Showing posts with label empire. Show all posts
Showing posts with label empire. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 24, 2015

have faith (and works), and speak to Herod's artificial line-mountain on the horizon

 (bonus points for anyone catching the two U2 references in my title)

I am all for '"you can move mountains" as radical charismatic faith...sometimes.
But as a corrective to the typical "speak to the mountain of your circumstance" interpretation,
Charles R. Page II is helpful.

Many have weighed in as to which mountain of the "this mountain" Jesus spoke of/to is in mind:.


  the temple itself (called a mountain in Isaiah 2; Isaiah 56 etc) ,
               Temple Mount (Joel Green/John Carroll says Jesus "could only mean" this),
                               Mt Zion,
                                      Mount of Olives.

Whichever candidate we  choose above (maybe all), the bottom line is the same: the whole temple system is under judgement and must go.  On that topic, see N.T. Wright in this video.   And this: "For Jesus, the time of the temple is no more.” -Green/ Carroll, “The Death of Jesus in Early Christianity,”).

BUT consider Ryland's first paragraph below:  Could the mountain  instead/also be Herod's Herodian?

ALSO consider the second paragraph as compelling alternative to "faith that can move mountains."
Could it be "faith and works"?"


Jesus was possibly passing along from Bethpage to the Mount of Olives when this teaching was offered.  From that from which they traveled one can see off on the horizon to the south the mountain fortress of the Herodian, Herod the Great's summer palace, some seven miles south of Jerusalem.  The Herodian fortress is built inside an artificial mountain that resembles a volcanic cone.  To create this structure, Herod the Great had the dirt removed from one hill and piled up on another.  It was hollow on the inside, and a very tall fortification wall surrounded its perimeter.  This is a mountain that was literally moved!

Furthermore, from the Mount of Olives, on a clear day, the Dead Sea is visible to the southeast.  In  the West we often misinterpret Jesus' meaning when he says we may move mountains, believing he is taking about magic, or perhaps telekenesis.  Yet this is a very practical teaching, conforming to practical Hillelian thought: 'You can do unbelievable things if you are willing to work.'  You can move mountains, but you must have faith to put a shovel into the ground and bend your back!
--Jesus and the Land,Charles R. Page II, p127-128



Related: On the Herodian symbolism to Jesus' subversion of empire:

"In the Shadow of Herod" video


Saturday, November 29, 2014

"Jesus didn’t cleanse the temple, he indicted it"

Rusty Butler:

Last week, Valerie encouraged us to look at the events of Palm Sunday and
to see in Jesus’ procession into the city of Jerusalem a counter parade to
the imperial/military parade that took place when the Roman Army
entered into Jerusalem at the beginning of the Passover celebration. On
one side of the city Pilot’s army comes thundering in with war horses, foot
soldiers, armor and swords, on the other side of the city, Jesus rides in on a
donkey a symbol of an entirely different kind of Kingship.

Was the parade enough of an affront to Pilot and the authorities to cause
Jesus death? If not, what else happened that week that propels the events
forward that culminate in Jesus death....

Well, a few questions spring to mind: Did Jesus do all this by himself? Or did
he have help from the disciples? Imagine this too..24 acres of open
courtyard. If Jesus and his followers had taken control of the entire
courtyard and held it for hours, the Imperial troops stationed at the
Fortress Antonia ....

...Some people call what Jesus did a Temple Tantrum, as if Jesus saw what
was going on and became surprised and then very angry that there were
such things going on. But the fact of the matter is, the buying and selling of
animals for sacrifice had been going on long before. Generations in fact,
even though before the courts were built, the buying and selling was to
have taken place away from the Temple proper.

Instead, I invite us to look at the act as an intentional one. One that is
strategically planned. Someone said, it is a symbolic act not unlike the Nuns
who broke into one of the missile silo sites and poured a vial of their blood over
the concrete missile site. That is a symbolic act, in no way do they
think they are bringing the entire nuclear missile program down, rather it is
supposed to suggest a stance, it makes a statement.

Think of what Jesus did in that way and it becomes something quite
different than a temper tantrum.

Most of us probably grew up knowing the story of Jesus overturning the
tables. And many of us probably heard that it had something to do with
people being cheated…during the buying and selling of animals and that
changing money should not be going on in a place of worship. In fact, we
talked about it on Wednesday at Bible study and each of us there has this
lingering sense that whenever we buy or sell something like Fairtrade
coffee or grocery certificates here at church we get a queasy feeling…that
that kind of thing should not be going on in a church…and that if Jesus
came back and saw that, he’d be distressed.

