Showing posts with label holy worldliness. Show all posts
Showing posts with label holy worldliness. Show all posts

Monday, December 17, 2012

Reading Rohr with Bono: half-naked elevation, necessary decadence and life-giving drink with the devil (without moving in with him)


This astonishing section  (and astonishingly nowhere online until I hit "publish") of Richard Rohr's book, "Adam's Return: The Five Promises of Male Initiation" 
below deserves to be read slowly, prayerfully, carefully....

and soundtracked to U2;
and with the following for context and contexture:

1)Thoughtful U2 fans will recognize  resonances of 1990s U2 (especially "Elevation" and "Mysterious Ways" as well as famous/infamous Bono quotes  about Catholic Carnival,   flesh/spirit, "a drink with the devil," incarnation, joy, beauty, sex  etc etc)  all over this reading.  See "Elevation leads to Vertigo 2.0,"  and blogs by  Beth Maynard  Tim Neufeld  for more).

 Bono, as  the extraordinary theologian Miraslov Volf  himself has said, is an "extraordinary theologian (of grace)".

 One almost wonders if the man and his "elegant wife"  in the last paragraph are not actually/  literally Mr. and Mrs. Paul  "Bono" Hewson; it is all so Bono/esque.
At  least  wonder how many "amen"s  a reading of a random line of this text would solicit from Bono.

2)Please don't hear what Rohr is NOT saying.  Don't write him off as a heretic.  Read well.
 Example: the concept of flirting..sometimes literally... with the line (flirting with the line, itself) as a spiritual discipline/"necessary training."

3)The book is on the topic of "male initiation," so the male/man language is not intended to be sexist.
It should be considered/read on the flow of the whole book.  Buy it yesterday, and buy one for Bono and wife.

Enjoy:



Do you  think  St. Francis really stopped being the king of the parties?  Do you think David of the dance, the psalms, the harp and the many women ever stopped being erotic?  Could Rumi, Kabir, Tagor or Hafiz  have possibly written their sacred poetry if they were not sensuous and sensual men? Did St. Phillip Neri  really stop telling jokes and drinking wine?  Did Mozart ever stop having fun?  Did the cloistered contemplatives not know joy?  I don't think so.  They just moved joy and pleasure to the highest level, which is the highest definition of a mystic.  The contemplative, or saint, is the most refined and highest level of the lover archetype.

It is strange that the West has largely created cultures of conspicuous consumerism when it took as its ultimate hero and God figure a  poor and simple man.  You would think our God figure would be Dionysius or Pan.  Why do most Eastern or Native peoples of the world  consider the West to be greedy and materialistic?  Why do we produce such a high rate of physically addicted people?  Why is the search for affluence and pleasure our main concern?  Could it be because we have not blessed the good side of joy and pleasure?  Now it comes back and bites us from behind.  When I consciously seek a certain amou8nt of creature comfort in my life, I find that it satisfies me, and also will never satisfy me.  That is a very life-giving and creative tension to live in.

I  do not find the same kind of approach and avoidance attitudes toward pleasure in Hindu countries. among most Jews, and surely not among Native peoples.  The lower part of a man was not paid his dues or given legitimate permission in Western Christianity.  As many say, sexuality and sensuality is our ever-recurring and "unhealed wound,"  Like petulant schoolboys, we Christians sneak all the fun we can at the expense of underdeveloped countries, our neighbors, and the health of our own bodies and souls.  We feel duly guilty about it all, but we usually don't stop.  We priests deny ourselves sex, but then we insist on four-star hotels and restaurants.  Carnival in Catholic countries became a necessary decadence to justify receiving the ashes the next morning.  Something has not come to balance inside us, and we remain schizoid.   We go to the outer world for our daily pleasures, but we  seldom allow them to bring us to God, or even to ourselves.  We remain split.  Flesh is bad and Spirit is good in our terrible dualism.  Yet the Christian religion is supposed to be incarnation-a love affair between flesh and Spirit.  It  is really quite strange.

Ours is the only religion in the world that dares to believe that God became flesh.  The only religion that chews on the flesh of God has a very sensuous, sexual symbol for the transformation of the lover; we call it the Eucharist.  Christianity says that God is Love but does not appear to really enjoy the lover.  Despite all the Bach masses, Baroque churches, incense, vestments, and luxurious art, we still made our religion into a moralistic matter instead of a  mystical joy.  Our operative God image was much more a banker, a judge, a timekeeper, or an accountant, but seldom a real lover--in any sense that the normal man understands.  Like Michal, the daughter of Saul, we despise David for dancing half naked in church (1 Samuel 6:16); we look away from Shakers, Pentecostals, and holy rollers.  Religion should be a proper and dignified thing, we think.  The hot sins for the Baptists and Catholics
are always associated with the body.  This is no religion of incarnation.

Frankly, it is the Hindu sacred poets, Sufi mystics like Rabi'a and Rumi, the Christian saints like John XXIII, Hildegard of Bingen, Franc is of Assisi, Julian of Norwich and Therese of Lisieux, or Jewish masters, like the Baal Shem Tov, Abraham Heschel, and Martin Buber who seem to have met a lover God.  The mystics of all religions know this lover God, but they are never allowed to set the tone for the ordinary Christian, Jew, Hindu or Muslim on the street.  We are all lost in law, custom and holy wars, which largely nullified any chance of a love-based ethic for any of the three monotheistic religions.  As Paul said so strongly, reliance upon moralisms makes grace impossible (Galatians 3), and it even leads to the death of the soul (Romans 7).  Moralisms keep us making lists for God instead of making love to God.

In short, if religion does not integrate and validate the sensual, pleasure-loving, erotic part of a man, it takes devious and destructive directions.  If you do not bless it and bow to it, it turns on you and controls you, as we have seen in the recent pedophile scandal.  If you bless it, it shows its limited value and longs for something higher.  The most loving men I have met, the most generous to society and to life, are usually men who have a lusty sense of life, beauty, pleasure and sex--but they have very realistic expectations of them.  The smaller pleasures have become a stairway and an invitation to higher ones, almost by revealing simultaneously their wonderful and yet limited character.  They offer a first taste but then create a taste for something more and something higher.  This is the necessary training of the lower archetype.

The true lover wastes no time in guilt and no time in gluttony either.  As Dome Bedde Griffiths said,  "Sex is far too important to eliminate entirely, and it is far too important to do lightly.  The only alternative is to somehow 'consecrate' it."  I am personally convinced this is true.  The man who took me recently to a four-star restaurant with his elegant wife, while speaking excitedly about the food making love to him, is the same man who talks passionately about refugees, injustice and Third World issues, and he has passed these passionate concerns onto his children.  He is the lover I am talking about. -Richard Rohr, Adam's Return, pp.  128-131.

Thursday, December 06, 2012

Ray Bradbury: "Go to the library! Don't spent all your time on the _______computer and all that crap!"

I'm guessing this is the first time a speaker at Point Loma Nazarene University (an evangelical Christian school)  began their speech with taking God's name in vain (g__d___).  The nervous but appreciative laughter immediately following is classic.

