Welcome! You have accidentally reached the blog of a heteroclite follower of Jesus: dave wainscott. I'm "pushing toward the unobvious" as I post thinkings/linkings re: Scripture, church and culture. Hot topics include: temple tantrums, time travel, sexuality/spirituality, U2kklesia, role of the pastor, God-haunted music/art..and subversive videos like these.
Pages
Search Me:
Monday, January 16, 2012
Tuesday, May 25, 2010
The "Lord's Prayer" does NOT say "daily bread"..yada..This is NEWS?
their homework knows the huge "secret" outed in Diarmaid MacCulloch's magisterial book,
"Christianity: The First Three Thousand Years."
So why don't we preach this stuff?Other than commentaries (and books by George Eldon Ladd) why does it only leak out in books like this by gay Anglicans (!!) that most of our flock will never read? And in reviews (by moderate Anglicans) of that book in a publication like The New York Times Book Review, that most of our flock will never read, but should?
Love the wry "not in Kansas" last line of the reviewer below, as he ponders these same questions, and maybe answers them. Time for us to kickstart out of Kansas and modernity and into an Oz-fest. Maybe the Anglicans (Phyllis Tickle, anyone?) are leading the way:
..in a wonderfully revealing insight of MacCulloch’s, that the “daily bread” for which countless Christians ask in the Lord’s Prayer is not what most people think it is, a humble plea for sustenance. “Daily” is the common translation of the Greek word epiousios, which in fact means “of extra substance” or “for the morrow.” As MacCulloch explains, epiousios “may point to the new time of the coming kingdom: there must be a new provision when God’s people are hungry in this new time — yet the provision for the morrow must come now, because the kingdom is about to arrive.”
We are a long way from bedtime prayers here.
-link
Maybe we are just afraid of what will happen if the flock find out they have been fleeced about what anyone who has studied the Bible (Matt. 4:17...) knows is THE central message of Jesus:
"..the Gospel is not that Jesus died on the cross for your sins so you can go to heaven when you die, but that the Gospel that Jesus preached was the Gospel of the Kingdom.
When you say this to people they look at you like you’re insane.
‘Of course the Gospel is that you can go to heaven when you die’, they say.
But the Gospel isn’t a one-time event, it’s a daily participation with Christ in the Kingdom life.”
Interview with Dallas Willard in RELEVANT Magazine
(read it all here)
Guess not many churches are quoting Dallas Willard either..
---------
MacCulloch describes himself as a "candid friend" of Christianity."I have a strong appreciation of the importance of it all," he says. "I've struggled with statements of belief. I think it's hugely important. It's still very important to me. I play the organ and sing in a church choir and I can't imagine life without Christianity. But I cannot sign up to doctrinal statements."
-link
Friday, May 14, 2010
on technology shaping God?
but need to, this post below by The Holy Wild is important enough to copy below in full.
(I doubt if he will kill me for that, as it comes with a commercial plug, and a large and live link.. Support this guy, read his blog, tweet w/him, buy him a beer..or whatever he wants).
-----------------------------------------
wires and lights in a box:
remember life without mobile phones? this past xmas my father-in-law gave me an iphone 3g and tho its already outdated it is a significant advance over my motorola razor v3xx flip. they call it a phone and it is in some ways but its also a pocket sized pc of sorts. its a web browser and mp3 player and camera along with every current means of connecting with the people in my sphere of influence from email to facebook to instant msg. and it has games.
this is so much more than a phone.
and as i marvel at the touch-screen technology im reminded of several things. i remember having a rotary phone on the wall in our kitchen when i was growing up. i believe it was our only phone at the time and i remember the sound of the dialer as it whirred from the number back to its starting point.
i also remember when we got our first push button phone and our first cassette tape answering machine. i remember when everything went digital and we got caller id. and i remember getting my first mobile phone…10 years ago. its astounding just how much daily life has changed.
i did a google search before i began writing my thots down on this and found that people have written extensively on the various ways technology shapes different aspects of our lives. everything from business to communication and networking to faith and sermons. what i didnt find was anything relating to how technology shapes god.
and i thot this was strange.
lets go back in time for a few moments. when johnny gutenberg developed the printing press it revolutionized everything including the church and played a significant role in the protestant reformation and shaping of theology from that point forward. simply put, it was technology shaping events in the life of the church. but did it also somehow shape god?