We grew up with that…but it is not the story.

For many, naming the story, the “cleansing of the temple” means that Jesus
sought to get rid of the money changers and vendors to purify the Temple.
But the fact is that this was a traditional practice, and the animal providers
and the money changers provided a service for the pilgrims and the
functioning of the temple. If you were a pilgrim who had traveled miles and
miles to get to Jerusalem, it was much more convenient to purchase your
sheep, cattle, dove at the temple than to bring it with you from home.
There is evidence according to Marcus Borg that the exchange rates were
closely regulated so the issue was not that pilgrims were being cheated by
these money changers.

So what was it that Jesus was taking exception to? Some have suggested it
was the animal sacrifice but Jesus mentions nothing about it. That seems
not to be the case either. As Mark tells the story, Jesus, after the turning of the
 tables teaches. And
this is what he says.
"Is it not written, My house shall be called a house of prayer for all nations?
But you have made it a den of robbers."
Herod had built the courts of the Gentiles so that people who were “all
nations” in other words, the gentiles could come to the Temple. That was
not the problem…The real key is the second sentence. You have made it a
den of robbers.

That phrase echoes a phrase found in the book of Jeremiah in the Old
Testament. Standing in the gates of the Temple, Jeremiah the prophet said
Do not trust in these deceptive words: This is the temple of the lord, the
temple of the lord, the temple of the Lord. He warns the people that the
Temple will be destroyed unless the people who worship there begin to
practice justice.

Listen to what he says: "If you truly amend your ways and doings, if you truly
act justly with one another , if you do not oppress the alien, the orphan and
the widow, or shed innocent blood in this place, and if you do not go after
other Gods to your own hurt, then I (God) will dwell with you in this place.
Then Jeremiah says, Has this house, (meaning the temple), which is called
by my name, become a den of robbers in your sight?"

The meaning seems to be, it was a den of robbers because it had become
the center of an oppressive system that did not practice justice but
exploited the most vulnerable in society. It was an indictment of the
powerful.

They thought of the temple as their safe house and a place of security. It
had become a hideout for the robbers of society. When Jesus calls the temple
a den of robbers, he was rather indicting the
temple authorities who had collaborated with the Romans at the top of the
system. Jesus didn’t cleanse the temple, he indicted it....



...When we think about the fact that we are the followers of a person who
strategically made moves against the authorities when he felt the system
they represented and led was unjust…it may begin to creep into our minds
that this Jesus was about more than just getting people into heaven…and it
may even change what we think about who we are as Christians.   link

Monday, August 25, 2014

the "elegance of language" allows a crude "loud fart": prophetic paranomoasia and structural synesthesia in Isaiah 5:7

The  multiplex literary canvas of Isaiah 5 includes the well-known  verse 7 phenomenon of...well, a very little-known literary term,  paranomoasia (Paronomasia - Merriam-Webster Online).
 You might call it a pun or a play on words; but hey, impress your friends by calling it a proleptic and prophetic  paranomoasia.  Or   "paranomoasia plus"  (:





I looked for justice,  but I saw oppression.
I looked for  righteousness, but I heard an outcry (of pain).

justice   (A)                           oppression  (B)
righteousness  (A)                 outcry   (B)

--

Jim posts:

Since I’m presently working on Isaiah for the series it’s only natural that I’d wind up in Chapter 5 with it’s stunningly beautiful pun

לְמִשְׁפָּט֙ וְהִנֵּ֣ה מִשְׂפָּ֔ח לִצְדָקָ֖ה וְהִנֵּ֥ה צְעָקָֽה׃

God looked for justice (mishpat) but only saw oppression (mispach). God looked for righteousness (tzedakah) and instead he heard an outcry of pain (tz’acha).
This pun is virtually impossible to render in English. The Common English Bible tries, but meets the same resistance as every other rendition has-
God expected justice, but there was bloodshed; righteousness, but there was a cry of distress!
The REB is essentially the same. What this shows, it seems to me, is that the rendition of puns from one language to another is excessively difficult. Perhaps translators, and especially commentators, should indicate the pun in transliteration in a footnote or in their comments so that readers of English can at least have some sense of the beauty and brilliance of the underlying original. link



Or try this on:

and he looked for justice — Both the administration of justice by magistrates, and justice in the dealings of the people with one another: but behold oppression — From the powerful upon their inferiors; and for righteousness — For equity, mercy, and benevolence; but behold a cry — From the oppressed, crying to men for help, and to God for vengeance. “The paronomasia, or play on the words, in the Hebrew, in this place, is very remarkable;mispat, mispach; zedakah, zeakah. There are many examples of it in the other prophets; but Isaiah seems peculiarly fond of it. The rabbis esteem it a great beauty: their term for it is, elegance of language.” — Bishop Lowth, in Benson Commmentary

