Showing posts with label temple tantrum. Show all posts
Showing posts with label temple tantrum. Show all posts

Thursday, June 23, 2016

Trump and Jesus both seem to love racist walls, and both called a woman a dog

If that title wasn't clickbait, I don't know what is (:



                                But it's true.





Don't worry....

 It's all explained in a fantastic section of A J Swoboda's  book
 "The Dusty Ones: How Wandering Deepens Your Faith."




Click  here..

                   


 and start reading with "A Gentile mother.."
                                                                                        

  You won't be sorry.

Tuesday, February 24, 2015

have faith (and works), and speak to Herod's artificial line-mountain on the horizon

 (bonus points for anyone catching the two U2 references in my title)

I am all for '"you can move mountains" as radical charismatic faith...sometimes.
But as a corrective to the typical "speak to the mountain of your circumstance" interpretation,
Charles R. Page II is helpful.

Many have weighed in as to which mountain of the "this mountain" Jesus spoke of/to is in mind:.


  the temple itself (called a mountain in Isaiah 2; Isaiah 56 etc) ,
               Temple Mount (Joel Green/John Carroll says Jesus "could only mean" this),
                               Mt Zion,
                                      Mount of Olives.

Whichever candidate we  choose above (maybe all), the bottom line is the same: the whole temple system is under judgement and must go.  On that topic, see N.T. Wright in this video.   And this: "For Jesus, the time of the temple is no more.” -Green/ Carroll, “The Death of Jesus in Early Christianity,”).

BUT consider Ryland's first paragraph below:  Could the mountain  instead/also be Herod's Herodian?

ALSO consider the second paragraph as compelling alternative to "faith that can move mountains."
Could it be "faith and works"?"


Jesus was possibly passing along from Bethpage to the Mount of Olives when this teaching was offered.  From that from which they traveled one can see off on the horizon to the south the mountain fortress of the Herodian, Herod the Great's summer palace, some seven miles south of Jerusalem.  The Herodian fortress is built inside an artificial mountain that resembles a volcanic cone.  To create this structure, Herod the Great had the dirt removed from one hill and piled up on another.  It was hollow on the inside, and a very tall fortification wall surrounded its perimeter.  This is a mountain that was literally moved!

Furthermore, from the Mount of Olives, on a clear day, the Dead Sea is visible to the southeast.  In  the West we often misinterpret Jesus' meaning when he says we may move mountains, believing he is taking about magic, or perhaps telekenesis.  Yet this is a very practical teaching, conforming to practical Hillelian thought: 'You can do unbelievable things if you are willing to work.'  You can move mountains, but you must have faith to put a shovel into the ground and bend your back!
--Jesus and the Land,Charles R. Page II, p127-128



Related: On the Herodian symbolism to Jesus' subversion of empire:

"In the Shadow of Herod" video


Friday, January 30, 2015

Jesus' "incredibly disrespectful, offensive and irresponsible inaugural miracle"

In a compelling section of his "Selling Water by the the River," Shane Hipps discusses the John 2 account of the wedding at Cana, concluding that "this inaugural miracle sets the stage for [Jesus'] way of operating in the world.  It frames his entire ministry."  He suggests that Jesus' use of the ceremonial washing jars, instead of using the "obvious" amphoras [wine containers] that were surely nearby, was an "incredibly  disrespectful, offensive and irresponsible thing."

Teaser: it has something to do with Tuma.

The entire section can be viewed on Google Books; pp. 31-36 here (the page numbers are not marked, so read from  the paragraph beginning "Jen had a warm but weary..." to the paragraph ending "confines of the riverbanks.")

When Shane autographed my book, he asked about me.  I mentioned I was a pastor and Bible teacher, and that I had found his teaching helpful.  He smiled, "And you haven't gotten in trouble  for that yet?"

I have always found it fascinating that John very intentionally hitches (some would call it framejacking)  this story to Jesus' temple cleansing. So it's worth pursuing how the temple tantrum was also  an "incredibly disrespectful, offensive and irresponsible inaugural miracle"...and for similar reasons.

