Welcome! You have accidentally reached the blog of a heteroclite follower of Jesus: dave wainscott. I'm "pushing toward the unobvious" as I post thinkings/linkings re: Scripture, church and culture. Hot topics include: temple tantrums, time travel, sexuality/spirituality, U2kklesia, role of the pastor, God-haunted music/art..and subversive videos like these.
Pages
Search Me:
Showing posts with label christian bookstore. Show all posts
Showing posts with label christian bookstore. Show all posts
Friday, October 16, 2015
Tuesday, August 26, 2014
Austin Farrrer on "probable tracks" of Jesus' temptations: subversion of Paethon and temple tantrum connections
![]() |
| hotel in Israel |
As one with a special interest in the temptations of Jesus, literary structure of Matthew, I wouldn't have resisted the testation to buy it at double the price (:
Come on..NO reviews on Amazon US or Amazon UK (He was British)?!...
"His activity in philosophy, theology, and
spirituality led many to consider him the outstanding figure of 20th
century Anglicanism. -Wikipedia
Turns out he was well-respected by C.S. Lewis,and had an intriguing solution for the synoptic problem. Wiki calls him a "maverick."
I like him already...even if/especially if he is sometimes wrong (:
Even in the preface, Frederick Borsh partly agrees with accusations of Farrer's sometimes fanciful flights into literary structural analysis, midrash and typology. But he defends him as being very thoughtful, creative..and ahead of his time as far as redaction/compositional criticism etc. "He may have seen too many typologies, but he was not wrong in understanding that biblical writers often thought in typological categories. This keen awareness pays particularly rich dividends in his study of Christ's temptations." (p. 2)
He does well, as does Donald Kraybill, in seeing many links from the temptations to the rest of Matthew's gospel.
I haven't read enough for a review yet, so I'll just
1)ask if any are familiar with this work
2)quote this:
Satan's insinuation...contains a hidden poison: "If you are the Son of God..If you cannot or dare not, what sort of divine Son are you?"...
Jesus declines..not because it is wicked..but because it is wicked to make a willful use of spiritual power...
"throw yourself down"...The suggested action is so utterly useless in itself, it can have one purpose only:.."Jump and find out; if you won't jump you can't really believe it."
...Christ refused to do what Phaethon did [doubt his paternity]. But could he have even thought in those terms? We may give a double reply. First, though Christ did not think that God was an inhabitant of Jerusalem, he took the sanctity of the holy place with complete seriousness He can, indeed, be said to have pulled his own death on his head, by taking the law into his own hands and cleansing the temple from trade. Second, we must say that in dreams or visions symbols become realities...
..It would be absurd to claim any sort of certainty for the suggestions we have advanced. We cannot be sure what paths of association Christ's visionary thoughts, as St Matthew represents them, follow out. Yet our guesses are not valueless. They were the sort of lines along which a devout Jewish imagination ran; and the exercise of working out probable tracks and junctions in the movement of such a mind puts us in sympathy with the author we are trying to understand.. Chapter IV
Tuesday, August 12, 2014
Gungorgate: banned for agreeing with C.S. Lewis (and having Rob Bell and Rachel Held Evans help with their CD)
Re: the new CD by "The Liturgists" ( a Gungor side project)
From World Magazine:
Michael Gungor responds:
From the Gungor Facebook:
--
Previous posts:
From World Magazine:
"Gungor Drifts From Biblical Orthodoxy.”
Michael Gungor responds:
From the Gungor Facebook:
"We have now had three concerts cancel and Lifeway Christian bookstores has removed us from their shelves for Michael agreeing with C.S. Lewis rather than Ken Ham about Genesis. Here's an interview with biologos.org about why Michael stands behind his position." http://biologos.org/blog/faith-after-literalism-an-interview-with-michael-gungor
--
Previous posts:
Friday, February 28, 2014
The infamous Derek Webb interview: faith, music and innovation
Below: the infamous Seth Howard Hurd interview of Derek Webb which lead to this book .
Hurd said of this interview: "..after 10 years in media (and interviewing everyone from Gerard Butler to Barack Obama)……I think this is the most important interview of my career." Amazon book description:
Hurd said of this interview: "..after 10 years in media (and interviewing everyone from Gerard Butler to Barack Obama)……I think this is the most important interview of my career." Amazon book description:
"Last time I checked, no matter what kind of band you are, no matter how you're gifted, no matter what your calling is, if you don't have a worship song...you will not get played on the radio. So, these bands who have no business writing or recording worship music, because it's not how they are called or gifted, are doing it because they have to have a radio single.
I never thought I would long for a day when Christian music was just bad and kind of irrelevant. Now it's all that, and offensive too."
--Derek Webb, 12/21/12
Seth Tower Hurd spent a decade in Christian radio. The final three were pure misery, as the "Christian hits" format, which was originally designed to offer relevant music outside of the typical "soccer mom" stereotype, slowly died.
After Hurd lost his job for "not appealing to 38 year old women," he released a book entitled "What Becky Didn't Want (Or: A Short Account of the Brief Life of Christian Hit Radio."
This in turn led to a 90 minute long Google Hangout conversation with renowned singer-songwriter Derek Webb, centering around the tension between faith and commerce in the "Christian" music industry.
The video took on a life of it's own, and is transcribed as the first section of this book. The remaining sections were submitted by as response essays by a variety of artists, writers and independent thinkers.
"I hope Seth Tower Hurd gets over his bitterness."
-Christian radio manager
Christian radio DJ: "Would you have written this book if you were still in the industry?"