I have color coded the words above to highlight the obvious contrasts between what God was looking for, and what he found.  This the vertical connections:

Justice                                           oppression
righteousness                                  ":cry 

But  once one reads the above in the original Hebrew, it;s clear the color-coding should (also) work horizontally:

mispat                                            mispach

zedakah                                         ze'akah

AA
BB



I keep expecting this to create a chiasm; but it's   a powerful punch of a  paranomoasia  kind of parallelism.

And to reinforce the contrast, another striking feature: a kind of structural synesthesia in the league of Revelations 1:8's  "I turned to see the voice."
Did you notice the (literally) non-sensical:


I looked for justice,  but I saw oppression.
I looked for  righteousness, but I heard an outcry (of pain).

How do you hear something you're looking for??
(See Webb's "The Divine Voice" and Cytowic's "The Man Who Tasted Shapes")

Brueggemann quips about this exact literary/thematic connection and it's practical application:,"This comes as close to a  synergism as a Calvinist could want" (Using God's Resources Widely," p. 49; he also spins this out in another article.
The prophetic pronouncement is devastating. And it took a lovely literary "elegance of language" to provide the ugly practical app.  The words must have landed like...well, in Eugene Peterson's classic line about  yet another poetic device, metaphor... " a loud fart in the salon of spirituality."



Being quite steeped in Scripture (and known to love Isaiah), I think Bono nodded to Isaiah's pun (and maybe a line from a Jackie Pullinger book)  in his live introduction to "Last Night on Earth"  (See  "I wanted to know Jesus, but you gave me a library").

Tuesday, August 19, 2014

Paul asks Philemon to "illegally" welcome Onesimus

In two places, Shane Claiborne suggests  Paul asks Philemon to engage in civil disobedience by "illegally" welcoming Onesimus:

 "...we find that Paul offered a biting critique of power and a creative path of revolutionary love. We might remember Paul urging his friend Philemon to illegally welcome back home a fugitive slave, Onesimus, as a brother, instead of killing him for running away. This is a scandalous subversion of Roman hierarchy. Paul was just as radical as Jesus. Remember that the Paul who "be subject to the authorities" is the same Paul who was stoned, exiled, jailed, and beaten for subverting the authorities... Is it possible to submit and to subvert? Paul's life gives a clear yes, as does Jesus' crucifixion" (Jesus For President, 161).


Paul's letter to Philemon was written to urge a former slave owner to illegally welcome back a fugitive slave (Onesimus)—a crime punishable by death—not as a slave but as a brother-Follow Me to Freedom, p. 134 (hear Ken and I interview Shane about this book here)

Wednesday, June 25, 2014

videos from Christian Political Witness Conference

Speakers include William Cavanaugh,Stanley Hauerwaus, Peter Leithart, Jennifer McBride .
All videos here.
Richard Beck reviews/summarizes the books based on the conference here.


Monday, June 23, 2014

Where the leitourgia has no shame: Christus Victor/ trickster calls to worship?

photo credit
Hat tip to Beth for my title; and my apologies to her for my twisting it.
Her wonderful chapter on "Where the Leitourgua has No Name: U2 Live" should be read well by the well-read   (it's in this book; for more on  leitourgia, see this),

Actually, the way I nodded to her title and tweaked it is itself perhaps a cheap example of the liturgical experimentation I am encouraging below.  Hopefully you will get the reference.
(As Beth herself has confessed about me, I can be "ever-prolix"  (:..)

Paul Ryan blogs:


One ordinary Sunday morning, I sat in my pew praying customary words of confession and hearing familiar words of assurance. My pastor announced, as he did every Sunday, “God assures us with these words of pardon . . .” But at that moment, the words surprised me. Immediately, I turned to my wife and whispered excitedly, “Pardon! That’s an image of the atonement!”
I had been studying notes outlining five images of the atonement: Christus Victor, ransom, penal substitution, sacrifice, and moral example. My professor, John Witvliet, had encouraged us to consider how we might balance these images in worship. That morning, I realized that the word pardon is a courtroom image (penal substitution). And I realized that we had been introducing our words of assurance with this image exclusively.
Since that day, I’ve been reflecting on how we might enrich and balance our confession through attention to other images of the atonement... LINK

SOO..what would it sound/look like to  shamelessly incorporate into corporate worship/leitourgia a shameless 
I don't know what it would look ;ike..maybe a high church Zoo TV? (:
Think of ...and suggest below...some practical examples of  such creative calls to worship, collects etc..

