb, amen? Of course, I am writing as a fan; so of course I think he is, as the kids say, “the bomb” (meaning something or something “really cool”). I also think it’s partly true that he himself is, by how own glad admission, the “bomb” of the album title (in addition to his standard interview answer...that his dad is the “Atomic Bob”....which is often an intentional subterfuge; slyly pressing one to guess at the second and more correct answer), in need of defusing and dismantling (more on that in Part 2).

    Bono is the bomb indeed. Which is why he’s also, in the language of the poem above, also the bird. Bono is the that particular brand of bird who can uncannily “sing very close to the music of what happens.” Indeed, one of a small and elite handful of singers who are true birds (I would include folks like Bruce Cockburn, Bill Mallonee, Nick Cave, Sinead O’ Connor and Steve Taylor/Chagall Guevara among this elite class). And I don’t mean just songbirds who can carry a tune with style. I mean one of those rare and amazing purebred birds that Bono’s favorite poet and fellow Irishman Seamus Heaney has snapshotted for us in the above stanza of his multilayered poem, “Song” .


    Many singers/writers have their moments. But the genius and genus of bird that Bono is, is evident in that the holy “moment when the bird sings very close to the music of what happens” happens startlingly and disproportionately often in Bono’s song.

    In the liner notes to a box set of the early 77s CDs, a Christian music journalist (likely John J. Thompson ...but I can't find the document) tells how Keith Richards of the Rolling Stones used to say "Any band in the world can be the greatest band in the world on a given night." To which the journalist responds something like "On most nights, the 77s are that band." (Detour: If the 77s are unfamiliar to you, hear this high praise from respected Christian review site, The Phantom Tollbooth: "Let the Rolling Stones boast as much as they want, but when the rubber hits the road the title of the world's greatest rock n roll band goes to the 77's and you can take that to the bank").

    On any given song, on any given night, Bono's prophetic words, if not his voice, are among the "closest to what really happens," in addition to fronting what is many folks choice for "world's greatest band." He speaks reality, he sings in synchronicity, he truth-tells with authenticity. In a priestly role, he says/sings; gives words, tone and color to things we feel, but cannot express; or even things we didn’t know we felt until we heard his lyric, heart and song, and only then recognized and resonated with the truth. Which is of course not only definition of a priest, but job description of artist; or a prophet; even a worship leader. ("I believe being a worship leader is the highest of all art forms,” he told a group of Christian journalists, “to worship and call people into the presence of God.")

    The one born Paul Hewson was born to sing; to become interpreter and intercessor of reality; of life; of feelings; of the things of God. He gives us voice through his voice, like any priestly bird at his best and most urbane and arcane.

    Like many profoundly gifted artists, he admits often to suffering from a “messianic complex, which he regularly defuses and detoxes by:

    · a)coming home after tour (“Honey,” his wife reminds, “You are not in front of 40,000 people tonight. Feed the dog!”)

    · b)admitting and confessing said complex often and publicly.
    He even directly confessed his favored mode of self-exorcism rite upon detecting the presence of the complex: “Letting Monty Python take me to the life of Brian,” he laughs. This is a reference, he explains, to the Monty Python film, where when Brian is confronted with worship, his mother hangs from the balcony and warns the crowds:
    “He’s not the Messiah; he’s a very naughty boy.””
    "Didn't you think it was a bit inappropriate to take Lennon's part in 'Sgt Pepper' on stage at Live 8 ? ," he was once asked. "Oh, I don't think like that; I have the immodesty of foolishness. I was proud to stand in his shoes."

    And his demeanor is humble and his awe is Godward when he simply states to his “Sixty Minutes” interviewer what may at first read sound like visions of grandeur, but may well be the thesis statement of this whole chapter:
    “Our songs occupy an emotional terrain that did not exist before our band did.”

    True, it is a band thing; a corporate gifting. Even Time magazine pays homage to The Edge’s “swirling epiphanies” on guitar. But the accompanying words of The Bird instantly create epiphanies and theophanies chillingly close “to the music of what actually happens” in a human heart and a fallen/God-haunted world. Something one cannot articulate about what Birdman articulates; it feels as if he is touching reality at its core and base.

    I believe that like few others of our time, he is.

    And since by God’s design, life at its very base is paradox/metaphor....and as Leonard Sweet would summarize physics of string theory: "Life is at base music" (p.63, Eleven Genetic Gateways to Spiritual Awakening), maybe (good) music and (healthy) paradox are interchangeable. Which is why Bono at his best when he can in a priestly-prophetic way, express and sing paradox for us; offering it as intepretive intercession for us, to us, and to God.

    Eugene Peterson is on track:

    “Prophets are characteristically masters of metaphor. Metaphor is the witness of language to the interconnectedness of all things visible and invisible….When prophets use metaphor, we get involved with God whether we want to or not, sometimes whether we know it or not…. If we are lucky, a prophet, one of the descendants of Hosea, or Jonah, or Habakkuk, shows up and with the simple expedient of a metaphor, said or sung, drags us outside into the open air when all the stuff we are studying is alive and moving and colliding with us. For many these days, it is U2 that shows up.”
    -Preface to "Get Up Off Your Knees : Preaching the U2 Catalog "

    As is fellow theologian Woody Allen:" Eighty percent of success is showing up." Perhaps the other twenty percent is showing up with prophetic metaphor, as U2 certainly does "for many these days."

