interested in an
amazing, creative,
hilarious, provocative,
profound
book on the parables? test-drive
"Kingdom, grace, judgment: paradox, outrage, and vindication in the parables of Jesus"
by Robert Farrar Capon:
Pages 1-32 strongly recommended, SCROLL DOWN:
....or hear his podcast on The Prodigal Son here.
Welcome! You have accidentally reached the blog of a heteroclite follower of Jesus: dave wainscott. I'm "pushing toward the unobvious" as I post thinkings/linkings re: Scripture, church and culture. Hot topics include: temple tantrums, time travel, sexuality/spirituality, U2kklesia, role of the pastor, God-haunted music/art..and subversive videos like these.
Pages
Search Me:
Showing posts with label capon. Show all posts
Showing posts with label capon. Show all posts
Wednesday, May 06, 2015
Wednesday, December 18, 2013
interventionist sewing machine from above or divine iceberg from below?
Capon's charts on competing views of history below. Which do prefer?
--
Capon on video talks on this:(all 3 videos here) ----------------
Gary Mar summarizes Capon's charts of divine action in history (from pp.426-433 of Capon's subversive classic, "Kingdom Grace Judgment: Paradox, Outrage,and Vindication in the Parables"):
--
III-A. Two Models of the Divine Action in Human History.
History, according to a Christian perspective,
is not merely a random series of happenings, but a meaningful sequence of
events in the grandest of all narratives: a narrative that lead to the end of
history in the final fulfillment of God's purposes for humanity. Moreover, the acts of God in history are not limited
to the Old and New Testaments, but continue today in the unfolding of current
events. To clarify how this might be
conceived, I borrow two contrasting pictures from Robert Farrar Capon's Parables of Judgment. The first picture sees God as transcendent
upon, but connected to, human history through a few critical biblically-recorded
divine interventions. Robert Capon
explains:
Figure 3. The Divine Tailor or Interventionist
Model of Gods Relation to Human History
|
The above divine tailor or interventionist view of history with its occasional
biblically-recorded accounts of divine actions connecting heaven and earth can be contrasted with what might be called
the divine iceberg or sacramental view of God's relationship
to human history. Capon contrasts and continues:
Figure 4. The Divine Iceberg or Sacramental Model
of Gods Relation to Human History.
|
by Professor
Gary Mar
--
Excerpt from Capon's book:
Let me posit God not as a divine tailor in heaven sending down an
interventionist needle from time to time but as a divine iceberg present
under all of time. On that analogy, one tenth of his presence to
history will be visible above the surface of its waters, and nine tenths
will be invisible below the surface, but his presence out of sight will
be just as much a part of history as his presence in broad daylight.
The divine acts in history are not just occasional interventions of a
reality that wasn’t present before; they are precisely acted parables -
sacraments, if you will, real presences - of a reality that was there
all along ... Better yet, the WHOLE of the mystery that underlies
creation is present every time one of those sacramental outcroppings of
the mystery occurs. It is not, for example, that the mystery of the
Creation occurs only at the beginning, to be superseded later on by the
mystery of the Passover and then by the mystery of the Cross, the
mystery of the Resurrection, and the mystery of the Judgement at the
End. It is that those several manifestations are outcroppings of a
single, age-long mystery of
Creation-Call-Passover-Redemption-Resurrection-Judgment that is fully
present in every one fo the. Just as each upthrusting of the iceberg is
one and the same iceberg in a visible aspect, so each upthrusting of the
mystery is a visible aspect of one and the same mystery.” link
Labels:
book reviews,
capon,
parables,
reading the Bible
Tuesday, October 15, 2013
"wonderfully pugnacious," rude, intelligent and convincing": "Unapologetic" (video and reviews)
Not to be confused with the Rihanna album of the same mane,
"Unapologetic" the book is now out in USA .
I am unapologetic and not being into apologetics, but do check this out!
(see my previous post on the book for more resources:Unapologetic at Mars Hill).
Video promo/interview:
Video of a lecture based on the book:
“The most exhilarating read of the year...his case for faith is rude, intelligent, and convincing.”
—THE TIMES
Amazon link:
"Unapologetic" the book is now out in USA .I am unapologetic and not being into apologetics, but do check this out!
(see my previous post on the book for more resources:Unapologetic at Mars Hill).
Video promo/interview:
Video of a lecture based on the book:
“You can easily look up what Christians believe in. You can read any number of defenses of Christian ideas. This, however, is a defense of Christian emotions—of their intelligibility, of their grown-up dignity. The book is called Unapologetic because it isn’t giving an ‘apologia,’ the technical term for a defense of the ideas.