I know this next example is taking it too far; but I remember Shawn Rabon and I thinking out loud how to gently satirize   (Yes, I know "gently satirize" is oxymoronic, but...) the tendency of some Christians to, during prayer meetings, address Satan more than God.  We wondered if opening a meeting with "Dear Satan"  would make the point. (:



Wednesday, February 19, 2014

Brian Zahnd's Problem With the Bible

My Problem With the Bible
Brian Zahnd
I have a problem with the Bible. Here’s my problem… continued

Sunday, January 12, 2014

Philemon doing more than Paul asks = ?

Ben Witheringtom on NT Wright's take on Philemon:
When I say that Tom is a global thinker, I also am referring to the fact that he wants to take a holistic approach when it comes to Pauline ethics as well as Pauline theology. The two need to be discussed together, indeed the two belong together and are co-entailed. In one sense ethics involves the living out of one’s theology, living out what God is working in the community to live and to do. Belief and behavior are two sides of one coin, in one sense. Or as Tom puts it in regard to Philemon, the reason it is necessary for Philemon to do what Paul is urging him to do is because of who Christ is— a God who is reconciling the world to himself, and wants reconciliation to be the signature of the relationships within his community.
Tom’s account of Philemon stresses that the main point of the letter is to get Onesimus and Philemon reconciled, back sharing koinonia, as it were. He takes it as possible secondary implications that: 1) Paul wants Philemon to manumit his slave, and 2) to perhaps send him back to Paul to work with him.
I actually think this does not go far enough. When Paul says quite literally in vs. 16 that Philemon should receive Onesimus back “no longer (ouketi) as a slave but above and beyond (hyper) the slave category as a beloved brother in Christ, especially so to me, and how much more to you even in the flesh and also in the Lord” he is indeed making an emancipation proclamation that comports with the implications of Gal. 3.28. In Christ there should be no slave or free (see the work of Scott Bartchy, especially his article published on this blog months ago).
While I agree with Tom that Paul is not like a modern Fredrick Douglas nor is he an ancient capitulator to the existing slave system. He is instituting reform within the context of the Christian community, not in society in general. And in this case the reform involves a fundamental principle– if one is a brother in Christ he should be treated as a person, and no longer as a piece of property, a slave. And Paul is insistent on this matter, speaking of Philemon’s obedience and threatening a coming visit. I take the ‘you will do even more’ to mean even more than manumit, namely sending him off to work with Paul.
What I especially find strange in the sublimating of Paul’s spinning out the social implications of reconciliation is that Tom is one of the big proponents of Paul’s anti-imperial rhetoric. Jesus is Lord and Caesar is not. Christ is the reality of which Caesar is the parody, and so on. But it is precisely that imperial ideology that had led to the enslaving of a huge portion of the population of the Roman Empire. Most slaves became slaves as fortunes, or better said misfortunes, of war.
Paul surely knows this, and since Paul was a global thinker he surely would have realized that opposing imperial ideology involves opposing the enslaving of much of the world. If Caesar is not the Christian’s lord, then Christians do not have to obey the dictates of Caesar when it comes to the slave trade. Paul is working for change within the context of the Christian community, not in society at large, but he is working at it, as Philemon shows, and as C.F. D. Moule was to say, Philemon provided the ammunition in early Christianity for a strong opposition to the contradiction in terms implied in having a Christian slave. Moule in fact suggests Paul provides here the depth charge which would eventually blow up the institution of slavery.
It is important however to end this post on a positive note, as there is so much to learn from Tom’s excellent reflections in his first major chapter (74 pages long). It is useful to remind ourselves of Tom’s helpful reiteration of his approach to texts and realia both ancient and modern– namely critical realism. Here is what he says it is, “a self-critical epistemology which in rejecting naive realism which simply imagines we are looking at the material with a God’s-eye view, rejects also the narcissistic reductionism of imagining that all apparent perception is in fact projection, that everything is really going on inside our own heads. Critical realism engages determinedly in a many-sided conversation, both with the data itself and with others (including scholars) who are also engaging with it. The conversation aims not at unatttainable objectivity, but at truth nonetheless, the truth in which the words we use and the stories we tell increasingly approximate to the reality of another world, in the historian’s case, the world of the past.” (p. 51)  link