Also: see Michael Frost  video  HERE for help on this text, including a suggested inclusio.
("Uncle Joshua would've had a lampshade on his head")

Tuesday, January 20, 2015

Miss Israel and Miss Lebanon....meet Miss Sarajevo

In light of  this news from a beauty pageant,

                   ..is there a time for Miss Sarajevo? (see this)

Tuesday, December 30, 2014

why was the temple veil torn?

How many times have you heard that the veil in the temple was torn to show that the way to God is now open? 

Maybe..but reading in context offers some perhaps better options:
Here's one:
.....Mark purposefully juxtaposes the tearing of the temple veil and the confession of the centurion so that the climax of Mark answers this question: “where is God?”
In this scene, the temple is exposed as a sham.  The veil isn’t torn to symbolize that the way to God is open.  It’s torn to indicate that the temple apparatus is a fraud, corrupted by power and greed.  There’s nothing there and there’s nobody home.  -Full link, Tim Gombis

 Another:

We all know "the curtain of the temple was torn in two as Jesus died."
And most assume it was the curtain separating the Holy Place from the Holy of Holies, meaning Jesus provides direct access to God.
Good and true that he does that, and it is the proper "evangelical answer"..
but what if the temple torn in two was not the second curtain (or second curtain only),but the first..
what would the implications be?  -click to find out

And:

Now from the sixth hour there was darkness over all the land
until the ninth hour. And about the ninth hour Jesus cried with
a loud voice, “Eli, Eli, lema sabachthani?” that is, “My God, my
God, why hast thou forsaken me?” And some of the bystanders
hearing it said, “This man is calling Elijah.” … And Jesus cried
again with a loud voice and yielded up his spirit. And behold, the
veil of the Temple was torn (eschisthe) in two, from top to bottom;
and the earth shook and the rocks were torn (eschisthesan); the
tombs also were opened, and many bodies of the saints who had
fallen asleep were raised, and coming out of their tombs after his
resurrection they went into the holy city and appeared to many.
(Matt. 27:45–53)

Notice the twofold consequence of Jesus’ death: with the yielding up of his
spirit, it is the Temple and the earth that are both “torn asunder” (Greek: schizo). In
other words, the effects of his death are both cultic and cosmic. With his crucifixion,
the Temple of the old creation and indeed, creation itself, are not only thrown
into a state of upheaval, but arguably begin the process of “passing away.” Should
there be any doubt about this suggestion, recall what we learned earlier and what
every first-century Jew would have known: on the Temple veil was depicted “the
panorama of the heavens.”50 Hence, with the tearing of the Temple veil and the
earthquake—the whole universe, “heaven and earth,” were symbolically being
torn asunder. And because the Jerusalem Temple was the sign and symbol of this
universe, it was now destined to share the same fate. The old Temple would be
replaced by a new, and the old world—as Isaiah had said so long ago—would be
replaced by “a new heavens and a new earth” (Isa. 65:17; 66:22). And all this, according
to Jesus, would begin “on the third day.”  LINK, Brant Pitre
How about:

two of the events of Mk 13/Matt 24 that  N.T> Wright argues are seen in AD 70, namely the “abomination of desolation” and the destruction of the Temple, are already seen in Jesus’ final work in Jerusalem and in his death. Wright himself argues that Caiaphas is presented as “evil incarnate” and his position as chief priest may point to his fulfillment of the “abomination of desolation.” Second and more strongly presented by the Gospels is the fact that the Temple is destroyed not in AD 70 but at Jesus’ death when the curtain is torn in two. As Wright demonstrates, Jesus proleptically enacts the Temple’s destruction in the Temple cleansing; the temporary cessation of sacrifices momentarily ends its purpose and thus its destruction is foreshadowed. Therefore when the curtain is torn in two at Jesus’ death, the Temple is permanently destroyed. The Holy of Holies has been violated; it can no longer serve its purpose.   link

Saturday, November 29, 2014

"Jesus didn’t cleanse the temple, he indicted it"

Rusty Butler:

Last week, Valerie encouraged us to look at the events of Palm Sunday and
to see in Jesus’ procession into the city of Jerusalem a counter parade to
the imperial/military parade that took place when the Roman Army
entered into Jerusalem at the beginning of the Passover celebration. On
one side of the city Pilot’s army comes thundering in with war horses, foot
soldiers, armor and swords, on the other side of the city, Jesus rides in on a
donkey a symbol of an entirely different kind of Kingship.

