Welcome! You have accidentally reached the blog of a heteroclite follower of Jesus: dave wainscott. I'm
"pushing toward the unobvious" as I post thinkings/linkings
re: Scripture, church and culture. Hot topics include: temple tantrums, time travel, sexuality/spirituality, U2kklesia, role of the pastor, God-haunted music/art..and subversive videos like these.
Ironically (or not), the album became the genesis (pun intended) of the revolutionary "gated drum" sound which eventually went hugely viral with the iconic and accidental (in both senses of the term) "In the Air Tonight" drum fill on Phil Collins' first solo album.
Having worked previously with Eno (the "Enossification" effects on Genesis' "Lamb Lies Down on Broadway" album), Gabriel may well have been inspired by Eno's "oblique strategies" of forbidding certain instruments or chords in songs, to see what unsolicited creativity would happen in the dare of the discipline (see "Oblique Strategies")
What have you learned about/from forcing yourself to work within certain structures and limits? How has limiting the palette opened up liminal and larger space..and thin places?
As a heteroclite theologian who is ever Pushing Toward The Unobvious..
I also wonder/wander if in works of art pondering the divine, what unique anointing there is in limiting the palette and downsizing the arsenal/toolbox of words and wineskins.
I wonder how Ed's being a Zen practioner shapes the form and content of his art?
What might I learn about God, life and myself if I write/voice my theologizing (laments, midrash and "reversed thunder") prayers in Haiku?
Here is a Haiku (a HAIKU TRILOGY, no less, I like 3s) from late Methodist pastor Cynthia Langston Kirk , and a poem from Ed which pique my holy curiosity..
Many mornings in the weeks and months after my wife Sonya died, the sun shining through the window would wake me up, For the first few moments finding my consciousness, I was content: becoming oriented to the opportunities of a new day.
Then, inevitably, I remembered.
Oh, she's dead.
Wait, really? Was it just a dream?
"Oh, #*#!, it's really true!," I actually said aloud more than once.
They joke there are two types of people:
those who say "Good morning, Lord!" and those who say "Good Lord, it's morning!"
On most days I was both; finding a way for both to coexist in the same space, soul and morning/mourning.
But I am getting ahead of myself..
---
Seven years later, I woke up I woke and oriented myself to the fact that it was day.
The "Oh, #!@$! , it's real" morning surprises were no longer a regular occurrence. I am not the same since she left; but I am happily remarried
I grabbed my phone, ostensibly to check the time or secure a morning devotion, but more likely to check Facebook...and found notification of a new U2 song.
"Song for Hal," it said. As I began playing it, the soundscapes escaped ; some classic and exciting new Edge "swirling epiphanies" emerged..
The vocals began. They were good, but something wasn't quite right; not quote Bono. Had I been fooled by AI?
No, it was the Edge on lead vocals..
Unlike most U2 releases of the past, I was not prepared for a new song by my favorite band. I had usually read the lyrics and maybe even reviews/forum comments..
But this time I had no idea what the song was bout, let alone who the hal Hal was. Let alone that it was about.
Full immersion
And as the morning light Stretches out across the floor
Can't believe it's another day And life goes on like it did before
What? Were Bono and Edge reading my memory?
My mail and my mind?
It wouldn't be the first time.
--
To switch gears to the task at hand..
--
To quote a book title that can be well-applied to personal journey/spiritual life: the "What to Expect While You are Expecting " principle is relevant here.
Two, I was not even expecting to expect two EPs ("Days of Ash" and "Easter Lilly"),
let alone one;
let alone two great ones;
from U2 this year before the full-blown album later this year.
Two albums (three releases) in their 50th year? And two (three?) that follow the liturgical calendar?
God is in the house. The lads are pregnant.
I consider the two surprise EPs as one whole; two sides of an album/coin/life posture. The band have spoken clearly about the first volume being more angry, political.. and lament-laden, and the sequel more personal and hope-filled .......as we are expectant of the "defiant joy" of the album to come,
To be expectant in U2 fandom is also to expect anxiety that the album this fall won't live up to these EPs. The worst fear is they partly lose the plot/baby. Me genoito, I hope Jacknife Lee is right!
