Showing posts with label Spirit Christology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Spirit Christology. Show all posts

Friday, May 08, 2015

figural Christology: reading backwards within the flowing stream of time

 Scot McKnight:


Believing to Understand

Richard Hays on figural Christology.

by Scot McKnight

What disturbs the professor is that so many read their New Testaments with nary a glance at the Scripture reference notes in the central column of many Bibles or printed in the footnotes in others. What disturbs the reader is what one finds when one pursues those cross-reference suggestions.

We need go no further than Matthew's first chapter. The original woman in mind in the famous "the virgin will conceive" was a "young woman" already married to Isaiah and pregnant and soon to bear a child. But the Greek translation, the Septuagint, turned the Hebrew almah into parthenos, which meant "virgin." Matthew, knowing Jesus was born of a virgin, chose the latter on which to hang this profound interpretation of the conception and birth of Jesus. In chapter 2, the holy couple, after having spent time in safety in Egypt, return—and Matthew finds a golden egg in a text that had nothing to do with the Messiah. Matthew brings rugged realities and scriptural patterns together: If Jesus is the Son of God, if he spent time in Egypt, if YHWH called Israel his Son and out of Egypt summoned them to the Land of Israel, then Jesus somehow needs to be seen fulfilling that text too. It's all in Matthew 2:1-15. Or take John 5:46, which tells us in the words of Jesus "If you believed Moses, you would believe me, for he wrote about me." If there is so much Jesus in Moses, why did so few recognize him when he came? Over and over we see this interpretive approach to the "Old Testament" when we pay close attention to the cross references in our Bible, at once opening a world of glorious discovery and faith and re-imagining history and at the same time provoking us into pondering what kind of readings these early Christian hermeneuts were offering their readers.

....The grip of historical method has historians by the neck, but not so the new "theological interpretation of the Bible" crowd, now on full and detailed display in the Brazos Theological Commentary on the Bible. For the historians, what the original author meant—only what he (or she) meant—is all that matters; for the theological interpreters, while authorial intent certainly matters, it is not all that matters. What matters perhaps more is what mattered to Jesus and the apostles, and what mattered to them is now mattering more and more to Christian readers of the Bible. The tight grip of the historians has been loosened. More and more we are learning to see the Bible as an inter- and intra-textual reality; only by embracing its central vision—Jesus as Messiah—can one read that Bible well.

Richard B. Hays, in the published version of his Hulsean Lectures in Cambridge, Reading Backwards: Figural Christology and the Fourfold Gospel Witness, proposes that Jesus read the events of his life "backwards" and in so doing taught Christians how to read the Old Testament "forwards." As he puts it, "the Gospels teach us how to read the OT, and—at the same time—the OT teaches us how to read the Gospels. Or, to put it a little differently, we learn to read the OT by reading backwards from the Gospels, and—at the same time—we learn how to read the Gospels by reading forwards from the OT."

Hays opens by appealing to the term "figural" to describe this backwards reading, and so we hear Erich Auerbach boiled down into New Testament hermeneutics:

There is consequently a significant difference between prediction andprefiguration. Figural reading need not presume that the OT authors—or the characters they narrate—were conscious of predicting or anticipating Christ. Rather, the discernment of a figural correspondence is necessarily retrospective rather than prospective. (Another way to put this point is that figural reading is a form of intertextual interpretation that focuses on an intertextuality ofreception rather than of production.)

That is, time and later perspective generate new readings:
Because the two poles of a figure are events within "the flowing stream" of time, the correspondence can be discerned only after the second event has occurred and imparted a new pattern of significance to the first. But once the pattern of correspondence has been grasped, the semantic force of the figure flows both ways, as the second event receives deeper significance from the first.
Hays, well known for his brilliant studies of how Paul read the Bible,[3] is concerned in this book with the Gospels, so we are treated to four separate, succinct introductory essays into how the Evangelists read the Bible backwards. The result is a masterpiece. Hays shows that the Evangelists had a "high" Christology, one that was shaped by the divine identity of Jesus... Matthew, Hays concludes, is not so indirect {as Mark}.  Indeed, he says Matthew "is producing an annotated study Bible, providing notes and references that will give the uninitiated reader enough information to perform the necessary interpretation." One quick reading of texts like Matthew 24:15, which updates Mark's more allusive reference in Mark 13:14, is enough to see Matthew's annotations in context. But there's far more to Matthew than this, as we indicated in the opening paragraph above. For Matthew, Jesus is Immanuel, God's presence among us—seen in worshiping Jesus (14:33) and in Jesus as present (18:20) as well as in his promise of continued presence (28:20). Matthew "believes and proclaims that Jesus is the embodied presence of God and that to worship him is to worship YHWH—not merely an agent or a facsimile or in intermediary"—and this takes a unique form: "the one who was crucified and raised from the dead is himself the embodiment of the God who rules over all creation and abides with his people forever."

...The historian and the apologist may cry out for a place at the table, but the hermeneutical loop eventually closes in and begs the reader to believe. For such a reader, believing that Jesus is the Son of God, the Bible suddenly makes (new) sense. Can any Bible reader not recognize what John does in 1:1 when he says all over again "In the beginning"? But now something has changed. Jesus has been inserted into the narrative, and the beginning has been christologically reframed: the Logos, Jesus, the Son of God, the Messiah, the incarnate one, is the Creator and the Life who gives eternal life. Whether it is the Temple (John 2:13-22) or the feasts of Israel (John 10:22-30; 19:14), under John's guidance they are all about Jesus—and the reader who sees they are about Jesus can rightly understand what the Temple and the feasts were designed to do. What then is John's approach? "John understands Scripture as a huge web of signifiers generated by the pretemporal eternal Logos as intimations of his truth and glory."  LINK

Wednesday, September 10, 2014

Blake on ecclesiology, profane becoming sacred, and thinking against oneself

It's kind of freaky that just a few days ago--before you and I had any idea that U2's surprise releases
would be called "Songs of Innocence" and "Songs of Experience"..

..I pulled out two books:


One theory is that "The Joshua Tree" was to be a double album; one disc "Songs of Innocence" and the other  "Songs of Experience".

One reviewer headlined a review of U2's "Pop" as  More Songs of Innocence and Experience.