“And also because I’m not sorry.” -Francis Spufford
“The most exhilarating read of the year...his case for faith is rude, intelligent, and convincing.”
—THE TIMES
Amazon link:
Unapologetic: Why, Despite Everything, Christianity Can Still Make Surprising Emotional Sense by Francis Spufford
Promo:First published in the United Kingdom to great acclaim, Unapologetic is a wonderfully pugnacious defense of Christianity. But it isn't an argument that Christianity is true—because how could anyone know that (or indeed its opposite)? Refuting critics such as Richard Dawkins, Sam Harris, and the "new atheist" crowd, Spufford, a former atheist and Fellow of the Royal Society of Literature makes an argument that Christianity is recognizable, drawing on the deep and deeply ordinary vocabulary of human feeling, satisfying those who believe in it by offering a ruthlessly realistic account of the grown-up dignity of Christian experience.
Fans of C. S. Lewis, N. T. Wright, Marilynne Robinson, Mary Karr, Diana Butler Bass, Rob Bell, and James Martin will appreciate Spufford's crisp, lively, and abashedly defiant thesis.
Unhampered by niceness, this is a book for believers who are fed up with being patronized, for non-believers curious about how faith can possibly work in the twenty-first century, and for anyone who feels there is something indefinably wrong, literalistic, anti-imaginative, and intolerant about the way the atheist case is now being made.
- Preview PDF here
- Great interview with Mockingird here
- Excerpt of "Yeshua" chapter here.(The writer there says, "I wish I could post the entire Yeshua chapter in Francis Spufford’s Unapologetic. It has to be the freshest, most vivid, gut-level and just plain exciting writing about Jesus since, well, Robert Capon)
- Another excerpt..F word included
Labels:
adbusters,
book reviews,
capon,
culture wars,
reading the Bible
Monday, October 14, 2013
"There's something wrong with this microphone": pastors, power, and "microphoning it in"
![]() |
| photo taken from this ad. You've heard of "The Cross and The Switchblade?" This is the "Microphone and The Cross". But are they compatible? |
I told a bad joke in a sermon once (only once?)
Here it is:
There was a church that was not very liturgically oriented; in fact they were decidedly “low-church.” So the pastor wanted to teach his flock a bit of the richness of the liturgy tradition. He figured he’d start them out with a “win-win” that would be easy; the classic responsive that begins with the leader saying:
“The Lord be with you.”
You know the response:
“And also with you.”
And the pastor thought he’d have the congregation practice the responsive for several weeks, and then officially inaugurate it on Easter; a high attendance Sunday with lots of guests.
So every week they walked through it:
“Now when I say, ‘The Lord be with you,’ remember that you say And also with you.’” Let’s practice…”
They practiced. They were primed. Pumped. Throughout the countdown weeks of Lent, they became quite prepared.
Then came the big Sunday; Easter in all its glory. Lots of guests; an air of expectancy in the room; especially among the well-trained saints knowing they were about ready to show off what they had been practicing.
So the pastor stepped up to the pulpit with a knowing smile. But he noticed that something was wrong with the microphone. So before he realized it, he said aloud just that:
“There is something wrong with this microphone.”
Well, the congregation was so primed and practiced that they immediately shot back, before they realized it, with one loud and clear voice:
“And also with you!”
-whole sermon here: The Lord Be With You...Even When He's Not!" (more bad jokes alert)
I often follow that bad joke with a
good comment:
"I only know two things:
- The Lord is with me
and
- There's something wrong with me."
But I sometimes feel part of the "something wrong with me" is that
I use microphones
at all.
I'm not a microphobe..
but I have a love/hate relationship with ...
and a healthy fear of..
microphones...
Not just that they may not work,
but that they will.
Technology is not neutral, and
medium is message/massage.
In a fascinating new article by Andy Crouch (based on his new book), he calls the wireless microphone the
"one single marker of spiritual authority" in many churches (context).
Then he talks about the "Wireless Headset of Authority" (:
Ironically, when the pastor wears a wireless, particularly one designed (literally) to be
invisible..
it can make the pastor look/sound/seem
invincible.
Where is that amplified megavoice coming from?
Must be God...
or at least the pastor
(oh, same thing).
Pay no attention to that man behind the curtain..or microphone/mask!
Crouch:
Hmm, it still sounds like the intimately invisible voice of God.
..But in many churches, the wireless headset sets a very different tone. Its goal is not volume—it is intimacy. An audience of thousands hears not the thundering strains of a dramatically amplified voice; instead, they are able to hear a single person speaking as if that person was talking directly to them, face to face, friend to friend.