    For those wondering if I am overpainting the foundational nature of metaphor to reality; let alone the significance of U2 in modeling it:

    What did no one less than Aristotle suggest was “the greatest thing, by far”?:

    “The greatest thing by far is to be master of metaphor. It is the one thing that cannot be learnt from others; and it is also a sign of genius, since a good metaphor implies an intuitive perception of the simiiarity in dissimilars.” (Poetics, 1459 a 5-8, "The Basic Works of Aristotle")

    All right, I'll pull out the big guns: a certain Jesus...who, Matthew 13:34 plainly claims, "did not even open his mouth without a metaphor." ( !!)

    It is largely because Bono follows Jesus, that he follows this rabbinic technique. But also largely because of the Jesus-factor, Bono's a prophetic metaphorist not just of words, but with life. Beyond the words themselves, his very nonverbal language and stage manner (even antics at times) are prophetic acts, his whole life as metaphorical media.

    No, I do not think I am overstating.

    This curriculum and storehouse of wise metaphor/paradox, constructed partly of "the mud-flowers of dialect" (could it be that Bono's "Zooropa" lyric: "put flowers in the mud, baby" were a nod to this Heaney line?), is the domain of all worthy teachers...whether they literally sing or not. At a recent conference, Leonard Sweet held up a toy slinky. It was a prophetic prop, which he used to challenge the church to embrace and celebrate paradox. Just as a slinky moves by transferring its weight from end to end through a weak middle; so do we; so does life. We live most naturally in “both ends of a paradox...any valid paradox. Balance is out. Movement is in; paradox is reality… it's alive."

    Bono knows this. Though his usual handhelds are a microphone and (occasionally) guitar (red, three chords, truth attached);
    he may well own a slinky. I watched him at a concert grab and blow a fan's bottle of soap bubbles, oblivious to the 20, 000 onlookers . Childlike enough to publicly embrace profound paradox...or at least the "immodesty of foolishness."

    “’I thank you, Daddy,’” laughed Jesus joyfully, ‘that you have hidden your secrets from the professional and the religious; and entrusted them to children and the childlike.’” (Luke 10:21)

    Anyway, the secret to navigating postmodern life is a slinky-like bringing together both ends of paradox and holding them in mind simultaneously, Sweet said. Transferring its weight from end to end through a weak middle.

    Sounds like that Slinky Bird Bono Vox to me.


    Back to the Heaney poem. In classic postmodern form, we have saved the first stanza for last; to highlight just where the reality-bird is perched:







    A rowan (re- berried ash tree) like a lipsticked girl.
    Between the by-road and the main road
    Alder trees at a wet and dripping distance
    Stand off among the rushes


    "Between the by-road and the main road." Hmm, sounds like a choice between roads; or a choice to live liminally; to stay on both. Sounds like "right in the middle of a contradiction, that's where I want to be." (as Bono often quoted Sam Shepherd in the 1990s). Actually it sounds like:

    "There's cathedrals and the alleyway in our music. I think the alleyway is usually on the way to the cathedral, where you can hear your own footsteps and you're slightly nervous and looking over your shoulder and wondering if there's somebody following you. And then you get there and you realize there was somebody following you: It's God."
    -Bono, New Tork Times, 2004


    If we sing anywhere "close to what really happens," there is no sacred/secular distinction; one can find God and be found by God in the alleyways near the intersection of Main and Church Street, right smack in the middle of a contradiction; or at least a paradox; definitely a metaphor.

    That's not being stuck in a moment you can't get out of; that's being positioned in the middle of what God is doing. I don’t want out of that Place.


    I FEEL, THEREFORE I AM…ALL BECAUSE OF YOU

    “Follow your heart,” the singer told the guitar player. And he walked away, confident that this advice was clear and self-authenticating enough to wrestle the player through. It was.

    In fact, we owe the very existence and strength of U2 these twenty some years later to that godly risky advice Bono gave to the Edge…who was considering following not his heart; but his church’s advice, about breaking up his new and exciting band because rock and roll was too “worldly.”

    The Edge eventually decided he didn't have a problem reconciling his art and faith. "It was mostly other people's problems."
    Or as Bono recalls:

    "There was a moment where myself and Edge sat around and we thought: 'Well, maybe we should knock this group on the head. Maybe it is frivolous, maybe these people are right, maybe this is just bullocks, this being in a band, and maybe it's just ego, and maybe we should put it behind us and just get to the real work of trying to change our own lives, and just get out into the world. There's much to do there.' For a couple of weeks, we were at that place. Then we came to a realization: 'Hold on a second. Where are these gifts coming from? This is how we worship God, even though we don't write religious songs, because we didn't feel God needs the advertising.' (laughs) In fact, we ended up at a place where we thought: 'The music isn't bullocks. This kind of fundamentalism is what's bullocks.'"

    It was a tougher choice than we know, as obvious and validated as it looks through hindsight. "It was a baptism of fire...We went down into the water," Bono looks back, “And we almost drowned."

    Embracing this baptism with passion, angst and persisteverance, the Edge spent weeks of not only following his heart, but following it into his guitar, creating the gut-wrenching, freedom-affirming sounds that became what we now know as "Sunday Bloody Sunday." (Highly ironically, U2's most "Christian" song yet!)

    What more heartfelt guitar riffs exist out there, I don't know. They ring like what the hymnwriter could only call "music of the spheres," and reverb frighteningly close "to the music that actually happens." If life is at base, music; this is base.

    And heartfelt.

    Note, one never says "headfelt."

    Let alone "wear my head on my sleeve."