One can see why Bono likes Blake. From Inchausti:

If one were to seek the great archetypal  precursor for prophetic Christian thinker championing the soul's return from the spiritual exile of Enlightenment rationalism, William Blake comes very close to casting the mold.  Condemned as heretical by some and as too orthodox by others, he was one of the first to point out exactly how the new sciences were distorting the role of the imagination in human affairs and putting the soul to sleep.
          Altizer  and Hamilton..described Blake's contribution to Western thought
Blake was the first of the modern seers.  Through Blake we can sense the theological significance of a poetic reversal of our mythical traditions, and become open to the possibility that the uniquely modern metamorphosis of the sacred into the profane is the culmination of a redemptive and kenotic movement of the Godhead
          This, I think, is an essentially accurate description of Blake's intellectual influence.
           I would, however, reverse the figure and the field.  Blake does not celebrate the sacred 
           becoming profane, but the profane becoming sacred.
                   
....Blake reminds us again and again that true knowledge--that is to say, knowledge of our ontological status as creatures made in the image of God--cannot be grasped by calculation; only through a vision.  And vision--in its most concentrated and inclusive firm --is what psychoanalysts call the "imago," an internal picture that transform s facts into meanings..


..His theme is that the church lost its radical energy by giving up its apocalyptic vision for a more accommodating set of doctrines, and so the church became more hierarchical and tradition-bound at the very moment it should have become more democratic and imaginative..

Christian thought critiques mainstream culture but also sees itself under judgment; our best modern Christian intellectuals have turned thinking against themselves into a veritable art form: from Blake to Dostoyevsky, from Kierkegaard to Chesterton, all the way to Dorothy Day and Walker Percy, the exemplary mode of Christian thought has been a triadic structure of self-reflection, paradox and irony that reverses the values of this world and the logic of cause and effect  pp 19-28, 178



Wednesday, November 13, 2013

my pet S-words

This is no skubala: several of my areas of study are "S-words"
I bet no one has ever preached a sermon with an alliterative outline like this:
  • simulacra
  • semiotics/signs
  • synesthesia
  • set theory
  • Sephardic
  • sound theory
  • Sapir-Whorf hypothesis
  •  
  • string theory
  • Spirit Christology
  • Spanish Language and Culture (my major)
  • Second Corinthians
  • Second Timothy
  • Sermon on the Mount
  • self-disclosure
  •  
  • sexuality/spirituality
  • subversion
  • structure of Matthew
  • subversion
  • Second Temple Judaism

Friday, October 11, 2013

temptations: leaping their scattergories and not to be listened to...and feeling hunger/beauty as pain

Among the interesting takes Anne Rice weaves into her "Christ the Lord:   The Road to Cana" account of Jesus experiencing the temptations in the wilderness is that she seems to suggest a "cross-mingling" (synesthesia?) of the temptations.

I have spent so much time with students on the taxonomy of the individual "testations" (see chart below, and these links : Timelines and Testations: Jesus, Sexonomics and Facebook  
that Jesus experiencing
hunger during the temple temptation got me thinking about how temptations can comingle/cotempt:

.. I stopped short at the edge of the parapet of the Temple, the Temple in Jerusalem, under the huge sky, and above the enormous crowds of those who wandered in and out of it. I was standing on the pinnacle. I was looking down into the vast lower courts.


The sounds and scents of the crowd rose up in my nostrils. I felt the hunger so deeply it was a pain. And out on all sides lay the rooftops of Jerusalem while the people swarmed below in its tangle of narrow streets.


"Look on all this," he said beside me.
             (read the whole chapter here....even though it claims a copyright, not sure it's a legal site, if Rice wants me to remove the link, I will) .


For fun...and to learn something, the other night  I had students fill in some blanks in a non-graded "pop quiz".  I knew the results would be intriguing...and you can see which answer caused me to literally LOL..when I included this "fill in the blank":


  Every temptation, at heart, is about __________.

Would anyone put "power?"  (yes!)
  If i had clarified "Every temptation of Jesus," would anyone have put "to operate out of his divine nature and not his human nature?

a few answers:


  • forgiveness
  • power
  • selfishness
  • choice 
  • desire
  • "I don't listen to The Temptations"
But of course, that last answer may well be profound..if all temptations (and all of life...and according to string theory, all of the universe) are sound- based and maybe sound-activated.  See Webb's "The Divine Voice"!

Also..

I also love Jesus' line in Rice:

 I felt the hunger so deeply it was a pain.


It connected me to two lines in  Rice's delightful "Called out of Darkness: a spiritual confession":

  • "It's important to stress here  that my earliest experiences involved beauty...things which evoked such profound feeling in me that I often felt pain. (6)
  • "I remember thinking, tiny child that i was, that this was so incredibly beautiful that it hurt me"(16)

I love so much that Jesus was human.

A I asked the same class:
"The Bible says that Jesus was able to do miracles because He was ___________"

Check out there answers.
Note again a brilliant offbeat answer (by the same person who doesn't listen to The Temptations"):



I was hoping at least one would give the best answer.

Hardly anyone ever does..

Look up the Scriptures (or the third question here) if you're wondering...



Sunday, May 26, 2013

Amos Young on Spirit/logos Christologies and atonement

Great post from Morgan Guyton:; excerpt:
I’ve been reading The Spirit Poured Out On All Flesh, a book by Pentecostal theologian Amos Yong, who could hardly be called “nascent.” He’s kind of like the Pentecostal Scot McKnight, well within the bounds of what evangelical sensibilities call “orthodox” while very sympathetic to postmodern concerns and critiques. And he offers a pneumatological account of atonement that seems to address a lot of the issues the emergents have with the traditional evangelical account of atonement, so he’s somebody that emergents like Tony really ought to read and learn from.
One of the things that Yong names which I had never heard articulated in quite the same way before is the coexistence of two Christologies in the New Testament. Yong calls the Christology of the synoptic gospels a Spirit Christology, which emphasizes the concrete account of Jesus’ humanity, while the Christology of John’s gospel is a logos Christology, which emphasizes the abstract account of Jesus’ divinity. Yong says that post-Chalcedon, the Western church has been left with a predominantly logos Christology because “the Synoptic Gospels were reduced to present what Jesus did, even as John’s gospel was understood to provide the definitive account of who Jesus really was” (110).

The result of a predominantly logos Christology is that the Spirit’s role in Christ’s atonement is minimized even though the Spirit is responsible for raising Jesus from the dead and “also remains present with Jesus through the passion, which ultimately separates the Father from the Son” (112). When atonement is understood in logos Christology terms, the result is an abstract transactional account (such as Anselm’s) in which the soteriological work of the cross is reduced to a math problem (e.g. infinite dishonor of sin + infinite sacrifice of Jesus’ blood = 0 debt owed).

