Showing posts with label Pete Rollins. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pete Rollins. Show all posts

Thursday, October 31, 2013

"you could think and act outside the box as long as it was inside the box of the other person."

Excerpt from Paul Leader's post, "Out of the Box" :
......The strange thing is in these moments the crowd goes wild. The event, the conference, the hype all play a part in sweeping everyone along with whatever is taking place. The conference has always been the breeding ground for the exciting stuff to take place and then we go back to being boring when Sunday comes around. The church programme was never invented to being exciting, it was a place of commitment and things we had to do to be a community of believers. Yet people get excited and agree and cheer all sorts of stuff. On both of these occasions the crowd went wild for breaking out of boxes and clay pots. No one wanted to go back to normal or the status quo. Everyone was ready to talk the talk and long for a freedom beyond what they had ever experienced before. There was a no going back mentality. Then reality struck and submission to leaders and local church and doctrine and Christian practice. The religious would challenge and shout rebellion and challenge the trouble makers and thinkers. Many may have gave up one box only to trade it for another. Others sat down with the bits of the clay pot and some super-glue of love and started piecing it all back together. They discovered, as I did time and time again, that you could think and act outside the box as long as it was inside the box of the other person. You could smash the container of religion as long as you lived inside the clay pot of another person. I discover everyday that someone always wants to build a wall around you or hedge you in......
....Remember the toy Stretch Armstrong, stretch him as much as you like and then he will return to his normal size and position? That is the walk of so many. But I long to be a shape shifter constantly. I long to stretch beyond recognition. When people say I am not the same anymore I take that as a compliment. I want to wander the land with others that have broken moulds. Others that will challenge thinking and ideas. Not that I want to join their cast or box, but to constantly break my own. I thank God for people around me today that do such things, like Martin Scott, Mark Pixley, John Matthews, Andre Van de Merwe, Michael Creel, Shannon Byous Ruddy, Peter Rollins, Wayne Jacobsen, Dave Vaughan, Justin Abraham, Mark Neale, Dyfed Wyn Roberts and even Bono! There are many others too that challenge, provoke, ruffle, annoy, stir, comfort, love, break mindsets, smash moulds, kick boxes, break clay pots, walk and not just talk in the wild wanderings of life. I thank God for such people. I may not agree with all they stand in or walk through, but I certainly appreciate the spirit and adventure and inclusion they give as they themselves pursue nothing more or less than the wild goose trail. Daily I will take a boot to the box. Daily I will get my hammer to that pot to smash it beyond recognition. There is no going back. There is only today to live in, a day to walk beyond expectations and pressures and philosophies and traditions and religion and mindsets and doctrine. A day to walk with Him in the wilds and and discover a place that only He knew existed. That box you have for me is forever broken.  -full post  link

Friday, October 04, 2013

Jack Heaslip...along with NT. Wright, David Dark, Frederick Buechner and other harry ticks like Rob Bell

You probably never even knew it existed.

Too bad it's been banished to the cutout rack because folks think Rob Bell is a hairy tick.

It's actually full of good stuff..by Rob and  by  some great  folks like
 N.T. Wright,
          David Dark,
              Frederick Buechner,
                              Cathleen Falsasni,
                                    Oswald Chambers (!)
                                          Peter Rollins
                                                David Miller et al..

a great chapter by Clayton Libolt on "Becoming a Deep Reader of Scripture...

including two original chapters by U2's chaplain, Jack Heaslip.  (If that's a new name to you, he's delightful; start here: "Jack Heaslip/Bono Audio: Elevation Tour Blessing")
.

It's the "Love Wins companion"..on sale now at Barnes and Noble...and of course not even stocked in the Christian bookstore (whatever!).  The enhanced edition has videos.

Do check out Heaslip's contributions: the foreword (free read on PDF here), and "Playing With Rocks" from Chapter 6 (Read it here on Google books, it's only missing the last page).