Was the parade enough of an affront to Pilot and the authorities to cause
Jesus death? If not, what else happened that week that propels the events
forward that culminate in Jesus death....

Well, a few questions spring to mind: Did Jesus do all this by himself? Or did
he have help from the disciples? Imagine this too..24 acres of open
courtyard. If Jesus and his followers had taken control of the entire
courtyard and held it for hours, the Imperial troops stationed at the
Fortress Antonia ....

...Some people call what Jesus did a Temple Tantrum, as if Jesus saw what
was going on and became surprised and then very angry that there were
such things going on. But the fact of the matter is, the buying and selling of
animals for sacrifice had been going on long before. Generations in fact,
even though before the courts were built, the buying and selling was to
have taken place away from the Temple proper.

Instead, I invite us to look at the act as an intentional one. One that is
strategically planned. Someone said, it is a symbolic act not unlike the Nuns
who broke into one of the missile silo sites and poured a vial of their blood over
the concrete missile site. That is a symbolic act, in no way do they
think they are bringing the entire nuclear missile program down, rather it is
supposed to suggest a stance, it makes a statement.

Think of what Jesus did in that way and it becomes something quite
different than a temper tantrum.

Most of us probably grew up knowing the story of Jesus overturning the
tables. And many of us probably heard that it had something to do with
people being cheated…during the buying and selling of animals and that
changing money should not be going on in a place of worship. In fact, we
talked about it on Wednesday at Bible study and each of us there has this
lingering sense that whenever we buy or sell something like Fairtrade
coffee or grocery certificates here at church we get a queasy feeling…that
that kind of thing should not be going on in a church…and that if Jesus
came back and saw that, he’d be distressed.

We grew up with that…but it is not the story.

For many, naming the story, the “cleansing of the temple” means that Jesus
sought to get rid of the money changers and vendors to purify the Temple.
But the fact is that this was a traditional practice, and the animal providers
and the money changers provided a service for the pilgrims and the
functioning of the temple. If you were a pilgrim who had traveled miles and
miles to get to Jerusalem, it was much more convenient to purchase your
sheep, cattle, dove at the temple than to bring it with you from home.
There is evidence according to Marcus Borg that the exchange rates were
closely regulated so the issue was not that pilgrims were being cheated by
these money changers.

So what was it that Jesus was taking exception to? Some have suggested it
was the animal sacrifice but Jesus mentions nothing about it. That seems
not to be the case either. As Mark tells the story, Jesus, after the turning of the
 tables teaches. And
this is what he says.
"Is it not written, My house shall be called a house of prayer for all nations?
But you have made it a den of robbers."
Herod had built the courts of the Gentiles so that people who were “all
nations” in other words, the gentiles could come to the Temple. That was
not the problem…The real key is the second sentence. You have made it a
den of robbers.

That phrase echoes a phrase found in the book of Jeremiah in the Old
Testament. Standing in the gates of the Temple, Jeremiah the prophet said
Do not trust in these deceptive words: This is the temple of the lord, the
temple of the lord, the temple of the Lord. He warns the people that the
Temple will be destroyed unless the people who worship there begin to
practice justice.

Listen to what he says: "If you truly amend your ways and doings, if you truly
act justly with one another , if you do not oppress the alien, the orphan and
the widow, or shed innocent blood in this place, and if you do not go after
other Gods to your own hurt, then I (God) will dwell with you in this place.
Then Jeremiah says, Has this house, (meaning the temple), which is called
by my name, become a den of robbers in your sight?"

