holy heteroclite:

Welcome! You have accidentally reached the blog of a heteroclite follower of Jesus: dave wainscott. I'm "pushing toward the unobvious" as I post thinkings/linkings re: Scripture, church and culture. Hot topics include: temple tantrums, time travel, sexuality/spirituality, U2kklesia, role of the pastor, God-haunted music/art..and subversive videos like these.

Pages

  • home/posts
  • about the name
  • about moi/social media
  • signs
  • dubbed Jesus videos
  • lotsa lynx
  • ekklesia-ish

Search Me:

Showing posts with label book reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label book reviews. Show all posts

Thursday, July 23, 2026

U2's Theological Imagination: A Guide For Pilgrims on the Way"


In this case, the title alone-- "U2's Theological Imagination: A Guide For Pilgrims  on the Way"-- would have sold me on buying the book.



But that the author is Steven Harmon?  That clinched the deal.  Harmon, Professor of Historical Theology at Gardner-Webb School  of Divinity is (see p. 9 for "U2 as Theologians)an articulate theologian and deep fan  of U2.

He definitely has some ground beneath his feet, and the authority to write this book.

As you can see, it  sits on the honored top of my stack and stash of books this month...




"My own academic discipline of systematic or constructive  theology helps me discern in U2's music the theological framework of Christian doctrinal convictions about God, creation, the human condition, redemption  and the goals of God's community-making work in a world that longs for reconciliation." (pp. 3-4)

Suffice to say this is not a pop-culture , superficial .. let alone "tacky and vouyeristic" ...mass-market title on U2 and their faith.

Having said that..

I didn't  expect  to see my name on the first page (:

There, in the acknowledgements (p.ix), he expresses indebtedness to "rewarding conversations  about  the theological implications of U2's music ...[with]  Scot Calhoun, Cathleen Falsani, Derek  Hogan, John Inscore Essick, Beth Maynard, Will McDonald, Mark Medley. Tim Neufeld, Angela Pancella, Kenneth Tanner, Dave Wainscott and Andrew William Smith."

Well, as you can see by the mentions of several of those names on my blog, and on my Facebook, that is would be  dynamic cohort to hang  with for a few days! Next U2 Conference, hopefully! ...

.. As long as Megan Click is also there! Her wonderful review of U2's "Easter Lilly' blew me away, and I will brag on her and that in my next post.

Harmon's  book is of course an indispensable addition to the library of theologically-minded U2 fans, and I will commend the Amazon preview and reviews to you at this link, and simply  highlight here  two vital talking points...both related to The Edge...  from the first two  chapters  alone.



1) Edge's eschatological guitar

My brother and I, who first saw U2 in concert on the convert on War tour, (see my review "I am still living off this concert" , and see this  to check how electric it was ), and we  have often talked about  "The Holy Spirit on guitar!"  when listening  to The Edge's "swirling epiphanies," There are others who seemingly pray through their guitar, but no one emotes it like Edge,

 Harmon's discussion of a  more specific branch of theology, eschatology,  illuminates how Edge is a theologically-informed guitarrist/pray-er:


".. ['Gloria'] exemplifies what I've come to regard as theologically significant about The Edge's very tone: the amp pushed just to the edge of breakup without going fully over into distortion, expressing an urgent stretching forth toward something not quite reached, contrasting with those ethereal chiming harmonics that break in from somewhere transcendent. Both come together in this next song, The first verse voices frustration at efforts to sing, and stand up, and speak up that don't quite succeed, accompanied by a riff that's the rock guitar equivalent of a Baroque keyboard fugue, played with that yearning overdriven tone. Then comes the inbreaking of those transcendent chiming harmonics...(p.5)

-------------------

"The word that comes to mind when I try to come up with language for the sound of a U2 song is  yearning ..the music itself evokes yearning."(p. 6)

----------------------------

"The reign of God is at hand and people have the opportunity to participate in it in the here and now, but it is not yet fully realized ar cannot become so without the participation of people in the rein of God. This tension is the key theological concept for understanding the spiritual significance of the whole of U2's music.

"...n the formative years of the band, U2 even found a way l express this tension through the distinctive instrumental sound they created. U2 remythologized the open-fifth power chord that eschews both major and minor thirds as a way of musically maintaining the eschatological tension between the now and the not yet...

..I. say that U2 "remythologized" the open-fifth power chord because, as one of my guitar-playing theology students noted when I mentioned this to him, the power chord commonplace in guitar-based rock music is by definition a root note, its fifth, and the octave of the root. But The Edge's rationale for utilizing this chord structure is theologically, in particular eschatologically, significant. When the neither-major-nor-minor fifths were combined with The Edge's frequent playing of ethereal-sounding chiming harmonics , his distinctive use of the delay effect not as an atmospheric effect= with trailing echoes but as a compositional technique to create notes that are not directly played but are integral to the music, and clean guitar tone overdriven to the edge of breakup without turning fully into distortion evoking urgency, the result was the yearning sound of the already/not-yet tension of Christian eschatology translated into the idiom of post-punk rock music."  (pp 22-23)


-----------------------------------------------------------

-2)Edge's   Pádraig Ó Tuama and Methodist connections

"I've been reading a lot about the early period of Methodism...and George Whitfield who was..the first evangelist to take his sermons out doors," said the Edge to Pádraig Ó Tuama

Wait..what?

Double take..

How had I ever missed that Edge had been interviewed by  Pádraig Ó Tuama?
And that in the process, he expressed great interest in early Methodist DNA? (see"Wesleyan Vile-tality: Reclaiming the Heart of Methodist Identity")


Two of my favorite topics.

Methodism is my heritage and tribe, and that Edge ( "the "Zen Presbyterian") had been reading about it--- let alone " a lot"--- made my day...a lot.



And of course no surprise that fellow Irishmen  and fellow theologians O'Tuama and Edge (see p. 9 for "U2 as Theologians) got together and got  along.


