Welcome! You have accidentally reached the blog of a heteroclite follower of Jesus: dave wainscott. I'm "pushing toward the unobvious" as I post thinkings/linkings re: Scripture, church and culture. Hot topics include: temple tantrums, time travel, sexuality/spirituality, U2kklesia, role of the pastor, God-haunted music/art..and subversive videos like these.
Pages
Search Me:
Monday, June 08, 2009
"Hey God: I watched the news tonight.."
(Is there such category in Scripture as "in church"?)
So maybe King's X has to settle for sing their "Get Away" song "as church."
Or maybe "in the church but not of it."
(of the church but not in it?)
Antone who has followed King's X (click the "kings x" label at bottom of this post to learn more)
from the days when some of them played with Phil Keaggy and Petra; were sold in Christian bookstores (and sung in churches) ..
...through one of their singers (Doug Pinnick) coming out...
to this new song..
will not be surprised at the first line of the song/prayer...or the roadie's (or someone's) T -shirt in this video. For the fundies, the T shirt be all the evidence they need! But I dare say it does not speak for Doug Pinnick or the band.
This does (click "play" below, click here for "not ready for church" lyrics):
Saturday, January 10, 2009
prayer that shreds
"what can i say/can i do/
Lord, for You
You're the glory"
...it's pretty clear the song is prayer.
The music ain't quiet and reflective,
and it's not ready for just any church..
but it is church:
passionate,
rocks,
"palpable holiness"
and is pure prayer at heart:
Original lyrics:
i sing this song, this one's for You
oh for You
You're the story
its You its You
what can i say
what should i do
oh for You
what can i say
what should i do oh
You're the glory
its You its You
The lead singer was a bit vague at Woodstock '94 about what the song ("Moanjam")is about;
but watch those mosh pit audiences members, banging to a song that inevitably is about, and to Jesus.
Do they know their swaying is a form of amen-ing the praying?
( watch here).
The studio version is a classic song, from a classic album ("Faith Hope Love"),
and offers one of the shreddiest guitar solos ever
prayed/prayed(huh, Skib).....by one of the gentlest Christians around (Ty Tabor).
Most readers here will know some of the band (King's X) story more recently,
particularly Doug Pinnick's..
you know why they are no longer sold in (most) Christian stores..
but if that keeps me from worshipping along to the song,
I guess God doesn't ever use Sigur Ros ...
("Sigur Ros @ Church: is there a problem with that?")
...either.Ty Tabor: I always hated it because the negative connotation of what Christian band means. King's X has always tried to distance ourselves from that industry, from that ideal as far as we possibly could because, in most instances, we have always been deeply opposed to it. The fact that some people write us off for that reason alone and were not even that at all -- has been kind of a drag. On the other hand, how do you ever really know how much something has affected you? We always looked at what we do as art -- just trying to be honest as people, blemishes and all.
link
Isn't every Christian as "opposed to Christian industry" as Jesus was?
Maybe that's why God himself has been spotted at the Nine Inch Nails gig with Bono.
Tuesday, December 16, 2008
simulacra-kklesia (part 5/cinco): todo es duende y spiritual
Maybe because it's knowing the work was translated from Chinese into English and then into Spanish made the product either:
-a copy of a copy of a copy at least three generations removed from the original...thus having lost much in translation
or
-by some Spiritaneous serendipity saved from "lost in translation" or simulacra, and in a sense "even better than the real thing,"
I am not the scholar to judge, but intuitively, it feels like it reads the writer's heart.
So i picked up Pascal's Pensees in Spanish. At our gathering Sunday, it was there on the coffee table as the rabbi dude and I were talking. I opened the book to a random "pensee," (#648) and read:
"Dos errores: 1. Tomar todas cosas literalmente. 2.Tomar todas cosas spiritualmente."
Translation:
"Two errors: 1. To take everything literally. 2. To take everything spiritually."
Of course, this was originally written in French, so we face a similar third gen factor.
But I bet the translation worked. Spanish is closer to French than my ruddy English, anyway.
Tweaking the language a bit, but hopefully meaning the same thing:
Either we believe
it's all spiritual
or we believe
everything is spiritual.
The second is life; the first death.
"It's all spiritual" is the old/new docetic/gnostic heresy. Can't go there, matter matters.
"God likes matter, " C.S. Lewis said, "he made it."
"Everything is spiritual" is good theology (See the Rob Bell videos by this title here. It's good TV, if not quite Zoo TV)and duels dualism.
I would venture that music is the primary means of
overcoming simulacratic (and socratic) nature of our times and church.
Only then will we hear and feel the need to pray God yanks us out of our commercialism and complacency.
But not just any music.