    HOOKED ON A FEELING


    Which is why we now jump immediately into a thesis currently being substantiated across disciplines: from neuroscience, by way of philosophy, to theology (Which of course, must involve U2). It has to do with the validity of (that's enough of a heresy for some church folk); even the at times primacy of (!) feeling/emotion/heart/subjectivity in the human…well, base. In neuroscience, this postulate has become common, in part due to the findings in the study of synesthesia. See, for example, the below from Dr. Richard Cytowic's "The Man Who Tasted Shapes", noting that this is not some free-spirited hippy advocating "touchy feely-ism," but an MD succinctly summarizing years of cutting-edge neuroscience research with “consciousness is a type of emotion” (188):











    I proposed that subjective experience and emotion form the quintessence that is
    uniquely human. Perhaps individuals just feel it is the right thing to do. And
    increased sensitivity to the Other and a belief in realism larger than oneself is
    not a rational attitude that people vote on or deliberately decide to adopt. It
    is an emotional one. (188)

    Recall again Bono's quote about their music "occupying an emotional terrain" so extraordinary and ex-nihilo that it simply "didn't exist before our band did."

    That's nothing you vote on, it's something you receive.

    Yet the Church in the West is obsessed with "voting rationally" (or "head-feltly"):

    "I, ___________, being of sound mind, hereby make this rational transaction/decision to be justified by faith." ("Sound mind." Why is it never "sound emotion"?)

    Or, as it was famously put by Bill Bright in “The Four Spiritual Laws" tract, and thus immortalized and canonized:

    The promise of God's Word, the Bible - not our feelings - is our authority. The Christian lives by faith (trust) in the trustworthiness of God Himself and His Word. This train diagram illustrates the relationship among fact (God and His Word), faith (our trust in God and His Word), and feeling (the result of our faith and obedience) (John 14:21).
    The train will run with or without a caboose. However, it would be useless to attempt to pull the train by the caboose. In the same way, as Christians we do not depend on feelings or emotions, but we place our faith (trust) in the trustworthiness of God and the promises of His Word.

    On one level, this is a good and helpful reminder. On another level, it primes us to caboose ; to jettison and jetsam our emotions, feelings and experience. Of all people, evangelicals speak of a "personal relationship with Jesus." How in the world do we have a relationship...let alone a "personal" one....with someone we never experience, feel for, and have emotions about?

    I once challenged a church leader who had just claimed that there is no place for experience in the Christian life; with:

    “Let me ask a question: Do you ever experience your wife?”

    He didn’t answer.

    Another conservative Bible teacher recently told me “I really like your church, but it also seems like it’s a bunch of people chasing after and experience with God.”

    I am evangelical in training; I might even be able to rattle off the Four Laws, and the “ caboose clause.” I knew that the sin of “people chasing after an experience with God” was supposed to be the unpardonable one. But in recent years I have retrained myself (And no, that doesn’t mean I became a Pentecostal!) aned have emerged in some ways as what Dave Tomlinson calls a “post-evangelical.”
    So after genuinely thanking the man for the observation, and agreeing that if it’s all about “experience as God,” then we were in deep trouble. But then I responded with a straight face:

    “A church full of people chasing an experience with God? And the problem with that is?”
    I told this story to an artist friend, and he suggested his answer was: “The only alternative is people chasing an experience without God. Is that what you want?”
    Yet it’s not only the church which fears experience/emotion:
    "What you knoe as your conscious mind is not the arbiter of whnat is real and true. It is not even the agent in the driver;s saet that wqe unthinkingly call tehs elf…the carnival amgiaivian who preteneded to be the SWizard of Oz soutyed, ‘Pay no attention to teha aman behind the curtain!’ Hw wanted all attenrion focuse on the powerful apparition he had created. Similarly, Wesytern cultures iedentify self with the seemingly powerful, ourtawrdly projected rational mind. However, the truth is that the irrational part of ousreves, the emotiponal, heuristifc mind, is the man behind the curtain and the one really in charge. (185)
    (Limbic system research) sees conscousness, language and higher mental functions as The consequences of our ability to express emotion. hEmotion is fundamental to mins, and what we call consciousness (196)

    Emotional affirmation strikes a chord precisely because it does speak to the heart instead of brain. This is perhaps why the filmmaker, artist, writer, an even the psychic (ed. note: Bono is the first three of these, and been accused of being the fourth!) are so popular in our culture .They are the cultural champions of the individual emotional needs (ed. note: If the church...and/or U2) is not the champion of emotional needs in our culture, someone else will be)….

    A pervasive distrust of our irrational intuitions and emotions is evident in stock phrases like “Sorry, I wasn't thinking.” I have never heard anyone say, “Sorry I wasn’t feeling.” (Cytowic, 218-219)

    But that is exactly what I involuntarily say/confess (very emotionally) when U2 music and lyric hit me…I repent (a very different response than "voting") of not feeling. Not Experiencing. Of worshipping the Rational Man behind the curtain. I longingly return...better, am returned… to the "emotional terrain." And I am healed. (And I’m sorry, Mr. Bible Scholar, there is no other way to receive a healing but experientially.)

    Even as I, especially as I, question God...emotionally and loudly.
    Cytowic, again; with U2 lyrics inserted:.
    We may feel, when situations are contrary to our desire, that unless we do something we will go out of our minds---which is exactly where we need to go…Such is the effectiveness of letting go and trusting (Ed. Note: Or as the message U2 literally projects in concert: “The Secret is Letting Go”).