I have been using a song (below)  of O. Tuama's  in teaching and seminars for years, a shocking (to evangelical sensitivities, anyway) song of lament (complete with F word ) for years.


I often wondered if O'Tuama knew U2.

I learned all this from Harmon's magnificent book (p.10). 

-----------------------------------

All that to say, as a pilgrim on my way, I highly  commend and recommend..

nay, require..this book,

Suffice to say I am thankful for the theological imagination of pilgrim Steven Harmon himself.








  
here



\
Posted by dave at Thursday, July 23, 2026 No comments:
Labels: book reviews, spirituality of music, U2

Friday, October 31, 2025

"Wesleyan Vile-tality: Reclaiming the Heart of Methodist Identity"

One of my favorite Wesley quotes ever:

 


And I love this book title which riffs on it ...



Thanks to Asheley Boggan for bring this quote back into the conversation(s) about where Methodism goes from here.  She rightly asserts that, "John Wesley's entire ministry was framed by a submission to be more vile." (p.23).

Wesley's Journal:

"I could scarce reconcile myself at first to this strange way of preaching in the fields, having been all my life (till very lately) so tenacious of every point relating to decency and order, that I should have thought the saving of souls almost a sin if it had not been done in church...

“At four in the afternoon I submitted to be more vile, and proclaimed in the highways the glad tidings of salvation…” (, Journal of John Wesley, II, 31 Mar. 1739, p. 167 ).”


What time is it for Methodism? It's four o clock in the afternoon.

At Bristol.

We of the Methodist tradition are quick to quote a different time, date and place as where it all began:


"In the evening,I went very unwillingly to a society in Aldersgate Street, where one was reading Luther’s preface to the Epistle to the Romans. About a quarter before nine, while he was describing the change which God works in the heart through faith in Christ, I felt my heart strangely warmed. I felt I did trust in Christ, Christ alone, for salvation; and an assurance was given me that He had taken away my sins, even mine, and saved me from the law of sin and death." (Journal, May 24, 1738)



But one year later at Bristol, everything took subversive shape:


"Have you had a Bristol moment in your life? 
A moment where you felt God calling you into something new and unexpected?
(Discussion question, p.22)


In a very moving section (chaper 1), Boggan recounts her own Bristol encounter, literally in Bristol on a Wesleyan heritage tour, interweaving it with her own personal trauma (divorce and death of parents) and the denominational trauma. That brave pilgrimage is one we all need to take! Thank you, Ashley for inviting us into the hard but required work of reflection which can birth a wholly and holy vile life.


Any who know my own traumas connected to discerning my calling as a Methodist pastor may be surprised I am not here to comment on the UMC/GMC divide, or conservative/liberal debates. (See 

"We've done everything we can to work with Rev. Wainscott!" if interested.

 It's no longer my fight; in fact it never was. I am a conscientious objector in the culture (and denominational) wars 

But I was Bristoled an   ATM in Fresno, California.


And I would love to be as Bristol-ed as I was Aldersgated.


I will let you peek at the table of contents,   and these reviews of the book  to learn more about how she apples the Bristol-birthed vile-tality  in the current situation.  She is well-versed in history,  a great story teller, and the challenges are clamant and convicting  A heads-up: many in our tribe are not aware of the Thomas Blair incident (pp 30-31) in which Wesley used his influence to spring a man accused of "sodomitical practices"  (reminds me of the Pastor Artie Bucco story)  from prison.  Tell that story, Methodists of all stripes.

May Wesleyans ever be "prophetically offensive" (p. 107) and sovereignly and steadfastly committed to Jesus..and to true "vile-tality."

Have you had a Bristol moment in your life?

-
Note: I received a copy of the book from Speakeasy for an honest review.

Posted by dave at Friday, October 31, 2025 No comments:
Labels: book reviews, ecclesiology, Wesley

Friday, February 12, 2021

the covenant post-Holocaust: "Only a wounded faith is worthy of a silent God"

 


"Children were sometimes burned alive at Auschwitz ..After describing this scene, Rabbi  Greenburg put forward the following proposition: 'No statement,  theological or otherwise, should be made that would not be credible in the presence of burning children.". -Gushee. p. 70, After Evangelicalism

Highly recommended:  read page 76 (and ideally the whole section of pp. 74-81)  of Gushee's  After Evangelicalism (read here) ,where he covers Greenburg's suggestion that  post-Holocaust, for the Jews,  the covenant is no longer in a "commanded stage," but is now voluntary.


"Israel's relation with God has been severely wounded.  Wiesel: ' Only a wounded faith can exist after these events.  Only a wounded faith is worthy of a silent God.'...God no longer has the right to demand covenant loyalty from his people."  -Gushee. p. 76, After Evangelicalism

Posted by dave at Friday, February 12, 2021 No comments:
Labels: apophatic, book reviews, jewish, lament, spiritual formation

Wednesday, November 27, 2019

Jerry Walls: Heaven, Hell.. and (Protestant)Purgatory

Links:
=

Search Results

Web results

Heaven, Hell, and Purgatory - Amazon.com

Conversations ~ Jerry Walls on Heaven, Hell, and Purgatory .
Posted by dave at Wednesday, November 27, 2019 No comments:
Labels: book reviews, spiritual formation

Thursday, January 17, 2019

"How many of you are artists?" ...show of hands

From a review of a great book  ("Orbiting the Giant Hairball"):