A top-quality wireless headset requires both electric power (fresh batteries, hundreds of watts of amplification) and technological power (meticulously designed circuits, expertly equalized sound). And it delivers extraordinary social power—the ability to address thousands with one-to-one familiarity. But once all that power is switched on, a good wireless headset is meant to disappear....
.. link
Chapter 38 ("Microphones and Power") of Doug Paggit's Preaching Reimagined should be wrestled with.
I find it intriguing to listen to megachurch pastors who either never wanted to be megachurch pastors, or who try to build in intimacy (Rob Bell, Greg Boyd et al). Doug Paggit is one: Solomon's Porch are so emergent/organic that they have couches, not pews. They meet in the round, and the speaker sits on a stool in the middle, bot stands behind a pulpit up front. BUT they are so large, they have to (?? never jump to "have to") use a microphone. Better yet, microphones. The whole place is wired, so that if someone in couch #33 (way better than pew 22) speaks, they can be heard.
I'm all for the microphonehood of all believers..
but I worry it's already too late when microphones "have" to be used at all.
( as the EBay Atheist wondered, what's a stage doing in a church, anyway?)
I am not sure "the young man or woman in the 22nd pew" can help see/hear the "Wireless Headset of Authority" as "something more than sexual".
Still, role models are out there. How can we use a microphones, but not be "of it?"
How do we refuse/defuse the power that it uses?
How do we (can we?) handle handling microphones without them manhandling us;
wear headsets without altering our mindsets?
A heteroclite blogger once pondered Pope Francis:
One of the first things I noticed about the new pope is that when he first came out on the balcony,
(microphones themselves raise crucial questions; see chapter 38 of
"Microphones and Power, see chapter 38 of Pagitt's Preaching Reimagined).
he tried to hold the microphone himself.
He eventually let his (literally) righthand man ) (=servant)take it.
And do read Crouch below. But ask: Is power "a gift to be stewarded" (Crouch)..or as others (Capon) might warn, to be avoided at all costs..as Jesus did (at least "right-handed power") ?:
But as is obvious with what we know so far about Francis I...
(has always insisted on speaking on same level as his audience, went to evangelical pastors meetings in Argentina and asked for prayer, asked for prayer from the crowd at installation, rode the train and subway to work as archbishop, checked out of the hotel himself, and then took the bus with other bishops after installation
etc
etc.
etc)
.... the guy is humble with his approach to power.
And he doesn't seem to be proud of his humility.
This will be interesting to see how we navigates all the trappings and pompenstance. link
Anthropologist Geert Hofstede coined the phrase "power distance" to describe the ways that some cultures prefer that the powerful look and act powerful. In high power distance cultures, power is made visible and tangible, and dramatic differences in power are seen as a natural, indeed crucial, part of a healthy society.
In low power distance cultures, on the other hand, visible hierarchy and signs of power are discouraged. Those with power are expected to treat others as equals, not as subordinates. Charles Tidwell, who has taught Hofstede's power distance concepts, summarizes it nicely: In high power distance societies, "powerful people try to look as powerful as possible." But in low power distance societies, "powerful people try to look less powerful than they are."
Not long ago I was with a member of Congress, a man who in many ways embodied traditional power—imposingly tall, possessing a confident and deep voice inflected with a proudly retained regional accent. A group of visitors filled every seat at the small table in his office, so the congressman sat in his leather high-backed chair, separated from us by several feet of expansive wooden desk. It was a tableau of power familiar to generations of political and business leaders.
But less than five minutes into the meeting, the congressman became visibly uncomfortable. Suddenly he interrupted. "Wait, this isn't working," he announced. He stood up, lifted his desk chair nearly over his head, and manhandled it over the desk. He set it down on our side of the room, joining the circle at the table. "That's better," he said.
And it was. It was also an astonishing reminder of how the norms of power have shifted. Thomas P. "Tip" O'Neill or Dan Rostenkowski, to name two powerful legislators when I was coming of age, would never have rearranged their offices to be closer to strangers. For all their bonhomie, they never would have thought to close the distance in the way that congressman felt necessary.
Our culture's attitudes toward power, or at least toward power's display, have shifted dramatically in a few generations. In the business world, the dress code of corporate leaders slid down a slippery slope from IBM's coat and tie, to Steve Jobs's turtlenecks, to Mark Zuckerberg's hoodie. America, today, is about as low power distance as it has ever been—and so is the American church.
Two Generations of Power
This shift in power distance in the church is perfectly illustrated by a father and son.