    As Pascal said in “Pensees,” “The heart has its reasons, which reason knows not.” Reasons are nothing more than the endless paperwork of the cognitive mind, which always hunts for explanations…If we really want to enter the emotional mind, we have to let go of our belief in reasons, including such beliefs as (note: I find all these false beliefs counteracted at a U2 concert) we are not creative, nobody loves us, we will never get ahead, that we cannot express who we really are, or that all there is is what we see on the surface (“Sliding down the surface of things,” U2 sang)….The only action we have to take is to decide whether we are going to stay closed or open up, accept experience as it is or to rationalize it to death. This is what Joseph Campbell meant when he said that what we seek is not the meaning of life, but the ‘experience of being alive.’ (“I’m alive…All because of You.”( 224)

    It is only in emotional questions; as opposed to rational answers, that I am allowed to be truly human, whole/holy, and emote-ional.

    And taste the “experience of being alive,”…questions, fears, doubts and all.

    "It is (in) the constant questioning in Bono's voice where the band stakes its claim to humanity," Bruce Springsteen astutely observes. "Bono's voice often sounds like it's shouting, not from over the band, but from deep within it: 'Here we are, Lord.'"

    In additional to Cytowic’s seminal work, I also recommend an exploration of such questioning as crucial, especially through Anthony Damazio’s well-documented and well-written "Looking for Spinoza: Joy, Sorrow and the Feeling Brain,” and Jospeph LeDoux’s landmark (and landmine) “The Emotional Brain.”
    Or just stick to rock bands as we make our case.

    Aerosmith didn't sing the praises of "Sweet Intellect." That would be oxymoronic and moronic. The Rolling Stones didn't beg (God?) for a "Rational Rescue." Rescue is inherently experiential and inextricably emotional. And the one hit-wonder was not “Thinkings…Whoah, whoa, whoa…. thinkings.” Finally, BJ Thomas was never "Hooked on a Thought."


    But enough discursus from theologians who punctuate their dissertations with "Oooga-Shakka."
    And back to Bono who suggested that when writing what became the band's centerpiece of emotional/spiritual high ("Where the Streets Have No Name") song he was "after a feeling".
    What would've become of that explosive orgasmic apocalypse "experience" of a song (during which, as Beth Maynard offers: "{it's} like the heavens have opened, while Bono appears for all the while to be actually experiencing the beatific vision over at stage right" -"Get Up Off Your Knees,” p. 134) if the writer had settled for being "after a thought"?
    Thank God that writer-bird has concluded, in song ("Vertigo") and in many interviews (see below) that "a feeling's so much stronger than a thought."

    “People think I tell the band what direction to go in. The truth is, they tell me. The singer has to put into words the feelings in the music. A feeling is so much stronger than a thought."

    As we are beginning to grasp, that provocative thesis is not just a nice throwaway way for Bono to rhyme "bought" in a catchy pop song; and to pepper his interviews with quotes that conveniently interlink to his songs. This thesis, the arguing for the legitimacy and even partial primacy of emotion, is not only a profound truth that modern neuroscience and physics are proposing , in fact, it actually predates the explosive findings of modern neuroscience. We will suggest it is even traceabable to Scripture; and thus central to Christianity at its best and most de-compartmentalized (de-caboosed). But watch what the church does (or at least did in the 17th century. Thank God we we’re more enlightened…right!...now) to one who even flirts with this thesis:

    With the judgment of the angels and of the saints, we excommunicate, cut off, curse and anathematize (this man), with the consent of the elders and all this holy congregation, in the presence of the holy books: by the 613 precepts which are written therein, with the anathema wherewith Joshua cursed Jericho, with the curse which Elisha laid upon the children, and with all the curses which are written in the law. Cursed be he by day, and cursed be he by night. Cursed be he in sleeping, and cursed be he in waking, cursed in going out, and cursed in coming in. The Lord shall not pardon him, the wrath and the fury of the Lord shall henceforth be kindled against this man, and shall lay upon him all the curses written in the Book of the Law. The Lord shall destroy his name under the sun, and cut him off for his undoing from all the tribes of Israel, with all the curses of the firmament which are written in the Law * * * And we warn you that none may speak with him by word of mouth nor by writing, nor show any favor unto him, nor be under one roof with him, nor come within four cubits of him, nor read any paper composed by him.’” (recounted in Damasio, 253)

    I know this judgement sounds remarkably akin to pronouncements that contemporary church "squeakies" have made upon U2 (see this for one well-meaning [?] but well wide of the mark attempt to issue such an edict). But it is the official statement of excommunication (that's an understatement, how about "damnation") of one Spinoza. Whose heresy was offering for suggestion in the arena of ideas the radical thought that...

    ...well, everything we've been saying so far: There is a place for feelings, emotions and experience in the Christian life. Denying such basic truth opens footholds of "tribalism, racism, tryanny and religious fanaticism"(Demasio, 289).

    Spinoza knew how to experience his wife.

    And he was only being “evangelical” ahead of his time in his “personal relationship with Jesus.”

    COLORFUL COMMUNION AT THE CARNIVAL: EMOTION AS EUCHARIST

    It has been called "the worst Grammy acceptance speech of 2006 ."

    And it might have been.

    Even though it came from the mouth of our man, Bono.

    Who, in the words of the Los Angeles Times, "indulged in a cryptic acceptance speech about elephant dung."

    But in the midst of Bono's rambling, prophecy (which in our day and age is always "in part," just as the Bible predicted) almost always happens. He compared being in a rock band with running away to join the circus: "You think you’ll be the ringleader," he said, "but sometimes you end up serving as the clown, the freak, even cleaning up the elephant dirt.”