One thing MacKenzie loved to do was to speak to school groups. He’d spend the day going into all the different classes starting with the kindergarten in the morning and ending with the sixth graders in the afternoon.
He started the same way with all the groups. He said
“Look, I’m an artist and I love to be around other artists. I look at your walls and you’ve got art on them so there must be artists here. Anybody an artist?”
In the kindergarten everybody in the class is raising both hands in the air, jumping about all excited saying
“Yeah, Yeah! I’m an artist! I’m an artist!”
They’re not just an artist, they’re an enthusiastic artist!
By the first grade, still every hand is up, not so much dancing around, not as many double hand raises but everybody is still an artist.
You get to the second grade and that’s where the first bit of attrition occurs – not every single child raised their hand. Then it progressed. He would get two or three people raising their hands starting in the fourth grade, a pretty pivotal moment in terms of identifying as creative.
By sixth grade when the children are old enough to understand this, the couple of people raising their hands are nervously looking round to see if they’re going to be judged by their peers.
It’s not just a fear of failure, it’s a fear of being judged. Creativity is as much about the ability to come up with ideas as it is about the courage to act on those ideas – Creative Confidence.
So Gordon Mackenzie asked the sixth graders
“Hey! What happened to all the artists in this school? Did all the artists transfer out? Did all the artists go to art school? I don’t think so. I think something much worse. I think someone or something has told you it’s not OK to be an artist. If you don’t remember anything else I say today I want you to go home and remember it’s OK to by an artist.” link
Posted by dave at Thursday, January 17, 2019 No comments:
Labels: art, book reviews

Saturday, April 07, 2018

Rohr at Google: The Divine Dance

Posted by dave at Saturday, April 07, 2018 1 comment:
Labels: book reviews, rohr, spiritual formation, trinity

Tuesday, October 24, 2017

Scot McKnight commentary on Philemon: cooler than the new phone book

I am so glad Scot McKnight's commentary on Philemon is out.
This is such good news that I feel like doing this:

McKnight  inaugurated the release with a  helpful post:
10 Reasons Your Church Needs Philemon



Here's a random reason that rocks (Click to see the rest):

9: An example of how to read a book in the Bible.
Philemon can be used to help people learn how to read a whole Bible book. Move then to a letter of John or to Jude or then to a shorter book like Philippians or Galatians then finally to Romans and Corinthians. Perhaps then on to a Gospel.
Reading each line in light of the whole book is possible for Philemon and it’s a good starting point for inductive Bible study methods. Also for historical context (study Roman slavery) and also for Paul’s house church movement of how they learned to live as Christians in an old institution: the house, the home, the family.  link

Bonus: video of him at Asbury (amazing school, my MDiv)
"The Challenge to Philemon" - Dr. Scot McKnight from B.L. Fisher Library on Vimeo.

Also here's a video (audio, actually):

Posted by dave at Tuesday, October 24, 2017 No comments:
Labels: book reviews, Philemon, reading the Bible

Thursday, October 19, 2017

"the mystique of superiority that came as a consolation prize"

Image Credit: Lonely Planet

"I believed myself above him simply on the basis of my Upper East Side address; like most New Yorkers,  I had bought into
the mystique of superiority that came as a consolation prize for life in a lonely and harsh metropolis"
-Deborah Feldman, Exodus, p. 201

From the  Amazon blurb on this book:
The author of the explosive New York Times-bestselling memoir Unorthodox chronicles her continuing journey as a single mother, an independent woman, and a religious refugee.
 

In 2009, at the age of twenty-three, Deborah Feldman walked away from the rampant oppression, abuse, and isolation of her Satmar upbringing in Williamsburg, Brooklyn to forge a better life for herself and her young son.  Since leaving, Feldman has
navigated remarkable experiences: raising her son in the “real” world, finding solace and solitude in a writing career, and searching for love. Culminating in an unforgettable trip across Europe to retrace her grandmother’s life during the Holocaust, Exodus is a deeply moving exploration of the mysterious bonds that tie us to family and religion, the bonds we must sometimes break to find our true selves. link

Related NYC  links:

signs of Kingdom life in Godhaunted NYC? please add comments


theology of New York City


Bad Day For Jesus on the Upper West Side

Posted by dave at Thursday, October 19, 2017 No comments:
Labels: book reviews, city, jewish, NYC, self-disclosure

Tuesday, June 06, 2017

Kultur and Quixotism; epistemology and esthetic, comic and cosmic

I can't  even explain it,

 and don't have the right and rapt metaphor for it,
but reading Unamuno in English
                       --as rewarding as it is--
                              

pales compared to reading the original Spanish.
(I've been that way ever since I was in the Spanish Musical at Liverpool High School, and wrote my first Poe-ish limerick en espanol ..It's  St. Bobbi's fault).

Es una menita como una catedral...

                                                                         .ese.


I must agree that all translation is largely messianic, betrayal...

                           and AT WORST is actual  messianic betrayal.

Translation is inevitably una mentira  como una catedral, ese.


(for fun, see these links on my misadventures in  bilingual life:

Eye See Two Gringos, 

Mary Rocks! and 

"this is only a test")


See this section below, for example..


I love Unamuno's insights on Quixote

 (BTW, how ironic...quixotic, rather... that after 17 years of false strarts and endings, the famous/infamous Quixote film is finally finished),

 So here it is, a loaded section in Unamuno, From "The Tragic Sense of Life, pp 288-87 
(or better yet,  en espanol at the click:"Del Sentamiento Tragico de La Vida" pp, 265-66):

Don Quixote journeyed alone, alone with Sancho, alone with his solitude.  And shall we not also journey alone, we his lovers, creating for ourselves a Quixotesque Spain which only exists in our imagination?
And again we shall be asked:  What has Don Quixote bequeathed to Kultur?  I answer:  Quixotism, and that is no little thing!  It is a whole method, a whole epistemology, a whole esthetic, a whole logic, a whole ethic—­above all, a whole religion—­that is to say, a whole economy of things eternal and things divine, a whole hope in what is rationally absurd.
For what did Don Quixote fight?  For Dulcinea, for glory, for life, for survival.  Not for Iseult, who is the eternal flesh; not for Beatrice, who is theology; not for Margaret, who is the people; not for Helen, who is culture.  He fought for Dulcinea, and he won her, for he lives.
And the greatest thing about him was his having been mocked and vanquished, for it was in being overcome that he overcame; he overcame the world by giving the world cause to laugh at him.