I like these two EPs both very much ; especially the second, so I am writing about it today..
I won't write much, as I can't add much to...but can amen much to.... these great reviews that I recommend and will reference:
I am so sad that Steve Harmon's book had to go to press without a chapter on Easter Lilly!
I will only major on three songs here, as I have observations, connections and questions.
It seems unpardonable to not write about the other three songs, as they form an amazing grace sound ; the death and resurrection trilogy. Don't get me started on "Scars," which may well be in my top five U2 songs already (Not bad for a late career E.P.)
But I want to start by calling attention to two intriguing structural observations on the EP as a whole (as an artwork); and then give a few heteroclitic and maybe unobvious comments and questions on each song.
1) An inclusio of sunrise language; especially being surprised by the sunrise. Cheesy as it might be if another band adopted it , it is clear that in the U2 dictionary, "sun" is often code/standing in for Son (Jesus). Drawing the fish in the sand, Here the focus on sunrise/Sonrise : fitting for an EP with Easter in the title.
Here is that inclusio:
-First song "Song for Hal".
And as the morning light Stretches out across the floor
Can't believe it's another day And life goes on like it did before
-Last song: "COEXIST (I Will Bless The Lord At All Times?)
Every night we hope and pray for a new day to rise Every morning when the sun shows up, it's still a surprise
And, as often with inclusios (and chiasms) , the term often shows up in themiddle (more or less) of the narrative. Thus, in the song "Easter Parade,'
Every night we hope and pray for a new day to rise Every morning when the sun shows up, it's still a surprise
2) An inclusio of the word/image "parade.'
First song "Song for Hal"
Then in "COEXIST (I Will Bless The Lord At All Times?) the ;last song:
Changes, these changes Will rain on this parade
Wherever the strange is on parade Wherever the music is made You'll be there
=
in "Easter Parade,' of course, the whole song is the parade.
Changes, these changes Will rain on this parade Changes, these changes I am not afraid
Then in "/COEXIST (I Will Bless The Lord At All Times?)
Changes, these changes Will rain on this parade
I love how PJ PJ DeGenaro matter of factly felt this, nd took the liberty to make the inclusio explicit , amd import the word "Easter" when the parade shows up in "Coexist". Yes!
'The changes will rain on our (Easter) parade" (link)
And, as often with inclusios (and chiasms) , the term often shows up in themiddle (more or less) of the narrative. Thus, in the song "Easter Parade,' of course, the whole song is the parade.
What is "Easter Lilly" about? The surprising and subversive sunrise and prophetic and poignant parade that springs forth from death.
On the avenue, Fifth Avenue The photographers will snap us And you'll find that you're in the rotogravure Oh, I could write a sonnet about your Easter bonnet And of the guy I'm taking to the Easter parade
Inclusio and chiasm are, with or without the writer being fully aware of embedding these structures, reveal quite a lot about the overall meaning/message of a work. Don't get me started on Bible inclusio and chiasm. But I could get started up here or here, LOL,. As Mick Jagger sang...
Alos, I note that every song (or almost every song on "Easter Lilly" ends with an outro or coda/last section.. that changes gears. I am sure there is a term for this in musical composition/theory. Instead of fadeout or repetition/reprise of a chorus, or an improv/scat/glossolalia/Bongolese ending (As in "Still Haven't Found".. a whole new thematic world opens up.
My favorite example here is "In a Life" ...which nods to a Peter Gabriel lyric (see 40:08 in video here to learn that is (in part) about God).. And how about the final note of "Coexist." There are different theories about what it means: a nod to the ending of the "Zooropa" album, an exclamation point on the album. a "more to come" teaser,. A requirement to say Edge played on the song...
Let's return to "Song for Hal," which now know is a response to death of the band's friend, Hal.
In a way it is my "Song for Sonya."