The meaning seems to be, it was a den of robbers because it had become
the center of an oppressive system that did not practice justice but
exploited the most vulnerable in society. It was an indictment of the
powerful.

They thought of the temple as their safe house and a place of security. It
had become a hideout for the robbers of society. When Jesus calls the temple
a den of robbers, he was rather indicting the
temple authorities who had collaborated with the Romans at the top of the
system. Jesus didn’t cleanse the temple, he indicted it....



...When we think about the fact that we are the followers of a person who
strategically made moves against the authorities when he felt the system
they represented and led was unjust…it may begin to creep into our minds
that this Jesus was about more than just getting people into heaven…and it
may even change what we think about who we are as Christians.   link

Monday, October 27, 2014

Pastors eavedropping: 1)grocery store freakout 1)near-funeral during funeral prep @ Starbuck's

1) grocery store freakout --read it here

2) " confrontation at Starbuck's ..see "Junk in the Trunk," listen to it on right hand sidebar, first five minutes here

Friday, August 29, 2014

2 articles for white folks to wrestle with

Two articles:


1)What My Bike Has Taught Me About White Privilege  By Jeremy Dowsett:

The phrase “white privilege” is one that rubs a lot of white people the wrong way. It can trigger something in them that shuts down conversation or at least makes them very defensive. (Especially those who grew up relatively less privileged than other folks around them). And I’ve seen more than once where this happens and the next move in the conversation is for the person who brought up white privilege to say, “The reason you’re getting defensive is because you’re feeling the discomfort of having your privilege exposed.”
I’m sure that’s true sometimes. And I’m sure there are a lot of people, white and otherwise, who can attest to a kind of a-ha moment or paradigm shift where they “got” what privilege means and they did realize they had been getting defensive because they were uncomfortable at having their privilege exposed. But I would guess that more often than not, the frustration and the shutting down is about something else. It comes from the fact that nobody wants to be a racist. And the move “you only think that because you’re looking at this from the perspective of privilege” or the more terse and confrontational “check your privilege!” kind of sound like an accusation that someone is a racist (if they don’t already understand privilege). And the phrase “white privilege” kind of sounds like, “You are a racist and there’s nothing you can do about it because you were born that way.”
And if this were what “white privilege” meant—which it does not—defensiveness and frustration would be the appropriate response. But privilege talk is not intended to make a moral assessment or a moral claim about the privileged at all. It is about systemic imbalance. It is about injustices that have arisen because of the history of racism that birthed the way things are now. It’s not saying, “You’re a bad person because you’re white.” It’s saying, “The system is skewed in ways that you maybe haven’t realized or had to think about precisely because it’s skewed in YOUR favor.”
I am white. So I have not experienced racial privilege from the “under” side firsthand. But my children (and a lot of other people I love) are not white. And so I care about privilege and what it means for racial justice in our country. And one experience I have had firsthand, which has helped me to understand privilege and listen to privilege talk without feeling defensive, is riding my ...CONTINUED HERE
--

2)Man Arrested While Picking Up His Kids: 'The Problem Is I'm Black'
A controversial video documents the St. Paul resident being harassed and tased.