And today? Today he feels his own comicness and the vanity of his endeavours so far as their temporal results are concerned; he sees himself from without—culture has taught him to objectify himself, to alienate himself from himself instead of entering into himself—and in seeing himself from without he laughs at himself, but with a bitter laughter. Perhaps the most tragic character would be that of a Margutte of the inner man, who, like the Margutte of Pulci, should die of laughter, but of laughter at himself. E ridera in eterno, he will laugh for all eternity, said the Angel Gabriel of Margutte. Do you not hear the laughter of God?

The mortal Don Quixote, in dying, realized his own comicness and bewept his sins; but the immortal Quixote, realizing his own comicness, superimposes himself upon it and triumphs over it without renouncing it.

And Don Quixote does not surrender, because he is not a pessimist, and he fights on. He is not a pessimist, because pessimism is begotten by vanity, it is a matter of fashion, pure intellectual snobbism, and Don Quixote is neither vain nor modern with any sort of modernity (still less is he a modernist), and he does not understand the meaning of the word "snob" unless it be explained to him in old Christian Spanish. Don Quixote is not a pessimist, for since he does not understand what is meant by the joie de vivre he does not understand its opposite. Neither does he understand futurist fooleries. In spite of Clavileno,[68] he has not got as far as the aeroplane, which seems to tend to put not a few fools at a still greater distance from heaven. Don Quixote has not arrived at the age of the tedium of life, a condition that not infrequently takes the form of that topophobia so characteristic of many modern spirits, who pass their lives running at top speed from one place to another, not from any love of the place to which they are going, but from hatred of the place they are leaving behind, and so flying from all places: which is one of the forms of despair.

But Don Quixote hears his own laughter, he hears the divine laughter, and since he is not a pessimist, since he believes in life eternal, he has to fight, attacking the modern, scientific, inquisitorial orthodoxy in order to bring in a new and impossible Middle Age, dualistic, contradictory, passionate. Like a new Savonarola, an Italian Quixote of the end of the fifteenth century, he fights against this Modern Age that began with Machiavelli and that will end comically. He fights against the rationalism inherited from the eighteenth century. Peace of mind, reconciliation between reason and faith—this, thanks to the providence of God, is no longer possible. The world must be as Don Quixote wishes it to be, and inns must be castles, and he will fight with it and will, to all appearances, be vanquished, but he will triumph by making himself ridiculous. And he will triumph by laughing at himself and making himself the object of his own laughter.  Unamuno
Posted by dave at Tuesday, June 06, 2017 No comments:
Labels: book reviews, duende, ecclesiology, epistemology, movies, spanish mystics, translation, Unamuno

Tuesday, May 23, 2017

"The Definition Of Hell For Each Myers-Briggs Personality Type" by Heidi Priebe

Click this:

"The Definition Of Hell For Each Myers-Briggs Personality Type"  by Heidi Priebe

One of her examples:
INFP
 – Your deepest thoughts and feelings are exposed to a large audience and everyone thinks that you’re pathetic and unoriginal.

Uhh..





Related::


"naked picture of Dave Wainscott"  (don't worry...safe click!!)


The Comprehensive INFP Survival Guide by Heidi Priebe


Posted by dave at Tuesday, May 23, 2017 No comments:
Labels: book reviews, myers briggs, self-disclosure, spiritual formation

Thursday, February 23, 2017

If I haven't been accused of being an atheist lately, I'm a bad Christian/pastor

If I haven't been accused of being an atheist lately, I'm a bad Christian/pastor.
See this below from Eugene Peterson. ( Related: see also my  "Occasional Atheist; Coffee, Not Jesus" and  "I am in sin if I avoid the appearance of evil"):


The atheist is not always the enemy. Atheists can be among a Christian’s best friends. Atheists, for instance, whose atheism develops out of protest: angry about what is wrong with the world, they are roused to passionate defiance. That a good God permits the birth of crippled children, that a loving God allows rape and torture, that a sovereign God stands aside while the murderous regime of a Genghis Khan or an Adolf Hitler runs its course—such outrageous paradoxes simply cannot be countenanced. So God is eliminated. The removal of God does not reduce the suffering, but it does wipe out the paradox. Such atheism is not the result of logical (or illogical) thought; it is sheer protest. Anger over the suffering and unfairness in the world becomes anger against the God who permits it. Defiance is expressed by denial. Such atheism is commonly full of compassion. It suffers and rages. It is deeply spiritual, in touch with the human condition and eternal values.

Ivan Karamazov is the most famous literary presentation of this atheism of passionate protest
He carried around a notebook in which he copied down every instance of innocent suffering  that he had heard or read of.  There were terrible things in his notebook:accidents and torture, cruelty and agony, malignity and despair.   He specialized in the suffering of innocent children.  The accumulated anecdotes served up an unanswerable indictment against the existence of God.  But he was always talking about the God in whom he did not believe.  He was haunted by the Christ that he rejected.
His very atheism was a grappling with the holy; with love, with meaning.  His atheism had far more spiritual depth than the conventional pietism of people who burn incense to mask the world's stink of suffering and cheerfully sing tunes about the sunshine of God..

..Pastors encounter [a] kind of atheism fairly often.  My response is to probe further.  I ask, "Tell me about this God you don't believe in.  What is he like?'  After listening to what follows, I can usually agree: "I don't believe in that God either.  Given the material the way you present it, I also am an atheist."
-Eugene Peterson, Earth & Altar: The Community of Prayer in a Self-Bound Society, pp. 107-8.
Later refashioned as Where Your Treasure Is: Psalms that Summon You from Self to Community
Posted by dave at Thursday, February 23, 2017 No comments:
Labels: book reviews, eugene peterson, lament, psalms, reading the Bible, role of the pastor

Thursday, June 23, 2016

Trump and Jesus both seem to love racist walls, and both called a woman a dog

If that title wasn't clickbait, I don't know what is (:



                                But it's true.





