Showing posts with label Ellul. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ellul. Show all posts

Thursday, January 29, 2015

"the city devours": Zombie Eucharist

pic credit
Matthew Tan:
Many often talk about cities as being soul destroying, whether it is in reference to a cultural deadening borne from the replacement of theatres, independent stores and galleries with consumerised counterparts (especially via commercial chains), or in reference to the decaying (often brutalist) architecture. 
A similar insight can be found in the sociologist Jacques Ellul's The Meaning of the City, in which Ellul warned his readers about cities being more than just boring architecture or sites of waste. For Ellul, cities are parasites. More specifically, Ellul compares them to vampires as they 


prey on the true living creation [...] The city is dead, made of dead things for dead people [...] the city devours men

Writing thirty years later, Ward made an explicit reference to this passage and extended the analysis to give it a Eucharistic inflection. In his Cities of God, Ward spoke of vampires as working in an anti-Eucharistic fashion. Rather than giving blood for the life of the world, the vampire takes blood from the world and and ends life to sustain an already dead being. "Vampire stories," Ward argues "are Eucharistic stories played out negatively. A similar observation could be said of the zombie genre...continued here

On a related note:

Monday, November 18, 2013

Ellul on SK: noise, Godsong and hearing through silence


Ellul,  The Humiliation of the Word, from Chapter 5: The Religious Conflict Between Image and Word


The present humiliation of the word is only the current version of a permanent reality: people detest the fundamental word, which nevertheless establishes them as human beings. As can easily be imagined, this is the central drama of every individual; it is another aspect of the death instinct. It is the key to the suicide wish and the real truth concerning the radical separation in a person’s heart. It explains his explosion when he denies what he has believed.

With brilliant insight, Kierkegaard has seen this better than anyone. (For this analysis I return to the first part of the previously cited book by Viallaneix, Kierkeguard et la Parole de Dieu. In this section, Viallaneix has thrown light on the degradation of the word especially well. But one should read her entire book.) Viallaneix has gathered his thoughts on the subject under the title "Captive Words," because all human words are overpowered by dissonance. And among these captive words can be discerned the forgotten word, which is the word of creation, the frozen word of philosophy, and the poetic word that is sung. We are made to live these words, but they have become incomprehensible to us when spoken; they lead to misunderstanding. The entire creation speaks, but instead of listening to this word, we want to see the secret of this creation. We want to see, and this leads to scientific demands. The words of creation, the world’s song, and the echo of Nature become confused words. According to Kierkegaard, God speaks this way, and creation tells of its creator. But we grasp only an echo that is actually a parody or a counterfeit of the creative word, which as human beings we can no longer hear because of our rupture with God. Nature "promises harmony and speaks to us of a divine message; but it gives us only incomprehensible signs which have to be interpreted." This is made essentially impossible by parasites on the wavelength and by interference, which prevent us from understanding this first indication of a possible word. These "noises of life" usher in all sorts of dissonance and drown out the intelligible word.

Kierkegaard then shows with prophetic vigor the kind of noise we experience today, whose importance he had discerned: the racket of the city, of speed, of politics and revolution, the racket of the press and of advertising, "urban chattering and gossip, like a snowy whirlwind" -- all this (and what would he say in our day!) utterly suffocates the word. "The problem with the daily newspaper is that it is expressly designed to glorify the present moment"; "nonsense, gossip, foolishness . . . these things are caricatures of the word; they transform it into impious chattering, yack-yack, so that the content of the message is scattered by senseless noises." "The retransmission of objective information is a parody of the communication of knowledge.,’ Faced with this mockery of language, Kierkegaard’s only possible response is "the catharsis of silence." Silence these noises and fall silent oneself. Nothing but silence can allow a person to hear a word of truth again as it traces its path through the echoes of nature.

Instead, people attach themselves to these noises. Thus they enter into another domain of the captive or betrayed word: the frozen word of philosophy, which claims to be listening for the ideal. Here again Kierkegaard appears to be amazingly ahead of his time, as he poses the basic question of the relationship between word and language. But he situates the question in its relationship to the rupture between human beings and God, between the word of human beings and God’s. "For the divine code, Nature’s code, and the human code are different. It follows that a person who tries to understand God’s message by himself is condemned to replace it with another message, from another language, which is human language." "The person puzzled by the jumble of words that creation whispers around him refers them to a linguistic system which he hopes will be able to tell him these words’ meaning.... The word is developed into a language; that is, it finds itself dialectically united to a language."

Kierkegaard proposes an observation (that for his time is astonishing) in which "the basic error in modern times is just this: being continually concerned with what one needs to communicate, rather than with the nature of communication." But after profoundly studying language as an ideal object, he discovers what we thought we had just recently discovered (Viallaneix deserves the credit for showing the extent to which Kierkegaard was ahead of us here!): that "each element of society has an element of discourse that corresponds to it. Both perform a function -- one in life and the other in language. The workings between these elements take on the same form. In short, there is an isomorphism in the human universe and the universe of discourse. Based on this fact, a human typology can be conceived based on an analogy with the study of language."

Language expresses what is deepest in a person, so that it should be clear and coherent. But its reality is quite different: confusion and gibberish. Human discourse has submerged us in misunderstanding and noncommunication, because language has triumphed completely over the word (Kierkegaard gives an extraordinary demonstration of this). So "language and thought are swallowed up by the same chaos." Once again, Kierkegaard connects this contemporary perversion with our inability to hear the Word of God. We substitute our own approach: logic, for example, or philosophical speculation, etc. It is pointless to fill in these outlines, which are found in Viallaneix’s book....LINK, full book

Thursday, November 14, 2013

Jacques Ellul, Lewis Mumford and C.S. Lewis: magic and technique

I love these three thinkers...they should have toured together.
Michael Sacasas quotes them here in a post on Technology and Magic


Ellul:
“Magic developed along with other techniques as an expression of man’s will to obtain certain results of a spiritual order. To attain them, man made use of an aggregate of rites, formulas, and procedures which, once established, do not vary. Strict adherence to form is one of he characteristics of magic: forms and rituals, masks whichever vary, the same kind of prayer wheels, the same ingredients for mystical drugs, for formulae for divination, and so on...

Every magical means, in the eyes of the person who uses it, is the most efficient one. In the spiritual realm, magic displays all the characteristics of a technique. It is a mediator between man and ‘the higher powers,’ just as other techniques mediate between man and matter. It leads to efficacy because it subordinates the power of the gods to men, and it secures a predetermined result. It affirms human power in that it seeks to subordinate the gods to men, just as technique serves to cause nature to obey.”

Mumford :
Thus although capitalism and technics must be clearly distinguished at every stage, one conditioned the other and reacted upon it.”

“It was because of certain traits in private capitalism that the machine — which was a neutral agent — has often seemed, and in fact has sometimes been, a malicious element in society, careless of human life, indifferent to human interests.  The machine has suffered for the sins of capitalism; contrariwise, capitalism has often taken credit for the virtues of the machine.”

“… indeed, the necessity to promote continual changes and improvements, which has been characteristic of capitalism, introduced an element of instability into technics and kept society from assimilating its mechanical improvements and integrating them in an appropriate social pattern.”

“Between fantasy and exact knowledge, between drama and technology, there is an intermediate station: that of magic. It was in magic that the general conquest of the external environment was decisively instituted.”

“In sum, magic turned men’s minds to the external world: it suggested the need of manipulating it: it helped create the tools for successfully achieving this, and it sharpened observation as to the results.”

“As children’s play anticipates crudely adult life, so did magic anticipate modern science and technology …”

“… magic was the bridge that united fantasy with technology: the dream of power with the engines of fulfillment.”


 Lewis:

I have described as a `magician’s bargain’ that process whereby man surrenders object after object, and finally himself, to Nature in return for power. And I meant what I said. The fact that the scientist has succeeded where the magician failed has put such a wide contrast between them in popular thought that the real story of the birth of Science is misunderstood. You will even find people who write about the sixteenth century as if Magic were a medieval survival and Science the new thing that came in to sweep it away. Those who have studied the period know better. There was very little magic in the Middle Ages: the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries are the high noon of magic. The serious magical endeavour and the serious scientific endeavour are twins: one was sickly and died, the other strong and throve. But they were twins. They were born of the same impulse. I allow that some (certainly not all) of the early scientists were actuated by a pure love of knowledge. But if we consider the temper of that age as a whole we can discern the impulse of which I speak.

There is something which unites magic and applied science while separating both from the wisdom of earlier ages. For the wise men of old the cardinal problem had been how to conform the soul to reality, and the solution had been knowledge, self-discipline, and virtue. For magic and applied science alike the problem is how to subdue reality to the wishes of men: the solution is a technique ….

Wednesday, October 23, 2013

"How Jacques Ellul Reads the Bible:Keeping the balance between the forest and trees" by Vernard Eller

Eller:
Voices in our midst are calling for some sort of new biblical hermeneutic. Most insistent among them, perhaps, are those of Brevard S. Childs (Biblical Theology in Crisis) and James D. Smart (The Strange Silence of the Bible in the Church). The primary complaint seems to be that regnant methods of interpretation simply are not communicating biblical truth in a way that is moving or meaningful to most believers.
The one who has come closest to meeting the challenge is, I think, Jacques Ellul, the noted French sociologist-theologian. He has not devised, described or proposed a new hermeneutic; or if he has, he has done so only in the form of scattered, offhand comments. He has done something better; he has produced some striking biblical studies. And any hermeneutic ought to be judged by its fruit rather than its ..Full article here

Tuesday, October 09, 2012

social sciences as subdivisions of theology/Christianity as a branch of physics



"To put it plainly,
         the so-called social sciences are
                          subdivisions of moral theology."
                      -Neil Postman, complete essay here

"If my thesis is correct..
          Christianity will become 
                          a branch of physics."
                        -Frank Tipler, here

Friday, August 12, 2011

Saturday, November 27, 2010

Ellul: The Humiliation of the Word

INTRO to The Humiliation of the Word  below, full book here

Saturday, August 21, 2010

Ellul: every moment of life= apocalyptic

."..as Christians, it is essential to understand that every moment of man's life is not historic, but apocalyptic."
-Ellul, "The Presence of the Kingdom," p.23
-------------------

Related:

We apparently have the word “apocalypse“ all wrong. In its root meaning, it’s not about destruction or fortune telling; It’s about revealing; It’s what James Joyce calls an epiphany-the moment you realize your so-called love for the young lady, all your professions, all your dreams, and all your efforts to get her to notice you were the exercise of an unkind and obssesive vanity…The real world, within which you’ve lived and moved and had your being, has unveiled itself. It’s starting to come to you. You aren’t who you made yourself out to be. An apocalypse
has occurred, or a revelation, if you prefer…Apocalyptic maximizes the reality of human suffering and folly before daring a word of hope. The hope has nowhere else to happen but the valley of the shadow of death. Is it any surprise that we often won’t know it when we see it?

-David Dark, “Everyday Apocalypse: The Sacred Revealed in Radiohead, The Simpsons and Other Pop Culture Icons”, p.10
--

end times as creation events

Monday, March 01, 2010

casting shadows on the city

The Clash once said "the city casts a shadow,"

....but our calling and vocation is to cast a shadow of Kingdom blessing/presence/influence on the
cities we are embedded in, and "church" in.

Here I am pictured, attempting to so do in my city (No, it's not trick photography or photoshop) contemplating
Ellul,
Beueggaman,
and Wink's words on cityshaping.
(see that serious theological look on my face?).

Maybe i need to be more like itinerant pastor Paul Hewson, who blesses and shadows the different cities he ministers in..even having a research assistant fill him in on the unique spiritual aspects of each city he visits, a kind of spiritual mapping, so he can be more effective. (When he finally ministers in our fair city of Fresno, he might want to read this)

Related:

Here's a good stretch:
RevKev was preaching...watch the clip right here (and whole hot sermon here) in Kansas City recently, and mentioned....in passing, partly joking...that so far, God hadn't healed anyone through his shadow..a la Acts 5:15.

Sequel: Hear Shawn Spiess (video below..somewhere, I can't find exact time cue..so Shawn, could you post story below in the blog comments) tell you about what happened an hour later!
(Bonus!: a great devotional by Raymond Jones also in same clip.. at 32:54ff), I will be using this message in my preaching class)



Cast shadows.



So I'm standing at the gates of the west
I burn money at the lights of the sign
The city casts a shadow of the perfect crime
I'm standing at the gates of the east
I take my pulse and the pulse of my friend
The city casts a shadow, will I see you again?

,,Ah say i know somewhere back'n'forth in time
Out on the dustbowls, deep in the roulette mine
Or in a ghetto cellar only yesterday
There's a move into the future for the USA.

I hear them crying
Eastside Jimmy and Southside Sue
Both said they needed something new

Standing at the gates of the west
In the shadow again
I'm standing at the gates of the west
In the shadow again
-The Clash

Saturday, August 15, 2009

"The system is now the god that makes us mad"


A thirty-year old book that is quite timely today:

"Our speed is constantly increasing, and it does not matter where we are going. We are caught up in the madness and hubris of the dance of death: the important thing is the dance, the Saturnalia, the Bacchanalia, the Lupercalia. We are no longer worried about what will emerge from it or about the void it points to. We are content to die of dancing. Our generation is not even capable of cynicism, it take a kind of terrible greatness to say, “After me, the deluge.” No one says that today; on the contrary, everyone is glutted with promises and regards the mad dance as a way to authentic renewal. Yet there is no goal, nothing transcendent, no value to light the way; the movement is enough.