Seth Tower Hurd: "Well, no. I would have been fired. Because, in the industry, you're pressured to keep secrets. Which is pretty much why I wrote the book." link
Tuesday, December 31, 2013
crossover crossdressers: Needtobreathe
For some reason...I don't know, maybe complaining Christians...Conan's website had dropped the video of Needtbreathe performing in drag...uh, pulling a Dalton Brothers. It was a Halloween broadcast, and they were actually dressed as Dolly Parton, Reba McEntire, Taylor Swift, Tina Turner and Minnie Pearl to play “Girl Named Tennessee ." Funny that a lot of people don't know this is a "Christian band" (or something like that).. ..Here is a YouTubed version, and some backstory:
Harvest Crusade’s Invite to ‘Crossover’ Band Who Dressed Like Women Questioned
Wednesday, December 18, 2013
Friday, December 06, 2013
"The view that a pastor is more ‘Christian’ than a girls volleyball coach is flawed and heretical"
Jon Foreman of Switchfoot, on being asked if his band is a Christian band:
(Note: none of the places I've seen this interview give a source/link. As soon as I find one, I will give credit. In the meantime, I'll assume it's legit, and will link to the place I first found it)
(Note: none of the places I've seen this interview give a source/link. As soon as I find one, I will give credit. In the meantime, I'll assume it's legit, and will link to the place I first found it)
“To be honest, this question grieves me because I feel that it represents a much bigger issue than simply a couple SF tunes. In true Socratic form, let me ask you a few questions: Does Lewis or Tolkien mention Christ in any of their fictional series? Are Bach’s sonata’s Christian? What is more Christ-like, feeding the poor, making furniture, cleaning bathrooms, or painting a sunset? There is a schism between the sacred and the secular in all of our modern minds.
The view that a pastor is more ‘Christian’ than a girls volleyball coach is flawed and heretical. The stance that a worship leader is more spiritual than a janitor is condescending and flawed. These different callings and purposes further demonstrate God’s sovereignty.
Many songs are worthy of being written. Switchfoot will write some, Keith Green, Bach, and perhaps yourself have written others. Some of these songs are about redemption, others about the sunrise, others about nothing in particular: written for the simple joy of music.
None of these songs has been born again, and to that end there is no such thing as Christian music. No. Christ didn’t come and die for my songs, he came for me. Yes. My songs are a part of my life. But judging from scripture I can only conclude that our God is much more interested in how I treat the poor and the broken and the hungry than the personal pronouns I use when I sing. I am a believer. Many of these songs talk about this belief. An obligation to say this or do that does not sound like the glorious freedom that Christ died to afford me.
I do have an obligation, however, a debt that cannot be settled by my lyrical decisions. My life will be judged by my obedience, not my ability to confine my lyrics to this box or that.
We all have a different calling; Switchfoot is trying to be obedient to who we are called to be. We’re not trying to be Audio A or U2 or POD or Bach: we’re trying to be Switchfoot. You see, a song that has the words: ‘Jesus Christ’ is no more or less ‘Christian’ than an instrumental piece. (I’ve heard lots of people say Jesus Christ and they weren’t talking about their redeemer.) You see, Jesus didn’t die for any of my tunes. So there is no hierarchy of life or songs or occupation only obedience. We have a call to take up our cross and follow. We can be sure that these roads will be different for all of us. Just as you have one body and every part has a different function, so in Christ we who are many form one body and each of us belongs to all the others. Please be slow to judge ‘brothers’ who have a different calling.” -LINK
Tuesday, December 03, 2013
Thursday, October 17, 2013
Lecrea inteviewed by Ed Stetzer
Video description:Lecrae discusses Christian labels and if they are helpful, being
missional in the music industry, and role of hip hop during this special
interview with guest host Eric Geiger on this episode of The Exchange
with Ed Stetzer.
Lecrae - The Exchange - Aired May 28, 2013 from Ed Stetzer on Vimeo.
Friday, October 04, 2013
Jack Heaslip...along with NT. Wright, David Dark, Frederick Buechner and other harry ticks like Rob Bell
You probably never even knew it existed.Too bad it's been banished to the cutout rack because folks think Rob Bell is a hairy tick.
It's actually full of good stuff..by Rob and by some great folks like
N.T. Wright,
David Dark,
Frederick Buechner,
Cathleen Falsasni,
Oswald Chambers (!)
Peter Rollins
David Miller et al..
a great chapter by Clayton Libolt on "Becoming a Deep Reader of Scripture...
including two original chapters by U2's chaplain, Jack Heaslip. (If that's a new name to you, he's delightful; start here: "Jack Heaslip/Bono Audio: Elevation Tour Blessing")
.
It's the "Love Wins companion"..on sale now at Barnes and Noble...and of course not even stocked in the Christian bookstore (whatever!). The enhanced edition has videos.
Do check out Heaslip's contributions: the foreword (free read on PDF here), and "Playing With Rocks" from Chapter 6 (Read it here on Google books, it's only missing the last page).
One line: "Jesus owned up to being himself"
Tuesday, August 27, 2013
Vampire Weekend: the safe ecclesiology of headphones
From Chris Leonard:
Call it the evangelical comedown. We don’t talk about it often, but when we do, it’s a tough topic among my friends. I find to my surprise, in a city as diverse as Nashville, that apart from all superficial appearances to the contrary, we share a common bond of evangelical upbringing from which we diverge in several directions. Christian college, like a four year church camp, resulted for many of us in a decade-long comedown that unwound slowly toward various shades of agnosticism, atheism, or re-personalized orthodoxy.
We’ve left countless churches that failed to make a safe space for hard questioning, some of us finally resting elsewhere, many of us nowhere. Largely, the safe space we’ve found has been our headphones — music that opens the imagination and lyrics that re-open the discussion. Tell someone that you listen to David Bazan, Mumford and Sons, or Derrick Brown, and suddenly you’re talking about more than music.
And now, with the release of their third record, Modern Vampires in the City, you can count Vampire Weekend among these. LINK: Vampire Weekend and the Evangelical Comedown
.
Billy Corgan: God as the future of rock music; U2 and Christian rock
Excerpt (see him say it on video here)
.
.
END
CORGAN: And, you know, they asked 50 artists, "What's the future of rock?" And my answer was, "God". And they said, "What do you mean?" And I said, "Well, God's the third rail of -" What is it? "Social security is the third rail of politics in America". Well, God is the third rail in rock and roll. You're not supposed to talk about God. Even though most of the world believes in God. It's sort of like, "Don't go there".
I think God's the great, unexplored territory in rock and roll music. And I actually said that. I thought it was perfectly poised. And, of course, they didn't put it in the interview.
RAJPAL: What would you say to Christian rockers, then?
CORGAN: Make better music.
(LAUGHTER)
CORGAN: Personally, my opinion - I think Jesus would like better bands, you know?
(LAUGHTER)
CORGAN: Now I'm going to get a bunch of Christian rock hate mail.