im thinking it did.
so wot changed when bibles became more accessible? many things to be certain but a few things in particular.
access – within a century printed bibles and gospels became much more commonplace. one no longer had to be clergy or nobility to have easy access to the scriptures.
authority – when the scriptures were brot to the people the authority of the church lost its strangle-hold on interpretation which began to revert to the public forum.
structure – as more and more people broke away from the RCC many met in smaller numbers with pastors far more accessible and down to earth than the priests and bishops of the high church liturgy altered or was removed altogether.
these changes were not simply cosmetic. they changed ecclesiology and ultimately they changed god – at least in the minds of the people. he wasnt so far away anymore. as with scripture so with god. the technological advance made him far more accessible and much easier to understand removed from all that latin chanting.*
likewise im thinking that mobile technology has dramatically changed god in some distinct ways.
consider this: what would god look like in the mind of an average person without things such as mobile phones? now stop and realize that there are people alive today who will never know the reality behind that question. my children have all been born since the mobile revolution and will never really understand the meaning of a busy signal. they will never really grasp the concept of a switchboard. a wireless world has always existed for them and understanding god may end up being quite a challenge in a world where anything they want to know is a simple matter of googling on their iphone.
this brings up some questions.
in a world where everyone we currently know is only a small flick of our thumbs away wot does god look like when he doesnt answer immediately? wot impression might we draw if his timing is not wot we expected? in a world this connected how can patience and endurance be valuable commodities?
think of the significant impact of trying to make plans when the person you are calling and texting and facebooking doesnt answer or reply. everyone is attached to their mobile media devices – how could this person not be receiving the messages? wot if we really need an answer quick before its too late?!
this may very easily translate in our relationship with god. when we want guidance and direction or an answer to prayers for healing or a job or mended relationships how might we understand him when his answer is not obvious or immediate? how might it affect our understanding of god if his lack of adherence to our time table results in missed opportunities or regrets? wot happens to my faith if god never returns my calls?
recently ive caught myself expecting god to work on a mobile phone basis – to answer my calls & texts within seconds – and the more i think about it the more i think theres something askew. not that technology is bad – we dont have to be amish. but technology is so pervasive in our lives that if we arent extremely careful it can become a terrible hermeneutic.
its been said (more than a few times) that jeremiah 33:3 is gods phone number.
call to me and i will answer you and will tell you great and hidden things that you have not known.
so much violence is done to this statement ripped from its context i doubt seriously that very many who have heard it preached know the situation in the passage surrounding it or the length of time it took for the promise made to be realized.
this passage is about messiah and the inauguration of gods kingdom on earth. its a promise that took several hundred years to bear fruit. hows that for instant messaging? wot would be my reaction to dialing “gods phone number” and getting his voicemail saying:
leave ur msg & ill get back to you in a few hundred years.
our technology breeds impatience and our impatience destroys any chance we have at really understanding god. this is wot i have begun to grasp in the past few weeks as i continue to struggle with not hearing from god during this difficult time. the whole “his ways are not as our ways” thing comes crashing home with force as i open my eyes to the reality of a god who is off the grid and even tho this notion bothers me i would rather know god in truth than comfort even if he stays mostly quiet.
~:::~:::~:::~
i cant live in a world with no technology and i dont know if i would want to but i need to remember that technology cannot be the lens by which i understand god. it can assist my understanding of him via video and other advances but i cant afford to allow its convenience and connectivity to form my thinking.
theres more i want to say about this but its a long read already so ill take a break for now and try to deliver part 2 shortly. as always i am looking forward to your thots.
*let it be known im a huge fan of gregorian chants. this isnt a slam on latin or chanting – its a recognition of how both made the notion of understanding or having a relationship with god difficult if not impossible for the commoner.
-The Holy Wild, link
Friday, April 30, 2010
Wednesday, April 28, 2010
It's 70 AD, and 1517, all over again...maybe The Matrix is Luther this time..

"We are at a time in history of great shift or change, what Thomas Cahill calls a 'hinge in history.'
It is comparable in every way to what happened in 70 A.D."
-Phyllis Tickle, way back in 2003..