The second time he repeated the phrase was just a  few minutes minute later (13:00ff):

"Go to the library! Live in the library, for Christ's sake!  Don't spent all your time on the g--d-- computer and all that crap!"

Then again at 14:25...
I wonder if anyone was sorry for inviting him.
I hope not..

Note: This is the same writer's conference that Eugene Peterson spoke at
(LOL.. I don't think EP used any coarse language..though I hear he is gracious towards that habit of Bono's).

By the way, that line about libraries and computers he  also delivered at  University of California.
 He's equal opportunity. It probably didn't even cross his mind to clean up his language while at a Christian venue.

And maybe he meant "for Christ's sake"  literally. (:

He sure loved the name of Jesus the day I met and I prayed for him...
--------------


Enjoy:
 
Follow-up conversation below....delightful. See 15:52ff on religion, and 21:56ff on God ("We are here to witness and celebrate. Otherwise, get the hell out!.. We are here as an audience to the miraculous!"):
Related:

see posts tagged "Ray Bradbury" underneath this post.





  • The Day I Prayed for Ray Bradbury

    davewainscott.blogspot.com/2007/.../day-i-prayed-for-ray-bradbury.htm...

    Sep 1, 2007 - The Day I Prayed for Ray Bradbury. Ray Bradbury smiled at me, and "amen-ed" my prayer. As one who grew up reading and relishing ...
  • holy heteroclite:: David Crowder (the"flippin' semiotician")'s ...

    davewainscott.blogspot.com/.../david-crowder-on-semiotics-and-his.html

    Dec 22, 2012 - holy heteroclite: ..... printing press (6) prostitutes (7) psalms (51) radiohead (13) Ray Bradbury (13) ray van der laan (20) reading the Bible (524)  ...
    You've visited this page 4 times. Last visit: 4/22/15
  • holy heteroclite:: Ray Bradbury and "God in your breast"

    davewainscott.blogspot.com/.../ray-bradbury-and-god-in-your-breast_22...

    Dec 22, 2007 - As a follow up to my The Day I Prayed for Ray Bradbury post.. I found this discussion on Bradbury and Christianity...mostly devoted to whether  ...

  • Friday, May 18, 2012

    Thursday, October 21, 2010

    Church with Sts. Andy Rogers and Chester Thompson

    You may remember St. Andy Rogers and ethnoceltic worship team worshipping while plyaing "Be Thou My Vision" in a pub (here).
    Now I see Andy and team did that song in a church with no one less that St. Chester Thompson (road drummer for Genesis and a deep Christ-ian).  Video below...LOL, only in churches do you see those glass drum cages..

    I once bumped into Chester in a church men's room.  What a double take that was.
    What an amazing drummer and person.
    And how cool to see him in a small church setting (audience of One, actually) when he has played to 80, 000 in a stadium.
    Andy says, "Check out the amazing rhythms that Chester plays just at the end of verse 3".  .Enjoy:

    Wednesday, June 10, 2009

    Jesus: "My kingdom IS of this world"


    "People often read John 18:36 as saying that Jesus said 'my kingdom is not of this world,' but as the influential British theologian N.T. Wright pointed out in a recent Christianity Today interview, what Jesus actually said is 'My kingdom is not from this world.'

    'That’s ek tou kosmoutoutou,' said Wright. 'It’s quite clear in the text that Jesus’ kingdom doesn’t start with this world. It isn’t a worldly kingdom, but it is for this world. It’s from somewhere else, but it’s for this world.'
    -Brett McCracken

    Tuesday, May 05, 2009

    church is now in session

    "God needs a body so that..all of humanity will know this is how God acts in the world."
    "Jesus Came to Save Christians: A Manifesto for the Church in Exile," p. 29.



    Last night in Romans class, we noted that Romans 12:1 
    ( "Offer your bodies...this is your service of worship") 
    is the only time the phrase "worship service" shows up in the Bible.

    What is a 'worship service' there?

    Wherever you take your human body!

    Wherever:
    to a church building,
         to the bathroom, 
               to Wal-Mart, to the bar.
    "Church buildings are sacred..." Mark Driscoll quips, 
    adding a pregnant pause,
    "...like everything else."


    "'Ekklesia' comes from the word 'ek' (out of) and klesis (a calling, kaleo means to call)...Note the church is not the enklesia-those called in..called away from the world to huddle together in a survivalist mode....By its very definition, the church does most of its work outside the four walls of the building and scattered throughout the world..

    The church does not have to be physically together to be in session."

    -Tom Fuller, "Let's Grow Up! Seriously Following Jesus in an Extreme and Compromising World," pp. 142-3

    Wednesday, March 25, 2009

    Flyleaf worships in public



    Hervict Jacobs tipped us off:

    "You MUST watch this incredible video. I get goose bumps every time I watch it.
    The lead singer of Flyleaf is at a secular concert - the massive Austin Festival - and at the end of the band's set - she does a worship song and worships God ... in front more than 20 thousand non-Christians. "
    -Hervict Jacobs, link


    It's a medley of David Crowder Band's "You Are My Joy, "and Hillsong United's "From the Inside Out." Notice she even made it explicit and added the word "Jesus" when it wasn't in the original lyric of second song.

    And He set me on fire, and I am burning alive.
    With His breath in my lungs I am coming undone.
    And He set me on fire and I am burning alive.
    With his breath in my lungs I am coming undone.
    And I cannot hold it in
    Remain composed.
    Love's taken over me
    So I propose the letting myself go.
    I am letting myself go.

    You are my joy.
    You are my joy.
    You are my joy.
    You are my joy.

    Everlasting, Your light will shine when all else fades
    Never ending, Your glory goes beyond all fame
    And the cry of my heart is to bring You praise
    From the inside out Lord, my soul cries out

    Everlasting, Your light will shine when all else fades
    Never ending, Your glory goes beyond all fame
    And the cry of my heart is to bring Jesus praise
    From the inside out Lord, my soul cries out.

    ------------------

    More? "All Around Me":
    (if you are not convinced what/Who this song is about/to,
    play the concert video version below it, and hear her unsubtle intro..)


    If ya feel better seeing them at a Christian festival, knock your socks off below.
    She's not afraid to preach to the choir (she even sings with Third Day on Christian radio)
    as you will witness right here:




    --
    Band is also not afraid to tour with groups like Megadeath (as they should. Maybe they can even open for the Gaithers on Crack)

    Song for Christian matryr, Cassie Bernal..Here the crowd at a decidedly secular venue sings/asks themselves: "Do you believe in God?":

    Sunday, March 08, 2009

    "time for the church to be evangelized by the world"

    "The world has come of age physically, culturally,intellectually and scientifically.
    Christianity must come of age as well,
    finding its ultimate meaning not within the church
    but outside of it in the texture of human life..

    ..it is time for the church to be evangelized by the world..

    Jesus is so perfectly human that we must call him God."

