Welcome! You have accidentally reached the blog of a heteroclite follower of Jesus: dave wainscott. I'm "pushing toward the unobvious" as I post thinkings/linkings re: Scripture, church and culture. Hot topics include: temple tantrums, time travel, sexuality/spirituality, U2kklesia, role of the pastor, God-haunted music/art..and subversive videos like these.
Pages
Search Me:
Showing posts with label trinity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label trinity. Show all posts
Saturday, April 07, 2018
Thursday, March 30, 2017
The real heresy of "The Shack"movie revealed!
![]() |
| Photo credit |
I try to follow Bell's Theorem of reviewing, and "only review books and films I've actually seen."
And so many are Tweeting, blogging and Spacebooking to call out alleged heresy in one or both.
I enjoyed both book and film, but I do feel compelled to expose the real and horrific heresy of the film.
It's not the items most bloggers are highlighting.
It's actually a heresy that wasn't in the book, but the film changed two words of a sentence that was pretty much infallible gospel and wasn't to be tampered with. With two words, the filmmakers introduced an unholy heterodoxy.... and as the Holy Heteroclite, it is core to my calling and blogdom to publicly expose such skubala.
Of course, it's always risky to bring a book to film, and it is inevitable that changes will be made.
BUT this one may be almost the unpardonable sin...
Ready?
In the book, God the Father (Papa) sings a bit of a Bruce Cockburn song while serving breakfast, and confesses: "I love that child's songs! I am especially fond of Bruce." (pp. 122-123).
This was such a huge win for the book, and a great plug for Bruce, who (unlike in his native Canada), is not well-enough known in the US. etc. Of all people, followers of Christ should be aware of this prophetic troubador. Heck, you can even ask (British) N.T. Wright!
If you're reading this blog, you are among the select and elect, and you likely know about him, and have noted he deservedly has his own listing under blog topics (Bruce even sent us ..me...some autographed product).
William Paul Young, author of The Shack, if you'll pardon the inappropriate but accurate reference, is man of wealth and taste. Not only does he insert St Bruce Cockburn ("What can I say… [I am a] huge fan of Bruce Cockburn. As far as I am concerned, one of the greatest lyricists alive..and an incredible guitarist to boot." ... link) into the book (on the lips of God, no less), but in the acknowledgements section gives credit to the following for inspiration: "U2, Dylan, Moby, Paul Colman, Mark Knopfler, James Taylor, Bebo Norman, Matt Wertz (you are something special), Nichole Nordeman, Amos Lee, Kirk Franklin, David Wilcox, Sarah McLachlan, Jackson Browne, Indigo Girls, the Dixie Chicks, Larry Norman and a whole lot of Bruce Cockburn." (link)
But the movie version?
I was wondering if the Cockburn reference would make the cut. I knew I would be thrilled if it did, but assumed it would be fodder for the cutting room floor.
When I recognized the breakfast scene, I held my breath..
...and heard Papa singing a tune by...
wait for it...
Neil Young!!!
She followed up with the familiar line:
"I love that child's songs! I am especially fond of Neil Young."
Boom! The heresy duck should have dropped right then.
Now, I love Neil Young as much as you; and he even has merited several posts on this here blog.
But he doesn't need the Holy Spirited PR that Bruce does.
Somebody made a bottom line decision that was about the film's economic bottom line.
It was bad decision about a good observation : "Hey, not many people will recognize Bruce Cockburn; let's change it to someone already famous." Non-sequitur city; this would've been great reason and vehicle to introduce a lot of people to a little-known singer who could change their lives.
Okay, I'm kidding about this being a real heresy....I think. (:
And when I lamented about this to Michael Bells , he had a point : "At least they are both Canadian.
But since I trust that this lil ol' blog has at least some influence, please check out the Bruce.
God loves him..
and as He (She) said in The Shack book:
"I have no favorite? Bruce, I mean?"
"I have no favorites." I am just especially fond of him."
"You seem to be especially fond of a lot of people. Are there any you are not especially fond of?"
"Nope, I haven't been able to find anybody." (p. 123).
Fair enough..
but one last dig..
Compare the spiritual depth of the Neil Young song Papa sang in the movie to that of the song of Bruce's that she sang in the book version. I could've nominated 50 better Godhanunted numbers from the Young canon/catalog/hymnal. Gee, how about this? .Or these? Or the two (here and here, the second one I filmed here in Fresno) that Bono has taken it upon himself to call our prayer/attention to?
Get back to me..