    Bono has long been fascinated by the circus (recall the song "Acrobat," partly about juggling Romans chapters 7 and 8), and its cousins Mardi Gras (witness the "Achtung Baby" album art and videos) and "carnival” (Bono has called their 9o’s songs "techno carnival" and participated in Brazil's 2006 Carnival as a guest of Brazil's Minister of Culture..,who by the way, moonlights as a pop star!).


    “If the carnival is a metaphor for existence, then it is emotion that brings color to the pageant. Emotion is an artist’s palette for each of us, supplying tints for mood and memory…We share our moods, we enjoy them, we suffer them. We trust our moods as an intimate part of the self. " (Dr. Peter C. Whyburn, "A Mood Apart," p.254)

    Intriguing connection between emotions and colors. First of all, studies in synesthesia (Cytowic) do suggest an inevitable link between emotions, colors, and what we might call "sacramental carnival.” Also, Bono has often spoken in songs ("Electrical Storm””s "Let's see colors that have never been seen"), concert asides ("We’re restless...still looking for new
    sounds, new colors"-Pop Mart Mexico City DVD), and interviews ("Many bands have one or two colors….we want all the colors!"-CBS Special: "U2: The Year in Pop") his mind (heart?) about all the emotions/colors as valid and valued in the artistic and songwriting palette.

    Until, of course, the day “the colors all bleed into one.”

    A maxim in counseling is "There is no value judgement on how you feel." We feel what we feel, that is not (at least inherently) right or wrong, it just is.

    Just is. And whatever "just is", is somehow tied up, then, with the fundamentals and fundamental-ness of reality. I feel; therefore I am.

    And I AM.

    But most church folk have a hard time imagining the I AM at a carnival.

    Or a U2 concert.

    Or having feelings His Holy Self.

    On this last point of God's "feelings" being foundational to who he is (and who "I am"), no one is more lucid than Jurgen Moltmann in the astounding (and emotional) chapter 2 of "The Trinity and the Kingdom." This making room for "emotions" in God is "not out of (his) deficiency of being; rather out of the superabundance of his creative fullness …On the contrary , the lack of any creative movenment (feeling, passion) would mean an imperfection in the Absolute." (45)

    “All this constituted the scandal of Christianity
    This was the scandal of Christianity among Jews and Greeks, among
    Pharisees
    and Stoics, and this, which was its scandal of old, the
    scandal of the Cross, is still its scandal to-day, and will continue to
    be so, even among Christians themselves--the scandal of a God who
    becomes man in order that He may suffer and die and rise again, because
    He has suffered and died, the scandal of a God subject to suffering and
    death. And this truth that God suffers--a truth that appals the mind of
    man--is the
    revelation of the very heart of the Universe and of its
    mystery, the revelation that God revealed to us when He sent His Son in
    order that he might redeem us by suffering and dying. It was the
    revelation of the divine in suffering, for only that which suffers is
    divine.


    I am well aware that in spite of my warning that I am attempting here to
    give a logical form to a system of a-logical feelings, I shall be
    scandalizing not a few of my readers in speaking of a God who suffers,
    and in applying to God Himself, as God, the passion of Christ. The God
    of so-called rational theology excludes in effect all suffering. And the
    reader will no doubt think that this idea of suffering can have only a
    metaphorical value when applied to God, similar to that which is
    supposed to attach to those passages in the Old Testament which
    describe the human passions of the God of Israel. For anger, wrath, and
    vengeance are impossible without suffering. And as for saying that God
    suffers through being bound by matter, I shall be told that, in
    the
    words of Plotinus (_Second Ennead_, ix., 7), the Universal Soul cannot be bound by the very thing--namely, bodies or matter--which is bound by
    It….
    The work of charity, of the love of God, is to endeavour to liberate God
    from brute matter, to endeavour to give consciousness to everything, to
    spiritualize or universalize everything; it is to dream that the very
    rocks may find a voice and work in accordance with the spirit of this
    dream; it is to dream that everything that exists may become conscious,
    that the Word may become life.

    We have
    but to look at the eucharistic symbol to see an instance of it.
    The Word has been imprisoned in a piece of material bread, and it has
    been imprisoned therein to the end that we may eat it, and in eating it
    make it our own, part and parcel of our body in which the spirit dwells,
    and that it may beat in our heart and think in our brain and be
    consciousness. It has been imprisoned in this bread in order that, after
    being buried in our body, it may come to life again in our spirit.

    And we must spiritualize everything. And this we shall accomplish by
    giving our spirit, which grows the more
    the more it is distributed, to
    all men and to all things. And we give our spirit when we invade other
    spirits and make ourselves the master of them.

    All this is to be believed with faith, whatever counsels reason may give
    us.

    And
    may God deny you peace, but give you glory!



    And also makes room for the full palette of emotions and colors in us.


    Especially in worship. Sacraments even.

    Bono told his interviewer (Assayas, 119)"It's almost like the two sorts of sacraments are music and friendship."

    Music and friendship. Isn't that how carnival....and life...feel; in essence? And even if literal carnivals (especially the excesses built into Mardi Gras/Brazilian variety) can allow emotions to drive the train, no questions asked (Bill Bright had a point), the concept of colorful and emotional carnival is inextricably a Kingdom connection, and insufferably sacramental. Carnival is church.

    The problem is sometimes church is carnival.

