Welcome! You have accidentally reached the blog of a heteroclite follower of Jesus: dave wainscott. I'm
"pushing toward the unobvious" as I post thinkings/linkings
re: Scripture, church and culture. Hot topics include: temple tantrums, time travel, sexuality/spirituality, U2kklesia, role of the pastor, God-haunted music/art..and subversive videos like these.
Yet another sad story about yet another megachurch pastor's moral failure.
I found one quote interesting, and telling, on several levels:
“You know he did a lot of good,” said Mitch Guetler, a church member.
“He helped out a lot of people and I’m just really sad but like he
always said up on stage—don’t follow him, follow Christ. So, you know,
he’s a sinner like the rest of us and it’s just too bad. (link)
My observations are not a judgment on the pastor or parishioner, but commentary (judgement) on church culture/language/assumed ecclesiology...sacred cows:
1)"up on the stage": Note the irony written large: It's from "up on the stage" that the pastor said, "Don't follow me." Medium=message; medium contradicts sermon. To paraphrase the EBay Atheist, "What in the world is a stage doing in a church?
Blow up church stages; they are oxmoronic and moronic.
-----------
2)"Don’t follow me, follow Christ." It's amazing that people think this is in the Bible when Paul said basically the opposite. (Don't get me started on folks who bet that "God will never give you more
than you can handle" is in the Bible, yet the opposite is...ad infinitum, ad nauseum):
"Follow me, as I follow Christ" Paul, 1 Cor 11: 1.
Blow up those "Don't follow me, I follow Christ" bumper stickers.
Create and sell a new bumper sticker that says,"Follow me because I follow Christ"...and give Brian Dodd all your profits . See Dodd's remarks on this in his important works "The Problem of Paul," "Empowered Church Leadership" (click here to read the relevant section)and his dissertation,"Paul's Paradigmatic 'I': Personal Example as Literary Strategy"
Paul admitted he was a "normal neurotic" (Dodd, Problem p. 153), yet was worth following.
------------
3) "he’s a sinner like the rest of us." Technically, he IS like the rest of us...but like the rest of us, he's not a sinner." I said "the rest of us," not "the best of us." One does not have to be dead, Catholic, or perfect to be a saint. According to the Bible, one just has to be a Christian. Even a sucky one like me counts. Remember that Paul calls even those bad Christians in 1 and 2 Corinthians what they are: "saints."
Blow up those "Just a sinner" T shirts. How about "just a saint"?
You are a saint who sometimes sins, not a sinner who sometimes is a saint.
Here is an abstract of, and link to the full document of, Ryan Schellenberg's dissertation. It might be read alongside Brian Dodd's diss.
I am so glad he included some challenges to prevailing view's re: prosopeion AND utilized Sapir!
Note: it later became this book
-----------------------
WHERE IS THE VOICE COMING FROM?: QUERYING THE EVIDENCE FOR PAUL’S RHETORICAL EDUCATION IN 2 CORINTHIANS 10
by Ryan Scott Schellenberg
ABSTRACT
Although it would be an exaggeration to speak of a consensus, a majority of scholars
now sees Paul as a man of relatively high social status. Most often cited as evidence for such
status is Paul’s putative education in formal rhetorical theory. The prevailing logic consists
of two propositions: First,
Paul’s letters can be analyzed according to the dictates of Greco-Roman rhetoric; therefore, Paul must have been well educated in rhetoric. Second, rhetorical education was available only among the wealthy elite; therefore, Paul
must have been brought up in such circles.
A number of scholars have observed that such argumentation fails to consider the
extent to which rhetorical ability exists independently of formal education. But despite this
general observation, there has been no attempt to determine whether the specific rhetorical
competencies to which Paul’s letters attest admit of informal acquisition. In this study, I use
insights from comparative rhetoric and sociolinguistics to get methodological leverage on
this problem and thus to reevaluate the evidence for Paul’s rhetorical education. Using 2 Cor10–13
as a test case, I demonstrate that Paul’s use of rhetoric provides no evidence of formal
education; on the contrary, his persuasive strategies are instances of informal
rhetoric.