HHA124L/Flickr
If you've never experienced arbitrary harassment or brutality at the hands of a police officer, or seen law enforcement act in a way that defies credulity and common sense, it can be hard to believe people who tell stories of inexplicable persecution. As I noted in "Video Killed Trust in Police Officers," the dawn of cheap recording technology has exposed an ugly side of U.S. law enforcement that a majority of people in middle-class neighborhoods never would've seen otherwise.
Today, what's most disheartening isn't that so many Americans still reflexively doubt stories of police harassment, as awful as it is whenever real victims are ignored. What vexes me most is police officers caught acting badly on camera who suffer no consequences and are defended by the police agencies that employ them.
The latest example of abusive, atrocious police work posted to YouTube comes from St. Paul, Minnesota, where a black father, Chris Lollie, reportedly got off work at Cossetta, an upscale Italian eatery, walked to the downtown building that houses New Horizon Academy, where he was to to pick up his kids, and killed the ten minutes until they'd be released sitting down on a chair in a skyway between buildings. Those details come from the Minneapolis City Pages,where commenters describe the area he inhabited as a public thoroughfare between commercial buildings. If you're 27 and black with dreadlocks, sometimes you're waiting to pick up your kids and someone calls the cops to get rid of you. The police report indicates a call about "an uncooperative male refusing to leave," which makes it sound as though someone else first asked him to vacate where he was; another press report says that he was sitting in a chair in a public area when a security guard approached and told him to leave as the area was reserved for employees. The Minnesota Star Tribune visited the seating area and reported that "there was no signage in the area indicating that it was reserved for employees."
So a man waiting to pick p his kids from school sits for a few minutes in a seating area where he reasonably thinks he has a right to be, private security asks him to leave, he thinks they're harassing him because he's black, and they call police. This is where the video begins, and that conflict is already over. The man is walking away from it and toward the nearby school where he is to pick up his kids.
So problem solved? It could have been.
Instead, this happened:story continued here



____________






ANd --------------- OK

Tuesday, August 26, 2014

Austin Farrrer on "probable tracks" of Jesus' temptations: subversion of Paethon and temple tantrum connections

hotel in Israel
Austin Farrrer , though apparently "one of the most profound and prophetic theologians of the twentieth century"  (so back cover says!) was new to me....but the price was right on one of his books (1.50):  "The Triple Victory: Christ's Temptation According to St. Matthew."

As one with a special interest in the temptations of Jesus, literary structure of Matthew, I wouldn't have resisted the testation to buy it at double the price (:

Come on..NO reviews on Amazon US or Amazon UK (He was British)?!...

"His activity in philosophy, theology, and spirituality led many to consider him the outstanding figure of 20th century Anglicanism. -Wikipedia

Turns out he was  well-respected by C.S. Lewis,and had an intriguing solution for the synoptic problem.  Wiki calls him a "maverick."

 I like him already...even if/especially if he is sometimes wrong (:

Even in the preface,  Frederick Borsh partly agrees with accusations  of  Farrer's sometimes fanciful flights into literary structural analysis, midrash and typology.  But he defends him as being  very thoughtful, creative..and ahead of his time as far as redaction/compositional criticism etc.  "He may have seen too many typologies, but he was not wrong in understanding that biblical writers often thought in typological categories.  This keen awareness pays particularly rich dividends in his study of Christ's temptations." (p. 2)

He does well, as does Donald Kraybill, in seeing many links from the temptations  to the rest of Matthew's gospel.

I haven't read enough for a review yet, so I'll  just

1)ask if any are familiar with this work

2)quote this:

Satan's insinuation...contains a hidden poison: "If you are the Son of God..If you cannot or dare not, what sort of divine Son are you?"...

Jesus declines..not because it is wicked..but because it is wicked to make a willful use of spiritual power...

"throw yourself down"...The suggested action is so utterly useless in itself, it can have one purpose only:.."Jump and find out; if you won't jump you can't really believe it."

...Christ refused to do what Phaethon did [doubt his paternity].  But could he have even thought in those terms? We may give a double reply.  First, though Christ did not think that God was an inhabitant of Jerusalem, he took the sanctity of the holy place with complete seriousness  He can, indeed, be  said to have pulled his own death on his head, by taking the law into his own hands and cleansing the temple from trade.  Second, we must say that in dreams or visions symbols become realities...

..It would be absurd to claim any sort of certainty for the suggestions we have advanced.  We cannot be sure what paths of association Christ's visionary thoughts, as St Matthew represents them, follow out.  Yet our guesses are not valueless.  They were the sort of lines along which a devout Jewish imagination ran; and the exercise of working out probable tracks and junctions in the movement of such a mind puts us in sympathy with the author we are trying to understand..  Chapter IV








Monday, August 25, 2014

NT Wright and CS Lewis on pointing your dog to something: sign>signified>signpost>sacrament

photo
The whole video here by NT Wright is worth watching.