    Or how about switching metaphors slightly to "fiesta"?

    As another amazing book, "Living on the Border: What the Church Can Learn From Immigrant Cultures," would have it:
    The Eucharist is a type of fiesta...also in the sense that Gadamer uses the term. It is a dramatic act whose nature is a repitition-with-a-differeence:
    "From its inception-whether instituted in a single act or introduced gradually--the nature of a festival is to be celebrated regularly. Thus its own original essence is always to be something different...even when it is celebrated in exactly the same way (Hans Georg Gademer, "Truth and Method,” p.12)
    Every time the eucharist is celebrated, its at once a unique event and an identically reenacted one. And as a dramatic event, its draped in a festival like mantle that according to Gadamer, covers even the act of interpretation itself. (Interpretation is, after all, just such a repetition with a difference...There is ample warrant, following Gadamer, to regard most of what the church does in worship and common life as being festive.)" (169)
    That excerpt is so loaded with Bono-connections that there is no doubt he would personally amen it. First of all, by his own confession to Rolling Stone Magazine (a great priestly source to hear confession…as are talk shows, according to a famous Bono lyric) his life and music are inherently sacramental: "If feels (Note that word again) like there's a blessing on the band...music is a kind of sacrament." On "repetition with a difference,” Bono has said of concerts and his conducting mass...er, singing lead: "The hard part is making it look spontaneous." Beth Maynard has called helpful attention to the liturgical flow of U2 concerts. Dennis Hopper, in the previously quoted TV special said of U2, "U2 is still writing 'Sunday, Bloody, Sunday,' it's just that this time around it's called 'Please." Catholic clergy desperate to breathe life and variety must inject variation, induct re-writes and infuse creativity at prescribed places only (or in inflection and gesture. Hello, Father Bono!) , as some portions of the Mass (set list) are mandated and standardized by the Vatican (fan popularity decides concert staples).
    The hard part must indeed be making it look spontaneous.
    Which by a real-time miracle and rugged insistence, U2 can manage extraordinarily well after nearly two decades and thousands of performances (masses) of "Where the Streets Have No Name." Every fan (congregant) worth their admission ticket price (offering) knows what's coming as the haunting keyboard intro (introit) stirs. And we know more or less what to expect in the first two minutes from the singer (priest/celebrant). But it is spontaneously planned liturgy; by the Book AND by the Spirit. Whatever shape, style, feeling or color the spoken or sung psalm/death wail/glossolalia takes, it does NOT look hard for Bono to "make it look spontaneous." Even though we have the lectionary memorized.
    Where the people of God gather, there is order; St. Paul said. But this same saint also insisted "Where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is freedom".

    Carnival. Fiesta.
    Ironically, but appropriately, Bono may well plan on a given night to announce "The Spirit is in the house tonight."
    The story is told of a pastor of a congregation not used to liturgy. He wanted to introduce the folks to a bit of it through the classic response:
    "The Lord be with you."
    "And also with you."
    So for several weeks, they practiced. "Remember, now, when I say, 'The Lord be with you,'" you all respond with 'And also with you.'" They decided they would show off their newfound expertise in liturgy to all the guests at Easter service.
    Week after week, they were catching on. They perfected through practice.
    Finally came the big Sunday, when they would officially incorporate this new liturgy without any rehearsal or instructions. The crowd was large; the Easter expectancy palpable.
    The pastor smiled in anticipation as he rose to the pulpit to announce "The Lord be with you," knowing the people would be primed and prepared.
    They were.
    But at the precise moment the pastor was about to begin, he noticed there was something wrong with the pulpit microphone.
    So he said just that: "There is something wrong with this microphone."
    To which the people perfunctorily and proudly responded: "And also with you."
    There is nothing wrong with Bono's microphone.
    But there are two things true of all of us:
    The Lord is with us.
    Something is wrong with each of us.

    We often even “want to get it wrong.” As Bono startlingly and unabashedly admitted (“Ultaviolet”).
    Which is why we need honest liturgy, drawing from the full range of emotions.
    Including “blasphemous” ones like "My God, My God, why have you forsaken me?"
    Or as U2 ...in equally liturgically and emotionally correct form ...have cried:
    "Jesus, help me. I'm alone in this world; and a f*#%ed up world it is, too…Wake up, Dead Man!”
    Don’t call the censors or the heresy detectors or the Feeling Police. Don’t bother complaining to Bill Bright.
    The boys have simply paraphrased Psalm 44.

    And also with you.

    But more of it.
    To append and update Dennis Hoppers astute observation: “U2 is still doing Psalm 44, it’s just that now it’s called "Wake Up, Dead Man”
    Or as the boys even more recently sang/psalmed in “A Man and a Woman, "you are gone and so is God."
    I make the case that both the dramatic postmodern carnivalesque and "secular" Zoo TV U2 of the 90s ("Wake Up Dead Man"; as well as the more positive, less ironic celebratory praises of the next decade's discs and concerts are both church as carnival, and equally allowable as sacramental.
    U2 is still doing Wake Up Dead Man,” It’s just that now its called "A Man and a Woman.”
    We dare not deny baptism of and place for ruthless honesty, genuine feeling, and well, relationship in the faith-walk, both "in church" and "in the world."
    For a good time, try tracing the usages of the word “feel” in the 90’s U2 material; connecting dots to the same term in the current decade’s catalog, and note how U2 have simply updated and re-contexted (“same thing with a difference”) their poetry and liturgy to better fit the times; and well, how the band currently "feels":
    ""Do you feel loved?" becomes "Do you feel anything at all?"
    "I feel numb" morphs into to "I feel your love teaching me."
    "I feel I'm drifting out to shore." shapeshifts into "Sky falls; it feels like it's a beautiful day."
    Excuse me?
    How could any day in which the sky falls be filed under "beautiful"?
    Only in the Kingdom Carnival.
    As U2 friends Switchfoot have captured by their album title: "The Beautiful Letdown." And as Sixpence None The Richer have likewise caught by their disc title: “This Beautiful Mess.”
    Too honest; too paradoxical, huh?
    Good.
    Switchfoot, by the way, has said “We are Christian by faith, not by genre.”