Monday, December 09, 2013

Antiochus Redivivus

Just as we shouldn't read the "temple tantrum" texts without getting the Antiochus Epiphanes/Judah the Hammerer connection (as N.T. Wright reminds), it's good to connect the Christmas/slaughter of the innocents story to  Antiochus Epiphanes as well (as Craig Keener reminds below:

....Regardless of how much Matthew's original audience knew about Herod's brutality, however, they could envision him like the anti-Jewish tyrant Antiochus IV Epiphanes, who also slaughtered Jewish babies. Most of all, they would associate Herod's behavior with that of Pharaoh of old, who killed baby Israelite boys in Moses's day. Ironically, it is Egypt that here provides Jesus's family refuge, and in the angel's later words to Joseph ("Return to Israel, for those who wanted to kill the child are dead") Matthew echoes God's words to Moses: "Return to Egypt, for those who wanted you dead are now dead themselves." Political corruption makes Jesus's own home the most dangerous place for him...link

Practical implication:

If made explicit, such contrasts between the political king and his new rival could connote treason, but the rest of Luke-Acts shows that Jesus and his followers are not out to violently overthrow the empire. Rather, they work for change as they pray for the coming of God's kingdom.

What we learn from the first "Christmas stories," then, is more than a challenge against seasonal greed, gluttony, and grudging giving. It challenges us to consider to which king our loyalty lies. Do we pledge first allegiance to those who achieve power by violence, intrigue, and economic or political exploitation? Does it matter where our wealth and merchandise come from? Or do we pledge first allegiance to different values, identifying with those in need and working for peace and justice in the world?

If it is the latter, these are values not only meant to be celebrated during Christmas season. In both the Gospels of Matthew and Luke the earliest scenes of Jesus pave the way for the rest of his ministry of healing and restoration and its culminating conflict in his execution by those who considered him a threat. In context, then, these first stories about Jesus's birth challenge us to follow his sacrificial way of life, no matter what it costs us.   link

Wednesday, November 20, 2013

Dylan finally releases video for "Like a Rolling Stone"...and it's interactive

Check out the story:
One of the best music videos of 2013 belongs to a 48-year-old song. The interactive video for Bob Dylan's "Like a Rolling Stone," released yesterday, is a tour de force: as the music plays, you can flip between sixteen channels of simulated TV programming. But whether you're watching a financial news update, a romantic comedy, or a tennis tournament, it looks authentic except that everyone seems to be lip-synching the lyrics of the song. While many of the channels are peopled by actors, the lineup is peppered with numerous celebrity performers such as comedian Marc Maron, rapper Danny Brown, the hosts of Pawn Stars, and Drew Carey (on the set of The Price Is Right). The overall effect is head-spinning but incredibly compelling: the more you surf through the "Like a Rolling Stone" video, the more the song's contempt seems to be addressed to all of western civilization. By the time you land on a vintage live performance of the actual Bob Dylan, he feels like the only real person in existence. 

"The effect can only be surrealistic if the channels are realistic," says Vania Heymann, the video's 27-year-old Israeli director. "In reality, channel-flipping is a very passive act. You're sitting back in your house, doing nothing. We wanted to make it an active thing, reediting the song itself to make a new version."
The video took about two   continued

Let me just say, watching it on "The Price is Right" channel is spooky; chilling.  Brilliant and prophetic (see: 

Trickster Dylan: Jeremiah inside empire).   As one of Bob's friends (see the "us vs. them" 

Jeriah sneer of Dylan once said, "Watch more TV".


Official video link here; embedded below


Monday, November 11, 2013

complete video of "Acts:the Heaven on Earth Show" by "the old, boring British guy" N.T. Wright

..along with some study questions I posted for my students (to keep them engaged with what one student called "that old boring British guy...his voice puts me to sleep".. (:

Parts 1-6:
 1)Define "Kingdom of God/heaven"
2)Did Jesus come to restore the Kingdom in Acts 1:1-11?
3)What is the sign-ificance of the ascension?
4)What are three possible answers to "where do heaven and earth overlap/interlock"?
5)What is announced in the first half of Acts?  The second half?
6)Where is earth's "control room"?
7)What is "apotheosis"?





------------- 
Part 7:

1)How might our Myers-Briggs personalty difference affect how we read the Bible/Acts?
(particularly STs vs  NFs...for explanation, see this).
2)Why is resurrection important?
3)Why is the Spirit poured out?
4)What does it mean for Jesus to bring a theocracy?
 5Which Old Testament book is helpful to understand this section of Acts?



Part 8:




1)In the first half of Acts, Jesus is announced as ____________.

This leads inevitably to a conflict with _________/

2_two key themes: a)K________  b)T_________

3)What do kings do?  They _____________temples.