So Yong seeks to show how a pneumatological soteriology is able to combine the best of the big three atonement theories: ransom/Christus victor, substitutionary, and moral influence. Here’s what he says about ransom theory:

How can the ransom theory remain plausible to the modern mindset, which has demythologized the idea of the devil? The pneumatological soteriology defended here not only reinvigorates the idea of the demonic… but reorients it according to contemporary sensibilities. Insofar as Satan represents the sum total of all evil and sin is thereby understood in cosmic and social terms, the ransom theory empowers a redemptive, nonviolent resistance against evil, following the example of Jesus… And insofar as the liberation of the captives accomplished by Jesus included the exorcism of demons from those held in bondage by destructive forces, so also does full salvation need to account for the triumph of Christ over the rulers and authorities of this present world. [113]

A pneumatological soteriology recognizes the power of the demonic and the need for salvation to involve the exorcism of demons from people’s lives, all of which affirms the ransom theory’s account of a need for captives to have their freedom “bought” by the blood of Jesus. This does not require believing in a literal anthropomorphic devil, only using Satan as short-hand for the evil to which we experience ourselves being enslaved.

Here’s what Yong does with satisfaction or penal substitutionary atonement:
Instead of being an outmoded notion limited to the feudal and penitential context of Anselm’s medieval period or a piece of legalistic speculation amidst the emerging Protestant city-states, I suggest that the satisfaction and substitutionary theories remain pertinent for our time. Given our increasing awareness of the web of interconnectedness that binds all life forms together to the point that human survival is always at the expense of other forms of life, including other human life, the blood guilt that is upon our own heads as survivors requires the atoning sacrifice of Jesus in order for us to engage each other, the earth, and the divine in good conscience… Insofar as the Spirit, who raised Jesus for our justification, also gives life to us, the experience of forgiveness of sins deals not merely with the covering of our past failures but also with the empowering of our future actions so that they retain their full moral and ethical significance. [115]
The key here, as I have argued before, is that Jesus is punished for the sake of our wholeness (Isaiah 53:5) and ability to act “in good conscience,” not for the sake of God’s need to spew wrath on His Son. Instead of bifurcating salvation into justification through the Son and sanctification through the Spirit, Yong understands justification and sanctification both in perichoretic trinitarian terms. The Spirit’s role in justification makes it more than a forensic legal fiction and binitarian Father/Son transaction; it is our empowerment to “go and sin no more,” knowing our forgiveness....  Full Post here

Monday, February 18, 2013

"Epic Jesus" by Frank Viola

Here's the main page , with tons of links.
Here's the audio  of the talk that started it all.

 Excerpt:
Epic Jesus by Frank Viola from Jeremy Myers on Vimeo.
An excerpt from a message by Frank Viola delivered at the Momentum 2011 Conference. Go to http://www.ptmin.org/epicjesus to hear the rest of the message and download the eBook.

Sunday, March 06, 2011

"Jesus did not obey literally all his own maxims"

"Jesus Christ  did not limit his own action, he did not obey literally all his own maxims.  The Divine Spirit perpetually inspired his holy soul; having always been abandoned to that divine Breath, there was no need to consult the preceding moment in order to determine the following one.  The breath of grace formed all his moments  on the model of the eternal truths which the invisible and impenetrable wisdom of the Holy Trinity preserved.  The soul of Jesus Christ received the divine orders at each instant and reproduced them in his conduct.  The Gospel shows us the result of these truths in the life of Jesus Christ, and the very same Jesus always living and working produces new wonders in holy souls."
-deCaussade, "Self-Abandonment to Divine Providence," Book II, Section 7, p. 69.
(Abandonment to Divine Providence  PDF)

Great quote..even my dog likes this book:





Wednesday, February 10, 2010

"Who's on first?" "Who gives a %$#@ anyway?"..


I have seen it done cheaply and cheesily,
and I have seen it formulaically programmed..

So, maybe the best way to "do" it sans cheese is to pray to "be" it.
The idolatry of "doing" (God made human beings, not humandoings) is suprisisngly tempting and ententacling, especially in the West.

For as soon as one says, "It's ultimately always all about mission, as God is all about mission."
red flags go up and red herrings show up....as they should.

How does one navigate being/doing this without using people, or making people feel like numbers or notches?

Hirsch and Frost believe the missional “genius” of a church can only be unleashed when there are foundational changes made to the church’s very DNA, and that means addressing fundamental issues like ecclesiology, spirituality, and leadership. It means there must be a complete shift away from a Christendom way of thinking, which, as mentioned above, has been attractional, dualistic, and hierarchical.
-Brisco


Len's (and Len's friends) posts on "Which comes first: ecclesiology or missiology?" are helpful:


Brad Brisco's important articles, "History of Missional Church,' "Missional: More Than a Buzz Word" and his series, "The Language of Sending"
are places I send my students who want to stretch.


One notes how often one backs into the Trinity, and the missiological nature of the Trinity in these discussions. In the old days we said things like, "God only had one Son, and he was a missionary." But beyond the fact that the words "missionary," "mission(s)"....let alone missional and missiology, of course...are nowhere mentioned in Scripture (though everywhere assumed).
Might it be best to consider all three persons of the Godhead as missional? (As long as we define the terms well, see Brisco quote above):





“God’s salvific work precedes both the church and mission. We should not subordinate mission to the church nor the church to mission; both should, rather, be taken up into the missio Dei, which now became the overarching concept. The missio Dei institutes the missiones ecclesiae.”
-David Bosch, quoted in Brisco



Frost and Hirsch must be wrestled with for anyone in these discussions. Their suggested flow is:
Christology>Missiology>Ecclesiology

Might be consider adding to the front?:
Theology>Christology>Missiology>Ecclesiology?

Or is that redundantly redundant, with Christ being fundamentally and microcosmically one with the Theos of theology? Can we actually get sidetracked from Trinitarianism by tracking too much on Jesus?

Cam we "assume" theology and christology will emerge as we "start" with missionality?


Are all such charts true and false at the same time;
as "The straight line is godless and immoral,"
as the tongue-kissing, seaside lady- friend of the French motorcycle cop would say, they are all "irrelevant...as (time/life/God) is not linear":

Brother Maynard teases that this ("Missology or ecclesiology first?") question is an "evil little trick"...as it may well be a"both/and" paradox (Alan Hirsch: "Dualistic expressions of faith always result in practical polytheism" or Heidegger : “It makes a difference where one enters the circle”); it may well be a "the two are essentially the same" (a la the classic quote by Emil Bruner, "The Church exists by mission, as fire exists by burning"); but ultimately...against everything we've been taught in Sunday School and seminary ... it may best be a "yes, missiology precedes."
As I have said (I doubt it's original with me), "The church doesn't have a mission, the mission has a church." Or as Len has..better..said: "It is not the Church of God that has a mission in the world — it is the God of mission who has a Church in the world."

