Showing posts sorted by relevance for query michael knott. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query michael knott. Sort by date Show all posts

Sunday, March 14, 2010

Today's Michael Knott radio

From three eras of the genius of Michael Knott

1)The Smallest Part (with Cush):


i'm an empty man
Swimming for the prize
Folding up my hands
For the fool inside

Christ, crush my head
Break those cloudy skies
Sing my song instead
For my fleeting life

To build a breathing heart
I'll do... I'll do the smallest part

For Christ to build my heart
I'll do, I'll do the smallest part




2)..and some vintage Knott (As Lifesavers Underground):

...Few songs capture the genius of Mike Knott and L.S.U. the way "Tether to Tassel," "Die Baby Die," "There's a Time" and "English Interpreter of English" do. For that matter, few careers warrant this kind of retrospective. However Lifesavers Underground have been a source of encouragement and enlightenment, and to some, controversy. Still, to those of us who turn to the laments of the Psalms and to Jesus' words upon the cross to make sense of the chaos of consciousness, L.S.U. was a positive witness. Faith does not wither in the face of doubt, it makes us better Christians, better people.

As Knott sings in "Shaded Pain:"

"What about the love we never find
Cut by the body forced to run and hide
What about the human, the human I am inside
How can we be forgiven if we don't live our lives
We throw off the shackles and then we wear the chains
shaded pain
we find out who we are and then we lose our names
shaded pain."

We are meant for more than this life. By loving one another, accepting our individual experiences and seeking to grow in caring and understanding, we can make a difference. We can leave the shade for the bright, warm light of love, where we are lonely boys and girls no more.

-by Brian Q. Newcomb
Former Editor and Founder, Syndicate
Newcomb is now a pastor in St. Louis who writes about pop and rock music, "whenever they'll let him."
-link





--
3)Bonus: LSU: perhaps his most devastating prophetic song:

Sunday, May 22, 2011

Two versions of "Jesus"

Which version of Michael Knott's
"Jesus" do you like the best?
>>The first is from his "Fluid" album, and comes in the context of a story; a girl crying out to Jesus from a car crash.. (academic paper: Investigating the Fluid album, by Aaron Taylor).  Here the official title is  "Tonight"..


>>A bit later the song was greatly rocked up, and lyric-ed up for the "Aunty Bettys" project...studio version and concert video.below.

1)"Tonight" ("Jesus") by Michael Knott (Fluid album)

TONIGHT

Jesus wont you take me in your arms tonight,
Jesus won't you save me from harm tonight?
I didn't know,
I didn't know which road was
wrong,
Which road was right
 
Jesus wont you save me from this blaming voice tonight,
Jesus wont you forgive me of my losing choice tonight?
Did I know, did I know
Which road was wrong, which road was right?
Did I know which road?


2)Jesus"  by Aunt Betty's Ford (Michael Knott)l

Jesus, won't you help me find my way
Won't you send me some money in the mail
Jesus, won't you let me drink one more
It helps me to ignore how much I have failed

I'm gettin' sick
gettin' ill
gettin' tired
gettin' fired
I'm gettin' killed
I'm gettin' chilled
I'm gettin' crazy

I'm gettin' lazy
I'm gettin' screwed
I'm gettin' used
I'm gettin' kicked
I'm gettin' tricked
I'm gettin' out

gettin' out
gettin' out
gettin' out

I'm gettin' ... high
I'm gettin' ... high

Jesus, I could keep my family
if You could just send me some money in the mail
Jesus, I don't mean to complain
but it gets cold, it gets lonely inside a cell

I'm gettin' sick
I'm gettin' ill
I'm gettin' tired
of gettin' fired
I'm gettin' killed
I'm gettin' chilled
I'm gettin' crazy
I'm gettin' lazy
I'm gettin' screwed
I'm gettin' used
I'm gettin' kicked
I'm gettin' tricked
I'm gettin' out
gettin' out
gettin' out
gettin' out

I'm gettin' ... high
I'm gettin' ... high

high, gettin' high
whoa-whoa-whoa
high, gettin' high

I'm gettin' sick
I'm gettin' ill
I'm gettin' tired
I'm gettin' fired
I'm gettin' killed
I'm gettin' chilled
I'm gettin' lazy
I'm gettin' crazy
I'm gettin' screwed
I'm gettin' used
I'm gettin' kicked
I'm gettin' tricked
I'm gettin' out
gettin' out
gettin' out
gettin' out ...

Friday, November 20, 2009

David Crowder and Todd Rundgren Do Church Music



By the way,

David Crowder is a friend of mine...



Yes, I agree with many reviewers that David Crowder Band's new "Church Music" is amazing, and a keeper...whether it will keep as long as "A Colission" remains to be seen.

What I long for on it is more creative, and not as predictable, lyrics. I know he can do it, but I am not sure my complaint is valid..he likely is doing straight up worship lyrics because he is supposed to. Of course, the negative spin on this is, as Patrol magazine was brave enough to say, the band is “wedded to the humdrum contemporary-worship form.”

But who am I to want a Michael Knott twist in every other song, when Ryan (who has opened up for Michael Knott and knows his good music) likes it...and when songs like this below transport me into the heavenlies, even if (because?) I can predict the next line:


The electronica on the album works well, as does the non-stop seguing of songs. Those two elements recall for me another candidate in some peoples books as one of the best albums of all time, Todd Rundgren's 1973 "A Wizard, A True Star,"....though of course that disc is not "Christian," and carries an explicit lyrics warning.

Which is perhaps precisely why I would love it if Crowder had thrown in a bit of a Rundgren wrench into the worship mix!

But do I really want:
"Earthquake in New York City
The Chrysler building fell in my yard
But when the s*^# hits the fan,
I've got to find my way back t0 Sunset Boulevard

on a Crowder worship album?

Why not? Isn't that canonical and kosher "church music"?


And how about a hidden track cover of "Is it My Name" with it's prophetic/pathetic line:
"You only love me for my machine"?


That would work well.
Who cares if it sells on CCM?

Hey, one song on "Wizard" even mentions prayer and the Golden Rule..it's ready for Chrisian radio.

And this:

Another virgin mary, another case is shut
Have another helping, prime cut of baby's butt
A sip of holy water, a shot of saving grace
Another western mystic, the words pore out my face
("Just Another Onionhead"
)


Oh, it just hit me, too. The lyrics on BOTH albums can seem a bit throwaway.
Maybe they're both profound..underneath the surface.

Maybe both albums are versions of U2's "Pop" both musically and lyrically.


Rundgren's bizarre, campy album ( Patti Smith's (R rated) review is a fascinating read) was perhaps the only way he could follow up to "Something/.Anything," which many consider the definitive pop album of all time.
In light of that juxtaposition, some see "AWATS" as a throwaway/novelty album , some see as sheer genius.. I thought it was a bit of both when I first heard it in the 70s.

My verdict still stands.

No doubt how Barney Hoskyns ( Mojo magazine) feels:

"Sometimes," Todd Rundgren sang, "I don't know what to feel." But sometimes you do know what to feel. And right now I feel like saying what I've contended for many years, which is that Rundgren's A Wizard, A True Star is simply The Greatest Album Ever Made.

You heard me right, pardner. Better than Pet Sounds. Better than OK Computer. Certainly better than Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Farts Dub Band. An album of vaulting ambition - of wizardry and true stardom - released into an unsuspecting world by a contrary, super-precocious wonderboy who should have been the biggest thing to happen in the '70s but who was just too complex and polymorphous for lasting pop success.

A Wizard, A True Star came out 35 years ago but still sounds more bravely futuristic than any ostensibly cutting-edge electro-pop being made in the 21st Century. A dizzying, intoxicating rollercoaster ride of emotions and genre mutations, the album was substantially the work of Rundgren himself, pieced together in late 1972 at his own Secret Sound studio on NYC's West 24th Street.

Barney Hoskyns for Mojo



Here's a helpful review from Amazon.com:

Something/Anything? Purists Be Damned,
By Samhot (Star Land) -

I'm sure many fans who know and love Todd Rundgren think that _Something/Anything?_ is his definitive (and best) musical statement. Well, if you worship Rundgren based only on that side of his musical personality, you'll probably want to walk the opposite direction of _A Wizard, A True Star_, which may be considered sheer musical blasphemy. _Something/Anything?_ was mostly an accessible (but diverse) pop/r&b/rock record, with the occasional 'bizarre' tune. However, on this outing, Todd dives head-neck-shoulders-torso-legs (you get the idea) into sheer outrageousness.

Almost everything about _A Wizard, A True Star_ is unconventional. Aside from the malleable genre-plowing and bizarre musical soundscapes, a large percentage of the disc (mainly the first half) contains many 1-minute tracks that flow seamlessly into the other - making this seem like a short 'best of' sampler. But, don't let these rather 'short' time-lengths fool you - this album is a rich, gargantuan slice of audio schizophrenia, which requires 'close' listening - possibly with a good pair of headphones. There are so many subtle complexities buried beneath the hyperactive surface, you can miss out on some aspects that bring out the 'life' of this album - as well as missing out on some truly enriching experiences. However, for the fan of Todd's 'accessible' side, there are a few of those nuggets to be found here...


...A very powerful album - complex, trippy, cerebral, futuristic, original and unexpectedly moving. _A Wizard, A True Star_ may not be what many fans originally wanted from Todd Rundgren, but he made an album that exhibits talent and prophecy, which arguably sounds ageless - given it was released in 1973. Highly recommended to progressive rock fans, as well as those who have a taste for mind-altering, adventurous and/or challenging music.

-Review by Samhot, Amazon.com


And interestingly...maybe inevitably...Rundgren is currently (2009) on tour, performing the entire AWATS album for the first time ever..
Rundgren explains below how it came about, but part of the answer is renewed interest in the kind of electronic techno vibe that TR helped invent almost forty years ago:



How about a double bill with Crowder and Rundgren since both band are already on the road?
Sure;y some Christian promoter will be brave enough to jump on it..

(smirk)

..and besides, it would be worth it to see Rundgren and Crowder singing along to this as the encore:



I still want U2 to open up, playing all of "Pop"..but with the Clawthedral.

Bonus below! Rundgren discussing "Music, Technology and Risk-Taking" , as the 2009 DePauw's Ubben Lecture:



And an interview with (" I'm not a Christian and I am not a materialist")
Rundgren here" (PDF). See also "The Spiritual Journey of Todd Rundgren. Part One"
and Part Two.


Friday, April 23, 2010

Church: Lessons from Brand X: Shadow Gold, Risky Wiki, and Wordless Vocals


What can we learn about life and church from Brand X?

The band Brand X, that is.
One of the best bands you never heard of.
(Tons of churches are like that...as it should be?)

No one is completely sure how to classify them: progressive fusion and free jazz come close.

But all agree on one classification:
They are anything but 1970s Genesis.
Which was precisely the point.

Smack in the middle of their run of classic, intricate, theatrical, progressive...quite often prophetic rock, Phil Collins (long before he became........... whatever he is now) of Genesis felt the need to use the other side of his brain, and swim in completely different waters as a side project, so he created Brand X by inviting some other brilliant musicians into a fusion/jazz-ish collaborative.

What then can church/ecclesiology glean from Brand X?

I will draw examples largely from their classic album, "Moroccan Roll"( amazon reviews):

1) To use the mixed metaphor inspired by my preaching professor (the one who had us create fairy tales and collages),"Your gold is in your shadow side."

This is not a Genesis album.. So I guess it makes no sense (or compete sense) that in the 70s i loved both the intricate, classically-inspired progresoive rock of that era's Genesis, and also the loosse fusion of Brand X (which I never would've been introduced to if not for the Genesis connection, fusion didn't sound like my genre). I came to love the shadow side of my taste and preferences, but I had to be indirectly hijacked (how's that for an oxymoronic metaphor?)

Right around this time, Bill Bruford of Yes tried to tour as the second drummer for Genesis...but he found that he inevitably wanted to play free, spontaneously, and play something a little different every night...which didn't work with Genesis' tight, meticulous, intentional and by they note-ness. Genesis' 1970s opuses were unpredictable (for a pop listener) in their twists and turns and time signature morphings, but in a completely predictable, note-by-note way, at least for the players and fans. Not a lot of room for wildly freeform detours and contours.

So Bruford left, and ironically (or inevitably)his highly successful replacement (to this day) was Chester Thompson (a Christian, btw) of jazz fusion band Weather Report.

Brand X may not have been the opposite of Genesis, but it's shadow...even a close cousin.
Both band did long and extended well...but one was tight and loose...or better yet, loose in its tightness and the other tight in its looseness.

An obvious leap for Phil if he wanted obvious opposite would have been from long and complex to short and simple. But Brand X was often just as long and complex as Genesis, but just from another style. Collins later definitely lept from long to short in his solo career).

Sometimes we are closer to our shadow and our salvation than we realize.
Yet we often don't go there as it doesn't feel like us.

I am so low church that I am high church without wanting to be or trying to be.
Or is it the other way around?

Brand X may not have been completely different waters than Genesis at all, but simply a previously unexplored tributary of the same body of work/water.

Richard Foster was inspired (read all about it here, but soundtrack it to Brand X) in calling the Body to draw from all streams of living water.
I wonder what he has in his CD player right now?

2)Collaboratives/wikis are required but risky...and rarely last in pure form

Brand X was designed to be, and largely was, a democratic experiment of equals...the independent, creative genius of each player was honored and followed...even with an obvious 'star' member. Of course, that this was largely an instrumental band helped...Though Phil was the drummer, he did occasionally "sing,' but never in a traditional way(more on that in the next point) but he was never (literally)the frontman. He hid behind the pulpit/drumkit.
That is the point of paradox.

Many will remember the amazing Cush, The catch it was to be a collaborative with no stars or frontmen...but it was fronted by star Michael Knott..

All churches should read the "Cush Manifesto"..and would do well to adopt it, but it is the harder, if holier way. Especially hard if your vocalist/preacher is charismatic, (in either sense of the term):

Cush is not a band. Not in the conventional way anyhow. Cush is far to hard to define. Certainly, the mystery can breed the legend...but the facts are, Cush isn't a mythical super band...but a gathering of friends. This is not to say Cush doesnÍt have some lofty goals. In the Cush manifesto that circulated shortly before the band debuted, it was proclaimed that Cush was "the new sound for the new decade". But even more so, the hope is for Cush to be unlike any other production the public has seen. "We wanted Cush to be more liquid," explains Eric Campuzano. "Anybody could be the singer, anybody could play the guitar, you know, like there never is really a central figure in the group. Like if we thought Andy could sing a song better than Mike Knott, then Andy should sing it...or vice versa."

Of course, Eric admits such a thing is easier said than done. "Reality is that, if you want to write a record, you have to write the record and you need facilitators to do that." Comprised mainly of members of popular early to mid-nineties modern rock band the Prayer Chain and the prolific alt-rocker Michael Knott, Cush runs the risk of being recognized more for itÍs members than the product itself. "Some people think of it as Mike's new project or our new project...and itÍs nothing like that at all, " Campuzano clarifies. "We had no desire...I really dont want to be a part of something like that. That's why we just listed the performers. No band shots, no lyrics...no credits. At times those...I guess it just takes away from the whole vibe behind it. "


The Cush Manifesto:


In a declaration of Truth and its winding road, members of the Prayer Chain, LSU, Honey, Fold Zandura, Duraluxe, Bloomsday, the Lassie Foundation, and Adam Again, have agreed to document below (the CUSH Manifesto) in which all members will seek the Truth and its Consequences. The result, A New Sound: CUSH.


The CUSH Manifesto


The Foundation of CUSH is: God. Jesus. The Holy Spirit. King David and The Psalms. Love. Celebration. Longing. Giving. Purity. Innocence. Faith. Pain. Gospel. The earliest Rock and Roll. Willing to change and grow with others. Willing to have anybody play any role, whoever is most suited for it at the time. Willing to be anonymous. Willing to be produced. Sharing, being selfless, letting go. Being Honest. The song winning. Soul. Letting your ego get you there, and then sacrificing it when the time comes. Music being able to be performed in any way, by any combination of people, in any setting. Being Free, Creative, Spontaneous. One instrument per part, one player per part. Minimal overlapping of tones. A Groove. A Drone. A Basic Progression. An acoustic guitar. An electric guitar. A bass guitar. A six-string bass guitar. A piano. An organ. A horn section. A cello. A violin. A viola. A voice. A hand-drum. A tambourine. All things that make a sound when you shake them. Washing everything in the dreamiest of reverb-effects until you can't tell what it is, but rather what it feels like.


Doing the thing you always wanted to do but were afraid to. Jumping off the deep end of the peer. Staring Fear in the face and walking right into it with a faithful heart. Turning your life upside-down.


CUSH is from the core of your relationship with God -- Good, Bad, and Ugly -- and reaching out in Moans and Groans to Him.
CUSH praises like Gospel, and wails like Rock and Roll.
CUSH feels the best, and hurts the most at the same time.
CUSH sounds familiar, like the best songs you've ever heard, but feels new.
CUSH is an Action.
A CUSH song does not have to be 3:30 long.
A CUSH song can be 68 minutes long.
A CUSH song is already a greatest hit. From the slowest, most isolated place, just before God, bowing down, quiet, heavenly noise, swelling, droning, heaving, glowing, flickering, underwater, the true reality, connecting spiritually with God and seeing all of humanity through His eyes. The true nature of Love and everything. Placid but full of colour, vivid life, musical movements, sounds, dreams, asleep but still awake, alive yet dead, dead yet alive. Alone, but not lonely. Haunting sad, painfully beautiful, moving, majestic, heart-wrenching, yet humble meek, and poor in spirit. Drone, Middle Eastern, heavy, rock, epic, magnificent, cross poly-rhythmic, whatever-wherever music, where all heaven and earth are in His command.
CUSH is not about self-loathing.
CUSH is not about editing yourself before giving.
CUSH is not a solo project.
CUSH is not a band.
In CUSH, you win by letting yourself lose.
CUSH is a concept, an ideal, a greater goal, a principle.
CUSH is a beautiful spirit shared by all.
CUSH is like 'the Force', ...But better.

-link

But the magnificent manifesto was hard to live up (or dial down) to. You know, contrary to what you would have guessed by the quotes above, at least on its main album, all songs were sung by the senior pastor (Knott).
They imploded. Brilliantly, I might add.

A church I know launched out with a model of three pastors, team leadership of equals.
That model lasted a little while and imploded... brilliantly, I must add.
Now they have two pastors:
One is technically the lead pastor, but it is still a collaborative, Cush-y fluid church.

Brand X in its original incarnation lasted a few years..though they have reunited without Phil.
(Sometimes the guitar replaces Phil's vocal, hear it later
).

In a church gatherings, I often comment that I am the man up front claiming it's not about the man up front.

There is no front, even when I am up there.

I may implode....brilliantly would be nice.



3)Wordless vocals can speak louder than words.
On those rare occasions when Brand X songs include vocals, they were never classically vocalized...or hardly ever in English ("Sun in the Night" was subversively in Sanskrit, sample snippet here). By the time they recorded "Streets of Soho" with Phil singing an almost pop lyric in English, I wandered of their days were numbered.

Here some posts on wordless vocals often taking us into realm of glossolalia, or instrumental "playing in tongues":


I love one movement (video, 3:37ff here) of the Brand X Song, "And So To F"....Phil's vocals might be transcribed as a mindless "la-la,"....but are moving beyond words to me..

Martins Smith (of Delirious)'s prayer language (I am in awe that some of his glossolalia moments are not excised from some concert CDs by Christian companies that may even be cessationist!) seems to be loaded with "La la"s that counterintuitively speak volumes.
(But as he once told Ken and I, "only in America," does the church seem not to get it).

Here's two Delirious examples (they must be online somewhere!) of what i mean:

  • From the "Access: D" album, play 4:01-4:17 of "I Could Sing of Your Love Forever." Here, many hear Smith singing ecstatically in tongues. He is actually(also) singing in Spanish (I remember the first time I visited a Spanish-speaking Pentecostal church...i was never sure if they were singing in tongues or in Spanish..or both (:...)
  • From the same album, play 2:07ff of "Access D Part 6: Lord You Have My Heart." Dare you to transcribe it. Better yet, interpret it. Best yet, soak in it.

The Bono "OOOHH" death wail (and nigun rap) are also always chilling beyond words.
Words should chill out and disappear, so they can chill and appear.

How about Phil Collins' "throwaway" or "scat" (or not) vocals on
"Disco Suicide's third (or so) movement:


It may be that the band's only choice when they reunited without Phil, and performed this song was to "replace"...better yet, "translate" or "interpret" (as in interpretation of tongues) his vocals via guitar (video here).


For those called and tempted to preach, I hope I am preaching to the choir in saying:
a) that there should be more preaching BY the choir....and that
b) sometimes one word/no words are enough.

See these wordy links about being less wordy (I may have almost made the Guinness Book of World Records for shortest sermon ever (story in 2nd link), but I do not perfectly practice what I preach):


As St. Bruce once preached,"Those who know don't have the words to tell"
-----------
Well, that was 3 points and a poem...how preacher-like was that!?
Summary: What can church/preacher-types learn from Brand X?:

Shadow Gold, Risky Wiki, and Wordless Vocals!

---------------------------------------------
Bonus track, "Macrocosm," which one Amazon reviewer calls "apocalyptic" and not (just) because it ends in an explosion:

Tuesday, May 01, 2007

Praying with Pink Floyd

LATER NOTE:  see sequel  (prequel?) to this post : Well-Ended Stories That Don't End Well
-------------------------------------


And if I show you my dark side
Will you still hold me tonight?
And if I open my heart to you
And show you my weak side
What would you do?...


Thought I oughta bare my naked feelings,
Thought I oughta tear the curtain down.
I held the blade in trembling hands
Prepared to make it but just then the phone rang
I never had the nerve to make the final cut


Devastating.
Honest.
Prayer.

Or at least flirting with prayer, but too shattered to hold out much hope for a loving and living God.

Why can't church be more like Pink Floyd lyrics? (like it used to be when Jews and Psalms informed us)

I know; at their worst, they are pure depression;and listening leads to the same.
But at their best, they are anointed liturgists...even worship leaders (here) leading us in..
Devastatingly honest prayer.

Overhearing despair-prayer can also be healing and facilitate healing..

..if listened to/sung in context of church community.

And maybe when spliced/mixed with songs on the same theme, but embedded with (a glimmering of) Christian hope.

In "The Final Cut," sampled above, Roger Waters knows he should "tear the curtain down," and let his feelings emerge. He even has the knife is his hands, but can't go through with the strength of will needed to facilitate healing.

Splice into:
"Tear the curtain down; Pull the altar to the ground."

This line (from a classic  77s song...and written from a Christian framework, by a lyricist honest about depression, how about that? The last time that was tried, the singer was fired from hosting a Christian TV show...or something like that), and the music accompanying it, might be creatively merged/mashedup into the Floyd song. After all, both lyricists know deep inside the curtain is that of God's altar.
What I'm not asking for is cheesygelical sequels that straighten out all the lines, and rebuke the doubt of the original songs and their gut-level honesty.

More than adding straight-up-salvation verses to "help" Bono "find what he's looking for,"as so many well-meaning Christians do to "I Still Haven't Found...":

"There has never been a more concise theology of redemption, atonement
and the substitutionary death of Christ. No clearer proclamation of the
Gospel has ever sold so many copies...But he hasn't found what he is looking
for. I remember speaking in Dublin and seeing this rather exuberant Christian at
the front of the hall. I began my address by asking had anyone found what they
were looking for. "Amen brother. Yes Hallelujah!" I am not sure how my dear
brother came to earth as he discovered that for the next hour I was exposing
that to have found what we are looking for has nothing to do with Biblical
Christianity...So my conclusion is that U2's I Still Haven't Found What I Am
Looking For is probably the best hymn written in this century, it has the
theology of the cross but is centred in the reality of a fallen humanity and is
about striving towards a better man and a better world" (Stve Stckman,
read it
all
)


Hey, how about taking some typical upbeat Christian worship soings, and adding a verse about doubt, temptation, fear...that might be a more appropriate and biblical tweaking of theme.
After all, as Bono has paraphrased God "Don't patronize me (with happy clappy songs that don't deal with doubt)...I am going to the Nine Inch Nails gig; they're speaking the truth."



Maybe, to offer some more Pink Flood lyrics, we need to "we're just two lost souls swimming in the fish bowl year after year." After all even this moves into prayer "...wish you were here."

Sometimes that's the most spiritual prayer you can muster.
Leave the fish in the bowl for now: Jesus felt that way on Good Friday. And sometimes Good Friday shows up on Easter.

Devastating. Honest.

Like Psalm 30,which

proclaims that endings are not as final as we sometimes think they are. It does not deny the reality of the darkness. It does not deny the experience of the absence of God. And it does not deny the dismay of finding that our beliefs do not always stand up to the realities of life. But it affirms that out of that grievous experience of death can emerge a new joy, a new hope, a new future, and a new confirmation of what it is to be the people of God." source

Does no one else recognize Ecclesiastes in Pink Floyd's breathless
"Breathe"?:

And all you touch and all you see
Is all your life will ever be
Run, run rabbit run
Dig that hole, forget the sun,
And when at last the work is done
Don't sit down it's time to dig another one
For long you live and high you fly
But only if you ride the tide
And balanced on the biggest wave
You race toward an early grave.

'
Many artists who are Christians would serve as anointed bridgebuiders for honest worship gatherings...if churches would allow them: Bruce Cockburn ("Whatever was God thinking of?" is honesty not blasphemy, but simply honesty (T Bone Burnett, Alice Cooper (actually admitting sexual and demonic temptation.)

The most haunting, devastating, barely listenable (which is why I regularly listen to it, and use it as a call to prayer and honesty)song I know is by Michael Knott, madman-genius-Christian of the voluminous catalog...whether under his own name, Lifesavers Underground, LSU, Cush...
Here's the song:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Double

you're sittin' there wondering why is it like this
and the whole world's crazy and the earth is sick
and someone's yelling from the bathroom door
the toilet's overflowing on the floor
and the one by the phone
says i cannot hear
while the one by the jukebox spills his beer
and the man on the pinball hits sixteen mil
someone ducks behind the counter to pop a pill
and you reach in your pocket to see if there's more
and the biggest bill falls so you're left with four
and you're too gone to look but you still try
then you see it in the hand of a great big guy
who looks just like he'd kill you fast
and you think for a minute
you let it pass

and the stool falls over when you set back down
it bumps a mean pool shooter from across the town
he misses his shot - it's all on you
and with your last four bucks you know what you'll do
sorry man can i buy you a drink
and he shakes his head and says, make it a double

the next thing you know you wake up at home
and the little one there won't leave you alone
she's awake and hungry
she needs some potty help
and you remember what happened last time she tried it by herself
and your wife says hurry, we're late for church
and you can barely see
and your head still hurts
and the preacher starts preaching
and you feel remorse
he's got five little kids and a big divorce
and your wife looks down and says she don't know how
he's been her guiding light for ten years now
and his marriage is over, it's barely alive
and how in the world will ours ever survive?

-Knott

The juxtaposing of "church"world and "real world" is too close for comfort...and offers little; as does a pastor's divorce. The sharing and prayer time after the stunned silence that song creates would inevitably be life-changing...

is there a problem with that?

Maybe central to my calling as a pastor is to be (as Keltic Ken has coined me) "Holy Spirit' DJ.
And perhaps central to that centrality is being a party planner...or a dirge director.


We may not be ready to spin  some of these songs, or this Floyd lyric in "church" yet:

The Lord is my shepherd, I shall not want
He makes me down to lie
Through pastures green he leadeth me the silent waters by.
With bright knives he releaseth my soul.
He maketh me to hang on hooks in high places.
He converteth me to lamb cutlets..


But have you never felt a bit like that?
The Lord be with you...
...especially when..

                 even when
                                            He's not.
--------------

video:

Michael Knott, "Healing"(You've been seen with a stiff lip
It's happening to the best when the pain grips
You've been beaten by the bell
In all that you do
You thought Hell was a place one goes to
But your Hell on Earth is true

This is the healing)

Thursday, June 21, 2007

we need some more honest & devastating Christian music.. "Make it a Double"

The original studio recording of the song "Double".... by genius Michael Knott

(who , like here, sometimes records under monikers like LSU) 

is devastating,
           prophetic,
                                       stunning...

complete with trash can lids played as drums. by Steve Hindalong

The juxtaposition of the Saturday night and Sunday morning realities..
                          too honest for church?

          That's precisely while we'll play it Sunday.

It's from a brilliant (half punk and half ballad) worship CD, "Grace Shaker"...

and the song makes complete sense (not common sense) in the context of a "worship"album...much in the same way "Eleanor Rigby" counterintuitively belongs on The Violet Burning's classic "Strength".



Double

and you're sittin' there wondering why is it like this
and the whole world's crazy and the earth is sick
and someone's yelling from the bathroom door
the toilet's overflowing on the floor
and the one by the phone says i cannot hear
while the one by the jukebox spills his beer
and the man on the pinball hits sixteen mil
someone ducks behind the counter to pop a pill
and you reach in your pocket to see if there's more
and the biggest bill falls so you're left with four
and you're too gone to look but you still try
then you see it in the hand of a great big guy
who looks just like he'd kill you fast
and you think for a minute
you let it pass

and the stool falls over when you set back down
it bumps a mean pool shooter from across the town
he misses his shot - it's all on you
and with your last four bucks you know what you'll do
sorry man can i buy you a drink
and he shakes his head and says, make it a double

the next thing you know you wake up at home
and the little one there won't leave you alone
she's awake and hungry
she needs some potty help
and you remember what happened last time she tried it by herself
and your wife says hurry, we're late for church
and you can barely see
and your head still hurts
and the preacher starts preaching
and you feel remorse
he's got five little kids and a big divorce
and your wife looks down and says she don't know how
he's been her guiding light for ten years now
and his marriage is over, it's barely alive
and how in the world will ours ever survive?

and the stool falls over when you set back down
it bumps a mean pool shooter from across the town
he misses his shot - it's all on you
and with your last four bucks you know what you'll do
sorry man can i buy you a drink
and he shakes his head and says, make it a double

Studio version:



"Double" live (note Michael's apologetic comment at the end, he knows it's devastating):


Here, he laughs abut how it's "depressing...but it's not in A minor, though.  So it could've been worse":

"Double" live, by Knott/LSU in a very small club with a rocked up version:

 This version below, close to the original, does includes one word change:
"How in the world.." becomes "how in the hell...".
It's by his "secular" band and on a "secular" label, because we all know only "secular" people talk like that (:
---

--
In other songs in Knottland, "Grace" live:




Grace

striving for the answer
in fighting for the streets of gold
hope you're not forgotten
you wonder if you've killed your soul
i've heard the words of judgment
but not from the one i know

it falls down on me
it falls down on you
grace falls free
the proud feel the need to work the loom
yet grace falls free

holding up to heaven
the winnings of your plow
look into the poor man
show him what he must do now
you've got all the answers
but he's got a book that shows him how

it falls down on me...

think about the river
how it always flows
they're still digging in the desert
but that's not where this river goes
it's filled with all the living
and quenches every wantin' soul

it falls down on me...

Sunday, September 05, 2010

transcending platitudes and ooze: The Essentials Collection


If you are Christian, but not sure you like Christian music,
especially if you a fan of the Sacramento Scene bands (or never heard of them),
 check out  (and subscribe to) the "Essentials Collection" from Strip Cycle Music Project:





What are the Essentials? They are those albums that have made an impact, stylistically and artistically and which still remain spiritually compelling. This is the music that proved once and for all that Christian believers were truly capable of creating art, vital and transforming art. 

This wasn't stodgy "church music." This was music that transcended platitudes, smashed the barriers of what was possible for Christians to write and sing about. Carmanesque Jesus cheerleading was passe and the stereotype that "Christian music is lame" no longer a truism. This music dared not only to sing of the joys of salvation, but of the darkness and doubt residing inside of every human heart.

Like an endangered species, the Essentials are fast disappearing. These groundbreaking albums are out of print and out of circulation.

The Strip Cycle Music Project makes as its first task preservation. It is our aim to hold onto the redemptive art that has been bequeathed to us by these stellar musicians. They have set their pearls before the swine of a cookie cutter industry that apparently cares nothing of its musical past. This must change. These albums must not be allowed to be forgotten.

Our second task is education. Strip Cycle strives to educate and inform others about the great musical heritage we have been given. This education entails exposure; SCM exposes you the listener to some of the greatest albums ever recorded by Christians, whether or not these believers label themselves and their work with the unhelpful terms "Christian singer" or "Christian rock." These are CCM (contemporary Christian music) labels used to limit and pigeonhole. They must be discarded.

The albums we feature are simply great records made by people who also happen to be Christians. That many are ignorant of this entire subculture is a travesty; it is a travesty perpetrated (intentionally or unintentionally) by the powers-that-be in the so-called "Christian music industry." They have cobbled together this unnecessary subculture, this ghetto of hidden creativity. 

Michael Roe, charismatic frontman of the legendary rock band the 77's, in a moment of extreme candor stated "If you were to say, 'Listen to this Christian rock record,' immediately this oozy slime is on the floor. The colors of the room turn pink and cream, sugar is dripping off the walls, the furniture is plastic," Roe says. "You change the whole atmosphere of the room with a few words like that. And the last thing you want to do that to is a kick-ass rock 'n' roll record."

Truer words were never spoken.
-by STRIPCYCLE MUSIC, LINK 
----
Music:
The 77's, Adam Again, Daniel Amos, The Choir, Lost Dogs, Michael Roe, Bride, Kaiser & Mansfield, Larry Norman, The Swirling Eddies, Steve Taylor, Deliverance, Guardian, Michael Knott, Lifesavers, Cush, L.S. Underground, Mortal, King's X, Saviour Machine, Gene Eugene, Legend Seven, Aaron Sprinkle, Over The Rhine, Jimmy A, Eden Burning, Chagall Guevara, Southside Blades Of Eden, Steve Hindalong, Vigilantes Of Love, Sweet Comfort Band, Terry Taylor, Aunt Betty's, Starflyer 59, Fluffy, The Violet Burning, Poor Old Lu, The Strawmen, Undercover, Dig Hay Zoose, Sass O' Frass Tunic, The Prayer Chain, Wish For Eden, Unveiled, Dakoda Motor Co., The Throes, My Little Dog China, Mark Heard, Dead Artist Syndrome, Pray For Rain, Veil, Vector, Raspberry Jam, Charlie Peacock, Galactic Cowboys, Tonio K and more

Friday, November 02, 2007

Well-Ended Stories That Don't End Well


"He never reached the door."

As a twelve-year old reading that closing and clinching line of a Ray Bradbury (long before I met and prayed for him) short story, I was impressed that it was a far more creative, effective, visual (and less violent) way to end the scene than spelling out what the reader "saw" between the lines:

                                           the man had been shot to death.

I can still remember where I was, and what I was doing.

I still can see the spot on the page where that sentence was typefaced ; the emotions that suddenly swirled as the import and imagination of the ending landed on me...thirty some years ago.

The memory is clearer and more detailed than JFK's assassination before it,

Such is the power; drama and trauma of a good art; of story well-told, of a well-ended narrative...

...especially when it doesn't end well.

The memory of myself catching that realization/revelation as a preteen is perhaps just as formative in me as 9/11.

Is there room for good art; place for restrained violence; for true "fairy tale endings" (just read some of those fairy tales and nursery rhymes..."when the bough breaks/the cradle will fall/down will come baby/cradle and all....whoa!) ; for actual intelligence, imagination and creativity; for thoroughgoing honesty and lament in music that Christians listen to (as opposed to that ridiculous pseudogenre "Christian music)?)

Have I gone too far?
can You reach me?
I've gone too far...


Uh, excuse me, Michael Pritzl and the Violet Burning. You missed that page in the rule book; you can perhaps begin, but you musn't end a song/prayer like that! It's unresolved; worse, it is resolved, in the "wrong" way.

Loose ends. So loose that the singer/character in the song may well hang himself when the last note fades.

You gave him enough rope, Michael.

Or to match the metaphor of the song at hand ("Underwater"),
 you are going to
               let God
                    let that poor soul drown.

 Shame on you, a fully professing Christian.

Or:

Bless you for the fully Christian profession that

sometimes it just feels/is like that.

Even though it didn't end well.

Or mention Jesus.

Maybe He'll show up in the sequel.

Or something sometimes more biblical:

                                                       Maybe not.


When is the last anthemditty you heard on "Christian radio" that mentioned a pastor? So far, so good...it's good to mention and honor our clergy. But how about a pastor who ends the song with a divorce and devastated divided flock? (We have all read about such cases in the newspaper, but how about in a "Christian" song) Or even worse in evangelicaldom; ending the song/psalm/prayer with a (gasp) question and question mark:

and your wife says hurry, we're late for church
and you can barely see
and your head still hurts
and the preacher starts preaching
and you feel remorse
he's got five little kids and a big divorce
and your wife looks down and says she don't know how
he's been her guiding light for ten years now
and his marriage is over, it's barely alive
and how in the world will ours ever survive?
(Michael Knott/LSU, "Double")


And I didn't even dwell on the narrator's hangover... in church.

Because things like that don't happen in the real world.

Just in the Bible.

And in newspaper stories that, very Christianly, don't end well.

Of course, the classic is the retelling of The Prodigal Son in which the unthinkable is thought.. out loud. And captured for eternity (or the rest of earthly life) on CD before it could be tidied up, and brought (hijacked) to happy ending. In this scenario, the prodigal son (brace yourself) not only doesn't come home; but celebrates that choice as such a spiritually appropriate and liberating moment that "for the first time, I feel love."

Some people, including me on some days, find that song unlistenable.

But what I find more often unlistenable is the revision of the song (U2's "The First Time") that Bono occasionally sang in concert years later. He actually dared to/yielded to the temptation to...brace yourself... tie and tidy up the loose ends; and gave the poor prodigal guy the keys back.

The guy repents, and comes back to the Father.

It's all good.
And it rhymes.

It might even play on Christian radio.

Forgive him, Jesus!(:

The actual lyric varied according to night and venue, but it usually went something like:

"I left by the back door, and I threw away the key...

But grace will lead me back to Thee."

Whazzup with all that?

The definitive U2 blogger Beth Maynard tells the story better than I can:

Drawing on the parable of the Prodigal Son, it depicts "my Father" as a "rich man" with "a rich man's cloak" who offers "keys to his kingdom" and a home among "many mansions" with "many rooms" -- but just as we're marveling at this tender generosity, the narrator abruptly declares, "But I left by the back door, and I threw away the key."

People who enjoy attacking the band on religious grounds (and who take any artistic creation as baldfaced autobiography) have had a field day condemning this sentence. I've never really understood the objection: the son does after all leave in the parable, U2's musical setting at that moment is ineffably sad, and a faith-filled lovefest resolution would have been way out of place on Zooropa. Besides, the liturgical form for sacramental confession with which I'm most familiar puts words in your mouth that directly echo these lyrics: "Father, you clothed me with the shining garment of Christ's righteousness, and established me among your children in your kingdom. But I have squandered the inheritance of your saints, and have wandered far in a land that is waste." Some of us tell God regularly that we left by the back door and telling him is considered a prescription for spiritual health.


However, all these years later in a live context, this poignant ending just isn't playing out the same way. Bono is experimenting with the verse to see what can be delivered authentically in the more religiously-assured context of the Vertigo tour.


Elsewhere (9:22 in this audio), Beth defends songs like the original version of "First Time" with a delightful debunking of the fallacious and pharisaical conclusion that "just because someone writes about sin, they're in favor of it." . Amen and touche.

(For more discussion of this seminal song, and video examples of it in both incarnations, see "Preaching Ecclesiastes and Throwing Away the Key".
For a full-blown (and overblown, as I wrote it) essay on the theological significance of how U2 ends/doesn't end their lyrics, visit this page.)



U2 fan's will be familiar with "40", basically a reading of Psalm 40:1-3's declaration of trust and waiting on the Lord, but tweaked with a shocking counterpoint; "How long to sing this song."

Of course, followed with a question mark.

That's the point.

And how can we complain when that lyrical complaint itself is simply imported not from the singer's "ungodly" doubt, but from another equally inspired scripture: Psalms,



Is there place in the canon and church/radio playlist for honesty/lament/well-ended stories that apparently don't end well? There is place in the psalter for all the above and more: imprecation ,virtual deus abscondit and veritable cursings of/by God.

"Jesus...I am waiting here Boss..
           I know You're looking out for us..

                                                 but Maybe Your hands aren't free."

Oops,I better stop, the F-word even makes a cursory  (bad pun intended appearance in that psalm/song...

"We are Christian by faith, not by genre," Jon Foreman of Switchfoot explains. Which may explain how this band of deep Christians apparently see no contradiction to appearing at Christian festivals and Victoria's Secret commercials.





Sometimes these songs are honest reflections of where we are in life and pilgrimage ,
or even imaginations/artistic and sympathetic portrayals of those who are in such spots. They may well be representations of artistic seasons we are in. ("Oh, that was U2's postmodern irony era.")

But we ban that stuff.

I'll never forget the shock and fear that registered upon hearing Amy Grant (then reigning queen of Christian pop) title a song "Faithless Heart," and even admit temptations toward an extramarital affair. I actually thought "Oh my goodness, if she keeps producing songs like that, she'll actually/inevitable have an affair.

I don't know that she did, but her marriage did soon not end well.

And maybe it was my fault for judging her for being honest.

Even Johnny Cash occasionally wanted "coffee, not Jesus."

Even Jesus, who prayed Psalm 22, uncut and uncensored, didn't always relieve the tension of the
bridge lyric by a slappy happy third verse.

And Psalm 22 for all its PinkFloydish agnosticism/atheism/apocalyptic/aopophatic is "To be sung to the tune of 'Doe of the Morning."

Go figure.

Or don't.

Maybe there is no irony, only gospel truth,  in a
"God, I 'm not on speaking terms with you" prayer.

Some never reach the door.

Soundtracking my writing at the moment is The Prayer Chain song ("Mercury)" with a haunting (healing?) refrain:

"It takes years to get there."

I hate that about life and faith and honesty.

But it does.

As a pastor ( a preacher needs pain" Bono insisted in perhaps his most passionate, indiscriminate "worship" song), I need to
 know,
           to remember,
                        to confess,
                                  to preach the truth that:

                                               Some people never reach the door.



His hands were shaking under the covers.
His body was cold...Suddenly he was very afraid...


He slipped from the bed and was walking across the room when his brother’s voice said, ‘Where are you going?


’What?’

His brother’s voice was quite cold. ‘I said, where do you think you’re going?’

‘For a drink of water.’

‘But you’re not thirsty.’

‘Yes, yes I am.’

‘No, you’re not.’

Captain John Black broke and ran across the room.

He screamed. He screamed twice.

He never reached the door.
link

Monday, February 13, 2012

" 500 Best Christian Albums of All Time"..including some by artists who may not be Christian

Adam has a wonderful collection of "CCM"s 500 Best Albums of All Time."
As he was finishing up the countdown, he posted this entry  about the trilemma he was facing picking #1.

Suffice to say that if you are tired of such lists that only include items sold in Christian bookstores (see " there are no Christian bookstores"), and  don't include the 77s/Mile Roe, U2, The Violet Burning,  Michael Knott/LSU,  Charlie Peacock, Simple Minds, Chagall Guevara, the Call. Michael Been (and even the guy I once passed potatoes to et al,........ you'll appreciate this list (here's his initial post, including his criteria)

..and the winner of the #1 spot.  It's about time!

Even though at least once the far more famous #2 album (on the same  mainstream label as the #1!)
was actually sold in a  Christian store (I had to get photo evidence of it, right next to Chris Tomlin... in case Jesus didn't know).

It's about time!

Note: his previous blog/collection is here:The Greatest Christian Albums of All Time,




"Sending people to get a Christian album that must be bought in a Christian bookstore is like sending people to the hardware store for eggs."
-Brian Healy / Dead Artist Syndrome

Wednesday, October 03, 2007

Jaded by Blackberries and Bushes

Where are they all going?

Literally, spiritually....Where ARE they all going?

The ache of watching and wondering as cars just keep on driving...real people, going somewhere (or so they think) often gets to me..

Especially if in an ironic juxtaposition...as in driving past a homeless person or Christian billboard they don't even see...

I have blogged before on "Double," the devastating beautiful painful masterpiece song by Michael Knott (lyric and commentary here )...

...but this live video clip doubled the devastation, due to the cars one can see just passing by behind the outdoor stage.

Oblivious.

Do they have any idea a



prophet is prophesying...perhaps about them...only yards away?

The closest experience I have is watching God show up dramatically as Michael Pritzl raised his guitar in worship, leading the audience at the Anaheim club in the astonishing closing verses of singing/praying:
"Lay Your hands on me...Let Your Love cover me" and prophetically challenging the crowd to "rise up"
(the video below is the same song from a Christian festival..so it likely wont have the same effect on you(:....but with people walking around the crowd casually...how could they?....The section that I am referring to begins at 4:40)



I was almost afraid to open my eyes. Jesus would surely be tempted to return (Or at least make a personal appearance) in response to such raw worship!).

Yet I did.

And I saw to my amazement:

The bartender, and his son, behind the bar..

Playing cards, not even acknowledging the stage and its near Christophany...

Fiddling while Rome burned.


EB Browning:“Earth’s crammed with heaven and every common bush ablaze with God. He who sees takes off his shoes, the rest sit round and pluck blackberries."

Or mechanically check their Blackberry devices..

But I may walk by Jesus every day.

I once threw out his water glass

Thanks to Kathy Ledbetter for capturing this photo that devastates me to this day...It is a scene right out of the Bible:




I didn't even speak to him on the Palm Sunday road into Jerusalem, as he greeted me with an outstretched hand and "Good Morning." I don't know if he was just a beggar, or just Jesus.

Or both.

He may have been sent by God or the devil.

Or both.

He may have been insane.

Or the smartest man in the world.

I walked by.