The nihilistic revolution has succeeded. Today’s political activists who still claim to be revolutionaries have nothing to put in nihilism’s place. Movement for movement’s sake, thorough study for study’s sake, the revolution for the revolution’s sake: that, they say, is the only way to escape the system. It is a remarkable thing, however, that this system renders mad not only those who are part of it but those who reject it as well. The system is now the god that makes us mad, but it is a god we have created with our won minds...

..Fragmentary theater and deciphered Moliere, poetry without words and music that is sheer noise, destructured language, Lacan, Derrida, and all their second-rate imitators who think that absolute incomprehensibility offers a way out, when in fact we have shut the door on all possibilities and hopes, and have sunk into a resignation that knows no future..



..The West has always claimed to be on the side of David against Goliath, and it continues to make this claim. The difficulty is that the West is now a Goliath, one of the might of the earth, yet it cannot but still judge itself according to its old values"
-Ellul, "The Betrayal of the West"

Tuesday, July 14, 2009

U2 can pastor the city

"the city's alight/ 
With lovers and lies/
Oh, the city's afire, a passionate flame/
It knows me by name ...surrender!"


Cities in Scripture (see Ellul) are both satanic and Spirited, harshly human and hugely holy.

Every city (including ours) is called and destined to be a city of blinding lights.
Sometimes it takes prophetic guests to plug in the lights, that the redemptive gift of the city can be spotlighted and spotted

Whenever intercessors take on a road trip to take on resident principalities, I would venture that something happens that blesses the city; perhaps not as dramatically as we captured on video here, but something surely happens and Someone surely shows up every time.


On the previous tour, Pastor Bono was intentional about blessing each city; reversing the curse of each city ...especially in "Yahweh," as the lyrics would become "Yahweh..bless this city's heart..," in his benediction at the close of (Psalm) "40," (May God bless you..stay safe in the city of Chicago..watch out for the traffic.."

(Of course, anytime his security lets a girl onstage, even if he prays for her..."Yahweh, take this girl.."... he takes the risk that a non-Yahweh-oriented gal will attempt to grab some booty right in the middle of a "church song." Watch it all here, as Bono concludes as he brushes off the advances, "Yahweh's got a sense of humor, too"... I witnessed a version of this in Sacramento)

This tour, the new and evolving intro to "Beautiful Day"..some call it Celtic, some Arabic..may be taking on this place in the liturgy/line up; as you can see below in Milano. The man sings/speaks to the city, with typical worship/prophetic hand motions. On the previous tour, it was the closing of the song that sometimes served mightily this way. See this incredible clip (3:33ff) ".rise up, with wings like eagles..Chicago!...Higher, higher than the Hancock Tower." It feels like we are eavesdropping on a Call rally,or Pentecostal prayer meeting.

 I shared a sunrise in 1998 at a monument/"high place" overlooking Asuncion, Paraguay, with local believers praying blessing over the city below.
All I can say is it was the same vibe..It's just that U2 are planting the monument/cathedral/claw/tabernacle smack in the middle of each city's stadium/heart/public square.

Bono has captured, likely intentionally the biblical construct of speaking to/calling out the spirit/soul of a city..The letters in Revelation 2-3 are even addressed to the "spirit" (or "angel") of each city. And I dare to believe, somehow, that each city's spiritual atmosphere has been changed once the boys and the portathedral have moved on to the next town..

Of course, the video for "Magnificent"(watch below , and read commentary here) would seem to be a call for the city to take off the graveclothes and "look up".

It may be inspired by Christ and Christo.


Or maybe it's just a video (:


And this is only rock and roll.

"i don't believe that rock and roll can really change the world
as it spins in revolutions, spirals and turns.."
Bless my city, Lord...and start with me..
but it would help if the Irish travelling preachers could come to town with their tent revival and sacred spire.

Wednesday, April 15, 2009

Technology and Faustian Bargain


Thanks to St. Artur for the tip;

excerpt from "The Modern Philosophical Revolution:The Luminosity of Existence"

by David Walsh. Catholic University of America:




The dominant force of the modern world is instrumental reason. This is
what dictates the flow of capital within an ever more integrated global
economy, what compels our submission to the demands of the comput-
erized manipulation of data, and what subjects us to the dehumanizing
possibilities looming over the biotechnology horizon. The problem of
modernity becomes conscious in the realization of modernity as a prob-
lem. We sense a fatal entrapment from which all avenues of escape have
been foreclosed. Neither technology nor its benefits can be surrendered.
We can no more live without electricity than we can live without water,
as periodic breakdowns vividly remind us. But the costs of our access to
electrical energy are measured not just by our monthly utility bills. They
are also purchased by the dependence on which our independence has
been built. Our putative mastery of light and heat and power is purchased
at the cost of our entanglement in the vast network of grids by which we
are held fast. Power and powerlessness seem coeval moments.