RAJPAL: But that's interesting -
CORGAN: Just wait, here's a better quote -
RAJPAL: Yes.
CORGAN: Hey, Christian rock, if you want to be good, stop copying U2. U2 already did it. You know what I mean? There's a lot of U2-esque Christian rock.
RAJPAL: Sure.
CORGAN: Bono and company created the template for modern Christian rock. And I like to think Jesus would want us all to evolve. full transcript
.
.
END
ZwanSong
Labels:
christian bookstore,
spirituality of music,
U2
Friday, April 12, 2013
mundane yet dramatic spiritual warfare: running signs (and demons) off significant cliffs via random acts of kindness
Mistook signs for signified
And so since I’ve often tried
To run them off a cliff like Gadarene swine
-mewithoutYou, "Fox's Dream Of The Log Flume"
---
How many times have you seen doll-size (or life-size)individual Christian soldiers in full armor (per Ephesians 6, of course) on the shelves or in the window of a Christian bookstore?
Well meaning............
...but well off the mark.
Not as creepy as the John Haggai teddy bear.....
....but (ironically) dangerous, exegetically.
For several reasons.
One has been dealt with in a previous post (misundertaking spiritual warfare: reading in context and in (anabaptist) communitas):
The "you"s are plural throughout. Read passages you thought you had all figured out in that light, especially 2:8-10, 3:16....and the passage at hand.
How exactly to imagine the armor on a group calls for...well, imagination.
(imagine that! Imagination...in church? This calls for spirituality that is actually Ignatian and SpongeBob-ian).
Guy Chevrau, in a helpful book, offers one possibility:
Even though Chevrau gathers his historical info from a trusted historical source (Rome at War), we still don't know for sure if this is the picture Paul means to evoke. Thus the same problem on the other side of the ditch: the image will definitely preach! And the powerful image (sign) may well stick in our minds more than actually using our faith (the sign-ified)....and other elements of armor)
It's the inevitable risk of a visual metaphor/parable/sign...
a risk God takes all over Scripture,
Jesus takes every time he opens his mouth (Matthew 13:34-35)
and Paul takes head on in the Ephesians text.
We in the West have focused on, obsexxed on the individual...thus individual armor.
I would venture many USAmerican fundagelicals go through the motions of "Putting on the shield of faith"....without the faith..
Like the character in the mewithoutYou song, "mistook signs for signified."
It's faith like a shield, not a "shield like faith."
Sometimes, after the metaphor has done its work and subverted us ( see Eugene Peterson's delightful...and still metaphorical.... definition of metaphor: "a loud fart in the salon of spirituality"), we can then in the (metaphorical!) language of the song, drive all said signs/demons of a cliff, so that only the signified signified remains.
Peterson's Message Bible is amazing on this passage. . It's not as sassy and sexy as most translations, which encourage us ti get jazzed up and armored up for some war games... but it is a necessary correction. Note it completely refuses to even mention the signs (pieces of armor). The emphasis and onus is thus off the armor, and all attention on the real reality.
The most helpful commentator I know on Ephesians is Tim Gombis:

Okay, we's heard that already. But keep reading! Gombis maintains that
The clincher:
Drat! To "do spiritual warfare," I might just have to (get to) do something as non-dramatic as..
drum roll, please..
Love my neighbor.
But in fact, as mundane as that is, Gombis holds that it IS dramatic..in the biblical sense.
And that is the whole point (His book is "The Drama of Ephesians," buy it yesterday).
And start some mundane, messianic, dramatic...and sign-ificantly subversive warfare to beat the devil.
And so since I’ve often tried
To run them off a cliff like Gadarene swine
-mewithoutYou, "Fox's Dream Of The Log Flume"
---
How many times have you seen doll-size (or life-size)individual Christian soldiers in full armor (per Ephesians 6, of course) on the shelves or in the window of a Christian bookstore?
Well meaning............
...but well off the mark.
Not as creepy as the John Haggai teddy bear.....
....but (ironically) dangerous, exegetically.
For several reasons.
One has been dealt with in a previous post (misundertaking spiritual warfare: reading in context and in (anabaptist) communitas):
The letter is to a church community, not an individual. It's not the letter to the Ephesian.
The "you"s are plural throughout. Read passages you thought you had all figured out in that light, especially 2:8-10, 3:16....and the passage at hand.
How exactly to imagine the armor on a group calls for...well, imagination.
(imagine that! Imagination...in church? This calls for spirituality that is actually Ignatian and SpongeBob-ian).
Guy Chevrau, in a helpful book, offers one possibility:
In fact, we do not stand alone. The entire armor passage is addressed not to an individual believer but to the Church. The pronouns are all plural. In Texas they would say correctly, "Y'all stand." The whole metaphor is a corporate calling.. This especially casts the "shield of faith in a new light/. The shield Paul names is not the small, round, garbage can lid.of a shield but literally the thyreos...a Roman soldier would hold this shield in his left hand and the right two thirds of the shield would cover his left side. The left third of the shield covered his fellow soldier's exposed right. When the troops were in position, they created a defensive position called the 'tortoise,' When the legionaires held their shields overhead and the front rows interlocked their shields, they created a kind of shell-like armor. link, p. 138
Even though Chevrau gathers his historical info from a trusted historical source (Rome at War), we still don't know for sure if this is the picture Paul means to evoke. Thus the same problem on the other side of the ditch: the image will definitely preach! And the powerful image (sign) may well stick in our minds more than actually using our faith (the sign-ified)....and other elements of armor)
It's the inevitable risk of a visual metaphor/parable/sign...
a risk God takes all over Scripture,
Jesus takes every time he opens his mouth (Matthew 13:34-35)
and Paul takes head on in the Ephesians text.
We in the West have focused on, obsexxed on the individual...thus individual armor.
I would venture many USAmerican fundagelicals go through the motions of "Putting on the shield of faith"....without the faith..
Like the character in the mewithoutYou song, "mistook signs for signified."
It's faith like a shield, not a "shield like faith."
Sometimes, after the metaphor has done its work and subverted us ( see Eugene Peterson's delightful...and still metaphorical.... definition of metaphor: "a loud fart in the salon of spirituality"), we can then in the (metaphorical!) language of the song, drive all said signs/demons of a cliff, so that only the signified signified remains.