- "Today's Church in America"..read part 2(From which this is excerpted)
Note, this delightful message, given at an Episcopal church as two sermons, lets you in on her developing thinking on the ideas that
became "The Great Emergence, shows that she "got" the huge cultural shift of "The Truman Show" and "The Matrix" movies..and ends:"And I for one have to tell you I like it a whole lot more having that one constant [God] than all that crap...
if you will forgive the French.
And on that inelegant note, thank you."
Tuesday, April 27, 2010
Phyllis Tickle complete "New Rose" video..and her heckler

picture link
(click photo to enlarge)
Here is Phyllis Tickle's complete NYWC talk on The Rose of The Reformation on one Gooogle video
(same as the 4 YouTube videos previously posted, but with delightful intro comments included here).
Mark Oestreicher blogs on what happened after the camera went off. Amazing:
...anyhow, phyllis turned the whole thing in the last few minutes to a point that had me in tears (and i looked to tic, and he was in tears also), as she talked about the role that we all (in the room) play in this; the precious gift we’re being given, the responsibility we have to the next 500 years. wow.the audience gave her a standing ovation, which was beautiful. she stepped down off the stage, and tic went up to say a few transition things and introduce chris tomlin. in the moment, as i was waiting to walk her back to the green room, a few people started coming up to her to say something. the very first guy was a large and loud guy who started blasting her: i mean, really, as chris’ music started, he was yelling at her (some volume on his part was necessary due to the music in the room — but he was filled with anger, so it came out as yelling, not loud talking). his first accusation was that she didn’t stand for the authority of scripture. phyllis politely responded, “oh, if you didn’t hear me talk about the authority of scripture, then i really miscommunicated” (i noticed how she took it on herself, instead of merely correcting him). i stepped in and tried to remind the guy about a point where she had specifically talked about the authority of scripture. but he really didn’t want to hear answers or responses; he was ticked. and he was so completely out of line and inappropriate in how he yelled at her. after a minute (maybe less), i stepped in, and tony myles (who blogged about this here) was my wingman, engaging phyllis, then the guy. in that moment, i told him how completely out of line he was. he pushed back (angrily) with a question about scripture, and i told him his questions were fine, ask away, but that yelling at a 74 year-old woman after she’s just finished speaking to us from her heart is what was so inappropriate. i think i said, “didn’t your mom ever teach you anything?”..-Mark Oestreicher, link
-
Monday, April 26, 2010
St James Bond Church, post-denom, and a confusing steak house

Ever hear of churches with ridiculous-sounding names?
Did you hear about the Methodist and Presbyterian churches that merged?They got along fine until it came time to recite the Lord's Prayer:The Methodists traditionally say "Forgive us our tresspasses," and the Presbyterians have always said "Forgive us our debts."So they called off the merger, and (punchline):The Methodists went back to their tresspasses,and the Presbyterians went back to their debts. (:
Phyllis Tickle does an excellent job emphasizing the need to not throw denominational babies (strengths of each tradition) out with bathwater when emergence happens and we become
movements (Harold Best suggests helical is not linear (Hello?), and enot circular, but a combination of both)
the St Luke's-Calvary merger (which was pulled off wonderfully by my successor, Kevin Smith).Ruth's Chris Steak House" is such a tongue-twister that one restaurant critic suggested it be used as a sobriety test: anyone who could say that name three times certainly couldn't be intoxicated...
...{There was} a legal spat with Chris Matulich [previous owner] that led Ruth to append her first name to his, creating the famously tongue-twisting Ruth's Chris Steak House. "Frankly, I've always hated the name," she would later say, "but we've managed to work around it.
-link
"Methdist's Presbyterian Church House?
Joe Levy, one of the family members behind the Gottschalks department store chain, is opening a new retail operation that will be called Gottschalks by Joe Levy, according to a news release issued today. The original Gottschalks dissolved in bankruptcy proceedings last year.
A news conference is scheduled for 10 a.m. Tuesday to reveal the details of Levy's new retail venture. Levy, 78, was the former Gottschalks chairman and CEO.
Here's a statement from Levy via the news release announcing the news conference:
"The Gottschalk name has always stood for outstanding customer service, value and name brand fashions. We are committed to continuing that tradition," said Levy.
The Fresno-based Gottschalks lasted 105 years before going bankrupt. Gottschalks had operated 58 department stores and three specialty apparel stores in six Western states.