    -Vincent J.Donovan, "The Church in the Midst of Creation"

    Wednesday, March 04, 2009

    "You don’t get into your car looking for a traffic jam." -Bono on Nee

    I have long been drawn to Watchman Nee's writings on the interior life, and church life.
    Gotta love AND hate that guy's writings, but wrestle with him we must.

    It is well known that Nee's theology was influential on the Shalom movement that U2 connected with in the early 1980s..

    .that is, until they were kicked out of their church for doing what God wanted them to do (be Christians in music and "in the world.")
    See 4:41ff in this clip:

    ...and my prior post:

    "New U2 song: The Sound

    of Watchman Nee's

    Girly Boots From the Future"


    If you hang around these parts of the internet, you likely know that Mike Morrell is an amazing and apostolic resourcer . Below are some helpful thoughts of Mike's ...lifted below from his comments on a post.

    I have often wondered what Watchman himelf would have counseled U2.
    I don't imagine him embracing ZOO TV (:
    ....though I think at his best and most consistent he might have appreciated its "holy fool" theology and subversion of simulacra.

    Same goals as Nee, right?

    Knowing that surrender to God is the only message I have,
    knowing that I am called to secure such surrender in the public sphere;
    in the world--but not out of it yet--
    with a holy worldliness..

    knowing that we are (g)not gnostic,

    here's Mike:

    I kinda like Nee & The Normal Christian Life. I mean, I have the same issues with Nee that Bono does (no really), and really it’s the same issues I have with any Plymouth Brethren-influenced folks; an unhealthy understanding of ‘the world’ and aversion to it that can lead to a kind of matter-hating gnosticism. But! I’d say that’s ’soft’ rather than ‘hard’ in Nee’s writing. (His trilogy ‘The Spiritual Man’ is way more hard-core in this regard - kind of ascetic - but he himself renounces this work later in life) I think you should read ‘The Normal Christian Life’ for yourself, Michael. Or better yet, ‘Christ: The Sum of All Spiritual Things’ (It’s shorter) You might be surprised. All I know is, a man who planted more churches in his lifetime than the Wesley brothers shouldn’t be too quickly discounted.

    In case you thought I was making that stuff about Bono & Nee up, here’s a piece from an interview:


    In November of 1982 you, The Edge, and Larry Mullins announced to your manager that you didn’t want to tour in support of your second LP, that the rock world was at odds with your Christianity. What happened?

    We were just being pulled in two different directions. A lot of it was based on the idea of the ego. We’d been reading a lot of Watchman Nee, a Chinese Christian mystic. His idea was: “Unless the seed shall die and be crushed into the earth, it cannot bear fruit.”

    Rock ‘n’ roll had this idea: “It’s me!” You know, “Look at me, ’cause I’m looking at you, m%$#!!!” Like, “Out of my way, looking out for number one, ‘I Can’t Get No Satisfaction!’” Watchman Nee’s attitude to that would be: “So what? What’s so important about you anyway?” (laughs)

    So it was like we were being torn in two. We felt almost subconscious pressure being applied to us by a lot of people we looked up to within that spiritual community that we were in and out of. In the end, I realized it was bull$#!t, that what these people were getting close to with this idea was denial, rather than willful surrender. It was denial, which is the next-door neighbor to self-flagellation, and that awful idea that “through pain is gain.” Yes, there is pain. Yes, you may gain from it. But you don’t get into your car looking for a traffic jam. (laughs)”

    - from Mother Jones


    Wednesday, January 28, 2009

    ‘Look what the world has come to'

    “The early Christians did not say
    in dismay:
    ‘Look what the world has come to,’
    but in delight,
    ‘Look what has come to the world.”
    -E Stanley Jones

    Sunday, December 21, 2008

    church should look "as much like the world as it can manage"

    "The church is not an enclave of refugees from the world; it is the sacrament of God's presence in the world by the Mystery of the incarnation. It's not supposed to look as little like the world as possible but as much like the world as it can manage. Otherwise, the world will never be able to recognize, in such a parochial culling of supposedly sinless humanity, anything even vaguely resembling its true face. It will just go on seeing in us the same old unforgiving face that already greets it in the mirror every morning. For the fellowship of the baptized is simply the world in all its sinfulness, dampened by the waters of forgiveness."
    -Robert Farrar Capon, The Astonished Heart
    Read more

    Wednesday, December 17, 2008

    "i find i relate more to the sinners than i do to the saints"

    "When i read the Bible, i find i relate more to the sinners than i do to the saints,"
    he said.

    Is that OK?
    Is that as it should be
    (as long as it is understood as it should be?)?

    Watch this clip of The Violet Burning's classic "Song of the Harlot."

    If it doesn't move you at
    all, that's OK.
    But you may be on the wrong blog (try a site that can't offend you, like this one).

    I have been overwhelmed by this song/praying with it since its first appearance in 1992.
    Thanks to Diane for the original tip: I might not even be alive without this band;
    (even though they almost killed me once ..see this).
    On a snowy day in Chicago, as the first Gulf War was breaking out, Diane handed me a cassette, suggesting I might like this new band.

    To say she was right is a huge understatement. Every day since then has been somehow tethered to that day.

    Oh, by the way, this song (inevitably) includes the "w" word:
    the whore at Your feet."

    Again, that is as it should be,
    if you interpret it as it was meant to be.

    More on whores, holy and otherwise:




    Yes, we had this band at our church..how could we not.

    The singer cannot not pray through guitar.


    Bless 'em, send 'em money.

    And a bonus:
    a very different song here from the very different next (1996) album

    (see: the most listenable "unlistenable" album ever made),


    but a psalm indeed.

    Though it sounds like the desperate cry of someone not sure they are a sinner or saint.

    Is that OK?

    Saturday, December 06, 2008

    on representing the world

    It's not my vibe or genre at all,
    and I don't know much about Krsytal Meyers.

    In fact all I know I just read in Patrol Magazine below:

    Krystal Meyers - Make Some Noise



    Krystal Meyers is sort of the anti-Katy Perry. While Her Fake Lesbianness was kissing girls and embarassing her parents, Krystal was remaking her "Born-Again Avril" image into something much more marketable and (let's be honest) attractive: a dance-pop diva with a way cool club video that was even a just a little bit sexy, like the old days of Christian music come again. "Make Some Noise" lifted her tolerability index out of the tolerability zone (where Katy Perry arguably still hovers), into "things we actually like" territory.

    Now it seems that other people like her, too. Really important people, like the ones who cast singles as soundtracks to NBC fall promos. That's exactly what's happening with "Make Some Noise," which plays behind stars like Masi Oka and John Krasinski. Check it out:



    So I was not surprised to read in the comments beneath her " way cool club video that was even a just a little bit sexy," what I assume is a sarcastic slam by a well-meaning believer:

    "Way to represent God.. er... I mean the world in this video."
    12/1/o8 post
    by Love4Christ7


    My response to "Love4Christ7":

    I may even share some concerns about the video;
    but actually, we ARE indeed called to "represent the world."
    Our prophetic priestly role inevitably involves re-presenting God to the world,
    and representing the world."