Peterson's Message Bible is amazing on this passage. . It's not as sassy and sexy as most translations, which encourage us ti get jazzed up and armored up for some war games... but it is a necessary correction. Note it completely refuses to even mention the signs (pieces of armor). The emphasis and onus is thus off the armor, and all attention on the real reality.
0-12 And that about wraps it up. God is strong, and he wants you strong. So take everything the Master has set out for you, well-made weapons of the best materials. And put them to use so you will be able to stand up to everything the Devil throws your way. This is no afternoon athletic contest that we’ll walk away from and forget about in a couple of hours. This is for keeps, a life-or-death fight to the finish against the Devil and all his angels.13-18 Be prepared. You’re up against far more than you can handle on your own. Take all the help you can get, every weapon God has issued, so that when it’s all over but the shouting you’ll still be on your feet. Truth, righteousness, peace, faith, and salvation are more than words. Learn how to apply them. You’ll need them throughout your life. God’s Word is an indispensable weapon. In the same way, prayer is essential in this ongoing warfare. Pray hard and long. Pray for your brothers and sisters. Keep your eyes open. Keep each other’s spirits up so that no one falls behind or drops out.
The most helpful commentator I know on Ephesians is Tim Gombis:

In Ephesians 6:10-18, then, Paul is not merely addressing individuals but the entire gathered church...
Okay, we's heard that already. But keep reading! Gombis maintains that
.
.....Paul does not derive the armor of God from his pondering of the armor of a Roman soldier, therefore, but from a consideration of the Scriptures....
....The church engages in warfare in ways that defy and overturn our expectation
The clincher:
Our warfare against the powers takes place on a mundane level....Strategic acts of love and self-sacrificial service to others are cosmically significant. ---all quotes from his book
Drat! To "do spiritual warfare," I might just have to (get to) do something as non-dramatic as..
drum roll, please..
Love my neighbor.
But in fact, as mundane as that is, Gombis holds that it IS dramatic..in the biblical sense.
And that is the whole point (His book is "The Drama of Ephesians," buy it yesterday).
And start some mundane, messianic, dramatic...and sign-ificantly subversive warfare to beat the devil.
Friday, March 22, 2013
Kindle is not God
I know you know that..but since we bibliophiles/Kindlephiles can be tempted..
I thought you might get a kick out of this:
Scot McKnight posted a prayer on his blog; a great prayer that should be prayed, but I couldn't help chuckle at the unintentionally funny (and convicting) opening line...must be read carefully, so do click the link to get the context!: (:
PS: He could've prayed to a Kindle Fire, that would totally make sense, too..
I thought you might get a kick out of this:
Scot McKnight posted a prayer on his blog; a great prayer that should be prayed, but I couldn't help chuckle at the unintentionally funny (and convicting) opening line...must be read carefully, so do click the link to get the context!: (:
Almighty God, kindle, we pray.... (continued here)
PS: He could've prayed to a Kindle Fire, that would totally make sense, too..
Labels:
bibliolatry,
christian bookstore,
technology,
testation
Rob Bell and Michelle Shocked on gay marriage
It was ironic and interesting to catch these two headlines in the same feed (click each to read article):
Just when I was sure Bell's new book tour wouldn't be even close to as controversial as his last one!
Turns out this issue, and not the universalism issue may be the reason his Christian publisher dropped him last book out).
Some reflections by Tony Jones (and David Fich) can be read by clicking "Why Rob Bell Matters."
(BTW, on that book title, a great book about Rob Bell is this..but it will now need a new chapter ...already!
Bell has now done follow-up interview below:
Rob Bell Comes Out for Marriage Equality (audio included)
Folk Legend Incites Mass
Walkout With Anti-Gay Speech… In San Francisco
Just when I was sure Bell's new book tour wouldn't be even close to as controversial as his last one!
Turns out this issue, and not the universalism issue may be the reason his Christian publisher dropped him last book out).
Some reflections by Tony Jones (and David Fich) can be read by clicking "Why Rob Bell Matters."
(BTW, on that book title, a great book about Rob Bell is this..but it will now need a new chapter ...already!
Bell has now done follow-up interview below:
Transcript:
What we’re seeing right now in this day, I believe God pulling us ahead into greater and greater affirmation and acceptance of our gay brothers and sisters and pastors and friends and neighbors and co-workers. And we’re realizing that God made some of us one way and some of us another. And it can be a beautiful thing. And so instead of throwing stones and causing more pain and suffering in the world by excluding some and writing off others and speaking in incredibly unkindly about some, we embrace that we’re all on a journey and all of us together, whatever our particular perspective is, let’s work together on the real problems we have ahead of us.
A lot of people when they say, by God ahead, do you mean like same sex marriage and – yes. And we live in a world where we have friends, neighbors, brothers, sisters, aunts, uncles, people we’ve journeyed with for years who are gay. And we need to love, affirm and all of us together work on the real problems we have in the world.
And I think that’s one of the things you’re seeing right now, is you are seeing God pulling us all forward into a greater realization that we need more love. We need more fidelity. We need more monogamy. We need more people who are committed to each other. It’s not good for us to be alone. So this is a huge moment when I think lots of us are realizing the old way of seeing things doesn’t work. It causes so much pain and heartache. And God’s inviting us to see things in new ways. And we need to say yes and then we need to step into the future together.
Probably every generation had this sense of, “Man we’re living in the midst of history.” What’s interesting about this – and if you look through history, generally great new technological breakthroughs caused a ripple effect across culture. So technology seems to spur all sorts of social, economic, cultural and religious effects. And I think what has happened with the Internet – and lots of people are saying this – is simply you cannot live in your own tribal bubble anymore. You cannot stay cocooned off from how the world actually is.
And what happens when you are all suddenly exposed to thousands of different viewpoints is it can call your own into question and it can have this refining fire sort of dimension to it when you realize, “Wow, I’ve been living with a bunch of views and perspectives that don’t actually work and don’t actually bring life. So I need to be honest about that.” And that can be painful, but it’s also liberating. It’s where the life is. -link
Monday, February 25, 2013
thoughts on "Down By the River" anybody?
What do you think of the classic...and disturbing Neil Young song, "Down By the River"?