Musical metaphor that is:
- lament (see Well-Ended Stories That Don't End Well)
- honest
- spiritual
as opposed the the normative and formative repertoire of church as usual:
- happy-clappy (hear Bono speak to this is a delightful and devastating audio quote here:
and then dare to pray Jesus' gut-wreneching prayer here: ""The Lord Be With You...Even When He’s Not") - untruthful (see CCM makes you lie)
- religious (Our only real enemy, the one who came to "steal, kill and destroy" in the context of John 10:10 is not the devil...he is nowhere mentioned in that section, no matter what we preachers have told you...but the religious person/false teacher.)
Back to the top:
Maybe the Spanish language/culture is the key anyway. A careful reading of this post on
might suggest that a Spanish mindset inherently "gets" that religion lies;
and that holy simulacra can lead us to the One who leads us into all truth.
The well known playful pun on the word 'papa':
--"pope" and/or "potato"--
may be telling that Sapir and Whorf were right.
One more helpful Spanish connection
At their worst, U2 comes off with bombastic pretension. At their best, they achieve what very few artists in any genre can: they create work with a sustained intensity that transforms the particular into the universal. U2 has that rare ability to communicate what the late Spanish writer, Frederico Garcia Lorca called 'duende'; that "mysterious power which everyone senses and no philosopher explains" (In Search of Duende, 1998, New Directions.)
"I have heard an old master guitarist say: 'Duende is not in the throat; duende surges up from the soles of the feet.' Which means it is not a matter of ability, but of real live form; of blood; of ancient culture; of creative action."Searching for the duende in the music of U2 may seem like the ultimate form of sycophancy or pretension, but as Miles Davis once so elegantly riffed, so what? No other band from the past two decades has so consistently given listeners reason to believe in the transcendental power of rock 'n' roll. U2 has the primacy of duende's "creative action" to thank for it.
..Lorca believed duende recreated familiar forms:"The duende's arrival always means a radical change in forms. It brings to old
Planes unknown feelings of freshness, with the quality of something newly created, like a miracle, and it produces an almost religious enthusiasm."
...Few other bands come close to these dizzy heights. "Sometimes" is pure duende.Lorca also stated "with duende it is easier to love and understand, and one can be sure of being loved and understood." U2 acknowledges that "tonight", as in other moments, weakness may overcome strength, but that's OK- everyone has those moments. It's in this realization that "Sometimes" crosses from the particular to the universal, cutting deep into the heart's core to pull out an emotional response that has nothing to do with Bono's father, but everything to do with our shared vulnerability as fragile living beings.Music of this caliber and class feels as primal as shelter and food. U2 is keeping duende alive in their sound. All we can do is listen. by David Kootnikoff ,
link
Twice the writer observed U2's movement from particular into universal, as characteristic of duende. You may remember that Wathrall noted this same progression (and its opposite) about the band and found it characteristic of post-simulacra elevation.
Maybe they're the same thing:
It's very tempting to understand U2's exemplary postmodern song (on which, in good postmodern fashion, I shall isolate and focus on here), "Even Better Than the Real Thing," as a celebration of the very postmodern condition Baudillard characterizes as the triumph of the simulacra.....but heard in this communal register, the erotic meaning of the lyric, "I'm gonna make you sing" has when...addressed to a particular lover becomes transformed, elevated into a celebration of communal singing as an ecstatic experience that transcends even the feeling of real love between individuals (This universalization of love-by which U2 seeks to transmute the entire audience into a belived--works, as Plato decribes in The Symposium by generalizing from the particular; it is thus striking that Bono sometimes performs the same gesture in reverse; by bringing a particular audience member on the stage to sing to her personally, as a particularization of the general audience he seeks to reach through her. With the very idea of an esctatic experience transcending personal love, we tread, I would suggest, into the territory of the holy.....Christianity itself was born out of such a fundamental attunement of universal love....without imposing borders. (91-93)
So more on that in parte siete of this series manana..
Oye, there may be uno, dos, tres, catorce parts to this after all.
*
*
*
*
Wednesday, December 03, 2008
drums and rapture...or at least Apocalypses in 9/8
Dream duet (or two bands you'd love to see join up)?When one thinks of drummers whose invocations could be rapture/Armaggddon-inducing, Karen Carpenter does not show up.
Gee, this just happened...U2 and Green Day...so now I'll wait for Kate Bush, Sinead O'Connor, Bob Dylan and Keith Green to sing alongside the Violet Burning/77s/U2 while Neil Peart ,Chester Thompson, and Keith Moon drum...gee, that drumming might cause the rapture.
link
Which is why some folk my age are still upset about Karen Carpenter (seriously!) winning the Rolling Stone "Drummer of the Year" award over Led Zeppelin's John Bonham..