He so reminds me of C.S. Lewis with his series of apt metaphors.  Here are three


  • Think if I offered you a drivers license, claiming  i had authority to issue it
  • -Think if someone destroyed all bank records and evidence of any debt you owe? 
  • Think what would happen if you pointed at something, hoping for your dog to look at it?
  But let's focus on  the third (4:13ff) here:



 The telling and true-to-life illustration of pointing your dog towards something;
and the temple being a signpost pointing to something (Someone) else is so good.

Try it on your dog, I double dog dare you(:

He may have clarified this in the longer video of which this is an excerpt, but it's likely Wright is  actually drawing (as he often acknowledges) on C.S. Lewis:

The sunlight in a picture is therefore not related to real sunlight simply as written words are to spoken.  It is a sign but something more than a sign, because in it the thing signified is  really in a certain mode present. If I had to name the relation I should call it not symbolical but sacramental..
..I have tried to stress throughout the inevitableness of the error made about every transposition by one who approaches it from the lower medium only..You will have noticed that most dogs cannot understand pointing. You point to a bit of food on the floor; the dog, instead of looking at the floor, sniffs at your finger. A finger is a finger to him, and that is all. 
-"Transposition," from The Weight of Glory...someone has uploaded the whole essay here)

--
Related:

When did dogs figure out pointing?

Dog Breeds: pointing




-"

Friday, August 15, 2014

The Threshing Floor of Araunah

The Threshing Floor of Araunah 
by Richard Beck

Waetjen on " the divine exit from the Holy of Holies"

    Now at the end of his life, at the moment of his physical death, the curtain of the sanctuary is torn apart, and God comes forth again. Jesus’ earlier symbolic act of invalidating the temple institution is consummated by the divine exit from the Holy of Holies. Consequently the architectonic center of Judaism is canceled. The old order, which is represented by the temple, its sacrifices and its hierocracy, is abolished. Jerusalem is no longer the navel of the world where heaven and earth are united and where God’s presence is uniquely experienced. Heaven and earth have been reconciled cosmically and universally. Accordingly, the binary opposition between the sacred and the secular, constituted by the temple as the axis mundi of Judaism, is dissolved. Both are reunited, and the entire creation once again becomes ambiguously sacred and profane. Henceforth no geographical, religious, social, sexual, or racial lines can be drawn to separate the clean from the unclean, good from evil,  life from death. God’s presence will be experienced everywhere or anywhere without the necessity of atoning sacrifices or a mediating priesthood. God’s presence will be experienced wherever the eschatological reality of the New Humanity that Jesus incarnated throughout his ministry is encountered.Herman C. Waetjen, A Reordering of Power a Socio-Political Reading of Mark’s Gospel (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1989)

Ched Myers on the temple: Who Would Jesus Whip?



--




  1. A House For All Peoples? - Ched Myers | Sojourners ...

    sojo.net/magazine/2006/04/house-all-peoples
    Sojourners
    This is later reiterated in the teaching of Jesus of Nazareth: “I was a stranger and ... the reconstruction of the temple (circa 515 BCE) and the time of Nehemiah (circa .... Ched Myers, for many years a worker on immigrant rights issues, lived and ...
  2. who would jesus whip? the temple cleansing episode | life ...

    liferemixed.net/2011/06/22/who-would-jesus-whip/
    Jun 22, 2011 - Was Jesus being violent when he cleansed the temple? ... was a great affirmation of your more recent post citing Ched Myers on June 16.






  3. Our God is Undocumented: Biblical Reflections on the New ...

    www.chedmyers.org/.../Our%20God%20is%20Undocumented%20-%20...
    Jun 3, 2007 - By Ched Myers. [A talk given on .... Jesus for whom there was no room at the inn, and the ... indicates that it was this “action” in the Temple that.

  4. THE CLEANSING OF THE TEMPLE - Academia.edu

    www.academia.edu/.../THE_CLEANSING_OF_THE_TE...
    Academia.edu
    While there are many interpretations of the meaning behind Jesus' actions, there .... (11:20-25) A. Jesus returns to the temple (11:27) 9 Ched Myers, Binding the ...