Never sang it in church, huh? (:
It's a lighthearted little ditty whose lyrics go like this:
That doesn't fit the "happy-clappy" category that Bono talked about.
But what is it?
I always long loved Beth Maynard 's quote on "the naive thought that any artist who
writes about sin must be in favor of it."
Knowing Neil Young, the song can't be an endorsement of, and encouragement toward, murder.
(See other posts of Neil Young and spirituality here)
So, sing it in church, maybe.
Is it psalmish?
Let art speak.
Neil Young himself would not surely keep the song boxed in by his own interpretation.
I love that The Indigo Girls and Dave Matthews have covered it.
When will Chris Tomlin also offer a cover?
That will sell..
Possible interpretations on the Song Meanings website here, apparent in-concert comments by Young here.
But maybe before reading all that, take it in. Not just the lyrics, but the music.
Never sang it in church, huh? (:
It's a lighthearted little ditty whose lyrics go like this:
Be on my side,
I'll be on your side, baby
There is no reason
For you to hide
It's so hard for me
Staying here all alone
When you could be
Taking me for a ride.
Yeah, she could drag me
Over the rainbow,
Send me away
Down by the river
I shot my baby
Down by the river,
Dead, oh, shot her dead.
You take my hand,
I'll take your hand
Together we may get away
This much madness
Is too much sorrow
It's impossible
To make it today.
That doesn't fit the "happy-clappy" category that Bono talked about.
But what is it?
I always long loved Beth Maynard 's quote on "the naive thought that any artist who
writes about sin must be in favor of it."
Knowing Neil Young, the song can't be an endorsement of, and encouragement toward, murder.
(See other posts of Neil Young and spirituality here)
So, sing it in church, maybe.
Is it psalmish?
Let art speak.
Neil Young himself would not surely keep the song boxed in by his own interpretation.
I love that The Indigo Girls and Dave Matthews have covered it.
When will Chris Tomlin also offer a cover?
That will sell..
Possible interpretations on the Song Meanings website here, apparent in-concert comments by Young here.
But maybe before reading all that, take it in. Not just the lyrics, but the music.
Labels:
christian bookstore,
lament,
spirituality of music,
U2
Saturday, February 16, 2013
2 more Godhaunted Neil Young somgs...ready for church
1) "When God Made Me"
Lots of interpretation of the song at this link, even some quotes from Young:
Ilove what someone commented under the live Farm Aid version on YouTube (posted below...be sure to see the genuine tears at the end):
WHEN GOD MADE ME
Was he thinking about my country,
or the colour of my skin?
Was he thinking about my religion,
and the way I worshipped him?
Did he create just me in his image,
or every living thing?
When God made me.
When God made me.
Was he planning only for believers,
or for those who just
had faith?
Did he envision all wars
that were fought in his name?
Did he say there was only one way
to be close to him?
When God made me.
When God made me.
Did he give me the gift of love
to say who I could choose?
When God made me.
When God made me.
When God made me.
Did he give me the gift of voice
so some could silence me?
Did he give me the gift of vision
not knowing what I might see?
Did he give me the gift of compassion
to help my fellow man?
When God made me.
When God made me.
When God made me.
2)"Change Your Mind"
I know this song was included on an album largely a response to Kurt Cobain's death
(Cobain even mentioned Young in his last journal entry), but I can't not also hear without interpreting "the one you love" as "the One you love"...thus another honest churchsong.
Hmmm...God "supports" you, "embraces" you, "soothes" you, 'restores you" (could be a CCM lyrics so far) "convinces" you.....and "destroys" you.
Isn't that the God you know?(:
(Song interp here)
When you get weak, and you need to test your will
When life's complete, but there's something missing still
Distracting you from this must be the one you love
Must be the one whose magic touch can change your mind
Don't let another day go by without the magic touch
Distracting you (change your mind)
Supporting you (change your mind)
Embracing you (change your mind)
Convincing you (change your mind)
When you're confused and the world has got you down
When you feel used and you just can't play the clown
Protecting you from this must be the one you love
Must be the one whose magic touch can change your mind
Don't let another day go by without the magic touch
Protecting you (change your mind)
Restoring you (change your mind)
Revealing you (change your mind)
Soothing you (change your mind)
You hear the sound, you wait around and get the word
You see the picture changing everything you've heard
Destroying you with this must be the one you love
Must be the one whose magic touch can change your mind
Don't let another day go by without the magic touch
Destroying you (change your mind)
Embracing you (change your mind)
Protecting you (change your mind)
Confining you (change your mind)
Distracting you (change your mind)
Supporting you (change your mind)
Distorting you (change your mind)
Controlling you (change your mind)
Change your mind (change your mind)
Change your mind, change your mind (change your mind)
Change your mind (change your mind)
The morning comes and there's an odor in the room
The scent of love, more than a million roses bloom
Embracing you with this must be the one you love
Must be the one whose magic touch can change your mind
Don't let another day go by without the magic touch
Embracing you (change your mind)
Concealing you (change your mind)
Protecting you (change your mind)
Revealing you (change your mind)
Change your mind, change your mind (change your mind)
Change your mind (change your mind)
Change your mind, change your mind (change your mind)
Change your mind (change your mind)
Change your mind, change your mind
Change your mind
Change your mind, change your mind
Change your mind
Change your mind, change your mind
Change your mind, change your mind
Lots of interpretation of the song at this link, even some quotes from Young:
In an interview with The New York Times by Jon Pareles, Young commented:
"I feel like our religion and our faith have been hijacked.
What is bothering me the most is the misappropriation of religion and faith, the misuse of God and the house of worship. It's one faith with different people trying to express it in different ways. It's all about being the little guy in the big world."
In an interview in Rolling Stone magazine by Alec Wilkerson:
"Young has a seeker's sensitivity, a susceptibility to impressions received in passing or only half-clearly. The hymn "When God Made Me" is deeply subversive. It is meant to unsettle those ardent believers whose certainty of holiness makes them feel they can abusively enforce their beliefs on the rest of the world.
"I was asking questions about faith," Young says. "But one kept evading me. I couldn't figure out what the last question was."
Ilove what someone commented under the live Farm Aid version on YouTube (posted below...be sure to see the genuine tears at the end):
I love this, because it isn't a straight religious song. So many questions, that's what makes it realistic.Why can't church music be more realistic indeed..questions included.