Don't worry....

 It's all explained in a fantastic section of A J Swoboda's  book
 "The Dusty Ones: How Wandering Deepens Your Faith."




Click  here..

                   


 and start reading with "A Gentile mother.."
                                                                                        

  You won't be sorry.
Posted by dave at Thursday, June 23, 2016 No comments:
Labels: book reviews, reading the Bible, structure of Matthew, temple tantrum

Thursday, June 02, 2016

Do dogs go to heaven? (Rob Bell says no). Cats? (Bell says no). Ferrets? (Bell:yes). Penguins? (TBD as soon as you take David Crowder's survey)

I'm amazed..again..to find a hidden gem from Rob Bell..one that, though published, has never been quoted on the interwebs or Googled.  Let me change the course of history as soon as I hit "publish" on this post.

The first time I found a Bellism that had been missed, it  had to do with his "watermelon in the garden" thesis.

This time it has to do with a  question I once tackled years ago, in a former life, when I had a "Dear Abby"/Ask Dave column online.  It's THE question; one that has dogged many: do dogs go to heaven?

Here you go, hidden in  back of the teen edition of "Love Wins":


Of course, we know his theology on cats (they apparently don't make it, as God didn't even make them) from this clip. (:
Gee, for someone being accused of being a universalist (which he denies, watch this), it's nice to know he can exclude.  (:
--
Related:
-Cat and DogTheology
 
-Another overlooked  and unGoogled classic:the credits/copyright  page of David Crowder's book.  I wonder how many think they've read ever word of the book, and never caught this life-changer.
And it has to do with a bias  towards penguins.
Posted by dave at Thursday, June 02, 2016 No comments:
Labels: book reviews, rob bell

Saturday, April 02, 2016

women, artists, outsiders and introverts: strong church leadership

 From Mandy Smith's The Vulnerable Pastor, pp. 122-124:

Being a woman can feel like weakness.  When you are a woman, your  own body teaches you your limits. From the time you're small, there is always someone bigger, with a stronger body and a deeper voice. And as you grow, you learn how little control you have over your own body, from a sometimes painful, often embarrassing inconvenience that will visit you every month to the strange season of having a person growing inside of you for 9 months. When the little bundle makes its appearance, your body goes from creator of life to sustainer of life. All kinds of new systems kick into gear. It's a miraculous process but one completely beyond your control. As you go from mother to grandmother, your body begins to change again, throwing you into a state of confusion as the steady cycles you have grown accustomed to become syncopated and erratic and then finally stop altogether.
If being a woman teaches humility and collaboration, isn't it a strength to be a woman?
Inhabiting this ever-changing form forces you to acknowledge (even celebrate) your limits and to sense your responsibility to and reliance upon the broader community.

 So if being a woman teaches humility and collaboration, isn't it a strength to be a woman?

In the church, these are leadership skills.
 
Being an artist can feel like weakness.  If you're an artist, you are spurred on by an unending search for truth and beauty. You can have your breath stolen by the smallest, seemingly insignificant thing and be unfit for anything else but crying or singing or writing about it for the rest of the day. And once you've found that tiny sign of hope, you must make sense of it. And so you make things to process and express it, trying to capture all the feeling and meaning for others through the limited media of notes and words and paint. You step into a creative process that is sometimes cruel and raw, a little too close for comfort. Then, with shaking hands, you put that outpouring of your soul into a public form and hope that someone understands.
 
If creative people know how to find truth and beauty, even when it's hidden in brokenn
 ess, if they're comfortable with mystery, failure, and vulnerability, isn't it a strength to be an artist?

In the church, these are leadership skills.
 
Being an outsider can feel like weakness. Being on the outside means always having that vague sense that you didn't get the inside joke. You feel like a child again as you have to learn things that are obvious and basic to everyone else. But over time you compensate. You learn not only to speak but to listen in other languages. You become self-aware as those things which were once transparent about yourself (back when everyone around you was the same as you) are suddenly glaringly visible. For the first time you feel the weight of the lens of your own culture, your own assumptions, and eventually, you learn how to switch glasses.

If being displaced helps us relate to the ways God's people have always been the sojourners, isn't it meaningful to be displaced?
If outsiders know how to be flexible and self-aware, to communicate in a relevant way in many contexts, isn't it a strength to be an outsider?

In the church, these are leadership skills.

Being an introvert can feel like weakness. Thinking of the perfect answer a day after the question makes you feel dumb, even though your belated but perfectly-worded response is more insightful than the one given by the quick-thinker in the room. Needing to recover from extended periods with people draws labels like "anti-social," even though you may have great social skills. Longing for depth and complexity and silence makes you feel like a precious egg-head in a world hungry for sound bites and noise.

If introverts know how to listen, and are unafraid of silence, depth, and authenticity, isn't it a strength to be an introvert?

(link from a pre-book article by Mandy)
 Similar article
 ---



More by Mandy on women and weakness
Posted by dave at Saturday, April 02, 2016 1 comment:
Labels: art, book reviews, ecclesiology, leadership, myers briggs, role of the pastor, self-disclosure, women in leadership
Older Posts Home
View mobile version
Subscribe to: Posts (Atom)