One line: "Jesus owned up to being himself"


Saturday, July 13, 2013

In the name

by  Pádraig Ó Tuama  (link)

The Lord be with you.
In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit
In the name of goodness and love and broken community
In the name of meaning and feeling and I hope you don’t screw me
In the name of darkness and light and ungraspable twilight
In the name of meal times and sharing and caring by firelight
In the name of

 action and peace and human redemption
In the name of eating and drinking and table confession
In the name of sadness, regret, and holy obsession
The holy name of anger, the spirit of aggression
In the name of forgive and forget and I hope I get over this
In the name of Father and Son and the Holy Spirit
In the name of beauty and beaten and broken down daily
In the name of seeing our creeds and believing in maybe
We gather here, a table of strangers
And speak of our hope land and talk of our danger
To make sense of our thinking, to authenticate lives
To humanize feeling and stop telling lies
In the name of philosophy, theology, and who gives a damn
In the name of employment and study and finding new family
In the name of our passion, our loving, and indecent obsessions
In the name of prayer and of worship and of demon possession
In the name of solitude and quiet and holy reflection
In the name of the lost and the lonely and the without direction
In the name of efficiency, stupidity, and the holy ineffectual
In the name of the straight, the queer, transgendered, and bisexual
In the name of boot clogs and boob jobs and erectile disfunction
Schizophrenia, hysteria, and obsessive compulsion
In the name of Jesus and Mary and the mostly silent Joseph
In the name of speaking to ourselves saying this is more than I can cope with
In the name of touch up and break up and break down and weeping
In the name of therapy and Prozac and full hearted breathing
In the name of sadness and madness and years since I’ve smiled
In the name of the unknown, the alien, and the holy in exile
In the name of goodness and kindness and intentionality
In the name of harbor and shelter and family
Peter Rollins

Sunday, November 18, 2012

More on Prodigal Pirates

Video of Kester Berwin, Peter Rollins and Barry Taylor (for context, see previous post:

Prodigal Pirate):

 
Pirates and Prodigals from Fuller Seminary on Vimeo:
A conversation between Kester Brewin, Peter Rollins, and Barry Taylor on the tragedy of the pirate and prodigal son archetypes and what this means for the future church. The discussion drew from ideas presented in Kester Brewin’s latest book, Mutiny! Why We Love Pirates, and How They Can Save Us.

The Berry Center for Lifelong Learning
andThe Inititive for the Church and Contemprary Culture
present: Pirates and Prodigals



Travis Auditorium
on the campus of Fuller Theologcial Seminary

Friday, July 13, 2012

U22 Zooropa: questions on the questions?

(also posted on atU2 forum here
I was sure I'd never hear "Zooropa" live.

I mean it was only played three times when it came out.


So who would've guessed it would be resurrected..in 20111/12 for the 360 Tour?

I am so glad it did.
I love the "questions" intro that was added(see computer voices ask human questions in new liturgy: U2 in Chile  and new content).

And I love/hate that I got to see it in person; up close in Oakland.
With the claw's cage down around the band, it reminded me of Pink Floyd playing behind the wall.
I just wish I had instead (also been far enough back to take in the Claw;s crazy light antics during the song.

But now that a version has been released on U22, I have some questions for fan(atic)s...mostly questions about the questions:


1)Is the first question, "What are you thinking about?" Bono's voice?

2)Is the "What sort of democracy for what sort of world"  voiced by the philosopher Peter Rollins?  (I know, all Irish accents can sound alike to a  USAmerican, but I am intrigued by the possibility there is a Rollins-U2 connection.  Tell me it doesn't sound like him)

3)What's the male voice saying at 33-37 :
"What's going on? Is this all there is ? Next: _____________?

 4)What's the male voice saying at 45-47?

