Welcome! You have accidentally reached the blog of a heteroclite follower of Jesus: dave wainscott. I'm "pushing toward the unobvious" as I post thinkings/linkings re: Scripture, church and culture. Hot topics include: temple tantrums, time travel, sexuality/spirituality, U2kklesia, role of the pastor, God-haunted music/art..and subversive videos like these.
Pages
Search Me:
Saturday, April 07, 2018
Tuesday, February 24, 2015
"on the edge of the inside of institutional religion"
Richard Rohr:
By definition, the prophet has to be on the edge of the inside of institutional religion. It's a hard position to hold, and it must be held both structurally and personally, with wisdom and grace. There are many times it would be easier to leave the system or to play the company man/woman and just go along with the game. Jesus understood this. He loved and respected his Jewish religion, yet he pushed the envelope wide open. He often healed people on the Sabbath, which was a deliberate statement against making a practice into a dogma that was higher than human need (Matthew 12:1-8). Yet he honored the same Jewish establishment by telling some he had healed to "go show yourselves to the priests" (Luke 17:14). Jesus walked the thin line of a true prophet, or what Ken Wilber so wisely names as the central principle, "transcend and include."
Friday, November 22, 2013
Rob Bell series: What is the Bible?
click here to read part 1, and then at the bottom of part 1, you can click to read part 2 (and so on)....
...or click parts below (I will add as posts are added) in reverse order..sorry, due to RSS, it will be a bit messy in formatting.
Also, some who have commented on the series:
Heyo, Rob Bell isn’t Wrong About Everything
Rob Bell's "What Is the Bible?" Series
Rob Bell and inerrancy
--------------------------------------
What is the Bible? Part 75
What is the Bible? Part 74: The Reason Why People Miss the Point of the Good Samaritan Story
What is the Bible? Part 73: You At The End Of You
What is the Bible? Part 72: The Question That Keeps Coming Up
What is the Bible? Part 71: Ever Read the Bible and Thought, There Must Be Some Background I’m Missing Here?
What is the Bible? Part 70: Wear the Shirt.
What is the Bible? Part 69: Bearing the Sword in Vain. Kind of.
What is the Bible? Part 68: Wrath and Inclusion
What is the Bible? Part 67: The Whole Melchizedek Thing And Why You Love it and Know That it’s True
What is the Bible? Part 66: You Gotta Meet This Man (Peter Enns)
- What is the Bible? Part 58: Who paid Jesus’s bills?
-
- What is the Bible? Part 57: Suffering, Biff, A Seat at the Table, And a Nod to Zeus
- What is the Bible? Part 56: Welcome to the Tradition
-
- What is the Bible? Part 55: Participating in the Divine Nature (Adventures in Your True Foosis!)
-
- What is the Bible? Part 54: Predestination, Election, and that Burning Feeling in the Pit of Your Soul
-
- What is the Bible? Part 53: A Shout Out To the Lonely
-
- What is the Bible? Part 52: It’s Friday My Friends
-
- What is the Bible? Part 51: Greatest Hits
-
- What is the Bible? Part 50: Buechner Week Rolls On!
What is the Bible? Part 49: Here is the World
What is the Bible? Part 48: Allow Me to Introduce You
rob bell • What is the Bible? Part 47 :Guns, Sons, Kids, Minds and Money
What is the Bible? Part 46: All Things Are Yours, Part 2
rob bell • What is the Bible? Part 45: The Two Kinds of Apocalypse
- What is the Bible? Part 43: Exactly How Narrow?
- What is the Bible? Part 42: Sheeeeeeeet!
- What is the Bible? Part 41: Paul and the End of the World
- What We Talk About When We Talk About God now in Paperback
-
- What is the Bible? Part 40: The Evolution of a Census
-
- What is the Bible? Part 39: Give It Up For Sidon!
-
- What is the Bible? Part 38: We Lost Him, And Then We Didn’t
-
- What is the Bible? Part 37: Kurt Cobain and the Book of Revelation
- What is the Bible? Part 36: Do What to our Whats? (Section C)
-
- What is the Bible? Part 35: Do What to our Whats? (Section B)
-
What is the Bible? Part 34: Do What with Our Whats? (Section A)
What is the Bible? Part 32: The Importance of Altitude
- What is the Bible? Part 29: Mother Mary and Rage Against the Machine: A Limited Edition Christmas Special
- What is the Bible? Part 28: Authority
-
- What is the Bible? Part 27: What’s the Deal with All Those Genealogies?
