Welcome! You have accidentally reached the blog of a heteroclite follower of Jesus: dave wainscott. I'm
"pushing toward the unobvious" as I post thinkings/linkings
re: Scripture, church and culture. Hot topics include: temple tantrums, time travel, sexuality/spirituality, U2kklesia, role of the pastor, God-haunted music/art..and subversive videos like these.
Having been a fervent follower of U2 since 1980, upon hearing "I Will Follow" on the amazing WPLR New Haven (Thanks to St Stoneman) I did (follow)...
And having been a fervent follower of Jesus since Spring 1983..
..when I had the chance, just days after signing on to that second followership, to see/hear/experience U2 at the New Haven Coliseum--a concert that was so historic and Holy Spirited that the leitourgia had no name, and inevitably they later had to literally blow up the arena (watch it here!), as no act could possibly top U2 (or even their alarming opening act)...
As one with wholly/holy obsession with said band , and an unrepentant bibliophile, these three books are among my favorites...and I own a few...
thousand.
Scot Calhoun, who directs the U2 Conference, has edited and curated these three voluminous (and luminous) volumes. Academic books about U2, including one on religious impulse? Order them yesterday.
Oh, before you go any further, soundtrack this coming conversation about Angela's observations with an opening act/prelude: the classic interview excerpt of Bono on Gay Byrne's "The Meaning of Life"; you can watch it below. See you after the break. You might even sense the religious impulse to be baptized/renew your baptismal vows after viewing this short clip...which may be precisely the the point.
The short section I have in mind starts at 1:55 (though do watch the first section as well, as Bono masterfully adopts/adapts the classic C.S. Lewis trilemma apologetic ( popularly called the "Liar, Lunatic, or Lord" apologetic).
Wow.. I hear that hushed silence from you after the video ended.
When I show this clip in class, it inevitably happens, even from non U2 fans!
That short section has moved me for years, not just because it is a humble, diplomatic but direct confession of Christian faith from the singer, but this particular exchange has often given me the chills and holy hush; it always felt deeply mystical...even liturgical..in a way I could never quite put my finger on..
Until now, thanks to Angela, who says on p. 162:
A video of an interview of Bono with veteran Irish broadcaster Gay Byrne, from his program "The Meaning of Life," includes an exchange oddly echoing the renewal of baptismal vows that take place in some Christian churches at the Easter:
Bono: I find it hard to accept that all the millions and millions of lives, half the earth, for two thousand years, have been touched, have felt their lives touched and inspired by some nutter. I just —I don't believe it.
Byrne: So therefore it follows that you believe (Jesus] was divine.
Bono: Yes.
Byrne: And therefore it follows that you believe that he rose physically from
Bono: Yes. I've no problem with miracles. (Laughs] I'm livingaround them. I am one.
Byrne: So when you pray, then, you pray to Jesus.
Bono: The risen Jesus.
Byrne: And you believe that he made promises which will come true.
The simple call and response. The rhythmic cadence. The simple but heartfelt "Yes" of Bono's answers the the questions of the host/inquisitive inquisitor/pastor Byrne. And even though the interviewer has been characterized as an agnostic/atheist, Byrne didn't see himself that way. He was more of a struggling Catholic. Someone
called him "a loyal if questioning Catholic later in life."
His genuine interest in Bono's responses are based on decades of friendship . I felt he was even rooting/praying for Bono to confess in a very Christ-honoring and orthodox way.
At the funeral Mass for the late Gay Byrne on Friday, the principal celebrant, Fr Leonard Maloney SJ said those who knew the broadcaster well knew him as “a man of faith”.
In his homily at St Mary’s Pro Cathedral in Dublin, the Jesuit provincial said Byrne’s faith was not the kind of faith that has all the answers. “It was the kind that asks all the questions. link
Bono's "yes" answers called to mind the many riffs and improvisations on the word I have heard over the years as a pastor officiating baptisms/ renewals. Sometimes it is said tearfully and barely audibly ; sometimes shouted as if from a rooftop. A student of mine's recent response was (video here)
But something about Bono's quiet, confident "yes' resonates with me...and I know it spoke to Gay Byrne like no armtwisting evangelistic sermon could.
"All the promises are yes," as St Paul asserted . . A confession of faith in summative one-word microcosm.
'Oddly echoing the renewal of baptismal vows," Angela so articulately commented.
Yes, that's what I had felt but had no language for.
Echoes are important.