5)Into the song, second section: It is well known that Bono cut out the "I have no religion..." line for  most of the tour.  This makes sense for a couple of reasons, one being the Christian revisionism of their 90s material when played in the new millenium.  But I sure seem to remember that the early version on this tour that he kept the line in, but revised it somehow. But I don't remember what he said. Anyone?  Maybe only God and Beth Maynard know.
(Ok. later edit: fond this answer. see comments)

6) I have always heard it  a  voice (early in song proper) of Jimmy Swaggart (or another televangelist: "Don't touch that dial!"  (interspersed with "What do you want?").   Google shows no evidence??


Here's atu2's transcription, but  still missing my question #3


What are you thinking about? Is conflict inevitable? What difference does it make? What sort of democracy for what sort of world? Why did you hurt me? How can I have been so stupid? Why does it always take so long? Why do you put up with me? How do I know what's true? What the fuck? When will I know if I'm a good father? What are you afraid of? Was it worth it? Where is my mind? Is history bound to repeat itself? Do you still love me? Is there something I should know? Why is it so hard? What have I done to deserve this? Why must I always stand alone? Is anybody home? Can we make it work? Is love really all you need? What's going on? Will you ever be able to trust me again? Why do I have to tell you? Are we still on for Friday? What do you want? What do you want?
Where are you from? Who do you love? What do you want? What do you want? What do you want?What do you want? What do you want? How do you love? How do you love?
    --



 official U2.com video of the song (w/o the questions intro):

Thursday, April 19, 2012

five coordinates for church

 Gladys Ganiel posts this about ikon, the church (or something like that) that Peter Rollins is pastor (or something like that) of:


Rather than adhering to a doctrinal statement or a set of beliefs, Ikon describes itself in five words, which they call ‘coordinates’.
They are:

  • Iconic
  • Apocalyptic
  • Heretical
  • Emerging
  • Failing


Link

Thursday, March 01, 2012

Church as Crack house

You may remember the lessons of "The Gaithers On Crack"...

Now we have Peter Rollins on "The Contemporary Church is a Crack house":

"My concern is that most of the actually existing church acts as a type of drug den with the leaders being like the nicest, most sincere, drug dealers..."


=Peter Rollins, See full article here
Update: now on video:

Crack House Church from The Work Of The People on Vimeo.

Thursday, January 19, 2012

Which would you choose: Jesus or heaven?

Which would you choose? (Parable by Peter Rollins):

You sit in silence contemplating what has just taken place. Only moments ago you were alive and well, relaxing at home with friends. Then there was a deep, crushing pain in your chest that brought you crashing to the floor. The pain has now gone, but you are no longer in your home. Instead, you find yourself standing on the other side of death waiting to stand before the judgment seat and discover where you will spend eternity. As you reflect upon your life your name is called, and you are led down a long corridor into a majestic sanctuary with a throne located in its center. Sitting on this throne is a huge, breathtaking being who looks up at you and begins to speak.
“My name is Lucifer, and I am the angel of light.”
You are immediately filled with fear and trembling as you realize that you are face to face with the enemy of all that is true and good. Then the angel continues: “I have cast God down from his throne and banished Christ to the realm of eternal death. It is I who hold the keys to the kingdom. It is I who am the gatekeeper of paradise, and it is for me alone to decide who shall enter eternal joy and who shall be forsaken.”
After saying these words, he sits up and stretches out his vast arms. “In my right hand I hold eternal life and in my left hand eternal death. Those who would bow down and acknowledge me as their god shall pass through the gates of paradise and experience an eternity of bliss, but all those who refuse will be vanquished to the second death with their Christ.”
After a long pause he bends toward you and speaks, “Which will you choose?”-Peter Rollins, The Orthodox Heretic: And Other Impossible Tales

Monday, December 26, 2011

Retroactive Justification

Peter Rollins video""Life is lived forwards and understood backwards":
:
Retroactive Justification from Peter Rollins on Vimeo.