Wednesday, July 09, 2014

great men from the past paying a time travel visit to institutions that were named after them..

Meme by Quaid Ens, see Quaid Approved Memes
Douglas Wilson:
...I have sometimes entertained myself with thoughts of great men from the past paying a time travel visit to institutions that were named after them. Many of these thought experiments end with furniture scattered around waiting rooms, broken glass, and police sirens in the background. And if you doubt that there could be actual mayhem — for that doesn’t sound as pious as we would like — reflect on what happened when Jesus, the name of God, showed up at the place where God made his name to dwell (Deuteronomy 12:11). First he made a whip, and then he made a commotion.  link

Tuesday, July 08, 2014

Levites from other nations?

Great catch from Pasha:

The Lord revealed some down right controversial things to Isaiah. So controversial in fact that it got him sawed in half. How about this excerpt from chapter 66.


And they will bring all your brothers, from all the nations, to my holy mountain in Jerusalem.... And I will select some of them also to be priests and Levites," says the LORD.


Levites from other nations? How can that even be possible. Aren't they supposed to be from the tribe of Levi. It just goes to show how serious the Lord is about people from all nations worshiping him in his kingdom is.  link

Monday, July 07, 2014

"Matthew's Temple Tax as Ransom: Interpretation of the Second Passion Prediction"by Rob Haskell

ABSTRACT

This paper expands on an idea mentioned by William Thompson in his study
Matthew’s Advice to a Divided Community, namely, that Matthew intended the temple
tax pericope (17:24-27) to be read with the second passion prediction (17:22-23) and so
to function as an interpretation of the death of Jesus. As such this pericope suggests that
Jesus’ death is a replacement for the temple tax and the sacrifices that it funded.
Thompson’s observations were brief and have not been incorporated into subsequent
scholarly discussion of this passage, but it is my contention that this is an extremely
fruitful approach and that there are several reasons for adopting it which go beyond those
noted by Thompson.
I present the following evidence. First, in the first century the temple tax was seen
as a “ransom for life” based on Exodus 30:11-16 and was thought to give its payer
representation in the sacrifices it funded. Second, various exegetical details, including the
parallel introductions of the second passion prediction and the temple tax pericope, and
the use of ἀ in 17:27, seem to point in this direction. Third, a similar pattern, also
noted by Thompson, can be discerned in Matthew’s two other passion predictions. Each
one is followed by a pericope that mentions ransom. The entire pattern climaxes in 20:28
where Jesus is said to give his live as a ransom for many. Finally, this approach also helps
explain the otherwise puzzling use of the phrase “the kings of the earth,” from Psalm 2:2,
in 17:26. I argue that this phrase refers to the chief priests of the Jerusalem Temple, thus
bringing the pericope into the thematic stream of Jesus’ impending death.

Full paper here

Tuesday, July 01, 2014

Jesus as a Led Zeppelin Tank Man in the temple..

Good post by Andrew Perriman on Jesus' temple tantrum here; especially on the Scriptures Jesus brings to the table  (literally!  He overturns the tables, and turns over the three Scriptures he cites) in this text.

His connection to the "Tank Man" of Tiananmen Square made me think: "Is Jesus more Tank Man or Banner Man?"..

His concluding paragraph made me  sing this.

Tuesday, June 17, 2014

does Jesus' whip reach back to Mishnah and Day of Atonement?

Buck Eschaton comments:
Just a note regarding Jesus cleansing the Temple with a whip. In the Mishnah, I believe, it instructs the High Priest, that during the Day Atonement he should spread the blood around the temple in a whip-like motion. The cleansing of the Temple thus] represented the cleansing of the earth, healing the damage that had been done.  link

He is is correct about the Mishnah reference (link).
See also Babylonian Tractate on Day of Atonement here .

How far, though, can we apply this to Jesus' use of a whip in the temple cleansing?