Normally the irony passes without remark. It is only when the realiza-
tion of our predicament is propelled into consciousness that the contra-
diction becomes explicit. Then we cast a glance over the whole develop-
ment in which we have become entangled and bemoan the loss of our
freedom. We see that it has been an ever more comprehensive project
of liberation that has paradoxically led to our ever greater confinement.
Our subordination to the tools of our domination becomes transparent.
But in that realization we simultaneously transcend the fatality of our
situation. We can step outside of who we are and ensure that we are
never just the sum of our constituents...

All around us we see evidence of the refusal to submit to the demands
of rigorous efficiency. Nostalgia for the old, monuments of spiritual aspi-
ration, the worldwide revival of ancient religious forms, the power of
orgiastic political movements of destruction, and the protest impulse
that has driven artistic expression for more than a century all testify to
the profound ambivalence with which the success of instrumental ratio-
nality has been greeted. The incoherence of the attitude is perhaps best
captured by its defining aspiration that we rid ourselves of the dehuman-
izing consequences of a technological society while retaining all of its
benefits. Fundamentalists with their technical expertise and their spiri-
tual ignorance best embody this lethal conjunction. But it would be a
mistake to regard them as unique. The underlying attitude is pervasive.
It can be countered only by a direct confrontation of the challenge posed
by the instrumentalization of reason in the modern world. Ghosts may
spook, but they cannot illuminate our technological problematic. Only
reason can grapple with the self-imposed limitation of reason. Instrumen-
tal rationality is primarily a challenge for philosophical reflection, and
its engagement has given rise to the formidable modern philosophical
development whose scope and coherence are still not fully understood.

The task of establishing a boundary to the reign of technology is gen-
erally taken to be so great that the efforts of resistance seem at best to
be inconclusive. Pressures to bend every aspect of nature and of life to
the demands of mastery seem relentless. Nothing is sacrosanct; nothing
is immune to exploitation so long as it can be put to service. Yet this
very critique is the fruit of modern philosophical reflection. Technol-
ogy, which treats everything as a means and nothing as an end, cannot
furnish its own purpose. Instead, it undermines all final goals, refusing
to acknowledge anything as an end in itself. Everything is drawn into
its imperious grasp, and nothing is allowed to stand in judgment over
it. We are left with a technique of control that can direct everything
except itself. The project of technological mastery, our philosophical
reflection has shown, can remain rational only if it is subordinate to a
noninstrumental finality beyond itself. Man himself cannot submit to
the same instrumentality; otherwise the instrumentality ceases to have
any purpose. The problem, however, is that we seem to have struck a
Faustian bargain. We have been able to obtain this vast technical prowess
only because we have been willing to override all presumptive limits.
Neither nature nor tradition nor mystery has been allowed to hinder the
enlargement of man’s estate, which now threatens to include humanity
too within its reach."

-David Walsh, link

Wednesday, January 07, 2009

creators of uncertainty

"Christians should be troublemakers, creators of
uncertainty, agents of a dimension incompatible with society."
-Ellul

Tuesday, July 22, 2008

Ellul: "know the world more profundly"

“Day after day the wind blows away the pages of our calendars, our newspapers, and our political regimes, and we glide along the stream of time without any spiritual framework, without a memory, without a judgment, carried about by ‘all winds of doctrine’ on the current of history. Now we ought to react vigorously against this slackness — this tendency to drift. If we are to live in this world we need to know it far more profoundly; we need to rediscover the meaning of events, and the spiritual framework which our contemporaries have lost.

This will be a difficult enterprise, for it is new and humble. But "all things are ours," that is, for us as Christians, and we are able to undertake this new work....

The Bible tells us that the Christian is in the world, and that there he or she must remain. Christians have not been created in order to separate themselves from, or to live aloof from, the world. When this separation is effected, it will be God's own doing, not man's.



...If this, then, is the Christian's situation, what part should he play in the life of the world? It is only too easy to reply: to "witness," to "evangelize," or "to lead a Christian life," or again "to act according to the will of God." All this is true, of course, but so long as it is not really understood, so long as each answer is only a traditional formula, it leads us nowhere.

...What the church ought to do is to try to place all people in an economic, intellectual - yes, and also in a psychological and physical - situation, which is such that they can actually hear this gospel - that they can be sufficiently responsible to say yes or no, that they can be sufficiently alive for these words to have some meaning for them. The secret of their choice belongs to God, but they should be able to make a decision; it is up to the church to see to it that they are not placed in such conditions that they cannot react otherwise than as swine, to whom pearls have been thrown. "Cast not your pearls before swine" - but men must cease to be swine, and this is not the work of grace, it is a human work, which man is quite able to achieve, though it is terribly difficult to do; Christians in particular are called to this work, because it is possible for them to see the true situation of man better than other people, and because they can see, better than others, where all this ought to lead, and what is its aim.

When we seek to discover effective action for the church, owing to the necessity for its intervention in the world, it seems as though its first objective should be the creation of a style of life."


- Jacques Ellul, "The Presence of the Kingdom"

Tuesday, February 19, 2008

My only (day) job: subversive televangelist?

>

photo credit: Adbusters


It took "ads" like this for me to realize it..

Bottom line, my only job may be:

subverting empire...


aka adbusting...
aka hijacking the party line..
aka temple tantruming

etc.

Those of you new to these parts are saying: "huh?"
Those of you who are natives or immigrants to EPIC culture are saying: "Amen...
That's all good and huge and necessary..
but what does that have to do with the real bottom line:
the great commission (as we said in modernity)
and being missional (as we enlightened pomos say)??"

Great question.
Simple answer:

Nothing if such subversion is end in itself;
everything if I navigate it wisely and well.

Means can be end.
Medium inevitably is message.

But we must be hijacking the right train.
Or we simply "become a monster so the monster will not overtake you."

As a writer and resident "alien consigileri" for "The Bohemian Alien: an organization of raging deadbeats, incandescent
idealists an profound christians"...

As chief dreamer, cultural architect and goatherder (un, pastor) of third day fresno..

As a pusher towards the unobvious in my facilitation of classes/workshops for our non-denominational network and beyond..

I am primarily a subverter of the dominant pair of dimes.

Someone has to (gets to) tell and show folk that the Emperor is naked.
Or religious, whatever is worse.

Delicate deal to be midwife without resorting to force and forceps...

Maybe optometrist is a better metaphor, i am merely suggesting/prescribing an alternate pair of lenses..


Until one has entered the book of Revelation not through the lens of evangelical endtime spornography or God's detailed daytimer..
and seen it for what it largely is:
a parody of sorts,
a prophetic satire;
a hijacking of empire...

Until we see/hear books like Colossians as
" Colossians Remixed: Subverting the Empire"..

we will largely missing the point and prophecy.

Flush the fashion, as St Alice of Cooper once preached.

Life in the Kingdom; becoming subversively orthodox (as opposed to its evil counterfeit: orthodoxically subversive)pilgrimmage with Sermon on the Mount as hymn and hypertext should foster a walk in which we cannot not walk all over empire. With a violent peace and an unloaded gun.

This is not being radical for radical sake, but simply (in John Piper's delightful phrase applied to fasting) "a prediction of what will seem normal for those who miss the Bridegroom."

But if this grand tradition, historically incarnated well by Anabaptists, winds up being
counter cultural and nothing more, we get nothing more than koinonitis.
An ingrown toenail on the Body of Christ.
A narcissistic "Sermon in the Amount" which ironically enthrones Mammon in the name of Jesus.

Counter-culture is crucial...but the crux of it all is engaging culture on its own ground; actually going to Mars Hill; being real..As Sweet says, "We are in the world, but not of it...but not out of it either." There is nothing more sacred than a holy wordliness that stays engaged to Jesus while engaging culture.

Don't hear what I'm not saying: cheesy copy cat ads to sell Christian products, or
centerfolds in Christian mags.

Although such is a great starting point IF it is orientedd as satire and starting point,
Until the holy hijack is commandered.

And great biblical ministries like "XXXChurch.com: The #1 Christian Porn Site"...kudos to Anabaptist Fresno Pacific University for hosting this holy, wholly subversive ministry (I am
sure they took a few hits)..

And great biblical ministries like a whole class on theology of U2..kudos again to St Tim and that same university!

But we must keep pushing; asking questions like:

Where are the Christian "Vagina Monologues"??




We must enter the system/matrix belly of the beast-whale to engage it, subvert it , and come back with the keys.

Even when it means allowing prayers to Jezebel on Wheaton College campus.


Helpful hint:
realize that there is a whole breed of Christians who are artists, who:


"see their job as preparing unreceptive and probably overgrown ground to be more open to the sowers who are going to come after them..so I am not going to talk about (them)...as if their primary task ought to be pleasing people who are already Christians. And I'm also not going to spend a lot of time on questions like 'What exactly does each of them believe?" or "Have they always lived up what they say say they believe?' I think apart from simply being kind of tacky
and voyeuristic, questions like that betray a misunderstanding of how art worksm in the first place. "

These extraordinarily relevant and revealing comments could and should qualm the fears of well-meaning religious folks who tend to major in missing the point. But I fear many will miss not only the pungent point, but the untold blessing in letting art work, for Christ's sake.
Yes, there is indeed a place to ask if confessing Christians artists betray Jesus with their lifestyle; but believe it or not, "betraying how art works in the first place" can lead to nothing less than betrayal of the daring Jesus who is longing to reveal himself through startling fresh, blatantly real, and admittedly imperfect vessels (Last time I checked, that's the only kind of vessels available to him).

That the context of these comments is a specific presentation on the music and motivation of U2 (by Rev. Beth Maynard) does not at all negate the applicability of the comments to filmmakers. Art is art. Maynard continues, referencing U2's work in the 1990s which was laced with irony, and was


"marked by depicting and lamenting humanity's shadow side...including their own
shadow side....(This was) misunderstood by observers, I'm afraid particularly byLink
Christian observers, who bring to that art the naive thought that any artist who
writes about sin must be in favor of it."



It's also way past time to re-imagine images.

I have written much about this at these links ("The words/IMAGES of the prophets written/PROJECTED on the subway walls" and First Church of Binitarian Biblilolaters).

Our point here is Jerry Mander's: "There is no rejection of images."

That statement is two-edged. We cannot reject all images in the name of a commandment that we have been told flatly forbids them. After all, "Christ is the image of God" (Col 1.15); how subversively sublime and sneaky is that...very postmodern of God!


Too bad the Reformation threw baby Jesus out with the artwater.

Mander's primary context was a warning, though: we inevitably accept all

images (at least through certain media) as valid and positive.

We cannot change the fact that our culture is full of images, some idolatrous and graven.
so we might as well say "Geez!" (explanation here) and subvert as many as we can.

Mander is well aware of the irony if his never appearing on television to talk about his book "Four Arguments for the Elimination of Television." But I wonder, in retrospect, if he would reconsider.

Even Anabaptists do not have to be Luddites.
As long as we are, in Jesus words, "simultaneously as sneaky as snakes and docile as doves" (Matt 10:16).

And as long as we read and wrestle with the angel... and with tribesters such as Ellul, Lessig, Dawn and Postman.






Mander spent fifteen years in the advertising business, including five as president of one of the most celebrated agencies in the US. But with a difference: Wall Street Journal dubbed him the "Ralph Nader of advertising" In 1972, he founded the first:

nonprofit advertising agency.

!!

No, I don't mean church.


And such is not an oxymoron. Just the way it should/could/must/will be.

Such is not a non sequitur. Just simple Its sequitur; a "prediction of what will feel normal to those who miss the bridgeoom" and are awaiting the wedding banquet.

Sex sells. Even sells mission trips (see: Pepsi, Sex, Elevation...& Mission Trips That Are Actually Missional).

And is sold by them.

A hellish sack of goods.

But subverting sexualization releases mission.
And leads to reduction of seduction.

It's elevation, as the rabbis (and Bono) would have it.

Just watch out for those pastoral retreats on the beach..(ostensibly for prayer)..

and beware the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue; here I refer you to John Tschetter's important article. (sorry if the pages are stuck together).


"Advertising," Stephen Leacock suggested, "may be described as the science of arresting the human intelligence long enough to get money from it."
Which is the same thing as cheap sex.

I don't want it.

Actually I do; so do you...that's the problem ...and opportunity.


Finally..

I am meandering my way back into the bottom line I eluded/alluded to at the top:

My only job is to subvert empire in such a way that mission happens.

And if the medium is the message (see McLuhan, and the wonderful book by Mennonite pastor Shane Hipps)..

it may indeed be inevitable that I

..I can barely bring myself to say it...

appear at least once in television.

!!

Even though i have more than four arguments against my doing so.

Even though (I think) I am half-kidding.

I'm not sire I could stomach being on TBN ..

..or watch it for 24 hours (like a very brave sarcastic Lutheran)
Link
It may have to be a very 'secular' show.
maybe on cable, or a channel known for porn.

Maybe Ken can connect me with someone at Clear Channel.

Somewhere at Mars Hill, or ZOO TV maybe.

Maybe a lingerie



ad like Dylan and Switchfoot have done.
(see "God Knows Victoria's Secret (so do Switchfoot and Dylan?)"

Imagine that.

Or not.

I am not naive about the dangers inherent in converting and subverting sex and violence.

They do not immediately become sax and violins.

But they never will without wise and foolish subverters.

I'll be the holy fool on mars hill.