-
- What is the Bible? Part 26: Highlights, Favorites, And Exercises in Absurdity
-
- What is the Bible? Part 24: Why This Library? PartB
- What is the Bible? Part 23: Why this Library? PartA
- What is the Bible? Part 22: The Word of God, Baby.
- What is the Bible? Part 21: In Air, In Sea
-
- What is the Bible? Part 20: Questions, Questions
-
- What is the Bible? Part 19: The Verse That Blows The Roof Off The Joint
-
- What is the Bible? Part 18: Our Dude is Alive!
- What is the Bible? Part 17: Assumptions and AA Meetings
- What is the Bible? Part 16: Awkward
What is the Bible? Part 15: Everybody Loves Stuart and Luscious
- What is the Bible? Part 14 What are you going to do with Stuart?
- What is the Bible? Part 13 Consciousness and Violence
- What is the Bible? Part 12 Tribes and Violence
- What is the Bible? Part 11 How We Got It
- What is the Bible? Part 10 Power of a Poem
- What is the Bible Part 9 Part 9: Adam and Eve
- What is the Bible?Part 8: Stoners and Swingers
Sunday, January 06, 2013
Father Rohr: "Catholics need to be converted; Protestants need to do penance"
|
Monday, December 17, 2012
Reading Rohr with Bono: half-naked elevation, necessary decadence and life-giving drink with the devil (without moving in with him)
This astonishing section (and astonishingly nowhere online until I hit "publish") of Richard Rohr's book, "Adam's Return: The Five Promises of Male Initiation"
below deserves to be read slowly, prayerfully, carefully....
and soundtracked to U2;
and with the following for context and contexture:
1)Thoughtful U2 fans will recognize resonances of 1990s U2 (especially "Elevation" and "Mysterious Ways" as well as famous/infamous Bono quotes about Catholic Carnival, flesh/spirit, "a drink with the devil," incarnation, joy, beauty, sex etc etc) all over this reading. See "Elevation leads to Vertigo 2.0," and blogs by Beth Maynard Tim Neufeld for more).
Bono, as the extraordinary theologian Miraslov Volf himself has said, is an "extraordinary theologian (of grace)".
One almost wonders if the man and his "elegant wife" in the last paragraph are not actually/ literally Mr. and Mrs. Paul "Bono" Hewson; it is all so Bono/esque.
At least wonder how many "amen"s a reading of a random line of this text would solicit from Bono.
2)Please don't hear what Rohr is NOT saying. Don't write him off as a heretic. Read well.
Example: the concept of flirting..sometimes literally... with the line (flirting with the line, itself) as a spiritual discipline/"necessary training."
3)The book is on the topic of "male initiation," so the male/man language is not intended to be sexist.
It should be considered/read on the flow of the whole book. Buy it yesterday, and buy one for Bono and wife.
Enjoy:
Do you think St. Francis really stopped being the king of the parties? Do you think David of the dance, the psalms, the harp and the many women ever stopped being erotic? Could Rumi, Kabir, Tagor or Hafiz have possibly written their sacred poetry if they were not sensuous and sensual men? Did St. Phillip Neri really stop telling jokes and drinking wine? Did Mozart ever stop having fun? Did the cloistered contemplatives not know joy? I don't think so. They just moved joy and pleasure to the highest level, which is the highest definition of a mystic. The contemplative, or saint, is the most refined and highest level of the lover archetype.
It is strange that the West has largely created cultures of conspicuous consumerism when it took as its ultimate hero and God figure a poor and simple man. You would think our God figure would be Dionysius or Pan. Why do most Eastern or Native peoples of the world consider the West to be greedy and materialistic? Why do we produce such a high rate of physically addicted people? Why is the search for affluence and pleasure our main concern? Could it be because we have not blessed the good side of joy and pleasure? Now it comes back and bites us from behind. When I consciously seek a certain amou8nt of creature comfort in my life, I find that it satisfies me, and also will never satisfy me. That is a very life-giving and creative tension to live in.