    A few posts above Love4Christ7's:

    no offense but she seams a bit provocative. I mean she's in a club for crying out loud. Not a very "christian" hang out. The excuse can't be she's gonna save the people in the club dancing on a table?
    Lowercasepeoples
    No offense back, but of course a club isn't a Christian hangout; but it's exactly where Jesus often hung out..
    even when well-meaning believers thought he shouldn't.

    Then a few posts below, a nice affirmation she is penetrating the "worldly" market,
    and is not just "preaching to the choir....assuming this comment is not from a conservative Christian (:
    ...though something within me hopes it is!:


    DAMN THIS SONG ROCKS!!

    Wednesday, October 29, 2008

    Seducing Sinners

    Contrary to what beloved Saint Steve may think (he has already stalk-read this post and groaned),
    the farthest thing from my mind and intent is to trip people up sexually..

    I just know that the church's failure to be honest..even mention and address/redress...sexuality is one reason for "oh, the shape we're in."

    I do admit choosing provocative post titles to shameless attract sex-addict googlers over to this site..partly as a parody, but partly because it works.

    I joked with Ryan on this post:

    Lindsay, Britney and Amy go into a bar ...



    about tricking surfers into visiting Christian sites.

    I have no intent of tracking ISPs..

    But I was surprised that my experiment (click title above for details) produced NO results that I noticed..

    but the two recent posts that seem to bringing in surfers and stealthers from all over the world
    are the one that promised:


    and that addressed:


    It's the economic times that brought on the latter;
    and the sexonomic times that brought in the former.

    Or are they both the same phenomenon/obsexxion?

    Even though I rebel against "attractional church,"

    whatever gets 'em in the door.
    (a safe click above, he he..)

    Tuesday, July 22, 2008

    Ellul: "know the world more profundly"

    “Day after day the wind blows away the pages of our calendars, our newspapers, and our political regimes, and we glide along the stream of time without any spiritual framework, without a memory, without a judgment, carried about by ‘all winds of doctrine’ on the current of history. Now we ought to react vigorously against this slackness — this tendency to drift. If we are to live in this world we need to know it far more profoundly; we need to rediscover the meaning of events, and the spiritual framework which our contemporaries have lost.

    This will be a difficult enterprise, for it is new and humble. But "all things are ours," that is, for us as Christians, and we are able to undertake this new work....

    The Bible tells us that the Christian is in the world, and that there he or she must remain. Christians have not been created in order to separate themselves from, or to live aloof from, the world. When this separation is effected, it will be God's own doing, not man's.



    ...If this, then, is the Christian's situation, what part should he play in the life of the world? It is only too easy to reply: to "witness," to "evangelize," or "to lead a Christian life," or again "to act according to the will of God." All this is true, of course, but so long as it is not really understood, so long as each answer is only a traditional formula, it leads us nowhere.

    ...What the church ought to do is to try to place all people in an economic, intellectual - yes, and also in a psychological and physical - situation, which is such that they can actually hear this gospel - that they can be sufficiently responsible to say yes or no, that they can be sufficiently alive for these words to have some meaning for them. The secret of their choice belongs to God, but they should be able to make a decision; it is up to the church to see to it that they are not placed in such conditions that they cannot react otherwise than as swine, to whom pearls have been thrown. "Cast not your pearls before swine" - but men must cease to be swine, and this is not the work of grace, it is a human work, which man is quite able to achieve, though it is terribly difficult to do; Christians in particular are called to this work, because it is possible for them to see the true situation of man better than other people, and because they can see, better than others, where all this ought to lead, and what is its aim.

    When we seek to discover effective action for the church, owing to the necessity for its intervention in the world, it seems as though its first objective should be the creation of a style of life."


    - Jacques Ellul, "The Presence of the Kingdom"

    Thursday, May 01, 2008

    Bono audio: God at the 9" Nails Gig

    Why do some people think I am a heretical Christian/pastor for writing stuff like

    "There's No Such Thing as Christian Music"
    or

    "Sigur Ros @ Church: is there a problem with that?"


    Why do we sometimes do "secular songs" (as if there were such a thing) in our gatherings?

    Maybe because God himself is skipping the gospel concert for Nine Inch Nails gig..



    Click here for the audio (or watch here on Youtube) of this delightful statement by Bono:

    "God is interested in truth, and only in truth. And that's why God is more interested in Rock & Roll music than Gospel... Many gospel musicians can't write about what's going on in their life, beacuse it's not allowed ..If you can't write about what's really going on in the world and your life, because it's all happy-clappy... Is God interested in that? I mean, 'Please, don't patronize Me! I want to go the Nine-Inch-Nails gig, they're talking the truth!
    -Bono

    From a 2003 discussion with New York Times, more audio here

    Wednesday, December 19, 2007

    I am in sin if I always "avoid the appearance of evil"




    Much of what we have learned in church, Sunday School and (gasp) sometimes even seminary is wrong.


    The list of Scriptures (atomized "memory verses" out of context, and interpreted through the grid of rationalistic modernity) we have always (mis)understood is almost endless; and the terrible irony is that often the plain and obvious (in context) meaning is opposite what we have always been told.


    For example, people actually believe the Bible says "God will never give you more than you can handle." (see God Always Gives Us More Than We Can Handle  and God Will Always Give You More Than You Can Handle).

    For another example, you have heard that Jesus would rather have us be hot (on fire for God) or even cold (no heart for God) than being lukewarm.  (see: WWJP Why Would Jesus Puke?: let's be hot AND cold, as Jesus wants)


    etc

    etc

    etc
    (see a few examples here)




    This is definitely one of my pastoral pet peeves.


    Tia Linn, a "Jersey Girl Among the Georgia Peaches," has done the most amazing job I have seen yet on exposing one of the biggest myths:


    You know, the "The Bible says 'Avoid the appearance of evil', so don't ever  put yourself in a situation/place where you could be accused of being in sin...." myth.


    If you are not aware of the obvious problem (King James translation, and read out of context...what else is new?) with this memory verse that is nowhere in the Bible, read her blog post.


    She makes the point that




    It is possibly the most misunderstood, misused verse in the entire bible.
    We've all had it said to us and we have probably said it to others. It's usually
    applied when we feel someone isn't actually sinning, but we believe that some
    unidentified lurking spy could misconstrue our behaviour as sin because it
    "looks bad."

    However, this verse, as it appears in the KJV, is a poor translation, and has NOTHING to do with freedoms and liberties that could be misinterpreted as evil.

    Here's the 1 Thess. 5:22 in Greek put into transliteration:

    apo pantos eidous ponèrou apechesthe

    The word eidos, based on meaning and context, is actually best translated as "forms" or "kind."

    In every other widely used translation besides the OLD KING JAMES version, 1 Thess 5:22 reads something like this: "Abstain from all forms of evil." This has nothing to do with appearances. It's referring to actual evil, in whatever form it manifests: stealing, lying, fornication, adultery, greed, etc. Whatever form it comes in, avoid it!