WHEN GOD MADE ME
Was he thinking about my country,
or the colour of my skin?
Was he thinking about my religion,
and the way I worshipped him?
Did he create just me in his image,
or every living thing?
When God made me.
When God made me.
Was he planning only for believers,
or for those who just
had faith?
Did he envision all wars
that were fought in his name?
Did he say there was only one way
to be close to him?
When God made me.
When God made me.
Did he give me the gift of love
to say who I could choose?
When God made me.
When God made me.
When God made me.
Did he give me the gift of voice
so some could silence me?
Did he give me the gift of vision
not knowing what I might see?
Did he give me the gift of compassion
to help my fellow man?
When God made me.
When God made me.
When God made me.
2)"Change Your Mind"
I know this song was included on an album largely a response to Kurt Cobain's death
(Cobain even mentioned Young in his last journal entry), but I can't not also hear without interpreting "the one you love" as "the One you love"...thus another honest churchsong.
Hmmm...God "supports" you, "embraces" you, "soothes" you, 'restores you" (could be a CCM lyrics so far) "convinces" you.....and "destroys" you.
Isn't that the God you know?(:
(Song interp here)
When you get weak, and you need to test your will
When life's complete, but there's something missing still
Distracting you from this must be the one you love
Must be the one whose magic touch can change your mind
Don't let another day go by without the magic touch
Distracting you (change your mind)
Supporting you (change your mind)
Embracing you (change your mind)
Convincing you (change your mind)
When you're confused and the world has got you down
When you feel used and you just can't play the clown
Protecting you from this must be the one you love
Must be the one whose magic touch can change your mind
Don't let another day go by without the magic touch
Protecting you (change your mind)
Restoring you (change your mind)
Revealing you (change your mind)
Soothing you (change your mind)
You hear the sound, you wait around and get the word
You see the picture changing everything you've heard
Destroying you with this must be the one you love
Must be the one whose magic touch can change your mind
Don't let another day go by without the magic touch
Destroying you (change your mind)
Embracing you (change your mind)
Protecting you (change your mind)
Confining you (change your mind)
Distracting you (change your mind)
Supporting you (change your mind)
Distorting you (change your mind)
Controlling you (change your mind)
Change your mind (change your mind)
Change your mind, change your mind (change your mind)
Change your mind (change your mind)
The morning comes and there's an odor in the room
The scent of love, more than a million roses bloom
Embracing you with this must be the one you love
Must be the one whose magic touch can change your mind
Don't let another day go by without the magic touch
Embracing you (change your mind)
Concealing you (change your mind)
Protecting you (change your mind)
Revealing you (change your mind)
Change your mind, change your mind (change your mind)
Change your mind (change your mind)
Change your mind, change your mind (change your mind)
Change your mind (change your mind)
Change your mind, change your mind
Change your mind
Change your mind, change your mind
Change your mind
Change your mind, change your mind
Change your mind, change your mind
Labels:
christian bookstore,
lament,
spirituality of music
Friday, December 21, 2012
Sweet and McLaren: Versus Verses and Verse-itis
First,Sweet and McLaren on "Versus Verses" from "A" is for Abductive (a great book which, of course, is on the cut-out rack at the Christian bookstore):
Then, Sweet on Verse-itis and apples/oranges
Then, Sweet on Verse-itis and apples/oranges
Thursday, December 13, 2012
'the voice of the Spirit, begging you to shut the ___ up"
"And you were too busy steering the conversation toward the Lord
to hear the voice of the Spirit, begging you to shut the ___ up."
Fill in the blank with the correct lyric.
Uh, it's not "heck."
But it IS a four letter word.
THE four letter word.
Yes, THAT one.
No wonder this Pedro the Lion song ("Foregone Conclusion")
made the list of The Top Ten Most Controversial Songs In Christian Music (a great read).So how would you respond to hearing the Spirit begging you to shut the f___ up"?
The next line in the song:
"You thought, it must be the devil, trying to make you go astray.
And besides, it could not have been the Lord because you don't believe he talks that way."
Complete lyrics here.
Better get the CD online..for some reason, it's not in Christian bookstores.
Censored version:
Uncensored:
Labels:
christian bookstore,
spirituality of music
Friday, July 13, 2012
Unkingdoms and "conversations that are neither polite nor free from confusion" (book review, "That Holy Anarchist")
Don't let the apparent oxymoron of "Christiian anarchist" scare you off; or cause you to call the heresy police on me (They already have my number).
Mark Van Steenwyck, author of
He adds a hilarious and too true footnote to that last
line that is worth the price of the book I am about to review:
"I recognize that the best conversations are neither polite nor free from confusion."
On that note, let's move directly into my (im)polite and (inevitably)confusing review of the book.
In two words:
Highly recommended.
And for a a few more words (mostly his, with my comments), read on.
My approach will be proceeding chapter by chapter, letting you in on some of my (literal) highlights, some of the author's one-liners that are amazingly articulate.............. and how this all has got me thinking and wrestling.
To your surprise, I am not going to answer the obvious question that has already tripped you up: How does he define "Christianity" and "anarchism?" I want you to buy the book, especially to see the section where he so masterfully does (or doesn't?) But start here, as it may in essence answer the tenor of both questions......... let it soak in:
Bottom line:
Chapter 1: Jesus and the Unkingdom of God
The author admits he is not completely happy with the "Unking" and "Unkingdom" terns he has coined. But I can't not incorporate them into my teaching/preaching/St. Arbuck's repertoire (as I have with Tom Fuller's "kingdomed"), as this gets to the heart of the book, and to Jesus shape of subversion. It may even be an attempt to push Donald Kraybill's "upside down Kingdom" beyond downside up./
A quote that is hugely helpful to those of us who love to talk about "subversion of empire;"
a quote that I would have given anything for LO Society's Bob Lyon to live ling enough to add his "amen" to; a quote that reminds us how careful and prayerful we are called to be, as we practice. the praxis of subversion:
I fear we don't at all.
Van Steenwyk notes that early Christians were called (at least by Tacitus
"haters of humanity" for their subversion.
Do I need to even ask why (a very different SORT of reason) we are called "haters of humanity" in our day, and in my country?