I'll have to go where Jesus goes..
..though he never appeared on TV..

Wait, I need to check and see if Jerry Mander has appeared on TV..or YouTube yet..

I'll be







right back.

Crap.


I guess I'll be open..
..to visiting the belly of the beast.

Geez!

For those who would caution me against such a snare, I hear you.
But for those who quote a scripture they are sure is in the Bible: "avoid even the appearance of evil," read I am in sin if I "avoid the appearance of evil" now.


Bottom line:

I have to be in the matrix to unplug others. Gotta be in the system (but not of it) to subvert it.

And since I know I only have one job..

I might as well do it.

Or at least be it..

after I read this book pictured, and

come to terms with the crazy contadictedness of all this...

Saturday, December 29, 2007

Ellul on Church and Politics

"Every stand taken by the Church on a current political problem merely demonstrates the Church's weakness as an influence on the world."
-Ellul, "False Presence of the Kingdom"
more of the book
more Ellul

Sunday, November 25, 2007

U2 devotional #7b:"like a preacher needs pain"

I was there

when Russell Willingham (lovingly) tricked a room full of pastors
into how unobvious our priorities have become
(take his brief test here).

But I am afraid I WASN'T there
when they crucified my Lord
(Excuse me, same album, different song)...

....................If I truly had,or I would be in a lot more pain over that Day's events.

Bottom line:

If I am a preacher, what do I need?

Yes, I know the answer is supposed to be

"Jesus."


Sometimes there is great value in indiscriminately tossing off raw similes in passionate prayer:




"...like a Phoenix rising needs a holy Tree..
like sweet revenge on a bitter enemy..
...like black coffee, like nicotine..
...like a preacher needs pain,

...like faith needs a doubt, like a freeway out..
...Like powder needs a spark, Like lies need the dark...
I need Your love"
-"Hawkmoon 269," U2


Uh...excuse me?! Back up that tape a bit.
Okay...I confess.

Preachers desperately need pain..

......that we might be in touch, real, and actually relate to Jesus and others.

But that's still too practical , utilitarian (What Would Ellul Do?) cheesy a reason.
Scratch that. Lies need dark.
"I cast you out, foul spirit of effectiveness!'

God didn't call me to techniques to relate to people.
He calls me to relate to Jesus,

preach from pain, preach as pain,
abdicate technique,
and watch what Holy Spirit does as I therefore
preach and practice for the first time.

Of course, a close look at the lyric reveals pain is only the pathway to what I really need.
It's a penultimate pointer to the bottom line, unltmate/intimate/only need/prayer:

"like a preacher needs pain...i need Your love.

Pain me there, Jesus.

Later note: an awesome commentary on this song here,
preachers should read at at great risk.

The studio version is a classic (first video);
They never were happy with the song live, but here (2nd video) is a rare live version.
I need it.

Monday, August 27, 2007

"I don't know if this is right, but I know it's working.."


"I don't know if this is right, but I know it's working.."



I couldn't help but bristle reading this quote from a well-meaning pastor.


It's just that one of my seminary mentors, Bob Lyon,warned us well (and armed us with Ellul, Bruggeman et al)) re: the dangers of a "means justify ends," "whatEver works" utilitarian model for ministry. Ellul even coined "inutility" as a worthy goal. And I have been greatly influenced by tribesters like McLuhan("the medium is the massage"), Nouwen (whose stark "I am deeply convinced that the Christian leader of the future is called to be completely irrelevant" is, well, completely relevant) and Hipps ("relevance is a moving target"154)


On visual technology, Tschetter () and Hipps() are to be wrestled with.

In context, the quote may be okay. But out of context it represents what any pastor is tempted to do/by default. Okay, the context:


Leadership: Beyond using visual technology to illustrate sermons, some churches are using video for the sermon. Is it just a novelty or the major trend for the future?

Stevens: We have three campuses, two of which use video. We literally gather in a theater at ten a.m., turn on the computer, and watch a DVD of a worship service—not just the sermon, but the whole service. Everything in me doesn't believe that it will work. I'm not sure I want it to work. But when you go to the service, you realize, it works!

We're experimenting with video with partners all over the world who don't have the resources to do a whole service themselves. I don't know if this is right, but I know it's working right now in a lot of places.

Hipps: You use the phrase "it works." Does that mean video preaching and worship brings people in?

Stevens: It's more than that. They're responding. They're connecting. They're growing. Link


On visual technology, Tschetter ("Sports Ilustrated Swimsuit Issue: Aphrodite, Sex and Projected Images") and Hipps('Video Cafes':TalkingHeads ,Whipped Cream, Graven Images") are to be wrestled with.