-link

Steve Seamands references Moltmann (who of course has penned a classic on the Trinity, in addition to living a gentle and practical trinitarian life): "It is not the church that has a mission of salvation to fulfill in the world, it is the mission of the Son and the Spirit through the Father that includes the church, creating a church a it goes on its way."


All I know is asking the "which comes first" of someone who doesn't read all these blogs and boogs. and doesn't see themselves as theologian or missiologist is delightful and dangerous.I highly recommend it...I always learn something, or see it all in a new way.




I asked a friend the question at hand. She immediately answered, "Missiology, of course. God told Moses he was being sent; before God even told Moses what his (God's) name was." Holy smoke!
-link



Ask five random such people in your life. Especially someone who would have to ask "Uh, what is 'missiology'?"

They may answer with a version of Zappa's "Who gives a %$#@ anyway?"..
before they ponder a bit, and come up with answer that is as "palpably holy" as the said Zappa song, say ,"Well, it would seem to be this way..."

Take note and take notes.

They may know more about it than you do.
They may well be a missiologist sent by The Triune Theos to you.
It's your job to give a %$#@ and a listen.

Wednesday, April 01, 2009

ReJesus ReView


I almost feel I am betraying friends to write this review.
I pray it is not so.
I more likely betray myself, and my misguided expectations of two of the most important thinkers/provocateurs/guides of our time.

I love, and recommend, all the books by Frost and Hirsch--the ones they write separately, and the ones the write together. "ReJesus: A Wild Messiah for a Missional Church" was no exception.

Or maybe it was.

Maybe the only thing wrong with the whole book is the subtitle.

It set up impossibly high expectations.
So, that I didn't glean much about Jesus being wild, messiah, or missional, was quite a letdown.

This was the book of theirs it felt like they were destined to write,
and the book of theirs I was most drawn to reading.

And it's the only one where each successive chapter let me down a little more;
I seemed top take less notes as it went by.

I still love lots about it, will reference it, and use it.
But in the sweep of their impressive catalog so far (and hopefully to come), it may not prove to be vital, as all their other works are (at least for me; it may have been designed with a different audience in mind from their past books). In their eventual impressive arc of their literature, I don't see it ever becoming their "Joshua Tree" or "Achtung Baby."
(Some might relate to the comparison to "the 'POP' of the U2 canon," but I actually love that maligned album. In fact, the trajectory and narrative of "Pop" might well communicate what I expected from "ReJesus." Hmmm...)

I really enjoyed the killer quotes from Ellul, for example;
and some of the sidebarred case studies of folks in history who modelled well being "little Jesuses." The brief paragraph on Kierkegard was hugely helpful for me ( SK saw himself as an "auditor" of apostles --Frost and Hirsch's point-- but in doing so proved himself an apostle--my conclusion), the snippets of Nick Cave's Introduction to the Gospel of Mark ("the Christ the church offers..denies Christ his potent creative sorrow or his boiling anger," p,21) are incredible, and the linking of Sinead O' Connor's "Theology" very key to the argument.

But that's the rub: I already own Kierkegaard, Ellul, Cave, O'Connor.
What I longed for is more of the amazing and articulate prophetic quotes that Frost and Hirsch are quite capable of.

They may be the only two on the planet who could deliver the definitive book about Jesus for our generation.

This is not it.

Though it is ocassionally extraordinarily valuable to me:


Having often asked groups and congregations which character of a Bible story they relate too, and often wishing more people had said "Jesus," but were afraid that was too arrogant, I was thrilled to read F/H wondering aloud the same after telling Scott Peck's story where only 6 out of 600 did so at a conference.

Whats up with that? Much of the book addresses that question creatively.

Great sections on epistemology; Greek vs. Hebrew ways of knowing.

Wonderful insights about dueling the dualisms so embedded in church culture and Christology.

Indeed, The Kingdom is so much bigger and broader than the church (p.30).

Amen and amen.

But we have heard all this from Frost and Hirsch before.

I was hoping to hear something more.
Or LESS:
a refocused, refounded picture of Jesus the Wild One.
It didn't quite develop for me.

I related a lot of Andrew's review:

ReJesus: A Wild Messiah for a Missional Church, by Michael Frost and Alan Hirsch, is a call to a renewal of spirituality and discipleship centred on Jesus; it describes what that renewed spirituality and discipleship might look like; it tells some powerful stories about spirituality and discipleship. It’s a wonderful book. Quintessential Frost and Hirsch.
But it is not really a book about Jesus. The authors expressly excuse themselves on this point. They are not endeavouring to outline the contours of Jesus’ teaching because ‘so many books have done a better job of that than we can possibly accomplish’; rather they are trying to find the ‘spiritual centers’ of the ‘lifestyle and faith that Jesus taught and exemplified’ - ‘to touch the wild and primal energy that radiates out of Jesus’ (41).
The rhetoric is compelling, but the argument bothers me. Frost and Hirsch call people to follow a captivating messiah, but they won’t tell us what he did, why he did it, or where he thought he was going. If we are not given the overall shape of Jesus’ teaching, how are we to be sure that the ‘spiritual centers’ have been correctly located? Much is said - and said well, if a little hyperbolically at times - about the character of Jesus: a ‘daring, radical, strange, wonderful, inexplicable, unstoppable, marvelous, unsettling, disturbing, caring, powerful God-Man’ (111). But is it wise to encourage people to follow - indeed worship - a dangerous charismatic figure without providing some basic information about his agenda, some sketch of the contours of his teaching?

-Andrew

So, overall..

My first impression:

After all these guys have written that is riveting and revolutionary , why does this (the only book promising to be riveting and revolutionary) seem like a zillion evangelical apologetics I read in the old days? I felt like I was back in the conservagelical movement, defending an orthdox doctrine of Christ in the face of the liberal relatvism.
Been there, done that, may be necessary (?), but feels old school..
It almost reads like "we just need to believe in Jesus a little harder."

My second impression:

For a book that promises, via subtitle, to introduce us to a wild Messiah, I picked up little wildness.
The press and the subtitle lead us to believe this is to be something along the lines of McManus's "The Barbarian Way." I wish it was.

Len suggests it's "Soul Survivor meets "Wild at Heart."
It could have/maybe should have been that and more.

My third impression:

I love that the book was about reframing, "refounding" all of church and life on Jesus.