Dr. Charles Stanley, senior pastor of First Baptist Church of Atlanta and a pioneer in television distribution through his organization, In Touch Ministries, preaches to this day in a suit and tie, a substantial Bible resting before him on a wooden reading desk. Born in 1932 in Pittsylvania County, Virginia, he came of age in a high power distance society, and a high power distance church.
His son, Andy, is the founding pastor of North Point Community Church, now a multisite church. In lieu of a sermon from the "campus pastor," most North Point affiliates project his weekly messages in high-definition video. Andy is universally referred to by his first name, has no doctoral degree, and usually wears an open-collared polo. He stands in a pool of light on a darkened stage cluttered with worship band gear, occasionally consulting notes on a café table.
Andy was born in Atlanta in 1958, just as that city began decades of growth that made it the center of a "New South." He came of age in a low power distance culture. And so it is not surprising that he helped create a low power distance church.
But this leads to a crucial insight from Hofstede. The difference between low power distance and high power distance is not whether some people are more powerful than others. That is true every time human beings gather, whether we like it or not. The difference is whether the powerful want to be seen as powerful.
When we in the church talk about power, we often talk about it strictly as something negative—something dangerous to be avoided—rather than as a gift to be stewarded.
Andy is no less powerful a pastor than his father. Indeed, you could well make the case that even at the height of his influence, Charles did not command as wide recognition, as much access to political and business leaders, and such great influence over an entire generation of church leaders as his son. (Some 12,000 people gather at the Catalyst conference in Atlanta every October, in no small part to hear from Andy and pastors he has mentored and trained.)
But in a low power distance culture, it is especially easy for the powerful to forget their power. A friend of mine was speaking with the senior pastor of a megachurch. "How do you handle the power that comes with your role?" my friend asked. "Oh, power is not a problem at our church," was the reply. "We are all servant leaders here."
It was a sincere answer; this leader's commitment to servant leadership is genuine. His church, like many megachurches, assiduously cultivates an informal, low power distance mindset—the daily wardrobe in its corridors runs a narrow gamut from ripped jeans (on the youth workers) to khakis (on the senior pastor). But I have felt the change in atmosphere when this leader walks into a room. It's as if someone had abruptly turned down the thermostat and shut off the background music. He is a servant leader. But he is also a person with power.
And this is the problem with low power distance, with the wireless headset and the informality of contemporary offices and dress codes: It can deceive us into thinking that power is not an issue that requires our attention, let alone a matter for discipleship. And the ones most likely to be deceived are the ones with the most power. (context)All I know is "there's something wrong with me."
Plenty.
But I love that two friends have identified two things I sometimes do right.
Tim suggested that I push toward the unobvious
Tom offered that I am a "low-key" pastor.
I take both as compliments and wear those badges with honor.
I'm just not sure I can wear a wireless microphone about it (:
Labels:
book reviews,
capon,
ecclesiology,
empire,
media,
Pope Francis,
role of the pastor,
self-disclosure,
semiotics,
sexuality
Friday, September 13, 2013
Capon tribute by Ethan Richardson
Nice tribute to "the very much alive" Robert Farrar Capon by Ethan Richardson. It concludes:
...I sometimes wonder about Jesus laughing—the Bible never says he did—and certainly the Cross is no laughing matter. Nor are many of the parables, for that matter. On the other hand, he called the silly boys and girls to him and said the kingdom was for them, and then the dense and forgetting nobodies who followed him around—wasn’t this a time-sensitive ministry anyways? Perhaps Jesus wasn’t concerned with making much of himself. This is what Capon is teaching me. Of the joy of Christ, that He died and rose again, that we may sit and wonder at what we’ve gotten all spun-around about, to feel relief for once in our jaws at night, and hurt in the gut from laughing at crude jokes.
Tov! Tov! Amen and amen, and now for a cigarette, and a nap.
-Ethan Richardson, full post here
Wednesday, September 11, 2013
Wednesday, July 17, 2013
Capon's non-universalist universalism
Capon: (HT and post title Johnny Parker)"I am and I am not a universalist. I am one if you are talking about what God in Christ has done to save the world. The Lamb of God has not taken away the sins of some — of only the good, or the cooperative, or the select few who can manage to get their act together and die as perfect peaches. He has taken away the sins of the world — of every last being in it — and he has dropped them down the black hole of Jesus’ death. On the cross, he has shut up forever on the subject of guilt: “There is therefore now no condemnation. . . . All human beings, at all times and places, are home free whether they know it or not, feel it or not, believe it or not.