I do not find the same kind of approach and avoidance attitudes toward pleasure in Hindu countries. among most Jews, and surely not among Native peoples. The lower part of a man was not paid his dues or given legitimate permission in Western Christianity. As many say, sexuality and sensuality is our ever-recurring and "unhealed wound," Like petulant schoolboys, we Christians sneak all the fun we can at the expense of underdeveloped countries, our neighbors, and the health of our own bodies and souls. We feel duly guilty about it all, but we usually don't stop. We priests deny ourselves sex, but then we insist on four-star hotels and restaurants. Carnival in Catholic countries became a necessary decadence to justify receiving the ashes the next morning. Something has not come to balance inside us, and we remain schizoid. We go to the outer world for our daily pleasures, but we seldom allow them to bring us to God, or even to ourselves. We remain split. Flesh is bad and Spirit is good in our terrible dualism. Yet the Christian religion is supposed to be incarnation-a love affair between flesh and Spirit. It is really quite strange.
Ours is the only religion in the world that dares to believe that God became flesh. The only religion that chews on the flesh of God has a very sensuous, sexual symbol for the transformation of the lover; we call it the Eucharist. Christianity says that God is Love but does not appear to really enjoy the lover. Despite all the Bach masses, Baroque churches, incense, vestments, and luxurious art, we still made our religion into a moralistic matter instead of a mystical joy. Our operative God image was much more a banker, a judge, a timekeeper, or an accountant, but seldom a real lover--in any sense that the normal man understands. Like Michal, the daughter of Saul, we despise David for dancing half naked in church (1 Samuel 6:16); we look away from Shakers, Pentecostals, and holy rollers. Religion should be a proper and dignified thing, we think. The hot sins for the Baptists and Catholics
are always associated with the body. This is no religion of incarnation.
Frankly, it is the Hindu sacred poets, Sufi mystics like Rabi'a and Rumi, the Christian saints like John XXIII, Hildegard of Bingen, Franc is of Assisi, Julian of Norwich and Therese of Lisieux, or Jewish masters, like the Baal Shem Tov, Abraham Heschel, and Martin Buber who seem to have met a lover God. The mystics of all religions know this lover God, but they are never allowed to set the tone for the ordinary Christian, Jew, Hindu or Muslim on the street. We are all lost in law, custom and holy wars, which largely nullified any chance of a love-based ethic for any of the three monotheistic religions. As Paul said so strongly, reliance upon moralisms makes grace impossible (Galatians 3), and it even leads to the death of the soul (Romans 7). Moralisms keep us making lists for God instead of making love to God.
In short, if religion does not integrate and validate the sensual, pleasure-loving, erotic part of a man, it takes devious and destructive directions. If you do not bless it and bow to it, it turns on you and controls you, as we have seen in the recent pedophile scandal. If you bless it, it shows its limited value and longs for something higher. The most loving men I have met, the most generous to society and to life, are usually men who have a lusty sense of life, beauty, pleasure and sex--but they have very realistic expectations of them. The smaller pleasures have become a stairway and an invitation to higher ones, almost by revealing simultaneously their wonderful and yet limited character. They offer a first taste but then create a taste for something more and something higher. This is the necessary training of the lower archetype.
The true lover wastes no time in guilt and no time in gluttony either. As Dome Bedde Griffiths said, "Sex is far too important to eliminate entirely, and it is far too important to do lightly. The only alternative is to somehow 'consecrate' it." I am personally convinced this is true. The man who took me recently to a four-star restaurant with his elegant wife, while speaking excitedly about the food making love to him, is the same man who talks passionately about refugees, injustice and Third World issues, and he has passed these passionate concerns onto his children. He is the lover I am talking about. -Richard Rohr, Adam's Return, pp. 128-131.
Friday, September 09, 2011
Monday, September 27, 2010
Shadow Boxing with Richard Rohr
We then project our own sick symptoms onto the screen of our outer world and call it reality. We don’t see the world as it is; we see the world through the prism of our anxiety, fear, and other rejected emotions. This is what creates the ...worlds of conspiracy theories, militia movements, and the hateful rantings of radio and TV personalities. People are largely fighting their own fears and denied shadow selves. If there is no real shadow boxing with the self, the boxing ring of life becomes scary indeed. This is much of our world."