It is unclear so far what kind of operation Levy's plans will bring. But with the economy picking up, it could be a good time to move cautiously back into the retail market. Levy said the new Gottschalks will create hundreds of jobs, according to The Bee's story.
link
Wednesday, April 21, 2010
Phyllis Tickle interviews Peter Rollins-video
Part 2:"God Can't Be Defined":
Part 3: What's Happening Outside The USA:
Part 4: Radical is Root:
Rummage Sale Ethics :No Violence or Credit Cards This Time Around

On Sunday, as part of our ongoing discussion of Phyllis Tickle's The Great Emergence, I commented on what could save us this time...for the first time...is that in this current Rummage Sale, we can glean from
- Anabaptists (nonviolence)
- Celtics (connectedness, no dualism) ..and
- women in leadership (the female brain trumps the male brain in making connections).... about nonviolently living it out in a humble and holistic way
Tickle:
We cannot look, however, at the huge gifts to western civilization of either Protestantism or a renewed Catholicism, without looking as well at how our forebearers on both sides of the divide chose competition over cooperation . Hegonomy, by definition, can only belong to one among, and above others. Pride of place, it is called, and it drove all the contenders who were the Great Reformation...just as five hundred years before...The Crusades...Now, a rummage sale later, we can not--must not--shake our heads, as if in confusion about how such things could ever have been, and then, with an assumed innocence, turn and look the other way. Those who do not learn from the past. it has been widely said, are destined to relive it.We also noted that now that the basis of power has shifted from
-p59-60
blood and land..that maybe Fresno can be pivotal this time, since our prophetic destiny seems to be intricately related to all this..Dropping the "fresno drop" and all..
(Great Schism)
to
cash money
(Great Reformation)
to
information
(Great Emergence)..
OK, we need all you Celtic, Anabaptist, Fresno women in ministry...more than ever.
Eugene Cho interviews Phyllis Tickle
Sunday, April 11, 2010
ReImagining Denominations like Jews in Hyperspace

Gustavo:
...Since the Protestant Reformation there have been lots of protestant denominations. What course could the denominations take in Latin America?
Anyul: Phylis Tickle has an interesting theory, she says that the denominations that do not engage with the emerging conversation are condemned to the decrease of its membership and later extinction, but I don’t believe this concept applies across the board… not even in North America. What I see is that there is a certain tendency in the denominations to strengthen their structures and to centralize even more. The “apostolic movements” are a recent example of that, which in my understanding are simply another effort to centralize the protestant church even more.
- Interview, Latin-American Emergence
Having witnessed examples of the indigenous Latin American denominations (which most North Americans have no idea they even exist) fall into "parallel universe" versions of the same traps as our North American denominations (especially shoring up and entrenching Protestantism and defining it against Catholicism...which as the very name of the Protestant movement betrays, was largely the point)....one realizes that even "apostolic networks"/new wineskins become new whineskins by default.
Is may be best to refuse to categorize ourselves as "Protestant" (even for legal purposes),
or does that inevitably lead to us starting yet another stream/denomination.
The "statements of faith" of most denominations/networks betray us .
We are afraid of being interpreted as a cult.
Which of course the early church was branded.
Until pastors have been offered drugs (see Seay) a but more, we may not even be pastors;
or even post-denominational....
.............................or even Christian yet.
What the heck are we pastors doing leading churches anyway?
Until 0ur "enlightened" and "emerging" churches morph into a whole new way of being and defining (beyond even good and helpful labels) ourselves, we may
not be found fully faithful.It's high time for each group/network/denomination to find it's redemptive place in the grand "fidelity of betrayal" that God is birthing..
It's past time to not just get out of the box to rethink, reimagine, redream (and be temporarily "closed for reprayers" as the shift happens)... but maybe out of our own dimension (:
Sane madman Cliff Pickover is a huge help for our times in this matter, a multiplex genius.
One of his creative and novel novels relates here-- see interview below.
In redreaming, it's time to pull out all the stops, orbit the giant hairball of our systems..
and reprogram ourselves to think creatively like..uh, Jews in hyperspace:
Finally, can you tell me a little more about your book, Jews in Hyperspace? What is it about, and can readers without any background in science or Judaism understand it?