I often play on shuffle, but even more than other U2 releases, it would seem blasphemy to consider any other intended running order of the Easter Lilly tracks. As Bono mentioned (quoting Dalai Lama) in the book accompanying "Atomic Bomb,' "To meditate on life, start with death."
-Question for fans and followers (Edge, I know you are reading, lol): In the opening lyrics
Did you hear "Forever"? Was it playing soft and low? It's not a song you wanna hear If you're not ready to go
Is the song "Forever" a specific actual song, or just an image? Here are some internet guessed.. Many suggest it is just a symbol of the afterlife; but I am still haunted by the way it is mentioned as if an actual song
Note also a possible connection binding the two EPS. The last song on the first EP declares " "You are not alone."
Watch this..Now to he first song on the next EP (or if you consider the two as one album, the very next song!
The repetitive “I feel alone,” conflicts with the refrain “you’re not alone” in “Song For Hal.” The personal confession of aloneness is raw — can’t see the forest despite the trees sort of thing. Here is a personal song about friendship, but he feels alone. Is it an emotional disconnect that’s being alluded to? Could it be that he feels that God hasn’t been with him? Bono did find himself calling out to God during his brush with death and he didn’t hear Him -link
"IN A LIFE"
The second song, "In a :Life", per the Edge's comments in Propaganda, and per the clear content of the official music vireo, is about the friendship of the band over the year.
OK....but I don't hear that...at all.
I was already with Megan on this l even before I read her post
It is valuable to quote Megan's full comment on the song, as it radically resonated with me.
The song that follows feels like a cross between the underworld and purgatory. Strongly connected to Bono’s Stories of Surrender, it uses the London Underground as a kind of in between space. The repeated fare/coin imagery evokes Charon’s crossing or the purchase of indulgences. It begins with “I’ll meet you in the air… with the fare,” and the person is met “in the empty space that occupies your place.” The looping percussion and guitar during the Circle Line section accentuates the feeling of circling until one learns what they need for passage into the next life. These lessons are both relational and communal and include the futility of ignoring God’s instruction, ”You’re kicking the pricks,: an archaic form of goads, which references Acts 26, and the need to surrender. There is a driver on the train of this circle that notes how the “souls are in so much pain,” which possibly may be the wounded healer Christ presented in Scars. Only confession , both corporate (“when we make our bed out of war”) and personal (“I never achieved anything on my own”), breaks the loop. The song ends with grace: “A skipping stone I was thrown, the ocean floor is not my home.” and gratitude, “I only received from being shown.” and leads us to the encounter in the song that follows. link
Instead of Charon (a fantastic connection, and it reminds me not to miss potential lyrical connections to paintings, as in the Mephisto "Checkmate' painting (see this)
UNOBVIOUSLY..I thought of the Trainman in Matrix Reloaded , who lives in the subway/underground,
headquartered at "Mobil Station "(Mobil is an anagram for limbo? the writers did that on purpose) , and seems doomed to keep riding the trains in a purgatorial state . He wears multiple watches (hmm . note the song lyrics 'And when we stop the clocks stopping time )The name of the train is Loop, symbolizing a loop in time or endless cycle of limbo
And when we stop the clocks stopping time ” and jumps to the other side of the platform He is in charge of Mobil Station (Mobil is an anagram for limbo:the writers did that on purpose). The name of the train is Loop, symbolizing a loop in time or endless cycle of limbo. See ("I am a strange christian loop")
.
Driver on the train is Jesus, Megan? Yes, thank you. Again, i had somehow not seen that..
"Meet you in the air" is classically connected to the dispensational theory of the rapture I (1Thess 4:17 literally says "meeting Christ in the air" and this was I think a doctrine of Shalom, too ) that it seemed to me certain he meant that..
Bono has even written in "Ahimsa":
" I'll meet you where the sky is torn
I’ll meet you in the air
I’ll meet you before the world was born"
Anyone with conservagelical heritage knows this excahnge:
or as Bono riffs on it : "Meet you in the air..or in the underground."
Also: now i wonder..
My question: “to wake up an unforgiving son” ..
what
Does that mean to you ?
Of course the brother of prodigal son comes to mind.