    Here's how the verse reads in the most used translations:

    1 Thessalonians 5:22
    New International Version: Avoid every kind of evil.New American Standard: Avoid every form of evil.New Living Translation: Avoid every kind of evil.English Standard Version: Abstain from every form of evil.Contemporary English: Don't have anything to do with evil.New King James: Abstain from every form of evil. (NKJ remedied the older version's poor translation)
    American Standard: Abstain from every form of evil.Darby Translation: Hold aloof from every form of wickedness.Holman Christian Standard Bible: Stay away from every form of evil.New International Reader's Version: Stay away from every kind of evil.Worldwide English: Have nothing to do with any wrong thing.

    The Old King James isn't technically wrong, but being that most of us do not utilize old English, we misread it. It's use of the word appearance more accurately means..."avoid evil whenever it makes an appearance." The context of the word is as occurrence, not outward appearance.

    ..Most of the time, people unknowingly misuse this verse with the
    VERY BEST INTENTIONS, because they desire to appear their very best, so they can lead people to Christ..

    The misused version of this verse only heightens our already unhealthy
    fixation on appearances and superficial piety instead of true substance. The
    terms of what appears evil are usually defined by those who are offended with a
    particular activity that can't be classified as real sin, thus it appears evil.
    The whole thing breeds suspicion, judgmentalism, and even idolatry. When we
    start assigning more power to inanimate objects or activities than they actually
    possess, it can turn to a form of idolatry...

    We all know it is completely impossible to abstain from the appearance of
    evil. We can't even abstain completely from that which is actually evil, let
    alone innocent liberties that could possibly appear evil if someone was walking
    by and squinting....The real issue is that JESUS appeared evil ALL the time, especially to religious people. He ate and drank (wine, not grape juice,
    baptists), he turned water into wine to keep the festivities going for people
    who had been drinking all day, hence the accusations of being a wine-bibber and
    glutton. He hung around with tax collectors and prostitutes and went into places
    deemed "unclean." He didn't perform the ceremonious hand cleansing rituals. He
    didn't follow the man-made religious traditions of the sabbath. He was with the
    woman at the well all alone, a Samaritan no less. People accused Jesus of being
    demon possessed because of how he appeared.


    link (emphasis mine)




    My response below; upping the ante,

                             but making only a basic/101 conclusion.


    This is NOT a non sequitur, not a fallacious stretch;

    not a reductionistic heresy.


    And I was thrilled to see (by a simple googling here) that many of the top posts actually get it right...


    Do the math!

    It is simply inevitable that:


    1."Jesus appeared evil .."

    2. We are to follow Jesus.

    3. If we do not appear evil much  of the time, we are in sin and not faithfully following Jesus.


    !!
    Now don't hear what I'm not saying: Go thou therefore and purposely look like you are attending an adult movie just to be seen and  just to tweak the fundies. Go and pull a Ted Haggard with God's blessing
    But if I have not been seen near an adult theatre, a gay film festival, or a prostitute lately,
    I should shred my pastoral orders, and re-read the Book.
    Where else would Jesus be?

    PS:
    If you are not familiar with C.S. Lewis' "Screwtape Letters," which Bono (literally) took a page from here:
    What if that image of purity is the image of a Christian in the original state
    of grace? As it is to many people. One night I was doing my..devil dance on
    stage with a young girl, in Wales, and she said "are you still a believer? If
    so, what are you doing dressed up as the devil?" I said "have you read the
    Screwtape Letters?" Which is a C.S. Lewis book that a lot of intense Christians
    are plugged into. They are letters from the devil. That's where I got the whole
    philosophy of mock-the-devil-and-he-will-flee-from-you. So she said "yes" and I
    said "so you know what I'm doing." Then she relaxed and said "I want to bless
    you....
    and of course inherited much misunderstanding from religious "squeakies"...
    ..you should be.

    But don't let anyone actually see you reading about Bono. You must "avoid every appearance of evil," brethren. Watch this exposé
     of these "false prophets" and get enlightened!! (:





    Thursday, June 07, 2007

    Church Music at Liquor King

    "Come on down and meet your Maker...",

    I heard faintly as our family finished our lunch at the mall.

    The phrase sounded familiar; but the music still faint.

    "Don't say I didn't warn you; this prophecy
    is coming true.." was the next snippet I heard.

    Ah, yes..."The Stand" by The Alarm, an 80's classic by that God-haunted band (who are stll around, by the way).

    Here's the dated (at least big-hair wise)video below. These guys absolutely rocked when I saw them open for U2 in 1983. I knew nothing about them, but within seconds of their first song's opening, my brother and I turned to each other; knowing this would be an amazing concert; and said "These guys are Christian, aren't


    they?"

    Whether they literally are or not is precisely not the main point.
    Which is that God has been using music...especially by God-haunted bands...to speak to people where they are.

    It's a centered set culture we are living in.

    I got chills in the mall, as I watched the punk rockers at the next table (ironically, they looked like The Alarm in the 80s) as the music (and evangelistic invitation) washed over them.

    Whether they heard and heeded it or not is up for grabs.

    But I actually think they are more accountable on Judgement Day beacuse God spoke to them at a fish palace at the mall one day through a song which may or may not be "officially" Christian.

    It was an altar call.

    That the altar was a table at Burbank Mall full of beer bottles didn't bother The Maker one bit.

    When I teach my Ministry Skills class on "Penetrating and Plundering Culture," I often start with these opening case-studies to make this same point:

    1)My daughter and I were singing along to that well-known worship song lyric, "Jesus, You are my King..." We were transported into God's presence...there at church..

    Actually, at McDonalds. The Newsboys were leading worship over


    the sound system!

    2)"My Creator...You gave me life, now show me how to live!" was the passionate prayer by the worship leader. That cut-to-the-chase honest plea seemed to make the presence of God almost palpable. Our family
    received it, and "amen-ed" it; there at church..

    Actually, we were at Extreme Pizza. The Audioslave song "Show Me How to Live" was playing.

    3)"I dare you to move..dare you to pick yourself up off the floor....salvation is here!," the evangelist begged with all his might. I stopped in my tracks; and almost fell to my knees.

    All around me where desperate, even drunk people; whose lives were "on the floor," and needed to be dared into salvation..

    By the lead singer of Switchfoot as he issued the challenged through the ceiling speaker of the church building...

    Actually the
    ceiling of Liquor King. Where I had entered (to some embarassment, hoping no parishoners saw me) to pay a uitlity bill at the back counter...of a liquor store.

    --
    I am aware some would "complain" that only #1 above is a "Christian band."

    #3 is all Christian guys, but on a secular label. "We are Christian by faith, not by genre," the singer often explains.

    Which is the ONLY reason their song was allowed in a liquor store.

    Which is exactly the kind of place where Jesus is making himself quite at home nowadays. He is the King of Liquor King, after all.

    Great days we live in.

    Mall, McDonalds, Liquor King, Extreme Pizza.

    "Church buildings ARE sacred...

    .Mark Driscoll says; finishing the quote with a flourish:

    "...like everything else in creation.

    Wednesday, April 19, 2006

    "Is there such a thing as Christian music?"