Sigh..
Chapter Two: Definitions
See my earlier thoughts. But it's worth noting that "Christianity is even harder to define than anarchism." (p. 19) and that "'anarchism' is the name given to the principle under whicha collectivity-a group of people-may be conceived without rule." The "collectivity" language is nice, and may be another nod to Kraybill.
Chapter Three: Anarchic Impulses in Christian History
This chapter is a fascinating, concise history of anarchic Christianity.. This exhaustive work has never been compiled before, let alone presented in such a succinct summary. You will meet some movements you have never heard of, but should've.
But here is an observation (p. 30) that floored me:
"Most radical Christian groups either die out or go mainstream."
God help us.
"We should try to learn from those groups that still exist but haven't mainstreamed., They may hold the key to sustainable nonconformity."
Sustainable nonconformity?
Another phrase worth far more than price of the book.
Question: why doesn't that phrase compete for Christian book titles and buzzwords...compete with "purpose driven" and "12 easy steps" and "how to.."
Don't answer that.
Instead move to this provocative quote from Ched Myers.
Chapter Four: Anarchic Impulses in Christian History:
Or Vam Steenwyck's observation (following Kraybill's taxomomy) that "In the wilderness, [Jesus} is tempted politically, economically.." (p. 39
And what is the temptation toward?
"...to assert his messiah-ship" (p. 39)
Hey, wait! This is precisely what Western evangelicals need Jesus (and Scripture) to do.
But Jesus doesn't only not do it..
....but in a sense, doesn't even do it indirectly...
...as even that would be caving into demonic temptation.
If that tripped you up "impolitely," read it again...and then read some NT Wright and get over it. (:
Yes, I believe with all my heart and faith that Jesus is Messiah.
It's clear that Van Steenwyck does, too.
But until we see that how/if he "asserted" that is a major issue, we haven't even started the important conversation:
"The temptation concerns the sort of reign Jesus should we pursue."
What sort of reign and kingdom /churchdoms) do we pursue?
Do ever even think to think about asking that question?
Add it to your list, along with this one, for another random (?) example.
Gulp.
And don't get me started on the author's quote of Ellul's (p. 44) regarding the
"intrinsic nonlegitimacy of institutions " (No, Ellul's one liners are never misunderstood as heresy(: See this)
--
Oh, I have mentioned soundbites worth the price of the book.
The book is priceless for the insight on Jesus inaugural sermon in Luke 4.
I have long noted how "when quoting Isaiah 61, he omits that portion whuch speaks of the Lord's vengeance." (p. 40)
That's radical and subversive enough.
But the observation (in a footnote, no less...where many bombs are hidden): "the context makes this clear: The miracles Jesus references in his sermon involve the healing of Gentiles" (emphasis mine)
"Provocatively, Jesus seems willing to include oppressors in the kingdom."
!!
That's why Kingdom is not just upside down, but UnKingdom.
Do I include oppressors in my kingdom?
If not, what am i doing with a kingdom anyway? Time to "undo" it.
Chapter Five: Tensions
The evangelical approach of preaching the opposite of a counterfeit is...counterintuitively.. not the right strategy:
So buy the book.
Even though an early version of it is online.
Even though the first four chapters are embedded below
Buy it, at full price, precisely because, as you will find on page 3..
"This book is not copyrighted."
!
How Christlike...and anarchistic..is that?
That Holy Anarchist
Mark Van Steenwyck, author of
"That Holy Anarchist: Reflections on Christianity & Anarchism," has struggled with just what to call the nexus:
Language will always fail to describe the strange relationship between the Way of Jesus and anarchistic political imoulkses. There are some real downsides to identifying as a "christian anarchist.." The stress naturally falls on one of the two words as though they are two separate things mashed together, unreconcilable into any cohesive whole.
I've toyed with alternative language...Even my own affinity for a phrase like "the unkingdom of God" is ofetn too confusing to be helpful in polite conversation. --p. 65
He adds a hilarious and too true footnote to that last
line that is worth the price of the book I am about to review:"I recognize that the best conversations are neither polite nor free from confusion."
On that note, let's move directly into my (im)polite and (inevitably)confusing review of the book.
In two words:
Highly recommended.
And for a a few more words (mostly his, with my comments), read on.
My approach will be proceeding chapter by chapter, letting you in on some of my (literal) highlights, some of the author's one-liners that are amazingly articulate.............. and how this all has got me thinking and wrestling.
To your surprise, I am not going to answer the obvious question that has already tripped you up: How does he define "Christianity" and "anarchism?" I want you to buy the book, especially to see the section where he so masterfully does (or doesn't?) But start here, as it may in essence answer the tenor of both questions......... let it soak in:
Bottom line:
Christo-anarchism refers not only to the insight that Jesus’ vision of the Kingdom of God has anarchic (anti-domination) implications, but also the assumption that, only by nurturing practices centered on the presence of the Living Christ, can we move from domination to non-domination, from death to life, from oppression to liberation, and from alienation to love. p, 65
Chapter 1: Jesus and the Unkingdom of God
The author admits he is not completely happy with the "Unking" and "Unkingdom" terns he has coined. But I can't not incorporate them into my teaching/preaching/St. Arbuck's repertoire (as I have with Tom Fuller's "kingdomed"), as this gets to the heart of the book, and to Jesus shape of subversion. It may even be an attempt to push Donald Kraybill's "upside down Kingdom" beyond downside up./
A quote that is hugely helpful to those of us who love to talk about "subversion of empire;"
a quote that I would have given anything for LO Society's Bob Lyon to live ling enough to add his "amen" to; a quote that reminds us how careful and prayerful we are called to be, as we practice. the praxis of subversion:
Jesus reign isn't other-worldy. It isn't apolitical. It's just political in a radivally different sort of way. Rather than taking Caesar's throne (or any throne, including the one Satan offered him) Jesus is saying that Caesar's days are numbered. By saying "My kingdom is not from this world" he isn't saying "My kingdom is only spiritual. so you don't have to worry. Jesus' Kingship renders Caesar's obsolete. It isn't a mere "trumping" as though Jesus is simply greater than Caesar; it is an entirely different sort of kingship. (pp12-13)We must ask "sort," kind," "form," "shape" questions a whole lot more.
I fear we don't at all.