But I am not a universalist if you are talking about what people may do about accepting that happy-go-lucky gift of God’s grace. I take with utter seriousness everything that Jesus had to say about hell, including the eternal torment that such a foolish non-acceptance of his already-given acceptance must entail. All theologians who hold Scripture to be the Word of God must inevitably include in their work a tractate on hell. But I will not — because Jesus did not — locate hell outside the realm of grace. Grace is forever sovereign, even in Jesus’ parables of judgment. No one is ever kicked out at the end of those parables who wasn’t included in at the beginning." link
Labels:
capon,
death of Jesus,
reading the Bible,
rob bell
Wednesday, June 19, 2013
"13 Christians Who Are Seriously Funny (On Purpose)"...and who would you add?
"13 Christians Who Are Seriously Funny (On Purpose)" by Cathleen Falsani
List and videos here..so glad Colbert, Fr. James Martin and Rob Bell made the list.
Who would you add?
-Ken and Vincent
-Dan Nainan
-Steve Taylor
-These folks
-Bone Hampton
-Rhett and Link
-Julian Smith
-Taylor Mason
-Robert Farrar Capon (see "Capon") tags below)
...and.. where are the women?
Friday, May 10, 2013
"On the eve of the Big Bang, over single-malt scotch and cigars, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit were making a final run-through.."
Robert Farra Capon:
Let me tell you how God redeemed the world. On the eve of the Big Bang, over single-malt scotch and cigars, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit were making a final run-through of their plans for the event. The Son was enthusiastic. "I think we've nailed it," he said to the Father. "I'm going to speak everything into being as your Word, and the Spirit here is going to breathe life into it. Then the two of us toss it back to you, and the cosmic party dances itself right into our Trinitarian lap. Elegant! Tov meod! Kala lian! Valde bona, and all that!"
"I have a problem, though," the Spirit says. "I'm the one responsible for the PR in all this, especially when it comes to the fail-safe gambit of Incarnation we've planned to cover both creation and redemption. The Son really does make the world, right? But with the human race locked into time and space, it's going to look as if we haven't seriously tried to redeem the mess they've made until Jesus shows up late in history. The fact that we've had the Son in there tidying things up from the beginning is the last thing they'll think of. How do I convince them the Incarnation isn't just an afterthought?"
"Easy," says the Father. "Sure, it will look as if the Incarnation of my Word is simply a response to sin. But since all three of us will have been intimately present to everything from square one, all you have to do is give them images that show both creation and redemption going on full force from the start. From before the beginning, in fact, since we're talking about it right now. What's the problem with that?
"The problem," the Spirit explains, "is precisely with the images. However many mysterious, right-brain images of the Word's age long presence I give them, they're going to dream up transactional, left-brain ones and view him as something you inserted late in the day. Think of the damage they can do to your reputation as the Father who creates or even to the Son's, as the one who redeems if they decide to think of you as the coach in a football game and the Son as the quarterback. Since you're not going to reveal the Word's Incarnation until some two-thirds of history has gone by, how do I stop them from thinking you kept him in the locker room until the fourth quarter? We three may know he's been in there right from the first possession, but no one else will. Even your biggest fans are going to be hard put to sell that as brilliant management."
"Listen," the Father says. "I decide what's brilliant management, not the fans. And as for my reputation, that's your department, not mine. Besides, haven't we talked about this practically forever? You know the drill. All through the process of revealing my Son in history, you keep slipping them images of the hiddenness of his Incarnation — of the mystery of the Word's activity in the world even before you arrange for him to be born of Mary. You're going to hang images like the Paschal Lamb and the Rock in the Wilderness in their minds. After that, all you'll have to do is get somebody like Paul to say that those things were presences of Christ before Christ — that the Lamb and the Rock are in fact my Incarnate Word anticipating himself. What's so hard about that?"
"Plenty," the Spirit answers. I've been doing simulations of human thought in my mind. I think we've underestimated the effects of cooping people up in four dimensions. Look at it from my point of view. You plunk Jesus into the world at one spot in history, and then you expect me to convince them he's present as your Word in all of history — before, during, and after Jesus?"
The Son interrupts him. "But I really am going to be present. Or, to put it their way, I really will have been all along. So I don't see..."
The Spirit's patience is wearing thin. "Give me a break! Since I'm the one who has to take everything that’s yours and get it across to them, I'm trying to solve your problems here too. Just think about what they'll do with a Jesus who stays in history for only thirty-three years. Even if I get John to say that he's the Word who made everything from the beginning, they'll probably imagine him as a pot of holy soup we delivered too late for a good many of our customers. And after they've jumped to the conclusion that the Word wasn't present to anyone who lived before Jesus, they'll leap to the even more dreadful notion that nobody who lived after him can have his benefits until their assorted churches get him canned, marketed, and distributed to them."