Jews in Hyperspace is one of my favorites, and I published it directly to the Kindle. I give a free excerpt here -- a website at which I also tell your readers how the book came to be written.
Readers need no special background in science or Judaism to enjoy the wondrous adventure. In the book, I mix higher dimensions and religion, miracles and modern technology, and politics and physics to produce a gripping tale set in a future Jerusalem. It’s a strange blend of scientific thriller and a quest for religious harmony.
April, here’s the premise. Orthodox Jews are disappearing from Jerusalem. One moment they are praying at the Western Wall, and in the blink of an eye, they seem to evaporate, occasionally leaving behind only their fur hats—their shtreimels—that sit like small, soft flying saucers, perched on stone pavement in the dwindling light. In order to build the Third Temple while being respectful of the Islamic structures on the Temple Mount, the Jews have discovered a way to access a fourth spatial dimension. They willbuild the Third Temple invisibly "above" the Temple Mount and "above" the Mosque in the direction of the fourth dimension. I discuss everything from the future of Israel and Jerusalem to Parallel Universes, the building of Third Temple in Jerusalem, Nephilim, angels, and the fourth dimension.
Without indie publication, this novel would be difficult to publish. Jewish publishers are not accustomed to publishing science fiction. Thus, it would surely be difficult to find a route to publication through Jewish publishers.
Interview
Of course the obvious irony here..though we need a temple tantrum... the invisible building of the New Temple in a new dimension, when translated too directly into doing church ("The 40 Days of Purpose-Driven Building a Temple in Hyperspace...and Beating the Heretics to Heaven") can easily wind up being just another way of topping the other denominations/ common 'enemy') system. We upend, and end up bankrupt..
..and pro-Protest-ant again.
I mean a general seeing things from a fresh perspective...
Bono was right: every decade or so (and especially every 500 years or so), we have got to "go away and dream it all up again,"
At our "church," we even let
people...even, gasp!...women like this (see pic)..
even (mercy!) Hispanic (full circle here) women like Alma here,
read books like this...during the "service."
But that still doesn't necessarily make us post-Protestant.
(i mean, we still have a website and a statement of faith...and a "service")..
Help...I need a 40 day retreat in Hyperspace..
Sunday, February 28, 2010
Rummage Sale Time! Phyllis Tickle videos: "The Great Emergence"
Below is the accompanying blurb from the book publisher:
"Rooted in the observation that massive transitions in the church happen about every 500 years, Phyllis Tickle shows readers that we live in such a time right now. She compares the Great Emergence to other "Greats" in the history of Christianity, including the Great Transformation (when God walked among us), the time of Gregory the Great, the Great Schism, and the Great Reformation.
Combining history, a look at the causes of social upheaval, and current events, The Great Emergence shows readers what the Great Emergence in church and culture is, how it came to be, and where it is going. Anyone who is interested in the future of the church in America, no matter what their personal affiliation, will find this book a fascinating exploration." -Baker Books
Friday, August 28, 2009
Thursday, March 05, 2009
Protestantism's somber joke
A more long-range benefit of the Reformation’s placing ultimate authority in Scripture was that, when coupled with the principle of the priesthood of all believers, sola scriptura required absolute and universal literacy if it were going to work. The Protestant imperative toward every believer’s being able to read Holy Writ for him- or herself excited the drive toward literacy that in turn accelerated the drive toward rationalism and from there to Enlightenment and from there straight into the science and technology and literature and governments that characterize our lives today. There were, of course, some disadvantages.The most obvious problem of universal literacy is that if one teaches five people to read and then asks them each to read the same document, there will be at least three different interpretations of what the five of them have read. While we may laugh and say that divisiveness was Protestantism’s greatest gift to Christianity, ours is a somber joke.
–Phyllis Tickle, The Great Emergence: How Christianity Is Changing and Why, p.46
Tuesday, February 24, 2009
Friday, December 19, 2008
suspended space and donut structure
suspended space and donut structure,
as well as how the role of the leader is to refuse to be a leader:
The rest of the series is posted here
Friday, October 10, 2008
Exile=good

>Between Len's post and Jonny's (below),
and my recent experiences teaching and preaching
(or whatever I call what I do on Sunday in wikichurch...probably haven't 'preached' for years)..
...I can find a place of encouragement that finally we entering into a season where folks that didn't "get" the
Maybe it's because (per Jonny below, read his full post) we are at "the end of the beginning" of the shift/Great Emergence, and it cannot be as easily dismissed as "oh, it's just a fad" (some of it has been);
there has been a lot of discussion and blogging around emerging church recently. is it over? is the term a problem? is it just a phase? i confess to being pretty bemused by the whole discussion...phyllis tickle in her new book the great emergence says that we are looking at the biggest cultural change for 500 years. it's not just a generational shift, it's much bigger than that. when these kinds of shifts take place it can take 50-100 years to know what we are looking at. and in the meantime it can feel very chaotic and uncertain. i referred recently to the bell curve of change. if anything is over, maybe it is the end of the pioneering phase for some people who are restless and want to do something new (or at least use a different label) and maybe generally there is much wider acceptance of the need to change - i.e. we're in phase two of the curve in some places
jonnybaker
or (read Len's link, excerpted below) the place we are in economically..
...Given the meltdown in the US economy, and the reverberations throughout the world, one wonders at our current location. This morning on CBC on the way to breakfast I caught part of an interview with Margaret Atwood on her new book, Payback: Debt and the Shadow Side of Wealth. Margaret is a respected Canadian author who has always had a fascination with debt. It began, she relates, when she prayed the Lord’s Prayer as a child. She noticed that some versions of the prayer asked for forgiveness from sin, others from debt. It turns out that this theme is common in the great faiths. What great faith could really claim to be comprehensive in human affairs that says nothing about economics in human communities?
What really caught me today, however, was how we are all in the same boat. On the one hand a millionaire may stare in the face of the credit crunch and wonder if he can access the resources he needs for his business; on the other hand those of us with ordinary mortgages wonder if they will be sustainable by 2009.
The result of all this uncertainty: fear. And that is where the resources of the Gospel become relevant.
Len Hjalmarson
and our western world at last being poised to realize exile (In addition to being the pits) is a wonderful and strategic place to be (the following flow out of Frost's "Exiles"):
a)Yay! Finally, we can embrace and celebrate "dislocation, uncertainty and irrelevance!" (p.8)
Shouldn't that elict a Yaconelli "Whooo Hoo!"!?
b)Finally, even folk embedded in modernity are realizing the bankruptcy of simulcra and inauthenticity , the "substituting the signs for the real" (84) .
c)Finally , we can be known for a critique of
d)Finally, we can get out of the church and buzzard-meetings and into the Third Places (they are limimal wardrobes) ...and especially the bars where we belong (see 63-65)!
NOW I hear the whooo hooos..
Tuesday, September 23, 2008
St. Phyllis Tickle video and more

“If I had a nickel for every pastor who said to me, ‘Can you tell me how to plant one of those churches?' The answer is, ‘No, I can’t.’ What the pastor is really telling me is that he wants to plant one and then turn it into a good denominational church. It just doesn’t work that way.”
-Phyllis Tickle, link
If you haven't seen this Phyllis Tickle diagram yet, it is perhaps even more exciting than Frank Lake's classic centerfolds: you need to read/hear all about it here.
More from St. Phyllis ("The Great Emergence" ) speaking @a Sunday gathering of Diciples Fellowship... well worth watching below..or here.
Summaries and reviews of the book
by Katherine Moody here; Rick Diamond here; Via here; Terry Mattingly here;
an interview with Tickle on the book here.
Excerpt of the book about Rummage Sales here.
Adapted excerpt of the book (published in Sojourners) below:
Rt. Rev. Mark Dyer, an Anglican bishop known for his wit as well as his wisdom, famously observes from time to time that the only way to understand what is currently happening to us as 21st-century Christians in North America is first to understand that about every 500 years the church feels compelled to hold a giant rummage sale. And, he goes on to say, we are living in and through one of those 500-year sales.
While the bishop may be using a bit of humor to make a point, his is nonetheless a deadly serious and exquisitely accurate point. Any usable discussion of the Great Emergence and what is happening in Christianity today must commence with a discussion of history. Only history can expose the patterns and confluences of the past in such a way as to help us identify the patterns and flow of our own times and occupy them more faithfully.