    Note: this article was penned a few years ago in response to a question on our forum, then became part of a U2 article, and now appears here to link into today's post on "Praying through the guitar". Enjoy!

    ====================
    "Is there such a thing as Christian music?"

    Such is a  question that begs to be wrestled with:

    "Saul has slain his thousands, David his ten thousands" Is that "Christian"?   Is it a Christian thought?  Whatever it is, it’s I Samuel 18:6-7, it was even put to music, the Bible says,  as a "joyful song".

    Book of Esther? Is that "Christian"? Doesn’t mention God!  Song of Solomon?  Uh, it's about...nevermind (blush).

    And besides, this discussion will naturally lead to a bit of challenge to the church to at least consider, and refuse to prematurely dismantle, another on-target Leonard Sweet bomb: "It may be that for the first time in history, God is more active in the world than the church." 



    Sweet’s sweetly provocative quote above explains, in part, why one of the most powerful, biblical and Christian prayers ever prayed was prayed over the world’s airwaves, and not the church’s. Without being overly dogmatic, or framejacking its context, I must maintain that  U2's "Elevation".. IS first and foremost about prayer; no, IS first and foremost prayer. I think I have proffered a convincing case for such a sweeping claim at this link   We must agree that in all things art and U2, there is a necessary freedom and fluidity in lyric interpretation. Always. We must honor and unleash that, wherever it takes us. But even though many interpreters will shut me down, I say "Elevation" has to be-- at heart-- heartfelt and honest (which is why it may not fly in many churches!) prayer. I do allow all kind of breathing room for other and complementary interpretations, other steams of meaning that are vital and valid. And this is an excellent time to insert a wake up and shake up call: some songs are "Christian" if not even "about God" at all; or even if (God forbid!) not written by a "Christian" at all.  Last time I checked, all truth is God’s truth.. T-Bone Burnett, one of the band’s spiritual and musical "pastors," was once thanked in U2 liner notes for "the truth in the dark." Which is exactly where Truth often hides and is brightest…but we miss its brilliance and blessing because we are afraid to "go there." And God has been desperately trying to get us to stand under the light and blessing of His "light bulb hanging over my bed." (That last quote, of course is Bono’s, from the same song/prayer["Ultraviolet/Light My Way"] where the Lord faces the accusation ..some say from Satan…that "You bury Your treasure where it can’t be found"..accurate, unless we are bold and believing enough to "go there", that is.)

    "You can write two types of songs as a believer," Burnett says. "You can write about the Light, or about what you see by the Light." His point is that since he tends to circulate more naturally in the latter type, some have pre-judged him as not even being ‘lit" (That means he flunked the church’s "lit"mus test, huh?) The church, of all people, has not easily blessed and baptized the truth of that classic quote. Just as some Christian radio stations appear to actually have a minimum "J-word" count to let a given song in the door, and on the airwaves, we evangelical types have been trained to fine-tooth  everything; ditching Baby with bathwater. We need to be retooled and retrained to enter into the subtle layers and levels of lyrics we feel "may not be Christian" just because they lack enough "J-word" namedroppings (or drop the unpardonable and atomic "F" bomb.!) . I have a yearning to to free Christians , not to violate their own conscience, but to trust it to lifeguard them even out in the "deep (read "forbidden" ) waters, where the swimming and drinking of this deep Kingdom water is exhiliratingly edifying and splashworthy. If you’ve never ventured far enough offshore to swim with the likes of Chagall Guevara, Bruce Cockburn, and of course Burnett: come on in, the water’s fine!). In the words of one frustrated blogger, "Sometime the best Christian music can’t be bought at Christian stores.")

    Perhaps it’s only "attempting to justify ourselves" and our "under the radar" listening to, and loving, a "secular" band for Christ’s sake; and for art’s sake, that we feel religious relief to hear that a certain song "really is about Jesus after all." Yet is it comforting, or afflicting, to hear Bono admit that "Our songs are either about God or women, and sometimes we confuse the two."? This rugged and ruddy honesty about confusing the two…because it labels what all of us experience but are afraid to admit...in "church," anyway… is precisely why "Elevation" as a prayer tool is such vital component of our tool belt. It would be a gnostic betrayal of Jesus, and St. Bono’s own "hermeneutical key" to NOT "turn each song into a prayer." "Each" is a wonderfully all-encompassing, and dangerously all-inclusive word…shamelessly sweeping in songs about..well, "sex and love and faith and fear" (not to mention "sex n drugs n rockandroll"); much in line with the reckless Matthew 13 fishnet of Jesus that chef-pastor Robert Farrar Capon recklessly and delightfully describes thus:


    The word used here is used only once in the New
    Testament..it is a particular kind of net, namely, one that is dragged through
    the water, indiscriminately taking in everything in its path. Accordingly, the
    Kingdom (and by extension, the church as the sacrament of the Kingdom) manifests
    the same indiscriminateness)..As the net gathers up everything in its path—not
    only fish but seawaeed, flotsam, jetsam and general marine debris—so too the
    Kingdom..So the church as fisherman should not get in the habit of rejecting as
    junk the flotsam and jetsam of the world—the human counterparts of the old
    boots, bottles and beer cans that a truly catholic dragnet will inevitably
    dredge up. (Parables of the Kingdom)

    Not to "trash" Bono’s..or any deep-water believer’s… sometimes "secular" ("fishy") lyrics, just the holy and wholly opposite: it’s all about being brave, brazen and Christlike enough to inkingdom, bless and baptize all of them, and let the King to sort them out, but not us, and not now: not until "the very end of the age" "(Matthew 13:39). Because in this age, the church and its net needs to be stretched enough to hear prophetic and pointed words from real-world "dredges"; saints and sinners (from Radiohead to REM to Over the Rhine and beyond) that the church would rather not let into the net, even if they are only visiting.
    Interestingly, Bono comments on what killed Elvis, and it relates:


    I
    I really think he was trying mostly to escape the pain
    of the guilt, the pain of believing that he was tapping into voodoo and the
    spirit of the devil.All of that must have affected him because of his
    Pentecostal upbringing. And he must've known, instinctively, that when he sang he
    was touched by the spirit ofGod. And he apparently did read countless books
    trying to figure out suchquestions., but I don't think he ever got a
    satisfactory answer. It's the thingthat Bob Marley lived, and not just in terms
    of the sex and the spirit but interms of the politics. He had that three-chorded
    strand. That's the wholeness I'm looking for. It says in the Bible "the
    three-chord strand cannot be broken."That's a reference to the Trinity,
    obviously, and the Trinity is God the Father,God the Son -- which is the flesh,
    Jesus wanting to understand what it's like to have a body -- and the Holy Spirit.
    That's what we must aspire towards. But Elvisd idn't reach that state of being,
    he was crushed under the weight of not figuring out how to draw together those
    three strands. And crushed under not being able to accept that God loves him,
    loves his creations as they are, and where they are.That's the tragedy. Though
    the problem also is learning how to live with the tensions between those forces
    and the thought that you may never pull them together. Maybe even feeding off
    that, which I think is what I do in terms of allt he music I create, and my life.
    Elvis was left with those two great energies,sexual and spiritual, and even
    though he never resolved how to draw themt ogether, with the the third strand,
    his music did help so many of us to pull together at least two of those strands.
    That was his greatest contribution to rock 'n' roll and to our cultural life in
    general. That's his greatest legacy.
    http://www.u2station.com/documents/variousarticles/irishtimes_article.txt