Search This Blog

praying through guitar

Total Pageviews

popular posts this month

  • misquoting Clive Staples, grief and anger
        I ran across the meme lately with the quote about anger and grief attributed to C.S. Lewis. Is it much exaggeration to say that most ...
  • "I wanted to know Jesus, but you gave me a library"
    "I wanted to know Jesus, and you gave me a library!" This devastating line that Jackie Pullinger once heard, ...
  • "Some Confessions from a Christian Pastor"
    Published in The Fresno Bee, Valley Voices column 7/11/09 ( online here) : "Some Confessions from a Christian Pastor" by Dave...
  • Zappa and Xenochrony: Strangetime synchronizations-- ξένοχρόνi
    photo From Wikipedia: link Xenochrony is a studio-based musical technique developed at an unknown date, but possibly as early as ...
  • temple tantrum/ which curtain was torn?
    "Behind the second curtain was a room called the Holy of Holies" -Hebrews 9:3 We all know "the curtain of the temple was to...
  • U2 Can Overcome the Death Bomb
    U2 Can Overcome the Death Bomb Many have asked to see this clip below; having heard me teach on it . The set up: How about this amazing...
  • will praying in Haiku produce a gated drum effect?
    One of my favorite poets and persons (and cousins) is Ed Brickell. I particularly admire his craft with Haiku. I remember how when Peter Gab...
  • "Moment of....Prayer Rap"
    Love the prayer rap at the end (5 minute mark video below, or audio here ) of "Moment of Surrender" on Saturday Night Live last ...
  • U22 Zooropa: questions on the questions?
    (also posted on atU2 forum here I was sure I'd never hear "Zooropa" live. I mean it was only played three times when it...
  • "Salvation on the Small Screen": 24 hours of Christian TV/crack
    2015 update: Years after this post, I am linking to it for some students, who I assigned to watch a half-hour of Christian TV, and post abou...

Topix:

Augustine (18) Beth Maynard (92) Bruce Cockburn (61) Brueggemann (44) C.S. Lewis (5) Chris Seay (12) Colbert (113) Craig Keener (21) Dostoevsky (1) Ellul (21) Joao Magueijo (5) Leonard Shlain (11) Leonard Sweet (56) Lessig (13) Luther (3) Mark DeRaud (44) Pete Rollins (46) Peter Gabriel (39) Philemon (27) Phyllis Tickle (17) Pope Francis (103) Ray Bradbury (14) Russell Willingham (11) Simone Weil (1) Spirit Christology (13) TED (62) TNIV (18) The Matrix (50) U2 (105) U2 1980s (66) U2 2000s (182) U2 2010s (94) U2 devotionals (20) Unamuno (3) Wesley (11) adbusters (34) alanis morissette (8) anabaptist (75) apocalyptic (79) apophatic (4) apostolic (17) architecture (52) art (83) being white (10) bibliolatry (33) bongolese (13) book reviews (209) brian dodd (17) capon (36) cathedrals (10) celtic (39) centered sets (152) certainty (57) chiasm/inclusio (58) christian bookstore (45) christus victor (23) city (41) clerical clothing (12) communitas (24) conversos (5) culture wars (70) david dark (36) death (8) death of Jesus (108) definitions of culture (4) derrida (8) duende (8) ecclesiology (631) economic (51) ehrman (5) elevation (59) empire (75) epimenides paradox (3) epistemology (75) español (2) eugene peterson (88) frank lake (3) fresno drop (12) gnosticism (5) grief (2) hofstadter (8) holocaust (8) holy fool (10) holy worldliness (22) image (4) images (28) imagination (3) improv (8) intertextuality (10) james k.a. smith (10) jewish (162) kenosis (1) kierkegaard (30) king's x (8) lament (133) lamott (3) language (76) last night on earth (3) leadership (92) let the pagans prophesy (5) letterman (6) liminality (29) listening (6) macphisto (15) margaret wheatley (8) mars hill (2) matrix (5) media (38) metaphor (50) midrash (1) mimetic (14) missional sacraments (42) moltmann (25) movies (90) myers briggs (25) n.t. wright (128) neal postman (10) neruda (5) parables (43) paraguay (7) paul hiebert (27) peru (22) physics (91) pickover (8) pink floyd (35) pioneer (4) pneumatology (18) poetry (5) pornography (34) printing press (6) prostitutes (7) psalms (64) radiohead (14) ray van der laan (21) reading the Bible (565) reformation (42) revelation (6) rob bell (90) rohr (14) role of the pastor (658) sabbath (11) sapir-whorf (31) sarcastic lutheran (28) seduction (4) self-disclosure (134) semiotics (44) sermon on the mount (14) sexuality (232) shame (4) shane claiborne (20) shane hipps (17) simulacfra (4) simulacra (82) sinead o'connor (24) social networking (72) sound theory (64) spanish mystics (15) spiritual formation (220) spiritual warfare (54) spirituality of music (644) string theory (23) structure of Matthew (49) synesthesia (37) technology (127) temple tantrum (93) testation (17) the frames (4) the voice (11) third places (17) time travel (81) translation (84) trinity (54) twitter (12) u2 1990s (65) ustedes va (17) violet burning (51) wolfgang simson (47) women in leadership (64) words about words (45) xxx church (25) zappa (11) zoo tv (26) Žižek (21)

recent comments//add yours

postz:

  • ▼  2026 (9)
    • ▼  Sep 2026 (2)
      • will praying in Haiku produce a gated drum effect?
      • Anabaptist Perspective: Did the early church teach...
    • ►  Jul 2026 (1)
    • ►  Jun 2026 (4)
    • ►  Apr 2026 (1)
    • ►  Mar 2026 (1)
  • ►  2025 (10)
    • ►  Dec 2025 (1)
    • ►  Oct 2025 (3)
    • ►  Sep 2025 (2)
    • ►  Jun 2025 (1)
    • ►  May 2025 (1)
    • ►  Mar 2025 (1)
    • ►  Feb 2025 (1)
  • ►  2024 (3)
    • ►  Nov 2024 (1)
    • ►  Jun 2024 (1)
    • ►  Jan 2024 (1)
  • ►  2023 (3)
    • ►  Sep 2023 (3)
  • ►  2022 (1)
    • ►  Dec 2022 (1)
  • ►  2021 (1)
    • ►  Feb 2021 (1)
  • ►  2020 (4)
    • ►  Jun 2020 (1)
    • ►  Apr 2020 (1)
    • ►  Feb 2020 (1)
    • ►  Jan 2020 (1)
  • ►  2019 (3)
    • ►  Nov 2019 (1)
    • ►  Sep 2019 (1)
    • ►  Jan 2019 (1)
  • ►  2018 (3)
    • ►  Nov 2018 (1)
    • ►  Apr 2018 (2)
  • ►  2017 (24)
    • ►  Oct 2017 (4)
    • ►  Aug 2017 (1)
    • ►  Jul 2017 (6)
    • ►  Jun 2017 (3)
    • ►  May 2017 (3)
    • ►  Mar 2017 (2)
    • ►  Feb 2017 (1)
    • ►  Jan 2017 (4)
  • ►  2016 (21)
    • ►  Dec 2016 (3)
    • ►  Nov 2016 (2)
    • ►  Jul 2016 (1)
    • ►  Jun 2016 (3)
    • ►  May 2016 (2)
    • ►  Apr 2016 (2)
    • ►  Mar 2016 (1)
    • ►  Feb 2016 (3)
    • ►  Jan 2016 (4)
  • ►  2015 (169)
    • ►  Dec 2015 (4)
    • ►  Nov 2015 (8)
    • ►  Oct 2015 (14)
    • ►  Sep 2015 (5)
    • ►  Aug 2015 (3)
    • ►  Jul 2015 (12)
    • ►  Jun 2015 (11)
    • ►  May 2015 (29)
    • ►  Apr 2015 (16)
    • ►  Mar 2015 (11)
    • ►  Feb 2015 (22)
    • ►  Jan 2015 (34)
  • ►  2014 (390)
    • ►  Dec 2014 (12)
    • ►  Nov 2014 (22)
    • ►  Oct 2014 (22)
    • ►  Sep 2014 (20)
    • ►  Aug 2014 (45)
    • ►  Jul 2014 (39)
    • ►  Jun 2014 (49)
    • ►  May 2014 (39)
    • ►  Apr 2014 (30)
    • ►  Mar 2014 (32)
    • ►  Feb 2014 (34)
    • ►  Jan 2014 (46)
  • ►  2013 (775)
    • ►  Dec 2013 (47)
    • ►  Nov 2013 (113)
    • ►  Oct 2013 (112)
    • ►  Sep 2013 (60)
    • ►  Aug 2013 (35)
    • ►  Jul 2013 (46)
    • ►  Jun 2013 (47)
    • ►  May 2013 (62)
    • ►  Apr 2013 (65)
    • ►  Mar 2013 (59)
    • ►  Feb 2013 (73)
    • ►  Jan 2013 (56)
  • ►  2012 (431)
    • ►  Dec 2012 (32)
    • ►  Nov 2012 (31)
    • ►  Oct 2012 (25)
    • ►  Sep 2012 (19)
    • ►  Aug 2012 (22)
    • ►  Jul 2012 (42)
    • ►  Jun 2012 (41)
    • ►  May 2012 (36)
    • ►  Apr 2012 (37)
    • ►  Mar 2012 (58)
    • ►  Feb 2012 (38)
    • ►  Jan 2012 (50)
  • ►  2011 (517)
    • ►  Dec 2011 (54)
    • ►  Nov 2011 (58)
    • ►  Oct 2011 (24)
    • ►  Sep 2011 (16)
    • ►  Aug 2011 (40)
    • ►  Jul 2011 (44)
    • ►  Jun 2011 (35)
    • ►  May 2011 (61)
    • ►  Apr 2011 (52)
    • ►  Mar 2011 (49)
    • ►  Feb 2011 (50)
    • ►  Jan 2011 (34)
  • ►  2010 (800)
    • ►  Dec 2010 (82)
    • ►  Nov 2010 (62)
    • ►  Oct 2010 (46)
    • ►  Sep 2010 (52)
    • ►  Aug 2010 (25)
    • ►  Jul 2010 (35)
    • ►  Jun 2010 (59)
    • ►  May 2010 (91)
    • ►  Apr 2010 (78)
    • ►  Mar 2010 (98)
    • ►  Feb 2010 (75)
    • ►  Jan 2010 (97)
  • ►  2009 (589)
    • ►  Dec 2009 (66)
    • ►  Nov 2009 (34)
    • ►  Oct 2009 (40)
    • ►  Sep 2009 (46)
    • ►  Aug 2009 (22)
    • ►  Jul 2009 (36)
    • ►  Jun 2009 (34)
    • ►  May 2009 (58)
    • ►  Apr 2009 (89)
    • ►  Mar 2009 (78)
    • ►  Feb 2009 (42)
    • ►  Jan 2009 (44)
  • ►  2008 (484)
    • ►  Dec 2008 (41)
    • ►  Nov 2008 (28)
    • ►  Oct 2008 (41)
    • ►  Sep 2008 (44)
    • ►  Aug 2008 (13)
    • ►  Jul 2008 (29)
    • ►  Jun 2008 (42)
    • ►  May 2008 (82)
    • ►  Apr 2008 (53)
    • ►  Mar 2008 (39)
    • ►  Feb 2008 (39)
    • ►  Jan 2008 (33)
  • ►  2007 (381)
    • ►  Dec 2007 (35)
    • ►  Nov 2007 (27)
    • ►  Oct 2007 (36)
    • ►  Sep 2007 (41)
    • ►  Aug 2007 (47)
    • ►  Jul 2007 (40)
    • ►  Jun 2007 (31)
    • ►  May 2007 (39)
    • ►  Apr 2007 (31)
    • ►  Mar 2007 (24)
    • ►  Feb 2007 (23)
    • ►  Jan 2007 (7)
  • ►  2006 (219)
    • ►  Dec 2006 (17)
    • ►  Nov 2006 (15)
    • ►  Oct 2006 (8)
    • ►  Sep 2006 (12)
    • ►  Aug 2006 (24)
    • ►  Jul 2006 (9)
    • ►  Jun 2006 (22)
    • ►  May 2006 (32)
    • ►  Apr 2006 (23)
    • ►  Mar 2006 (26)
    • ►  Feb 2006 (29)
    • ►  Jan 2006 (2)

follow?