The Father tries to break in. "But what about the Pentecost party we've planned to get the church going? Won't that. . . ?"
"I'm sorry," the Spirit insists, "but I'm afraid Pentecost will be just one more thing for them to misread. Don't get me wrong: I'm totally on board with both of you. But suppose I do give you the rushing mighty wind and the party hats made out of fire. Even suppose I throw in the mystery of speaking in different languages in order to get the universality of the Son's work into the picture. They're still going to think the church is in the world to sell clam chowder to customers who never had it before.
"I mean, think of the possibilities for ecclesiastical arrogance. Jesus takes away the sins of the world, right? In him, everyone who ever lived gets free forgiveness for whatever went wrong in full, in advance, and all in one cosmic shot, no strings attached. I'm even going to get the church to include "one Baptism for the forgiveness of sins" in the Nicene Creed so they'll see that the Baptism of Jesus himself does the whole job, even if no one else ever gets baptized. But do you know what they're going to do with that? They're going to paint themselves into a corner and say that the unbaptized go to hell or even that sins after Baptism make forgiveness flake off like a bad paint job, and that unless Christians go to confession for a second coat before they die, they'll go to hell too. Oh, sure. We've also agreed on this Reformation business where I convince them that nobody has to do anything to be forgiven except trust the grace that Jesus has already given everybody. But give them a hundred years after that and they'll manage to turn faith itself into a requirement for grace: no faith, no forgiveness. Out the window again goes the free gift we've given them once and for all; and back in comes forgiveness as a deal that's good only as long as they behave themselves."
"But why on earth," the Son wonders, "would they balk at getting something for nothing like that? Free grace and dying love isn't enough for them? Would they rather we dealt with them on the basis of accountability?"
The Spirit just keeps pressing his point. "I don't understand it any better than you do; all I know is what my simulations tell me. Human beings aren't afraid of accountability; they're crazy about it. If they can't get credit for themselves or dish out blame to others, they cry "Unfair!" That's why I pleaded with you to let me include something less subtle in the revelation. Remember? I suggested an image of the Son hiding a box of chocolates in every person's house: the gift would be there whether they know it or not, like it or not, believe it or not. Maybe then they'd see that their faith doesn't do anything to get them the chocolates of forgiveness; it simply enables them to enjoy what they already have. If they don't trust the gift, of course, it won't mean a thing to them. But the chocolates will always be there. I was even willing to make them miraculous, just to keep the element of mystery in the mix: no matter how many pieces anyone are, the box would always be full. I still think it would have been a good idea."
Finally, though, the Father has had enough. "I understand your difficulties," he says; "but after all, somebody's got to be in charge here. In my mind, we've come up with a revelation that does the work of your chocolates without making us look like candy-pushers. The Son and I have every confidence in you. If you want to inspire the odd Christian apologist here or there to come up with images like that, be our guest. As I said, it's your department. But we're coming down to the wire here, so let's call this a wrap. We have a big day tomorrow." -
Robert Capon, "Where It All Began," prologue to The Fingerprints of God; Tracking the Divine Suspect Through a History of Images
Labels:
capon,
ecclesiology,
images,
reading the Bible,
trinity
Saturday, February 11, 2012
Timelines and Testations: Jesus, Sexonomics and Facebook
![]() |
| (found this online) |
revelatory,
and (even) fun to, as part of a class that several others and I teach, have students plot out (on the whiteboard) their timeline.
As Pastor/Trucker Franks suggests below, sometimes it's "more about the journey than the destination." (See also "What if Torah/ מלכות השמים, is more 'journey than 'doctrine'?")
We then take time to interweave/intertext our personal timelines with the timeline/trajectory of Jesus' life in Matthew's gospel (the thrust of the class).
Especially helpful is the suggestion by Donald Kraybill ("The Upside Down Kingdom") and Ray Van Der Laan (video) that throughout his earthly life, Jesus was revisited by remixes of the original three temptations ("testations" ) of the devil in chapter 4.
Kraybill provocatively proffers the following taxonomy of the temptations; suggesting that any later temptation Jesus faced (or we face) is at heart in one of these three spheres:

1= Bread into stones: Economic
2=Jump from temple and test God:Religious
3=Own all kingdoms: Political;
Henri Nouwen ("in the Name of Jesus") breaks it down this way:
1= Bread into stones: temptation to be relevant
2=Jump from temple and test God: temptation to be spectacular
3=Own all kingdoms: Political; temptation to be rule over
So, it may be useful to plot out various temptations along your life timeline, and ask which of Jesus' temptation are each is tied to.