- Richard Rohr, "On the Threshold of Transformation:Daily Meditations For Men," devotional for Sept 7:THE MALE JOURNEY: Shadow Boxing"....HT to amazing resourcer St. Mike Morrell
Saturday, June 26, 2010
Church is the dating service
Sometimes she thinks she is the date.”
-Richard Rohr, HT: Len
Wednesday, March 10, 2010
We need something longer and more nonsensical than Sunday church: Rohr on liminality
(photo credit: Feris's blog)Often the question I wrestle with here on this blog/block is,
"What is God saying to us here about the role of the pastor in the current culture?"
(click the "role of the pastor" label at bottom of page to see all posts on that topic)
I often half-joke about new "titles" for "pastor" that help us refocus the role; and half-joke about including that on my next business card.
Reading Rohr allows me to still be a party planner (whew!),
but add on "liminal planner/liminoid exorcist"... jk (:
ROHR:
"Nothing fresh or creative will normally happen when we are inside our self-constructed comfort zones, only more of the same. Nothing original emerges from business as usual. It seems we need some antistructure to give direction, depth, and purpose to our regular structure. Otherwise structure, which is needed in the first half of life, tends to become a prison as we grow older.
Much of the work of the biblical God and human destiny itself is to get people into liminal space..it is the only teachable space. So much so that spiritual giants try to live their entire lives in permanent liminality. They try to live on the margins and periphery of the system... It can take the form of monks... [or those who]deliberately place themselves in risky situations, which is to displace yourself.
For most of us...once a week church services do not normally come close to creating liminal space....There has to be something longer, different, daring, even nonsensical..
..The bubble of usual order has to be broken by a bit of whimsy, holy uselessness, deliberate disruption or displacement, learning how to walk in the opposite direction..Forty days is probably a minimum period to spend in liminal space..
The most common substitute for liminal space is "liminoid space,"...Nothing new happens here, only a continuation of the old..Victor Tuner calls this ceremony, as opposed to ritual...We love ceremony, the limimoid, because it asks so little of us other than to show up...
.,,This is why...Jesus mistrusted acts of mortification, dietary laws, or any religion of heroics. They are usually liminoid instead of liminal. The Christian liturgical season of Lent is ideally forty days of practice at some form of liminality..They are structured liminal space..As the Jewish tradition brilliantly intuited: if at least one-seventh of life is not consciousness, presence and naked human BEing, the other six days will be caught up as human DOings that have little depth, meaning or final effect. If at least one -seventh of life is somehow Sabbath and sabbatical, the rest will take care of itself. Without daily, weekly and yearly choices for liminal space, our whole lives eventually become liminoid and we end up just doing time."
-Richard Rohr, excerpts from Chapter 12 ('All Transformation Takes Place in Liminal Spoace" ) of "Adam's Return: The Five Promises of Male Initiation."
Tuesday, September 15, 2009
Wednesday, March 04, 2009
stoned with popcorn/Rohr on heresy
That line was a priest, who pondered after being asked "What's it like hearing the confessions of nuns?"
The episode is recalled in the intro to Robert Raines' "Creative Brooding: Readings to Provoke Thought and Trigger Action" where he admits we don't need another fluffy, "popcorn" devotional.
Which is why many "enjoy" Oswald Chambers, over "Our Daily Bread."
But for our day and age, I wonder:
Doesn't everyone read Richard Rohr for "devotionals"?
In the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus says there are three basic obstacles to the coming of the Kingdom. These are the three P’s: power, prestige and possessions. Nine-tenths of his teaching can be aligned under one of those three categories.
I’m all for sexual morality, but Jesus does not say that’s the issue. In fact, he says the prostitutes are getting into the Kingdom of God before some of us who have made bedfellows with power, prestige and possessions (see Matthew 21:31-32). Those three numb the heart and deaden the spirit, says Jesus.
Read Luke’s Gospel. Read the Sermon on the Mount. Read Matthew’s Gospel and tell me if Jesus is not saying that power, prestige and possessions are the barriers to truth and are the barriers to the Kingdom.