Here is one version of the renewal of baptism vows:
V. Do you reject Satan?
R. I do.
V. And all his works?
R. I do.
V. And all his empty promises?
R. I do.
V. Do you believe in God, the Father Almighty, creator of heaven and earth?
R. I do.
V. Do you believe in Jesus Christ, his only Son, our Lord, who was born of the Virgin Mary was crucified, died, and was buried, rose from the dead, and is now seated at the right hand of the Father?
R. I do.
V. Do you believe in the Holy Spirit, the holy Catholic church, the communion of saints, the forgiveness of sins, the resurrection of the body, and life everlasting?
R. I do.
V. God, the all-powerful Father of our Lord Jesus Christ has given us a new birth by water and the Holy Spirit, and forgiven all our sins. May he also keep us faithful to our Lord Jesus Christ for ever and ever.
Also, don't get me started on the two words in the sample ceremony above; and Bono's last and final answer, where it felt right to "say more" and add only two words: "Yes..I do"
They are still going strong as they near their seventieth.
May it be with all who we baptize, marry and speak to.
And interview about the meaning of life.
Amen,
"For no matter how many promises God has made, they are “Yes” in Christ. And so through him the 'Amen' is spoken by us to the glory of God. (2 Corinthians 1:20)
"In his interview in ‘The Meaning of Life’ Gay said this to Martin Sheen: ‘Suppose it’s all true, and suppose you get to meet God at the pearly gates. What will you say to Him?’After hardly a pause, the seasoned actor said: ‘Deo gratias. Thanks be to God.’”
The Lord's Supper [is] probably the most potentially meaningful of the codes regularly employed within Christianity, at least when it is practiced as a full meal.
When, however, the Lord's Supper is practiced (as in most of Western Christianity) as a skeleton ritual with precious little resemblance to a participatory meal (or to any other part of real life), the communication value is radically altered. The excessive ritualization of such a code destroys its value by pushing the experience to an extreme diametrically opposite that of the example above...enacting the drama is such a way that it was [incorrectly] interpreted as real life. In the case of the excessive ritualization of the Lord's Supper, the communication value is lost (or at least radically changed) when it bears no resemblance to anything else in the participants' experience. This means that our attempts to interpret the event via analogy with other life experiences are frustrated. But since we are taught that God commands us to do it, we tend to interpret the strange, unique thing as sacred and magical. That is, we interpret this meaningless ritual as we interpret any meaningless ritual (e.g. kissing grandma)--as required by the one in charge (in this case God) and entered into to please him rather than as a participatory experience.. ...Since eating together already exists as a meaningful code within the society, all that needs to be done is to practice the Lord's Supper as a real meal (as the early church did). This would allow the sacramental significance of the activity to develop naturally from the associations between it and real life, on the one hand, and between it and the historical experience of Jesus with the disciples, on the other. These [dead codes} (like poor Bible translations) are like bridges halfway across a river that require the receptors to build their own half from the opposite bank if they are to be able to make use of the part of the bridge that has been built. -Charles H. Kraft, Communication Theory for Christian Witness, pp 115-116
The Submerging Church, as I see it, is radically subversive, relentlessly incarnational, and ruthlessly hospitable. It dives deeply into everyday life, sharing it with others, while at the same time questioning and critiquing the conditions of that life we share. Since this community lives from its center, the risen Jesus Christ, its boundaries are porous and permeable with arms outstretched to everyone who encounters it.
Here are some characteristics of the Submerging Church:
first, it is hard to find because it is small and spread throughout the community;
second, it is difficult to join because “membership” is relational and based on a shared journey towards the center;
thirdly, it is culturally atheistic, that is, not committed to a cultural Christ or his civil religion;
fourth, it is more like yeast (which though small permeates the whole) than a beast (a mega-church prominent in the community);
fifth, it finds its “niche” with those at the margins and their experiences, which generates the “lens” through which it views and responds to the world; and
finally, it focuses on “inner-tainment” (life with God) rather than entertainment.
The core content of the Submerging Church comes from:
first, being a Kingdom Outpost rather than a religious institution;
second, following a Cruciform Jesus rather a Cultural Christ;
third, living by a Holy Script (Bible) rather than a cultural script;
fourth, being centered on a bath and a meal rather than programs;
fifth, seeking justice for all (especially the poor) instead of good for “just us”; and
sixth, sharing “communitas” rather than just fellowship (Google it!).
The first two questions are partly true. For example, simply reading the previous verses (unheard of!) suggests the primary answer to #2: "This is the spirit of the antichrist, which you have heard is coming and even now is already in the world." The devil is mentioned nowhere in the context.
It's the third question I'd like to focus on.
I wish everyone could read biblical Greek and Hebrew.
But speakers of language like Spanish GET the idea of a plural "you."