Van Steenwyk notes that early Christians were called (at least by Tacitus
"haters of humanity" for their subversion.
Do I need to even ask why (a very different SORT of reason) we are called "haters of humanity" in our day, and in my country?
Sigh..
Chapter Two: Definitions
See my earlier thoughts. But it's worth noting that "Christianity is even harder to define than anarchism." (p. 19) and that "'anarchism' is the name given to the principle under whicha collectivity-a group of people-may be conceived without rule." The "collectivity" language is nice, and may be another nod to Kraybill.
Chapter Three: Anarchic Impulses in Christian History
This chapter is a fascinating, concise history of anarchic Christianity.. This exhaustive work has never been compiled before, let alone presented in such a succinct summary. You will meet some movements you have never heard of, but should've.
But here is an observation (p. 30) that floored me:
"Most radical Christian groups either die out or go mainstream."
God help us.
"We should try to learn from those groups that still exist but haven't mainstreamed., They may hold the key to sustainable nonconformity."
Sustainable nonconformity?
Another phrase worth far more than price of the book.
Question: why doesn't that phrase compete for Christian book titles and buzzwords...compete with "purpose driven" and "12 easy steps" and "how to.."
Don't answer that.
Instead move to this provocative quote from Ched Myers.
Chapter Four: Anarchic Impulses in Christian History:
The “Fall” in Gen 1-11, then, is not so much a cosmic moment of moral failure as a
progressive “history” of decline into civilization—exactly contrary to the myth of
Progress. Its polemical perspective is plausible when correlated with various
aspects of the Neolithic “rupture” hypotheses noted above. The biblical primeval
history thus should be considered not only as “mythic memory,” but also as
perhaps the first literature of resistance to the grand project of civilization—rightly
warning against its social pathologies and ecocidal consequences. -p. 35 in the book, and context of Myers' article at this link
Or Vam Steenwyck's observation (following Kraybill's taxomomy) that "In the wilderness, [Jesus} is tempted politically, economically.." (p. 39
And what is the temptation toward?
"...to assert his messiah-ship" (p. 39)
Hey, wait! This is precisely what Western evangelicals need Jesus (and Scripture) to do.
But Jesus doesn't only not do it..
....but in a sense, doesn't even do it indirectly...
...as even that would be caving into demonic temptation.
If that tripped you up "impolitely," read it again...and then read some NT Wright and get over it. (:
Yes, I believe with all my heart and faith that Jesus is Messiah.
It's clear that Van Steenwyck does, too.
But until we see that how/if he "asserted" that is a major issue, we haven't even started the important conversation:
"The temptation concerns the sort of reign Jesus should we pursue."
What sort of reign and kingdom /churchdoms) do we pursue?
Do ever even think to think about asking that question?
Add it to your list, along with this one, for another random (?) example.
Gulp.
And don't get me started on the author's quote of Ellul's (p. 44) regarding the
"intrinsic nonlegitimacy of institutions " (No, Ellul's one liners are never misunderstood as heresy(: See this)
--
Oh, I have mentioned soundbites worth the price of the book.
The book is priceless for the insight on Jesus inaugural sermon in Luke 4.
I have long noted how "when quoting Isaiah 61, he omits that portion whuch speaks of the Lord's vengeance." (p. 40)
That's radical and subversive enough.
But the observation (in a footnote, no less...where many bombs are hidden): "the context makes this clear: The miracles Jesus references in his sermon involve the healing of Gentiles" (emphasis mine)
"Provocatively, Jesus seems willing to include oppressors in the kingdom."
!!
That's why Kingdom is not just upside down, but UnKingdom.
Do I include oppressors in my kingdom?
If not, what am i doing with a kingdom anyway? Time to "undo" it.
Chapter Five: Tensions
The evangelical approach of preaching the opposite of a counterfeit is...counterintuitively.. not the right strategy:
I don’t believe that it makes any sense to say “God is such a big King that he obliterates all other kings…therefore, I’m an anarchist.” Rather, I would say “The way in which God sustains and shapes existence…and calls us to be in deeper relationship is the opposite of how Kings function…therefore, I am an anarchist.” To quote the late Dorothee Soelle:
Obedience presupposes duality: one who speaks and one who listens; one who knows and one who is ignorant; a ruler and ruled ones. Religious groups who broke away from the spirit of dependency and obedience cherish different values such as mutuality and interdependence…The main virtue of an authoritarian religion is obedience…God’s love and righteousness are less important than God’s power…why do people worship a God whose supreme quality is power, not justice; whose interest lies in subjection, not in mutuality; who fears equality?” 1Jesus is an unking. I worship the one who calls me friend. But I don’t think it would be accurate to say that I “obey” him in the way that servants obey masters. That is just a first step–a metaphor. Just as most green anarchists believe they should respect, cherish, and affirm nature, I am called to worship and love the source of life. Semantics? Not to me. (p. 33)
Even in the context of trying to offer an apologetic for Christian anarchy, "The temptation is to try to force it" (p. 58.
It always is.
And it never works.
Or it does work, and that's the problem.
Could be that "trying to force it": is a testation, and the core one, at that.
Chapter 6: The UnKingdom of God is Here:
Perhaps the highlight of the entire book for me was his suggested (not blueprinted or formulaic) practices. They must be read slowly, and considered. If we really catch that "to be mystics is to experience reality" (68), we are ready to engage.
By the time you are done with this book, the author hopes you will sense
..a shift away from seeing Christian Anarchism as a set of beliefs and ideals, as well as a shift away from seeing it as a category or a faction. Rather, I want to see it as a way of interpreting and a set of practices first and foremost. Certainly, likeminded communities are bound to network and organize around common ideals and convictions. This is important and good. But in that networking and organizing, I believe our focus should be on engaging the Living Christ.As a friend of mine once told me: “All we have to offer the world is the Presence of God.” I agree. And I believe that Presence tears down walls of alienation. And that is, in so many important ways, an anarchist project.
--
Even though an early version of it is online.
Even though the first four chapters are embedded below
Buy it, at full price, precisely because, as you will find on page 3..
"This book is not copyrighted."
!
How Christlike...and anarchistic..is that?
That Holy Anarchist
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)