Friday, December 16, 2011

The Revolutionary Potential of the Actually Existing Church

The Revolutionary Potential of the Actually Existing Church

By Peter Rollins

I was recently reading Slavoj Zizek’s excellent essay “The Ambiguity of the Masochist Social Link” and was struck by his reflection on how symptoms can represent forgotten failures to act. I would like to reflect upon this in relation to what we see in so much of the actually existing church today.
In order to approach this subject let us begin by taking the example of a man who drinks to excess, neglects his children and mistreats his...continued

Wednesday, December 14, 2011

Peter Rollins interviewed By Kim and Ken

What a catch!  The  Kim and (Keltic) Ken  show scored an audio interview with Peter Rollins ..on his :"Insurrection" book and other subversionicities.  Don't miss:

Saturday, November 12, 2011

honest worship music?

Via Kim Gentes:
Dark Night of the Soul P.1: Honesty in Liturgical Space- Peter Rollins with Kim Gentes:

Part 2: Dark Night of the Soul- Thoughts and Challenge for Worship Leaders:

Wednesday, August 24, 2011

a matter of words:: naked economic missiology and the "biblically screwy false witness" of attractional church

It's never about language and semantics.
It's always about language and semantics.

It's all we have.
But thank God it's not all that is.
And it's not all that God has.

I can understand  the complaints that recent conversations about Christology, missiology,  ecclesiology...and which precedes which...
as being merely academic  and a waste of time.

They sure can be, and often are.


And they are  just  clanging gongs if not implemented and actualized in actual, practical acts of  indiscriminate love for lepers, tax collectors and prostitutes.
But until we've wasted time in the ivory tower we may not be wasted enough to be any practical good on the streets below.
Theology makes praxis; and praxis makes perfect....and maybe perfect theology.


But again:

Words matter.
Largely because matter is words.
That's not just intriguing linguistics, but cutting-edge physics,
it's good theology .

Theology.
Uh, oh.
Just theory, right?

"There's nothing more practical that theory, and nothing more theoretical  than practice."
When I first heard, and considered that phrase, not even knowing it was Marx, it made sense
(Evangelicals might flinch, but Jesus, Ellul and Žižek would approve),


Theology is formed, forged, and practiced in the street, as we do mission(=do life).
"Tear the curtain down, pull the altar to the ground," the 77s once sang, ostesibly about worship.
But bring down the theology and missiology as well.  That alters our altar..
Yank theology into the streets, and do it among (and with) street people., street walkers,  street fairs, street sweepers.







What's the deal with seminaries with a "Department of Practical Theology"?
Departments  can compartmentalize.
Calling it practical can ensure it's not practiced.
See "God loves donkeys, sweat, entrails and menstruation"


All this talk is not just all talk.
It is necessary to subvert and reorirent our imaginations..

...and our language.
Which matters, and is matter.

Two case studies.

Not long ago, our church had some documents to fill out for the IRS  (Why in the world is church connecting with IRS?..  But that's another post and topic for another day).  So I said to one of our leadership team, "can we have you sign a form after worship?"

Later, as we were signing, she said "I wondered wbat happened.  You said we should sign  after worship, so when we didn't sign after worship, I figured you forgot."

I had absolutely no idea what she meant.

Then it hit me.  In many circles (and in her previous church, the songs that are sung early in the gatherings  are called "worship" or the "worship time" or "worship songs."  So she thought i meant "after the music," and I meant "after the gathering (Of course, my definition was even more problematic)..

It is unbelievable that so few ever even notice, let alone challenge, this common practice in contemporary church.  As I blogged a few years ago:


A strange shift began about fifteen years ago,

Ask most evangelical or charismatic Christians in USAmerica about the place of "worship"
in a gathering. For some strange reason, the word has come to be synonymous with "the songs sung early in the meeting."

"Good morning! After the worship, the children will be dismissed, and Pastor Steve will share from God's word"

We even call the person leading the singing the "worship leader."
Whazzup with that?