In fact, you should learn spanish JUST to read 1 John 4:4:
Ustedes, queridos hijos,
son de Dios y han vencido a esos falsos profetas, porque el que está en
ustedes es más poderoso que el que está en el mundo. link, context
"Greater is he who is within you all" doesn't do it justice. Just ask anyone from Texas. "How are y'all doing?" usually means a single 'you". To ask about a group, it's "y'all of y'all."
I sometimes suggest to Spanish speakers that the "singular plurals" of the Bible are almost like an "Ustedes va" --a grammatically incorrect phrase, the "you" is plural and the verb is singular-- a community as one, not one (individual) as the community as English forces us to think.
On the singular plural, see A Crash of Rhinos...a Committee of Buzzards. It is ironic and should be obvious that one of the groups we can learn the most about spiritual warfare is Anabaptists/Mennonites, nonresisitants and pacifists! How do folks who don't "do war" actually "do war" with the devil. Secondly, they GET community/communitas. I was privileged to spend a week in community (ahh) studying spiritual warfare and worldview with a great Mennonite Brethren scholar, Paul Hiebert. I may upload some of his notes. There are also at least two helpful related resources:
Direction: A Mennonite Brethren Forum, Vol 29, No. 2 (online here )which includes an article by Hiebert (here)
------------- Not to mention....okay I will... that high up on the list of misunderstood scriptures is the "spiritual armor" of Ephesians 6: "take up the shield of faith," which we usually read as addressed to an individual. But it's addressed to a group/church...grammatically and theologically. -- Related:
I love reminding peope of the community/communitas nature of the church by saying something like "Guess how many times the word 'pastor' shows up in the New Testament? Only once, and in passing: Ephesians 4, where is it mentioned only as part of the shared leadership the church is called to have."
BUT I was wrong! Thanks to Gary Amirault for straightening out my math and theology:
The word “pastor” doesn’t occur in the New Testament (KJV, NIV, NASK, NRSB) at all. Shocked? I was. The word “pastors” occurs ONCE in the N.T. in Ephesians 4:11 and NOT as a title. Gary Amirault
Okay, that may evoke a groan, and seem like only a technicality to you.
BUT, remember in a parallel way, "saint" also appears a total of ZERO times in the Bible.
It also only shows up in the plural.
And quite a few more times than "pastors."
It would seem the early church expectation was multiple saints with the gift of pastor are inevitably embedded in the local body. And this likely has nothing to do with multiple pastoral staff. It has to do with many "laypeople" (a word that shows up nowhere is scripture, singular OR plural...so glad Moltmann highlights this, "The Source," p. 95) walking in their gifts..
whether in the gathering, or (more importantly) in the "world" (I remember commissioning Regean as the "pastor to Jiffy Lube").
I realize one might count "shepherd" as the same biblical term as pastor, which opens up other references..but this gets just as subversive, if as in John 10, a "shepherd/pastor is to know all her/his sheep BY NAME."
All this might entail blowing up the 22nd row of pews (better yet all pews...is that word in the Book?).
More? Chain saw the pulpit..
"The meaning of Scripture is enacted in the Christian community, and only those who participate in the enactment can understand the text. Consequently, the transformation of the community is not the presupposition but also the result and proof of true interpretation. Where God’s spirit is at work, the community (“we all”) is being transformed into the image of Christ and liberated to see, when they read Scripture, that the old covenant prefigured precisely this transformation." -Richard Hays, Echoes of Scripture in the Letters of Paul, p. 152)
The U2 transition into the 1990s always calls to mind liminal space; even the very border/end of liminal space. Here's the "From the Sky Down" documentary...a few highlights for me, with insights on
15:00--20:00 section on Bonglose/language, "building your house from the sky down."
36:36-37:42, the force with which Larry literally/symbolically threw away the sticks of the 1098's on New Years Eve.
50:32-53:37 on Edge's divorce...especially hearing Edghe sing "Love is Blindness"
Best of all, 40:57'-41:19's:
"You have to reject one expression of the band first before you get to the next expression.... and in between you're nothing... you have to risk it all"
Great insights also on the concept of clan and community; as as most fans know, the timing of the shift with the fall of Berlin wall..