Nouwen himself, one of the most profound writers on the temptations of Jesus, was both Catholic (gasp!) and struggled with homosexual temptation (!!!)..
And....Uh, on that last temptation, the sexual one, he was in good company, according to a good Book I read:
"Jesus was tempted in every single way humans are..."(click here for the shocking source...but warning, it's a dangerous book for religious folk!)
SO..if every temptation can be filed under one of the three categories:
Economic Religious Political..
or
Relevant Spectacular Rule over
..under which does sexual temptation occur?
Note Rob Bell's definition of "sexuality,"
biblically defined:
"For many, sexuality is simply what happens between two people involving physical pleasure. But that's only a small percentage of what sexuality is. Our sexuality is all the ways we strive to reconnect with our world, with each other, and with God." (Rob Bell, "Sex God," p. 42)...
How might virtually all temptations (the three Jesus faced, or others you could name) be fundamentally economic? Kraybill, you'll remember, calls the bread temptation "economic," but how might any/all others temptations trace to this root/'garbage"?
HINT: Note that he term economics comes from the Ancient Greekοἰκονομία (oikonomia, "management of a household, administration") from οἶκος (oikos, "house") + νόμος (nomos, "custom" or "law"), hence "rules of the house(hold)".[1]
------------------
Note that the baptism of Jesus (chapter 3) and the temptations (chapter 4) should be read together as one literary unit or paragraph ( a "coupling" or "particularization") as two items connected.
Remember how important repeated words are..in this case, "SON":
-The segue is direct..."Then after his baptism, Jesus was led by the Spirit into the desert for temptation by the devil." (Matt. 4:1)
(see this amazing assortment of Scriptures, maybe he is "God's devil" after all..)
-In light of that, ask In what other ways do the baptism and temptation connect?
How does baptism prepare for temptation?
See the sermon by Nadia Bolz-Weber, "How To Say Defiantly, ‘I am Baptized!’"for a contemporary world application.
NOTE: a drop-down box in the temptation scene:
The devil's text ,
"IF
you are the son of God.."
might better be translated
(according to the Greek word used) as:
"SINCE
you are the son of God.."
What difference might it make? Is the devil wondering/questioning asking Jesus if he is son of God? Or is he assuming it; he and Jesus both know that he is...and thus "Since you are the Son of God, what kind of ways can I tempt you to use/abuse that Sonship?"
--
Van Der Laann, in "Jesus Our Desert – The Three Temptations") proposes that the three "temptations" Jesus met in Matthew 4 were the same three that show up (repackaged, revisited) throughout Jesus' timeline on earth...right up to, and especially including the cross (as in, not avoiding it) .Several examples:
- Jesus put God ahead of family ("Who are my brothers and sisters?" "Whoveer loves father and mother more than me cannot be my disciple."-Matthew 12:46-48...in fact, how many ways can you find in that whole chapter where Jesus re-encounters versions of one of the testations?
- When people reported Herod wanted to kill him, he was not concerned (Luke 13)
- When people wanted to make him king by force, he walked away (John 6:15)
- When the crowds were hungry, the disciples wanted Jesus to feed them. He refused (Feeding of the Multitude)
- The "get behind me, Satan" comment to Peter when Peter suggested Jesus should bypass the cross (Matthew 18)
- "go ahead and use Your power; the cross is going to hurt"
The video offered lots of help on how the Testations of Jesus are related to/equated to/hyperlinked to the Testations of Israel in Exodus, Numbers. Deuteronomy. It is no accident that all three testations of Jesus were found in different form in the OT, as well as the Scriptures Jesus used to counter the testations.
Though it is obvious who "The Son (of God)" is in Matthew (Jesus), unless we know the literary/historical background, we miss that in the Old Testament, that phrase is used for Israel/God's people. (see Exodus 4:22-23 and especially the way Matt 2:15 quotes Hosea 11:1) Thus...remember this chart :
Now we realize that God tested/the devil tempted the first "SON" in a similar way.
Jesus the Son succeeds (in 40 days) in "reversing the curse" that Israel the Son inherited by not passing it (in 40 years).
Jesus is not only (in a sense) the
New Moses,
but (in a sense) the New Israel
(for help on that important point, see this article,
and this).
VanDer Laan suggested that the heart of Jesus' "success" was consistently and persistently keeping the "Shema," and not caving into a (mis)use of power. This is the "binder" of the testations: Love God and neighbor.Thus
Q).Who is Jesus in Matthew?
A.) The One who, unlike Israel, passed the wilderness testations by loving God with all his heart, soul, mind and strength....and refusing to give into using "right-handed" (a la Capon) power.
VanderLaan prefers to translate "tests" instead of "temptations."
You have seen that I have coined the word "testations" It would seen that in Scripture that God tests, and the devil tempts...and sometimes both are going on simultaneously.
HERE are some helpful questions you might think about if you want to pursue this topic::
- 1)What were the three temptations of Jesus in Matthew 4:1-11, Compare any ways Mark's account, Mark 1:12-13 and Luke's account, Luke 4:1-13 differ, and suggest any reasons why.
- 2)How does Nouewen summarize the three temptations(1=to be relevant 2=to be spectacular 3=to rule over). H? How do you (use your own words)?
- 3)How do the three temptations connect to the historical and literary world of the Hebrew ("Old')Testament?
- 4)How do the three temptations connect to the contemporary world of Jesus and the disciples?
- 5)List and discuss several possible ways that versions of the three temptations reoccur and are revisited throughout Jesus' life in Matthew's gospel? (How is Jesus tested/tempted elswhere in Matthew, and how are the temptations versions of a similar one (two, or three) that he faced in the original temptation passage?
- 6)What are the three core temptations you face, and how have they revisited you throughout your timeline? How would you categorize them using Nouwen's categories? Using the three categories of the "Shema" (heart/mind/might) a la Vander Laan'? Using Kraybill's three categories (1=Economic 2=Religious 3=Political; see chapters 1-4 of "Upside Down Kingdom")
- 7)What have you learned about passing these tests/resiisting these temptations?
- 8)What does all of this (the Matt 4 Scripture, and testing/tempting) have to do with the Kingdom?
- 9)Discuss how the passages that deal with Jesus not being immune to temptation( Hebrews 2:17-18, Hebrews 4:14-16, and Hebrews 5:7-9) affect your views of "Who is Jesus?" and of Jesus' divinity and humanity.
Finally..
Facebook!
I started teaching all this before Facebook announced it was changing its entire format/interface to "Timeline." As you probably know by now ( If note read all about it here), your Facebook page and wall (oops, the wall is renamed "timeline") is now regeared to feature and celebrate key points (and photos) of your life.
Ostensibly, the (eventually mandatory) switch was about the fun of highlighting historical markers of your life. As we all (should) know, it's all about Facebook catching even more personal data about us, so they can better target their ads towards us..
...in an attempt to tempt us.
So, whatever their motive, I also see the switch as a significant (sign-ificant) sign of the times;
there is a hunger in the culture for narrative/story/journey. Such is integral to the postmodern shift of our EPIC times.
So, plot your life and testations...if not on Facebook, on paper or in your mind.
Who knows what you'll learn.
Maybe how to me more like Jesus...who faced equivalent temptations to all of us..and passed the test.
..But you know, he never was on Facebook ..
--
In any case, the clincher for the argument that the devil's ideas {in the wilderness temptations}aren't all bad comes from Jesus himself. At other times, in other places, and for his own reasons, Jesus does all of the things the devil suggests. Instead of making lunch out of rocks, he feeds the five thousand miraculously--basically the same trick, on a grander scale. Instead of jumping off the temple and not dying, he dies and refuses to stay dead--by any standards, an even better trick. And finally, instead of getting himself bogged down in a two-man presidency with an opposite number he doesn't really understand, he aces out the devil on the cross and ends up risen, ascended at the right hand of the Father as King of Kings and Lord of Lords--which is the best trick of all, taken with the last trump.
No, the difference between Jesus and the devil does not lie in what the devil suggested, but in the methods he proposed--or more precisely, in the philosophy of power on which his methods were based...If you are really God, the devil says, do something. Jesus answers, I am really God, therefore I do nothing...The devil wants power to be used to do good; Jesus insists that power corrupts and defeats the very good it tries to achieve.
..the devil in the wilderness overs Jesus a short cut, Jesus calls it a dead end and turns a deaf ear.-Robert Farrar Capon "The Third Peacock," 43-45.
"Contracted":
understudied and reckless fool
spliced heart laments
staccato bravado
Eucharisting torments
still small in grief
Mourning has broken my record of wrongs
tidal wave offering
strange land , banned songs
immersed by the mystic,
simplexity of trust
Sinai volcano
Seeking one justice; not one is just
testation of forty
daze of wilderness retreats
It is written largely
Adonai slyly defeats
power overpowered,
i found faith
in time.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)