    Important point. One of the reasons that Switchfoot, Sixpence and U2 are among the select class of Heaney’s “bird(s) who sing close to what really happens” is that they realize like few others that:
    "God is interested in truth, and only in truth. And that's why God is more interested in Rock & Roll music than Gospel... Many gospel musicians can't write about what's going on in their life, because it's not allowed …If you can't write about what's really going on in the world and your life ...and doubt... because it's all happy-clappy... Is God interested in that? I mean, 'Please, don't patronize Me! (laughter) I want to go the Nine-Inch-Nails gig, they're talking the truth!" (-Bono, as if you couldn’t have guessed!)

    To tweak the carnival/fiesta a little more, it might even become flamenco. More specifically: “holy duende”. In a perceptive article in “Pop Matters” (indeed!), David Kootnikoff finds that:
    At their best, they achieve what very few artists in any genre can: they create work with a sustained intensity that transforms the particular into the universal. U2 has that rare ability to communicate what the late Spanish writer, Frederico Garcia Lorca called 'duende'; that "mysterious power which everyone senses and no philosopher explains" (In Search of Duende, 1998, New Directions.)
    Popularly associated with flamenco dancing, the concept of duende originated in the south of Spain centuries ago and has since migrated over to the English language. The Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary gives its meaning as "the power to attract through personal magnetism and charm", but it's much more than that. In 1933, Lorca gave his famous lecture, La Teoria y Juego del Duende (The Play and Theory of the Duende) in Buenos Aires detailing his conception of duende:
    "I have heard an old master guitarist say: 'Duende is not in the throat; duende surges up from the soles of the feet.' Which means it is not a matter of ability, but of real live form; of blood; of ancient culture; of creative action."
    the exuberance of what could be, the limitless possibilities inherent in what Lorca called "newly created things" that duende conveys and U2 embodied.

    Live form? Ancient culture? Must be U2. Bono once (in the “Elevation” tour program “U2 on its own is a very interesting group and all, but U2 with its audience is a culture.” Remember Bono at Brazil’s Carnival, appearing with that nation’s Minister of Culture and popstar. Bono of all people knows that being both is not only not a contradiction in terms, but perhaps required.
    Another writer has seen U2 not just as a culture, but a corporation..,as anything corporate inevitably defaults and backslides into:
    "At one level, U2 is just these four guys making some music. But they're also not that at all. They're so huge that it becomes something else entirely. They're like Coca-Cola. As a commodity, as a corporately manufactured and distributed entertainment commodity, they — to me — become totally legitimate targets and you don't have to worry about what their feelings are or ask permission or anything." ( "Suits, Lawsuits, and Art: Negativland Takes On The Man" by Deuce of Clubs )

    U2 HAVE NO BORDER PROBLEM: PERMEABLE MEMBRANE AND MATRIX
    U2 have no border problem.
    Bono once blew off a question about the origin of the Edge’s nickname with “He’s always on the edge between something and nothing." More precisely, the band…corporately and corporationly speaking… is not afraid to travel the edge and border between significant somethings and other significant somethings. Which of course is a sacramental thing.
    "The church is not an enclave of refugees from the world; it is the sacrament of God's presence in the world by the Mystery of the incarnation. It's not supposed to look as little like the world as possible but as much like the world as it can manage. Otherwise, the world will never be able to recognize, in such a parochial culling of supposedly sinless humanity, anything even vaguely resembling its true face. It will just go on seeing in us the same old unforgiving face that already greets it in the mirror every morning. For the fellowship of the baptized is simply the world in all its sinfulness, dampened by the waters of forgiveness."
    -Robert Farrar Capon, The Astonished Heart
    Maybe Brian’s mom was right: Bono is both messianic AND a very naughty boy.


    The “border problem”? We need to, in the great theological phrase of the Taco Bell commercials “run for the border.” Running from the border is only running to stand still.

    As I have been recently gathering insights about “centered set” (versus “bounded set” or “bordered set” theory (see this page: http://3dff.com/php/viewtopic.php?t=386), and a studying a cross-cultural theology of borders (the "Living on the Borders” book already quoted); this has made me ponder the probability of permeable membranes in life, and in the Kingdom. Then along comes a surprisingly helpful piece on Chuck Colson's page about the band Green Day (spin their "Jesus of Suburbia" song sometime): which quotes a Catholic about a place that might be "uniquely a permeable 'border' between the mundane and the transcendent, the visible and the invisible, the ordinary and the extraordinary, the human and the divine"


    Place Vetigo or the heavenly Place…where strrtes have no name” Both. Precisely. Bordelandsa we run…

    Jesus walksed the boder jonm 4

    ”Thats a Green Day gif, betteyt ye U2 worship ecep. Shoukd be church. IF itw ernt mystem faulre.