    The question "What makes music (or lyrics) Christian" needs to be pursued, wrestled with prayerfully and carefully and maybe even eventually (only post-wrestling)..left abandoned and unanswered, or at least left uncomfortably open. On the other (third!) hand, maybe it can be…after the hard theological work and crucible, be dogmatically closed. Whatever the ultimate answer, and meaning of , "case dogmatically closed", it cannot .include either sibling of the following twin and tempting heresies: 1. "As long as it's not_____(fill in supposedly "satanic" genre: rock, rap, Gaithers, Elvis, opera, U2, whatever) , or 2. "As long as it satisfies the minimum count/quota of the 'J-word'. And just maybe Jon Foreman of the band Switchfoot, (whom I recently saw at the local fair ; they book fairs and arenas more often than Christian festivals) settled it once for all, if only our ears would hear: "I am Christian by faith, not by genre." At any rate, a quick and cursory "goggle" for this exactly phrased question {'What makes music Christian?'} yielded no less than 92 links, representing nearly as many articles and essays asking and probing the depths and rabbit-trails of this at first all-too-obvious "answer in the question" question.

    Often the very asking of this focused, perhaps ridiculously rhetorical, question grows out of the evangelical disequilibrium we are reeled into upon hearing passionate and bold Christian musicians..from Foreman to P.O.D. to Jars of Clay... say things like "We are not a Christian band. We are a band of Christians." Or "our love songs are just as Christian as our worship songs...because all of life is sacred and Christian". Take the following defining example as a microcosmic window into this forced sacred/secular dichotomy...and be prepared then to unashamedly but gently throw a brick through that dichotomy and window...in Jesus’ name of course:

    The Christian in-house debate over ( and at times near ex-communication of ) " Sixpence None The Richer" and their Steve Taylor-produced (pastored?) breakthrough single on the "secular" charts, "Kiss Me," was both humongous and hilarious; both necessary and fruitful on one level, and ridiculously unneeded on another; both intrinsically-motivated in some, and extrinsically and Pharisaically-so in others; both appropriately Christian at points and sub-Christian and unadulterated Gnostic at others ("all matter is inherently evil", "clear distinction between secular and sacred", etc).. at others. Said song may have not mentioned the " J" word . or even a generic "G" word (maybe that can be snuck and danced round by substituting "Yahweh," or maybe, "I AM", ..someone oughta try that!), but who is to say whether it is ultimately..or simultaneously..about a human romantic kiss , and/or a kiss between our Divine Lover and us…and as you know by now, Bono has recently invoked a Song-of-Solomonic kiss on his Guiness-tainted mouth by none other than Yahweh! ), but it sovereignly led (in a way a "straight-up" worship song couldn't have) to an amazingly Spirit set-up moment between Sixpence singer Leigh Nash and David Letterman on Letterman's show, where God convicted Letterman, and not only literally turned him red in from of millions of viewers, but momentarily turned him into an articulate evangelist, who theologized aloud about God and salvation through the lens of C.S. Lewis before his studio and worldwide "congregation". Is that "Christian"? (Rejoice and read more of "the rest of that story" and a proposed answer by clicking here.

    One should also celebrate the good company of the very same Steve Taylor (Sixpence producer and frontman of the most missed band around that almost opened for U2: Chagall Guevara), whose credentials speak for themselves when they include being kicked out of the Christians stores and club for (all but literally) putting on MacPhisto-like horns and driving an "ice cream truck" loaded with bombs with intent to "blow up the clinic real good". Accused of advocating the bombing of abortion clinics by playing a character who advocated it, even though the tongue in Taylor’s cheek was as ridiculously oversized and obvious as the horns on Bono’s head, he was dutifully bounced out, by the left foot of fellowship, of the very club he was trying to speak to. Of course, this resume resembles that of another band. Anyone hear of certain well-meaning fellowship in Ireland that very early on questioned that their most famous members (3 of U2) could actually be a Christian band, or a (worse!) a band of Christians...

    To coin oneself a " Christian" band may sound like a good and God-honoring thing to do (and it may well be), but nowadays can get one relegated/ banished/ shelved (literally) in only "Christian" stores (where few pre-Christians haunt) or the "religious" sections (ghettos) of secular stores, which "forgets to remember" that the point of Christianity is to give it away. The last time I remember seeing a U2 record in a Christian store was so long ago that it WAS literally a record (the "Wide in America" EP), and the price tag was strategically placed over the cigarette hanging out of Adam’s mouth! What a picture of the church’s sincere but sincerely wrong strategy. And of course, you may have guessed by now that the record was buried...in the cut-out rack..the comparable "ghetto" of the Christian stores! About the same time era, I remember having to bribe a Christian store employee (thankfully, it was my wife!) ..to sneak me a contraband copy of a 77s record that was conveniently stocked for all customers to see (not!)…in the storage room!! And the church is not yet over that disease, I see, having noted recently at that same store... under "L" section, Lifehouse was indeed available…behind the counter!….I assume alongside the cigarettes and condoms.

    Bono, in his liner notes to Johnny Cash's glorious "God" CD (which, despite its title, is presumably sold only in stores that DO also sell cigarettes and condoms) , admitted he always felt like Johnny, though saved, was "not only singing TO the damned, he was singing WITH the damned...and sometimes he preferred their company." The fact that Cash's "God" record was one of a trilogy/trinity of discs named "God", "Love" and "Murder", revelates that the late Cash was right on time and in unfortunate touch with the pseudo-reality of much "Christian" music. Maybe the following lyric was included and spotlighted just to tweak the Pharisees: "I shot a man...just to watch him die." Cash belts out this line on the "Murder" (of course!) disc, not because he ever did such a thing or sanctions it, but because he was honest enough...meaning Christian enough, E. Stanley Jones would add....to say (and thus pray) publicly that he had flirted with such a thing in his heart. So it is confession…but the confessional is in the marketplace, not the meeting place. U2 of course picked up a play from this book in the 90s with their shortlved but longsighted "video confessional," in which audience members waiting in line were invited to film their confessions, which would be presented onscreen during the concert for the whole congregation..uh, crowd..to see and forgive (Something about the priesthood of all believers?). And how about Jimmy Carter’s infamous confessing to committing adultery in his heart, in a Playboy magazine interview presented between pages designed exclusively for men to commit adultery in their heart? God bless Rosalynn Carter and June Carter (no relation but except through the Christ-tribe and a common Kingdom honesty) Cash for letting their husbands bleed honesty in the marketplace..the world is waiting to see such fearless honesty. And of course Mrs. Bono likely smiled and smirked knowingly, when her husband responded to an interviewer’s question as to why they announced their "Pop" tour at a Manhattan K-Mart, and why on Ash Wednesday, with "Ash Wednesday and K Mart..that about sums us up!" As does Romans 7, which paints a perfectly imperfect view of (even the redeemed) human heart. But we prefer, for whatever reason (maybe we sickly prefer to "kill our inspiration and sing about the grief") , to jump to Romans 8 and prematurely find what we’re looking for: victory. .But this is nor right; not realistic nor real; it is rape..it is Easter shorn of Good Friday. Where’s the glory in that? In fact it is denying that some Sundays are bloody Sundays indeed. Wouldn’t we rather honor God and reality with gut-level, gut-wrenching, resplendent, refreshing, rare Kingdom honesty?