Even though that was clearly a sin;
it may not have been the unpardonable sin....
so it probably deserves a pardon..
They're both dead..get over it.
Besides, she just recently made Rolling Stone's list of Top 100 Singers of All Time..
Guess it is the end times (:
Anybody (well, not me) can play a flashy solo, or fill a fill;
but I love the smart ones who can do that
but also/instead
can understate,
can be creatively "on a roll,"
can march to the beat of a different timer.
Neil Peart is an artist and genius, but you knew that.
Brand X , a band you've never heard of, cut some great jazz in the 70s, and their unknown dude on the drums (Phil Collins) sounded freer than ever.
Zappa picked gifted drummers: Coliuta, Bozzio et al
Here are some of my favorite drummers and kairotic drumming moments; how about yours?
I'll start with the sublimely subtle:
Jason Lord Maize played at our church w/The Violet Burning,
proof:

Here he is on "Gorgeous":
Speaking of timing (and Genesis ); now the subtly sublime and insanely sane time signature:
The "Apocalypse in 9/8" section of Genesis's 24 minute exorcism epic/commentary on Revelation, "Suppers Ready"...whether with Bill Bruford (as below) or the classic St Chester..
After the amazing drum section, dare you to NOT worship along to the lyrics and passion of Phil with the
"There's an angel standing in the sun/
And he's crying with a loud voice, This is the Supper of the Mighty One/
....the Lord of Lords, King of Kings has returned to lead His children home/
To take them to the new Jerusallllllllleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeem"
(excuse me, that part raptures me every time) section at 6:39ff...
From Wikipedia:
The song has been highly regarded by fans for its epic nature and cathartic climax, with Gabriel in particular delivering an emotionally charged vocal performance at the close of the song. Referring in part to the song's lyrical depiction of a struggle between good and evil, Gabriel has been quoted as saying he felt he was "literally singing for his life" in the recording studio. In contrast, Hackett is said to have responded to a fan who enthused "Steve, I actually saw God at the end!" with the rather more down-to-earth "Well, I was just trying to get the notes right"Ok, the clip:
link
( audio here)
I cannot NOT mention Larry Mullen, Jr. of U2..especially his unappreciated moments on an unheard "worship album": "October." On a song that U2 haven't played for nearly 25 years "With a Shout (Jerusalem)," Larry played some drums I have never gotten tired of for 25 years.
And I was thrilled that someone (Ian Kelly) shares my awe for another amazing Mullen moment:
I have many favorite Larry moments but I would have to go with his thunderous drums on the Rattle And Hum film version of "With Or Without You". The drums in that performance are absolutely amazing, and help to make that my favorite version of "WOWY". He really seems to be in his own world during that performance, which I believe was one of the first times they ever played that song live.
And at the climactic point just before Bono explodes with the added verse of "Yeah, we'll shine like stars in the summer night...," Larry, sitting with his headphones on, seems to slip away into his own private universe, playing as fast as humanly possible and showing his true emotion and love for the song. I love the way the spotlights come down on him too like he was alone up there on his drum riser. The energy is indescribable!-- Ian Kelly, atu2.com
I love 2:49, when we first realize, "Wow, he's really into it today; something's about to happen(In U2 lexicon, God is about to walk through the room) ; then if you watch from
3:35, you are primed for the section Kelly mentions (4:19-4:43). I can't live with or without that section; that half minute may well have restored my soul and saved my life. It's my pastor "after church" song; Mullen himself says "that song never made sense on the radio; maybe in church":
Manu Katche, playing for Peter Gabriel, 4:21ff:
That does cause a dad's heart to experience rapture..
or at least get teary eyed and apocalyptic.
We apparently have the word “apocalypse“ all wrong. In its root meaning, it’s not about destruction or fortune telling; It’s about revealing; It’s what James Joyce calls an epiphany...The real world, within which you’ve lived and moved and had your being, has unveiled itself. It’s starting to come to you. .. Is it any surprise that we often won’t know it when we see it?
-David Dark, “Everyday Apocalypse: The Sacred Revealed in Radiohead, The Simpsons and Other Pop Culture Icons”, p.10
Thursday, November 06, 2008
drum
Dream duet (or two bands you'd love to see join up)?Because when one thinks of drummers whose invocations could be rapture/Armaggddon-inducing, Karen Carpenter does not show up.
Gee, this just happened...U2 and Green Day...so now I'll wait for Kate Bush, Sinead O'Connor, Bob Dylan and Keith Green to sing alongside the Violet Burning/77s/U2 while Neil Peart ,Chester Thompson, and Keith Moon drum...gee, that might cause the rapture.
link
Which is why some folk my age are still upset about Karen Carpenter (seriously!) winning the Rolling Stone "Drummer of the Year" award over Led Zeppelin's John Bonham..
Even though that was clearly a sin;
it may not have been the unpardonable sin....
so it probably deserves a pardon..
They're both dead..get over it.
Anybody (well, not me) can play a flashy solo, or fill a fill;
but I love the smart ones who can do that
but also/instead
can understate,
can be creatively "on a roll,"
can march to the beat of a different timer.
Neil Peart is an artist and genius, but you knew that.
Brand X , a band you've never heard of, cut some great jazz in the 70s, and their unknown dude on the drums (Phil Collins) sounded freer than ever.
Here are some of my favorite drummers and kairotic drumming moments; how about yours?
I'll start with the sublimely subtle:
Jason Lord Maize played at our church w/The Violet Burning,
proof:

Here he is on "Gorgeous":
Speaking of timing (and Genesis ); now the subtly sublime and insanely sane time signature:
The "Apocalypse in 9/8" section of Genesis's 24 minute exorcism epic/commentary on Revelation, "Suppers Ready"...whether with Bill Bruford (as below) or the classic St Chester..
After the amazing drum section, dare you to NOT worship along to the lyrics and passion of Phil with the
"There's an angel standing in the sun/
And he's crying with a loud voice, This is the Supper of the Mighty One/
....the Lord of Lords, King of Kings has returned to lead His children home/
To take them to the new Jerusallllllllleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeem"
(excuse me, that part raptures me every time) section at 6:39ff
From Wikipedia
The song has been highly regarded by fans for its epic nature and cathartic climax, with Gabriel in particular delivering an emotionally charged vocal performance at the close of the song. Referring in part to the song's lyrical depiction of a struggle between good and evil, Gabriel has been quoted as saying he felt he was "literally singing for his life" in the recording studio. In contrast, Hackett is said to have responded to a fan who enthused "Steve, I actually saw God at the end!" with the rather more down-to-earth "Well, I was just trying to get the notes right"Ok, the clip:
link
( audio here)
I cannot NOT mention Larry Mullen, Jr. of U2..especially his unappreciated moments on an unheard "worship album": "October." On a song that U2 haven't played for nearly 25 years "With a Shout (Jerusalem)," Larry played some drums I have never gotten tired of for 25 years.
And I was thrilled that someone (Ian Kelly) shares my awe for another amazing Mullen moment:
I have many favorite Larry moments but I would have to go with his thunderous drums on the Rattle And Hum film version of "With Or Without You". The drums in that performance are absolutely amazing, and help to make that my favorite version of "WOWY". He really seems to be in his own world during that performance, which I believe was one of the first times they ever played that song live.
And at the climactic point just before Bono explodes with the added verse of "Yeah, we'll shine like stars in the summer night...," Larry, sitting with his headphones on, seems to slip away into his own private universe, playing as fast as humanly possible and showing his true emotion and love for the song. I love the way the spotlights come down on him too like he was alone up there on his drum riser. The energy is indescribable!-- Ian Kelly, atu2.com
I love 2:49, when we first realize, "Wow, he's really into it today; something's about to happen(In U2 lexicon, God is about to walk through the room) ; then if you watch from
3:35, you are primed for the section Kelly mentions (4:19-4:43). I can't live with or without that section; that half minute may well have restored my soul and saved my life. It's my pastor "after church" song; Mullen himself says "that song never made sense on the radio; maybe in church":
Manu Katche, playing for Peter Gabriel, 4:21ff:
Keith (no last name needed) from 7:25:
Here's a classic '78 clip of two of the best drummers ever (Thank God one of them is still alive, I just wish he would tour, he's an animal!):
Bottom line, my favorite drummer on the planet lives with me, so get to hear him practice (Thank God he didn't take up violin! ). He wears my jeans and my genes. He's brand new at drumming; and you can find an assortment of his early jams here...Here's a clip made before he had a single lesson, just experimenting:
That does cause a dad's heart to experience rapture..
Wednesday, October 01, 2008
Honest Liars and King's X
Everything you want is not anything it is
Liar
God Vendor..
Makes me sick, makes me wanna vomit
I'm fillin' my heart with rocks and sand
I am the slogan, "Christ for sale"
-Mike Knott, "Liar"
Could it be that as soon as we say "I'm telling the truth," we're lying?
Rings true.
If we claim "I'm lying," we may be telling the whole truth.
That may be a lie.
The sentence below is false.
The sentence above is true.
Honestly, this is nothing new,
if you recall the classic self-referential Epiminedes Paradox:
Epimenides was a Cretan who made one immortal statement:
"All Cretans are liars."
The self-referential paradox arises when one considers whether
Epimenides spoke the truth. link
This whole paradoxical deal is even (inevitably) referenced in the Bible:
"One of Crete's own prophets has said it: 'Cretans are always liars.'
He has surely told the truth."–Titus 1:12
The sentence below is false.
The sentence above is true.
Can we Christians ever tell the truth?
Especially by claiming we love unconditionally?
I fear we all have unconditional conditions.
.............Which may make us honest liars (And we all know where liars go).
Can we followers of Truth incarnate ever tell the truth?
Especially when "one of us" says he's gay?
Paul didn't seem to fear being struck dead (so help him, God) by involing a triple oath of honesty:
"I am telling the truth;
I am not lying;
My conscience confirms it in the Holy Spirit" (Romans 9:1)
When one considers the context of that promise (he would be damned so others could be saved);
it's all the more amazing.
I wish I could say it were true of us/me saying that we still unconditionally love "one of our own"
who now claims to be gay..
..and suggests he smokes pot..
...Oh, he also drops the F-bomb frequently.
Honestly, aren't those three sure signs of losing ones salvation? (:
The first one cut him off in many folk's eyes...even though a careful reading of the interviews imply that he admits and orientation, and has not had an acual homesexual relatiinship.
As if that would make a difference, anyway.
I may be a Cretan.
Honestly.
Doug Pinnick started out with impeccable evangelical credentials: living in Christian community; founding member of Servant, bandmate of Phil Keaggy..
..but long story short (more here), the brilliant Pinnick--who along with his bandmates in King's X have created some of the most amazing, prayerful, HONEST music ever---has definitely distanced himself from Christians....and Christianity.
" they (Christians) rejected us anyway after they learned who we were.
They're human, they hide it.
We're not like that, we're too honest.
That's why I am down on Christian music.
In the name of truth they live lies.
That's never been me."-2006
"Me and God got no f---in' problem... My problem is all these people that put His name on their work."
1998
But now Doug Pinnick (via a King's X song, "Prayer", are asing for prayer..
..or is he?
Read the whole lyric in context (there is defintely a punchline, and an eventual qualifier on those invited to pray for him)..and especially in context of all he's been through...and you can decide:
- more King's X lyrics
Pray Lyrics
And if you think that what you think is truefull lyrics
If you found peace deep inside of you
If your faith made a mountain move for you then,
Don't forget to pray for me,
Hear me now
If you think that Jesus has saved you
Mother Mary is waiting there for you
If you think that God has spoke to you then
Don't forget to pray for me,
more lyrics
I honestly hope I am teling the truth..
..that we can learn to love him (and anyone) unconditionally.
Don't hear what I'm not saying:
I think it's OK to be gay, smoke pot, and swear.
yada, yada.
"I'm not straight...not gay either"
That that is precisely NOT the point IS the point.
--
Enjoy some classic King's X:
"Over My Head"
("Grandma she was praying/I hear music..over my head):
(They still do this song)
and this one:
"It's You...I sing this song for You/You're the glory".
(seen is this later-career clip with the "legalize marijuana" sticker on Pinnick's bass):
See also these related posts by a true Cretan:
Monday, January 21, 2008
Not Alright
and of course"The Lord Be With You...Even When He’s Not");and as any
church who weaves a bit of Pink Floyd into the "worship set" knows..
it is refreshing and encouraging to sometimes spin and pray tunes that are not...well, refreshing or encouraging,
But are honest about what Ethel called our inevitable "occasional atheism,"
and what the Psalmist called life.
Contemporary Christian music seems to be convinced that everything's always alright.
Well, I know Romans 8:28 as well as the next preacher, but a larger section of Scripture (Psalms, Escclesiastes etc) is downright honest..
..and flirts with the feeling..if not the reality...that at least until the Kingdom fully comes, everything is not yet altogether alright.
Richard Foster used to tweak the title "I'M ON, YOU'RE OK" to "I'M NOT OK, YOU'RE NOT OK..BUT THAT'S OK!"
Two songs with the shocking but healing lyric "I'm not alright" come to mind. Can we sing them 'in church'?
They might prove themselves redemptive and refreshing.
THE BURNING DOWN
by King's X
Where are you tonight
I don't seem to know you
No I'm not all right
Where are you tonight
And my heart is nearly gone
There's not much left to offer
If I could somehow know
I could stop the burning down
Where are you tonight
Are you even really out there
I won't put up a fight
Where are you tonight
And the world keeps spinning round
A vicious cycle turning (vicious cycle turning)
Some of them know love
Some of us know the burning down
"I'M NOT ALRIGHT"
BY SANCTUS REAL
If weakness is a wound
That no one wants to speak of
Then “cool” is just how far we have to fall
I am not immune
I only want to be loved
But I feel safe behind the firewall
Can I lose my need to impress?
If you want the truth, I need to confess
I’m not alright
I’m broken inside, broken inside
And all I go through
It leads me to you, it leads me to you
Burn away the pride
Bring me to my weakness
Until everything I hide behind is gone
And when I’m open wide
With nothing left to cling to
Only you are there to lead me on
Cause honestly, I’m not that strong
I’m not alright
I’m broken inside, broken inside
And all I go through
It leads me to you, it leads me to you
And I move, and I move, and I move...closer to you
And I move, and I move, and I move...closer to you
And I move, and I move, and I move...closer to you
And I move, and I move, and I move...
I’m not alright
I’m broken inside, broken inside
broken inside, broken inside
And all I go through
Leads me to you, leads me to you
I’m not alright, I’m not alright, I’m not alright...that’s why I need you
VIDEO
Friday, March 03, 2006
Sigur Ros @ Church: is there a problem with that?
It was our Thursday night cell group at a member's home...all present that night seasoned Christians; and experienced yet balanced in the prophetic gifts...so I sensed the time was right to have them listen prayerfully to what to me was a profound song of worship; and reporting afterwards on what the Lord may have been showing or saying through the song.
Now this group is mature enough to know not only that all impressions are not of God, but that:
a)God can definitely use what might be seen as simplistic "easy-rhyme" worship songs..so we don't want to judge the validity or anointing of those types of songs even if we do not prefer them.
b)He is likely to speak through more complex, obtuse, creative or "out of the box" songs..especially for those who prefer that wavelength
Since this song was definite "B," and not a "CCM" staple, I assumed it would match their wavelength and yield a fruitful prayer time. I intentionally didn't tell them much about the song, other than to warn them the lyric wasn't in English ; this group was from another country (so the lyric was in their native language, and also perhaps partly in tongues/glossalalia and just spontaneous sounds/words that flooded out of the singer's soul). So I suggested that through the mood of the music and the "non-verbal" cues of the lyrics and tone, the gathered might sense a certain theme, or general impressions, regarding the worship song.
I also dropped that this band's music was starting to be used in many worship/church settings (often as background music or as soundtrack to prayer/ministry time) with great blessing and benefit.
Once the saints settled in, I spun (OK, that choice of terms betrays my age..I remember records!) the song.
Hey, I would recommend not reading anmore yet, but right now watching or listening to the song. Here it is:
Music Video Codes By MusicJesus.com
I had looked up a suggested translation of the lyrics; they felt like a prayer around mystical union with God, yet the pray-er was having a hard time waiting on His presence; yet persevered and found peace. But I tried pray a tabula rasa expectationless expectation into me as well.
It was a powerful experience for most; for some it was very visual. Whole scenes and scenarios opened up to them about, well, " prayer around mystical union with God, yet the pray-er was having a hard time waiting on His presence. " Some testified to significant healing and restoration. There were teardrops on some journals and Bibles.
We eventually moved on to a brief Bible Study, but it was clear top all that the song had been the God-centering highlight of the evening. I smiled as the gang left: "Next week I'll tell you the secret about that song."
I play dirty pool. I am a sneaky pastor. But I wanted to make a point. The point this article is leading up to.
The next week, folks were still celebrating the embrace of God they had experienced through my "worship song."
I put on a Paul Harvey smile and spilled a few beans.
"Oh, I never said that the artist was Christian."
!
They flinched for a moment, but got over it.
Just in time for me to drop the other bomb.
"Oh, by the way, the lead singer is gay. "
!!
"Does anyone have a problem with that?"
Beans spilled, and jaws dropped.
But because these were no "fighting fundies," they didn't kill me.
I explained that the group was Sigur Ros, a creative band with an ethereal sound that indeed (some) churches were beginning to use. The lyrics were in Icelandic, Hoplandis (an improvised phonetic langauge) and sometimes glossalaia, Jonmsi, who yes is gay.
Okay, for those who need to hear it, let me be clear.
Here what I'm not saying:
1)I endorse everything about Sigur Ros.
2) I believe an active Christian should be actively gay .
3)We should use only non-Christian music in worship.
yada yada yada
These three points may be important for context; but in asking whether God can use the band, they are precisely not the point. We evangelicals can be too obsexxed to hear the voiceprints of God at Mars Hill. I love what Episcopal priest Beth Maynard said in a talk about U2 and Christianity: such conerns about God using a band that may or may not measure up to "standards" for Christian faith are somewhat "tacky and voyueristic."
Gee, who wants to be either of those?