After undertaking a history of scholarship in part 1, in part 2 I reassess recent claims
of Paul’s conformity with formal rhetorical conventions in 2 Cor 10–13.
Here I demonstra that many alleged parallels derive from misleading treatment of the
rhetorical sources and
cannot be sustained. Convincing parallels are few
—I isolate four and rather general;
nevertheless, they do merit further explanation.
I seek to provide such explanation in part 3 by offering a basic theory of informal rhetoric and it
s acquisition, and demonstrating the use,by speakers with no knowledge of formal rhetorical theory, of precisely those rhetorical eatures found both in Paul and in the ancient rhetorical sources.
Finally, in part 4, I begin a redescription of Paul’s persuasive voice: Paul’s prose style, his self
-description in 2Cor 10:10 and 11:6, and his “foolish boasting" reveal him to be a speaker both abject and
defiant. LINK, full dissertation
cannot be sustained. Convincing parallels are few
—
I isolate four
—
and rather general;
nevertheless, they do merit further explanation.
I seek to provide such explanation in part 3
by offering a basic theory of informal rhetoric and it
s acquisition, and demonstrating the use,
by speakers with no knowledge of formal rhetorical theory, of precisely those rhetorical
features found both in Paul and in the ancient rhetorical sources.
a)He
might be a slave, but not a runaway. He simply was asking Paul for help
in being an advocate. This view solves several problems with the
traditional view, and this article is helpful on Paul's style of
persuasion/theme of the letter. by Brian Dodd: click here
b)"This is not about a runaway slave at all. Paul and Onesimus are literal brothers.":
There are several problems with the interpretation that Onesimus is a
runaway fugitive slave. There are other examples of letters written in
the period that Paul was writing that implore slaves to return to
their masters and that implore masters to receive their slaves back
graciously. Paul’s letter to Philemon does not follow the same
pattern.
In addition, the epistle itself never says that Onesimus is a runaway
or a thief, this is simply a presumption. Finally, the entire argument
that Onesimus is a slave is based on verse 15 and 16 where Paul uses
the greek word doulos to describe Onesimus. Certainly the word
can be interpreted as slave, however, the word is used many other
times in scripture and does not always mean that the one called doulos is a literal slave. Sometimes doulos refers to a son or a wife, not a slave. That one word is not a definitive identification of Onesimus.
What if Callahan’s interpretation is correct? Onesimus not just a
Christian, he is actually a blood brother to Philemon. This
interpretation means that the book of Philemon is about reconciliation
in families rather than an admonition for the slave to remain obedient
and the master to treat the slave fairly. LINK: Philemon...Slave Master?
..and then we encounter these verses which have caused many varied
interpretations. Verses 15-16. Callahan translates them as, “For on
this account he has left for the moment, so that you might have him
back forever, no longer as though he were a slave, but, more than a
slave, as a beloved brother very much so to me, but now much more so
to you, both in the flesh and in the Lord.”[1]
First, there is a grammatical question about how to translate this
phrase which many have rendered “no longer as a slave.” Callahan
dissects the greek and he argues that the phrase is more accurately
translated, “no longer as though he were a slave.” Even with Callahan’s
translation, the question remains: Why did Paul choose to use the
word slave if Onesimus wasn’t a slave?
The word used is doulos and according to Callahan’s research, it “was a term of both honor and opprobrium in the early Christian lexicon.”[2]
It was thought to be an honor to be called a doulos tou theou or
a slave of God. In fact, Paul calls himself a slave of Christ in
several of his letters including Romans, Philippians, and Titus, as do
other authors of the epistles of James and 2 Peter.
It is also true that the term slave signified subjugation,
powerlessness, and dishonor, one who does not have liberty or agency on
one’s own.
Callahan argues that Paul is using the term doulos to capture
both dimensions of the human condition and is perhaps even making a
connection with the Christ hymn in Philippians 2 where he quotes an
ancient hymn that exalts the Christ who humbles himself to be nothing,
powerless, and empty of the divine dimension, like a slave to the
human condition.
Callahan argues that Paul is simply calling Onesimus a slave in the
same way that he describes himself as a slave. Onesimus is also a doulos tou theou, a slave of God.