The line could mean “to wake up someone who is an unforgiving son” or “to wake up as a forgiving son”...
]
On to:
"COEXIST: I Will Bless the Lord at All Times.
First a quick question. In the flurry of fan comments when the song first appeared. there was discussion about who is the "Girl Of Guadaloop" Of course, it is likely primarily the Virgin of Guadalupe.
But why her, and why does she how up here? And Pat Washington evem wondered if Girl was thjs other girl here,... who Bono would obviously admire. LOL. But her name doesn't rhyme with "book"...though neither does "Guadaloop," for that matter
This chilling song redeems or buys back some bad memories I have of the old TBN network.
Paul and Jan Crouch sometimes hosted some guests that I was interested in seeing..
But their campy creepiness often buggd me..let alone the scandals that ultimately came out.
Paul routinely opened their flagship show with an overly enthusiastic quoting /cheerleading of this same Scripture:
“I will bless the Lord at all times and His praise will continually be on my lips.”
And Bono's now bought/brought it back from me.
From now on this Scripture will be voiced by Bono and the U2 song, not the
TBN theme song
PTL!...to risk quoting another controversial televangelist show/
Finally:
One mystery : All U2 fans know what COEXIST means, and Bono's history with the motto and headband/blindfold. But what does that have to do with the song's story Why is this in the title and nowhere in the lyric?
Ken Penner has as a suggested answer:
The anchor of the song is a vow seized from King David in duress, a stubborn promise to bless the Lord at all times, quoting verbatim “I will bless the LORD at all times: his praise shall continually be in my mouth” (Psalm 34:1, KJV). This is praise spoken through gritted teeth, and the COEXIST title frames that struggle with what Bono called a “powerful symbol of tolerance,” an attempt to imagine common ground when human rights feel under siege in the aftermath of 9/11. -Ken Penner
But Brian Zahnd has an additional (final?) answer, and
he may well be right! I haven't seen anyone suggest this. but I love the "obvious unobvious" . Someone ask Bono!
See 16:05 to 20:05 in Zahnd's sermon above.The take home?:
"Can the commitment to bless the Lord at all times COEXIST with the reality of a worldwhere children are killed by down strikes?"
Or dead men don't wake up? Isn't the ruthless and refreshing honesty of dozens of U2 songs that faith and doubt /grief an joy and coexist ? (see "Bono audio: God at the 9" Nails Gig")
"
"Bono sings laments and yearnings as willingly as he sings resolve, peace and joy.'
Or as Walter Brueggemann, whom Bono quotes and references, has said,. the gospel and a prophet, and :prophetic imagination" is all about the coexistent paradox of grief and amazement?
Amazing Grief, how sweet the sound of this graced E.P.
--
"Oh #@! It's real!" ..but God is good..
all the time..
and at all times.
I am learning to creatively coexist in the midst, milieux and mess of that.
"The song is about the search for God and like the film, it’s looking for a fresh slant on spirituality, in this case with a high level of doubt.' Peter Gabriel
Why don't You show yourself
Why don't You show yourself
Why don't You show yourself
Was that something whispering in the leaves
I can smell Your breath within a breeze
Something lying at your feet
Making you alive more complete
And we rely on
All that's forgotten
With the way that destiny
Can pull You down
So we are searching
Searching for You
And we go hunting
Hunting for You
And in this empty space
In this hollow place
Why don't You show yourself
Why don't You show yourself
Life and death
The strong and the weak
The only thing you think about
Is exactly what you seek
We look for footprints
We look for clear signs
Look for any presence
That we can find
And still we're searching
Searching for You
And we go hunting
Hunting for You
And in this flesh and bones
In this man's heart
Why don't you show yourself
Why don't you show yourself
Hard to find You
Harder to see
The way you're talking
And the way you ' re set to be
In You I find me
Why don't you show yourself
And we go hunting
Hunting for you
And we we're hunting
Hunting round this world
And in this wounded place
Why don't you show your face
Why don't you show yourself
Why don't you show yourself
Why Don't You Show Yourself
-- studio version mp3 here
"I tried to pray..I'll give it a shot" (lyrics to Filter's "Captain Bligh").