But it seemed odd and ironic that such focus was never seemed to come into ..well, focus! Nor placed securely enough in the contet of the community of the Trinity (and the community of the Bride).
Maybe this is another book, but I could have used a few more paragraphs and pages on the amazing, loaded and leaded sentence, "the physical embodiment of the Trinity is in the people of God" (28). I would pay big money to hear someone the calibre of Frost and Hirsch unpack that for an hour.

I was shocked to finally arrive at a section entitled "a quick word on the Trinity" (136) ! Excellent material, but far too brief...and ultimately the truth argued for there seemed negated by the rest of the book.

Certainly, Jesus is somehow "center" of Trinity, and though the authors are careful to (briefly) plant him in the context of the community of the Godhead. I just don't see how the wildly missional Messiah that Jesus indeed was and is, can ever be such sans the context of his own missional community/communtas (see
(Moltmann, Steve Seamands, and a hots of others who pick up this card).
In particular, I felt we needed more connection/connexion to the Third Person, and what is sometimes called "Spirit Christology" (see the third section here, regarding why this is so crucial to book about Jesus):






But if we start with pneumatology, and move to a Spirit-Christology, we affirm de facto a Trinitarian frame and we start with ontology. Thus we begin with our common humanness; a starting point among rather than above. -link, Len Hjalmarson
See Len's posts on the book for more implications here.
Also, ironically, the authors delightfully discuss three other "trinities":
  • Christology, missiology/ecclesiology (p.6)
  • God as Missio Dei/Church as Participati Christi/world as imag Dei (38)
  • Orthodoxy/orthohopraxy/orthopathy (158)
As I posted earlier:

Nowadays, when the emphasis is more on conversation and culture than doctrine;
it almost sounds old school to some to call for a renewed focus on the doctrine of the Trinity..

..but those of us who "believe" this doctrine definitely assume it's not just that,
but life and relationship..
..and somehow foundational to everything else we do, say and pray.

Having been moved for years by Moltmann's "The Trinity and the Kingdom,"

and captured in recent years by Eugene Peterson's writings
("Trinity is the most comprehensive and integrative framework that we have for understanding and participating in the Christian life."),


and Capon's clever take (often comparing the Trinity to three Jewish guys in conversation):

"Before anything was made, it was all already done within the Trinity. The whole thing was accomplished before it started... Pure monotheism is dangerous. The doctrine of the Trinity embraces the paradox of mutuality in God himself without violating the unity of God—because it can only be presented as a paradox and a mystery. Paradox can take you on trips that religion can’t even buy a ticket for."




Check these two random and unrelated (yeah, right!) quotes:


1)"Theologian Kevin Giles..says that the Trinity 'is the model on which ecclesiology should be formulated. On this premise, the inner life of the Trinity provides a pattern, a model, an echo, or an icon of the Christian communal existence in the world.'

Simply put , the Trinity is the paradigm for the church's native expression."
-Frank Viola, "Reimagining Church," p. 36

and

2)"William McLaughlin, an astrophysicist..., says..'The doctrine of the Trinity represents a revolutionary form of logic which is ideal for new forms of computer systems. Instead of one master control chip, a Trinity computer would have three...(such) would be adept at intuition... non hierarchical authority...and lateral thinking, otherwise known as fuzzy logic, where the solution to a problem lies outside the system being studied."
-Adrian Berry, "Galileo and the Dolphins," 172-174.
link
Having said all that, this may be the perfect book for someone who has not read (and may not ever) the other books by this dynamic duo. And I am sure I need to read it again...yet I am not sure I will.

That will likely be my loss. So pray I get "ReJesus"-ed again.
I may even have to write sequel/apology for this review.
That would be a great sign I got my Christology straight...
..and RePented.

Tuesday, July 01, 2008

Bruce Cockburn in God's Shack

I finally got around to reading "The Shack."

Every preacher dude is getting asked about The Shack and the "Lakeland Outpuring."

I liked it surprisingly well. I thought it would get cheesy..but it didn't.

Mark Driscoll will call me a harry tick:


Here's an interview with the author:


One of the highlights is hearing that the God character loves Bruce Cockburn:

"I am especially fond of Bruce, you know." (p. 118)

Mack asks God, "I thought You'd be listening to George Beverly Shea, or..something churchier."

"Now see here, Mackenzie. You don't have to look out for me. I listen to everything--and not just to the music itself, but the hearts behind it. Don't you remember your seminary classes? These kids (the band Diatribe) ain't saying anything I haven't heard before; they're just full of vinegar and fizz. Lots of anger, and I must say with some good reason too..." (91)

Heck, the book even quotes Buckminster Fuller; "God is a verb."

--------

"But what about all those miracles? The healings? Raising people from the dead?
Doesn't that prove that Jesus was God?"

"No, it proves that Jesus is human." (99)
------

Wednesday, January 09, 2008

Risking Fixed Fluidity: "Working for the church while your family dies"



"Working for the church while your family dies"
-Arcade Fire, "Intervention"

That lyric starkly paints the place where pastors/leaders inevitably go if the "instititutional model" is permitted full birth and berth and us.

Len's recent blogs (here and here)on institution vs spirit/organized vs. organic will  keep me from ever singing that song (again). He picks up on my bringing Steve Seamands' ""Ministry in the Image of God: The Trinitarian Shape of Christian Service:
in as a potential balance/discernment:

Dave Wainscott furthers my reflections on institutions, (reflections aided greatly by Alan Hirsch) pointing to the dichotomy of institution vs spirit. At the theological level what he is hinting at for me is the need to hold Word and Spirit together. If we understand the Word as given, fixed, eternal, and the Spirit as spontaneous, fluid, and contextual, then the meeting of the two is Incarnation. We become, and our communities are, living letters, both organic and organized, both structured and adaptable. link

The tethering of Word and Spirit has long been one of my mottos and orthodoxies. But letting God secure it as mainstay and orthopraxy in the practical case studies of daily life has been another matter. So wrestling with Len's suggestions of "the Word as given, fixed, eternal, and the Spirit as spontaneous, fluid, and contextual" will be fruitful.

In any given life or ministry (oops, a Gnostic dichotomy leaked out there) situation, I seek to clear the slate and assumptions and ask prayerfully of God and carefully of the people, "How is the Spirit leading in this particular situation?" That might be reframed as "Is this a time to be fixed or fluid?" And all the qualifiers and nuances come into play: Maybe this is a "fluidly fixed" time...
\ A practical case study for a emergimissional type of church such as ours might be how many "programs" to have; how often to have the children have their own meeting, when to unplug a meeting or move/morph it, etc. Knowing that, be it both bias and God's choice, our deafult mode, magnetic north will be the "spontaneous, fluid, and contextual" actually frees us to trust that when we do feel "It seems good to the Holy Spirit and to us in this situation to be more given and fixed" that we can be fixed in our fluid kind of way.