Of course, this definition is foreign to Scripture, and to the church in all history and places..until our lifetime in the ... continued




It's only words, but words matter and cement our reality, worldview, hermeneutic, and practical theological/missional acts/axis.

Dan Kimball even asks "Should the church accountant be the one called the 'worship pastor'"? 
He's only half joking.

Walter Brueggeman, who never jokes, quips that "The key issues of worship in the community are fundamentally economic."

Talk to Wolfgang Simson, please.

Note that the term economics comes from the Ancient Greek οἰκονομία (oikonomia, "management of a household, administration") from οἶκος (oikos, "house") + νόμος (nomos, "custom" or "law"), hence "rules of the house(hold)".[1]  

Evertying is langiuage.
Everything is mission.
Everything is worship.
Everything is economic.

Frost and Hirsch:
Worship therefore is not a utility but an offering, that is a sacrifice, an economy of grace that interrupts and critiques the feverish cycles of production and consumption, which is why  the collection is not fundraising bur cultural critique."  ("The Faith of Leap,"161)

All of life is econimic, including worship.
All worship is missional, including the collection.
All collections are cultural critique.

Don't worry, it's just semantics.
Or semantics that are just.

Time for the second case study.



Music is not worship.
Worship is not music.

Note, though, we need qualifiers here, in the first case study: Music is part of worship, etc.

BUT, our second, deeper, case study:

Church is not a building.
A building is not a church.

No qualifiers needed.

If the Bible is our lexicon.

If life itself is our lexicon.
.
I love Dylan's quote: "The songs are my lexicon. I believe the songs.”

It's our songs, and eventually our lifesongs, that reveal what we believe.

Not our words or church words, as Peter Rollins reminds.

This case study, seeing church as a building, is far deeper, and far more fundamental..

...and inevitably, eventually idolatrous.

"it's not only pathetic, it borders on false witness." (Frost and Hirsch, p. 175, emphasis mine).

Not just because of the "obvious reason": churh is the people..

But because  missiology precedes ecclesiology.


Because, as  Frost and Hirsch emphasize, mission is the  "organizing function," " catalyzing principle"  that "brings to life" the other three functions of church (worship, community, discipleship.

"this makes sense of why Christians refer to the building that house the weekly worship meeting as 'the church.'  It leads Christians to refer to the fact that they 'go to church'.  This phrase in itself is biblically screwy and most Christians know it, but they can't break from the default mode that tells them that the worship experince [not mission/Missio Dei] organizes everything that we understand church to be.  )169)
Tim Neufeld: "Our spirit of outreach is a veil for self-absorbed religious tourism."
And I make the case ( Pepsi, Sex, Elevation, Mission Trips That Are Actually Missional)
that not just tourism, but also voyeurism  and  exhibitionism.

Whats up with short term "quickie" mission trips?  Here's a fuller quote from Tim:

.. I have seen and been a part of many mission trips that have a stated purpose of helping the people they are going to minister to. Churches raise $50,000 to visit an exotic country or flock across the border into Mexico. Team members feel good when they return home because they have served, but missionaries often report that the groups they host are loud, arrogant, culturally insensitive and often more trouble (to the missionary or national pastor) than they are worth. I wonder if the best thing that happens in Mexico over spring break is that American churches stimulate the Mexicali valley economy by buying tacos and Pepsis. Our spirit of outreach is a veil for self-absorbed religious tourism. But we feel good about ourselves when we come home."Our spirit of outreach is a veil for self-absorbed religious tourism. But we feel good about ourselves when we come home." (-Tim Neufeld, Occasio blog)

If you come home feeling bad about yourself, the mission trip probably worked.
Feel good about yourself if if you feel badly about yourself upon re-entry.

It means you have the gift of reassessing your theology, theory, language, worship, economics , sexuality and mission.