I’m not pointing to Church leadership, I’m pointing to us as the Church. The Church has been comfortable with power, prestige and possessions for centuries and has not called that heresy. You can’t see your own sin.
(Richard Rohr, Radical Grace: Daily Meditations, p.18, day 16
ht: Mike Todd)
By the way, Robert Raines' devotional quouted at top, is on sale for 40 cents at Amazon...sign of the times.
Thursday, December 18, 2008
simulacra-kklesia (part 7): Jesus steals for Christmas
This may be the first year we have the opportunity to save Christmas from the Simulcra it has become; it's time to invoke the fidelity of betrayal and quit copying our copies of copies.
It could be we never get church beyond belief until we get beyond belief.
Crank the simlacra amp up to 11,
so we can dial it back down, and steal it back.
It might just spontaneously combust.
The Advent Conspiracy has been a helpful tool to encourage our churchtribe to detox from commercialism of Christmas .
As subversive as the Conspiracy may seem, everyone knows intuitively that it is simply Christians calling us back to Christian sanity.
That's all needed and good.
But maybe it's too Christian to work(:
Sometimes the most compelling appeals back, are actually are those that partner with, or even originate from, for lack of better terms, non-Christian tribes.
Examples:
>The amazing Richard Rohr (linked often on blogs like this), a Catholic,
asks "Is Christmas Christian" in a Jewish magazine, Tikkun ("A Jewish Magazine, an Interfaith Movement"), He confesses up front, "As a Franciscan priest, I think I have the right to ask that question. Frankly, it is much easier to ask in a non-Christian owned magazine!"
>The intriguing Rev. Billy and his church:
The Church of Stop Shopping is an activist performance group based in New York City, led by Reverend Billy, the stage name of Bill Talen. Using the form of a revival meeting, on sidewalks and in chain stores, Reverend Billy and his gospel choir exhort consumers to abandon the products of large corporations and mass media; the group also preaches a broader message of economic justice, environmental protection, and anti-militarism, protesting sweatshops and the Iraq War. Though it continues its street theatre activities, the Church has also appeared on stage and has toured internationally...Though Talen does not call himself a Christian, he says that Reverend Billy is not a parody of a preacher, but a real preacher; he describes his church's spiritual message as "put the Odd back in God."
Each year, Reverend Billy and his choir attends and performs at the Burning Man festival in Nevada.
Sounds part Zoo TV of course; and sounds prophetic. Here of course the subversion is channeled through a Holy Fool vehicle. Who took the Odd out anyway?
>Of course U2's recent subtle, sly converting of Greg Lake's Christmas song
is a classic example of using "non-Christian" material to preach to the choir...and anyone else listening who's fed up with Christmas and/or Christians/
And besides, who commercialized Christmas anyway? Rohr tells:
Frankly, we must confess that it was likely our founder, St. Francis (1182-1226), who began to make Christmas the sentimental celebration that it has become, although his intention was never at all in the direction it has taken. He was the great lover of poverty and simplicity, and would be aghast at the consumer- and group-defining feast that Christmas has become. He merely replicated the drama of the stable with live animals and music.
For Francis and the early Franciscans, “incarnation was already redemption,” and the feast of Christmas said that God was saying yes to humanity in the enfleshment of his Son in our midst. If that were true, then all questions of inherent dignity, worthiness, and belovedness were resolved once and forever—and for everything that was human, material, physical, and in the whole of creation. That’s why Francis liked animals and nature, praising the sun, moon, and stars, like some New Ager from
California. It was all good and chosen and beautiful if God came among us “as Emmanuel” (Isaiah 7:14).
But groups need and create their identity symbols, and the celebration of Christmas became the big one for Christian Europe, just as Jewish people need Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur, and Muslims need Ramadan and pilgrimage. The trouble is that the meaning became group-defining instead of life-transforming. As we say today, it got “off message”! It was no longer God’s choice of the whole, but God’s choice of us! (In fairness, most religions make the same mistake at lower levels of transformation).
At those lower levels of civil religion or any religion as a “belonging system,” the original meaning is always lost and often even morphs into its exact opposite. Strange and sad, isn’t it? In this case, the self-emptying of God into humble and poor humanity (Philippians 2:7) became an excuse for us to fill, consume, dominate, use, and spend at staggering levels for ourselves. In fact, the days leading up to December 25 are the economic engine around which the entire business economy measures itself in Christian-influenced countries. One might think that the fasting of Ramadan and Yom Kippur might have been a much clearer act of solidarity with the actual mystery celebrated.
Ouch and amen. And thank you.
And probably no surprise that Rohr notes:
"In Christian circles, when I call these false gods into question, I am invariably criticized on other grounds of heresy and church protocols, almost so we do not have to look at what our real loyalties have been and are."
Hmm..maybe Christ is calling Christians to spend more time out of "Christian circles," where its easier for God to communicate his subversion of simulacra. At Christmastime, it is good to get out of bounded setism, so that maybe together, along with some wonderful Jews, non-Christian pastors, and even some prophetic atheists...we can "put Christ back in Christmas." (:
Why let Adbusters have all the fun....and do all the Kingdom work without us?
Michael Pritzl: "When I read the Bible, I find I relate more to the sinners than I do to the saints."
Paul Raushenbush: "Sometimes intra-faith dialogue is much harder than interfaith."
So what can be done..as we saints and aints collaborate?
Can we conspire to steal Advent back?
That last line of couse is a reference to Bono's famous introduction of U2's cover of "Helter Skelter":
"This is a song Charles Manson stole from the Beatles, we're
stealing it back."
As in:
"This (Advent) is season Christians stole from Christ, we (Christians and non-Christians) are stealing it back (by simply doing what Jesus would do at Christmastime!)"
Or better yet, as Rohr changes the agent of the stealing, and ends his article with real reality:
Maybe our humble Jesus is stealing our idols from us, and inviting us back into his Bethlehem stable.
Tuesday, December 16, 2008
Tuesday, October 16, 2007
Context is Everything: Programmed by Books we haven't read
As we say here in the States, Mackan: "My bad."
My amazing professor Bob Lyon always said, and the MacMan (who even put it on a T shirt...cool!) still doth say:
"Context is everything."
The paraphrased quote at hand(by another seminary professor of mine):
Most of us are programmed by books we never read.
George Hunter, Radical Outreach: The Recovery of Apostolic Ministry and Evangelism ,p. 105
The context:
He was specifically lamenting that so many pastors, without even knowing or reading the book that such theology was based on (Richard Baxter's 1656 classic, "The Reformed Pastor"), have adopted/been taught such theology. Namely, and stated extremely, the view is that pastors do all the work, and the laity are just there to listen to you. Hunter recommends that we take a page from another Book that we have hopefully read (The Bible, which makes the priesthood of all believers quite foundational) ; as well as John Wesley's books, which journal well what happens when the so-called "laity" are empowered.
He also applies the "Most of us are programmed by books we never read"principle to other disciplines. A most obvious example is physics: We are still informed by a Newtonian worldview, when Einstein/relativity/quantum theory/string theory has rocked that old mindset. To cross disciplines, this revolution/shift of wineskins in physics holds profound implications for theology , as Len sweet, Len Hjalmarson and Margaret Wheatley have creatively explored.
Every field of study has its seminal textbooks, some hundreds of years old; and most which have a lot to offer and are indeed classic (as Baxter..he got a lot beautifully right). But most have never literally read them; Just been"by default hugely influenced by them (trough their graduate school' s secondary source texts)
"Protestant Christianity's equivalent of Darwin's 'Origin of Species'-for understanding who we are--and Newton's 'Principia'--for understanding our place in the scheme of things,and how the (church) world works--is Baxter" (p.105)
Another way of saying this then, is "The mind can only take pictures using the film with which its been loaded." (quote by Richard Rohr, hat tip to Len).
Basic to a postmodern epistemology is a (healthy) questioning of our lenses and our "texts" (as Derrida used the term, a "text" could be anything, not just a literal book).
It's also a helpful question in overcoming ethnocentrism.
Lord, help us to know how we have been programmed. We may need deprogramming, deconstruction, or even a kick in the butt. Amen.