I am afraid of that prayer.
I need to pray about that.

Then Len, as he does so well, jacks up the stakes...or as he more humbly coins it:

Ok, now I am going to further confused the matter by pushing for an alternate paradigm, an historical/theological one. My intention isn’t to argue that the paradigm of the Trinity can’t work, but simply that there might be a better historical precedent. Incidentally, I know who referenced this paradigm in the last century: Karl Barth. Who else? So here is my proposal:
I suggest that the church is a culture - a way of life as well as a particular structure of meaning - analogous to Jesus incarnation as expressed in the Chalcedonian formula in 451. Here is the formula:
**
Following the holy Fathers, we unanimously teach and confess one and the same Son, our Lord Jesus Christ: the same perfect in divinity and perfect in humanity, the same truly God and truly man, composed of rational soul and body; consubstantial with the Father as to his divinity and consubstantial with us as to his humanity; “like us in all things but sin.” He was begotten from the Father before all ages as to his divinity and in these last days, for us and for our salvation, was born as to his humanity of the virgin Mary, the Mother of God.
We confess that one and the same Christ, Lord, and only-begotten Son, is to be acknowledged in two natures without confusion, change, division, or separation. The distinction between natures was never abolished by their union, but rather the character proper to each of the two natures was preserved as they came together in one person (prosopon) and one hypostasis.
**
According to the council of Chalcedon, Jesus has two natures, both human and divine, neither confusing nor separating the two. Similarly, I believe we must be incarnational in our living in this world as kingdom citizens, neither confusing culture with the kingdom of God nor failing to find Him there; neither separating ourselves from the life of the world, nor taking on their way of life, their perspective, or their spirit....Orthodoxy is an event. Historically we have some terrific examples. It means that the new creation must exist in living communities, like the Celtic communities...link



Thank you, Len...that not only compassed the model, and kept me from framejacking, it pushes me to consider a further quest: Do we remember to do what Jesus would do: Corporately decide/discern how to respond (versus react) to every given situation or person in front of us with God's Kingdom wisdom (which may well surprise us) and not our own.

As Bono said before (in the context of feeling like he had to prove/improve himself in a given situation to impress others), "I feel like its a fight with yourself, And you just hope that your better half wins."

The point is not that we have two halves. The NIV mistranslates "flesh" as sinful nature", endorsing the old dualistic theology of the "old man and new man." One of my college Bible professors once offered $100 to any student who could prove from the Bible the common teaching that we have two natures (and thus are always in a terrible fight).

He never had to shell out a cent.

The flesh, world and devil are indeed insidious and coordinated in their desire to derail our trust in the Spirit and incarnational community...and we (like Jesus did) have very real choices and gethsemanes before us daily.

But we hope and Holy Spirit to uncmomfort and kickstart us into the Godward action. Orthodoxy is event indeed.

Another college Bible professor cautioned us against adopting a
"schizoid Jesus" that was 50 percent human and 50 percent divine, constantly toggling between "halves" of his brain/brains. Just like marriage is not 50-50 (half and half partnership) as is so often preached, it is instead a 100-100 model(each partner aims to give incarnationally, mutual-submission, 100 percent). Jesus was 100 percent God and 100 percent human. To know that Jesus had a urinary tract may have shaken up the audience at Houghton College when Debbie Blue preached it (audio), but he did. And it is beyond doubt that Jesus had bad hair days, and (yes) erections.

Yes, Jesus had erections....and homosexual temptations. What he did with them is another matter.
(more in that...believe it or not..on my "Jesus...a Tempted Apostle" sermon audio here)



"Because Jesus was tested and tempted in every single way that we can be...." (Hebrews )

!!
But we "can't talk about that in church"??!! Where DO you want to talk about it?

There is an anecdote, perhaps anecdotal (that I can’t find right now) about a former U.S president…probably Hoover or Truman (or someone else with a sly and dry sense of humor) who wanted tp prove to a fiend visiting the White House that visitors at “meet and greet” photo-op receptions were typically so taken with the glitz and hype of the White House that the ten-second of each to “meet and greet” the president was so unreal and rote that he as president could say anything to the person in line he was shaking hands with, and it wouldn’t register. This was a time when the president’s mother was known to be ill, so many greeters as they shook the president’s hand asked “How’s your mother, Mr. President?”, out of nervousness or just to have something polite to say. So the president whispered to his friend, “Watch this, to the third person who asks me how my mother is, I’ll say “She died this morning,” and they’ll say something like “That’s wonderful, Mr. President,” as they smile for the picture and move on. It worked!

I occasionally felt during those years of “meet and great” at the Whue House..uh I mean local church…I mean greeting the line of parishioners at the door… as wonderful a it was, was also at times nothing less than an encouragemnent for them and me to lie. “How are you?” The answer was usually (supposed to be) “ Fine” whether or not the
person had diarrhea, demons, disease or death coming against them.”.link


So in this real world that we are incarnated missionally in, a world of church programs, bad hair days, diarrhea and urinary tract infections...WWJD?

So Len contexting our quest in the two natures of Christ challenges us to actually do as Christ would do if he were in our shoes and world.

Because he is.

But it is as he WAS that the heart of the lesson lies.

Not that in Bible days , "Today Jesus acted out of his human nature, and tomorrow he may act out of his divine nature." The standard Sunday School answer is "Of course, Jesus was God, and he always acted out of his human nature."

Gong.

Jesus indeed was and is God...but perhaps in his earthy years/incarnation he consistently and insistently acted (only?) out of his human nature, trusting the power of the Spirit and what the Father was saying and doing in that moment (John 5: 19, 30); partly to model for us submission, trust, incarnation, and kenosis.

If Jesus did no ministry out his divine nature; than neither should I.

I know, Mom, I do not have a divine nature..even though St Peter shockingly announces that together we are "partakers of it."