Because it all starts with  mission...or, uh, sex:

"For many, sexuality is simply what happens between two people involving physical pleasure. But that's only a small percentage of what sexuality is. Our sexuality is all the ways we strive to reconnect with our world, with each other, and with God." (Rob Bell, "Sex God," p. 42)...
Everything is sexuality...and elevation thereof (as the rabbis and Bono preach)

Male and female in the image of God..
The only way we multiply.
The only we are missional.
Not  talking the sexualizing of mission and  taking sexed up mission trips.
We're taking about  taking a trip into  missional theology (=sexuality).

It's all language.
Naked language.
Sexual language


A missional church will be on the front lines of sexuality...
we cultivate e a missional sexuality.

Examples of such undepartmentalized practiical theology? Check out xxxchurch.com and its Extreme Makeover Brothel Edition, or check into churches/ministries that address and redress human trafficking..
(as opposed to  just "shoulding" on people.with lectures that "Pre-marital sex is evil"  "Abortion is a sin," etc....as true as those truisms are, better to start more holisically, Hebraically...theologically.)

The call is to baptize our sexuality (not sexualize our baptism)

Here's a  quirky video that ties up some of these thoughts:
NOTE: it's not for the religious or faint of heart.
But it offers a reminder that old school church can be so consumed with consumerism (the evil twin of economics, which you'll remember has to do will all of life and worship) that it overlook wayward sexuality.sexual immorality (Remember our definition of sexuality...Language matters).


Uh, if you are still here after that video (:..

Let's talk.
It's not just language.
It always is.

Tuesday, August 23, 2011

"Insurrection" by Peter Rollins: Church, let's sing suspended in space...

Long live the insurrection.

It's the only way our church will finally be able to sing while suspended in space.

Huh?

We'll get to that.. but I would recommend all churches list that as an official goal or mission statement (:

I have been looking forward to Peter Rollins' new book, "Insurrection," (subtitle: "To Believe is Human; To Doubt Divine," so I was glad to be offered a review copy. (Here's my review:  Buy it yesterday).


I was thrilled to see that it included a whole chapter on my hottest topic around here (at least by number of tags, see "topical diving" in righthand sidebar):

the "role of the pastor."


So I'll start there.

The chapter is  called "I don't have to believe; my pastor does that for me."

Thud.

Of course, no one would ever say it that nakedly (I hope!!), but that's what many of us (including us pastors) in reality do.  That  whole trick itself is one of the key themes and streams of the book: It really doesn't matter what we SAY we believe, as our actions very often prove otherwise.  We have a tremendous capacity for self-deception.  Our practices ARE our beliefs.



That's the good and bad news.
That's partly why Rob Bell says:

"In this book, Pete takes you to the edge of a cliff and pushes you off.
But after your initial panic, you realize that your fall is a form of flying.
And it's thrilling"  (front cover)
I need to be pushed.

Because  I now see "curator of honesty"  (my term, not Rollins' )as key to my role and "job description."

To the cliff:

Previously we saw how the structure itself believes on our behalf, thus protecting us from the experience of doubt, unknowing, and a sense of divine loss.  The structure itself is manifest most clearly in the words and actions of those who symbolize the structure, i.e., the pastors, priests, youth leaders, worship bands and ministry teams.  From the last chapter, one might think the way to change the structure is to convince the  people who run the structure that doubt, mystery and unknowing are all part of faith and should be experienced liturgically.

However the problem goes much deeper.

..At its most basic, church leaders believe on behalf of the community.  This seems to allow us the freedom to doubt...the pastor acts as a force field, holding the Christian trauma of the Crucifixion at bay.

In order to participate in the Crucifixion, we must find leaders who openly experience doubt, unknowing and a deep mystery. leaders who see these as a part of Christian faith...The problem is not that there are  a lack of leaders who have these experiences,rather, there is a lack of leaders who can admit to these experiences..