Labels:
Bruce Cockburn,
movies,
n.t. wright,
spirituality of music,
trinity,
U2
Saturday, December 24, 2016
kenosis in transitional/liminal space
Martha Reineke in René Girard and Creative Mimesis:
Winnicott's work proves useful at this juncture. As his work is interpreted by Ulanov, religion is an environment "provided by a God who holds us in being." This environment is healing to humans because each human's infancy and childhood inevitably has included gaps which have led them to falter in their reconnoitering of transitional space. Ulanov finds Julian of Norwich's words descriptive of God's work: God "knits" humans into divine being, "oneing" them into God's being. Likened to a mother, God stays with humans through all their ruthless attacks, surviving these attacks
"out of her own resilience" and, remaining empathetic, "mothering us into one whole persons living through her shared experience with us."
..Winicott's vision, Ulanov claims, has profound theological implications. She understands that “good enough parents” can facilitate in humans the development of a capacity for a capacity for symbol-making that supports creative explorations of being within transitional space ...In conversion,
new relationship is forged by a God who "eternally, graciously, enduringly offers relationship." Ulanov describes in precise ways how the Christian community of faith supports transitional space.
To meet God within this space, one must undergo kenōsis, emptying oneself in ways that mirror Christ's emptying himself in order to enter into human life. -René Girard and Creative Mimesis
pp. 45-6, link
Winnicott's work proves useful at this juncture. As his work is interpreted by Ulanov, religion is an environment "provided by a God who holds us in being." This environment is healing to humans because each human's infancy and childhood inevitably has included gaps which have led them to falter in their reconnoitering of transitional space. Ulanov finds Julian of Norwich's words descriptive of God's work: God "knits" humans into divine being, "oneing" them into God's being. Likened to a mother, God stays with humans through all their ruthless attacks, surviving these attacks
"out of her own resilience" and, remaining empathetic, "mothering us into one whole persons living through her shared experience with us."
..Winicott's vision, Ulanov claims, has profound theological implications. She understands that “good enough parents” can facilitate in humans the development of a capacity for a capacity for symbol-making that supports creative explorations of being within transitional space ...In conversion,
new relationship is forged by a God who "eternally, graciously, enduringly offers relationship." Ulanov describes in precise ways how the Christian community of faith supports transitional space.
To meet God within this space, one must undergo kenōsis, emptying oneself in ways that mirror Christ's emptying himself in order to enter into human life. -René Girard and Creative Mimesis
pp. 45-6, link
Labels:
ecclesiology,
kenosis,
liminality,
mimetic,
spanish mystics,
trinity
Thursday, December 01, 2016
perichoretic and polycentric church structure
Ask ten random churchfolk:
"What are the practical implications of the Trinity for church structure?"
After the first few responders offer blank stares, maybe one will catch something profound (like these folks), and as the Q man (Quentin P. Kinnison) does below in a highly-recommended book.
From a section headed Trinitarian Implications for Church Structures:
...From Trinitarian themes, an ecclesiology forms which expresses serious concern regarding the specialization of ministry. Any specialized ministry in the church occurs within the ministry of all members--the universal priesthood of all believers.
...Viewing the relations of the Trinity as complementary perichoretic subjects, Volf concludes that ecclesial structures must be viewed as complementary and egalitarian. Therefore, he forcefully states:
-Quentin P. Kinnison, Transforming Pastoral Leadership: Reimagaining Congregational Leadership for Changing Contexts, pp. 83-84
For more on what polycentrism might mean, see pp. 96-99 of the book.
Yes, buy it now!
--
PS:
I am intrigued by how best to draw/chart out polycentric.
Here are some starting points from Google Images.
Or maybe this could be attempted through set theory. See:
"What are the practical implications of the Trinity for church structure?"
After the first few responders offer blank stares, maybe one will catch something profound (like these folks), and as the Q man (Quentin P. Kinnison) does below in a highly-recommended book.
From a section headed Trinitarian Implications for Church Structures:
...From Trinitarian themes, an ecclesiology forms which expresses serious concern regarding the specialization of ministry. Any specialized ministry in the church occurs within the ministry of all members--the universal priesthood of all believers.
...Viewing the relations of the Trinity as complementary perichoretic subjects, Volf concludes that ecclesial structures must be viewed as complementary and egalitarian. Therefore, he forcefully states:
If one starts from the Trinitarian model I have suggested, then the structure of ecclesial unity cannot be conceived by way of the one, be it the pope, the patriarch or the bishop. Every ecclesial unity held together by a mon-archy, by a "one-[man!]-rule, is monistic and thus also un-trinitarian.In such a church, the Charismata are recognized as universally distributed and are practiced by all in a "polycentric community" where members are participative, fulfilling their calling to serve God and the community in God's mission.