If this is the case, then Paul uses language that indicates Onesimus
and Philemon are related, in fact that they are brothers in the flesh.
Reconciliation and love between brothers was a special concern for
several ancient writers and philosophers. One Roman philosopher named
Plutarch writes of the importance of repairing a breach between
brothers, even if it comes through a mutual friend...
NOTE also: metaphorical terminology by Paul re: slavery in Galatians 4:7:
"So you are no longer a slave, but God’s child; and since you are his child,
God has made you also an heir"... actually a verse quite similar to
Philemon 16 (first clause the same, second clause family language)
"no longer as a slave, but better than a slave, as a dear brother."
c)Allegory:
Philemon, an allegory?
Consider the following passage (Philemon 8-18) with these analogies in mind:
Paul (the advocate) : Jesus
Onesmus (the guilty slave) : us (sinners)
Philemon (the slave owner) : God the Father
Accordingly, though I (Paul) am bold enough in Christ to command you
(Philemon) to do what is required, yet for love's sake I prefer to
appeal to you—I, Paul, an old man and now a prisoner also for Christ
Jesus— I appeal to you for my child, Onesimus, whose father I became in my imprisonment. (Formerly
he was useless to you, but now he is indeed useful to you and to me.)
I am sending him back to you, sending my very heart. I would
have been glad to keep him with me, in order that he might serve me on
your behalf during my imprisonment for the gospel, but I preferred to
do nothing without your consent in order that your goodness might not
be by compulsion but of your own free will. For this perhaps is why
he was parted from you for a while, that you might have him back
forever, no longer as a slave but more than a slave, as a beloved
brother—especially to me, but how much more to you, both in the flesh and in the Lord. So if you consider me your partner, receive him as you would receive
me. If he has wronged you at all, or owes you anything, charge that
to my account. I, Paul, write this with my own hand: I will repay
it—to say nothing of your owing me even your own self. LINK: Philemon, an allegory?
"There is the kiss and the counterkiss, and if one wins, we both lose." -Walter Brueggemann -
---------------
We covered the biblical tradition of the "holy kiss" in our gathering last Sunday.
It was a lot of fun. We started with a game of Hangman;
We had "Holy _ _ _ _" on the whiteboard when folks came in!
They has to guess what four letter word filled in the blank to make this a phrase that appears in Scripture. When i said "yes" to the first guess of "S," you should have heard the comments!
That the Bible explicitly mentions this practice five times:
Romans 16.16a — "Greet one another with a holy kiss" (Greek: ἀσπάσασθε ἀλλήλους ἐν φιλήματι ἁγίῳ).
I Corinthians 16.20b — "Greet one another with a holy kiss" (Greek: ἀσπάσασθε ἀλλήλους ἐν φιλήματι ἁγίῳ).
II Corinthians 13.12a — "Greet one another with a holy kiss" (Greek: ἀσπάσασθε ἀλλήλους ἐν ἁγίῳ φιλήματι).
I Thessalonians 5.26 — "Greet all the brothers with a holy kiss" (Greek: ἀσπάσασθε τοὺς ἀδελφοὺς πάντας ἐν φιλήματι ἁγίῳ).
I Peter 5.14a — "Greet one another with a kiss of love" (Greek: ἀσπάσασθε ἀλλήλους ἐν φιλήματι ἀγάπης).
...makes it a classic case study in how to apply
any scriptures that we assume need a cultural equivalent to out taking them literally.
(Though some of our folks took the "holy kiss" literally Sunday..no, not on the lips....I wish I had video..someone post the stories!(:...)
On this issue of interpretation:
Brian Dodd's discussion of the "interpretive bridge" is helpful (p. 19 here)
as is
Ron Martoia's posts on the "two buckets" (see "The Two Bucket Theory Examined" here).
I really recommend you read both above links, then get back to us.
They helped us when we tackled women in leadership, and homosexuality.
We learned that, counterintuitively to our guesses from this end of the cultural bridge, it seems the early church's holy kissing was almost always... on the lips!
The reason is powerful: that form on kiss implied equality...a kiss on the cheeks implied one person was inferior. Nothing like a Kingdom Kiss as an acted parable and reminder that in Christ we are equal! Of course, today, when we look at cultural equivalents like the "holy hug", "holy handshake," we might not realize that that, too, began as a Kingdom equalizer:
In fact, handshaking, which can seem quite prosaic today, was popularised by Quakers as a sign of equality under God, rather than stratified system of etiquette of seventeenth century England
-link
Ironically, the kiss of inclusion became a kiss of exclusion (from centered to bounded set):
Just as kissing had many different meanings in the wider ancient world, so too early Christians interpreted the kiss in various ways. Because ancient kissing was often seen as a familiar gesture, many early Christians kissed each other to help construct themselves as a new sort of family, a family of Christ. Similarly, in the Greco-Roman world, kissing often was seen as involving a transfer of spirit; when you kissed someone else you literally gave them part of your soul. The early church expanded on this and claimed that, when Christians kissed, they exchanged the Holy Spirit with one another. Christians also emphasized the kiss as an indication of mutual forgiveness (it’s from here that we get the term “kiss of peace”). These different meanings influenced and were influenced by the sorts of rituals kissing became associated with. For example, because the kiss helped exchange spirit, it made perfect sense for it to become part of baptism and ordination, rituals in which you wanted the Holy Spirit to descend and enter the initiate. The flip side of the coin is that before someone was baptized you wouldn’t want to kiss them. Early Christians often believed that previous to exorcism and baptism people were inevitably demon possessed. Given that they also thought that kissing resulted in spiritual exchange, it’s pretty clear why you wouldn’t want to kiss non-Christians. I sometimes think of this as an ancient form of “cooties.” It resulted in early Christian debates over whether one could kiss a pagan relative, if one should kiss a potential heretic, or if Jews even had a kiss. -Penn, link
We incorporated insights from these and other articles linked below, and quoted the only book on the topic, "Kissing Christians" by Michael Penn. You'll note some of the articles below include interview with him. We particularly enjoyed some of the early fathers and teachers' comments and guidelines on the practice.
One early guideline, for real (wonder if this was in the weekly "bulletin"):
1)No French Kissing!
2)If you come back for seconds, because you liked the first kiss too much, you may be going to hell!!
"when your lips draw close to the lips of your brother, let your heart not draw away."
One interview with Michael Penn:
By Rich Barlow
Whoever said ''a kiss is just a kiss" didn't know their theological history. During Christianity's first five centuries, ritual kissing -- on the lips -- was a vital part of worship, says Michael P. Penn, who teaches religion at Mount Holyoke College in South Hadley. In that context, kissing helped Christians define themselves as a family of faith, he writes in his new book, ''Kissing Christians: Ritual and Community in the Late Ancient Church" (University of Pennsylvania Press). Excerpts from a recent interview follow.
Q: Let me start with the basic question: Who kissed whom?
A: In the first two centuries [AD], men may kiss men, women women, but also you would have men and women kissing one another. In future centuries, there continued to be a debate over who should kiss whom. In later years, Christians will no longer have men and women kissing each other, but only men men, women women. [Christians had] debates on whether or not priests could kiss the laity, on whether you should kiss a non-Christian relative in the normal, everyday situation, even debates over whether Jews have a kiss or not.
Q: When in the service was the kiss performed?
A: Our earliest references would be a kiss that would follow a communal prayer. Later on, it gets increasingly associated with the Eucharist and also occurs in part of the rites of baptism and in ordination rites. You have Christians kissing each other as an everyday greeting or also martyrs, before they're killed, kissing one another.
Q: What was the theological significance?
A: In antiquity, a kiss on the lips was seen as transferring a little bit of one's spirit to the other person. You have a lot of early -- I kind of think of them almost as Greco-Roman Harlequin -- novels that speak of the kiss as this transfer of spirit. Christians modify it a bit, to suggest that when Christians kiss each other, they don't just exchange their own spirit, but also share a part of the Holy Spirit with one another. So the kiss is seen as a way to bind the community together.