..On the rare occasion that a  pastor does stand up and declare his (or her) embrace of unknowing, a crisis among the congregants can ensue.  Not because the congregation now doubts, but because the pastor's belief provided a protective psychological dam that held back their doubt.(pp,64-65)

So, central to our calling is to "create structures that bring us face to face with the experience of doubt...such a community would need to ritualize the full range of human emotions, bringing radical doubt, ambiguity, mystery and complexity into the very heart of the liturgical structure itself.  Hymns would need to delve in to absence, sermons excavate doubt, and prayers prob the possibility that no one is on the other side."  (73)



Rollins brilliantly begins each chapter with a parable (one of his gifts is parabler),, draws delightfully from Kierkegaard, Žižek, and (perhaps most deeply) Bonhoeffer.  For those who have experienced Rollins via video, and are concerned his style is a bit, uh, nonlinear and academic, I noted several very helpful summary statements  (ex. page 162) along the narrative of the book that truly flowed the book.

You may not always agree with where he is going, but you will follow.

Rollins is exceptional on exposing our well-meaning cliche, "It's not a  religion, it's a relationship"
One way he calls our bluff:

"this enables us to ridicule the religious view of God intellectually while affirming this God in our practice..

This is an approach to Christianity that stands as the polar opposite of what we find expressed in the Crucifixion, for on the cross, religious belief is not intellectually questioned ("My God, My God") it is robbed of its grounding power ("Why have you forsaken me?)

 ...It is only as we are cult loose from religion in the very depth of our being (experiencing an existential loss of God..then we are free to discover a properly Christian exoression of faith (50-51. 62)

 A few more highlights:

1)As far as apologetics, he provokes us beyond "Does God exist?" to "What does it mean to claim that God exists?"  (126)

"Do you believe in God?"  'Ask my enemies."

Thus the book is eminently practical, missional...if mainly by subverting and reorienting not only our theology/Christology/ecclesiology but our missiology (Don't worry, nontechnical readers.. he doesn't use many of these words, they are presented here as a reference to current debates, see "Does missiology precede ecclesiology?")


2)Rollins is astonishing and articulate on our call to be found "changing the system by ignoring it."
He suggests that without the insurrectionist ignoring,  we inevitably fall into the twin traps of "token gestures" and "perverse protests"  (150-51)

Here's a clip of Rollins on "Changing the Structure":


3) This is one of the rare books that not only picks up helpful commentary on Christ,  church and church culture from The Matrix, but digs deep into the "not so evangelical" and uncertainty of the second and third Matrix films.  If those two films confused you and sent you into uncomfortable theological territory (for example, why was The Oracle a program of the matrix), it may be that  1)yes, the films are kind of a mess and 2)the films are far more helpful than we have noted.
Rollins shines in his brief section.

5)In applying this book, our church may not go as far as incorporating the "Hymns to Swear By" by Pádraig Ó Tuama, (though we probably should be that bold and insurrectionist).  
But we
 
But we will no doubt glean lots from the section of the book ("The Centrality of Absence," p, 175ff in which we are introduced to an example from their catalog.   About one song, Rollins comments, "this is not simply a song about suffering and the sense of cosmic homelessness--is is sung from that space (177).

Here's the song, but you are probably not ready to include it next Sunday.
Which is precisely why you should.

(P.S. Just tell your team it's called, "Maranatha," ....doesn't that sound safe enough?(:

Maranatha from Peter Rollins on Vimeo.



Video excerpt on the "suspended space" we can live from:



Bottom line of the book:

"Resurrection as a mode of living that embraces the lived experience of doubt, complexity and unknowing, affirms life and accepts our responsibility in transforming the world:...in a way that is
"fundamentally violent":


And by the way, this whole falling off the cliff and flying process begins with us being willing  to admit and "fess up" that we deny the resurrection:


P.S.

I love "The Rebel God".  Here is that  blogger's helpful review, which picks up some areas I didn't:

 


-----

Related: