Showing posts with label Leonard Shlain. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Leonard Shlain. Show all posts

Monday, May 20, 2013

The Alphabet vs The Goddess

The Alphabet vs The Goddess: The Alphabet vs The Goddess: The Alphabet vs The Goddess Q and A: Thinking Allowed:

Friday, October 15, 2010

Myers Briggs, Culture Shift, Brain Theory

I teach so I can learn from students! (:


It hit me in a recent leadership class discussion
 that though polarizations are often false,
       and dichotomies are  potentially dualistic and                 dangerous,
                               there is value in comparing
 (on the one hand), 
  • the "left hand" of Myers Briigs preferences (ESTJ=Extrrovert, Sensing, Judging, Perceiving),
  • the "modern" world   (RRWI=Rational, Representative. Word-Based, Individual)as Sweet summarizes it) 
  • the left brain functions as summarized by Shlain (DWAN=Doing, Word, Abstraction, Number)

 To the other hand:
  • the "right hand" of Myers Briggs preferences (Introvert, iNtuitive, Feeling, Perception)
  • -the "postmodern world (EPIC=Experiential, Participatory, Imgae-Driven, Connectivity) as Sweet summarirzes it
  • -the right grain functions as summaried by Shlain  (BIMM=Being, Image, Music, Metaphor)




  • ESTJ                                                                                                                            INFP
  • RRWI                                                                                                                           EPIC
  • DWAN                                                                                                                        BIMM
No, I am not making a political statement by putting the left in blue, and right in red (:
...or the supposed  "right" answers  (the ones that match me!) on the right  (:
etc..


Helpful links:
Myers Briggs and Left/Right Brain here
EPIC acrostic on PDF, p 36-37 here)

Friday, October 08, 2010

Amazing books by Leonard Shlain: video lectures

(RIP LS)
"Art and Physics":
Promo:"Leonard Shlain proposes that the visionary artist is the first member of a culture to see the world in a new way. Then, nearly simultaneously, a revolutionary physicist discovers a new way to think about the world. Escorting the reader through the classical, medieval, Renaissance and modern eras, Shlain shows how the artists' images when superimposed on the physicists' concepts create a compelling fit."  (excerpt):
"Alphabet and Goddess": Promo:
"Leonard Shlain contrasts the feminine right-brained oral teachings of Socrates, Buddha, and Jesus with the masculine creeds that evolved when their spoken words were committed to writing. The first book written in an alphabet was the Old Testament and its most important passage was the Ten Commandments. The first two reject of any goddess influence and ban any form of representative art.":

Thursday, December 17, 2009

what is the opposite of linear?







The short answer is 'all at once."

But the long answer is "Nothing...There is no conveyor belt, Neo..maybe not even a line on the horizon..or a line anywhere."

Maybe even the "time working backwards" that George Ladd and Bob Dylan have commented on is an illusion.

I love Leonard Shlain, and pray he's doing well.

He would be a great guy to sit down with Bono, and talk art and physics.
Shlain might dare to suggest, though, that the shapeshifting Holy Spirit, hole-in heart, gal from Fez may have given a bit of bad physics advice to
the French motorcycle cop in 'No Line on the Horizon:"

It would seem that it's space, not time, that's truly not linear.

Space...and math/physics...and the nose... appear to be left-brain function...and somewhat logical and linear.
Time....and music....and the eyes.. appear to be right-brain functions...and pretty darn non-linear.

From Shlain's "Art and Physics":

whereas sight is largely holistic, all-at-once sense, the nose must process smells one-at-a-time...The right hemisphere of the brain is best able to apprecoiate these states (visual, contemplation) since the right all at once brain is older than the left one at a time brain...The right side specializes in the simultaneous coordination of information in space, while the left side collates data percived sequentially in time. This arrangement forces on dual-brained humans the illusion that reality is a series of casual events that appear in three- dimensional spatial extensions in a specific sequence..