4)Reading the OT, even the last book (Malachi), what was the state of the temple?

5)What is the tension in Acts 2?  If Jesus and the______ are the temple, problems exist with ______________.

6)Draw and label  chart of this first half of Acts which includes the bookends, the capstone, and the events on either side of the capstone.  Give chapter and verse references.
7). If the __________ is the alternate __________, then __________________________________________________.
8(What are the four SIGNS of the church living as the new ________?
The signs result in a)__________________  b)_________________
9)The church is a family business, not ____________________/


Part 9:

1)"No needy among them" is a reference to Deut 15 and 16.  The reason no one was in need

is because they saw themselves as living in _____________.
2)They were behaving as people who  ____________________.
3)Maybe the fact that we don't see a lot of ________________ today is related
to the fact that we don't see a lot of _____________.
4)Tension: disciples were going to __________ yet living as if they were __________.
5). "It's not us; it's what God has _________________."
6)It's more about where we are in the story, than about ____________________.


Part 10:

1)What's more important than your individual resurrection someday is

_____________________

2)Resurrection splits into two: a) ______  b)_____

3)Again, we learn how important it is the get the context and historical world

of which  Old Testament book?





Part 11:

1)Draw a chart labeling the two extremes of a New Testament political theology, and

the two  candidates for the possible balancing components which prevents  the extremes.

2)They/we need to learn to navigate being faithful to _____________ and

obeying _________.

3)Pattern: When the church trusts God, they find _______________.

4)The Hebrew vs. Hellenist problem only existed because the believers were ___________.

5)Steven's sermon is the ___________ of this whole section, and its whole point is that we are the true ________.  Within this main point, two subpoints: a)God sends _______________

b)People are always guilty of ______________, particularly of the __________.

6)______________ is only an advanced signpost.  Signposts are saying "Don't ___________."

Part 12:

1)The specific is to benefit the __________.

2(Draw a chart which places Paul's conversion in between two other episodes.

The point: Paul's idea of reaching the Gentiles was not a new idea.

3)Phillip quotes Isaiah 53, which we think is all about the cross and individual salvation (and

it is, but this leads to Isaiah 54 which is about _____, and Isaiah 56, which is about membership granted to ___________ and __________.

Part 13:

1)On his way to conversion, Paul may well have been practicing the meditation of the

_____________________.

2)Paul realized that --regarding everything he stood for:

a)Everything is ______________  b)Everything is ________.

3)When Wright talks about clean/unclean, draw this as a bounded set.





parts 14-26 here:











Monday, November 04, 2013

Kraybill on Jesus' upside-down fumigating of the temple

Due to Kraybill's "The Upside Down Kingdom" being (for now) readable online and Google-able  here on ISSUU (along with several theological book en espanol here),  it is nice to be able post the key sections on the temple tantrum here in one place. (see what you think about this publishing model here).
Note: a previous edition of the book is complete  and downloadable here on Scribd..

1)Page 53:

Purging the temple of moneychangers wasn't a mandate for violence..Had a major riot erupted the 600 Roman soldiers in Fort Antonia, overlooking the temple, would have quickly intervened. The temple drama was a prophetic  condemnation of profiteering by money and a sign that the temple should be opened for Gentile worship The prophetic Word--not action--stood at the center of the temple purge  

2)In a section "Fumigating the Temple,"  that is pp 150-152 in the current edition, here is the text in the older edition (161-63):





3)Page 202:
The Gentile vision  flashes through the Gospels in other places as well.  Jesus sends out seventy missionaries, a number symbolizing the wholeness and completeness of his mission (luke 10:1)  He instructs the disciples to be light and salt, not just within Judaism but in the whole world (Matt. 5:13-14.  He chases the money changers from the temple's outer court so it can be a house of prayer for all nations (Mark 11:17) Jesus' earthly sojourn begins and ends in “Galilee of the Gentiles” where his  disciples receive a final mandate to go and make disciples of all nations (Matt. 28:19)

4) page 275 footnote 15:

Kelber expands the traditional interpretation that the temple  cleansing was done primarily to open up the outer court to the Gentiles.   He also suggests that the prohibition to carry vessels had more religious significance than stopping people who were taking a shortcut through the temple.  Sanders contends that the temple incident was not merrly chasing out moneychangers  or“cleansing” the temple for the purpose of restoring it to routine operation.  It was rather a defiant public act directed against the temple itself, and it was and it was this provocative act that more than any other led to Jesus' death.  Myers argues that the temple was fundamentally an economic institution  and sees Jesus taking symbolic direct action against the temple operation.
Here below is the current edition embedded:

Eugene Peterson: the plagues and temple cleansing as exorcism of evil imagination

 Eugene Peterson:

The ten plagues were employed to expose the emptiness of evil, to purge the Hebrew minds of all envious admiration of evil, to systematically demolish every god-delusion or god-pretention that evil uses to exercise power over men and women. … Each of the ten plagues was an ammonia-laced scrub-bucket of suds for just such a cleaning. … 

The ten plagues were an elaborate exorcism, a casting out of the demons, that freed the imagination of the Hebrews form domination by evil so that they were free to hear and follow their Savior and worship God “in spirit and truth” (John 4:24). When Moses began his work with his Hebrew brothers and sisters, their spirits were “broken” (Exod. 6:9) and the only “truth” they had access to was this huge Egyptian lie. But Egypt and Pharaoh were not the “real world.” They were the real world defaced, desecrated, demonized. …

 The exorcising drama of the ten plagues freed the Brews from this Egyptian way of understanding reality, clearing the mind to accept God’s revelation reality, energizing their spirits to live in the world of salvation. The intent was that by the time they left Egypt, they would not only be physically free of the evil oppression but mentally free of the evil imagination that had crushed the life out of them for so long. The ten plagues would cleanse the “doors of perception” so that Israel could see life in a totally different way – the unreality of Egypt exposed; the untruth of Egypt laid bare – and would set them free to live a different life when they get out of Egypt, free to live the freedom of salvation..

Jesus in his temple cleansing compressed the eight-month drama of the ten plagues exorcism into the work of  a single day..

....In the act of cleansing the temple, he cleansed people’s understanding, purged their imagination--an exorcism so that the people, clear-eyed on the matter of God’s sovereign authority, would be able to embrace salvation without distraction, without clutter.  We carch a clear echo of the ten plagues in the temple cleansing.

...The work continues, the work of the ten plagues...the cleansing of the temple.. This is a  major and never-ending task, this exorcism of the culture's lies
and pretensions from the Christian imagination so that God’s sovereignty in history can be received in a life large with salvation  --Christ Plays in Ten Thousand Places, pp. 165-169
Read this whole section here

Wednesday, October 30, 2013

"Free your mind and your ass will follow" -Bono Subversio Vox

I'm sure some never got the reference to Bono's (punch)line in this 1994  acceptance speech. I had to google it myself..
.
It's from the 1971 Funkadelic song  by the same name:

Free your mind and your ass will follow:


The kingdom of heaven is within
Open up your funky mind and you can fly
 Free your mind and your ass will follow
 The kingdom of heaven is within

How would you interpret Bono's  use of that line in the context of the speech?
Funny the post on SongMeanings suggest the meaning is obvious (:
It can't be (just) a throwaway chance to use "colorful" language..
It's always about subversio..and always prayer to Bono Vox.
Achtung, Sitz Im Leben, Baby!
Get on your boots..

Friday, October 25, 2013

Eller's zanily prophetic framework for not framejacking the episode formerly known as the temple tantrum

meme by Quaid
Here's an excerpt from a great book that surprisingly few know about (Greg Boyd interacts with it.  See A Critique of Eller's Thesis  andA Defense of Eller's Thesis)

Don't avoid the book  because you fear it's trying to convert you (violently) to pacifism.
It's not. 
 Vernard Eller's "War and Peace: From Genesis to Revelation" is creative, simple/profound, prophetic 

...and funny!

Funny? 
In this review of a previous version of the book, Ratzlaff called it "zany."   Oh, click that link to see the zany name the book originally had.

In a remembrance in Christianity Today, David Neff celebrated Eller as The Mad Theologian.
He was master of the heterolitic ...and hugely helpful...metaphor (church as ballerina, misguided church as antacid, in this one book alone).

  So buy it already.  (You won't be surprised to hear that he also wrote "The Sex Manual for Puritans)

I had to take the trouble/time to type out the follwing section on the temple tantrum (I'll have to quit calling it that, Eller suggests a better name) as (amazingly) it appears nowhere online (Many of Eller's other books are a free read online, click here).  This section doesn't have much Ellerian mad zaniness, but should be wrestled with.    Often we eisegete an "alien template" in reading the scriptures, especially such a "mad, zany"  one as the temple encounter(acted parable/guerilla theatre).  Granted, you may need to read the whole book to get all Eller means by the Zion/purgation cycle (hint: the  'reverse fighting"  motif of the  subversively Suffeing Servant, and God  temporarily using Holy War/enemes to fight against ..not for..Israel).  Also, for context, I have posted the amazing Chapter 8 for my students here):