And Bruce Cockburn ( a professing Chrsitian if it makes you feel better..but one who is brutally honmest) 's classic "Maybe the Poet" comes to mind and turntable here:
Maybe the poet is gay...Let him l be heard anyway
Maybe the poet is drugged
But he won't stay under the rug
Maybe the voice of the Spirit
In which case you'd better hear it
Maybe he's a woman
Who can touch you where you're human
Good grief, evangelicals! Can God ever speak through a gay person (Guess we won't clue them in to Henri Nouwen, or this founder of the Jesus movement...or Billy Graham (okay, just kidding...about the last person!) And a how about God actually using a woman...even the emerging church is still lagging behind here (and I can't wait to see what happens when some bloogers find out the secret of the "emergent woman" they have quoting and linking to; like one of them.....)
Jonsi is blind in one eye, too. Is that okay?
It may or may not be okay to ordain him in your tradition. or even have him be a full member of your church...but that's not the question at hand.
It may be that Len Sweet has not overstated the case: "It may be for the first time in history, God is more active in the world than the church."
I would recommend this survey of various articles about Sigur Ros, either from a Christian perspective, or valubale in the conversation (here ). After all, this is the band about which Melody Maker said, "They sound like God weeping tears of gold in heaven."
I have heard no moe prophetic and accurate assesement of said sound.
Then there's this hilarious piece below by Geffery Wilson :
1. If you can imagine the mix-tape Jesus makes every Christmas for Buddha, you
might approximate half the overall impact of Ágætis Byrjun.2. Lead singer, Jonsi sounds as though he's (having himelf) reorganized by seraphim wielding
sold platinum vise-grips.3. This album shimmers--Stars are going to have to find another word for whatever it is that they do.
4. If the Mormon Tabernacle Choir teamed up with Handel to record the collected liturgical music of the Hare Krishnas, the result could not be so transcendent as Ágætis Byrjun.
5. . . .like God using Radiohead as hand-puppets.
6. How perversely ironic that only Icelanders have found a way to pack a winters' worth of radiant warmth onto five inches of plastic.
7. The lyrics, written in a combination of Icelandic and an imaginary language called "Hopelandic," sound startlingly like retarded Cherubs placing an order in a Korean restaurant. 8. . . . like freebasing Mercury Rev through a unicorn horn.
9. Ágætis Byrjun on the car stereo turns rolling through the Burger King drive-thru into a cinematic slo-mo transaction with sublime
eternities.10. A big bunch of (wimps) making such exquisite sounds, you barely want to (kick 'em around)
An intrerview with a band member:
GEORG: Yes, we like different venues, more like theaters or churches, mainly
because these places have a certain atmosphere: You walk into the room and
there's a certain atmosphere already there. But you walk into a normal rock 'n'
roll venue, and there's no atmosphere except rock 'n' roll. And I don't think
our music is purely rock 'n' roll--it's some sort of rock, maybe, but it's the
atmosphere that really matters.LAUNCH: I've heard that you get some pretty emotional reactions from audiences everywhere.
GEORG: Yeah, there's a lot of fainting going on at our concerts, and I don't know why. Often you see people crying, and that's good, that's what our music is about: emotion. It's music for your whole body, not for dancing--it's for your whole head.
So is the music listed on "Essential music for theologians," (of course, Sigur Ros makes the cut)but how many artists would claim to be biblical Christians? Musician and Christian Todd Evans, in a candid HM magazine interview is frustrated with the "Christian affiliation keep me from my calling", and asks aloud this about Sigur Ros:
Why are there so many bands not affiliated with Christianity that touch
something in the heavens that many believers do not? I experienced the best
worship at a Sigur Ros concert.. Absolutely amazing. They went to a place
and took us there. How can they do that? Many refuse to let an industry, or money
dictate to their mind how to express themselves. Many are broken and
reaching out for answers...and finding new places creatively in their broken
state...parts of the walls in their soul are down. WE NEED TO BE BROKEN. WE
NEED TO LIVE BROKEN.
.
If you are still reading, you will be open enough (or bored enough) to actually see or hear the particular song ("Svefn-G-Englarsong") we played at cell group. I'll give some links, but remember..it may or may not work for you; sometimes it's just a style thing...I am a sucker for "ethereal music"...but it's deeper than style. I was disappointed not to find the Iceland Opera House live video of the song, but here'sa Google "Sigur Ros"video list herehttp://video.google.com/videosearch?q=sigur+ros
official site several audio videos here
Svefn-G-Englarsong we did at cell grouip here : One set of sugested lyeics is here
Vido version online live at Iceaklnd Opear house. goodle it down
Thismay work...