-Quentin P. Kinnison, Transforming Pastoral Leadership: Reimagaining Congregational Leadership for Changing Contexts, pp. 83-84
For more on what polycentrism might mean, see pp. 96-99 of the book.
Yes, buy it now!
--
PS:
I am intrigued by how best to draw/chart out polycentric.
Here are some starting points from Google Images.
Or maybe this could be attempted through set theory. See:
Labels:
centered sets,
ecclesiology,
role of the pastor,
semiotics,
trinity
Tuesday, April 26, 2016
Eugene Peterson and Bono film on Psalms: cussing without cussing
Here is the new Fuller Studio film of Eugene and Bono on Psalms.
Links and quotes below
Gotta love so much about this film..like Eugene calling Rolling Stone Magazine "Rolling Stones"..
and a mosh pit a "mash pit." (;
If you like the hilarious story (excerpted above) about how EP first turned Bono down, there's a whole video of EP on that and more here.
--
EP:
"At twelve years old , [the psalms] showed me that imagination was a way to get inside the truth.
....translating a psalm...To try to get them to realize that praying wasn't being nice before God.. The psalms are not pretty; they're not nice...just pray this psalm.. It's not smooth; it's not nice, it's not pretty; but it's honest. And I think we're trying for honesty..which is very, very hard in our culture.
We need to find a way to cuss...without cussing. And the imprecatory psalms surely do that.
We've got to some way in context; and the context is the whole Bible; whole psalter...to tell people how mad we are.
...We have crosses in every room in this house. But when I look at those, I don't think of decoration; I think 'This is the world we live in..and it's a world with a lot of crosses . ' And I would just like to spend my life in doing something about that through Scripture, through preaching, through friendship. My years are getting shorter, and I don't have many left; but I don't want to escape the violence..."
Bono:
"The only way we can approach God..if we're honest..is through metaphor; through symbol. So art becomes essential; not decorative.
..The psalmist is brutally honest about the explosive joy that he's feeling and the deep sorrow or confusion, and it's that that sets the psalms apart for me.And I often think,
'Why isn't church music more like that'? ..
...I'm talking about dishonesty. I find in a lot of Christian art ..a lot of dishonesty. I think it's a shame because these people are vulnerable to God (in a good way)...porous; open.. I would love if this conversation would inspire people who are writing these beautiful.., gospel songs: write a song about their bad marriage; write a song about how they're pissed off at the government. Because that's what God wants from you: the truth... The truth will set you free; it will blow things apart. Why I'm suspicious of Christians is because of this lack of realism..and I'd love to see more of that in art and life and music."
(answering "What is the work of the artist..in acknowledging the intensity; the reality of the feeling without indulging the feeling?").
Having feelings is perfectly normal. ...David danced naked in front of the troops; that's one reason I like him .. abandonment... very important... understanding our bodies as well as our minds and ourspirits. The Three-Personed God --The Trinity--is reflected in our body, mind and spirit..,We really do ignore this.
--
EP prays:
"Be with us as we continue our lives of serving You with poetry, with the arts, with psalm, finding ways to enter into what You're already doing: not calculating the chances, but doing what's right there, what You've already started doing..."
Listen for the prophetic summary in the last two words of the film
...from Mrs. Peterson.
--------------------------
See:
Links and quotes below
Gotta love so much about this film..like Eugene calling Rolling Stone Magazine "Rolling Stones"..
and a mosh pit a "mash pit." (;
If you like the hilarious story (excerpted above) about how EP first turned Bono down, there's a whole video of EP on that and more here.
--
EP:
"At twelve years old , [the psalms] showed me that imagination was a way to get inside the truth.
....translating a psalm...To try to get them to realize that praying wasn't being nice before God.. The psalms are not pretty; they're not nice...just pray this psalm.. It's not smooth; it's not nice, it's not pretty; but it's honest. And I think we're trying for honesty..which is very, very hard in our culture.
We need to find a way to cuss...without cussing. And the imprecatory psalms surely do that.
We've got to some way in context; and the context is the whole Bible; whole psalter...to tell people how mad we are.
...We have crosses in every room in this house. But when I look at those, I don't think of decoration; I think 'This is the world we live in..and it's a world with a lot of crosses . ' And I would just like to spend my life in doing something about that through Scripture, through preaching, through friendship. My years are getting shorter, and I don't have many left; but I don't want to escape the violence..."