There's another side, though. There was a concern that kissing an individual who has promised to join the Christian community but isn't yet baptized should be avoided, because the spirit that would be transferred wouldn't be a holy spirit but a demonic spirit. So you have the kiss working as this ritual of exclusion.
Q: Did Christian leaders worry about the erotic overtones?
A: We have only two explicit references to this concern. One says, essentially, to kiss with a closed and chaste mouth, which suggests that a few of these kisses may have been too erotic. The other one warns against those who kiss a second time because they liked the first one so much.
Judas kissing Jesus [to betray him] terrifies them a lot more than eroticism. There's this evil intention behind it. Early Christian writers use the kiss of Judas to warn that it's not just how you practice the kiss, but what you're thinking. If you kiss another Christian while keeping evil in your heart against them, you are repeating Judas' betrayal.
Q: When did kissing fall out of favor?
A: In the third century, men and women are no longer to kiss one another. Early Christians met in what we think of as a house church -- you meet in someone's living room, essentially. Starting in the third century, when Christians [worship] in a public forum, this familial kiss is less appropriate. It's also a time where Christianity becomes concerned with making sure women and men are categorically separated. In the fourth century, that clergy and laity become increasingly distant. You start having prohibitions against clergy and laity kissing one another.
The ritual kiss never entirely died out. We still have it as an exchange of peace [in Christian services]. We see it in the kissing of the pope's ring. In Catholicism, a priest may kiss a ritual object.
Q: What would Christianity have been without the kiss?
A: What I find exciting is to see how what we think of as trivial is so central to early Christian self-understanding. Our earliest Christian writing, Paul's letter to the First Thessalonians, talks about the ritual kiss, albeit briefly. We have hundreds of early Christian references to this ritual. For these authors, it was anything but trivial.
2. It is helpful for sharing Jesus with not-yet Christians;
3. It tilts from a Central Asian perspective and application, and helps us look sideways at our assumptions and habits that paralyze us from moving out of the bunker of church-culture;
4. I know Steve and Marilyn to live what they say here. They speak from character rather than professional training--I find that usually has much more umph.
5. It is freely received, freely given. I forward the authorization below so you can feel free to forward this study to anyone you think it might help.
Here below is an excerpt that called to mind my experience with the precious Quechua people in Peru..food you couldn't turn down, story here); and also dovetails with our discussion of "sacrament" of the Love Feast as organic/missional, link here).
I will excerpt more later.. the whole document is on Google Docs here, and appendix here.
Chapter 6
MANDATED EATING AND DRINKING
“And remain in the same house, eating and drinking such things at they give, for the labourer is worthy of his wages. Do not go from house to house. Whatever city you enter and they receive you, eat such things as are set before you.”Luke 10:6- 7
A/ RELATIONAL INTEGRITY AND MULTIPLICATION
Once you find your house of peace- stay there.Or as Peterson says in the Message, “Do not move from house to house looking for the best cook in town.”Once you find a house of peace, honour that house.Demonstrate relational integrity, faithfulness and friendship.If God has led you there, stick out any misunderstandings and difficulties and stay there. Work it out.
Thecommand to remain links with the command of Jesus to make disciples,to train all to obey the things that Jesus commanded.We are not counting decision cards.Your house of peace connection is not a one time event.This is the long term!You stay in the house,stay in relational connection and do not leave them until the job of discipleship is done and then you still continue as friends.You teach them to be the pastor of their family and friends in their own house.A new friendmay be comfortable coming to your house but their family and friends will not.You do not want to gather to yourself.You want to go to newhouses and teach your man of peace to do the same.You want multiplication.By yourself you can only see growth by addition but when your disciples do the same, you start to see multiplication.By the fourth generation it is out of control but the key is to multiply quality relationships.
Jesus hadtwelve disciples and stuck withthem for three years.He kept sending the crowds away, especially when they wanted to make him king.He poured His life into the twelve.He did not add to the twelve since He did not want to dilute the quality of the relationships which He shared with them.I have heard many testimonies of the intimate, joyfulfriendship enjoyed by folks as they started a church in someone's home.They grew and soon felt they needed a building and as they grew they lost the quality of those first relationships.Instead of friendships, came programs and as they became successful numerically, they lost their first love.This is the result of growth by addition.