 

...the cleansing of the temple, Jesus' condemning of the corruption and the chasing out of its money men and their animals.  However, more than any of the other writres , Matthew again points us to an  interpretation of the incident.  All that is required to bring the matte clear is to change the customary label from "the cleansing of the temple" to "the purgation of Zion" and recall the words of Isaiah:

1 25 I will attack you;
I will purify your metal with flux.
I will remove all your slag.
26 I will reestablish honest judges as in former times,
wise advisers as in earlier days.
Then you will be called, ‘The Just City,
Faithful Town.’”
27 Zion will be freed by justice,
and her returnees by righteousness
An even clearer precedent comed from Malachi..It represents the late  prophetic tradition and focuses almost exclusively upon the "purgation of Zion" rather than upon the Zion Cycle in its entirety--although there are clues to indicate that the writer was aware of the larger picture.  But in any case, these are the words which surely must form the setting within which Jesus' action must be understood

Malachi 3:1-4

New English Translation (NET)
3 1 “I am about to send my messenger, who will clear the way before me. Indeed, the Lord you are seeking will suddenly come to his temple, and the messenger of the covenant, whom you long for, is certainly coming,” says the Lord who rules over all.
2 Who can endure the day of his coming? Who can keep standing when he appears? For he will be like a refiner’s fire, like a launderer’s soap. 3 He will act like a refiner and purifier of silver and will cleanse the Levites and refine them like gold and silver. Then they will offer the Lord a proper offering. 4 The offerings of Judah and Jerusalem will be pleasing to the Lord as in former times and years past.
 Put it within the Zion framework and rename it "the purgation of Zion," and the cleansing of the temple becomes so "right" and so properly situated that it must be that Jesus himself was thinking in "Zion" terms.  The purgation of Zion, which triggers Jesus' crucifixion, itself points to the stroke of the "sword not of man which in its striking heals"  What other alignment would makes sense?

Matthew puts it on the track of this interpretation in away that the other gospel writers do not, because his account includes an element the others lack, namely a description of Zion purged,  The verses following the cklean sing read

Matthew 21:14 The blind and lame came to him in the temple courts, and he healed them. 15 But when the chief priests and the experts in the law saw the wonderful things he did and heard the children crying out in the temple courts, “Hosanna to the Son of David,” they became indignant 

The Messiah (at least for the moment and in as symbolic way) has with justice redeemed Zion and restored her tio what she was meant to be, a center of healing and servant m inistry for the world.

Because the temple incident figures so large in current thought, we need to comment further.  This event constitutes the golden text of the Bible for many pacifists; in fact, some of them give the impression thatt it is the only text they know.  It forms the rationale for those who feel the need top become quite militant in their peacemaking.  Aggressive confrontation is their style; and they claim to be following the temple-cleansing Jesus in applying something of his technique to the White House, Pentagon a nd Selective Service offices.
  

But it won't wash; it won't even begin to wash!  If what Jesus performed was the purgation of Zion, then it was not in any sense an act of human political activism...There is no suggestion at all that this is an aspect of his  work in which he called his dsiciples to share..

...But if Christians are to find their place within the model of the cleansing of the temple,it is as Zion (=Israel=the new Israel).  The passage calls for them to open themselves to purging by God so that, as delivered Zion, they are ready to perform a healing and foot-washing ministry to the world..

...there is a further line of thought that relates to  the purgation of Zion.  In Matthew and some of the other accounts...abd once, in Acts..the charge is brought that Jesus had talked about how he would destroy the temple and rebuild it...the most likely explanation would seem to be that Jesus had spoken of the purgration  of Zion and his words had been misunderstood and/or distorted.

..Finally, in Matthew 23, within Jesus condemnation of Scribes and Pharisees., there is a passage that rellated strongly to the purgation of Zion:

37 “O Jerusalem, Jerusalem, you who kill the prophets and stone those who are sent to you! How often I have longed to gather your children together as a hen gathers her chicks under her wings, but you would have none of it! 38 Look, your house is left to you desolate! 39 For I tell you, you will not see me from now until you say, ‘Blessed is the one who comes in the name of the Lord!’”



The lament does not describe the entire action., of course.  Nevertheless, we need always to remember the NT understanding pf peace goes deep enough that it can call for and include a painful yet creative purgation of Zion, the holy community which will become, in turn, an instrument for the healing of the world.  Truly Christian peacemakers must themselves be open  to the  purging of God  (pp 131-133)