The first pattern we must consider as relevant to the Great Emer gence is Bishop Dyer’s rummage sale, which, as a pattern, is not only foundational to our understanding but also psychologically very reassuring for most of us. That is, as Bishop Dyer observes, about every 500 years the empowered structures of institutionalized Christianity, whatever they may be at that time, become an intolerable carapace, or hard shell, that must be shattered in order that renewal and new growth may occur. When that mighty upheaval happens, history shows us, there are always at least three consistent results or corollary events.
First, a new, more vital form of Christianity does indeed emerge. Second, the organized expression of Christianity that up until then had been the dominant one is reconstituted into a more pure and less ossified expression of its former self. As a result of this usually energetic but rarely benign process, the church actually ends up with two new creatures where once there had been only one. That is, in the course of birthing a brand-new expression of its faith and praxis, the church also gains a grand refurbishment of the older one.
The third result is of equal, if not greater, significance. Every time the incrustations of an overly established Christianity have been broken open, the faith has spread—and been spread—dramatically into new geographic and demographic areas, thereby increasing exponentially the range and depth of Christianity’s reach as a result of its time of unease and distress. Thus, for example, the birth of Protestantism not only established a new, powerful way of being Christian, but it also forced Roman Catholicism to make changes in its own structures and praxis. As a result of both those changes, Christianity was spread over far more of the earth’s territories than had ever been true in the past.
OVER THE COURSE of previous hinge times, the church has always been sucked along in the same ideational currents as has the culture in general, especially in matters of governance. The result has been that, at any given time, the political structure of one has always been reflected in and/or exercised influence upon the organizational structures of the other.
Gregory the Great, in wrapping up the chaos of the 6th century, created a church run by monasteries and convents, a system that was in every way analogous to the manors and small fiefdoms of Europe’s Dark Ages. The Roman Church, in emerging from the Great Schism, positioned the exercise and definition of authority in a single position, the papacy, and the council of appointed cardinals surrounding that throne. As a pattern, it was a religious expression of the system of kings and lords growing up in the centuries of pre-Reformation culture.
The Reformation, with its shift to the democratic theology of the priesthood of all believers and its insistence on literacy for the sake of sola scriptura, created a governance exercised by elected leaders subject, in theory anyway, to the will of the people whom they served. Modern Pro testant bodies reflect this flow of authority for the same reason that America itself does. Both are products of the same stimuli and circumstances. Given all of that, what logically can be expected of the Great Emergence, especially in terms of authority in religion?
When one asks an emergent Christian where ultimate authority lies, he or she will sometimes choose to say either “in scripture” or “in the community.” More often though, he or she will run the two together and respond, “in scripture and the community.” At first blush, this may seem like no more than a thoughtless or futile effort to make two old opposites cohabit in one new theology, but that does not appear to be what is happening here. What is happening is something much closer to what mathematicians and physicists call network theory.
That is, a vital whole—the church—is not really a “thing” or entity so much as it is a network in exactly the same way that the Internet or the World Wide Web or, for that matter, gene regulatory and metabolic networks are not “things” or entities. Like them and from the point of view of an emergent, the church is a self-organizing system of relations, symmetrical or otherwise, between innumerable member-parts that themselves form subsets of relations within their smaller networks, in interlacing levels of complexity.
The end result of this understanding of dynamic structure is the realization that no one of the member parts or connecting networks has the whole or entire “truth” of anything, either as such and/or when independent of the others. Each is only a single working piece of what is evolving and is sustainable so long as the interconnectivity of the whole remains intact. No one of the member parts or their hubs has the whole truth as a possession or as its domain. This conceptualization is not just theory. Rather, it has a name: crowd-sourcing, and crowd-sourcing differs from democracy far more substantially than one might at first suspect. It differs in that it employs total egalitarianism, a respect for the worth of the hoi polloi that even pure democracy never had, and a complete indifference to capitalism as a virtue or to individualism as a godly circumstance.
The duty, challenge, joy, and excitement of the church and for the Christians who compose her, then, is in discovering what it means to believe that the kingdom of God is within one and in understanding that one is thereby a pulsating, vibrating bit in a much grander network. Neither established human authority nor scholarly or priestly discernment alone can lead, because, being human, both are trapped in space/time and thereby prevented from a perspective of total understanding. Rather, it is how the message runs back and forth, over and about, the hubs of the network that it is tried and amended and tempered into wisdom and right action for effecting God’s will.