I know; I'm behind the times.
Filter is a new band to me: I heard "Skinny" the other day,
and found it captivating and spiritually moving. The band is basically Richard Patrick and whoever rallies around for a given album.season.
For someome who claims to (no longer?) be a believer..I wonder if he doth prostest too much.
Pretty God-haunted.
Even though Captain Bligh is supposed to be about Patrick's leaving his former band (NIN):
to me it smells like another singer (Peter Gabriel)'s song ("Solsbury Hill") that is officially about him leaving his former band (Genesis)..but reads like a journal following a God-encounter.
Even though one album is "Anthems for the Damned," it feels like a pulling a Johnny Cash.
After shows, we stay until everyone who wants an autograph gets one. The biggest rock stars are all nice guys: Bono, Mick Jagger," he says.
Since it's agnostic Carl Sagan's birthday, I ask him how his own
agnosticism influenced the new album. As far back as Filter's first
release, Patrick has peppered his songs with jabs at organized religion,
but on The Trouble With Angels he's more direct, like he's no
longer pulling his punches. "Did you hear the one about heaven? There's a
guy that's running the sky," he sings on the title track.
"Science
is awesome," he says, displaying an almost childlike enthusiasm for the
natural world that's infectious when you're in his presence. "I can see
beauty in the rings of Saturn. Why does there have to be a reason for
everything?" He's a non-believer in religion and a believer in science.
He launches into a lengthy diatribe on the theory of evolution, ending
with, "How much more proof do you need?"
His wife is a Christian.
"She's moderate, she prays at night," Patrick says. If everyone was like
his wife, he says, he wouldn't have as much of a problem with religion;
it's the fanatics that get under his skin. link
it was only one hour ago it was all so different then there's nothing yet has really sunk in looks like it always did this flesh and bone it's just the way that you would tied in now there's no-one home i grieve for you you leave me 'so hard to move on still loving what's gone they say life carries on carries on and on and on and on the news that truly shocks is the empty empty page while the final rattle rocks its empty empty cage and i can't handle this i grieve for you you leave me let it out and move on missing what's gone they say life carries on they say life carries on and on and on life carries on in the people i meet in everyone that's out on the street in all the dogs and cats in the flies and rats in the rot and the rust in the ashes and the dust life carries on and on and on and on life carries on and on and on it's just the car that we ride in a home we reside in the face that we hide in the way we are tied in and life carries on and on and on and on life carries on and on and on did I dream this belief? or did i believe this dream? now i can find relief i grieve
I hate to disagree with
Peter Gabriel:
"I Grieve" was conceived after Gabriel looked over his catalogue of music as if it were a catalogue of emotional tools. He found one major missing tool to be one to cope with death and therefore "I Grieve" was born. "I Grieve" wiki (hear him say this on the 9/11 video below)
I think Gabriel's canon/cannon (including his songs with Genesis ) is full of tools to help him/us grieve/lament/deal with death.. ("With only one colour, dead" etc etc) One of my favorites (though not officially about death, but death of a relationship):
This old familiar craving/I've been here before/ this way of behaving/Don't know who the hell I'm saving anymore/Let it pass let it go let it leave/From the deepest place I grieve/This time I believe.... Peter Gabriel - Love to be loved from Al Ex on Vimeo.
Also, note..he quoted himself (from the song above) to the song at hand ("I Grieve").
Of course, any song dealing with grief/death is transferrable to new contexts,concerts, and Sitz Im Leben situations ("U2's "Sunday Bloody Sunday is a classic example; see this):
Gabriel performed the song live on the television show "Larry King Weekend" on the one-year anniversary of 9/11, during which Gabriel said that his two daughters were living in New York City on 9/11 and he could not contact them for a while, and that this song was for people who didn't hear anything from their
relatives then.[8] It was not, however, written specifically for 9/11, having appeared on the City of Angels soundtrack in 1998 (in an earlier version) and