dave wainscott

My photo
dave
About me
View my complete profile

recent posts from friends

  • Stuff Christians Like - Jon Acuff
    The Lie of ‘Do It While You’re Young’: Why Every Decade Can Be Your Best - The post The Lie of ‘Do It While You’re Young’: Why Every Decade Can Be Your Best appeared first on Jon Acuff.
    2 years ago
  • The Dude Abides
    Yahrzeit | Sinéad - A year gone: From the moment I first heard her fierce voice and mighty, fragile heart thru the radio in my teenage bedroom, Sinéad O'Connor was an inspirat...
    2 years ago
  • THE UPRISING
    HipHop Psalms - Home alone for an hour - Loud Hip Hop as...
    4 years ago
  • @U2 News
    Signing Off... - [image: atu2 logo default 1200px] We're signing off today.
    5 years ago
  • satire and theology©
    PhD: Twitter quote 21 - *PhD: Twitter quote 21* Photo; Pixabay, Bridge Railway PhD version Erlandson explains that many theodicy are fatally flawed since they are too focused ...
    6 years ago
  • The Rebel God
    Facing Racism - The Trump era has caused us to face the ugly specter of racism. No one wants to think of themselves as racist. When someone says "that's racist" let alone...
    7 years ago
  • Igneous Quill
    Don't Be a Boy Scout - Given the ways the perspectives of Humanists have been ignored or belittled in Unitarian Universalism in recent years, one would think that they would be t...
    7 years ago
  • While We Slept
    Why Women Are Not Female Versions Of Men - When God created male and female, he created them differently; not discriminately. When disobedience entered the scene, things changed. Just like a good ...
    8 years ago
  • Sarcastic Lutheran (Nadia Bolz-Weber)
    The Denver Statement - The Denver Statement – a response to the Nashville Statement by some of the queer, trans, gay, lesbian, bi-sexual, gender-queer, asexual, straight, single...
    9 years ago
  • The Bored-Again Christian
    How to Search Engines Like Google, Bing and Yahoo Work - There are many search engines but, Google, Bing, and Yahoo are the most common. They all use different algorithms, but all take these essential factors i...
    9 years ago
  • shallowfrozenwater
    Kathy - she was the best of us. she was the kind of person that I want to be. she was a simple soul and we were robbed of her presence. she was strong. my God, so...
    10 years ago
  • Peer Pressure Is Forever
    Lee Camp et al - I find it helpful to say that we’re never not cultivating in one way or another. Or as my friends Rob and Kirstin put it: Culture is not optional. Which...
    10 years ago
  • Those who dance are thought mad by those who hear not the music.
    "Do as you will": Are Libertarians the Anti-Christ? - Compare these two statements and see if you are not at least a little alarmed by their similarity: "Do as you will." This is the only ethical command...
    11 years ago
  • Shifting Paradigms
    Hubs, Networks, and Teams - Whether in vocational church or marketplace ministry, our ability to respond quickly and adapt is critical, and it's becoming even more so as technology an...
    11 years ago
  • Occasio
    Reflections on Charleston: the example of Armenian reconciliation - “We have come here to apologize for what our ancestors did, to ask for your forgiveness.” “We plead with you, if you can, to forgive us and the crimes of o...
    11 years ago
  • Post-Rapture
    Leonard Knight’s Salvation Mountain - From, The Great Wall of China and the Salton Sea,Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing, Spring 2016 We drove east away from the Sea, through Niland’s marginally inhab...
    11 years ago
  • U2 Sermons
    Sites to take a look at - Some readers may already have seen Tim Neufeld's post on his talk "Social Justice and Pop Culture: U2 as a non-traditional Christian voice," from the meeti...
    11 years ago
  • the living room
    the overdubs - Blood Test ep - faith, hope, love, indie rock.
    11 years ago
  • Church in a Circle
    If form follows function, perhaps we need to redesign our churches. - The number one rule of architecture is “form follows function.” Buildings and spaces should facilitate and enhance their purpose, not detract from it. The ...
    11 years ago
  • The Dusty Follower
    LAMENT OF THE WANDERER - Over the last four and a half years, the path forward in ministry has not been clear. This led to a number of days of doubt and questioning. I have often...
    11 years ago
  • the holy wild
    the great adventure: day 12 - time does weird things to memories. sometimes it clouds them with forgetfulness and other times it infuses them with additional information that may or may...
    12 years ago
  • Out of The Shadows (Paul Leader)
    The Traveller’s Rest- “The Traveller’s Rest.” - Devon Cream Teas & Family. On Saturday we returned from our week in Combe Martin, Devon. One word … gorgeous. Seven days of wall to wall sunshine, morning ...
    12 years ago
  • UrbanChristianMaggot
    In the name of Jesus - Over the last couple of years I have grown increasingly agitated by the use of the phrase “in the name of Jesus” as people close up their prayers or interj...
    12 years ago
  • Hacking Christianity
    -

Dumb disclaimer:

It should go without saying...but i wouldn't want it to... that since this blog is a Spiritaneous place to throw out thoughts/feelings/articles "in process," it does not represent any of the fine institutions you see by my profile that I am affiliated with (Heck, it may not even represent me! (:........). The blog is merely an attempt to subvert subversion and "push toward the unobvious" (Thanks, Tim N. for that phrase) on the six hot topics listed at the top of the page....Welcome, engage it, and don't be offended (for the wrong reason, anyway!)

tribesters

ekklesia-thing

ekklesia-thing

translate me

Bookmark and Share
Awesome Inc. theme. Powered by Blogger.