All the innovative features of the left hemisphere--doing, words, abstract thinking,a nd number sense--are principally processed in time.. Time's function in speech is evident because language can be understood only if one person is talking at a time....By contrast, we can listen to all the instruments of a 70-piece orchestra's simultaneuous sound and hear them holistically, all at once....The four key features of the right brain are holistic...Music demonstrates the ability of right brain to process information in an all at once manner.
-Shlain, "Art and Physics",chapters 26, 27



Of course, this means that the woman in Bono's song, by virtue of appearing in a song, is in her right brain and right mind.
So maybe her advice is good after all.

And as a woman of the future (oops, spliced a song), she might like to overhear Shlain quoting William Blake: "Time and Space are Real Beings, a Male and a Female. Time is a Man, Space is a Woman."

Only women in space can comment prophetically about men in time.

And do it all at once, too boot.

No wonder she stuck her tongue in his ear, and messed him up for the rest of the album.

--

New York Times
Book Review:
"Provocative...passionate...Shlain points out uncanny parallels between the visual representations of artists and analytic representations.... He is an engaging story teller, skilled in the use of metaphor, analogy and even imaginary journeys that at times are poetic... Dr. Shlain's discussion of artistic images and his demonstrations of how these images can be used to describe the impenetrable ideas of physics are important."

Monday, December 07, 2009

oh my we are all artists around here


Note that the below definition of "artist' is almost interchangable with the biblical definition of the sons of Isacchar ("The ones who knew and understood the 'secular' times and culture, and thus knew and intimately and intuitively what God’s people should do” 1 Chron 12.32) as well as much of what I mean by pastoral leadership in these amazing days.

I will pay Mark DeRaud to comment on this definition.

Here you go:


"The artist is the one in any field,
scientific or humanistic, who grasps the implications of their actions and of new knowledge in their time, They are the person of integral awareness." -McLuhan, quoted in
Shlain, "Art and Physics:
Parallel Visions in Space, Time, and Light" " p. 124


Shlain...a laproscopic surgeon (and thus an artist!) is a must read..here's some video of the man.

And Mark..who has finally begun blogging is a

He taught an amazing session for the preaching class I taught this semester..
I can kick myself for not getting it on video!
artist dude.

"The new generation, some say, is actually a new creature, is wired differently than mom and dad. The new generation appreciates and processes knowledge and "truth" more visually and experientially than we do. The difference is so profound yet so sublime that we literally have trouble experiencing the difference so that we might adjust to the new reality. We just can't understand why the teaching of propositional truth, so compelling to us modern, though august creatures of the Enlightenment, is not so compelling to the post-modern believer. Having relied on teaching as experience, I suspect we are very suspicious of actually experiencing "wisdom", or "love", or "transformation" that transcends our humanity and are quite intimidated, especially our teachers, of making propostional statements that assert with any certainty, that transcendence happens and can, and should,here and now be experienced. " -Mark DeRaud link

Wednesday, April 15, 2009

The Reformation and the shape we're in

Just a few lines from a choice chapter (30) and pivotal tract for our times.
This explains a lot of TSWI.

"Mysticism had no role in the early Protestant Reformation: both Luther and Calvin depended wholeheartedly on the persuasiveness of their carefully composed inked syllogisms. All founders urged their followers to have 'faith,' but the underpinnings of Protestantism were actually written, torturously logical constructions that were oresented in long dense, imageless tones...

The Protestant Reformation was clearly not a return to the content of the New Testament; but I submit, a wrenching sociological shift wrought by a new information technology dependent on users being alphabet-literate. This in turn changed the collective perception of culture. The printing press made the Reformation's rigid an repressive self-discipline possible."
-The Alphabet Vs The Goddess: The Conflict Between Word and Image | by Leonard Shlain

By the way, pray for Shlain, he is recovering from a brain tumor (news)

Tuesday, February 05, 2008

i am a musical female computer user who reads Chinese


Simply reading the amazing Leonard Shlain's amazing "The Alphabet Verses the Goddess: The Conflict Between Word and Image" (see also his seminal "Art and Physics"), and putting his two and two together made it obvious to me that the demographic most open to what God is doing in this current postmodern reformission...or whatever "this weird moment in history" is to be called....would have to be:

Musical female computer users who read Chinese.


Huh?

This of course may be a fallatious argument, based on the obsolete model of modernity/Newtonian world: linear thought, adding up of rational principles (which indeed is part of the point).

But many studies would suggest...especially in the fastest growing Christian harvest on earth in
our day (and maybe the fastest growing since the early church)..I hit a bingo. Expecially factoring in the underground and house church movement. Have you seen the wonderful DVD "The Cross," documenting the incredible revival birthed by a musical female who reads Chinese (don't know if she has a computer). The whole episode is online here,


Back to Shlain, who concludes that (p 182) languages that are read vertically actually rewire ones brain to provess in a more holistic, image-based, right-brained way...which post-Newtonian physics has shown is the "way" wired into life and the universe; and also (not coincidentally) happens to be the preference of our postmodern age.
There's the Chinese culture being in some sense closer to a Kingdom worldview than others.
(I am reminded of David Crowder's hilarious story; and I wish Alan Hirsch would unpack the meaning of all this).

Computers? Well, the first Reformation was fueled by the printing press, decidedly the most important invention in the last two thousand years..

..until now, with not just computers, but most specifically Google,
deseminating our theses. Leonrad Sweet says we have gone from the Gutenberg Galaxy to the Google. Shlain:

The computer "mouse" liberated the right hand's need to stay within confines...Computer-literates use a hand-eye coordination more spatial than linear...(and)..the computer's unique word-processing programs added still another right-brained talent. The geographical moving about of phrases (etc)..increased the right hemisphere..And there are no
pages to turn in a computer, which further discourages linear thinking. "Scrolling"...is more akin to deciphering vertical Chinese ideograms than reading horizontal alphabet text. (417)

"Reading" computer, like reading Chinese, retrains us to think and feel in a manner startling akin to the way life "should" flow.

The female advantage? They are considerably more right-brained than us no-brain..uh, left-brain men. And check this: Shlain suggests that "writing of any kind will realign the gender politics of any culture." Even though Chinese culture may seem sexist and patriarchal in ways, "Chinese men chose to construct their patronymics upon the spine of a maternal symbol...An ancient Chinese character for "wife" also meant "equal." (180)

Music? Right-brained...and if Len Sweet's succinct summary of string theory is at all accurate, "The universe is at base, music," them cultures with a bias towards music will find God's voice prints quicker than the rest. Cioran, a professed agnostic who "knew" music (notably, Bach) was evidence of God, must be read (try reading him in Chinese!)Not just in music, but "Chinese writing is emphasis on form...Content supercedes form in the West, form is an indispensable adjunct to content in the east. One must be artistic to read Chinese well." (Shlain, 183).

Insightful studies such as "The Mozart Effect" are telling here; see also "This is Your Brain on Music" which offers compelling evidence that those who listen to music...and especially those who create it...literally experience the connecting and merging of otherwise disparate parts of their brain.

I can't help but wonder why the most effective evangelist in postmodern Japan (although not female) is...

Bach (check this)!

And my question for Scottis: what might be the implications for Oriental jazz (since evertone knows that jazz is right-brained and all that other Godstuff (see
HOW JAZZ CAN BREAK THE HERESY OF WHITE CHRISTIANITY)

--

I feel kickstarting my right brain and mind into praying/singing something like,

"Lord, make me as much as possible

a musical female computer user who reads Chinese..

(sans the sex-change, please)...

Amen

and

A
M
E
N

Later note: Here's a sequel




Wednesday, April 26, 2006

WHAT IS THE MOST IMPORTANT INVENTION IN THE PAST TWO THOUSAND YEARS?


Click the title to read how a hundred plus geniuses/thinkers/intellectual scientists (from string theorist Brian Greene to ex-Monkee Mike Nesmith, by way of folks like Esther Dyson ) answered this very crucial question for the church in these amazing days (where God is speaking wake-up calls to the church through "secular" people and technologies)....

WHAT IS THE MOST IMPORTANT INVENTION IN THE PAST TWO THOUSAND YEARS?

Interesting they chose the last 2,ooo years as the time frame, recognizing (at least) the Christian era...I wonder if anyone gave "Chrisianity" as the answer...

Actually, one of my favorite answers is by one of my favorite thinkers, Stephen Johnson who said, winkingly:

Given the amount of self-reference in the answers so far, I'm tempted to nominate
this very discussion list as the greatest invention of the past two thousand
years, and hopefully out-meta all the other contenders


..before giving his intriguing nomination:

I think part of the problem here is the fact that inventions by nature are
cumulative, and so when asked to pick out the single most important one, you're
inevitably faced with a kind of infinite regress: if the automobile is the most
important invention, then why not the combustible engine? (And so onŠ) In that
spirit — and in the spirit of nominating things you happen to be working on
professionally — I'd nominate the ultimate cumulative invention: the city. Or at
least the modern city's role as an information storage and retrieval device.
Before there were webs and telegraphs making information faster, there were
cities bringing information physically closer together, and organizing it in
intelligible ways. ...


The printing press came up more than once...very telling...especially since that's what catapulted and vehichled the Reformation. What will do it for this current reformation? Obviusly the Internet is part of that answer, maybe Google (or Google Image...recognizing that the last Reformation was Word; this one is Image) in partcular; but I am sure it will eb more multiplex this time...

Re: the "next" printing press (one appropriate for a "new orality culture," as Walter Ong would coin it or "EPIC culture" as Len Sweet would have it), see this article, and it's sequel linked at bottom; especially references to Leonard Shlain, who said in the seminal " The Alphabet Versus the Goddess: the Conflict Between Word and Image":


The Protestant Reformation was clearly not a return to the CENTER of the New Testament; but, I submit, a wrenching sociological shift wrought by a new information technology dependent on users being alpha-literate. This, in turn, changed the collective perception of culture. The printing press made the Reformation's rigid and repressive self-discipline posible.(349)

The religious wars that wracked Europe...occurred ONLY in those lands impacted by the printing press..(361)



Wednesday, April 19, 2006

Seeing God @ St. Arbuck's II


I was God-blasted one again, in similar fashion and in the same place as my previous "word from God at St. Arbuck's"..

..again on the subject of visualcy and a synesthesiatic "seeing what God is saying" (a la Habb. 2:1-2 and Rev 1:12 etc).

This week's cup:

Way I See It #68

In an age when pictures have become more eloquent than words, schools are still programmed to reduce the child’s immersive interaction with the visual world to the practical poverty of the alphabet. Visual literacy should become a pedagogical priority in order to prepare our children to function within the increasingly visual complexity of our environment.
-- Vik MunizArtist and photographer. Born in Sào Paulo, Brazil, he now resides in New York City.


For those of you with valid concerns that this all leads to the downfall of reading and a "literal" literacy, hear (see) what this is NOT saying. This is no small issue for the church in current culture. Just talk to St. Marshall McLuhan (well, don't talk to him, he's dead...but read his prescient writings), or some of the writers quotes and linked below...read (see) witha n open heart, mind...and full St. Arbuck's cup.


From Leonard Shlain's "The Alphabet Versus the Goddess: The Conflict Between Word and Image":

The ostensible rationale for the war between the canaanites and the Israelites can be simply put: the former worshipped their gods through their use of images, the latter worshipped their God through the medium of written words. Words triumphed in this first of many confrontations between pictures and text (102)

The Protestant Reformation was clearly not a return to the CENTER of the New Testament; but, I submit, a wrenching sociological shift wrought by a new information technology dependent on users being alpha-literate. This, in turn, changed the collecvtive perception of culture. The printing press made the Reformation's rigid and repressive self-discipline posible.

(349) The religious wars that wracked Europe...occurred ONLY in those lands impacted by the printing press..(361)

SEE also:

And read what St. Mark is about to post...Mark, tell us about the new Reformation book...we need apostolic arteurs such as yourself in this conversation..or we may not see straight...

That's the way I see it..


Tohu bohu,

dave