Some theologians call this "Spirit Christology" or "kenosis", and whether this proposed theology is consistently true. If it is, it would almost move this question into the realm of "essential" doctrines, because it then provides the very key to how we are to live in relation to daily Christian life, walking in the power and possibilities of the Spirit; doing the "greater works than Jesus" that Jesus flatly and unapologetically predicted we would do. Now, not every proponent of "Spirit Christology" or "kenosis theology" is biblical or orthodox, so hear me when I say that I know I don't agree with everyone using these categories. The basic argument would be this; to put it bluntly, as one preacher did for shock value:

"Jesus did nothing on earth as God! "

Wow, better unpack that! Now, that statement doesn't have to imply He was not God.. He was, is and always will be fully God in my Book! It's just that He didn't. during His earthly ministry, anyway..do anything out of His innate, inherent and intrinsic Godhood. He voluntarily surrendered the rights to use and access His God hood's attributes... such as omniscience, or power to do mighty miracles. Several
Scriptures come into play: John 5:19 and 30 offer that Jesus did nothing in and of Himself, but only did what the Father and Spirit told/led/empowered Him to do. Philippians 2:6-11 asserts that Jesus didn't take advantage of, or even access of the rights and power of His Godhood, which would be "robbery," and a violation of the whole point of His incarnation; His coming to earth. Instead of functioning out of His eternal power and prerogative as Almighty God, He "emptied Himself". A by-product of this, is as Hebrews affirms "Jesus know every temptation we have endured by His own experience" (2:18 and 4:15). I also love to shock congregations by asking "When Jesus did miracles on earth, how was He able to do those miracles?" Well-trained evangelicals of course automatically answer, "Because He was God!" When actually, that may be the wrong answer all together. Of course He was God, no debate. But the only Scriptural answer to "How did He do those miracles?" is "in the power of the Spirit". And witness Matt. 12:28: He cast out demons; not because He was God and could do so, but as a human "by the power of the Spirit." Thus, that is the "key" key, crucial catch, and ancient but overlooked secret as to how we, mere humans, are to do the same works He did, even greater. (Jesus said that, not me. Blame Him: John 14:12)

Answer: We do them through "checking in" with the same Father Jesus checked in with while on earth; and trusting,...radically; to the point where the supernatural almost becomes natural and norm... the same Spirit Jesus trusted. (Note Jesus, a few sentences later, suggests that is His secret, and ours. He simply passes the torch to us, but not without the sharing the same equipping Holy Spirit: verses 16-17).Such deep trust and dependency doesn't make us Jesus, of course, but they do position us to trust the timing and voice of the Father, and prompting and power of the Spirit, as radically as Jesus did...with similar and "even greater" results! If JESUS never did anything in and of Himself (John 5:19 and 30), who do we think WE are?

When Jesus asked, in Mark 5:30, "Who touched me?," did He mean it, or was this a test? If "Spirit Christology" is true, one could answer the former, without sacrificing an iota of essential, foundational evangelical theology. When Jesus said even He (Matthew 24:36) did not know the day or hour of His return, was that a lie?. No, and this "lack of knowledge" on the part of a member of the all-knowing Trinity poses no problem. I would propose that He knows now, but He chose not to know on earth. This was all part of His modeling a complete self-emptying. This, though, is core to my third question:" How consistent and complete is this theology.? Did Jesus ever do anything 'on earth as God', even though He was God? And Lord, is this profound truth so profound that to miss it allows us to miss the 'normal' life you have intended for us?"

Whatever the ultimate answer to this question the Lord would give me, the bottom line question I keep hearing in the meantime. and "real time" is haunting: "Have I yet trusted as completely and recklessly as I could in the leading of the Father and the power of the Sprit? I almost don't even care if I do a greater work or not, I just want to be found faithful, and be an answer to Jesus' wild and waiting prophecy of John 14:12.

I love Dwight Edwards' penetrating, "must-be- wrestled- with" self-questions :

1. What have I done recently that could not be duplicated by an unbeliever, no matter how hard they tried?

2.What blatant evidence of the supernatural God has leaked out of my life?

Questions indeed! link






Working Summary:

If we (not just "I" as Lone Ranger Pastor) seek to be so in tune and touch with God that we catch his heartbeat and marching orders for each practical decision about form/formation/culture in our community...may we so radically trust Word and Spirit to remind us that we are locked into in "life with God" and "life together" that in those (rare?) times when he surely seems to be leading us into some shape that smack us as too institutional/organized... we'll adopt and amen it; knowing some treasures are new and some old even in the new wineskin.

Of course God Almighty won't lead us to start any programs (!), host children's church, (!!), build buildings (!!!) , hire paid staff (help) and all that pagan stuff...

Will he?

Gulp.

Do I have to reclaim my dress from E Bay?

Steve Seamands concludes his book (the one I have been keeping at hand throughout this conversation)  with "Let's consider two common barriers that hinder our participation on God's mission:a church centered approach, and our hesitancy to take risks..."


We can't find you now,
But they're going to get their money back somehow,
And when you finally disappear
We'll just say you were never here.

Been working for the church
While your life falls apart,
Singing hallelujah with the fear in your heart,
Every spark of friendship and love
Will die without a home.

Saturday, September 01, 2007

The Meaning of History at St. Arbuck's..in 3 Easy Strands


Maybe the beloved biblical maxim about a strand of three cords not being easily broken is not just for marriages anymore.

And maybe it will work in my favor here.

All (!) I want to do in the next few (!) minutes is string together three strands; and note how they interrelate/intercalate, dovetail/Dovetail and form/inform each other:


  • 1.) The emerging consensus of missiology preceding ecclesiology
  • 2.) Quantum loops and the emergence of spacetime and gravity
  • 3.) The epistemological emergence of consciousness/soul

All right, for the three of you still reading(:.........

At least the common word "emergence" has tied all three together. But isn't it obvious (or is
Tim correct in his analysis of me: "you always push toward the unobvious") that all three phenomena are versions of (strand-ed together by) the same meta-phenomenon (that being: the meaning of history)?

Okay, for the two of you still reading...

This morning at St. Arbuck's I asked the ever prophetic subversive punster Keltic Ken (from Klovis) the question that everyone at every table of every St. Arbuck's is asking, if they really admit it:

"What is the meaning of history?"

He said (correct me, Ken) something like "God working out his purposes, and revealing himself, through sinful humanity."

I immediately congratulated him on his intuitive transcendence of a hyper-Hegelian overemphasis on "God/Geist AS history."

But if history/culture is indeed the chief "secular" venue in which is God is attempting to sovereignly self-disclose, Ken is (as usual) onto something huge.

And since we are blessed to live "at such a (postmodern/emerging/shift) time as this" IN history (David Dark: "this weird moment in history)":

"God must have a lot of confidence in you to put you on the planet at just this time. It was his sovereign decision to insert you onto planet earth during a time of huge transition. It takes incredible faith to lead during hinge points of history. " -Reggie McNeal,"The Present Future"

And to offer a surprising..but accurate...twist on the usual semantic domain of faith/confidence, try this quote from Graham Cooke:

"When the old wineskin is dying, the new wineskin is created by people who are not afraid to be vulnerable. "

Or this from ecologist Buhro:

"When the forms of an old culture are dying, the new culture is created by a few people who are not afraid to be insecure"



Thus...we need...counterintuitively...some profound and holy insecurity/vulnerability to our faith-life in these amazing days to see all that could come to pass, actually materialize. Because Bono is right: "History is more malleable than you think."