Jesus did not dilute the quality of relationships by allowing others into the group of twelve.You can easily imagine that others wanted to join but He did not let them.If each of the twelve had then had their own groups of disciples those groups could enjoy the same quality of relationships.The growth is through multiplication and through releasing new generations of disciples.This is not some top down multi level marketingprogram but the natural expression of healthy relational life.
B/ EATNG, DRINKING ANDACCEPTANCE OR BELONGING, BEHAVIOR AND BELIEF
We have found every culture is the same in one way.When you eat with new friends they are always anxious to know if you enjoy the food.Why?If you enjoy the food, you show acceptance and enjoyment of their culture, of their likes and dislikes, of their gifts to you and, ultimately,of them.
This command to eat and drink “such things as they give”is a very strong command in a conservative Jewish culture which forbade the eating of many things as “unclean”.Eat whatever is set before you?This was a cultural divide that Peter needed a very strong dream repeated three times to understand and get over.Because of that dream he was ready to eat unclean food with unclean Gentiles in the house of Cornelius in Acts 10 and then defend that decision before the other apostles in Acts 11.
Notice the order in Luke 10 7- 9... We are to eat,serve and then declare the Kingdom.Eating together shows acceptance but in the culture of that day it was even stronger.To break bread with another meant that you were committing to be their friend for life.Jesus repeats the eating commandment twice.Then we are to serve and then we are to declare “the Kingdom of God has come near to you.”
Let us put that another way, first belonging, friendship and community then secondly behaviour, serving, meeting needs and lastly belief, truth and the communication of the Kingdom- belonging, behaviour and belief.Most of the traditional evangelical community has reversed those three things.We have tended to demand that people first agree with our version of truth, believe the same way that we do and then behave like we do and if they do so, then we will accept them- they can belong.Our acceptance is the reward we give to others for believing like we do and behaving as we would want them to.
Jesus did not do that.He went to Zacchaeus' house (Luke 19) and because of this acceptance and friendship, Zacchaeus received conviction and grace to change his behaviour
Thefirst requirement to be a good apostle is not long academic training but someone who is able to enjoy all kinds of people and who is able to eat and drink with them!
Due to an offhanded comment, i "accidentally" started to compose a list of " the top five books that should be included in seminary curriculums, but likely aren't."
I am thinking of books that likely aren't officially "Christian," or officially about "Christian" topics, but offer valuable lessons re: life and ministry in the postmodern world. Or maybe books that may be theological, but push envelopes, norms and forms..books we may not agree with doctrinally, but God can use to form us as far as cultural sensitivity.
Love to see your list!! Post them below.
Oh, here are my first (off the wall, and odd the cuff) three, including one (second link) that I actually was allowed to use in seminary (Gotta love Asbury! I even joked about sneaking it into the seminary in a brown paper bag!). In no particular order:
Oh, it should go without saying that, if I go with a list of books that are in some way officially Christian/theological, the list gets easy and long.. Of course, "Get Up From Your Knees: Preaching the U2 Catalog" should make the list...Wolfgang Simson, Alan Hirsch, Annie Dillard..et al... Love to see your lists of those...but:
I would really love to hear your more provocative..unobvious...good "pagan" books, yeah! (:
Even though Brian Dodd's response was profound, and ideally should shut down all submissions:
Dave, I find the whole exercise self-defeating. It is a wrong question, that leads to wrong answers, that lead to misguided behavior. We need to be a people of ONE book. We are anemic as a church, not because our religious professionals need to read different books, but because we read--and do--everything but the Bible. When I was a leadership ... See Moreprofessor at your alma mater, I continually got this feedback for my "Servant is Leader" class: "I read more Bible in your leadership class than I have in any of my Bible classes." Sad, but true. The Bible sheds a lot of light on the commentaries and commentators. The command is not to understand, but to stand-under, and to "teach them to OBEY ALL that I have commanded you." Oh, give me the book of God! I want to know the way to heaven! Brian (for more on this, see "Why I am not writing another book" @ http://www.brianjdodd.blogspot.com/). - Brian J Dodd
I sometimes get asked if I am writing another book, usually by someone who has read one of the 5 I wrote. Sometimes I have been told that I am "wasting talents" since I am not writing books. That is not how I feel. I believe I am faithfully following the path Jesus has led me down. Here are some milestones on that path:
1. During my Ph.D. studies, I was struck by the New Testament and early church identification of false apostles and teachers as those who "peddled the word of God." It occurred to me too slowly--being overeducated but not all that bright sometimes--that perhaps the Christian publishing industry was a source of darkness rather than light.