Bono:
"The only way we can approach God..if we're honest..is through metaphor; through symbol. So art becomes essential; not decorative.
..The psalmist is brutally honest about the explosive joy that he's feeling and the deep sorrow or confusion, and it's that that sets the psalms apart for me.And I often think,
'Why isn't church music more like that'? ..
...I'm talking about dishonesty. I find in a lot of Christian art ..a lot of dishonesty. I think it's a shame because these people are vulnerable to God (in a good way)...porous; open.. I would love if this conversation would inspire people who are writing these beautiful.., gospel songs: write a song about their bad marriage; write a song about how they're pissed off at the government. Because that's what God wants from you: the truth... The truth will set you free; it will blow things apart. Why I'm suspicious of Christians is because of this lack of realism..and I'd love to see more of that in art and life and music."
(answering "What is the work of the artist..in acknowledging the intensity; the reality of the feeling without indulging the feeling?").
Having feelings is perfectly normal. ...David danced naked in front of the troops; that's one reason I like him .. abandonment... very important... understanding our bodies as well as our minds and ourspirits. The Three-Personed God --The Trinity--is reflected in our body, mind and spirit..,We really do ignore this.
--
EP prays:
"Be with us as we continue our lives of serving You with poetry, with the arts, with psalm, finding ways to enter into what You're already doing: not calculating the chances, but doing what's right there, what You've already started doing..."
Listen for the prophetic summary in the last two words of the film
...from Mrs. Peterson.
--------------------------
See:
- Story of the film, along related quotes with resources
- Behind the scenes
Bono audio: God at the 9" Nails Gig
atu2:"The Message Author Says U2's Message is Refreshing, Faithful, and Honest
Labels:
art,
death,
death of Jesus,
eugene peterson,
lament,
language,
metaphor,
psalms,
reading the Bible,
translation,
trinity
Thursday, May 28, 2015
Since "there's no end to grief," let's "set endless love to musical performance" so in the ruins we can know that "to know is to mourn"
![]() |
| photo credit |
As I have said/confessed/sung/prayed more than once, "I grieve not grieving."
But I finally realized that that itself is inherently grieving, and thus a good place to start.
May He who began a good work in me be faithful to complete my encounter with grief..
Life is ruthless, indiscriminate....and ultimately loving....in supplying us the traumascape and holy ground of grief.
But often we need to gather..or enter into... a soundtrack and soundscape to
sustain, sanctify and hold our grief-ground.
"Songs to Grieve By" could be a delightful name for a Spotify playlist. I'll have to claim it.
Of course the songs that make the cut don't have to all be classically sad songs;
laments, wails
and Pink Floyd downers.
Even though life is often best "tuned to minor chords"..
Some of the songs selected should be uptempo and upbeat,
and shamelessly embedded with unrepentant joy..
"California" by U2 is an intriguing choice.
The rocker is hardly a dirge; though a quick read at some of the lyrics might cause you to guess that it is.
This section has haunted (stalked) me for months
I've seen for myself, there's no end to grief/That's how I know
And why I need to know/That there is no end to love
All I know/And all I need to know is There is no end to love
U2 has faced an unimaginable string of losses in recent months:the
Bono's harrowing accident,
the death of the band's chaplain, the indefatigable "north star" Jack Heaslip,
the death of Larry's father the week of the tour kick-off..
and yesterday , this:
U2's road manager for 33 years, the amazing Dennis Sheehan died suddenly last night here in LA. Dennis was a calm and kind Christian man. The team is heartbroken so Adam, Larry, Edge, and Bono asked me to share some scripture, words of comfort, and pray with them right before they walked on stage tonight. After sharing the #ChooseJoystory from my son's death, I asked "So how do you go out and do a concert when your heart is hurting?" Bono said "We choose joy!" Right. Pray for Pam who lost the love of her life. link
That version of "choose joy" is not some "name-it, claim it" happy-clappy motto (Denial is not just a river in Egypt), but a hardwon naked trust in the endless love that is know only through the crucible of endless grief.
That doesn't preclude anger..even yelling at life, grief, the grieved...and God.
Last night, at the end of "Raised by Wolves," itself a stunning public griefsong, Bono snippeted Psalm 23 in the outro (as usual), this time followed by "Comfort me. COMFORT ME, COMFORT ME!" (see video below). Psalm 22 and 23 are two sides of the same whole and holistic grieflove lamentjoyprayer (see"The Lord Be With You...Even When He’s Not!")