"In this book, José Faur articulates the political dimension of Judaism, the essence of the Jewish alternative to the cunning societies of world history. As Faur describes, thousands of years ago, the Jewish nation became what Nobel laureate Elias Canetti called a "naked crowd"; a society built on transparency and inclusiveness, impervious to the attempts of would-be tyrants to control the "crowd" through mind-games, linguistic manipulation, and mass hysteria. While the Jewish people have, over the course of history, occasionally lost touch with this foundation of their society, they have never lost the dream of a truly free society for all. This book serves as a comprehensive introduction to Judaism from the perspective of the Western political tradition. The last section examines Pauline Christianity and its origins in Greek and Roman pagan thought and culture." -Jose Faur Studies.org
''Prof. Jose Faur's 'The Naked Crowd' carefully and correctly defines what is unique to the nation Israel: it is ruled by a 'Book,' the Torah, written by God and accepted by Israel. The Torah teaches the dignity of humankind that inheres in the divine image that every human shares. Therefore, following the sagacious King Solomon, demeaning a human being is a moral assault on the all-powerful, all-knowing divine Creator. Viewing Israel's Torah as a document subversive to all hierarchical societies (pagan, Christian, and some Jewish societies included), Prof. Faur finds the assault upon Israel and its 'Book' to be political and not theological. This fine monograph is a worthy introduction to the Judaism of the Written and Oral Torah, that Jewish dialectic of culture that provides the benchmark for existential authenticity in Israel.'' --Alan Yuter, rabbi, Congregation B'nai Israel, the Orthodox Congregation of Downtown Baltimore
An introduction to the differences between Western and Jewish politics.
For thousands of years, humanity has suffered at the hands of cunning tyrants, individual men who use charm, rhetoric, and deception to maintain power over the masses. From the ancient times of the biblical tyrant Nimrod and the Pharaohs, through the terrible reigns of the Caesars, to the despotic regimes of the Hitlers and Stalins of more recent times, human society has been structured to benefit those in power at the expense of the common people.
Mission
The sole exception to this arrangement - the only society to be formed around the needs and rights of its members and not the selfish whims of flesh-and-blood rulers - is the Jewish society. Thousands of years ago, the Jewish nation became what Nobel laureate Elias Canetti called a "naked crowd"; a society built on transparency and inclusiveness, impervious to the attempts of would-be tyrants to control the "crowd" through mind-games, linguistic manipulation, and mass hysteria. While the Jewish people have, over the course of history, occasionally lost touch with this foundation of their society, they have never lost the dream of a truly free society for all.
In this book, José Faur articulates the essence of the Jewish alternative to the cunning societies of world history.
Welcome to the Naked Crowd.
Products
Chapters include:
* The Effects of the Anti-Maimonidean Ideology on the Mind-Set of Modern European Jewry
* Ejecting the God of Sinai
* La Suprema and Scripted Truth
* Cunning Humanity
* The Emergence of Greek Rationality
* The Four Phases of Hebrew Wisdom
* Nakedness in Paradise
* En route to the Promised Land
* God and Man in Jewish Thought
* The Berit Contracted at Sinai-Moab
* Morality, Exclusiveness, and Universality
* Monolatry and Idolatry
* Election, Love, and Redemption
* Wedding Widow Israel
* Oedipal Theology
* "Sold Under Sin"
* Paul and Rome: Putting their Shoulders to the Wheel
It appears to be for real that The Edge is not proud of his humility. Sometimes he is even self-effacing about his self-effacing. (Even Bono's much more obvious ego and self-confessed "messianic complex" is largely misunderstood as pure pride, but a careful reading of his interviews, and his life, will suggest that he has humbled himself in the sight of the Lord, and of his own potential for pride).
I think with The Edge it is largely due to the fact that early on, Lypton Village, The Monday Night House Church, the Shalom Community, and (especially) U2 (watch 12:30ff in the Beth Maynard video at bottom for that important backstory) allowed Edge to taste and see that communitas is good and is of God.
He certainly seems to be a naturally humble and modest person, but being formed and forged in that rarest of environments and crucibles--community with grows a 'tas'--has gently and powerfully set such as his very core and course.
In the language of Lord of the Rings, he has been endlessly intrigued by that "mission..quest..thing" that creative community creates...and that necessarily leaves one at a loss for words.
Thus the need for a guitar..or two.
Or two in one...
In this video interview/demonstration of his guitar technique, Edge notes (00:35ff) that "the two (playing and echo effect) work off each other totally ...I discovered early on that playing rthymically with echo gives you opportunity to almost play off a second musician, its almost like a conversation... the conversation in this case is between me and the echo."
Note that he has discovered..ironically while being alone..that the best introverted alone work/art happens when one creates and facilitates conversation/community. Matthew Fox talks of "extroverted monasticism." Edge sets it to music, and on fire. What happens between Edge and his guitar is so holy and hushed that it might seem wrong and exhibitionist to yank it out of the (prayer and practice) closet. But it is in essence a relationship; a relational essence that emerges when Edge plays (prays) his guitar. That may sound like the ultimate in narcissism, but I think he "gets" that with any inhouse conversation/intra-relationship that one has created, one is responsible to missionally move that relationship outward, inviting others in.