If Ken is right about the meaning of history is , and Bono is correct about
the mallebility of history..

...then maybe we shouldn't be afraid to (assuming Cooke and Buhro are spot-on) tie my three strands together, and see what emerges and converges.

The three strands, then, laid out:

-----------------------------------------------

1)Missiology precedes eccelesiology

Len asked a million dollar question ,"Do you think missiology precedes ecclesiology, or it is the other way round?" and then collected answers by some seminal thinkers and bloggers. These answers are all worth weighing, and are posted here:




Brother Maynard teases that this question is an "evil little trick"...as it may well be a"both/and" paradox (Alan Hirsch: "Dualistic expressions of faith always result in practical polytheism" or Heidegger : “It makes a difference where one enters the circle”);

it may well be a "the two are essentially the same" (a la the classic quote by Emil Bruner, "The Church exists by mission, as fire exists by burning");

but ultimately...against everything we've been taught in Sunday School and seminary (Brian Dodd: "Healthy churches tend to have non seminary trained leaders...')... it may best be a "yes, missiology precedes."

As I have said (I doubt it's original with me), "The church doesn't have a mission, the mission has a church."

Or as Len has..better..said: "It is not the Church of God that has a mission in the world — it is the God of mission who has a Church in the world."


By the way, since you asked(:... my longwinded answer to Len's question is here (and there Steve Porter lovingly challenges me, which makes me think(: I may even be right)..and if you want the short wind of my article, concludes:


So, again, If I had to pick an answer, it would be yes..missiology tends to precede and produce ecclesiology; philosophically, epistemologically, and practically speaking. I find quantum physics hugely helpful here; especially 'reverse causality," which accords with what Ladd has well emphasized about the Kingdom entering this age "from" the future; time working 'backwards," etc. This will be fleshed out (incarcarnated) in smaller, organic, networked and non-hierarchical (all lessons from physics again; the universe is such) ways and means...

...Meaning that counterintuitively to our modern mindset, doing can precede being; missiology can even (creatively) create ecclesiology.


I asked a friend today the question at hand. She immediately answered, "Missiology, of course. God told Moses he was being sent; before God even told Moses what his (God's) name was."


Holy smoke, she's right!

Bono nails it again (in a sermon he has preached around the world); "God may be with us in our mansions on the hill...I hope so....but God is with the poor. And God is with us, if we are with the poor."

We find our ecclesiology as we find and follow our missiological tug.


In the process, we might even find God.


Or as Hirsch would have it:
Christology>Missiology>Ecclesiology

(And check out Cultural Savage's addendum)

And as Mike Todd would unpack that:

Our Christology leads to missiology which leads to ecclesiology..In other words, who Jesus is gives us our mission, and our mission prescribes what church should be. How many of us in the west have that exactly backwards? We need to reboot, as Al calls it. We need to return to our primary source documents--the Gospels--and figure out who this Jesus was. Or, as we put it in our faith community:
We need to get to know Jesus again for the first time -link


Note: Andrew Jones and Radical Congruency have also asked the question(answering it similarly) and assembled answers..


2.) Quantum loops and the emergence of spacetime and gravity
..
Some of the debate in quantum physics revolves around whether the curvature of spacetime creates gravity, or the other way around. Like the question in #1, this could well be construed as a both/and... chicken-egg ...Or, just as missiology can assume precedence, there may be something a priori (in a spacetime way)about space-time...as in the common consensus:"gravity arises out of the curvature of spacetime".






3.) The epistemological emergence of consciousness/soul
I love the Hofsadter title "I am Strange Loop'. Because I am, amen? Check out his cheeky interview about the book here, and consider his thesis that Consciousness/"soul" arises out of a series of self-refrerential loops" By the way, literally a Pulitzer-Prize winning thesis.


And then weigh in with a quote Roger Penrose (no slouch either...co-winner with Stephen Hawking of the Wolf Prize for Physics" that floored me, (or to switch the metaphor back, stranded my #2 and #3 cords together):



"I have argued strongly against the view (of computational functionalism) in which it is merely computational activity that gives rise to conscious mentality), and I have indeed suggested that consciousness actually depends on (emerges from) the missing gravitational OR theory." -The Road to Reality : A Complete Guide to the Laws of the Universe , p. 1033)


Threw me for a loop (pun intended...as it is technically "loop quantum gravity" that is under discussion)..

Consciousness emerges from a self-referential loop; eh, Hofsatdter?...And (maybe this is the same thing) perchance it (also?) emerges from spacetime-based gravity.

All that to say God knew what he was doing when he embedded himself in history/culture/physics.

---------------
There you go; I have only begun exporing this three-standed triad. And I am aware that it is in the liminal spaces/thin places/holy Venning where they overlap that a lot is to be learned.



If we are about our Godbusiness of being missional then God will back us up (I love one of E Stanley Jones's keynotes: When you think Kingdomly and missionally, "You are no longer working against the grain of the universe; you are working with it.") to the tune of space and time "suddenly" and sovereignly working in our favor, and...as a free bonus, our loopy souls and consciousness will get bigger.

Ain't that the veritable meaning of history?

I am serious.
And if you seriously want to hear more about time and space working for us as Kingdom partners, check this out.

Because THAT is the meaning of history! I learned it at St. Arbuck's! (And maybe from a good book called..uh, "The Meaning of History".)

Would the one of you still reading (likely Ken or Len)...pick up here?....

after I give Reggie McNeal the last word so far:

The current spiritual awakening in North America lacks Christian content and file systems. This is the scary part of it. Left to their own imagination people will devise all sorts of crazy stuff about God, from New Age crystals to self-enlightenment. But this is also the opportunity of the current spiritual landscape. People are open to revealed truth of God if they can get it. Unfortunately, the North American church has lost its influence at this critical juncture. It has lost its influence because it has lost its identity. It has lost its identity because it has lost is mission.

The correct response, then, to the collapse of the church culture is not to try to become better at doing church. The need is not for a methodological fix. The need is for a missional fix.

The appropriate response to the emerging world is a rebooting of the mission, a radical obedience to an ancient command, a loss of self rather than self preoccupation, concern about service and sacrifice rather than concern about style.

The collapse of the church culture is God's gracious invitation to the church to rediscover itself. It will do this by dying to itself and coming alive to God's mission.link