That doesn't preclude anger..even yelling at life, grief, the grieved...and God.
"I walk through the valley of the shadow of death. Comfort me, COMFORT ME, COMFORT ME!!!" -Bono at end of "Wolves." #RIPDennis #U2ieTour
— Tim Neufeld (@timneufeld) May 28, 2015
Last night, at the end of "Raised by Wolves," itself a stunning public griefsong, Bono snippeted Psalm 23 in the outro (as usual), this time followed by "Comfort me. COMFORT ME, COMFORT ME!" (see video below). Psalm 22 and 23 are two sides of the same whole and holistic grieflove lamentjoyprayer (see"The Lord Be With You...Even When He’s Not!")
Even St Paul unapologetically confessed, "I had no peace of mind."
And as another singer has added/midrashed "Peace of heart is better than piece of mind."
Peace of heart...finding love limitless in the midst of limanality and limitless grief is the only ways and means of knowing anything. Not to mention are only lens for knowing as we are known. ( By the way, we can know the Unknown Calle)r.
Note the last line of that excerpt of "California"-- "there is no end to love" ---is itself a clear nod to Paul's 1 Corinthian's 13 insistence that "love never ends."
But do check well the line before that, which has baffled me: "There's no end to grief. That's how I know there is no end to love."
This apparent nonsequitur and profound truth is also thoroughly Pauline. NT Wright has detected in Scripture, notably in Paul, an "epistemology of love."
He even suggests that it must inevitably worked out in art; specifically music...even more specifically "musical performance":
....Is this then a reinforcement, from a musical point of view, for Dorothy L. Sayers’ thesis in The Mind of the Maker, to which I referred earlier? Is there then indeed a Trinitarian pattern to the work of the artist or writer which, reflected back, provides some kind of evidence of who God may be? I am not sure that this thesis can be sustained by itself, or that a natural theology built up by that means without help from elsewhere would arrive at anything approximating to the God and Father of Jesus, the giver of the Spirit. But when the creative and aesthetic project meets the scriptural revelation — mediated, of course, through the thinking of the household of faith — then the two can perhaps at least be complementary. I have explored elsewhere what I have called ‘an epistemology of love’, in which the sterile opposition between ‘objective’ and ‘subjective’ reductions of ‘knowing’ are transcended. I think, and hope, that what Paul Spicer and I discovered in our work on the Oratorio was something like that: a love for the subject-matter, a love worked out in art and scholarship, through which we both learned and grew and grasped afresh some of the central matters of Christian faith. And if this is true it may be a pointer to something else - something which the whole Theology Through the Arts project is all about: the non-reducible, and not merely decorative, function of imagination within historical work (as Collingwood insisted) and also theological endeavour, as well as in musical composition and performance.
I realize that I have thus arrived, as a non-specialist, at more or less what Aquinas says in his famous formulation: ‘As grace does not destroy but perfects nature, it is right that natural reason should serve faith just as the natural loving tendency of the will serves charity.’ There is of course a dangerous circularity about reaching that conclusion about method precisely by engaging in what, I hope, might be an instance of it happening in practice. But I think I have said enough to show that this is a fruitful area for further enquiry and experiment, especially if — though this would be a matter for specialists to enlighten me further — what Aquinas meant by ‘natural reason’ is a large enough category to embrace aesthetic and artistic integrity, the composer’s and conductor’s sense of ‘what works’. Certainly in this case the composer’s — and conductor’s — aesthetic and artistic integrity ‘served faith’ in a way that makes the ordinary jobbing theologian and preacher jealous. If all theology, all sermons, had to be set to music, our teaching and preaching would not only be more mellifluous; it might also approximate more closely to God’s truth, the truth revealed in and as the Word made flesh, crucified and risen.
NT Wright, link
Is this how the band got through the concert last night?
Is this how they get through every night?
I too have felt (well, maybe not; which is itself the problem) the deaths of a series of loved ones:
a cousin who was like a brother, dear friends from church...
and I have grieved not grieving.
And even though I have been weaning myself from the evangelical idol of certainty in recent years (and that is a grieving indeed)..
in recent weeks, thanks to U2's "California," and their healthy navigation of their own grieving, I have been learning and leaning into all that I need to know.
Steven Garber writes of Walker Percy (whom I am pretty sure is a U2 influence):
One of his best stories is Love in the Ruins. It is the first of two novels featuring the character Tom More, a fictional descendent of Sir Thomas More, “the man for all seasons” who, in the 16th century, was the Speaker of the House of Commons and the Lord Chancellor of England – and who refused to go along with Henry VIII’s desire for a divorce, so lost his head and his life. Percy’s More is a bad Catholic, a wandering husband who drinks too much, and a brilliant doctor. Written with a finger to the wind to the social turmoil of the 1960s, Percy wrote of Southern life embodied in the institutional frailties of the Love Clinic, a place where physicians and patients are thrown together in their hopes, longing to belong to someone somewhere.
Literally and metaphorically staggering his way through the story, More develops a machine that promises to save the day for the Love Clinic; he calls it “the qualitative/quantitative ontological lapsometer.” For anyone with ears to hear, attentive to the Enlightenment Project of the last few hundred years, Percy here captured the fundamental flaws of the modern world, fictional as they were in imagination and conception. When More is asked about the nature of a lapsometer, he replies – innocent as a dove, wise as a serpent – “It measures lapses – in the human soul.”
The dreams and debates of modernity, cascading as they are into postmodernity, are always at the heart of the human condition. It cannot be otherwise, as we are never more and never less than sons of Adam and daughters of Eve. So we take our place as folks who long to love and to be loved. Percy understood that with an unusual eye: historically, philosophically, psychologically, politically, and, yes, theologically, seeing the complexity for Everyman and Everywoman. We want love, yet we also know how hard it is to love and to be loved.
There’s the rub. To know and to love; to love and to know. Can both happen at the same time? Can we do both? Can we have both?
Most of the time it seems impossible. For reasons beyond the scope of this short essay, I would argue that human beings more often than not choose cynicism or stoicism as alternative accounts of life and of love. Rather than an epistemology of love, a way of knowing that is manifest in loving, we choose to protect our hearts, “knowing” with the poet Byron that “he who knows the most mourns the deepest.” To know is to despair. To know is to flounder. To know is to mourn. link
Related:
- Crowder goes slumming /Psalming: Gilligan's Island, R-rated T-shirts, automated urinals, St. Airport...and sunsets and sushi
- Pepsi, Sex, Elevation...& Mission Trips That Are Actually Missional
- Soundtracking Grief and Missing Jesus
- an impossibly bad ending that's good news
- No Sanctified Church without Grieving our Grief
Tuesday, May 19, 2015
Eugene Peterson interview: The Relationally-Grounded Pastor
And these are just the first two questions of the interview!
![]() |
| great pic, from a different interview here |
When you look at the state of the pastoral vocation, what concerns you?
One of the things that distresses me most is how much ambition there is. I'm alarmed that we measure things by what the world counts as important. We've lost a scriptural imagination, I fear. It's so important for pastors to understand the Trinity, because it shows that God is totally relational. There's no part of the Godhead that isn't in relationship to the other parts and with us. If we don't saturate ourselves in that relational reality, the values in this world just crowd in on us.
How did your parishioners shape the way you saw your role as a pastor?
They treated me as a person of prayer, as a person of conversation. When they would come to me with a problem, I really wouldn't deal with the problem. I got them talking about their lives in different ways, and it's surprising how many times, after two or three times together, there was no problem. They thought the problem was the only way they could get my attention. And when it didn't get my attention, at least not in the way they thought, then the conversations would get deeper and more intimate. I think because of the culture we live in, we almost have to disappoint people, at least at the outset, in order to get them to understand who we are and what we're doing..... link
Wednesday, September 10, 2014
Blake on ecclesiology, profane becoming sacred, and thinking against oneself
It's kind of freaky that just a few days ago--before you and I had any idea that U2's surprise releases
would be called "Songs of Innocence" and "Songs of Experience"..
..I pulled out two books:
I would, however, reverse the figure and the field. Blake does not celebrate the sacred
becoming profane, but the profane becoming sacred.
would be called "Songs of Innocence" and "Songs of Experience"..
..I pulled out two books:
- Blake's "Songs of Innocence and Songs of Experience"
- Inchausti's "Subversive Orthodoxy
One theory is that "The Joshua Tree" was to be a double album; one disc "Songs of Innocence" and the other "Songs of Experience".
One reviewer headlined a review of U2's "Pop" as More Songs of Innocence and Experience.
One can see why Bono likes Blake. From Inchausti:
If one were to seek the great archetypal precursor for prophetic Christian thinker championing the soul's return from the spiritual exile of Enlightenment rationalism, William Blake comes very close to casting the mold. Condemned as heretical by some and as too orthodox by others, he was one of the first to point out exactly how the new sciences were distorting the role of the imagination in human affairs and putting the soul to sleep.Altizer and Hamilton..described Blake's contribution to Western thought
This, I think, is an essentially accurate description of Blake's intellectual influence.Blake was the first of the modern seers. Through Blake we can sense the theological significance of a poetic reversal of our mythical traditions, and become open to the possibility that the uniquely modern metamorphosis of the sacred into the profane is the culmination of a redemptive and kenotic movement of the Godhead
I would, however, reverse the figure and the field. Blake does not celebrate the sacred
becoming profane, but the profane becoming sacred.
....Blake reminds us again and again that true knowledge--that is to say, knowledge of our ontological status as creatures made in the image of God--cannot be grasped by calculation; only through a vision. And vision--in its most concentrated and inclusive firm --is what psychoanalysts call the "imago," an internal picture that transform s facts into meanings..
..His theme is that the church lost its radical energy by giving up its apocalyptic vision for a more accommodating set of doctrines, and so the church became more hierarchical and tradition-bound at the very moment it should have become more democratic and imaginative..
Christian thought critiques mainstream culture but also sees itself under judgment; our best modern Christian intellectuals have turned thinking against themselves into a veritable art form: from Blake to Dostoyevsky, from Kierkegaard to Chesterton, all the way to Dorothy Day and Walker Percy, the exemplary mode of Christian thought has been a triadic structure of self-reflection, paradox and irony that reverses the values of this world and the logic of cause and effect pp 19-28, 178
Tuesday, June 10, 2014
Third Ways and Triple Albums: on U2 taking cues from The Violets and David Crowder
There are always two ways..
and often the best way is the third way
(even though as dc talk suggested, that way is the hard way).
Apparently, one of the plans for what was to became U2's first masterwork--The Joshua Tree--was a double album on the theme of "The Two Americas." Another possible schema followed William Blake's "Songs of Innocence" and "Songs of Experience.'
Maybe the decision to keep it to a single album was to present the contradiction/paradox in a cohesive --though of course, still contradictory--collage, as opposed to they too-easy dualism of a dual-disc.
Most dualisms must be dueled; even dialect can be dualed.
"Songs of Innocent Experience."
"The Two Americas in One."
As Brendan Kelly once wrote (in a review of U2's "Pop"):
But trialectic? Tertium quid? The third way isn't always Yahweh; but it often is the creative solution.
It might lead to trifurcation...or a holy trinity.
U2 could've released the Joshua Tree as three discs; they had that much material.
(the same is true with their current project, but...arggg... that's another topic. take a cue from TVB, boys. Or at least read my blog).
Or maybe it's best to see several trilogies in their catalog .
Do you see thesis/anithesis/synthesis in any perceived trology?
Or other patterns?
U3?
--
Note:
Many felt blindsided by the "sudden" death of The David Crowder Band; but DC had long said (and even given clues in album titles..
let the reader understand) they had long planned their discography as a series of seven CDs; even to the degree where the first three were mirrored (sequeled? as "reannunciations") by the next three...and the seventh (itself a double album, which includes seven sequences) was a...synthesis? prequel? requiem with hints of new birth?
Many see the three U2 albums of this decade as a trilogy.
So why not go out with a triple bang with this next triple album..
Related:
.
and often the best way is the third way
(even though as dc talk suggested, that way is the hard way).
Apparently, one of the plans for what was to became U2's first masterwork--The Joshua Tree--was a double album on the theme of "The Two Americas." Another possible schema followed William Blake's "Songs of Innocence" and "Songs of Experience.'
Maybe the decision to keep it to a single album was to present the contradiction/paradox in a cohesive --though of course, still contradictory--collage, as opposed to they too-easy dualism of a dual-disc.
Most dualisms must be dueled; even dialect can be dualed.
"Songs of Innocent Experience."
"The Two Americas in One."
As Brendan Kelly once wrote (in a review of U2's "Pop"):
More Songs of Innocence and Experience:
..We live in an age when sexuality and spirituality are usually treated as completely separate realities despite the fact that down through the ages some of the greatest poets and song-writers identified the presence of the one in the other. Think of Blake's 'Songs of Innocence and Experience', D. H. Lawrence's poems, stories and novels, and some of W. B. Yeats's greatest poems. (Yeats, in fact, is a strong and perfectly absorbed influence on Bono)... link
But trialectic? Tertium quid? The third way isn't always Yahweh; but it often is the creative solution.
It might lead to trifurcation...or a holy trinity.
U2 could've released the Joshua Tree as three discs; they had that much material.
(the same is true with their current project, but...arggg... that's another topic. take a cue from TVB, boys. Or at least read my blog).
Or maybe it's best to see several trilogies in their catalog .
Do you see thesis/anithesis/synthesis in any perceived trology?
Or other patterns?
U3?
--
Note:Many felt blindsided by the "sudden" death of The David Crowder Band; but DC had long said (and even given clues in album titles..
let the reader understand) they had long planned their discography as a series of seven CDs; even to the degree where the first three were mirrored (sequeled? as "reannunciations") by the next three...and the seventh (itself a double album, which includes seven sequences) was a...synthesis? prequel? requiem with hints of new birth?
Many see the three U2 albums of this decade as a trilogy.
So why not go out with a triple bang with this next triple album..
Related:
U2 and their three eras: id, ego and supergo? what's next?
.
Labels:
centered sets,
spirituality of music,
trinity,
U2,
violet burning
Friday, May 23, 2014
did Paul (shamelessly) plug Jesus into the Shema?
![]() |
| chart-from this page |
See Andrew Perriman:
also:
The Shema and 1 Cor 8:6
Paul's Expanded Shema in 1 Corinthians 8:6
Labels:
death of Jesus,
jewish,
n.t. wright,
reading the Bible,
trinity
Tuesday, April 22, 2014
Polkinghorne on Trinitarian theology as Theory of Everything
As a quantum physicist, I have been concerned with how that subject's veiled account of created reality might influence theology's understanding of God's relationship to the physical universe. Yet I have also wanted to make clear, as opportunity offered, that the central source of my own belief in God does not lie in such matters. Rather, it is to be found in my encounter with the figure of Jesus Christ, as I meet him in Scripture, in the Church and in the sacraments. For me, it is Trinitarian belief that is truly persuasive belief. Of course, that belief is much more complex than the simple recognition of the Mind of God behind the order of nature, just as modern quantum theory is more complex than Max Planck's original idea that energy comes in packets. Yet, Trinitarian belief is complex in ways that seem to me to be necessary to match the depth of experience and insight recorded in the Bible, and continued in the ongoing life of the Church.
I...make what some of my scientific colleagues might think was an over-audacious claim, that a deeply intellectual satisfying candidate for the title of a true "Theory of Everything" is in fact provided by Trinitarian theology.
The exercise on which I... engage is somewhat similar to that which an earlier age might have been called the search for 'vestiges of the Trinity'. Of course, I am not claiming that the earth is full of entities stamped 'Made by the Holy Trinity'. God's work of creation is rather more subtle than that. What I shall claim is not that we can infer the Trinity from nature, but that there are aspects of our scientific understanding of the universe that become more deeply intelligible to us if they are viewed in a Trinitarian perspective. It seems to me that it would be perplexing for the Christian believer if no such indications could be found, but I also acknowledge that they will not prove to be of so unambiguous a kind as to force the minds of everyone necessarily into seeing things the way that I do. It is to be expected that God is neither totally hidden nor totally manifested in the works of creation. -John Polkinghorne, Science and the Trinity: The Christian Encounter with Reality, pp. xiii, 61.HT Alan Bevere
Friday, November 22, 2013
Begbie: music and perichoresis
Leithart:
Begbie uses musical categories to speak of perichoresis:
“When more than one sound is present, occupying the same space while remaining audibly distinct, we may speak of a space not of mutual exclusive but of ‘interpenetration.’ Sounds do not have to ‘cut each other off’ or obscure each other, in the manner of visually perceived objects. The tones of a chord can be heard sounding through each other. In the acoustic realm, in other words, there is no neat distinction between a place and its occupant.” Later he writes, “Music directly ‘pulls the strings,’ so to speak, of the spatial framework in which it is deployed – no neat divine marks off occupant and place in musical experience. We need only to think of a three-tone major chord, which we hear as three distinct, mutually enhancing (not mutually exclusive) sounds, but together occupying the same aural space.” Sounds occupy the space created by other sounds, and in occupying that space also create space for the sounds in which they exist. Each envelops each.
In Resounding Praise, he draws the Trinitarian implications directly: “What could be more apt than to speak of the Trinity as a three-note chord, a resonance of life; Father, Son, and Spirit mutually indwelling, without mutual exclusion, and yet without merger, each occupying the same space, ‘sounding through’ one another, yet irreducibly distinct, reciprocally enhancing, and establishing one another as other?”
To say that the Persons are in perichoretic communion is to say that God is music...link
--------------------------------
See also:
--------------------------------
See also:
Friday, August 30, 2013
Monday, June 24, 2013
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)