The Trinity of course is the primary paradigm here: Three Persons whom the Scripture takes pains and pages to show have relationships with each other. But since God is also One, he cannot be content to just talk to himself. Inevitably, the missio dei kicks in, the dance of pericherosis is in motion...and elevation happens.
You too (and U2) have been invited to overhear the conversation God is having with himself. "I feel like a lot of our songs are overheard conversations," Bono offers, "sometimes they are not my stories."
When one plays/prays through guitar and voice, within a context of community and conversation (communisation),one begins telling (even instrumentally/glossolaically) the stories of others...and The Other.
"Here's where we've got to be/Love and community Laughter is eternity/if Joy is real." (U2, "Get on Your Boots").
For most folks, that's a big "IF." But to be discovered by real joy is to create community that can't create koinonitis, only community; that won't wind up myopic, but mystic.
I love this vintage 1984 article about Edge that atU2 recently hauled out of the vault:
Bob Dylan once called Robbie Robertson "a mathematical guitar genius," a description which also seems to fit the Edge's goldcrested style. I hope it won't damage his modesty. Most times I asked the Edge about himself, he kept pulling back to "we," the community of the band. He seems to huddle aside from fame. "I cannot ever really comprehend what our fans see me as," he says, "I can only observe it from the eye of the storm."
"Probably the people who buy our records or go to our shows are far more aware of the Edge as the public person than I am. I happen to be more aware of his private side." Thus the Edge: the semi-detached guitar hero.
But do you see tihis gifted guitarists' dilemma. He indeed might still be tempted to play "just for himself," and surely the energy that is created/recreated when he is alone in his room doing what only he can do on guitar is rewarding. When you are that good, one might also be tempted to "shoot your wad and name yourself God.":
"As a guitar player, I've always done the work of two. One of the reasons Dik left was because two guitar players never worked. I never had that discipline. I was always filling up every spare moment with guitar."
..Yet its not truly a dilemma but a trilemma that he is on the horns of: One choice: play for yourself. Another choice: play for others. Third, and only choice: The above is not only false dichotomy and dilemma, but misses that life, faith, conversation and community are inherently incarnational, Trinitarian in unity, fissional and missional.
Beth Maynard (Beth's blog here)gave a delightful talk at Gordon College on U2 and Community..
(Note: the embedded video has some blips...until they fix it, best place to watch the complete video is
here, mp3 here). Excerpts below are from 22:07ff on the embedded video:
"Shane Claiborne has paraphrased Dietrich Bonhoeffer as saying, 'Love community and you will kill it'..
It's just way too ingrown in a Christian worldview for the raison d'être of a community to be nothing more than 'having a community'...it's much more healthy and much more biblical for a mission to generate its community..
there are no [monastic] orders whose call is just to be an order. Classically, that question of vocation comes before the question of community.'
You might be surprised that early on U2 articulated their vocation with a founding Scripture, which shaped them early on, and for the long term "not as onstage evangelists, but as way-clearers, as obstacle removers, as objection-raisers ...thirty years of...asking thorny qiestions that only turn out to ultimately make sense if Jesus is Lord." (Maynard)
But that Lordship leads to giving oneself "first to the Lord, and then to others." Beth quotes Edge:
"In the long run, I suspect that other people will wind up doing far more than us...and that's an exciting idea.
Easy enough to say..or is it...but Edge just believes it...even (especially) when he plays alone in a room. It's humbling to live in kenotic community, but ironically it's the only path to "doing the greater works than Jesus" that Jesus himself promised would be normative for followers...who hear the Echo.
Since, like St. Carla of Delano, he knows he is never alone, and always for others... Philippians 2-style.
It is not good for humans to be alone, God is quoted as saying in Genesis. By the time one finishes Revelation, one is convinced it is not good or possible for God to be alone either.
"The Spirit and the Bride say 'Come.'"
I hear (and see....holy synesthesia is often the subversive language of U2...and Scripture) that United Voice every time The Edges' "swirling epiphanies" talk to themselves.. and thus to me.
--
P.S. By the way, that smile of the Edge's, that begins at 1:33 at the instructional video above...and grows with a recognition that "something is up" is priceless, and wordlessly summarizes everything I've tried to say with words.
When you watch the Edge demonstrate "Where The Streets have No Name" played "normally," and then after his explanation, with the Echo.. he cannot help but smile...as he knows the 'conversation with the echo" makes all the difference....and he knows its not about him.