Stve Collins of Small Ritual (stole teh photo of Sigur Ros at top) exgellent obsdrevations reuring Sigy Ros cobert
.a la Bono:
Quote:
"God is interested in truth, and only in truth. And that's why God is more interested in Rock & Roll music than Gospel... Many gospel musicians can't write about what's going on in their life, beacuse it's not allowed ..If you can't write about what's really going on in the world and your life, because it's all happy-clappy... Is God interested in that? I mean, 'Please, don't patronize Me! I want to go the Nine-Inch-Nails gig, they're talking the truth!"
-Bono (audio clip of this quote in context is here)
This was a very important discussion,. We often miss the voice of God if we limit it to just "Christian" songs, or just a certain style. The contributers were from a variety of ages and styles, yet no judgement..and what wonderful eclectic lists.
amazibng list herehttp://3dff.com/php/viewtopic.php?t=2146
Genesis:
"Supper's Ready" "Afterglow"
Peter Gabriel:
"Red Rain"
"Secret World"
"Solsbury Hill"
"Indigo"
all U2:
"Elvis Presley and America" "Walk On" "40" "Bad" "Where the Streets Have No Name" "Wake Up Dead Man" "When I Look at the World" "hawkmoon" "Unchained Melody" (yes, they covered the old classic) "scarlet" "gloria"....NO END IS SIGHT WITH U2 SONGS//I JUST HAVE TO STOP!!
Traffic: "Dear Mr. Fantasy"
Pink Floyd: "The Final Cut" "Comfortably Numb" "Time" "Great Gig in the Sky" "Wish You Were Here" "Run Like Hell"
Alice Cooper: "Generation Landslide" "Cleansed by Fire"
Charlie Peacock: "Monkeys at the Zoo"
DC Talk: "Satellite/hardway"
The Choir: live version "Restore My Soul"
The 77s:
"The Lust, the Flesh, The Eyes and the Pride of Life" "The Jig is Up" "denomination blues" "Pray naked"
Steve Hackett:
"Spectral Mornings"
Violet Burning: (i can't pick here!)
"Song of the Harlot" •••••••••••••• "Invitacion Fountain" "Elaste" "Low" "Eleven" "Blood of Jeus" "ilaria" "nobody Else"
The Frames:
"Fitzcarraldo" "The Blood of Jesus Never Failed Me Yet" "Santa Maria"
Sigur Ros:
"Vidrar"
Delirious: Spontaneous songs from 1996 live; "Great is the Lord"
Brownsville: "Happy Song" "Lover of My Soul"
David Ruis: "Find Rest" "Can it Be"
White Heart: "heaven of my heart'
creedence clearwater: Green River (??????), Pagan Baby (!!!!!!????)
Brian Doerksen: "Prodigal Son Suite" "More"
Raspberry Jam: "Surrender "
Robin Mark; "Days of Elijah"
Steve Taylor/Chagall Geuvara: "violent blue" "hero" "finish line" "on the fritz"
Rush: "hemispheres" "new world man"
yes: "starship trooper"
mike rutherford: "smallcreep's day"
" Audioslave: "Show Me How to Live"
Keith Green: "Asleep in the Light" (the first "Christian" song I ever really heard. it midwived me)
Michael W. Smith: "Agnus Dei"
Radiohead: "fake plastic trees'
bruce cockburn: "maybe the poet," "rocket launcher"
johnny cash: "hurt" "san quentin" (and with u2:"the wanderer"
spiritualized and jeff buckley will likely make my list once i grow into them
billy joel: "captain jack"
elton john: "ticking"
iona: "dancing on the wall"
sting" if i ever lose my faith in You"
the call/michael been: "i still believe," "i don't wanna", "To feel this way"
mark heard or the call: "we know too much"
joan osborne "what if God was (one of us)"
Sixpence: "love salvation and fear of death', "love"
passion worhsip: sweep me away, wonderful king, knowing you, you are my king"
bob dylan: "ring them belsl" "most of the time"
charlie peacock: "lie down in the grass" "monkeys at the zoo"
mike knott/cush: "i am no christ" "the bomb was brighter than the stars"
the cure: "pictures of you" "trust"
king's x:"moonjam'
the who: "won't get fooled again
the clash
zappa:"watermelon in easter hay"
paul mccartney: "maybe i'm amazed"
eagles: "last resort"
sinnead o'connor: "thank you for hearing me" sinnead with u2: "thief of your heart" sinnead with the edge:"heroine"
nilsson "without you"
neil young: "cortez the killer" "old man"
beatles: "day in the life" "golden slumbers/carry that weight/the end"
the prayer chain: "healer" "sky high"
dave matthews: "pantala naga pampa" (totally thanks to jason for sneaking in as a call to worship..awesome) "cry freedom" "don't drink the water"
simple minds: "new gold dream" "soul crying out" "waterfront"