    Another honest theologian (may the tribe increase), E. Stanley Jones, has often keynoted the theme that reality itself is Christian. The Kingdom of God is ultimate reality; wherever the Kingdom is, there is reality; therefore..hold your breath and your heresy gun...wherever reality is, there is the Kingdom (in however a veiled, pre-Christian singer or player; or no matter even how flotsamic or demonic the wrapping or wineskin.) "The people of the Kingdom have the whole universe backing them up," he would say. So, anything that is in essence real; honest, is by definition or by default Christian/Kingdom, at least in its purest genesis. "Evil is only," Lewis suggests "fallen good." Music, no matter how twisted, tampered with or tweaked: , no matter how later demonized by anti-Christ lyrics, is, at heart, at first, and at nutshell, a gift of God.

    Bono: "Songs are the language of the Spirit...the melodies are how you sing to God. It's a deep language. But they can't explain everything, because really great songs touch places that you can't explain." In another interview, he tips his hand:. "All our songs are about God or women..and sometimes we confuse the two," he confesses with a casual, almost "throwaway" honesty which shocks, but which would benefit, traditional Christians. Part of the honesty of his confession stems from his fear of fans idolizing him, not just as a rock star, but as a professing Christian (or "Christian singer"..if there is such a thing): "I am a believer and I have faith in Christ," he is quick to put on record. "But I am not a very good advertisement for God." The band in fact, "went into the baptismal waters..and almost drowned" when, against their church's advice, they felt called to stay in the "secular" music industry and detour and Dovetail around the ghetto of "Christian music" .

    "I'm just drawing my fish in the sand", Bono offers. And "every great song", he reflects, in perhaps an ultimately even more accurate quote than his God/woman confession, "is either about running to God, or from God". I ask: Is a song about "running from God" Christian? I dunno, but try some of the Psalms on for size. The shoes may fit. How about songs honest and real enough to be "agnostic prayers"?. Psalms again.
    Such anthems cannot be anathema. . Aa heartfelt, heartbroken Bono lyric, responding in part to the death of his mother:" Jesus! Jesus, help me, I'm alone in this world, and a f____up world it is, too." Blasphemy or Christian? You decide, but to hear Bono pray/ sing it, one does not walk away saying "Bono swore," but "Bono just articulated, -psalmlike, something I had felt..and may never feel comfortable saying aloud..but in an odd way..maybe a God way..I find myself healed and worshipping afresh as I listen."
    (For follow-up, you will be stretched by the column that the editor of Worship Leader magazine wrote, carefully entitled "Why I Would Follow Bono into Hell", kept here: http://www.3dff.com/discus/messages/49/215.html?1070127997 ).

    Very often a song by a person who is likely not a Christian by our (or their own) definition (Peter Gabriel, for example; a friend of U2), may animate and articulate (untainted by Christianese) a heretofore-latent worship emotion or expression. Thus: "This old familiar craving/ Don't know who the hell I'm saving anymore/ Let it go, let it pass, let it leave/ from the deepest place I grieve/ This time I believe..And I let go.." is a song (Gabriel's "Love to be Loved") with more passion and raw honesty than many an official or self-proclaimed "Christian" song or church "prayer"...yes, despite, maybe even PRECISELY BECAUSE OF the unedited "h" word...even at the expense of not naming the "J" word, which one might make the case is in between every line. And how about his belting out for life and death, in the song "Supper's Ready" (named after the marriage supper of the Lamb in Revelation! ): "There's an angel standing in the sun/Crying with a loud voice?/ This is the supper of the Mighty One...The Lord of Lord , King of Kings.. returns to take His children home/To take them to the New Jerusalem!" There is something in Gabriel that believes this with all his heart and more. Is he Christian? I do not think he would claim it. However, his lyric and voice do! Are his music and lyric "Christian?" Take a listen. No wonder his songs (like "In Your Eyes": "In Your eyes, the light, the heat/ I am complete in Your eyes/ I see the doorway of a thousand churches, the resolution of a thousand fruitless searches" ) have been recorded by "Christian artists" without a need to baptize the lyrics. Is "In Your Eyes" "Christian", even if Gabriel sometimes wonders if the words are written to God or a woman? Here I can only speak for myself: I fall on my face and worship Jesus to these lyrics. Do they come from a flawed even non-Christian messenger? Of course. But the music and lyric is Christian to the core and reached and teaches the core of my soul And as a result, God’s "love is teaching me to kneel" to a degree I wouldn’t have gotten to without a "secular saint" being a doorkeeper into the House of God.

    Is there such thing as "Christian music"? I dare to believe the answer may well be yes, but not in the way the typical evangelical might frame question, or mean the answer. I don't believe I am "frame-jacking" to believe there is Christian music everywhere...even from the mouths of babes, the mouths of backsliders, and more often than we have admitted, the mouths of pagans. Leonard Sweet again,( this time from p 163ff of "Eleven Genetic Gateways to Spiritual Awakening") makes the case that life is "at its very base" music: "Scientists are finding that they are no different than theologians...They are finding that...Music does more than help us experience God as spirit as we experience life as spirit . Music is more accurately the essence of who we are created in the image of God. If the most elemental and elementary aspect of life is "energy that vibrates" (as scientists say they have discovered in quantum "string theory"), then life is at base music...For anything that vibrates gives off sound…so...you and I… are at base a song.. There is no one who isn't musical….My personal definition of Jesus is 'God's perfect Pitch.’ It is in our genes to see (God's Words) as musical notes....As Pythagoras said, ' A stone is frozen music.'" Rocks cry out?

    Whew! Maybe the starting point is now not "Is there Christian music?", but "Isn’t music Christian? Alternatively "Is life Christian?"

    Besides, a wise non-Christian(?), Adam Clayton, outted and uttered this astounding observation about "With or Without You: "You don’t expect to hear that song on the radio. Maybe in a church." " Maybe marriage of radio and church, if done well (as Larry Mullen has said, "not at an angle"), could and should work. If it is moving in the right direction, and is not a hijacking. As Bono once told me (OK, me along with the other 30, 000 fans in attendance at an "Elevation" tour concert), "I’m going to take you to church!" He took us; no hijacking; it was holy. So about this marriage:
    What God has joined together; let no reviewer; no radio; no church, set asunder.