2. Several years ago, I was invited to speak at Expolito, the Spanish Christian Booksellers annual meeting in Miami, Florida, at the release of a Spanish translation of my book on ministry in the Spirit according to Paul. Since I could not keep up with the speed of the conversation over several days, I was forced to pay attention to what I was seeing. For the most part, the convention wasn't even bothering to "peddle the word of God"--they were peddling everything but. (They learned from their English language version's bad example). Hmmmm, I thought, this is NOT good. Not good at all. I think during that time the penny dropped for me that I needed to stop writing books and put the emphasis elsewhere.
3. I became more and more aware in homes that I visited and conversations with Christians that we were full of books, but not people of One Book. People talked about what their pastor had preached or favorite author had written, but NOT about what God had told them to obey. We are a church and nation of spiritual prurience, ever spectating from the bunker, rarely in the game or on the front line. I began to connect the dots: we are what we eat, and we have been feeding on the chaff of human doctrine, not the meat of God's Word. There is an old principle that applies: if the horse you are riding on is dead, for God's sake, dismount.
4. Jesus' parting charge to us kept coming to my mind: "teach them to obey all that I have commanded to you." We have distorted that into left-brain rationalism without action, rock-star conference culture of hero worship and heads full of knowledge but lacking wisdom, tough-mindedness ("wise as a serpent") and a cutting edge to the mission of our lives. The salt has lost its saltiness, and our little lights no longer shine. The words we overlook in Jesus' charge are crucial: OBEY and ALL. He didn't put a big premium on understanding and analyzing. The emphasis was on standing-under and actualizing His word. We need to be people of one book--in compliance to its wisdom we become an arrow shot from and to heaven.
5. One day I was pondering why church-as-we-know-it is not the scary threat to hell's doors that Jesus said he would build ("I will build my church, and the gates of hell will not prevail against it"). And, it is not even mildly effective at evangelizing not-yet Christians in our culture. It finally dawned on me. This is NOT the church Jesus built. This is a straw house on sandy foundation built on mere human wisdom and celebrity or tradition. This is the church WE built--that is why it is so pathetic. Jesus never told us to build churches. He told us to train them to comply and practice everything he imparted to us. If we do that, He does his part--builds a church whose advance hell can't stop. I see it now here, now there. When the rains come down and the storm crashes in, all that will stand is such houses built on the rock of obedience to Jesus as Lord.
So here is the "book" that I am supposed to write. Paul's self-understanding in 2 Corinthians 3:2-4 is my example to emulate: "You yourselves are our letter, written on our hearts, known and read by everybody. You show that you are a letter from Christ, the result of our ministry, written not with ink but with the Spirit of the living God, not on tablets of stone but on tablets of human hearts. Such confidence as this is ours through Christ before God."
The book I am to write is pages on others' lives as I seek to obey all Jesus taught, and teach them to do the same. I am not to write a book on paper between covers but on souls with skin. Here are some of the best books and articles I am writing that you may have never read: Ingrid, Julia, Jeff, Kirstie, Carlo, Elizabeth. I hope you get a chance to read them some day.
Whose lives are you writing the kingdom of God upon?
(Oh yeah, one other milestone. AJ, Julia and Jeff Rogers kept pressing me to write something on the internet--Julia got me to blog. I see this as more of a journal than publishing. More a soap box of what I would shout across the nation to Alaska and Hawaii, than what anyone else would ever want to "publish." Since only about two and half people ever read it, it has no danger of supplanting my life-writing mission).