    Very good connections By the way, the last lines of the Matrix, before Neo's "ascension," which serve as a Great Commission recruitment are: "SYSTEM FAILURE: Welcome to a world without rules, borders and boundaries" means several things, in typical postodren and prophetic fashion.

    First: the old religious system/matrix/wineskin has failed. Now is the time for the church to bless (in certain areas, granted) what it always considered heresy: permeable membranes, boundarylessness, another Matrix connection, in the 2nd movie, the Trainman serves as the only person allowing entre into the Matrix or the real world. He serves in a no man's land, literally "living on the borders". he is very guarded about who he lets on the train to move from one world to the other...but in positive spin, could be a border guard who gives up the old rules and allows the membrane to be permeable..


    tARIN mAN BiLL bRIGHT, discerning which feelinsg can be riddena ll the wy, And as the end of the first Matrix movie portrays, we have often been told "the sky's the limit." that sounds good, optimistic and a Jesus kind of thing. But it's too small. Lindell Cooley sings "Open Up the Sky!"http://www6.instantestore.net/merchant5588/pd_open.cfm Click over to Len's Next Reformation website( http://www.nextreformation.com/) and put your mouse over the archway picture at top to read the wave-over text that appears..it's related
    No we don’t. e sgoudl and could Don’;t. Norm or form of most church meeting

    ----

    LAMENT ALL FEELINGS...APOPHATIC AND AGNOSTICISM



    The presence in feeling of a life totality that transcends the present moment is a presupposition for the behavior of a living being .

    (Compared to thought...)Fundamental feeling is stronger.(261)
    Pannenberg's massive missive "Anthropology in Theological Perspective""


    Uh, Bon reading pammeberh "A feelig's so much syronfer tahan a thoughtr. Cponfess
    up the eante and evoidence


    The feeling of being seized and empowered becomes intelligible, a feeling that at the same time is accompanied by a letting oneself be seized, by a feeling of being elevated above the everyday, and by the acquisition of hitherto unspusected powers.(265)

    Ckear connections; typival U2 gig "acheives liftoff" trth leeting go elevation rabbliv prayer techiue

    There is certainly a danger here that the object of passion may be taken to represent absolute fulfillment, so that onbsseiona nd bondage are the fresult But passion can also be a response to the call of God (wjo remains transcendent) in the concrete situations of the world of every day life, a response to a call that elevates indivudaula bove the everyday and renfer tem capable of extrdeaordinary dedication, witjiut caising ftehm to be blinded by sfalse absolutes


    Peterson uw qualms ptrophetic music too much:

    Feelings are the scourge of prayer. To pray by feelings is to be at the mercy of glands and weather and digestion. And there is no mercy in any of them. Feelings lie. Feelings deceive. Feelings seduce. Because they are so emphatically there, and so incontrovertibly interior, it is almost inevitable that we take our feelings seriously as reputable guides to the reality that is deep within us--our hearts before God.

    But feelings are no more spiritual than muscles. They are entirely physical. They are real, and they are important. But they are real and important in the same way that our fingernails and noses are important--we would not want to live without them (although we could if we had to), but their length and shape and color tell us nothing about our life with God. To suppose that our emotions in any way give us reliable evidence of the nature or quality of our life with God is to misinterpret them. They are wonderful and necessary and glorious. They are part of the rich and stunning complexity of the human being in the image of God. We must value and develop and share them. But they are not prayer.

    But how do we both affirm our feelings and detach ourselves from them? Through liturgy. We pray not when we feelk like it but when someone, the pastor, the priest, the choir,aster (or Bono) says “Let us pray” (unoffesive way bloffgegd ). We lose nothing of our emotions except theiot rtraynny. The gamut of emotions experienced in our human condirion is given full exporession in the psalms. We pray through easch plasm and hit every note, sound every tome of feeling…But th feelings do not have the firsty and controlling word. The feelings are incorporated in the prayers, not trhe prayers in th feelings. LKiturgical prayer misse not a sungke heartbeat of feelings, but refuses evena hint of doirection from them (87-088)



    Through liturgy..whiuch is sacramental..metaphorival infoirmes

    “Coroptrate liturgical worship


    “In prayer the task is not to rarify language into an abstract spirituality but to thicken it with the metaphors of weather and geography and enmity into a spirituality of honest and actual experience.”
    He then talks about the tendency to make spirituality more spiritual than material.

    Full circle
    “…for metaphor is an affront to their gossamer immaterialities and inner-ring whispers, a loud fart in the salon of spirituality.”

    Psalms and Metaphor (hmmm synonymous)conquers gnostisma, and the by definition, “music of what reallky jappnes” “harmonies not natal but achived”
    “actual ecperience

    In a later book by Eugene Peterson, “Eat This Book: A Conversation in the Art of Spiritual Reading,” Peterson makes intriguing, contrasting and “paradoxing” observations about translation. These comments are highly germane as eucharistic priests (like Bono) and songwriters (like Bono) are inevitably translators .
    First, he quotes, Franz Rosenzweig:
    “Every translation is a messianic act, which brings redemption nearer.” ( p. 119).
    Then he compliments JB Phillips, by saying that for him:
    “Translation (is) a pastoral act.” (174)
    And he admits, translator that he is, that “Translation is betrayal” (170).

    So, which is it? Is translation inherently messianic or betrayal.

    The only answer is “yes.”

    Which is why Peterson can talk about metaphor being simultaneously so holy that it “signals transcendence and encounter with the One who speaks everything into being’ (98), and simultaneously call it “literally a lie” (94).